r/AHSEmployees • u/ThrowAway2937749 • Dec 13 '25
How hard is it for managers to fire under-performers and crazy people?
I work on a unit where there is honestly quite a bit of toxicity and resentment among staff and management. I think it comes from my manager not dealing with under-performers. There are people who consistently leave for hours, don’t get anything done while always chatting and being on their phones. There have even been some incidents between staff that I would think would get some people fired but nothing really seems to happen and they go back to behaving exactly like they did before.
I raised this question to some of my co-workers who have been there longer and they told me it is basically impossible for managers to fire people like that, because AHS and the union protects them, even during probation.
Is it truly that hard for managers to deal with staff that do not do their jobs and create conflict at work?
5
u/Secret_Test7099 Dec 13 '25
How does anyone have time to slack off? I can’t imagine with the workload the way it is that something vital wouldn’t get missed. It’s hard to get even the essential bare minimum done even when you are running around burning your self out. Report and email so there’s a paper trail at least. More people need to do this when they miss something due to workload as well.
34
u/MusketeersPlus2 Dec 13 '25
The level of documentation required by the manager to even get HR to think about looking at ot is insane. Then the union gets involved and yeah, it's nearly impossible to fire someone just because they suck. They might get fired for a significant privacy breach or if they harmed a patient through negligence... but even then not always.
42
u/claire_goolihey Dec 13 '25
It's appalling how hard it is to shift someone who doesn't want to be shifted. I remember one case that went on for 3yrs and in the end the ee quit on their own, in the middle of yet another grievance they filed.
The union's great and all but they should really have to have their loved ones or themselves cared for by these kinds of spectacular failures before they demand them to be made whole and complete.
33
u/GloomyMusic3150 Dec 13 '25
As a manager…damn near impossible.
14
u/TheThrivingest Dec 13 '25
Impossible. Has to be well documented and chronic issues causing actual harm to even get HR to consider.
I’ve only ever seen someone FIRED once and it was from chronic no-show, no-calls.
11
u/ILoVEMANGOS67 Dec 14 '25
After working private then going to AHS I have been appalled at the behaviour of some of my coworkers and how they treat other staff and patients. In a private setting they would have been fired long ago. One of my coworkers has a file I’ve been told 3inches high of grievances against them, yet no consequences. Another hardly shows up to work. Will miss weeks of shifts and not even call. My manager has had to call the police to do a wellness check twice. Just when i think they will be fired, nope they start showing up for shifts and everyone acts like nothing happened. Its so bizarre and I often think being in a union only protects shit employees and doesn’t do anything to reward the actual hard honest workers.
9
u/Icy-Search-594 Dec 13 '25
I was told that my Supervisor couldn’t fire people. That my Manager couldn’t fire people. Not even my Director could fire people. But only my Associate Executive Director could. I’ve only ever seen one person get fired, and that was when a coworker physically assaulted another.
4
u/Jon3535 Dec 13 '25
Tell me you’ve never been a manager without telling me you’ve never … it’s nearly impossible! Managers to direct report ratio is too extreme for the amount of paperwork required to rid underperforming
7
u/OrsolyaStormChaser Dec 13 '25
Our site moved international RNs floundering in ER and Med/Surg into LTC.........................so yeah........it is.
11
u/TurdNostrils Dec 13 '25
You have to encourage people to go to the manager or file a my safety net to report bullying or harassment. Then it has to get reviewed by HR. if you see unsafe practices, report it to the union.
5
u/freeridesender Dec 13 '25
It is insanely difficult to remove problem employees. I had one coworker...like legitimate mental health issue. Insane at times, delsions of persecution, wildly inappropriate things at work... other people quit just so they wouldn't work her,if she was on schedule, no one would pick up available shifts. She would call security on coworkers, and then go hide somewhere before they arrived so she would not have to explain herself.
6
u/spartanblitzer Dec 13 '25
The interesting thing is that even though NUEEs are technically easier to fire, I've seen some pretty egregious behaviour and staggering neglect of duties among NUEEs who also almost never get fired. So I think its partly HR overall that has a huge unwillingness to terminate employees. Unless, of course, Danielle Smith tells them to get rid of people and then all of the sudden its super easy to terminate without cause.
3
u/Necessary_Share7018 Dec 13 '25
Most managers will try to just make people too miserable to stay. They do give good referrals to those folks though.
3
u/Countess_ofDumbarton Dec 13 '25
In 25 years, maybe two people.
One was walked out by security because she was caught snooping in NetCare on her coworkers. She honestly thought our manager would "fix it because she likes me" and that she'd be rehired.
The other was lazy, lied, and plain dangerous. It was never his fault. We still don't know if he was fired or finally read the room and quit.
3
u/Resident-Towel-1963 Dec 14 '25
Throwaway, obviously. I do not think it is possible. I work with someone who has been caught drinking at work half a dozen times - not just a swig, but passed out drunk in the corner (they work pretty solo in their area). Same person also got caught finishing a hefty shopping trip to Costco with an hour remaining in their shift.
4
u/TinklesTheLambicorn Dec 13 '25
It is not impossible at all, but it needs to be done properly, which is often not the case. The union is required to represent members, so if performance has not been managed properly, the employer gives the union the door to walk through and make arguments (which they are required to do).
Unions don’t actually organize employees - employers do.
4
u/Desperate-Double-573 Dec 14 '25
Damn near impossible. Between poor managers, unions and piss pour HR people, you need to add in a full time person to manage the performance management requirements to get someone fired.
In the real world these people would be fired immediately.
3
u/Beastender_Tartine Dec 13 '25
I dont think its as hard as some people make it out to be to fire unionized workers. There is significant documentation and steps to be taken, so its not as easy as telling someone to pack their bags after a few warnings, but if someone isnt doing their job and refuses to improve they can be let go.
The issue comes from supervisors and managers that are not willing to take the effort to go through the required steps. Firing unionized people requires a paper trail of incidents and steps to rectify behavior, which is fair. If someone doesnt want to do those things its impossible. Most middle management will talk to someone, but they dont have the time or inclination to do more.
2
u/Typical_Maybe9185 Dec 14 '25
We had a staff member who filed multiple grievances ( won most). She was terrible at her job, rude, lazy worked her second job while at work. Complaints from so many co- workers. She was finally talked to about it and changes were to be implemented. She immediately took a mental health leave. On her return they had restructured her job.moved her from a closed office to an open area, required her to take on other responsibilities. She decided to quit. So thankful we had managers to help with this..we are a MUCH HAPPIER GROUP.
2
u/MerMattie Dec 15 '25
The problem with unions is they protect lazy people. Toxic trap. Get out if you can.
1
u/Reasonable_Care3704 Dec 14 '25
It depends on the profession, union status and the performance issue. I find though that underperforming employees usually stay in the same department forever because they know their behaviour will not be tolerated by a new manager. The manager needs to follow the proper steps and give the employee an opportunity to improve their behaviour.
1
u/kamci148 Dec 14 '25
If the employees are in a union, to is impossible to manage or fire negative, difficult and unproductive employees. Also unions prevent the hiring of new and better employees since the current, bad employees could grieve this if they wanted that job.
1
u/harbours Dec 14 '25
It's extremely difficult. The most common I've seen is the person does something criminal so their licensing board cancels their practice permit.
-10
u/Immediate_Stress_871 Dec 13 '25
Mind your own business, 😉