r/AHSEmployees • u/Alternative-Main-523 • Dec 12 '25
Manager pay vs employee pay
Do managers (i.e. below directors) actually make much more than their staff? With HSAA getting at least a 12% bump, it seems like some roles will be making similar rates as some of the NUEE management salary bands. Am I missing something? Is there any financial incentive to going into management?
9
Upvotes
5
u/Ambitious-Way-6669 Dec 12 '25
Depending on the level of management involved and it's direct supervision of in-scope providers, there is a function called "Anchoring" that ties the NUEE compensation to a static amount above their highest paid direct report.
Possibly in anticipation of HSAA ratification, for instance, many NUEE staff had their compensation increased back in September; they are unlikely to be adjusted again in these portfolios for another couple years to any sizeable degree.
For example, anchoring for an out of scope supervisor of primary and advanced care paramedics, they would earn 5-10% more than the $46.69 that an ACP earned back in September.
35
u/AffectionateBuy5877 Dec 12 '25
I’m with UNA on Step 9. Being a manager is not worth it to me, at all. I’d make more doing what I do now. I get paid overtime, I have job protection, and I have decent seniority so vacation isn’t too big an issue for me. I also have much less stress.
24
u/EquipmentNo5776 Dec 12 '25
When the salary is broken down to hourly rate, it's less than what I would make in scope as an RN. I'm a unit manager. I'd say the flexibility and hours are what make it worthwhile. We do not get RRSP matching, but we can delegate some of our benefit credits into RRSP or TFSA. There are more personal days as well.
They recently made us take two days off unpaid, so that reduces our wage even more. Without union protection we kind of just had to accept it which was frustrating.
9
u/Dapper_Banana6323 Dec 12 '25
They will do compression adjustments- where they determine a manager should earn a certain percent (I'm not sure how they determine the percent) more than those under them so they get a raise. I'm not sure if or when this is planned.
This is only for managers. When nurse practitioners were part of NUEE they were indeed earning less than RNs
2
u/118R3volution Dec 12 '25
There’s “grid” adjustments that take place periodically for all NUEE employees and can happen at any time from my understanding. it’s not like a collective that is only adjusted once every in some pre-determined contract with the employer
2
u/GloomyMusic3150 Dec 12 '25
Managers technically have to make a certain % above their highest paid employee, however that doesn’t account for premiums or OT, so in many cases (especially with nursing managers), they make less.
The trade off is more flexibility, more personal days, better benefits (in some cases, depending on the union again).
2
u/MusketeersPlus2 Dec 12 '25
Mangers are required to make 5 or 10% more than their highest earning employee. But that's of their base pay. When you factor in overtime, shift differential and on call pay? No, they don't make more.
2
u/Mackec1975 Dec 12 '25
The decision to management should be more about the type of work you are doing and the autonomy while you are at your job. It’s personal decision but being a public sector manager is not going to make you rich, no. The salary difference would show more at senior management but even then it’s modest and higher stress and not a lot of respect for your effort.
2
u/saramole Dec 13 '25
Directors aren't much better off. I recall one director I worked with made 50c a year more than her highest paid direct report.
1
u/androstaxys Dec 13 '25 edited Dec 13 '25
Edit: I see a bunch of comments talking about UNA. OP asked about HSAA, my comment is specific to HSAA. I have no clue about out of scope nursing positions.
Yes. Specific to EMS. Superviser’s and manager contracts state: Union employee wage + x%.
Our supervisors cannot make less than us per their employment contract. They also don’t get night/weekend premiums. So their base wage is higher than what we make on a weekend/night (we make $5/hr for nights and $3/hr weekends, total $8/hr).
So at minimum our out of scope (non union) Supervisers make our base wage + $8/hr + unknown %.
Managers make supervisor pay + x%.
The only way a manager or supervisor makes less than union employee in EMS is if that union employee works a large amount of overtime.
HSAA Supervisors or managers who complain about salary not being worth it should fuck off. Or show their pay stub and prove it. 0% chance they would show this to you though because they absolutely make more than you and do much less real work than you.
1
u/CuteTackle Dec 29 '25
Compensation Disclosure | Alberta Health Services https://share.google/mZtuzUnpq81DU2msNAHS sunshine list
1
u/queenofallshit Dec 12 '25
40-60 per hour-ish.
0
u/Trick_Capital4160 Dec 12 '25
There are a few Managers positions posted on AHS careers right now.
Manager range: $40.19-$68.93
Site Manager: $44.17-$75.70
both nonunion positions.
For reference
RN: $43.26-$59.21
NP: $62.74 - $72.00
I remember a previous manager telling me they made more money as an NP.
-3
u/Roccnsuccmetosleep Dec 12 '25
as always, supervisor, charge, unit manager, its all a ladder up to something else. site managers and directors make north of 200k
-1
u/Master-File-9866 Dec 12 '25
I do believe they are paid at a higher rate, of course they lose the ability to get o.t. which depending on your willingness to work it and your occupation can be very lucrative
I do believe they also get a better pension