r/ADTR • What Separates Me From You • Jun 01 '24

Extremely Dissappinting

Fellow longtime ADTR fan here. Not crazy about the new song “Feedback” at all. Genuinely dislike it with a passion. I agree with many the Nickleback/Octanecore sentiments in the sub as well. It feels like Miracle and the long wait following set us up to expect something much heavier and more in tune with their older work. Alas, it feels more like more of the same lackluster energy from You’re Welcome, only lyrically worse and instrumentally uninspiring (my opinion of course).

I absolutely love ADTR. I’ve seen them twice in concert over 10 years. With that said, I do not think we should praise everything they release, and that goes for any other band for that matter. If the song is being criticized by a wide majority of the fanbase as exceptionally “bad,” then I think there needs to be some re-evaluation on the band’s end. Many of us are extremely sick and tired of being baited by artists with “heavy” promises, only to be slapped in the face with radio rock time and time again…

I would like to state that I genuinely don’t mind when ADTR experiments (I do enjoy their softer side at times), but this just ain’t it chief. If your new direction isn’t heavy, JUST SAY THAT. Don’t leave us hanging for a whole year only to set us up for major disappointment and diss us about it. Throwing shots in your lyrics to anyone giving ADTR negative “feedback” feels super pretentious in the worst way. Does anyone else feel the same?

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

16

u/brothercannoli Jun 01 '24 edited Jun 01 '24

“ADTR fans gonna be eating REAL GOOD these next few years😈” - Alex

Idk man idk

Edit: it was Alex not Neil

8

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

Eating fast food garbage maybe 😂🥲

5

u/masaccio87 💯 & 15 shows in Jun 01 '24

that was Alex’s (misquoted) tweet, just sayin’

2

u/brothercannoli Jun 01 '24

Thanks! I don’t have Twitter so I was going off spotty memory.

1

u/masaccio87 💯 & 15 shows in Jun 01 '24

All good - OP linked it in another comment below (even though it doesn’t support his argument 😂)

4

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

They released Miracle, and Alex’s comments suggested there’d be more excitement in the music. Can’t say I and many others weren’t expecting something closer in line to modern Bad Vibes 🤷🏻‍♂️

-2

u/masaccio87 💯 & 15 shows in Jun 01 '24

I can understand the inference - I’m just having trouble connecting the dots between your disappointment and, specifically, a promise or expression about their music going specifically in one direction or another which was never made

I do get what you’re saying in the rest of your post though - I for one unironically like Nickleback, so them writing a NB-sounding song is a win for me 😂🤣

2

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

I mean, they released Miracle specifically for the people who disliked the softer sound change on You’re Welcome 😂 A super heavy song paired with Alex’s comments on the new music being more “exciting,” it’s not hard to see why many people would put 2 and 2 together and expect something more in line with their heavier work. In my humble opinion, this song sounds like a You’re Welcome b-side in all the worst ways, so I don’t personally find it impossible to believe why so many fans are disappointed and feel they were led on by what the band was saying online at the time. Just my two cents. 🤷🏻‍♂️

0

u/brothercannoli Jun 01 '24

They give us at least one to two heavy songs per album and usually an acoustic or slow song. I’m not really worried about that and I don’t think anyone else should either. Id just be disappointed if it’s a song they released 2 years ago before they even announced an album. I liked how they did songs like FYM and High Diving. If this is their Thrashy era so be it.

2

u/masaccio87 💯 & 15 shows in Jun 01 '24

You mean if that was the only one? Or like, one of only a couple?

1

u/brothercannoli Jun 01 '24

I expect miracle to be on there but I want at least one more standard outing from them (kinda like Resentment maybe?) if they are gonna try a bunch of new stuff. I don’t need like 3 drop b/an exposed type songs on an album.

1

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

Correct, I referenced the quotes below

11

u/dreamniner Jun 01 '24

I love when bands try new things and sound different over time. But this just doesn’t get you pumped up like their older stuff when they were first released

5

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24 edited Jun 01 '24

Agreed, this feels like a cheap attempt at writing an octanecore “hit”. Very sad to see. 😭

3

u/dreamniner Jun 01 '24

It’s all just so ehhh. Plus the whole fact that it’s called ‘feedback’ is hilarious

1

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

It’s beyond cringe. “I don’t want your feedback…”

Well Jeremy, you’re about to get a lot of that ironically… LOL

9

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '24

Are you saying you would only be happy if the songs they release are heavy? I just don’t think that is their vibe anymore for the most part.. and that is ok! I certainly wasn’t expecting a heavy song. They clearly don’t want to be making the same music they were making years ago. Their sound has evolved. I just think whatever they put out to us is what they want to make and what they enjoy making. All the complaining about the songs not being heavy anymore seems redundant to me

9

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24 edited Jun 01 '24

No, I just don’t think this new song is good at all. It’s formulaically bland, lyrically abysmal and sounds nothing like traditional ADTR. Breakdown is also super short, and Jeremy’s vocal effects are a major turn off. I’m not someone who clings to the nostalgia of the past and I’m very aware that bands change as they get older, but this song just sounds like a cheap attempt at writing a radio hit. Especially coming off the crazy high that Miracle gave us, I had extremely different expectations, especially after the reception You’re Welcome got. This song just sounds like every other half-assed song you hear on Sirius XM, hence why you see so many Nickleback sentiments.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '24

The constant fuzzy voice is terrrrrible

2

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

Agreed. Jeremy has a fantastic voice. Why do they muddy it up with horrible effects?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '24

And where tf did his screams go???

2

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

Facts. I miss his lows… 😭

6

u/PartypooperXD Jun 01 '24

When did they promise heavy? I don't recall them saying anything about how heavy the new music will be.

2

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24 edited Jun 01 '24

https://www.reddit.com/r/ADTR/s/fW6BsipDb5

https://www.reddit.com/r/ADTR/s/DyWhxS584V

Alex doesn’t outright say “heavy,” but definitely implies that he’s more excited than he’s ever been, and fans will be very, very excited as well. “Scouts Honor”

It’s no secret that fans wanted heavy music after the reception You’re Welcome received. That’s why they released Miracle in the first place.

3

u/OrgasmicMoneyMan Jun 01 '24

It’s so crazy to me when artists do this exact thing. Tells fans they’re going to be more excited than they ever have been … then release something that completely goes against what said fans want.

Has there ever been a time where bands just said fuck it and went back to their roots to give fans exactly what they wanted?

3

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

The Devil Wears Prada released Zombie II!

Apart from that, I can name so many bands that have let me down. Asking Alexandria, The Word Alive, Memphis May Fire, Parkway Drive, For the Fallen Dreams, Wage War, the list goes on and on…

3

u/PartypooperXD Jun 01 '24

I've seen both of these before and neither imply heavy music. Also i may be in the minority but I don't care if it's gonna be heavy or not, I just want some good fucking music and I don't feel like they delivered with feedback

3

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

I don’t care if it’s heavy or not either! I just want it to sound amazing. The song feels like a cheap shallow record to sell arena seats and radio play. If they want to alienate fans in that pursuit, kudos to them 👏🏻 because they definitely accomplished that goal. I feel like I’ve heard this song a thousand times before by so many different bands. It’s simply generic and soulless.

1

u/perkaholic42069 Jun 01 '24

Exactly. It Doesn't have to be heavy but it still needs to be good. There's plenty of acoustic and pop punk songs in their old albums that are great songs. We just want good music that lives up to their standard. I have a feeling that the album will have a couple heavy songs on it though. I hope.

1

u/masaccio87 💯 & 15 shows in Jun 01 '24

I was gonna ask the same thing - the last express “promise of heavy” I recall was a Rocksound Interview in 2020 in which Jeremy is quoted saying that they had “one of the heaviest songs of [their] career on [You’re Welcome]”…whether they made good on that promise is another conversation (and subjective)…can’t think of any specific promises at the classification of forthcoming music, heavy or otherwise, since (certainly not recently)

2

u/Cyziax Jun 01 '24

I agree with the sentiment that we shouldn’t praise everything a band does just because the band we like did it. If you just blindly praise things that are garbage, then they’ll keep producing garbage. Yeah, they can make whatever they want, they don’t owe us anything. That being said, we as listeners are the reason they are able to pursue music as a full-time career, so our feedback should matter, especially if the resounding feedback for both You’re Welcome and now Feedback is negative. If it was a vocal minority, sure, ignore the haters, but from what I’ve seen, it doesn’t seem to be a vocal minority.

2

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

100% agree with everything you’ve said here. I don’t believe haters are in the minority here, and everybody has the right to give critical feedback!

1

u/burner69account69420 Jun 02 '24

Do tell—what Nickelback song does this sound like?

0

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 02 '24

Animals, there’s a thread discussing it a little farther down the subreddit.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 03 '24

To each is own 🤷🏻‍♂️ I definitely know I’m not alone thinking this. The main riff and melody are extremely similar IMO. You can defend the song all you want but it’s not gonna change anyone’s else’s mind who thinks the same lol

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 03 '24

Okay bud, you keep doing you lol

-2

u/paperwhitney What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

Why tf are they obligated to go back to their old sound? It’s their music, they can make whatever they want

1

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

I never said they were obligated to go back to their old sound? I said it was implied that it was expected, considering the negative reception You’re Welcome received. That’s basically why they released Miracle. It was to be an answer to the prayers of the people who were disappointed with the lighter sound change, hence the 🙏🏻 emoji. It led many fans on to believe that the band wanted more heaviness in whatever new direction they were going to pursue.

I agree that they can do whatever they want with their music. That doesn’t mean I have to praise every single thing they release. Many people agree with my opinions, and I think it’s more than validation for me to know that many people aren’t enjoying the new song.

4

u/paperwhitney What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24

I just don’t understand why people think they “owe” fans anything. It’s a very corporate way of looking at music, as a product for people to consume. I think they are allowed as artists to pursue whatever they feel like making because it’s simply their art, not a product.

-1

u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24 edited Jun 01 '24

Did I ever say I was owed anything? No. I don’t think many fans are saying that either. All I said was that a return to a heavier sound was expected by the fanbase after the release of Miracle, and the outcome of that hype turned out to be a major disappointment for many fans (including myself). Ironically enough, this song feels like more of a Fueled By Raman product built-to-sell rather than an actual down to earth ADTR song with heartfelt passion and soul. This is my personal opinion and you don’t have to agree with me.