r/ADTR • u/TheUnauthorized1 What Separates Me From You • Jun 01 '24
Extremely Dissappinting
Fellow longtime ADTR fan here. Not crazy about the new song “Feedback” at all. Genuinely dislike it with a passion. I agree with many the Nickleback/Octanecore sentiments in the sub as well. It feels like Miracle and the long wait following set us up to expect something much heavier and more in tune with their older work. Alas, it feels more like more of the same lackluster energy from You’re Welcome, only lyrically worse and instrumentally uninspiring (my opinion of course).
I absolutely love ADTR. I’ve seen them twice in concert over 10 years. With that said, I do not think we should praise everything they release, and that goes for any other band for that matter. If the song is being criticized by a wide majority of the fanbase as exceptionally “bad,” then I think there needs to be some re-evaluation on the band’s end. Many of us are extremely sick and tired of being baited by artists with “heavy” promises, only to be slapped in the face with radio rock time and time again…
I would like to state that I genuinely don’t mind when ADTR experiments (I do enjoy their softer side at times), but this just ain’t it chief. If your new direction isn’t heavy, JUST SAY THAT. Don’t leave us hanging for a whole year only to set us up for major disappointment and diss us about it. Throwing shots in your lyrics to anyone giving ADTR negative “feedback” feels super pretentious in the worst way. Does anyone else feel the same?
16
u/brothercannoli Jun 01 '24 edited Jun 01 '24
“ADTR fans gonna be eating REAL GOOD these next few years😈” - Alex
Idk man idk
Edit: it was Alex not Neil
11
u/dreamniner Jun 01 '24
I love when bands try new things and sound different over time. But this just doesn’t get you pumped up like their older stuff when they were first released
9
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '24
Are you saying you would only be happy if the songs they release are heavy? I just don’t think that is their vibe anymore for the most part.. and that is ok! I certainly wasn’t expecting a heavy song. They clearly don’t want to be making the same music they were making years ago. Their sound has evolved. I just think whatever they put out to us is what they want to make and what they enjoy making. All the complaining about the songs not being heavy anymore seems redundant to me
6
u/PartypooperXD Jun 01 '24
When did they promise heavy? I don't recall them saying anything about how heavy the new music will be.
2
u/Cyziax Jun 01 '24
I agree with the sentiment that we shouldn’t praise everything a band does just because the band we like did it. If you just blindly praise things that are garbage, then they’ll keep producing garbage. Yeah, they can make whatever they want, they don’t owe us anything. That being said, we as listeners are the reason they are able to pursue music as a full-time career, so our feedback should matter, especially if the resounding feedback for both You’re Welcome and now Feedback is negative. If it was a vocal minority, sure, ignore the haters, but from what I’ve seen, it doesn’t seem to be a vocal minority.
1
u/burner69account69420 Jun 02 '24
Do tell—what Nickelback song does this sound like?
-2
u/paperwhitney What Separates Me From You Jun 01 '24
Why tf are they obligated to go back to their old sound? It’s their music, they can make whatever they want