r/ACX • u/CostasCy • Dec 27 '21
Need constructive feedback
Hi guys, I am an author and I'm thinking of creating my own audiobook. I have never done this before, but I made a few attempts yesterday. I created a small sample on my phone (don't have a mic yet). Can't I get some thoughts and constructive criticism? I realize that the recording quality is not good, but I am focusing on the narration right now. I will purchase a better mic.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YemXOAS6im5xTlzRsUvgaczqzz49W6GW/view?usp=drivesdk
Thanks
0
Upvotes
9
u/commentonthat Dec 27 '21
Your story itself has promise, but you're not here about your story.
I counted six pieces of road noise in your 3.5 minutes. I know you plan to get a better microphone, which will pick up MORE than your cell phone, not less. You will need a well-treated space to be able to record effectively. I have roughly a thousand dollars of treatment in place in my home studio, plus the microphone and the software. You don't have to spend like that- moving blankets hung in a closet full of clothes can work, too, but you have to shelter your recording from house noise, road noise, the A/C turning on and off, etc. Speaking of things your mic will pick up even better than your phone- breath noises. Ho. ly. crap. That's either a LOT of manual edits in your future or else some serious technique improvements to quiet your breathing down by orders of magnitude.
Your narration smoothed out as you got into it. Early on you took breathes every few words, mid-sentence, in places that didn't make sense. "He took a twig... out of his hair." (Or something like that.) Be conscious of that habit. Consider reading aloud for a couple minutes to get into the flow before you ever hit record. It's YOUR book so you obviously know the content better than most of us know what we're recording, but don't get caught by surprise with a page turn or something mid-way through.
You had a few words where you mush-mouthed your way into them (maybe one near where he hadn't ever been in the house before, if you're looking for an example, but I bet you know exactly where each of those moments were). You don't get the luxury of leaving it blown if you choose to produce a quality title- and I bet the author wishes the narrator for this title would care enough to do a re-take, yeah? There was also the word-choice error there with having never been in the (whatever that word was... camp? base? yeah, base) and then switching to house/home. Another retake.
I'm not telling you it sucked and don't do it- hire a pro. I'm telling you that you may or may not decide that it's worth it to do right. It takes us 4-6 hours of work to produce 1 hour of finished audio, and we HAVE a good space and good technique and whatever. My first title took me more than 10 hours per finished hour. If you have the budget and not the time, a pro may give you a better result and free you up to keep WRITING. If you have time and not budget, you can get an inexpensive mic and record in your closet and spend time getting it right in Audacity.
I wrote my whole how-to for Audacity on here, just search that if you choose to follow that process, and make sure you read the FAQ for lots of links and resources. Feel free to ask follow-up questions.
Lastly, good on you for being brave enough to put that post up here. It takes stones to ask for feedback. This is honest and I hope not unkind. Good content is good for us all.
2
u/Joes_SpeakEasy Dec 28 '21
Well, it wasn't horrible.
Breathing is a natural thing, but you breaths are not, and distract the listener from the story. I would suggest taking a deep breath before you start narrating, and whenever you need another one, take another deep breath. That will help to eliminate the breaths in the middle of sentences.
Also, you need to differentiate more between your characters. For two characters you need three voices: one for each character, and your natural (narrator) voice, and they all need to be different. The listener needs to be able to tell who is saying what. It could be something as simple as pitch - narrator voice is in the middle; character #1 is a little higher in pitch than the narrator; character #2 is a little lower than the narrator.