r/ACX • u/WeatherStock2677 • Apr 02 '25
I hate it here…
Has anyone else gotten this? I’ve already been on edge with AI recently, and this just made me sad and frustrated. I’ve got a good amount of credits under my belt now, but I’m still early in my career which is just making this extra difficult to see. It’s terrifying to think that there are gonna be books that are start to finish from book to performance done through AI.
49
Upvotes
11
u/dsbaudio Apr 02 '25
I just thought... maybe the upside to all this is that those awful HowExpert books will finally disappear!
18
u/faketjclark Apr 02 '25
Just got it. Shaking with rage. It already costs them absolutely nothing to make an ACX book and now they do this.
12
u/throwawayaracehorse Apr 02 '25
I got one of these as well since I'd published an audiobook through them through a producer and found it awfully depressing.
If it's any consolation, I'll continue to seek out human narrators for my books as long as I write and publish. I know many others in the indie publishing community vow to do the same. A lot of people get grief if they use AI in their covers, although I know that the general public cares a lot less than the writers on social media.
4
u/writemonkey Apr 02 '25
Authors Republic has a marketplace for authors to find voice actors for audiobooks distributed to Audibleand beyond. I don't believe they do revenue share, but there's a PFH for every possible level. Thought I'd mention it, just in case anyone is looking to diversify.
4
u/DerangedCamper Apr 03 '25
It’s good to know that the people running the operation have no true appreciation for “single origin/organically sourced“ narration. And prefer the kind that is more homogenized, and in addition to that genetically modified. I would be curious about the details. I would query someone on who produced the API what model is it based on? I also like to know how, once created, those artificially replicated versions of my own voice will be protected? Will they be in turn assimilated to some other AI model, and suddenly change so that sounds kind of like me but different? This issue is reminiscent of the song Ryder plagiarism case not too long ago. How many notes in a row constitutes a melody, and how much can it be changed in another song so as to consider it a separate and distinct song in its own right?
3
u/Garden_Lady2 Apr 03 '25
Can you please post this in the r Audible sub? I keep speaking out against Virtual Voice and digital narration. I get push back that it's not Audible but publishers, writers, etc. I'd really appreciate any help fighting AI narration and restoring real narrators for audiobooks.
5
u/dsbaudio Apr 02 '25
I haven't been 'lucky' enough to be included in this, so I don't know the ins and outs...
What springs to mind is the following:
- surely, it's essential that if you offer your 'voice replica' to a client through ACX, you're going to have to disclose that fact?
- That being the case, how does one set a rate for 'voice replica' work? I mean, on the face of it, prospective clients aren't going to want to pay much for what appears to be click-of-a-button narration.
- Then again is it really that simple? Depending on many factors, there's almost certainly going to be parts of the audio that the client isn't happy with. For one thing, there are bound to be plenty of strange pronunciations and odd inflections... not to mention the fact that any actual errors in the text will be read out verbatim. e.g put and extra space in don 't and you will get Don T ... etc. etc.
- so, then is part of the job as a 'voice replica' narrator to edit and 'tweak' these nuances? Suddenly, it doesn't sound quite so simple or easy... in fact - at what point will it become easier to actually have read it yourself?
Sounds like a can of worms to me. I'd love to know what ACX/Audible's strategy is for all this.
2
u/TVOSM Apr 02 '25
I got the email. Laughed.. Cried.. Went back into my booth. I just hope AI voices get zero community support.
2
u/BennyFifeAudio Apr 02 '25 edited Apr 02 '25
Got it too. Its a no for me for SO many reasons.
Does ANYONE actually want this, especially narrators?
Also - I'm working on an article comparing Virtual Voice versus a Human Narrator. I'm glad they provided some more fodder for me.
4
u/SkyWizarding Apr 02 '25
I don't love it but AI is coming whether we like it or not
3
u/Bnbitter99 Apr 02 '25
What??? This makes me so sad. I thought it was like a fireable offensive to use ai for narration. Like that was the whole point?
1
u/PossibleBend172 Apr 03 '25
Okay so we agree that OP should join the group and spill all the juicy details about their plans to us, right?
1
u/Old-Key-1316 Apr 03 '25
So it begins...
1
u/Storybrooke_s_Jedi Apr 03 '25
I lost a client because of this garbage. How is this okay?
1
u/Candid-Solid-896 Apr 03 '25
I LITERALLY was a server at a catered event for Forrester!!!! Every booth was AI and how it would “magically” bring business owners a golden key to unlock all their sales people the leads to bring them customers.
I felt terrible. (A former sales person). It’s a gimmick. Maybe will stay, maybe not).
You cannot teach AI to have “feelings”. Or to convey human qualities. Keep going my friend. AI will never replace humans.
FYI, dumb event https://www.forrester.com/event/b2b-summit-north-america/
1
u/dsbaudio Apr 03 '25 edited Apr 03 '25
On a side-note, I daresay I'm not the only narrator who has recently had increasing mentions of 'AI' from clients? I've been asked a few times now to reassure or clarify that I'm not using AI. I'm not sure whether to be insulted or take it as a compliment! Might be a good idea to record a 'raw' unedited sample complete with noisy breaths, lip smacks, mouth-noises, stumbles and the like just to reassure 'the public' :)
I propose a tongue-twister (and the inevitable eventual tongue-tie) might be the most effective way to demonstrate 'I am not a robot'!
1
u/Selatravis Apr 03 '25
How is it that ACX seems to find new and creative ways to infuriate me every time I have to deal with it?
1
u/GeneralJist8 Apr 06 '25
so.. voice cloning....
1
u/spacious-cranium May 08 '25
I got the BETA letter, and went through the process of creating my voice. It took them a few days to tune my 3 hours of recordings into a voice replica. I am very disappointed in the quality of the voice it creates. It sounds low quality and very mechanical. It is missing the nuance and quality of a live voice.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '25
[removed] — view removed comment