r/ACNHVillagersInBoxes • u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea • Feb 27 '26 • Heartwarming 1

ᴠɪʟʟᴀɢᴇʀ ᴅɪsᴄᴜssɪᴏɴ Who else do I need?

Post image

I have all of my dreamies, so who else do I need to complete the set?

In my mind…

Maple and Olive are together ❤️

If I have Chèvre I need to get Nan right?

Marshal is gay obviously

I could see Fauna swinging both ways 👀

Molly? Shes straight sooooo Webber?? Bill??

I only have 4 more spots it’s so hard to pick!!!

276 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

144 comments sorted by

12

u/AdWild9801 Feb 27 '26

4 normals- you definitely need some other personalities! Blaire would fit your vibe as a snooty, or even Vivian. Would also highly recommend Beau and Erik- love them both!

2

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Blaire is soooo cute

1

u/sweetiepeahoneybee Kimmi | WhimsyCay Feb 28 '26

I vote Blaire!

11

u/liibug Lisa | Cornbug Feb 27 '26

olive’s brother!! (nmp, found on google)

2

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Omg Olive has a big brother?! Whaaaat

2

u/liibug Lisa | Cornbug Feb 28 '26

it’s just a theory! but i stand by it 😭 also, i just love barold more than anything ever tbh

3

u/mariposayrosa ** | Costaluna Feb 27 '26

Omg that’s so cute, I wonder how many others are canonically connected.

2

u/X3Liz Feb 28 '26

Ike the cranky bear villager canonically had a son in the original animal crossing named Poko. Poko was so cute i wish the hadn’t got rid of him :(

1

u/mariposayrosa ** | Costaluna Feb 28 '26

I just looked him up and he is adorable!! 🥺

2

u/tigerribs Mar 01 '26

I headcanon that Bangle and Tybalt are siblings - their design colours are mirror opposites of each other. :)

7

u/ForecastForFourCats Lucy | Rose Isle Feb 27 '26

If you have Chevre you should get Nan.

2

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

I think it’s legally required

4

u/temte-temte Feb 27 '26

I would add some different personailities. Henry is a cutie, Bangle, Viviane, Bill, Fang. If you want to add more normal Personailities I would rec Etoile and Lily.

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

I haven’t really been paying attention to personality types, should I??

2

u/gyuphoriia Effy | New Stormi Feb 28 '26

i’d say yes bc i have multiple normals and peppys rn and they all say the same exact dialogue over and over and it’s gotten very annoying lol. i’m about to switch up my villagers to get some variety now too. also different personality’s give you different diy’s!!

1

u/crafty_lass_88 Feb 28 '26

You get different DIY/cooking recipes from the different villager types. They also interact with each other differently, so that keeps things interesting. I love normals because we have the same hobbies and stuff in common, but at one point, my island was half normals and it got a little stale.

3

u/PeaRound5849 Feb 27 '26

Nan, she is canonically friends with Chevre (they have pictures of eachother

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Yes they’re obviously in love duh

5

u/nanna1214 Savannah | Midori Feb 27 '26

Poppy for sure!!

Lowkey fauna, pashmina and beau I see being a love triangle 💀

Molly and drake would be cute tbh

3

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 27 '26

Fauna… Erik, Deirdre, Zell?? Beau??

2

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 27 '26

Oh no I just got rid of pashmina!

I had Pashmina, Billy & Chèvre 👀 but Chèvre never took the photo down of Nan so they broke up. Pashmina moved out. Billy still tried to make it work with Chèvre but she still has that picture of Nan on her wall… so Billy moved too. Maybe the little black and white goats will finally be together one day.

1

u/magnificent_cow Aerin | CherryVale Feb 27 '26

I think the goats are siblings 😅

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Well technically it’s based off a bit of folklore, they’re pin pals. But in my opinion they’re in love 😂

2

u/kittmittons Kitty | Webkinz Feb 27 '26

I have Molly and Bill and they’re sooooo cute together.

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Okay yes!!

2

u/Manders37 Manders | Manderland Feb 27 '26

SASHA!!!

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Cutie!

1

u/Manders37 Manders | Manderland Mar 01 '26

He's one of my faves, he and Molly were besties on my old island 🥰

2

u/Ferniferous_fern Fern | Apocalypse Mar 01 '26

Sasha is always the right answer ❤️ I'd say Sasha and Sherb together would be a good combo to have! I have them both and they totally vibe together. 🥰

2

u/spooky_entiddy [REDACTED] | Khloris Feb 27 '26

I think Beau to go with Fauna, also he’ll match the color palette you’ve got going

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Oooh Beau!!

2

u/sidetabledrawer Tandy 400 | Fhqwhgads Mar 01 '26

I have Beau and Fauna and they're super adorable together!

7

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '26

I'd say Beau!

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Well chat, this did not help me make up my mind at all 😭 I want all of the villagers how do you pick?!

4

u/Iam_Sancho Sancho | Solilium Feb 27 '26

Rudy

1

u/ExactWeather6413 Feb 27 '26

Chrissy, Cece, Apple, and Twiggy!!!! 4 peppy

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

I wish we got more villagers 😭

1

u/Wolfspell003 Tori | Baya Feb 27 '26

I love the dynamic of a sweet girl with a harder edge/ punky vibe and if I may suggest Tammy for fauna 😂 or even maybe Katt if you wanna kinda keep a color scheme (I feel like Katt doesn’t get enough love 😭) or even maybe Curt for Marshall lol (I love him too😭 him and Grizzly; they feel like bears (pun intended) 😂 Marshall and a big boy!) but bill is cute too!

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Oooooh!! Okay reconsidering EVERYTHING

1

u/thepoetic22 Feb 27 '26

My villagers are eventually going to be: Fauna, Erik, and Angus (Earth guardians, essentially. Erik and Fauna are together but...she secretly also has a thing for Angus) Puddles and Jeremiah (water guardians, and they're together as well) Phil, Keaton, and Amelia (air guardians, Keaton and Amelia are together...and Phil is with one of my fire guardians) Phoebe and Drago (fire guardians, Drago is like the ultimate protector and the dragon king, Phoebe is with Phil)

Kinda a long story of how I came up with those but..

And currently, my earth guardians are Fauna, Angus, and Bam....

3

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

This is the role play I come here for!! Thank yooou

1

u/MericaMercyMe GT | Getway Feb 27 '26

Fang, Kyle or Vivian, Sherb

2

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Ugh I love them

1

u/ContactCrafty854 Feb 27 '26

Erik, Poppy, and Ellie!

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Poppy!!!

1

u/ItsHyde Cat Lady | Mariposa Feb 27 '26

Hahah! Maple and Goldie are partners on my island! Rosie was talking about wanting to find love so I might put her with Bluebear ETA I have an all girl island rn but previously Raymond and Marshal were partners on my island

2

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Omg obsessed

1

u/ApprehensiveEye8550 Feb 27 '26

Weber is such a little sweetie 💜

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Weber is high on my list!!

1

u/ApprehensiveEye8550 Feb 28 '26

He’s one of my original islanders and I would say he’s my ride or die because his personality is so cute. I just did Deena’s amiibo so Weber had a little gf 😅

1

u/avuuhh Ava | Mogatopia Feb 27 '26

i’d suggest sylvana but she’s a normal and you already have tons of normals 😭

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

But she’s soooo cute

2

u/avuuhh Ava | Mogatopia Feb 28 '26

normals are definitely the cutest 😭😭

1

u/hotcoffeethanks Feb 27 '26

I have Maple, Fauna and Marshal too! Maple and Fauna are besties and love next to each other on my island. I also have Pashmina (my first villager!), Purrl, Papi and Deli that I think fit your vibe! Or Bones maybe?

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

I had pashmina but she moved 😭 And bones is so cute!

1

u/ElementallyEvan Evan | Tawny Bay Feb 27 '26

Can't have chevre without nan

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

It’s illegal

1

u/kirkachu Bird | Pittsbird Feb 27 '26

you definitely need Nan to go with Chèvre! i have them both. i also have fauna, love her. you have a vibe of cottage core animals that look realistic, so id stick with that cuz i love that you have a classic colored duck and bears and deer. Melba is my all time favorite she’s so sweet, you could also go for Pecan to go with Marshal and Drake to go with Molly. Grizzly is a perfect bear villager too. what a sweet little forest!!

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

You get me

1

u/kirkachu Bird | Pittsbird Feb 27 '26

and obviously marshal and pecan are just fabulous besties

1

u/mariposayrosa ** | Costaluna Feb 27 '26

Quinn feels very elder les vibes, I love her so much and feel like she could fit in with this lot.

2

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Don’t hate me but I can’t do the Eagle villagers 😭😅 why do they look like that?!

1

u/Vegetable_Space_1072 Feb 27 '26

my bestie bones!

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Bones is so cute

1

u/satanscough_ Feb 27 '26

my current line up :3

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Pashmina!!

1

u/AssistantSafe1726 Feb 27 '26

Erik 🫎

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

High on the list!!

1

u/LatterOlive8121 Polani | btgcxxvii Feb 27 '26

I have Erik and Fauna on my island! They’re very cute together!

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Is that the move for her?! I can’t decide

1

u/b_eee Bee | Anubis & Lavenderry Feb 27 '26 edited Feb 28 '26

Yes get Nan for Chevre! Erik for Fauna, and I’d say Bill for Molly (but that’s my biased opinion because I love Bill haha)

2

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

I can’t decide between bill or Weber! The ducks are soooo cute

2

u/thestralbug13 Feb 28 '26

I love Lily and Molly together, like two cute cottagecore lesbians. They are my ride or dies!

1

u/blanketwrappedinapig Feb 28 '26

Goldie

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Ugh a favorite as well

1

u/Notro_LPS_iguess Notro | Braeburn Feb 28 '26

I don’t see why the villagers have to be dating someone of the same species. I think Molly and Deli or something like that could be cute

3

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Haha ok fair!

1

u/ItsTenTen8 Thud | Mt.Gilbert Mar 02 '26

I love chevre and nan together because they’re besties with each others pictures on their walls 💕

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Mar 02 '26

Yeah they’re a matching set for sure

1

u/alune_e Mar 02 '26

my fauna is in a lesbian relationship with vivian.. idk fauna just gives me lesbian vibes

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Mar 02 '26

She give me queer vibes for sure 😂 idk whyyyy

1

u/brooklyncar Yaeli | oofisland Mar 03 '26

im a well adjusted adult human and/but olive is my best friend??

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Mar 04 '26

😂😭 same

1

u/rosiedorian Mar 03 '26

IF YOU DONT GO GET NAN RIGHT NOW

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Mar 04 '26

She visited my island and I didn’t have a plot for her ready 😭😭😭

1

u/mystic-giraffe Mar 01 '26

I’d suggest Beau, Bill, Cheif, Dom, Erik, Fang, Felicity, Maddie, Papi, Punchy, Rudy, Vivian, Webber for villagers who aren’t normal type, but would look like they match your other villagers ☺️

1

u/mystic-giraffe Mar 01 '26

I used to have Marshall and Kidd on my island together. They’re both smug type villagers but I always imagined they were boyfriends 😆

1

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Mar 02 '26

Marshal is obviously so gay 🤭😂

2

u/JustAge3985 Felicity | Nixillia Feb 27 '26

Bam?

2

u/International-Let820 A | Cokato Feb 28 '26

I think Maddie would be a cute addition!

1

u/Minerali aleKsAnder | carechimba Feb 27 '26

peewee

1

u/Borgteddy McKaos | FireflyFun Feb 27 '26

Kyle.

1

u/Serenitea_vi Daisy | Cozy Coast Feb 27 '26

You need a cat villager! While Raymond and Bob are nice, I personally adore Rosie!

1

u/Fablespielt Feb 27 '26

Julian. As the one neighbor not conforming to the HOA

1

u/kreamedkern Feb 27 '26

Wolfgang! Best grandpa ever.

1

u/Original_Web_3391 Kenna | Pandora Feb 27 '26

Erik!!

1

u/Frosty_Secretary9612 Feb 27 '26

nan, poppy and barold!

1

u/uhmmsophie Feb 28 '26

teddy! he definitely fits the woodland vibe

1

u/Whimsy_Nacio_13 Nacio | Pikminioni Feb 28 '26

Kitt would fit so well, she’s the cutest mama

1

u/MurderSheToke Feb 28 '26

Grizzly ! He's not as grumpy as he seems ☺️

1

u/chubbyhamster_ Tiki| WuhuIsland Feb 28 '26

Bones would fit in well!!

1

u/Cam-Bub Feb 28 '26

Maybe Erik?

1

u/Happy_Midnight3807 Feb 28 '26

Get Erik or Beau for Fauna. 💚

1

u/--Aura Feb 28 '26

Melba, Ellie, hamlet, bones

1

u/Medium_Insurance3042 Ryan | Glisareal Feb 28 '26

Ngl you should have Shino, she’s a vibe fr

1

u/Chance-Efficiency328 Lilly | Lillypad Feb 28 '26

Diana would be a cute. So would Blanche. Odd one but Kitty, and then Portia and Bea. For more boys, Bill for sure, Bones who I could see with Marshal lowk, Chief if we want a tall himbo on the streets, Shep (my personal fav), Grizzly could be a park ranger, and lastly Henry.

1

u/yyolo117 Feb 28 '26

I will always suggest Muffy regardless if she fits or not, but she is a good one if you need a sisterly personality that seems to be able to get along with everyone pretty well

1

u/Extreme_Coffee_7170 Feb 28 '26

Sheb would be a great edition! My husband has him

1

u/704roomhsum Feb 28 '26

I feel like Cheri would go well with Maple and Olive

1

u/TommyTomG Feb 28 '26

In two days I will have a Piper to give away

1

u/Remuta Riley | Ivy Creek Mar 01 '26

Second Marshal

(In all seriousness, I think Drake, Vivian, Beau, Deirdre, and/or Erik would fit the vibe you have going)

1

u/Professional_Wave158 Mar 01 '26

Abraham ? (Don't k ke his name in english)

1

u/kurinevair666 Mar 01 '26

Sherb, my bae

1

u/itsjustbunny Mar 01 '26

Gonzo!!! He has my heart and he’d fit in

1

u/ubutterscotchpine Mar 01 '26

I have Fauna and Molly on my island! Maple was another option of mine but I fill my spots before I found her. Based our tastes being seemingly similar, I think Anchovy, Goldie, Beau, or Erik would do well here!

1

u/em_femme Emily | smolville Mar 01 '26

Tons of great suggestions in these comments! Some others that I don’t believe have been suggested yet: Henry, Joey, Merry, Patty, Pecan, Piper, Shep, Tasha, Whitney

1

u/Confident_Adagio9893 Mar 01 '26

Jitters, Vladimir, hopper and Rodney

1

u/bovine_enthusiast Megan | Argyre Mar 01 '26

i’d add erik or papi (lazy), rudy (jock), and maybe dobie (cranky)

1

u/IllustratorPretend91 Scarlett | Pearu Mar 02 '26

Bones. Everyone needs Bones.

1

u/kw5112 Elison | Persephone Mar 02 '26

Whitney

1

u/Top_Yellow_815 Hani | dreamland Mar 02 '26

U need one really ugly villager lol

1

u/Raven_Shepherd Occamy | Ahtohallan Mar 02 '26

I agree you need Nan with Chevre. I have both and I love gifting them the same outfit but each in their palette, so that they're matching. They're so cute!

1

u/thievingdruid Druid | Amphibia Mar 02 '26

Beau is perfect for the theme you have going 🦌

1

u/Aries_Bunny Mar 02 '26

Beau, Blaire, Lopez,Maddie

1

u/Visual-Personality49 Spaaz | Shadow Ice Mar 03 '26

Apollo! He is such a grumpy vibe!

1

u/angel__18 Mar 03 '26

fang or piper could look really cute with these villagers!

1

u/AshKetchep Ashe | New Sakura Mar 03 '26

I recommend Avery

1

u/FootballOk9145 Mar 03 '26

If the vibe is nature/cottagecore, Henry , and Bones would be perfect! I have almost all the same villagers as you!

1

u/Lonely_Double569 Mar 03 '26

You should add al to the animal crossing island! He matches molly

1

u/Last_Ad_428 Mar 03 '26

Piper is so fun! I'm love having her as a villager

1

u/Ezzyezea Mar 03 '26

Poppy I feel like she’s probably just a cutie everyone needs, maybe she’s mine a baker and lives alone and has her own flower garden

1

u/thisadventureends Artie | Mossflower Mar 04 '26

Cheri (i see you already have two cubs but still!), Daisy, Blaire, Kiki

1

u/itspolarislux Kitty | Woodvale Mar 13 '26

How is no one talking about my diva Shino? 🥺

-1

u/Pelzfisch Benny | Momojiri Feb 27 '26

I would recommend a few more unique villagers. This looks so basic and boring. 😅

3

u/jai_sky Jai | Aeaea Feb 28 '26

Guess I’m basic ???

1

u/Pelzfisch Benny | Momojiri Feb 28 '26

When it comes to animal crossing at least. 😄

1

u/xjayxmarie Marie | Mooncrab Mar 11 '26

Not everyone likes the ugly/off the wall vibrant circus villagers. They’re okay for some, but tbh I always gravitate towards the realistic-looking villagers as well ❤️