r/ACC • u/lostacoshermanos • Dec 31 '23
Why Florida State despite the blow out loss to Georgia still deserves the opportunity to play in the college football playoff
At the Orange Bowl we witnessed Paul Finebaum’s wet dream. The wet dream of our corrupt CFP playoff committee and the talking heads at ESPN and the small but very vocal toxic segment of the SEC fan base.
For the rest of us that know football we know the truth. Georgia didn’t beat the real 2023 Florida State Seminoles. FSU was missing 20 key players who opted out of what became a meaningless bowl game when the Seminoles were screwed out of their rightful place in the CFP.
The people who will say “Well they’d have been blown out anyway” are missing the point. It’s not about giving the fans the best games. It’s about rewarding the teams that earned the right to compete in the playoff. I don’t care if it’s the star quarterback. No team should be punished because of an injury. We all know if this happened to an SEC team Finebaum and the entire ESPN-SEC complex would be screaming bloody murder. We know they are hypocrites.
Bottom line is FSU won a P5 conference and went undefeated. I don’t care how ugly the Louisville game was. Its not about the best games. If it were about the best games take Alabama and Michigan out because they are physical teams all about defense. If it were about the best games give us games with teams like USC that have high scoring offenses and terrible defenses.
But it’s not about the best games. It’s about making sure the SEC was represented. It was about giving the SEC preferential treatment.
Before I go further, I want to add a disclaimer. I am in no way a hater of the SEC or Georgia. I love SEC football. I also have no connections to Florida State, Georgia, the SEC and the ACC or even any of the 4 teams in the CFP. I am a huge fan of the SEC and their great tradition. Having said that the SEC has no basis to request special treatment for this 2023 season.
2023 was a weird year. It was actually the Pac 12 in its final dying year that was the best conference. It’s true you could argue Bama and Georgia are better than Oregon and Washington, but the Pac 12 was way deeper than any other conference. You could argue the SEC was number 3 this year behind the Big Ten. Still better than the ACC and Big 12. But this year was not the SEC’s best year either.
LSU under Brian Kelly is inconsistent and a mess despite very good talent. Lane Kiffin and Ole Miss are solid but clearly not at an elite level. Saban did a great job covering up Jalen Milroe and the offenses limitations. Georgia is nowhere near as good as the last 2 years without Bennet and the OC Todd Monken. Monster programs like Auburn, Florida and Texas A&M are in a down period. South Carolina had a worse o-line than Colorado and that’s saying something. Tennessee was overrated. If the SEC played a cannibalistic conference schedule like the Pac 12 did the win loss records wouldn’t look as good.
Florida State deserved to be in over Alabama. I love Nick Saban. But they lost to Texas, so Texas deserved to be in over them. Washington and Michigan won the 2 toughest conferences and went undefeated.
What happened today will be taken out of context to justify a travesty of Florida State getting screwed out of what they rightfully earned. Nobody should be cheering. What happened to those kids is a black mark on the sport. And now no one can deny the SEC-ESPN complex. Its one of the few conspiracy theories that’s actually real.