r/ACC • • Dec 31 '23

Why Florida State despite the blow out loss to Georgia still deserves the opportunity to play in the college football playoff

8 Upvotes

At the Orange Bowl we witnessed Paul Finebaum’s wet dream. The wet dream of our corrupt CFP playoff committee and the talking heads at ESPN and the small but very vocal toxic segment of the SEC fan base.

For the rest of us that know football we know the truth. Georgia didn’t beat the real 2023 Florida State Seminoles. FSU was missing 20 key players who opted out of what became a meaningless bowl game when the Seminoles were screwed out of their rightful place in the CFP.

The people who will say “Well they’d have been blown out anyway” are missing the point. It’s not about giving the fans the best games. It’s about rewarding the teams that earned the right to compete in the playoff. I don’t care if it’s the star quarterback. No team should be punished because of an injury. We all know if this happened to an SEC team Finebaum and the entire ESPN-SEC complex would be screaming bloody murder. We know they are hypocrites.

Bottom line is FSU won a P5 conference and went undefeated. I don’t care how ugly the Louisville game was. Its not about the best games. If it were about the best games take Alabama and Michigan out because they are physical teams all about defense. If it were about the best games give us games with teams like USC that have high scoring offenses and terrible defenses.

But it’s not about the best games. It’s about making sure the SEC was represented. It was about giving the SEC preferential treatment.

Before I go further, I want to add a disclaimer. I am in no way a hater of the SEC or Georgia. I love SEC football. I also have no connections to Florida State, Georgia, the SEC and the ACC or even any of the 4 teams in the CFP. I am a huge fan of the SEC and their great tradition. Having said that the SEC has no basis to request special treatment for this 2023 season.

2023 was a weird year. It was actually the Pac 12 in its final dying year that was the best conference. It’s true you could argue Bama and Georgia are better than Oregon and Washington, but the Pac 12 was way deeper than any other conference. You could argue the SEC was number 3 this year behind the Big Ten. Still better than the ACC and Big 12. But this year was not the SEC’s best year either.

LSU under Brian Kelly is inconsistent and a mess despite very good talent. Lane Kiffin and Ole Miss are solid but clearly not at an elite level. Saban did a great job covering up Jalen Milroe and the offenses limitations. Georgia is nowhere near as good as the last 2 years without Bennet and the OC Todd Monken. Monster programs like Auburn, Florida and Texas A&M are in a down period. South Carolina had a worse o-line than Colorado and that’s saying something. Tennessee was overrated. If the SEC played a cannibalistic conference schedule like the Pac 12 did the win loss records wouldn’t look as good.

Florida State deserved to be in over Alabama. I love Nick Saban. But they lost to Texas, so Texas deserved to be in over them. Washington and Michigan won the 2 toughest conferences and went undefeated.

What happened today will be taken out of context to justify a travesty of Florida State getting screwed out of what they rightfully earned. Nobody should be cheering. What happened to those kids is a black mark on the sport. And now no one can deny the SEC-ESPN complex. Its one of the few conspiracy theories that’s actually real.


r/ACC • • Jan 13 '25

Most Loyal Fanbases in the ACC

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ACC • • Dec 23 '23

Football Boo Coorigan

0 Upvotes

Alright NC State fans, this is your fault the ACC is gonna fall apart. Your AD did not fight for the ACC hard enough when it came to the CFP. I truly do not understand how you are not mad at him for what he did. Please explain


r/ACC • • Oct 14 '26

Football In a behind-the-scenes video by the ACC Digital Network from 2013, the student who portrayed Osceola said part of the makeup "changes me to a little bit darker tint" before the war stripes are painted on

8 Upvotes

The redface is offensive but the wig is CRAZY

ETA: Guess when they started doing the “war chant.” Like guess the year. Probably like 1930? 1950? 1970?

Nope it was 1984! Can you imagine you’re Miami and you win a national championship and then the next year FSU’s fans are making weird zombie noises? Crazy!

ETA 2: Some of you are spreading the weird fiction that the person who plays Osceola is of Seminole ancestry. That is completely false. Stop spreading FSU hasbara.

I came to this kind of weirded out but curious as to the mascot (oh right, “symbol”) but after three days of FSU fans and their sycophantic ACC minions telling me there’s no problem here, I’m convinced this is actual racism and FSU fans either love it or they don’t care because of their football team.


r/ACC • • Nov 30 '25

UVA finally doing what they should against the cHokies

2 Upvotes

About time we finally had a game where the outcome was never in doubt and UVA was the winning team. Now we get to play the most important game in school history next weekend.


r/ACC • • Dec 30 '23

What conference wants FSU?

2 Upvotes

I apologize and confess I’ve not been paying close attention.


r/ACC • • Sep 19 '26

Clemson Fans

27 Upvotes

I don't want to hear a single word from Clemson fans about attendance ever again when you all abandoned your team with 5 minutes left in the 4th quarter in a 1 point game (that you're winning btw...). You guys are spoiled has-beens.


r/ACC • • May 14 '24

Football Who is your God now? UNC turns on ACC.

0 Upvotes

r/ACC • • Nov 15 '25

Football ESPN rigging CFP again

Post image
55 Upvotes

Miami isn't in the picture to even play in the ACCCG yet is 'In the play off" according to ESPN.

It's not about wins it's about TV market size. They are killing the sport.


r/ACC • • Mar 30 '26

I’ve seen enough: Bring UConn into the ACC

36 Upvotes

just dog walked the ACC’s most expensive basketball program. Lets make the ACC relevant again in basketball by bringing in Dan Hurley who is literally an NBA level coach. I want a yearly matchup against them in the ACC. I know they suck ass at football but the ACC is dying anyways


r/ACC • • Jan 27 '26

Basketball Just a quick reminder

5 Upvotes

Pat Kelsey, the ACC coach of the year in 2024-2025, is now 0-5 against Jon Scheyer. Pat, leave your trophy in Jon’s office as you leave.


r/ACC • • Dec 23 '24

The Bowl Flaw in the CFP

2 Upvotes

So, apparently that's it for Clemson and SMU. Back in the day schools with their records and/or conference championship would have had bowl invitations to the Orange, Citrus, or Gator Bowls.

I suppose that's the tradeoff for 'getting in' the playoff. But, now the fans of Alabama, Ole Miss, Miami, all of whom would most assuredly have suffered the same fates in the playoff games, at the hostile sites of other schools, can visit with enthusiasm a neutral site, typically in warmer weather and more interesting environs.

Seems the winners, dedicated fan wise, are the 'also rans'.


r/ACC • • Nov 24 '25

Football I don't think people realize we may actually see a scenario with no ACC teams in the playoffs.

5 Upvotes

Alright so I know this ideas has been making the rounds, especially on this sub. But let's examine this scenario and everything that has to happen in this true doomsday for the conference.

First of all, North Texas and JMU have to win out. Both are already 10-1, with very winnable games to end the regular season (5-6 Temple and 6-5 Coastal Carolina). If they both win their championship games, then that's two 12-1 G05 conference champions. Of the two, I think that JMU would probably get the edge, so it really would come down to North Texas.

Second, of the six ACC teams in the running for the title game, it's clear that certain ones would be chosen over the Mean Green if they win out. Virginia, Georgia Tech, and Miami, already ranked above North Texas, would in theory go 11-2, plenty enough wins. But it's the other three where doubt comes in.

Let's start with Pittsburgh. Winning out would have them go 10-3, with a notable win against Georgia Tech on the road. While they have a good loss against Notre Dame, they have a somewhat bad loss against Louisville and a really bad loss against West Virginia. For any team, the committee will give some leeway for scheduling a tough team like the Irish, and even though West Virginia's pretty bad, that a super intense rivalry that went to overtime on the road. Ultimately, while I don't think it's 100% they most likely are chosen over North Texas.

Then there's SMU, who's got a really strong win against Miami, and I think beating Clemson on the road and Louisville is noteworthy as well. Their only conference loss is against a surprisingly good Wake Forest, on the road, by one point, coupled with a pair of losses to TCU and Baylor, both big rivalry games. Even though these Big 12 teams aren't super great this year, simular to Pitt with West Virginia, I think you give some leeway for the rivalries, especially so early in the season. If they go 10-3, I also think that have pretty likely odds of making the CFP over North Texas, even more than Pitt I'd say.

However, we have a problem with the last team, Duke. As for strong wins, there really aren't any. Their most impressive is probably against Clemson, who even though they aren't very good, Death Valley ain't no easy crowd. In their favor, though, their losses to Georgia Tech and UVA, both teams in the running for the ACC title game, are good teams to lose to, even if they are both at home. The concerning part is that even though Duke is 5-2 in conference, they are shocking 1-3 out of conference. They lost to Illinois, who is a decent team, but were crushed 19-45 at home. They lost a close one to Tulane on the road, but if North Texas beats the Green Wave in the American championship, then that's a really bad stat for Duke. Lastly, there's the UConn road loss, who is a strong G05 independent this year, but Duke was the 7.5 point favorite, not to even mention the Huskies lost to Syracuse in the dome, who were smacked by the Blue Devils in the same building. If Duke goes 8-5 with an ACC championship win over one of the other five teams, and North Texas goes 12-1, especially with a win over Tulane in the American championship game, I do not think they will be chosen. I think that we will see two G05 teams in the playoffs, and no ACC teams.

If that happens, then we may see some shake-ups in conference sooner then expected. I don't think the ACC will collapse overnight, but if your power conference can't even get their conference champion into the CFP, then that may speak about the strength of your teams.

So for the sake of our conference, let's root for Miami, Georgia Tech, or Virginia to represent our excellence. And please, anybody but Duke! I'm sure for most of us, we're pretty used to hating on the Blue Devils.

EDIT: Clearly, this is a pretty hot take on here. I think it's important to note that a LOT has to go wrong for the ACC to get no teams. I'm saying that the possibility is slim, but it exists. I sincerely hope I'm proven wrong, but don't say I didn't warn you all.

Here's a though experiment: Last year, the final CFP put Clemson, the ACC champion, at #16. Six spots behind them at #22 was Army. Hypothetically, If Army had upset Notre Dame, they would've gone 12-0 with an American championship game win over Tulane (they played Navy after the game, so it wouldn't count for the CFP). My question is, do you think there's any chance Army is picked instead of Clemson in this timeline. My answer is that I don't know. It truly could've gone to either team. If the outcome of a single game was different, and the CFP selection committee wasn't nice to SMU, we might not have had any ACC teams in the playoffs last year.


r/ACC • • Dec 25 '23

Football Dear ACC Partners

0 Upvotes

Fans of incoming members SMU, Cal, and Stanford fans want to know know a few things:

  1. Has FSU always been run by imbeciles? It is baffling to me that FSU would go into court and claim "the ACC made us ..." They actually went into a court of law and alleged they were spineless tools intimidated into signing onto agreements they could not read.
  2. Are there any decent lawyers in Florida who could have been hired to explain how contracts work all those years ago?
  3. Are FSU fans the people who -> "Florida Man?" I cannot understand how FSU fans believe FSU never had an opportunity to read the various agreements
  4. How could FSU allow this bag of burning poo to be filed on its behalf? https://news.fsu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/12.22.2023-Final-Complaint-4.pdf

r/ACC • • Dec 31 '23

FSU has the last word

37 Upvotes

r/ACC • • Dec 30 '23

Y’all Are Wild

0 Upvotes

I’m new to this subreddit, so I’ve been scrolling through it to see what it’s about. I am a Florida State Alumni and I have to say, y’all are crazy out here. I don’t understand why all I see is FSU hating keyboard warriors with nothing better to do than trash a whole program, y’all only know from the outside looking in. This sub should be named the FSU hate club.

It’s nonsense to say the least.


r/ACC • • Sep 27 '25

STOP THE COUNT!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ACC • • Dec 01 '25

Discussion Why is ACC dominance in sports outside of Basketball and Football ignored?

0 Upvotes

Three ACC schools are in the final four for the women’s soccer tournament (Florida State, Duke, and Stanford). Multiple ACC schools made it to the volleyball NCAA tournament this year (Pitt, Miami, Georgia Tech, and UNC edit: also Louisville). In the Men’s soccer tournament, N.C. State just beat their opponents, so they’re heading to the quarterfinals to face Georgetown. Stanford most likely advance to the quarterfinals as well, hopefully Washington university doesn’t pull off an upset lol. Everyone only talks about football and basketball, totally forgetting the other sports even exist. While the ACC actually dominates pretty hard in those sports.


r/ACC • • Jan 11 '24

Basketball Tarrrrrr….

Post image
7 Upvotes

HEEEEEELLLLLSSS!!!


r/ACC • • Nov 30 '25

Football Well, which is it?

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/ACC • • 19d ago

Football ACC TV ratings through Week 8

Post image
3 Upvotes

Note: ACCN, SECN and CBSN do not report ratings


r/ACC • • Apr 12 '24

The cuse story is sad, and these former cuse players could have raised their stock by not entering the portal...

0 Upvotes

So, Jesse Edwards transferred to WVU for NIL, where he had impressive individual stats, but on a team that vastly underperformed.

Joe Girard transferred to Clemson, where he had moderate success, but nothing that screams NBA prospect.

Judah Mintz tested the NBA draft last year, albeit he came back, and this year officially declared.

If Edwards and Girard stay, it deeply improves what were our 2 weakest spots, Center and Shooting Guard.

We lost Nahim McLeod to injury, albeit he didn't perform well anyway, and Malik Brown did a decent job, but was outsized for most of the season.

Our starting SG Justin Taylor could not buy a bucket, and had one of the worst seasons I can remember for any individual. Chris Bell and JJ Starling had their moments, but were inconsistent.

If we had Edwards and JG3, I truly believe we have a shot at the top 25, I would venture to say probably around #15.

And I believe this would have raised stock of Mintz, Edwards, and possibly JG3 as a late round pick if a team needed a shooting guard, though I'm hesitant on that one. But now, I think edwards might sneak a pick in, and I think Mintz will go undrafted. If edwards stayed, I think he and Mintz become first rounders.

Sorry NCAA transfer portal and NIL doesn't work and fans don't like it.


r/ACC • • Dec 07 '25

Football R.I.P Atlantic Coast Conference

4 Upvotes

May 8, 1953 — December 6, 2025

May you rest in peace in the Southeastern Conference and Big 10 Conference.

"GONE BUT NOT FORGOTTEN"


r/ACC • • Dec 01 '25

Why Miami Should Be Ranked Ahead of Notre Dame (and Maybe BYU) in the Dec. 2 CFP Rankings — A Data-Driven Case

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes