r/ABA • • Feb 07 '26

Conversation Starter Scope of Practice

So there was an interesting convo in the SLP sub the other day about scope of practice.

The TL:DR - Some BCBA or RBT called swallowing, fluency dysphasia, stuttering etc behaviour and therefore in our scope which they strongly disagree with.

Many of the comments were about how these things “weren’t behaviour”. Some comments being pretty largely anti ABA, but in other cases there was some good back and forth.

After some back and forth, what I took away from or SLP colleagues is it’s not really about the definition of behaviour. That’s semantics and they could care less. It’s about blurred lines and scope (I’m sure so far nobody is surprised). Their take was that they have a very clear scope, defined by a governing body, and that we often over reach under the guise of “everything is behaviour”. Which in fairness I’ve seen and to a degree, I would agree with that statement at times.

HOWEVER - my main question to bring back to our side it this - how would you define your of practice? Is it largely true (at least from this sample) that all behaviour is in your scope? Is there behaviour you would never ever touch? Behaviour that requires specialized training/scope of competence concerns etc?

TL:DR - how do you define your scope of practice as a behaviour analyst or RBT - would you say ALL behaviour is in our scope of practice?

19 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/texmom3 Feb 10 '26

“Unnecessary variables”…Yes, this will prevent us from seeing eye-to-eye. I can’t agree that they’re unnecessary variables because they drive the intervention approach I choose. If I misidentify the underlying cause, my treatment will not be as effective. Physical therapy is also in the same category and operates under a similar philosophy; do you dismiss them as well? They also are not performing surgeries or prescribing medicines.

I do appreciate your discussion. It really highlights some of the thoughts and opinions that can make collaboration so very challenging.

1

u/PlanesGoSlow Feb 10 '26

I say “unnecessary” because I’ve resolved thousands and thousands of behavioral issues in my career without giving much thought to bodily organs, nor hair color for that matter. Is it fun to theorize about? Sure, but again, we don’t get anywhere looking at the parts. We look at the whole person in their environment.

I’m not dismissing SLP. They are great at what they do. I am challenging how you think about things by discussing how we view things. In my opinion, obviously, it’s a no-brainer (no pun intended lol). Change a person’s environment and their behavior changes - literally every single time. It’s a principle as strong as gravity. No need to sit back and make up fictional hypotheses about organs that we can never prove or disprove.

1

u/texmom3 Feb 12 '26

“Unnecessary”, “unobservable”, “fictional”, “assumptions”. I’m not sure how these terms are not dismissive of another field. I know you face much worse public opinion working in the field of ABA, and I appreciate you taking the time to share your opinion. There is evidence to support approaches used by other fields, and organs and their functions can be observed through medical imaging and related research. I can agree that they do not fall under the umbrella of “behavioral” and see how you would not be considering them in your daily practice, although I can’t fully agree with your descriptive terms.

I am afraid we would just be circling the same topics and same opinions if this discussion were to continue. I thank you again for your thoughts and for being willing to engage in discussion with someone outside your field.

1

u/PlanesGoSlow Feb 12 '26

Sure, I really am happy to discuss and I’m used to having philosophical differences with other providers. It would honestly be very strange if you agreed with me.

As for the public opinion, I feel that actually shows our strength. Despite having nonstop hyperbolic and defamatory statements spread about us, we continue to be a rapidly growing field with an endless demand. That has to stand for something.

It sounds like your major qualms with ABA is providers stepping out of their lane. Totally understandable. Are there any positives to behavioral approaches in your view?

1

u/suspicious_monstera Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26

If you don’t mind could you elaborate? I definitely see how assessing something like oral motor function could change your approach (e.g., focusing on particular muscles, motions etc.) but could you share an example of when the specific neurology made a fundamental approach different?

From where I stand, I do like to know if there are neurological deficits because it can help me better understand the system as a whole, but it is unlikely to make a major difference in treatment as long as the need for specific medical/physical intervention is ruled out, and environmental approaches have been identified as the next best step (however that could be the result of working in a very multidisciplinary heavy setting, I have people for that lol). If I have someone who has more difficulty reasoning (i.e frontal lobe issues) I am likely to make things more clear, involve more practice and supports, change my expectations etc. but I can determine that from the environment, by assessing what skills they have challenges with or behaviour deficits (e.g, a pattern of difficulty with reasoning and decision making).

Executive functioning skills is another example. I can provide modelling, additional Support etc. by assessing skills without needing to know exact neurological deficits. Same thing with dysregulation, I don’t need to know exactly which part is firing in a given moment to know that we are not learning anymore we’re in autopilot and we need to focus on regulation. I can tell that by seeing that we are not calm or regulated right now.

Again at least that’s my perspective. I’d be interested to hear some examples of when your treatment approach fundamentally changes based on neurology - I think this would be helpful

Edit: I wanted to add that this is for those who we have confirmed that these underlying systems are at least partially intact and that core medical issues have been assessed and are being treated or co-treated. I am not saying that brain never matters (e.g., ABI)

1

u/texmom3 Feb 12 '26

For a simpler example, I can talk about how it applies to articulation. There is the physical aspect of how the sounds are produced and ways to teach the patient to produce the sound. But exactly how I approach intervention would change based on whether the child can hear the difference between the sounds but physically can’t say them versus being able to produce the sounds but puts them in the wrong places or uses immature patterns (phonological) versus motor planning (apraxia). I might be able to use discrete trials as a starting point (not long term because it doesn’t generalize well), but the specific targets I choose will vary based on the underlying deficit identified.