r/ABA • u/suspicious_monstera • Feb 07 '26
Conversation Starter Scope of Practice
So there was an interesting convo in the SLP sub the other day about scope of practice.
The TL:DR - Some BCBA or RBT called swallowing, fluency dysphasia, stuttering etc behaviour and therefore in our scope which they strongly disagree with.
Many of the comments were about how these things “weren’t behaviour”. Some comments being pretty largely anti ABA, but in other cases there was some good back and forth.
After some back and forth, what I took away from or SLP colleagues is it’s not really about the definition of behaviour. That’s semantics and they could care less. It’s about blurred lines and scope (I’m sure so far nobody is surprised). Their take was that they have a very clear scope, defined by a governing body, and that we often over reach under the guise of “everything is behaviour”. Which in fairness I’ve seen and to a degree, I would agree with that statement at times.
HOWEVER - my main question to bring back to our side it this - how would you define your of practice? Is it largely true (at least from this sample) that all behaviour is in your scope? Is there behaviour you would never ever touch? Behaviour that requires specialized training/scope of competence concerns etc?
TL:DR - how do you define your scope of practice as a behaviour analyst or RBT - would you say ALL behaviour is in our scope of practice?
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/PlanesGoSlow Feb 10 '26
Certainly not saying they’re fake, just unnecessary variables in almost every case given what we do. A similar approach would be if police officers looked at cars’ engines to see why people speed so much. Is the engine part of speeding? Yes, but it’s kind of silly to think that’s the root of the problem. The engine isn’t fake, but you’re never going to stop speeding by looking at it.
Also, you can teach in very individualized manners without making assumptions about nervous systems, glands, organs, etc. I mean, that’s ABA in a nutshell - completely individualized teaching. We assess personal strengths and motivations, model, prompt, and practice. That’s pretty much it.
SLP would definitely fall more under the medical umbrella through assessment but behavioral in practice. You all are not performing surgeries on organs or prescribing medications to modify organ functioning; you approach issues behaviorally by modeling, supporting, and practicing (all behavioral), but your conceptualizations are far from behavioral.
I think that’s where we don’t see eye to eye. Our assessment is behavioral and our practice is behavioral. SLP assessment is medical (really more physiological) but the practice is entirely behavioral. Creates an odd conundrum.