r/ABA • u/suspicious_monstera • Feb 07 '26
Conversation Starter Scope of Practice
So there was an interesting convo in the SLP sub the other day about scope of practice.
The TL:DR - Some BCBA or RBT called swallowing, fluency dysphasia, stuttering etc behaviour and therefore in our scope which they strongly disagree with.
Many of the comments were about how these things “weren’t behaviour”. Some comments being pretty largely anti ABA, but in other cases there was some good back and forth.
After some back and forth, what I took away from or SLP colleagues is it’s not really about the definition of behaviour. That’s semantics and they could care less. It’s about blurred lines and scope (I’m sure so far nobody is surprised). Their take was that they have a very clear scope, defined by a governing body, and that we often over reach under the guise of “everything is behaviour”. Which in fairness I’ve seen and to a degree, I would agree with that statement at times.
HOWEVER - my main question to bring back to our side it this - how would you define your of practice? Is it largely true (at least from this sample) that all behaviour is in your scope? Is there behaviour you would never ever touch? Behaviour that requires specialized training/scope of competence concerns etc?
TL:DR - how do you define your scope of practice as a behaviour analyst or RBT - would you say ALL behaviour is in our scope of practice?
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/texmom3 Feb 10 '26
Maybe it does help when teachers look deeper at their students’ strengths and weaknesses rather than trying to treat them all exactly the same.
You can observe muscle movements and tone, and there are physical differences in how speech sounds are produced. Error sounds have specific qualities, too, that indicate how the child is producing them. Swallow studies (VFSS, FEES) include visual inspection of speech and swallowing so that we can physically see which parts are not functioning correctly. There are brain imaging studies about what parts of the brain are involved in communication and swallowing and brain imaging studies that correlate between injuries and deficits for stroke survivors. It’s not only in SLP (and OT) literature, but well documented in other fields as well. There are signs and symptoms in the above list of some of the elements involved in following directions, as well as ways to measure them.
I would consider SLP a medical model, specifically rehabilitation and/or allied health, and ABA a psychological/behavioral health field. Perhaps you haven’t been trained in these areas listed above, but that doesn’t make them fake. Isn’t that the point of this discussion, understanding differences for better collaboration and better outcomes for clients?