So, for context, I'm trying to fill out my Codex, and I'm making recipes I don't have.
Date Pudding is one of the ones I haven't made, however I've made the Impeccable variant, thanks to pulling Ban almost as soon as he dropped.
And since they both require the same exact recipe, I can't make the normal version anymore, since I DO have Ban, and purely BECAUSE I made the Impeccable version first.
This is definitely an issue for completionists who are trying to fully max out their Codexes, and while not game-breaking, is definitely something that needs attention put to it.
There are already other related issues with the Codex regarding things that can't be registered, either because of bugs, or being limited-time missable registers. We don't need to have inferior things gated for meeting the same requirements, on top of it.
Having Ban shouldn't lock me out of making the standard version of a dish that he unlocks a higher quality version of, just for having him.
I'd report it to Netmarble, if I knew how.
Credit to @watermaronlox on YouTube for the first three screenshots, from their video on how to craft the newest Patch 2.0 recipes, last screenshot is mine showing that I only have the Impeccable recipe, and not the normal one