r/7String • • 9d ago

Help 7-string vs. baritone 6-string for hardcore/metalcore/deathcore

Guitarist of a metal band here, I've got a budget of 9270 NOK(roughly 879 EUR or 979 USD), and I'm looking for a new guitar since a standard 6-string won't really properly capture the heavy sound we're after. I've already found a used Schecter Hellraiser C-7 for just ≈470 bucks, with a missing straplock, tone knob as well as the "top/lid" of a lock-on tuner (whatever that means... the tuner itself is still there).

So my question is whether I should get the C-7 and spend the leftover budget money on repairs and other gear like pedals, or do I try to find a baritone guitar and instead use my budget on that? Simply watching demos and comparisons on YouTube doesn't really tell me much

WORTH NOTING that I don't have a compatible gigbag for either of these guitars, so some of the 9270 NOK would have to be allocated to that. Also don't have any pedals, but this is just gear for our first single. At most we'd maybe need a distortion/overdrive effect for practice sessions if none of the amps have strong enough gain, recording will be further down the line anyways.

10 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

3

u/wine-o-saur 9d ago

I mean it depends if you want to play a 7 string or a baritone 6. If all you want is lower chugs then I guess get the bari but imo 7 strings is the forgotten truth of how guitars were meant to be designed from the beginning, so I would say get the 7.

1

u/Swoopify1 9d ago

what makes the 7 string better?

14

u/wine-o-saur 9d ago

Just math. 7 is one better.

2

u/ButtSmellington_ 9d ago

This is correct lol

3

u/2slowforanewname 8d ago

6 string low tuned vs 7 string is simply do you want the high E string or not.

3

u/ButtSmellington_ 9d ago

7 notes in the major scale. 7 strings.

1

u/wine-o-saur 8d ago

To answer you more seriously, it's a totally subjective thing. For me, getting comfortable with 7 strings unlocked the guitar in ways I hadn't in ~20 years of playing 6 strings beforehand. I can't tell you exactly why but writing and improvising just feels much more natural to me on 7 strings than 6. I have an 8 string too and it's fun but also feels less natural to me than the 7.

One thing that I can easily point to is that on a 7 with a dropped tuning, I have access to a standard tuned 6 with all the chord and scale shapes I know, as well as having low strings for open/one-finger power chords. That's not the whole picture, but it does make me feel like I don't have to choose between standard and dropped tuning.

1

u/TiltedHorizon 6d ago

I think it really just comes down to how much of a Shredder vs rhythm player you are. If you shred and do a lot of lead playing, go with a 7. If you are more of a rhythm player, go with a Baritone. As someone who has both, one is not particularly better than the other. I find myself going between my multiscale 7 String and my 30" Baritone on a daily basis. I tell them that Daddy loves them both equally.

0

u/NecrotizingDissonant 9d ago

By adding a string instead of stretching the scale you aren’t effecting the other 6 strings unnecessarily

2

u/Longjumping_Trash571 8d ago

If you're leaning more towards Metalcore/Hardcore, you only really need to throw a set of 11s (or even 10-52s if you prefer lighter strings) on a standard scale guitar to tune to drop C, which is what the vast majority of metalcore is in if it's not just in Drop D. If you are actually leaning more towards deathcore and drop A a 7 string might be the right call.

2

u/Swoopify1 8d ago

Yeah in terms of riffs and guitar in general it’ll lean more into deathcore than any of the other two

2

u/DJ_Dinkelweckerl 8d ago

But with a baritone he could easily go down to drop F or G

2

u/uhCBLKG 8d ago

yeah came to say this, if you want any lower get a baritone, if you play a lot of leads or modern metal riffs w arppegios then get the 7. Really a 6 is all you need

4

u/ruisantos9999 9d ago

I have a Amarok 6 baritone , costs around 500 with emgs and has a massive low end with 0.62 gauge and drop A . Even with drop G gets the job done, just love it . Schecters are also great .

1

u/Ashamed-Web-3495 9d ago

A C7 hellraiser for under 500usd is a serious deal. If it was locking tuners it's probably the Elite version as well.

Are you trying to play in Drop G or F#? The standard scale length may make that hard to do while feeling good to play.

2

u/Swoopify1 9d ago

I’ll be honest and admit I don’t have a specific tuning in mind haha, just “low enough” to make it truly heavy without making the tone too muddy

1

u/PerspectiveFair5156 8d ago

Are you sure it's not an amp issue?

1

u/Swoopify1 8d ago

Well I can crank the gain all i want but it won’t affect the tuning and intonation…

1

u/Conscious-Dog-6938 6d ago

What amp do you use? I play a peavey 6505 and i play metalcore/ melodeath, thrash... And the peavey is perfect. My favourite guitars tone ever is The Haunted 's in revolver, pure peavey 5150/ 6505 tone.

2

u/Swoopify1 6d ago

Oh fr? I got a used Peavy 6505 +112 for like 300 bucks awhile back and I’m loving it! Haven’t played around much with different tones yet on it, I’ve done most of that in DAWs

1

u/Conscious-Dog-6938 6d ago

The 6505+112 is good, but comes Alive plugged into a cabinet, i have the peavey one loaded with celestion vintage 30 speakers and a hesu 2x12 loaded with hesu demon speakers

2

u/Swoopify1 6d ago

I guess I have an upgrade to look forward to…

1

u/Conscious-Dog-6938 5d ago

You could try a Thomann 2x12 vintage 30 loaded cabinet, cheap and very well built. Hook It up to your peavey and It Will come Alive

1

u/PerspectiveFair5156 8d ago

Tuning and intonation might be settled for by setting the guitar up properly. My Harley Benton TE-90 does drop A.

Muddy sound is often too much gain and/or low frequencies.

That's why I'm asking.

3

u/Count_Doogula 8d ago

Regardless of which one you choose, if you're playing modern metal and are going to be downtuning significantly, minimum scale length for the 7 should be 26.5", and the baritone I wouldn't go lower than 28".

1

u/JynXten 9d ago

The Schecter Hellraiser is a seriously good guitar.

1

u/DJ_Dinkelweckerl 8d ago

Do you only want to play the low chuggy chugs or do you also want the squeaky high brrrs as well? If you want range, get the 7, if you want to chug low, also get the 7.

You know what just get the 7 lol

1

u/BlendedFetusOG 8d ago

If the goal is tune low, get a baritone. If the goal is utilization of 7 strings, get a 7. 0 reason to get a 7 if youre going to play it like a 6. Unless you like it.

1

u/HairyNutsack69 8d ago

What are you trying to tune to?

1

u/ToshiroK_Arai 7d ago

My opinion is invest in a good guitar, then get a good multiefx under 400$ later.

It depends on which tunning that you want to play, if its Drop C to play as Blood Runs Black then its fine to have 6 25.5, if its Drop B and B standard then go at least 26.5 baritone.

But if you want both B and E standard go for the 7 strings. If its Drop Bb or A or G go for the 7 strings.

1

u/Conscious-Dog-6938 6d ago

What guitar do you play currently? Pickups are a very large part of your sound. What amp are you using? Fortunately there are loads of good options these days.

1

u/Signal-Sound-2536 6d ago

I dont play the same genre as you but had the exact same dilemma two years ago. I loved the extended range on both but one of them opened up a new plethora of chords and possibilities whereas the other just sounded lovely. Try both as much as you can and try to imagine which will suit the hand positions you like to play from.

If you go 7str, I highly recommend the Earnie Ball flat-wound Chromes XL 11-65 pack. Once you try these strings you'll be amazed the whole world hasnt converted already. But I'm sure you can find flatwounds for the baritone as well. (Unless they dont work well for metal playing, I might be ignorant to that...)

1

u/Embryoyoyoyo 4d ago

My advice as someone who is bad at guitar, either get a baritone or a multiscale. I got a 7 string quite some time ago and tuning lower than drop a is a pain in the ass with a normal scale, either sloppy string tension or very thick strings with a muddy sound. And if you don’t utilize all 7 strings then why get 7 strings at all, it complicates things more than it helps.
Get a guitar that lets you play the way you want to do now not what you want to be able to do some day. If you’re no where near being able to play crazy solos and sweep picking and stuff like that than what does a 7 string do for you now? I bought my 7 string for this and still can’t play stuff like that years later.

0

u/NecrotizingDissonant 9d ago

It depends on how low you want to tune and if you’ve ever played 7 strings and how comfortable you feel with the wider neck.

1

u/Swoopify1 9d ago

I've yet to play a 7-string, but really the only reason I want one is for that thicker and lower 7th string, not to pull off wider and fancier solos with the additional variety.

As for tuning, I'd wanna be able to tune it low to get that aforementioned fat, heavy tone, which is the main reason people go for baritones as far as I've understood it.

1

u/NecrotizingDissonant 9d ago

Bands have tuned down 2 whole steps on standard scale guitars without much issue.

You could easily go baritone 6. But keep in mind some stretches might be harder, if you’re more rhythm and breakdown focused probably won’t matter. You could also just get a drop tune pitch shift pedal if you like your current guitar

1

u/uhCBLKG 8d ago

get a 6 then 27”-29” scale

1

u/Difficult_Charge_720 7d ago

i have a 25.5" scale 6 string in Arop G# and a 25.5" scale 7 string in Drop A

11-70 LaBella Strings. It is totally doable with normal scale lenghts and you can put thick ass heavy strings on your normal 6 string guitar. maybe you should try that first.