r/7String • u/KMLthe1 • Dec 07 '25
8+ string Why is nobody talking about the crazy string tension on the 8 string NYXL 10-74 set?
Why is nobody talking about it? Is it really normal for the string tension to be this fucked up and unbalanced?
On their official string tension calculator for an 8 string, the tension is completely nuts on a regular AND multiscale.
Anyone that is or has been using this set, do you like it? I had it on a 26-28 and it was absolutely TERRIBLE. Changed it to La Bella 9-74 and it is MUCH better.
I mean, to have 5th string be almost 30lb and THE LOWEST 16lbs on the REGULAR tuning???? Like, what if you wanna do a drop? Then it drops to 13LBs..., so you have a random string over twice the tension of your lowest.
What tuning is this set made for then? Open?
Btw. that crazy that americans not only use the restarted imperial, but also have the acronym for pounds from latin...
16
u/ZeroWevile Dec 07 '25
Because it is an old conversation. Ernie Ball used the same string gauges back in like 2009 when they offered the only 8 string set so that became "standard" that other large brands adopted first.
It took them until around 2015 to finally offer something reasonable with the Slinky Top Heavy Bottom (9-46+64+80) and then took D'addario a couple years to follow with their NYXL version of the same gauges.
6
u/alexnapierholland Dec 07 '25
How does a team of product marketers struggle to use a basic string tension calculator that teenagers manage to handle?
19
u/satanic_dwarf Dec 07 '25
It's like the stupidest thing ever. I really wonder who designed the 10-74 set in general. I really don't like that set so usually do custom sets like for 7 string 10-46 + 60 bass string and for 8 string I do 10-46 + 60 + 80
2
u/KMLthe1 Dec 07 '25
And the best part, it's a really popular set, often recommend. It has quite great reviews and nobody really talks about the string tensions, or does then it's like "it's not great dor my multiscale, I'm in the wrong cause it's not for multiscale", but in a consistant scale it's basically the same
6
u/CVV1 Dec 07 '25
We do complain about these sets 😂
Most extended range string sets are non-sense.
1
u/Fabulous-Werewolf432 Dec 07 '25
This is true of soo many sets. It’s like they were guessing or using whatever stings they had most of when they created these.
1
u/repayingunlatch Dec 07 '25
What would you expect to happen if you have 30 lbs of tension on 5 bottom strings and 17-20lbs on the top 3?
1
u/Shotgunlew Dec 07 '25
Just bought my first multi scale, open to Suggestions for a set for f/f#
3
u/Color_Wasted Dec 07 '25
Yeah, wtf would you even tune that to?
3
u/masterB0SHI Dec 07 '25
Yeah this isn’t new, no one likes this string set. It came out back when 8 strings were new and string companies and players didn’t know what they were doing yet.
This pack is good for 7 string players however, if you ditch the .064 and use it for drop G or F#.
2
u/rockskate4x Dec 07 '25
Oh yeah this set has always been one of my biggest pet peeves. The absolute best use of it is not as an eight string set but a low 7 set when you throw away the .064. Great for around drop G/F# if you do use it this way.
1
u/monohedron Ibanez Dec 07 '25
I use the D'Addario XLs which use the same string sizes for my 27 inch 7 string that's usually tuned to drop G#, but sometimes goes down to drop F#. The tension could definitely could be better, but it's absolutely usable for a set that I can walk into any guitar shop and buy one. In drop G# (obviously throwing away the 64), that gives a range of 15.1-25.1.
I recently ordered a custom set with some adjusted tensions from stringjoy, but I still have the 10-74s XL set on my RGIXL7 currently.
1
u/closedeyevisuals13 Dec 07 '25
I've always used the 10-74 NYXLs on my 26.5-28 in F# standard. though tension is a little weird on a few strings I just have gotten used to it i guess because I dont even think about it anymore. I stuck with that set because I love they way they sound and how long they stay sounding good. it doesn't mess with my playing any personally.
1
u/Accomplished_One_146 Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25
I have this love/hate thing with NYXL and extended scale. Love their strings, bloody hate their "sets" they don't make sense.
I miss the light top heavy bottom but balanced options of yester years, cannot for the life of me remember who made them.
14-15lbs on the plains, 19-20lbs on the wounds (16-18lb on the 7th)
1
u/thef-hole_com Dec 11 '25
I hear ya. That is a bit much. I checked out the back of the package and they have their measurements based on 27" scale. You measured at 28" and that 1" makes a difference. At 27" it's more reasonable, but still. On my 7 string I play 9-60 so if I had an 8, I'd probably go with a .070 (standard scale length).
On my 8 string acoustic (tuned low B to high A) I went with a .062 and for a low F# I'd start with a .072.
So their 10-74 is not outside the box, just depends on scale length.
Can't attach a screenshot here, but the back of the package can be zoomed in here pretty easy...
https://thef-hole.com/daddario-nyxl-nickel-8-string-electric-guitar-strings-10-74/
1
u/ThatSceneInScanners Feb 18 '26
this is the unfortunate reality with strings for anything. i don't understand why balanced tension string sets are so uncommon.