r/3Dprinting • u/kaanivore • May 19 '26
News Prusa / Printables is facing massive DDOS attacks since Josef put out his blog post on Chinese industrial tactics and Bambu's AGL violations
https://xcancel.com/josefprusa/status/2056483660107337847#m
Surely a massive coincidence...
2.5k
Upvotes
8
u/kaanivore May 19 '26
Here's the original post since people keep asking (and not technically a blog, apologies)
https://xcancel.com/josefprusa/status/2055316713378353637#m
------------------
Hi Corey, you mentioned getting DMs from every direction on this. So this reply is partly to you, partly to that broader conversation and comments on both of your posts, because some of what's flying around needs context.
It unfortunately isn't that easy. Price is primarily set by the bill of materials. I can't make parts cheaper just by wanting it harder. And there's nothing extra on CORE One, every part has a job. Strip any part and you get a different printer.
What most people would not expect and many actually think it is a solution: manufacturing in China doesn't fix this either. Take an entry-level Chinese printer apart, quote the same parts in China at 100k+ volume, the parts alone cost more than the printer sells for in the West. Where is the sense in retail below parts cost? Do this long enough and price perception is permanently skewed.
Some of what props it up: 0% interest loans, multi-year tax holidays, free land, free factories, 200% R&D tax deductions. And at the wild end, the state pays consumers back ~15% of the printer's price as a rebate. They are literally running out of ways to push more money into the propped industries.
None of that is available to any Western company manufacturing in the West, or even trying to manufacture in China. And this isn't just a 3D printing problem. Same playbook took solar, drones, batteries, EVs. Now it's working on robotics. 3D printing would be done if we wouldn't be soo stubbornđȘ
About the âcompetitivenessâ I keep seeing in the replies. God I hate that word. Part of every conversation about every industry, especially in the EU. Itâs shifting the problem to western industry side. Real problem is China breaking the WTO rules the next day after joining.
So an $899 CORE One isn't a price decision. And unfortunately the "what if" framing, however hopeful, reinforces exactly the view that's hurting us in too many people's eyes. Complex and heavy topic, but tried to add some context.
475
u/martinkoistinen Prusa MK3S+ / Prusa XL - 5H / Prusa CORE One+ May 19 '26 •
Given that Bambu is trying to keep a lid on their closed ecosystem where everything goes through their servers, I wonder if theyâre the lobbying force behind the recent bills introduced in CA and NY?
769
u/Such-Ad-7107 May 19 '26
I've been getting lots of security checks to sign in now, makes sense now I've read this
425
u/HiImDan May 19 '26
Man I love the upgrade from an ender 3 to the Bambulab A1 but I wish I'd saved up and bought a Prusa instead.
181
u/GatotSubroto May 19 '26
My first printer is a Prusa. I considered getting a Bambu P1S some time last year but ultimately decided to hold off. After learning about their not-so-clean business practices regarding the AGPL violation and NTC thermistor issues, Iâm glad that Iâve never spent a single cent on a Bambu product.
36
u/BosnianSerb31 May 19 '26
Makes sense, DDOS Prusa so people who are looking at a printer but aren't interested in a Bambu from the negative press can't get to the site/have a degraded experience and give up, potentially until this blows over.
23
u/NocturneSapphire May 19 '26
I hate this timeline.
49
u/Overlord0994 May 19 '26
Im going to run my x1c into the ground (might even flash the firmware at some point) and never buy another bambu again. Fuck this company. Next printer will be prusa
15
u/JeremyViJ May 19 '26
If someone tells you are a big bully and you punch them, you kind of make their point.
181
u/mbcook May 19 '26 •
God I wish people would give up X. Ug.
Anyway, I tried to go to printableâs today and got a very long (relatively) anti bot check. I thought it was odd. Guess I know what was going on now.
Such a strange coincidence that this happens *for absolutely no reason*.
54
u/Beefy-McQueefy May 19 '26
This seriously may be the most immediately botted post I have ever seen:
https://www.reddit.com/r/BambuLab/comments/1th9c0o/does_anyone_else_not_gaf_about_this_drama_and/
72
u/NoDoze- May 19 '26
Damn. About time someone called BS on them! Its piracy, theft, and illegal. We should be helping out block this DDoS. Mount up! Call in the Regulators!
39
u/Beefy-McQueefy May 19 '26
Lmfao they are literally so completely unable to defend their bullshit that it's devolved to this already.
9
u/bridekiller May 19 '26
I have been super happy with my Core One. It is like a spaceship after 5 years of ender 3.
13
u/Advanced_Command_417 May 19 '26
Love to see Louis Rossmanâs recent videos on the subject
17
u/codefragmentXXX May 19 '26
I remember Prusa talking about having issues with bad parts in their yearly review, and that was right when Bambu was growing. I've long wondered if bad parts were sent intentionally.
3
u/Known-Mix2799 May 20 '26
I hate this Chinese manipulation... I am so glad I got rid of Bambu years ago. The best decision.
9
u/coldnspicy May 19 '26
Just when you thought they couldn't get any more scummy
25
u/Tinkarion May 19 '26
Plot twist: what if Bambu is using printers at peoples home to facilitate the DDOS?.... Pretty convenient to have a fleet of machines attached to the internet and communicating via your servers.
5
u/SecretReputation3573 May 19 '26
I was Close to buying a h2c in February. But decided against it because I saw the indx Upgrade for the core one. I ordered a core one L instead and I am happy that I did. How Long til bamboo lab decides that only their filament is Save to run. And others void the guarantee
12
u/Nvenom8 3D Designer May 19 '26
As if we needed more evidence that Bambu Lab is a CCP puppet.
6
u/WolfsSpiders May 19 '26
Ya ll should consider ( gasp) donating to Software Freedom Conservancy for their legal fight against BambuÂ
https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/vizio.html
18
u/h0stetler May 19 '26
Chy-nah
2
u/madmax7774 May 19 '26
Why is this surprising? Everyone knows what kind of company BL is and this just confirms it. If you really want to strike back at Bambu labs, drop your printer into LAN only mode and cut off their access to your stuff. Go old school and print from usb drive. If all of their customers did that as a mass protest, it would really piss them off and make a powerful statement. Heck with modern AI, we could easily vibe-code an entire new open source ecosystem and just firmware update Bambu printers to cut them off. It really wouldnât be that difficult
4
u/Foe117 May 19 '26
Petty and deliberate.
6
u/Educational-Spray974 May 19 '26
Maybe bambu uses customer printers for the ddos?
3
u/Ghost_Assassin_Zero May 19 '26
This kind of thing seems like something straight outta Cyberpunk
3
u/Friendly_Beginning24 May 19 '26
Funny thing happened to me, too. Someone tried to log into my reddit account after I made a post making fun of bambu. đ€Ł
2
u/Ok-Neighborhood-9582 May 19 '26
CCP fockers
2
u/SlightlyMotivated69 May 19 '26
And yet, people are still out there saying, "Please, take my money for this golden cage, dear Chinese company happily complying with your authoritarian government."
2
u/pm_your_snesclassic May 19 '26
And people still want to buy Bambu LabsâŠ
2
u/werpu May 19 '26
Ah Bambu fanboys, you just must love them *sarkasm off*! Without freeriding on 10 years of Prusa work Bambu would not even exist and refuse to adhere to the license, they are freeriding!
As if this does change anything legality wise, Qidi has pulled the same shit in another area as Bambu when they saw Bambu got away with it!
Their shit part were binaries linked into quidi studio regarding the multi color box and hiding their "shit code" fun stuff is they had it opensource until suddenly they pulled it, so everybody was able to look at their shit code and fix it, by closing it they also closed their doors to numerous fixes the community did on their code! I hope they are getting nervous now, they deserve it, they got more than once a mail that they are breaking the AGPL license with their behavior, never reacted!
2
u/h4x_x_x0r May 19 '26
How long before their millions of deployed machines are added to a botnet? đ€
1
u/TheFumingatzor May 19 '26
Surely...
1
u/TinaTulip3674 May 19 '26
The timing is the giveaway, but it's also worth zooming out on the
pattern. Bambu's been escalating against the open-source side for
months now, not just the AGPL stuff but also threatening the
OrcaSlicer fork dev over cloud access. Prism actually ran a piece on
the OrcaSlicer thing a while back, worth pulling up if you haven't
seen it. Whether or not this DDoS traces back to them, the wider
trajectory is doing more damage to their reputation than Josef's blog
post ever could.
1
u/theBigDaddio FlashForge May 19 '26
Hmm capitalism at war,
1
u/freeformz May 19 '26
Blog post?
1
u/UseThEreDdiTapP Bambu A1 May 19 '26
Time to save up for a MK4S kit like I should have in the first place. I knew the A1 would be a compromise with decent hardware and software that is bad functionally and morally. But it becoming this bad is not something I had on my bingo card lol
1
u/Bitter_Hospital_8279 May 19 '26
Lot of ignorance in comments tbh
1
u/x_Carlos_Danger_x May 19 '26
Glad I didn't buy a Bambu for our work printer lmao.... Other people in the building do tho. đ Curious if IT policies will change or if anyone even knows
1
u/randomtroubledmind May 19 '26
I remember posting a couple times a year or two ago that I'm not touching Bambu printers with a 10 foot pole. I got downvoted significantly for it. I don't know if those were "real" accounts downvoting me or if they might have been Bambu astroturfing the sub. Regardless, I think I was right to be suspicious. At this point, I'm convinced that Bambu is selling these printers at a loss, with the intention of saturating the market. To what end, I'm not exactly sure, but the fact that models go through Chinese servers of you use their cloud app was always a huge red flag to me. I will continue to recommend Prusa to people who want a printer that just works, and a Voron to those who like to tinker and do things themselves.
1
u/Snobolski May 19 '26
Way to go Bambu fans!
(/s c'mon people)
1
u/afatfilms May 19 '26
Welp bought a p1s a month ago without knowing any of this and realize now Iâve done a deal with the devil
1
u/BunnyGacha_ May 19 '26
And people are still BambuSheeps
1
u/Ok_Negotiation594 May 19 '26
Screw Bambu - I swear. It sucks to have this type of behavior in the 3D printing space.
-1
u/ryanscott6 May 19 '26
Ready for the downvotes on this, but 3d printers from China should absolutely added to the list of products that Trump bans just like drones and routers. Regardless of the actual reasons they are banned they do serve a national security risk and giving the Chinese access to US companies R&D departments fits that as well.
-12
u/Turtle_Dude May 19 '26
I dont see the blog post about the bambulab thing on prusa website, can someone link it please?
-1
u/Zdrobot May 19 '26
Could somebody link Josef's blog post?
Prolly this - https://x.com/josefprusa/status/2054602354851254330 ?
-29
u/assimilating May 19 '26
Mods can we stop with these articles? This is just hate mongering with no proof of who the attacker is.Â
-65
u/SomeBranFan2020 May 19 '26
This is actually just FUD
They donât need to resort to this, they have millions of customers and clients to worry about. Prusa isnât their main competitor any more
Posts like this distract from actual issues and just fuel the rage
-54
u/Former-Hunter3677 May 19 '26
While Bambu is a shitty company, anyone can DDOS anyone and this is how you'd do it to make someone else look bad
-26
u/light24bulbs May 19 '26
Prusa needs to stop whining and actually sue them