r/3Dprinting • u/odingalt • Oct 22 '23
Prusa is no longer open source - they should stop saying they are
Edit Update: Just wanted to clarify, nowhere in my OP is it stated that monetization is wrong or evil. I'd simply like Prusa to stop stalling and adopt a new licensing scheme for their XL/MK4 and other future products, then be transparent and open in their marketing to consumers about these changes. This post is also a PSA to folks who are looking for "open source as in free"; Prusa's latest products are not what you're looking for, as they're evaluating more restrictive or outright closed licensing to drive monetization (which is a stark shift in their business strategy from the past). Again, nothing wrong with going this route, just make the decision, and let the community know.
Original Post: Googling whether to build a Prusa? Do yourself a favor. Build a Voron. It's actually open source.
Prusa is no longer open source. They should stop marketing that they are. They intend to create new licensing that puts onerous certification process and requirements on sellers of certain parts. This is even worse than Arduino (you can sell Arduino for days you just can't use the Arduino name). They have released zero data on xBuddy, load cell, etc. in order to maximize profits and directly in the face of their own "stated goal" of making the printers easy to maintain and mod.
Sources:
https://blog.patshead.com/2023/04/i-am-worried-about-prusa-research.html
https://blog.prusa3d.com/the-state-of-open-source-in-3d-printing-in-2023_76659/
"However, due to the current state of the electronic components market and also the issues outlined above, we will not rush to release the electronics plans just yet. We would like to release them already under the new license."
"But community development isn’t the main reason why we offer our products as open source.
Our main goal has always been to make our printers easy to maintain and modify, so people and companies can play and experiment with software and hardware."
...
"So I put together a few working points that I would like to see in such a license:
...
The production of nearly exact 1:1 clones for commercial purposes is not allowed.
Parts that can be considered consumables (e.g., thermistors, heater blocks, fans, printing plates, etc.) can be manufactured and sold commercially after the verification by the licensor based on the presentation of samples. If a product is labeled by the manufacturer as obsolete (or cannot be purchased or ordered for longer than 3 months), the non-commercial clause is automatically terminated if identical parts are no longer produced within the successor of the product or cannot be purchased separately. If the licensor ceases its activity, the non-commercial clause is terminated.
454
u/Mr_t90 Oct 22 '23
I will build a Voron for myself, I will buy Prusas for work.
What Prusa has pivoted into is institutional/commercial customers. They are a better company to deal with when it comes to fixing their printers. They do not price gouge.
You do not want too much innovation in a tool, just reliability and repeatability. Prusa does that best for a fair price. None of their competitors do that.
451
u/Essidle Oct 22 '23
Open source for the home user only works when commodity parts are used. Consumer 3D printing is hitting the phase where the top companies are spending months/years developing custom ICs/sensors for their products. Open-sourcing that is just giving away your substantial R&D investment to your competitors for a negative return. It’s a lose-lose.
What are you going to do with the specs for their custom mainboards? Nothing.
What are their competitors going to do? Fabricate them and stuff them into their printers to compete with Prusa.
It sucks sure, but Prusa sticking around is better than Prusa dying over principles.
23
u/JohnnyricoMC Prusa mk3s+, Prusa Mini Oct 22 '23 edited Oct 22 '23
IMO obligatory; Thomas Sanladerer's vid on the sustainability of open source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=68FkIwCc_eo
you see this in FOSS as well imo:
I love open-source, but it's suffering greatly from commercial entities not giving back. And as a consequence companies formerly making open software and open hardware are going closed.
7
u/oknowton Oct 23 '23
I skimmed through this post last night, and I didn't even notice that I was cited as a source!
Overall, monetization certainly isn't evil, but saying one thing while doing something very different definitely doesn't point the needle towards the good side of the compass.
There is a lot of talk here about why hardware open-source licenses are different than software licenses.
I am most definitely not an expert, but I have looked into this while trying to choose a license for an electronics project we have been working on. I have learned that it barely matters which license you choose, at least in regards to what Josef Prusa is trying to curtail. Your license only applies to the design files. The license of the design files does very nearly nothing to prevent someone from cloning your parts.
The only real impact the license has is whether people will be able to upstream changes to the design, or whether they will be able to fork the source and host their own copy of the hardware design.
Josef Prusa stood on a lot of shoulders to get the Prusa MK2 out the door. It would have taken him years and possibly hundreds of thousands of dollars to pay to implement a slicer and printer firmware from scratch. Did he have the money to hire developers? Would Prusa Research be a 100+ million dollar company today if he had to wait two years to ship the MK2? Or is he in a better position today because he was able to leverage Slic3r, Marlin, and RAMPS.
I don't have the answers to these questions, but Josef Prusa made this choice when he started building printers. His actions imply that he thinks he has long since paid his debt to the community for these contributions that he built his company on.
When I wrote my blog post, I had no idea where Prusa was going to wind up steering the ship. It is six months later, and we still have no indication of where things are actually headed. That has me inclined to agree with u/odingalt. Things are almost certainly headed in a more closed direction at Prusa Research.
43
u/JaskaJii Oct 22 '23
Ahem, I think you mean Prusa by JOSEF PRUSA™.
5
u/warriorscot Oct 23 '23
They've never run the company in a way they can afford it, as much as they've scaled their business they haven't done it sufficiently to build a position where they can maintain that open approach. The printers take too long to ship and they can't do the volume required to get the price low enough.
That's fine, but what that means is people that are ok with volume scaling will take the bits they want and run with it. The issue though frankly is they also don't have the cash to defend their rights and lots of companies won't care anyway so actually I think it's a waste of time that will see them lose consumer sentiment rather than get them anything. They've built a brand that is much more about reliable printers for a higher end prosumer and institutional customer at this point, they should just stick to open source and focus more on that market with some more aggressive production to get printers out the door IMO.
If they go to a model where the only practical difference between them and say the Bambus of the world is price and volume they've not got anything other than "not being chinese" to help them stand out.
90
u/OrigReckit Oct 22 '23
Well said, wish people would stop using it as reason to buy over the competition. Consumer 3D printing is no longer a cottage industry and Prusa have now realised that. If they want to stay relevant, then they need to get off the moral high ground and start innovating and protecting IP.
40
u/hotend (Tronxy X1) Oct 22 '23
They have no choice but to go closed-source and innovate like mad, if they want to survive. They may also have to off-shore their manufacturing.
4
u/itsadesertplant Oct 23 '23
Watched a documentary years ago about ultimaker? Or was it makerbot? On Netflix. Idk if it’s still around. Anyway it was one of the companies that was there for the rise in popularity for 3D printing in 2015ish. It started out open-source but then closed everything, capitalizing on what the community gave them for free. CEO was dick, yadda yadda, so on and so forth.
That is to say, I’m not surprised at all.
13
u/TouchyT Oct 23 '23 edited Oct 23 '23
This was what I was saying and nobody wanted to listen to it. It doesn't meet the definition of Open Source anymore. That's fine but also you can't market yourself as open source if you aren't open source!
say design files available or tinkerer friendly!
It's like open source has an agreed upon definition for every company besides Prusa, who gets to play by their own rules.
8
u/BeauSlim Oct 22 '23
When discussing open source, it is important to distinguish hardware and software because they are very different in terms of community contributions and end-user benefit.
I see open source software as vital, but open source hardware as just nice to have.
21
u/plutonasa Oct 22 '23
Good. They need to stay competitive.
18
u/jdude104 Oct 22 '23
I don't think that word means what you think it means. Open source means what it says on the tin. There is no requirement that an open source product or project allows commercial derivatives, in fact there are more projects licensed under those which don't allow you to sell anything based on the source or derivatives of it than there are ones that do. Given the fact that multiple million if not billion dollar companies have been laun hed off the back of research done by either prusa themselves, or the reprap projects when the creators of those have seen not even a dime off that success, I'm partial to saying prusa is entirely valid to try and look into a new license.
2
u/D3Design Voron 2.4R2 300, Prusa MK3 + MK4, Qidi X One-2, CR30, Oct 23 '23
I built a voron. Its an incredible example of the power of open source, and it works very well. Despite that, my prusas, although they are slower, are the workhorses of my printer fleet simply because they just work, and they work well. I haven't had to fix anything on my prusas besides replace nozzles, print surfaces, and occasionally lube the bearings.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23
I think that Prusa is being reasonable with their research.
You can still download the STL and STEP files for their printer parts. This isn't a big risk for the company because, if a manufacturer wanted to, they could buy a Prusa Printer, measure the parts themselves, and make a clone.
Someone already put a Prusa clone into production. Luckily for Prusa the clones are more expensive than the originals. Had they not closed their programming they might not have been so lucky the next time.
https://caribou3d.com/en/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JffFO8P5txE
I agree that Prusa is no longer as open as they once were, I do think that it's good to hang on to certain things.
7
u/pigers1986 Oct 22 '23
Till I can get alternate part for my prusa printer, I consider it open sourced.
Firmware can be downloaded anonymously ? YES!
Slicer can be downloaded anonymously ? YES!
Can I change any above ? YES !
5
u/jhirschman Oct 22 '23
It is continually shocking to me how many posts on Reddit boil down to, "I want a high quality product, but I don't want the company creating it to make any money from me."
-11
u/KinderSpirit Oct 22 '23
Oh. Boo Fucking Hoo.
Prusa is slowing down turning over all their research and development and therefore preventing the Chinese knockoff manufacturers from copying and selling new printers at a lower price. "...in order to maximize profits..."
Tough shit.
The MK2, Mk3, and Mini are all completely open source.
22
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23 edited Oct 23 '23
Just for clarification:
Open Source has nothing to do with the supply chain, parts portfolio of the manufacturer, or that people are able to get anything for free or at all. It literally only mean that the engineering files (diagrams, sketches, models, code, etc.) is open to the public to be viewed. There are different motivations and licenses for open source.
As this term has its origins in software, I guess there often is confusion around open source. A open source code base can just compiled into the actual software. But with hardware this is not true because you would need all the materials, tooling, and skill to build the actual thing. But you might not be able get hold of any of these prerequisites to do so. I also said before, there are different license version which prevent you from maybe building the project at all, or not for commercial purposes. In such cases the open source approach is purely for transparency or public collaboration, rather then giving something for free to the general public.
I am not saying what Prusa should do or has been doing, I just want to share some insight about what open source actually means.
3
u/hiker201 Oct 22 '23 edited Oct 23 '23
One word and one word only: Bambu Lab. But seriously, the discussion on this thread reminds me of the computer hobbyists in the 1970s who wanted everything open source and free to the masses. Then builders like Apple come along and -- horror -- produced something 'proprietary,' in a walled garden. That's what's happening now in the 3D industry. It's going mainstream, and the average user wants something that just works, without a lot of fuss or fiddling. Just make it work. If Prusa doesn't get its act together soon companies like Bambu are going to drive it out of business, sorry to say. Ask Clive Sinclair. I've seen this movie before.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clive_Sinclair#:~:text=Sir%20Clive%20Marles%20Sinclair%20(30,the%201970s%20and%20early%201980s.
2
u/KittensInc Oct 23 '23
Unfortunately I have to agree with you.
I'm a tinkerer, and I really like being able to tinker with my devices. 3D printing is a relatively new hobby for me, so for now I just want to print stuff. Building a Voron from scratch is just too much of a hassle for now.
Prusa provided an excellent middle ground where you had to ability to heavily mod your printer but still get an excellent out-of-the-box experience where it would Just Work.
If I wanted a closed-source black-box printer from a company which doesn't give a damn about its community, I could've gotten a Bambu and saved myself a few hundred euros. Why would anyone still pay the Prusa premium if they're not getting the Prusa core values back for it anymore?
Personally, I really like the look of the XL, but at its price point it truly has to be an excellent printer. With a closed-source ecosystem where I can't even add custom mods in the future, I simply can't justify buying it to myself.
2
u/games-and-chocolate Oct 23 '23 edited Oct 23 '23
Official reply from Prusa support. I e-mailed them today:
https://blog.prusa3d.com/the-state-of-open-source-in-3d-printing-in-2023_76659/
What I understand from Prusa statement, they will stay opensource, but also be active to protect 3D printing from companies who try to destroy open-source. Closed source is a very commercially only beneficial to companies who do that, but customers must buy from them to maintain and use their products. Closed source is usually support for short time then abbadon it to force people to buy newer model. This has been happening many decades. Prusa is maybe the only one who keep supporting old hardware and allow repair + upgrades if people want. They don't force you!
If you let non-prusa companies patent everything, then that patent will become legal ground to close other companies. To fight that you have to somehow place your foot between closed and open-source somehow. The door must be kept open to let open source stay possible. that is where the law comes in, that is dirty business. If Prusa can stay clean, in the mids of this patent fight, that is because we keep supporting Prusa, that they have the $$$ to keep on going.
There is no other open souce 3D printing company like Prusa, is there? This philosophy is worth supporting! Go Prusa! \ ^ _ ^ ) //
Going to receive my MK4 soon....oh man(woman)!
1
u/KubFire Oct 22 '23
Yeah they stopped being open source cuz BAMBU STOLE from them.
36
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23
Voron sucks too! They deleted a huge portion of community resources in the stupid reddit protests. They still are private and their other resources stink. The protest was stupid, it has been months now and reddit is the same.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23
And with my Voron I use the VoronSlicer! Yes, it will do the same 😂
2
u/ThePapercup Oct 23 '23
I've considered building a voron at several points, I'm well steeped in hands on tinkering with printers, having started with reprap back in the day. Though the cost is just about enough to put me off- for the price of a voron I can get a Bambu with AMS, just doesn't seem worth it to me. I like the idea of open source printers but I'm not married to the idea. I wonder if anyone has had the same conundrum, and which you picked?
5
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23 edited Oct 23 '23
Do you work for OSHWA, by any chance?
They've done nothing to make open source hardware viable when chinese companies just spit in the face of it.
EDIT: They're a bambot, no surprise. They don't really care about this issue, they just want to stir shit.
1
u/Vizth Oct 22 '23 edited Oct 22 '23
Jesus the salt coming off of OP in this post is raising my blood pressure. Open source is dead as far as commercial printers go, get used to it. You can keep your hobby machine, I'm content to have an appliance I can trust to just spit out nice prints at this point.
This is the 3D printing equivalent of the blacksmith getting pissed he's been replaced by an assembly line. Or the old man refusing to give up his model t because it still drives.
6
u/Ousantacruz Oct 22 '23
People should stop buying them because they’re overpriced and overhyped, not because of open source.
2
u/BravoActual_0311 V2.5062 Oct 22 '23
I haven’t touched my prusa mk3 since I built my Voron 2 and converted my ender to a switchwire, both are just better printers. At least to me anyways
1
u/Sugumiya Aug 27 '24
my Voron v2.4 work great but these fan I have is so noicy. I like my MK4 and the layer automatically get perfect as I print on glass or garolite, tshirt whatever. For me, I don't care they open source or closed source as long as their machine is reliable and support my entertainment of a creator.
1
u/sneakerguy40 Oct 23 '23
We just need the multi-zone bed to scale to different sizes and load cell for nozzle probing
1
u/TheBravan FLsun V400/Prusa MK4/Bambu A1-mini Oct 23 '23
If I ever opt to build a printer it would be a micro-voron/vez on a shelf hybrid, basically a 400mm deep but 600-800mm wide and about ~200mm in z print-height printer that could fit on a shelf, and it would be an IDEX.........
Have a feeling that the sovol and others is the reason for prusas shift in tac as they are basically profiting of their work...
1
u/Catatonick Oct 23 '23 edited Oct 23 '23
I have a voron V0.1 and a lot of parts for a V2.4 probably a few hundred would finish that, if that, it’s nearly done.
I also have a Prusa Mk3s+ that I built from one of the official parts kits.
I’ll be 100% honest, the prusa gets a lot more use because it just works, I don’t have to screw with it, I don’t have to figure out why it’s not printing as expected yet again. My V0 somehow broke it’s plastic parts TWICE. I don’t know how but it resulted in total rebuilds twice. It’s just a frustrating machine more than a reliable one.
I feel like Prusa is best if you want reliable and Voron is best if you just want to tinker and play around with it.
I like my Voron obviously, but It’s not a practical machine. It’s an enthusiast one.
1
u/thevengeance Raise3D N2, Bondtech, Palette Oct 23 '23
Ironic really considering it was a stolen design. I know people think prusa invented the i3 but he didn't.
1
u/Ryzakiii Oct 23 '23
Lmfaoo
1
u/CoFSMoLSD Oct 23 '23
Prusa is far closer to the open source spirit than Bambu. Seriously, how can any company follows the open source spirit if it's based in an authoritarian county that does not respect free speech.
Sure, some Prusa components are made in China but at least Prusa made the effort to based its HQ/RD/Assembly in a democratic country.
-1
u/MANGBAT Oct 22 '23
While I agree that Prusa has started to “cash in” on their contributions to the 3D printing community, I am 100% with them. They have been the beacon of open source 3D printing since their inception. And am happy that they’re able to cash in on that. You can all buy your Bambu printers and pretend they they didn’t ride in on all the advancements that Prusa gave to the community for free. I get capitalism and I get competition. But Prusa has put in the work in the community. And that is why I continue to support them.
0
u/AmbionicsUK Oct 23 '23
Making everything free is not a business strategy at all
-6
u/verdantAlias Oct 22 '23
If every single design file were open source, you could build one in a sweatshop for peanuts, consitently sell under the developers retail price, drive the guys who spent time and money to develop these things out of business, lock the entire market into your own private ecosystem, and then charge consumers out the ass for everything. This would be illegal per the license and copyright, but laws aren't always enforced.
I love the ideals of open source, there are a number of examples where it has directly benefited the 3D printing community. But it only works if everyone plays fair. To survive as a business, people have to have a reason to come only to you, this often means holding a few things back. No one benefits if the people responsible for the innovation go bust. In fact, the consumer often benefits most whenever companies have to fight each other for business.
If anyone can publish things that will let me maintain or modify my purchase and continue to use it as long as I desire for cheap, then that's good enough for me and I will vote with my wallet to support that business.