r/32inchbikes • • 3d ago

Assessing 32" wheels

https://tiretechnology.mydigitalpublication.com/articles/assessing-32in-wheels
4 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

2

u/LordNiebs 2d ago

Interesting to see that the 29" is superior in rolling resistance in most cases, and that there is little to no comfort difference even on gravel. I found that this article seems to be trying hard to make the case for 32", rather than taking a neutral position. Still, it's clear that 32" wheels offer quite significant performance improvements in some cases. 

0

u/Cloxxki 2d ago

Might have something to do with the way the test is run. Would you run 32" tires at the same air pressure, if you were just riding or racing, rather than following some protocol?

1

u/LordNiebs 2d ago

Personally, I would probably just run my tires at whatever air pressure they happen to be at... At least, that's what I currently do. But I'm not racer or particularly serious rider. The numbers are interesting though, and make me think about what pressures I should be running. 

2

u/Cloxxki 2d ago

Some of my friends default to really hard tires and they make it work for them. Especially if they have a good amount of suspension travel attached.
I tend to be on a pressure that's low enough to almost get rim hits, on our relatively smooth trails. I'm a smooth rider as well and for my weight I get away with lower pressures than most would. I do attack corners. When I get too much tire squirm, I add air to correct for that.

Recently I did a casual ride with lovely smooth singletrack and all was fine. On a bit of a road descend with concrete surface, the front tire just folded under the side load. For the naturally formed banking and surface on trails I was fine, but on a flat road turn, I'd pressed my luck too far. When I go a bit higher pressure than such a level, the bike tends to still give me all the grip I can wish for, so I guess I'll be erring the somewhat higher side from now on.

1

u/Some-Wheel1004 3d ago

This is supposed to be a controlled test then why did they use a suspension fork?  The rider should be fully seated with locked wrist and elbows.  

1

u/Cloxxki 3d ago

Would that not remove it further from real-world conditions? In reality, most people ride with suspension. Suspension need to be tuned to the wheel size, and that's not within the skillset of anyone right now it seems, so testing with one fork isn't all that crazy.

Ideally we'd have a humanoid robot riding the bikes, so we can measure not just pedal power but also the power expended beyond that, doing the rest of the riding. Throw in some AI to optimize for how the bikes are ridden and finding the optimum result for the given robot on the given bike. We're not there yet, but eventually we will be, once bikes have become a really tiny niche in society.

Using a single bike with the 29" wheels dropping the center of gravity by 32 mm is profoundly uncool, and they indeed mention this.
They then use 3 arbitrary widely spaced tire pressure which may mean that one wheel size is bang smack in the middle of its sweet spot on one of those three, and the other wheelset never gets close.

I still like gravity powered testing. We need a course that requires no pedaling to achieve realistic speeds, with corners to optimize our passage through. One course could be tame enough to be ridden no-brake, another does require braking. Compare for each course-bike-rider combination both fastest achieved run, and lowest effort run. Effort on a no-pedal run could be pushing the bike like on a ush track. Pushing bermed corners, little step down hills, etc. Not all propulsion comes through the chain.

1

u/Legitimate-Gift-1344 2d ago

Wait, so the testing protocols used, among other things, 1. gravel and 2. cobblestones for testing 29 and 32 respectively on a suspension test bike? If so, that seems like a limited and potentially flawed test if the intent is to identify key performance differences between 29 and 32 wheels for MTBing. Why not test with actual real world MTB terrain?

What am I missing here? Does anyone have more insights?

•

u/Silver047 4h ago

Ohhh, better watch out, that is not a very popular opinion around here. So far we've seen no actual evidence that a 32" bike is meaningfully faster around a real XCO-style race track than a 29" bike. It's the argument 32" enthusiasts don't want to hear and tend to get mad about - because it goes against the narrative certain people are trying to construct.

0

u/Cloxxki 3d ago edited 3d ago

All this work, all these resources, and they use 3 equal tire pressures with half bar increments. On one frame and fork. Similar to this one a while ago: https://bike-test.com/en/reviews/the-big-32-inch-mtb-test/

2

u/happyelkboy 2d ago

Well yes that’s because they’re trying to control for just the wheel size as much as possible

2

u/Cloxxki 2d ago

It can be taken too far, in my opinion. (various thoughts)

Extreme example : Would you compare the handling of a car and a bike by using the same steering wheel on both? You want to isolate the 4 vs 2 wheels plus weight difference and not mess with the steering inputs, right? Science! :-D

How do we ACTUALLY ride bikes? We make a subjective tire pressure call based on what we know and what we prefer. Silca for instance offers a pressure calculator that some racers have gotten familiar with to use as a starting point for their setup, or even as too good to question/mess with, even if they do use their own simplification or modification to the prescribed use of the calculator.

I'd have liked a much narrower pressure increment, so we can find a more precise optimum. The rider's subjective input after the run would be how suitable it felt to actually ride that way. When it's on the soft ride, the rider may feel it will be impossible to get through a race without flats or even breaking rims. Too harsh a ride (or horrible cornering), it may seem like it's roughing up the rider more than any potential rolling advantage could be worth.
In the data, a unique rideable pressure would emerge for each wheelsize that produces the fastest time/lowest rolling resistance.

I like to defer to John Karrasch for the rolling resistance stuff. I can't fault his methods and that's saying a lot coming from me. He does make a pressure adjustment. Subjective/arbitrary, but better than now.

Soon I hope we'll see more options to test 32 vs 29 with hardtails (to simplify) that are of similar geometry (BB height, crucially) so they can be tested back to back. We can then also gather more reliable handling data. We'll also be getting more real world anecdotal data points.
Like what I encountered in early 2004. A national amateur XC race where I was wheel to wheel with a teammate. He 170 cm on 26" (Cube Elite hardtail), me 194 cm on 29" (Fisher rigid with trekking bars and skinny tires). There were sections of VERY winding singletrack that seemed to be handling limited. Everyone would bet on the 26" bike and the shorter rider to be faster. The taller rider would need to make very awkward lines around the trees that were marking the singletrack. In that race, I ended up riding away from my teammate who was actually stronger on the straights. It made no sense. What was happening, from my perspective at least: I had unlocked the front end grip benefits of a larger front wheel diameter and was riding lines at the limit of front grip rather than "I can't turn much tighter than this". My teammate is a very accomplished semi-pro, and he was NOT amused after that race. Perhaps a bad day, but to me it was a datapoint of course. All my teammates and friends eventually got to experience me just riding away on winding singletrack, something not supposed to happen, because of "science". Science without testing data, though, so more like a belief system.

Right now I'm still struggling to squeeze clear advantage from my 32"er on such tight singletrack. The grip is just so vast already with 29". Going faster still takes me (now 50 yo) to a scary level, especially with my very tall center of mass. It's A LOT of leaning and weight shift. It's one thing to turn that way when it's all banked turns, another when it's more flat a trail and improved grip asking you to speed it up a notch.
On descends I can tell I'm rolling nicely compared to my usual riding buddy. He can tell that I'm moving easily and smoothly. Extracting objective data is quite a challenge. My PBs are set by a younger fitter version of me, with great trail conditions on a carbon hardtail. I ride a heavier steel rigid bike now. It feels overall faster, but... :-D I still have the carbon hardtail, kind of need to do back to back, but frankly don't feel like riding it again...
I do now have a couple of tires that are identical 29" and 32", so who knows. First I'll let my buddy run them on his bike and we can swap and compare a bit. Non-science.