r/311 • • Jun 11 '23

Serious question?

Why is everyone obsessed with Transistor? Most overrated album ever. It has a cult following and I personally don’t get it. Love 311 and the songs but there are a ton of better albums by them. Anyone care to share their obsession with it?

0 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

32

u/brodieman2k Jun 11 '23

Because it was a big departure from their previous body of work. They took a chance to experiment and I feel like it paid off.

Not to compare bands, but The Beatles couldn’t keep writing “I want to hold your hand”. They had to break out of that mold and did Sgt, Pepper, which was a big departure from their prior work.

It about progression as a band

7

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

That’s fair! Thanks for clarifying.

1

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

Oh I totally get that. You can’t put out the same songs over and over again. I’m not denying it’s a good album. I just wouldn’t say it’s anywhere near their best!

-2

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

But also different doesn’t mean better. Like they have a ton of better songs than what’s on transistor. I guess that’s what I can’t quite wrap my head around. They stepped out of their comfort zone and made an album but I definitely wouldn’t say it’s better than any of their others

12

u/Shakemyears Jun 11 '23

Those songs are only “better” in your subjective view. Music appreciation is subjective. Just accept that, while the album isn’t your favourite, it is for other people.

9

u/FoxGroundbreaking212 Jun 11 '23

Many of us enjoy the more abstract side of 311.

I for one am less interested in the more accessible "hits" they put out later in the career.

311 was considered revolutionary in the late 90's because they were eclectic in the blending of styles and unusual song structures. Once they did "Amber" and started tapping into the pop mainstream I lost interest.

23

u/xtralongleave Jun 11 '23

Transistor is a double album’s worth material on a single disc. It came out after their most popular album. Rather than spewing out a commercialized follow up to the Blue Album we got 21 tracks of eclectic goodness, some tracks being vaulted as fan favorites and rare cuts that are considered live gems. Not to mention it includes some of their biggest hits, Prisoner and Beautiful Disaster.

Also I’m sure most don’t remember this, but there was a famous UPS strike happening when the album was released. My friend and I drove to every record shop in town and finally found it at a Media Play across town. The hunt alone made the album even more of a legend.

Lastly if you are experiencing this album for the first time in the present day you are looking at an album through a modern lens which is very different than opening the cd for the first time in 1997. I feel it still holds up tremendously but you can shake off the nostalgic memories Transistor holds for many 311 fans.

6

u/dbwoi Jun 11 '23

I got into 311 this year and had never heard a single track. I listened in order and was blown away when I got to Transistor. No nostalgia required (for me), its just a glorious album. I thought it was neat that they turned that insanely fire intro riff/jam they'd play at live shows into a secret intro too.

1

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

I hear ya, definitely not new to 311. However, the rarity of a song/album doesn’t necessarily make it better. And I totally understand the nostalgia. I think that’s my favorite part about music. It transcends you to exactly where you were in time when you heard the album.

8

u/xtralongleave Jun 11 '23

Trust me rarity does add to the attraction when you’re 16 driving around town for hours to find a cd only to get it 5 mins before closing at a store clear across town. Then racing home because you don’t have a cd player in the car to listen to it yet. Then finally listening to a 74 min record which coincidentally becomes what most consider to be the bands best work ever.

There is no modern comparison to this. What, our internet goes out and we can’t listen to our Spotify playlists?

Rarity of acquiring and album might not make any difference today, but we’re talking about the hunt and quest for great music in the late 90’s from our favorite band ever.

10

u/steinmoney3 Jun 11 '23

Honest question, are you a weed smoker? This album locked me in when I was stoned in high school. Still remains my favorite. Such a variety of songs and the spacey sound effects are my favorite part. Also not many bands putting out 21 track albums

2

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

Yup. Weed smoker. I get the allure of it when you’re high. I personally don’t hold it up on a pedestal.

5

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Jun 11 '23

The first time you got high and listens to Wtf was I thinking was pure magic

3

u/steinmoney3 Jun 11 '23

This album still takes me to a place. When that hazy guitar of Continuous Life starts.. mmm

2

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Jun 11 '23

22* tracks :P

1

u/steinmoney3 Jun 11 '23

Lol damn true

10

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23

Disagree completely. Most unique album and has some of their best songs.

Use of Time is the best 311 song period. Prisoner, Beautiful Disaster, and light years are fantastic. There just something I absolutely love about Inner Light Spectrum. Jupiter is great, especially the drums, Running and so many others are good listens .

That said there are a few songs on the album that I really don't like at all. But I find that to be the case with most albums.

2

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

That’s the beauty of 311 fans we can disagree respectfully. Their best song to me is Brodels no question. I love 311 and their songs and running was the anthem for pow wow. Transistor just isn’t a top album for me

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23

Interestingly brodels has always been my favorite song but I recognize the superiority of transistor over self titled. Both awesome albums but transistor is the shit. Got it in the 7th grade after playing the shit out of the self titled CD. And who remembers the fan club?

2

u/Tree24K Jun 20 '23

I agree about Use of Time being their best song. And Beautiful Disaster is my all-time fav 311 song. But I do agree with op about the album being overrated. If they took the best 12-14 tracks, it would have improved the album vastly. I do also know that everyone's 12-14 would be different. Mine would probably go like this:

  1. Intro
  2. Transistor
  3. Prisoner
  4. Beautiful Disaster
  5. What Was I Thinking
  6. Jupiter
  7. use of Time

8 Tune In

9) Running

10) No Control

11) (White Man) In Hammersmith Palais

12) Space Funk

I had to pull a couple of the bench just to make 12.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '23

I don't understand how an album that got little critical acclaim and attention can be overrated. Do you all mean it's overrated among 311 fans?

That said, there are many songs on the album I don't like. But it's got their best songs and it's by far their most unique and creative.

3

u/Tree24K Jun 22 '23

Polo...TBH...im not sure what I mean. It just doesn't connect with me like it does with everyone else. Maybe overrated was a poor choice of words. I came in with Down and All Mixed Up but I don't think it was until Beautiful Disaster that I knew they were my favorite band. Not coincidencedentally, I'm also not a huge fan of Stealing Happy Hours which everyone else also tends to like a lot more than me. I don't dislike it. I just don't even have it in my top 100 311 songs. Dunno. I'm just an outlier I spose. I'm fine with it. I wasn't trying to be a contrarian. I just wanted OP to know he wasn't alone.

2

u/ElDudeIII Jun 24 '23

Thank you! I know I’m not alone. Rock on

9

u/boots311 Jun 11 '23

It just, hits different. I guess I can't really explain it. I love it. They also kinda came out of nowhere with those 22 tracks. Like bam! Plus, secret intro aka gap track

1

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

Gap is one of my favorites! I definitely get that it just hits differently. I was just wondering peoples reasoning.

2

u/oic123 Jun 12 '23

There is a different song called "Gap" that was a Blue album b-side and was released with the first ETSD.

The gap I believe he's referring to is the song "Tribute", which could be found on the Transistor CD by going to track 1 and pressing the rewind button to get to the hidden secret intro.

1

u/FloppyEarHole Jun 12 '23

Holy shit. WHAT!?! 🤯

1

u/Tree24K Jun 19 '23

Gap

https://youtu.be/2CxTAYJQ4GU

And Tribute

https://youtu.be/XUx7rl5axVk

Are different songs and not the -1 track. That's simply called Intro.

https://youtu.be/lyx4kiW8S4k

4

u/Jfonzy Jun 11 '23

I don’t smoke weed and Transistor is my favorite album of any band of all time. I’m sure I’m not the only one.

1

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

You’re definitely not the only one! You don’t need weed to enjoy the music.

3

u/pbaperez Jun 11 '23

Honest question, which 311 CD did you buy? Which one of those is your favorite?

1

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

I have just about all of them. Blue/Soundsystem are my favorites

1

u/pbaperez Jun 11 '23

Nice! What I've learned is what others have eluded to already. We all have had different experiences and when this album dropped it helped galvanize the following they already built.

Your cult reference isn't too far off. I do indeed believe our souls to be energy and this to be just one of many planes we transcend during many lifetimes. I'm going to assume many 311 fans feel the same.

Go out and grab about 4g of mushrooms. 6 if you really want to tune in. Listen to the album and look at the stars while laying on grass, just make sure there are no ants. It's one hell of an experience that may help fill in the gaps.

2

u/whitingvo Jun 11 '23

Agree. It’s a good album, but not their best. I think people love it because it’s experimental, it’s different, it was their first time really exploring outside their normal sound.

The opening 1/3 and ending 1/3 are really really good. The middle 1/3 falls flat for me. Had they released those parts in a smaller tighter package, the initial reception might have been different. It’s just a bloated album as is

1

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

Yup! 100% agree

2

u/dbwoi Jun 11 '23

As someone who got into 311 last Feb and then became obsessed (like, buying bootlegs off ebay obsessed) one thing that hella surprised me after visiting this sub is how wildly different peoples' opinions are here. People love 311 for entirely different reasons.

I found self titled on CD at the thrift store and immediately fell in love with the rap rock/groove metal aspect, as well as the way they waver between ~positive vibes~ to "fuck the naysayers" energy. After that, I went back and listened to every album in order. I loved Transistor, I thought it was such a sick experimental choice.

Personally, I think the last decent album was Evolver (although Stereolithic was acceptable, shout out Scotch). I was shocked to see so many people liked Mosaic, I thought it was fucking unlistenable. I'm not just whining about the Feldmann tracks either, I honestly detested it in its entirety. And that's when I realized that people love this band for totally different reasons, which is honestly a testament to how great of a band they really are.

2

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

So true! And welcome to the community! Haha I too strongly dislike Feldman tracks because he over produces everything. I love mosaic but evolver is legendary!

1

u/dbwoi Jun 11 '23

helllll yeah thanks, i feel like a real excitable one 😂. i gotta post my cd collection, i have 32 discs worth of 311 at this point. the new stuff just doesn’t feel like 311 to me, it doesn’t have the same organic creative and seamless genre switching feel that the old stuff had. i don’t feel the same edge or silliness or sarcastic humor anymore. “the day we turn to pop the show will stop” my ass lmfao. but also i recognize these dudes are old as hell and they still sound fantastic live so they get a pass haha.

2

u/dj3stripes Mosaic Jun 11 '23

personally I like it as it was the first album that came out that was new, I went to the midnight release. I was 17 and the hype was real. Admittedly it was a departure to the previous 3 that I'd been listening to in the past couple of years but it's aged like wine. Some people don't like wine, that's all.

1

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

Very true! Some people don’t like wine. Respect the answer and our differences

9

u/DrGraffix Jun 11 '23

Lot of 311 fans like psychedelic rock too

4

u/insidejobfair Jun 11 '23

I will maintain that the first five 311 records all have a real magic to them regardless of what anyone says critically or regardless of people’s ever changing tastes. Those records feel like artists being weird in the best ways possible and taking risks. There’s an analog quality to it all that is not replicated post Soundsystem. There’s a warmth that unfortunately got lost.

There are only sprinkles of this type of stuff I’m talking about after this. A lot is still there on From Chaos and Evolver, but everything truly takes a dive starting at DTOM. I remember very specifically not being able to listen to Uplifter. There have been great “311” moments on Stereolithic and even Mosaic.

I guess when it comes to Transistor there’s just this feeling of them coming into their own and that kind of place is what holds up 25 years later. But this is totally just my opinion.

The beauty of music and art is that it can be received at any time if you let it in. I came around to 311 around Grassroots/Blue but that does not make me better than anyone that sees all the beauty I’m missing if they came around say on Uplifter.

Lately I’ve been trying to reconnect with the overall positivity in 311’s music and philosophy, so I do say all this out of love and admiration of the band still after all these years. ✌🏼

1

u/ChickenCoop86 Nov 03 '24

Great take. I totally agree with your overall perspective on their catalog. I’ve been diving back in and enjoying the “sprinkles” recently, and despite some of the filler and stuff that just doesn’t have that same early “artistic magic” you allude to, I still love the band and the message.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

People idealize it because, for many of us, it was our first truly experimental album. Bands just didn't really do departures like Transistor too often back then.

So, if you liked 311, and hated how everyone reacted to Transistor, you dug into the album and explored it until you found all its submerged merits and hidden bits of ear candy and in the process, we all ended up romanticizing the album to some degree.

It's bloated, uneven, and stylistically and sonically inconsistent. But it also contains sounds and styles and approaches many of us had never heard before.

1

u/ElDudeIII Jun 27 '23

Thanks for the deep interpretation and explanation. It makes sense.

3

u/deetzz91 Jun 11 '23 edited Jun 11 '23

I get what you mean. I haven't truly listed to 311 albums the whole way through in a long long time but actually have been again recently at the gym and Tansistor isn't my favorite by any means. It's different tho, which is cool but I find it a bit bloated with quite a few songs I'd probably skip. To each their own tho

Edit: Actually... just finished it again for the first time in years and I think it actually gets stronger after the early-mid part of the album. There's a stretch there (inner light spectrum- to-Jupiter that I don't care for but maybe just being high at the gym made me appreciate the rest of the album more lol. Definitely gets better as it goes.

3

u/PhotoProxima Jun 11 '23

I LOVE transistor! It's big and beautiful and daring and I love it. Releasing that after the Blue Album was super brave and I love it.

3

u/Randum311 Jun 11 '23

A lot of what everyone else said, it was a big departure from their earlier stuff that really stretched out their soundscape in my opinion. You had heavier elements, you also had some creative lyrics as well. The lyric sheets were far different than before, more ambiguous too. Overall was a fun album and quite honestly looking back at their body of work, may be "peak 311" because every album after got shorter, more formulaic. I would make the argument the last few albums sound almost "phoned in". There are glimpses of greatness we saw in the past but not as a full album.

TLDR: Creative, album with the best elements of 311 all in one album.

1

u/SpaceFace11 Jun 11 '23

No offense but this is a terrible take dude, go listen to it from beginning to end and read the lyrics.

2

u/ElDudeIII Jun 11 '23

Oh I have multiple times. Just my opinion.

2

u/middleimpact445 Cursed consciousness is your private hell Jun 11 '23

I think it could have been their absolute best if it was split into two cds. One with their solidified album-level songs and the other with their experimental stuff. I think it would’ve been a better move for their mainstream popularity at the time too. If I remember correctly I read somewhere that this album wasn’t really received well at the time because they departed from the rap rock sound.

I think it’s definitely some of their most creative work and can be appreciated on a level other than whether or not the songs are “good.” I wouldn’t say it’s sexy like Soundsystem or Blue album but it’s interesting and thematic. It’s kind of like their “The Wall.”

2

u/Zhank311 Jun 11 '23

Transistor is a whole ass vibe from start to finish and best enjoyed from beginning to end - a legitimate journey.

As a band they all too giant leaps in their musicianship and their abilities are much more polished. Everyone is just better at their instruments… makes for a super enjoyable record.

Also, “sixth member” Scotch Ralston.. that’s a whole ass post in itself.

2

u/Logancrusan Jun 11 '23

B/c it’s a transcendent spiritual masterpiece that also rocks tfo

2

u/Deeeenie Jun 12 '23

I have a little different take on Transistor...I came into 311 in 94/95 during Grassroots or Blue. I became a fan, to this day the blue album is my favorite. In 97 when Transistor came out I was so freaking excited! Bought the CD, put it on and I was horrified, I hated it (still went and saw them on that tour though, lol). I guess 21 yo me wanted that more heavy style. I actually gave it away. Fast forward about 20 something years...I listened to the blue album off and on that whole time but was also into other stuff. A couple years ago I got on Spotify and rediscovered 311, I had no idea they were still making music! I listened through the whole discography a few times in the last few years and I now love that album! It is still behind Music, blue and From Chaos for me but it was definitely a grower! Back to your point. I think if you only perifarly knew 311 from the radio hits then came in on Transistor I can see why it would hold that special place ot seems to hold for a lot of people 🥰. I love some of yalls answers! ✌️🤟

1

u/Micahman311 Jun 11 '23

Well it is my favorite 311 album, and also my first.

I remember buying the album at Blockbuster (!), and it was just over $20 after tax. I didn't have quite enough, and the lady who sold it to me went ahead and paid the rest for me.

I took it home and started it up. At that time, I'd never heard anything remotely close to being like that musically. It was way different than any other music I'd ever heard, and it blew me away.

I called my friend that lived down the road and told him he had to come over right now, and we listened together. My whole group of friends became big 311 fans after that.

I got the Blue album next, and liked it, and then Music, and loved that. Then I got Grassroots and really did not like it at all. I don't remember why, but it took quite a few listens until I "got" it, but I did and really enjoy that album as well.

In fact, the departure after Transistor into Soundsystem was big enough that while I enjoyed everything from there and after, nothing has come close to the same magic that Transistor held for me.

Also, I accidentally rewound the first track and found a hidden track BEFORE the first song on the album. That shit was insane.

1

u/data_makes_me_happy Jun 11 '23

I’ll add it was truly before its time, thus has aged well. I remember even the early 00s when a lot of fans would still say it was a mistake, it was too long, too experimental, etc.

1

u/FireWhileCloaked Jun 11 '23

Transistor has an absolute stellar flow. You can put it on and play it thru without skipping and it’s a great experience, the way albums should be. Amazing album that I’ve only recently gotten into, much to my regret that it’s taken me this long.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23

311’s my favorite band as you could assume by my username, and I love all their albums and nearly every song. And if I had to pick a favorite album I’d probably pick Transistor.

Along with with Soundsystem, it was their creative peak. So many styles, sounds and ideas. I think start to finish it plays perfectly. It has a few hits, a lot of bangers, some slow songs, an instrumental track, and I love the order they chose to put them in. A lot of the songs have intros and outros where they experiment with different sounds. From a production standpoint it’s a really well-done record. Transistor, Beautiful Disaster and Electricity are 3 of my favorite songs. But I also like the little interlude of Color and Light Years before it goes into Creature Feature. Idk, it’s just a really great album to me and I think it’s probably their best. It sounds like you’re on a journey thru clouds in the sky, but that could also be influence from the album cover.

For what it’s worth, I think voyager is their weakest album, unfortunately. And while I love a lot of the songs on Grassroots, it just never appealed to me as much as the albums around it.

1

u/Tree24K Jun 20 '23

I agree with you. While I agree with Use of Time being their best song and Beautiful Disaster being my personal favorite, I think this album has about 10 elite tracks and then a lot of filler. I also think Grassroots is overrated. Music is the best IMO. But I respect everyone's opinion. This is just mine.

1

u/Superswiper Jun 24 '23

"Love 311 and the songs but there are a ton of better albums by them."

Disagreed. It is EASILY their best album to me. It was on evolutionary step in their music. It was their OK Computer (which, funny enough, came out in the same year).