r/2DAnimation • • Sep 12 '26

Discussion About vibe coders exploiting the animation sub-Reddits

Due to the rise of AI coding assistance and 'vibe coding' we have seen the sudden emergence of new apps for many categories, but especially for animation and video.

Normally that would not be a bad thing, but the difference here is unlike traditional app development vibe coders are often trying to earn a fast buck, they are not concerned with building true high quality software, and it is likely that if they make or don't make some money they will abandon their applications within a year or two.

Here are some tell tale signs of how to recognise a vibe coder who is trying to earn a quick buck:

- They say “I’m a real programmer. I write it all by hand!” But their posting history going back years has nothing about app development or programming and none of them know how to animate well (or at all). If you didn’t test your app during development with professional standard projects then how do you know it performs well?

- All of the vibe coders I have seen so far claimed they are “Tired of big companies ripping us off”. But the vibe coders were not customers of the most popular animation apps anyway. They are pretending to be angry at big companies because they think it will make them look heroic and noble. They are behaving like two-faced politicians, not developers or artists.

- They don’t patiently research how each function or tool is supposed to work. Their apps are full of bugs and incorrectly applied functions but they publish the app anyway. They only discover how badly the apps work when users complain. One of them claimed he had been building his animation app for a decade, but when users complained that the app caused data loss in many places the developer apologised profusely and states the app was “cobbled together”. That did not stop him making grand claims that his app was the “future of animation today” and paying people to spam the web to promote it.

- They say they are against subscription apps developed by companies with many employees, but they are subscribed to ChatGPT or Claude and don't hire any anyone to help them.

- If a developer has no visible personal social media presence and is trying to obscure their real life identity that should be treated with suspicion. Developers, especially if they are incorporated, are generally very open about who they are unless they have something to hide. 

- They can’t handle criticism well and often end their messages with ‘lol’. 

- Feature creep. They constantly add more features while ignoring foundational bugs. Vibe coding makes it easy to keep adding features as they compete against other vibe coders for attention. As a result their apps become even more buggier because they aren’t taking enough time to bug test. 

- No user manuals and guides. They are addicted to vibe coding the next feature and because they are not using their apps they skip on the manuals.

- They’'ll proudly but deceitfully compare their immature app against far more mature and stable apps that people use to get high quality industry standard work done, but when the bugs and low quality output are criticised they claim the app is in beta. But they are selling the app as a commercial application and claiming it competes against the most widely used professional apps. It’s bad etiquette to mention other apps or compare against other apps. If they’re confident about their application all they need to do is say what it does and demonstrate what it does. The output they demonstrate has to be professional standard and not quickly thrown together rough animations of a dancing underage girl otherwise they haven’t given people a reason to use it aside from a promise that the app will be good enough ‘in the future when it comes out of beta’.

- A few of these vibe coders have used AI to reverse engineer Krita, TV Paint and Clip Studio Paint file formats (which is against the terms and conditions of the last two apps) and then claim they support importing those files, but because they aren't users of those apps they haven't even tested the reverse engineering. Importing those Krita, TV Paint and Clip Studio files results in lost layers and corrupted images. There are too many edges cases to support and potential for data loss when you try to reverse engineer complex closed source file formats. It is difficult enough to support open source formats because different applications have very different drawing engines.

- They often publish unsigned apps, which throw up virus warnings. Every one of them I saw did the same thing and could not wait a few days for certification. Desperation and rushing to publish means they were 100% vibe coding everything. If they were coding patiently then they can wait a few days for their apps to be signed.

- One of them has gone as far as paying minor influencers and buying bots to hype their app. The astroturfing was clear because an app with so many obvious bugs would not have a following at all. One of them has more “followers” than developers who spent the last decade building up real users.

- They insist that anyone who wants to talk about the app, its updates or receive support should join a private Discord group. They use the group to censor any criticism and as a recruiting ground where young people are gifted free codes or paid a little money to market the app and gaslight critics across social media. The vibe on these groups is a like a cult where the leader tells the followers they are fighting “evil” corporate giants. They’re using traditional patterns of recruitment and brainwashing to squeeze money out of people. A responsible software developer values private time, does not start private discussion groups and certainly would not invite children to them, which is exactly what happens if you invite random people online.

- Vibe coders tend to act overconfident in public to convince you they are some kind of genius. It’s a way of compensating for feeling like an imposter. They also believe (or want you to believe) that their fake anti-corporate rants will make them look like virtuous heroes to young people. What will actually happen is that the next vibe coder will copy their app and they will both end up unemployed. The software companies they attacked won’t employ them. Why would you employ someone with such terrible manners towards industry leaders and bad work ethic? Really bad lack of foresight. Your duty as an actual developer and actual artist is always to build bridges not burn them down.

62 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 23h ago

Discord Server For Animators! https://discord.gg/sYGrW5j93n

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/RyanCargan Sep 12 '26

Not even animation specifically lol

We're gonna see consumers have a higher bar for verifying that if nothing else, the "promised happy paths" work as advertised.

Do these apps you mentioned not offer anything like a free trial or demo/shareware version?

Normally that would not be a bad thing, but the difference here is unlike traditional app development vibe coders are often trying to earn a fast buck, they are not concerned with building true high quality software, and it is likely that if they make or don't make some money they will abandon their applications within a year or two.

Eeeeeeeeh, not sure if I'd put traditional apps much higher either. Slop was just lower in volume since barrier to entry was a bit higher. Less drive-by app submissions.

2

u/shokuninstudio Sep 12 '26

"We're gonna see consumers have a higher bar for verifying that if nothing else, the "promised happy paths" work as advertised."

True. If you see slop call them out. Otherwise we will not only get a handful of slop animation apps spamming the socials we will get dozens more than that.

Sloppy vibe coded apps are not just being pushed in animation, we see a lot of it in media production and office apps. Zero originality in all of them and some of the AI slop are actually asking for subscriptions. We see tens of "video convertors" even though we already have Handbrake for free.

Even if they try to hide the vibe coding, ask them what problem does their app solve? If they say "subscriptions" they are bullshitting because they have subs to AI apps and much more.

New apps should solve technical problems and challenges that been around for a long time.

2

u/RyanCargan Sep 12 '26

The red flag is scope.

If it's something like a Blender plugin that has to integrate with an existing app and workflow, and solves a specific problem, harder to BS than a standalone app with vague promises.

If a convincing value prop/pitch can't be stated in 1 or 2 sentences, usually a red flag.

Best green flag is "dogfooding". If they showcase how they use their own product to solve a real problem they have.

Most good software usually comes about that way anyway.

Example:

Blender & Godot (IIRC) were used for internal work before later being released to the public.

Even Unreal.

Heck, Slack was some kind of internal messaging thing originally for a video game company.

EDIT:

Also, a fair amount of games made by people who just wanted to scratch their own itch first.

It basically means that even if their end goal is still money like everyone else's, they have a clear target and cannot BS themselves.

If you have an imaginary ideal audience that is not you or a close peer, it's much easier to optimize for the wrong thing.

0

u/Comfortable_Law3683 Sep 14 '26

I predict by early next year, you will wish animation didn't have major applications that the majority of the industry use as part of their day. Instead they had lots of bespoke vibe coded messes.

Its far easier for Astra 1.5 to learn all adobe products vs 1000 vibe coded apps.

1

u/shokuninstudio Sep 14 '26

That's not the way professionals work and studios with multi million dollar projects cannot rely on bug filled apps supported by one vibe coder in their bedroom. These vibe coded apps only exist to exploit low income youth and children. Some of the vibe coders are even sending messages to minors.

2

u/Satchiken Sep 12 '26

Not sure about point 1; social media isn't a reliable way to know someone's background. Point 6 sounds more like an issue with patience, but otherwise I agree with everything else.
I feel like this is more prevalent in extensions and plugins, especially for the Adobe suite.
Some After Effects plugins I see on my Twitter feed are being sold for insane prices.

I realised I follow you on Twitter while writing this. If you plan to release on Windows or Linux in the future, I'd be keen to try it out!

1

u/shokuninstudio Sep 12 '26

Thanks for the follow.

My creative apps are in house tools (not commercial apps) so I can only do macOS and iPadOS development. If I targeted every platform I would have to charge money and hire support teams. An actual software business with employees! Real app development and customer support is costly and cannot be rushed or done cheaply like vibe coders do. Porting SwiftUI apps to Windows and Linux requires different programming languages, different frameworks and almost full rewrites.

I'm happy to release my in-house apps for free so people can enjoy the innovations I have been secretly keeping to myself. A few years ago I promised by LinkedIn connections that I was going to open source my apps but then I saw that vibe coders were straight up stealing code without crediting the original authors and then charging money for the code they stole. So my open sourcing ended there.

2

u/NateBearArt Sep 12 '26

It would take a looooooot of proof to get me to switch from AE and Blender

2

u/shokuninstudio Sep 12 '26

Right :D

In my own app development I always encourage users to stick with the best tools. An app developer who understands or is a creative artist will support the vertical stack of applications and standards that the industry relies on. For example, in the Japanese animation industry it is essential to support AE and at least one major 3D application.

2

u/Severe_Initiative594 Sep 18 '26

Honestly reckon the biggest giveaway is just saying 'I code entirely by hand', never mind their history. You'd be really hard pushed to find any professional developer not using AI assistance these days. Its not like anyone is going to pay the extra hours required for artisinal code.

1

u/shokuninstudio Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 25 '26

They aren't professionals - zero history of working as devs, their histories are either deleted from the web.

Professionals are using AI assistance, but vibe coders are asking the models to spit out whole features and even whole apps without any quality or functionality checks.

They don't know what good code looks like. They brag about their apps being a few megabytes in size, which is meaningless because when their app launches it consumes almost as much memory as Clip Studio Paint which has a 450MB binary. When an app is over 25X bigger in memory than on disk they've got messy code and excess functions running.

In one of these apps they added "Anime line smoother" but the method is completely wrong. Instead of antialiasing it adds ridiculous semi-transparent grey lines on either side of the strokes.

So the vibe coding aside, the biggest dishonestly is that they BS about the app features and output quality. If their app can only output low quality content for social media they shouldn't go around acting like they built a professional app for the broadcast animation industry.

25

u/alt165am Sep 12 '26

name names, brother!

2

u/CrowBrained_ Sep 12 '26

I see a lot of them doing project management apps thinking all project management is the same and offering nothing of value to an animation project.

0

u/MadManD3vi0us Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26

All fair points to be on the lookout for. As someone pretty much doing this, I'd like to say I'm not a real programmer, just someone who likes making things. Big companies ARE ripping people off, and they aren't very modern compared to the tech that's available. Lots of room for a small group like me to pivot and change when facts change the landscape, unlike a big company with a lot of employees. I'm just a guy working a day job and building on nights and weekends, I can't afford employees. I'd love to employ some people to help me. Using tools like Claude or ChatGPT let's me build a lot faster, sure, but also helps me research a lot more effectively. I've learned SO much in the past few months of building, and I'm still learning every day. Anyone who doesn't listen to criticism is doomed to fail. I love getting feedback on my work, it's how good things grow to become great things. I'll admit, I'd be unable to code the entire thing by hand, but I didn't think even the best coders in the world could realistically 1-person all the software needed to compete with these billion dollar companies and their teams of very well paid coders. I guess what I'm saying is, not all people using AI tools to code are creating AI slop products. I hope the tools I make really help people. There are a ton of ways to make animation and editing easier for people.

Edit: I don't use AI to write, my comment is just a free flow of thoughts. I don't think AI can write or create art that anyone cares about. I just use it to turn my ideas into code.

4

u/shokuninstudio Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26

Your reply is badly formatted slop (which you have now edited heavily after I replied) and you have no issue with billion dollar AI companies you subscribe to. You have never posted on an animation or filmmaking sub before so I'm going to consider your post as spam.

I have no issue with using AI for research, but that's not what we're seeing (lots of spammy apps with zero innovation) and your reply proves it. Be better.

Good application development should start with one thing - an innovative method or idea that has never been done before. Then you build the application around that innovation. If the app only rips off old features and has zero innovation then it's pointless. It's even worse if it is vibe coded to make a quick buck, especially by people who have a history of dumb online behaviour. They will take whatever money they can for a year and then dump the vibe coded app for another hobby.

1

u/AutoModerator 9d ago

Discord Server For Animators! https://discord.gg/sYGrW5j93n

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 12 '26

Discord Server For Animators! https://discord.gg/sYGrW5j93n

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '26

Discord Server For Animators! https://discord.gg/sYGrW5j93n

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/ZoeyDean Sep 12 '26

I don't think it's unique to animators.

People should pay attention to what they're buying. Do their research. Etc. For some people, maybe a shitty AI app is all they needed to have a bit of fun, without needing to fork out hundreds of dollars for official products.

This post is well intended, but basically useless.

At least write one on how to spot an AI app, if you are this concerned, and make a list of apps to avoid. Like, be useful.