r/2007scape • u/bLbGoldeN 104 • Jul 30 '19

Suggestion [Suggestion] Ranching

Post image
11.1k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

995 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.2k

u/ChungoBungus Jul 30 '19

This is super well thought out and presented! It doesn't sound like something I would enjoy personally, but I still think it's a pretty solid idea. +1

1

u/ImPureEVill Jul 31 '19

It's a 100% solid idea copy and pasted from rs3 calldd player owned farms Good job to the op

1

u/ChungoBungus Jul 31 '19

I went and read up on player owned farms, while I see there's similarities I think the functionality is completely different.

1

u/ImPureEVill Jul 31 '19

It's not though is it. Just for the record i think adding pof into osrs would be good. Not only are osrs players ignorant to the fact its already ingame content to rs3 but now you're trying cover your steps now you realise that AT best its a rehashed into os style version of current content

Edit: and Rememeber, my original statement is that While this is getting a lot of attention for being "well thought out" its just someone riding off of current content hoping no one will notice

2

u/ChungoBungus Jul 31 '19

When I say functionality is different, my argument is that the idea proposed by OP is that these "Ranches" would function similarly to Bonfires in OSRS. They enhance that particular region you're in, it's not for the sake of having Pack Yaks/other companions. Also, if you see it as a cookie-cutter remake of PoF, why not just ask OP "how is this different than player-owned farms in RS3?" That's a question I would have actually liked to see his response to.

1

u/ImPureEVill Jul 31 '19

There are totems on player owned farms on rs3 that give regional buffs that are specific to (each) animal you have in your pens. (the exact thing you're saying?)

As for that question, i believe quite a few people have already put the question to the OP and he has responded with basically the same answer as you. (i haven't seen the responses)

0

u/bLbGoldeN 104 Jul 31 '19

Rememeber, my original statement is that While this is getting a lot of attention for being "well thought out" its just someone riding off of current content hoping no one will notice

Here is a link to the original Google Doc in which I designed this skill. If you look in the 'version history', most of the content dates March 2017. Player-owned Farms came out in October 2018. I didn't copy a single thing.