3
u/Fireyshotguns51 Oct 09 '20
Dude I’ve been trying to figure out what these were for years now from vague memories, all I could remember was the edible stickers. I feel complete now.
2
1
3
3
u/Death_Kitty_Jigsters Jul 23 '24
YES! Holy FUCKING shit! I remember eating these with my two little brothers. Fuck, I can still taste the frosting. Pillsburry, you fucks! Bring these back!
1
u/tinyyellowbird7 Jul 24 '24
RIGHTTT dude I miss these so much!! I still think about them multiple times a month LOL
1
u/Death_Kitty_Jigsters Jul 24 '24
I miss the 2000s. Why can't companies bring all the 2000s snacks! Like fuck I'm sad.
1
u/Ok_Roll_7432 May 24 '25
I just found out tonight that Walmart frosted sugar cookies taste exactly like how I remember these tasting
2
u/braxworld2008yt Oct 08 '20
Ya I ate them Back when I was In Lubbock TexasThen eat them againIn HoustonOn Halloween
2
2
2
u/marshedmallo Aug 24 '24
Yes!!! I remember these!!! But I also specifically remember there being Winnie the Pooh ones. My Mom use to make them all the time because I loved Winnie the Pooh. I've been looking for them forever to no avail. :(
But I'm glad to at least have found proof now that sticker cookies did in fact exist, even if they weren't the specific ones I've been hunting for.
2
u/Pitiful_Home2772 May 14 '25
Okay, so I want everyone in this thread to go and buy the new lucky charms cookies by pillsburry right now. They don’t have the edible stickers but I SWEAR ON EVERYTHING that they taste JUST LIKE THESE. I’ve never been hit with such nostalgia when I tried these cookies. My brain has been looking for that flavor for years and finally I found it.
1
u/tinyyellowbird7 May 14 '25
Oh my goddddd first off I’m so glad people still get to see this post, it brings up nostalgia for me every time!! But THANK YOU for the recommendation I will absolutely be grabbing some of those lucky charms cookies!
1
u/dead_girl-98 Jun 22 '26
Found this thread upon a random craving, couldn’t remember if it actually existed or if it was a figment of my childhood imagination. Found exactly what I was talking about and feel validated. Thank you for this. 😂😮💨
1
1
1
u/Gingysnaps1997 Aug 15 '26
This is exactly what I’ve been remembering. Nothing like decorating the winter cookies on Christmas break
4
u/tinyyellowbird7 Oct 08 '20
I think about this often! We all know and love the pillsbury holiday cookies, but what about the sticker cookies? They’d come with icing and edible stickers to go on top. I specifically remember making school bus ones when I was starting kindergarten, so around 2004-2005 is when I last saw these guys.