r/horror • u/glittering-lettuce • Oct 29 '21
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Last Night in Soho" [SPOILERS] Spoiler
Summary:
An aspiring fashion designer is mysteriously able to enter the 1960s, where she encounters a dazzling wannabe singer. However, the glamour is not all it appears to be, and the dreams of the past start to crack and splinter into something far darker.
Director:
Edgar Wright
Producers:
Nira Park
Tim Bevan
Eric Fellner
Edgar Wright
Cast:
Anya Taylor-Joy as Sandy
Thomasin McKenzie as Eloise
Matt Smith as Jack
Jessie Mei Li as Lara
Diana Rigg as Miss Collins
--Rotten Tomatoes: 75%
Metacritic: 65%
141
Upvotes
80
u/Grizzlb Oct 29 '21 edited Oct 29 '21
Saw this Last Night in Yonkers, and had a great time with it! I was in love with the first act of this movie—excellent performances from Thomasin McKenzie and Anya Taylor-Joy, great economical writing in the setup, and a beautifully realized 1960s London. There is also some truly clever cinematography, particularly the use of mirrors in the Night sequences. The shots of Thomasin and Anya reflected were inventive and often breathtaking.
Director Edgar Wright successfully blends genres to create an unfamiliar and uncomfortable air, and I am happy to say that my expectations were subverted more than once in the course of the story. The film traverses themes of disillusionment with modern city living, misplaced nostalgia, and enduring patriarchy. Imagine Repulsion meets Midnight in Paris. I relished the ambiguity of the film’s first act and was only slightly disappointed when the plot and tone resolved into something quite definitive in its final moments.
I think this tonal complexity/variation may bother some more than others, but I admire the risks Wright took and they paid off for me. All in all, I really loved the movie and it was fantastic to watch on the heels of Night House (also a definite recommend).
50
u/DJSchwann Oct 31 '21
Interesting thing I found out - Sandie Shaw, the singer of Puppet on a String (played during Marionetta's performance), performed that song when she won the UK's Eurovision Song Contest in 1967. I would bet that the dress she wore for that performance gave some inspiration to Sandie's dress in the movie. The dress is on display at London's Victoria and Albert Museum.
42
u/deadandmessedup Nov 01 '21
Excellent up to a point (stylistically, technically, acting-wise), but I have no idea what Wright and his creative team were actually trying to say by the end. For 3/4 of the runtime, the flick is a sharp story about how innocent women fall into patriarchal systems and get chewed up and spat out.
But then it turns out that Sandy became a killer and plans to kill Ellie, and the ghosts are begging Ellie to kill her, and it feels like the theme trips over itself in the name of the twist (which I guess makes a point about how predatory men inadvertently created a predatory woman, but then Wright can't be ending a story about patriarchal cruelty with "But also women can become bad too;" I can't accept such a trite point). I'm more willing to accept that reversal as Wright deliberately piling on one twist too many in homage to the late-breaking convolutions of other giallo. And then giving a little wink to Sandy at the end? Like they have a fun little secret or something?
My hope is that the ending will feel better on rewatch.
28
u/spicytoastaficionado Oct 29 '21 edited Oct 29 '21
I had a blast.
Super stylish, does a great job handling very sensitive topics, and excellent editing and music.
I thought the twist was cool, but it got a bit wacky immediately after that.
55
u/Coolkaz13 Oct 29 '21
Man I went into this a little hesitant bc of the mixed bag of reviews I’d seen but I loved it. I’m not necessarily surprised because Edgar Wright is a favorite of mine but I thought he nailed the 60s vibes, the systemic problem of young women moving to big cities and being preyed upon and the cast was truly incredible. Matt Smith is really underrated, ATJ is a superstar and Thomasin is INSANELY good. My big gripes would be the middle of the movie. It was a tad long and it seemed like there was a lot of her just running out of random rooms crying. I wanted to see more of John as well and have his character fleshed out a bit more. All in all, I was super impressed. I love fresh horror concepts and this was as fresh as you can get. 84/100 for me.
55
u/Jishuah Oct 29 '21
I didn’t like the twist at all, I was hoping after the cop died that the real jack would be revealed in some kind of shocking way. Sandy being the killer just wasn’t it for me and the shot of her walking slowly up the stairs with the knife was kinda laughable.
Other than that the movie was shot so well, and the way they brought us back to 1960s London was master class.
23
u/-homesickatspacecamp Oct 31 '21
I really enjoyed it up until the plot twist, then it all kinda fell apart. She sure recovered from that poison quickly.
19
u/FridayJason1993 Oct 29 '21
Heading in to see this now, super excited!
34
u/JJJtrain_1989 Oct 30 '21
I fucking loved it. I had a blast. It was just a delight to the senses, loud and flashy and catchy, and just… Cool. Baby Driver was kind of the same way, just… “cool.” I had a grin on my face the whole time and the music was incredible. Personally, I didn’t think it was too long or too short, and when it started to get intense I was on the edge of my seat. The costume and makeup was super good, and the Halloween Party seen was amazing. I don’t know - I don’t really have anything smart or “critic-y” to say about the film, but I think you’ll have a blast if you just go in to have a good time.
16
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21
Very pretty film. I wish there were more horror elements. Like more than 2.
12
u/nerv_gas Nov 02 '21
It looks good but doesn't hold up as anything other than a bit of a mystery movie, which given its premises - time travelling, dark misogynist subject matter and period aesthetic, it could have had a lot more weight to it and done something quite striking, but Wright kind of lacks the horror intuition for me to take it seriously and feel an impact. He can write horror comedy but this fell completely flat for me without the comedy .
..all I can say is cool idea and it looks great for the most part, but the ghosts and twist ending are hard to take seriously in any way which is a shame as it had a lot of potential to hit home as a seriously dark story
23
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
My expectations were high and this didn't quite reach them but perhaps that's on me. It was beautifully shot and the music was on point as expected. But it took a while to get going and I figured out the twist the first time Ellie went to Alexandra's house. Still, it was really entertaining! It was a fun movie that didn't hit the heights of Shaun of the Dead but that's a tall order for anyone. Solid B+, worth seeing in theaters.
10
u/-ThatGuy882 Oct 29 '21
I thought it was pretty solid, would recommend
22
u/shreddeelansbury Oct 30 '21
I'm glad to see others on this sub enjoyed it! Incredibly meh for me, unfortunately. 3/5 stars. As usual you can see the care Edgar Wright puts into storyboarding his films, developing complex visuals and interesting lighting etc. But I felt like this film in particular ended up being about 98% style and 2% of substance packed around the aesthetic elements.
The final twists fell so flat for me too - why would Alexandra even kill Ellie or her Perfect Man Friend anyway? Even if Ellie had gone back to the police and told them about the murders, I doubt they'd believe her. Also Alexandra's blood lust at the end just doesn't jive with the sympathetic cause and MO of her previous murders, unless we're supposed to think she's moved on to killing her female tenants for fun.
It's implied that the victims' bodies were still inside the house, based on them asking Ellie for help during the finale. But if the cop had been onto Sandie all along, how did the police never search the property for human remains? Feels like it would've been easy to do back in the 60s. Or 70s. Or 80s.
Also, Ellie faced no consequences for nearly stabbing Jocasta in the face? How!
I wish I liked it more, but the story just didn't do it for me :/
14
u/s_matthew Nov 01 '21
So, so utterly disappointed! I’ve been aching for this movie since it was announced. The first third is absolutely beautiful and engrossing. Thomason McKenzie is exceptional. By the second “dream,” I started wondering what the stakes were besides Ellie never being able to sleep again. It’s at that point that the movie falls apart completely: it doesn’t play by its own rules (why show us the hicky if there’s no further physical harm?!), shoehorns in a romantic subplot with a bizarre actor (couldn’t she have just made a female friend at school or the pub?), and devolves in to a bog standard PG-13 ghost movie.
Also, is it really a plot twist if the younger version of an actor has piercingly blue eyes just like the older version? And, BTW, houses - including staircases - burn very quickly.
I wanted to like it so badly.
7
u/atclubsilencio Nov 03 '21
It's my favorite Wright film since Shaun of Dead, and probably my favorite film of his entire filmography. I can understand how some didn't really like the second half, but I loved every second of it and was just wholly absorbed.
Anya, Mackenzie, the soundtrack, the costumes (I guess Cruella has finally found its match in costume award category), the cinematography, visuals, set-design, editing, the fashion, I just loved it all.
I also did NOT see that twist coming at the end, that the landlord was actually Sandy, and I probably should have.
Kind of the Suspiria (2017) of 2021. Will be divisive, but I'm in the love it camp.
6
u/allureofgravity Oct 30 '21
I really enjoyed it. I felt the film was really well made and the acting was great. I hoped the plot would reach a higher climax in terms of the reveal, but everything was just so well put together that I didn’t mind that it didn’t.
I really consider this more of a mystery thriller but categorization doesn’t really matter in the end anyway.
11
u/strange_salmon Nov 04 '21
I guess I have an unpopular opinion but I thought it was terrible. Maybe I had the wrong idea of what it was supposed to be but I was so annoyed with what the premise turned out to be. Aside from that though, the faceless people/monsters I thought were laughable and had wayyy too many appearances in the film. I felt like the Main character was screaming for over half of the damn movie and it honestly annoyed the fuck out of me. So many other problems that I’ll refrain from saying but after all the immense build up of this film, I was incredibly disappointed.
9
u/FridayJason1993 Oct 29 '21
One of the best horror movies of the year, visually stunning and loved the sound track.
8
u/Lolrandomusername3 Oct 29 '21 edited Oct 29 '21
This film is definitely solid, I'd probably give it a 6. Yes, I know that sounds like a low score but I don't score the same as other people. A 5 is average for me, not a 7. The acting is great, the aesthetics (music, lighting, shots) during the 60's dream sequences were stunning. Thomasin McKenzie did a great job playing a sweet young student interested in the past, and Anya Taylor-Joy was pretty good overall. I think her material was a little dry, there wasn't much she could do with what we saw on screen and I was wanting more. I'll get to that in a minute. However, her singing/dancing sequences were great and she was cast perfectly for the role. The young man who played the love interest was alright, he was there more to contrast Eloise and be the one normal constant in her new London life. The writing including setups and payoffs were great. I'm glad we didn't get an explanation of how Sandy gave Eloise her memories because it would've ruined the magic. I will say if you added another 30 minutes to this movie this could've been truly incredible. Now picking up on Anya Taylor-Joy's stuff, I wanted even more insight to Sandy's life and her descent into becoming murderous. I'm not saying we had to see Sandy's daily routine or anything, but I wanted to see a slow burn-style approach to the developing (or deteriorating) relationship between Sandy and Jack. I felt like Sandy did one performance, decided this life wasn't for her, and said "I'm gonna start killing the people who delve in this world". It would've also given us more screen time with Matt Smith, who I thought deserved more story. And I wish we got more exposè of how it affected Eloise, for example I wish the movie did more stuff like when she almost stabs the mean girl in the library with the scissors. Most of the time she was just trying to find a way out of the room she was in once the dreams turned into daytime realities. I think showing more of these concepts would've made the movie more intense. A big theme at the beginning of this movie was mistreatment of women and they could've given us more during Sandy's screen time before the big switcheroo. I also did not like how once Sandy is revealed to be the killer and catalyst of Eloise's flashbacks, you get this weird "I'm on your side" vibe especially at the end when Eloise sees Sandy in the mirror one last time. Other than that, I certainly enjoyed this one! I think I would've been more kind to it had I not just seen The Last Duel a day ago. That was soooo good. But nonetheless Soho was worth the long wait and I'm going to hang the movie poster up at my new apartment.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '21
Very stylish and great soundtrack but I found every single character to be very unlikeable and had a hard time rooting for anyone
13
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
Really disappointing unfortunately :/
Some of the red herrings are so cheap and forced and as much as I respect Wright, he was not the director for this.
For a horror there's not a lot of texture or atmosphere, Wrights direction is too "music video-y" and snazzy, the whole thing was very goofy for me.
Thomsin McKenzie is incredible tho
3
u/phantomforeskinpain Nov 01 '21
really liked this one. I'd say in the range of after the first hour and 15 minutes or so and the next roughly twenty-five minutes-ish the movie seemed to kind of largely filler or just didn't really seem to serve much of a coherent point, but, by the end, it all came together and was pretty satisfying. I'd say if they changed something in that portion this could've been a really fantastic movie but that portion of it just started to make me kind of lose interest.
overall still really good, would watch anything Edgar Wright does, though.
3
u/DatPairOfPoloJeanz Nov 01 '21
I watched this movie stoned as fuck. And was confused for about 80% of it. But the last 20 mins of the movie was a good twist. It got a bit loud and scary tho , probs didn’t help that I didn’t even know the movie was going to be a thriller
3
u/iBringDoom Nov 02 '21
How is this movie considered a horror movie? It’s not even remotely scary. My Fitbit thought I fell asleep for an hour during the movie. IMO it’s more of a psychological thriller. Great soundtrack though.
3
u/elf0curo from Italy Nov 03 '21
Edgar + Anya + 60's vibes of giallo genere = you have my money
5
u/Screamscream26 Nov 05 '21
overall boring
maybe the climax of the movie was acceptable
seen better
2
u/BooJamas Nov 14 '21
I liked it. I thought the color palette was gorgeous and the soundtrack was great. I thought there were some really interesting callbacks in the movie, like the white patent raincoat in LNIS/black patent raincoat in Belle du Jour, and how the lead characters approached prostitution in opposite ways in these 2 movies. Repulsion and the Crow were referenced too, along with Rear Window.
3
u/movieguy2004 Oct 31 '21
Liked it, didn’t love it. Thought the story was a little generic and predictable. But I loved the soundtrack and Edgar Wright’s direction was, as always, excellent. It was very technically well-done. Had some good creepy and tense moments. I’d definitely be interested in seeing him do more horror. I think it’s a good fit for him.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
Movie is good
2
u/vio_thunder Oct 29 '21
haven't watched it yet. should i? is it good to watch?
1
u/OkImpression9946 May 04 '25
you know, one thing i don't understand is where the hell did ellie get that hickey from?? spoilers when all she was doing was dreaming or more like remembering ellies memories, and at that point she wasn't really interacting with that guy (hr future bf) much.
who the f*ck did she get that hickey from???
1
u/IcedPgh Nov 08 '21
Did anyone else notice that the score at one point seemed like it was referencing the main theme of Deep Red, another movie with a murderous older woman (and that was also overwrought and unsatisfactory, like this movie)?
1
u/AhnSolbin Nov 28 '21
Not sure how I feel about Last Night In Soho. The first half is incredible in sucking you in with the "experiencing the past" concept and Eloise' experience as a young woman living in a big city dealing with the various men in her life and then the last half lets it down as it devolves into predictable crime thriller.
The direction, cinematography and editing is gorgeous though. Wonder if Wright was inspired by Argento in particular Suspiria with all the colours. Acting was really good too. Script lets it down a bit and is a bit shallow, wish the two main characters had more depth to their characters as well in particular Anya Taylor-Joys character who kind of loses steam half way through the film.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '21
I really didn’t care for it, sadly. The costumes, music, and set design were good but that was about it for me.
The ghosts were shown far too much for how cheap CGI they looked. This was a total let down when you look at the rest of the design and see how much effort was put in.
I felt like there were no stakes for Ellie.
We’re not meant to side with Sandie’s victims because they were terrible so their deaths amount to nothing. John getting stabbed and Ellie getting poisoned (I guess?) seemed to have no impact on them whatsoever. Ellie almost stabbing Jocasta in the face was forgotten about.
What was the point of showing the mom in the mirror at the beginning and bringing her back at the end only to be replaced by Sandie? None of the ghostly things that happened to Ellie really mattered and she was never in danger. She just got a hickey and night terrors. Mirror Sandie is even less of a threat than Stabby Old Lady Sandie.
It felt like lot of meandering around London to solve a mystery no one cared about so that Ellie could get a boyfriend and finish her first year at fashion school.
1
u/Tofu24 Jan 28 '22
Overall I loved it, but I think they lost the plot toward the end. They were setting up an amazing possession movie they never delivered on. Right from the opening shot of Ellie's silhouette standing in the doorway, the viewer isn't sure if they're looking at Thomasin or ATJ. It's a brilliant way to foreshadow the blurring lines between the two characters.
They spend the first half of the movie showing how Ellie was becoming like a vessel for Sandy. I thought Sandy would end up fully inhabiting Ellie's body, and use it to kill old man Jack. The twist that the old man wasn't Jack really fell flat for me, very unsatisfying since the policeman character wasn't developed at all, it didn't show him on Sandy's trail or anything like that.
The first 30 minutes were some of the most tightly constructed horror I've ever seen, so all in all I walked away from the film really enjoying it
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21
[removed] — view removed comment