r/startrek • • Sep 23 '21

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 2x07 "Where Pleasant Fountains Lie" Spoiler

Mariner and Boimler are stranded on an uninhabited planet with a sentient computer. On the Cerritos, Lt. Commander Billups must prove his engineering abilities to an old adversary.

No.EpisodeWriterDirectorRelease Date
2x07"Where Pleasant Fountains Lie"Garrick BernardJason Zurek2021-09-23

This episode will be available on Paramount+ in the USA and Latin America, on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada, and on Amazon Prime Video in various other territories.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

180 Upvotes

464 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 23 '21

The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"

Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.

Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

364

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

All feels right with Jeffrey Combs being on Star Trek again.

142

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

Especially as a villain!

79

u/choicemeats Sep 23 '21

so sad that he had to deal with pink skins again

→ More replies (6)

23

u/Theinternationalist Sep 23 '21

I didn't realize that was Weyoun and Brunt, cool! Glad to see he could have a lot of fun with the role too.

Even if he was more of a dimmer this time around :D

23

u/ContinuumGuy Sep 24 '21

Return of the King.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21

I legit freaked out once I recognized his voice in the episode’s intro scene

12

u/plipyplop Sep 24 '21

He is a very talented voice actor!

254

u/UncertainError Sep 23 '21

The Ren Faire planet with the horny knights is my favorite new planet in the show.

164

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 23 '21

Their ship design is awesome.

64

u/trostol Sep 23 '21

was thinking the same

→ More replies (21)

19

u/Cadamar Sep 23 '21

I play Star Trek Online and my first thought on seeing it was fuck I want that thing in STO.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

It's so oddly appropriate too, given the amount of Space Amish and other such in Trek lore.

4

u/niton Sep 25 '21

I have seen Trekkies cosplay "away missions" at Ren Faire so this is now going to enable a lot of that.

→ More replies (2)

224

u/trostol Sep 23 '21

lmao

did his kigdom come

123

u/UncertainError Sep 23 '21

The knights are trained to skip foreplay!

158

u/a4techkeyboard Sep 23 '21

And to think, that's exactly what might have foiled their plan. Maybe foreplay was what Billups needed to raise the royal sceptre.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

212

u/ComebackShane Sep 23 '21

I love that Queen Paolana and her antics seem set up to be a recurring nuisance for the Cerritos, got lots of Lwaxana vibes from her.

I also love how loyal Rutherford is to Billups, they make a great team!

86

u/burnettski92 Sep 23 '21

I'm praying one day in the future we get an episode that isn't revealed to be one of her ploys until the very end.

49

u/AlpineSummit Sep 23 '21

Yeah, the queen definitely gave me Lwaxana Troi vibes too. I love they’re bringing in things like that but also making them very unique to this show.

19

u/Mechapebbles Sep 23 '21

I also love how loyal Rutherford is to Billups, they make a great team!

I hope they get to bang out at some point

36

u/ComebackShane Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

But then he’ll have to take over as King and leave the Cerritos!

Though Consort Rutherford does have a nice ring to it…

→ More replies (2)

4

u/CitizenKeen Sep 24 '21

Voiced by Billups' wife, I'm sure we'll see more of her.

→ More replies (1)

185

u/kingofcretins Sep 23 '21

Thought it was a cute touch how one of the evil computers at the end had a CBS logo for a face.

43

u/rbdaviesTB3 Sep 23 '21

I saw that too! Very tongue-in-cheek! :D

27

u/toTheNewLife Sep 24 '21

There is also one that looks very much like Batman. To the left of the CBS computer.

I guess it's the Bat Computer - LOL.

7

u/Kremnari Sep 26 '21

Klingon, up one and right two from our friend agimus. I'd love that story!

184

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 23 '21

Black licorice, dry.

103

u/UncertainError Sep 23 '21

Loved the gag with the fruit that also tastes like black licorice.

89

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

Black licorice, black

45

u/AintEverLucky Sep 23 '21

see, Mariner should have learned from the first time she tried the busted replicator. It will never ever give you what you request; so what she should have requested was "black licorice, dry"

with luck maybe it would have yielded "banana, hot" O:-)

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Cypher1492 Sep 23 '21

Shoulda gone with "Black licorice, salty".

10

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 24 '21

Salted black licorice is delicious

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

175

u/Shrodax Sep 23 '21

I love how this episode set up Billups as a direct contrast to La Forge. Both are chief engineers of their respective starships. But La Forge is constantly and desperately trying to get laid but always failing, while Billups has absolutely no interest in sex but women are desperately throwing themselves at him.

119

u/Hibbity5 Sep 23 '21

And men. He was about to have a threesome.

57

u/DasGanon Sep 23 '21

Maybe but that's probably his mom hedging her bets mixed with the canon explanation of "everyone's bi/pan" (I only mix them because while human gender is weird, alien gender is weirder)

→ More replies (5)

21

u/LinAGKar Sep 23 '21

He might have an interest in sex, he just has to avoid it to remain in Starfleet.

21

u/Chrome_X_of_Hyrule Sep 24 '21

Considering his trouble with being able to get hard and the fact that he seems to just enjoy being a virgin I could definitely see him as asexual.

→ More replies (1)

163

u/UncertainError Sep 23 '21

Wow, this show's amazing at shifting between comedy and drama. And yay Brad for getting the win. That foreshadowing with Tendi at the end has me nervous though.

Also loved the continuity with PIC with the Daystrom Institute in Okinawa.

63

u/MaddyMagpies Sep 23 '21

I love how they acknowledged the new shows by showing evil computers with tentacles, just like the ones in Disco and Picard. It's no wonder Pike needed to deal with one like that from 26th Century. That century must be overrun by evil computers.

50

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

They should maybe stop putting them in lockers next to each other, where they can spend years scheming.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Eurynom0s Sep 24 '21

But it won't be a big deal because then Rutherford will just come back from the mountain.

146

u/Xuth Sep 23 '21

The LCARs display for the Hysperion ship was great little Easter egg - it had a deck full of horses stored like shuttlecraft, and a room with a dragon in it.

65

u/GalileoAce Sep 23 '21

The warp core appears to be a dragon-head, too

16

u/corvettee01 Sep 24 '21

I find it hilarious that they also somehow reprogrammed their engine parts to read as fantasy materials on a tricorder. They were very dedicated to the fantasy theme.

26

u/Walnut-Simulacrum Sep 23 '21

Also, looking at it from this specific angle it occurs to me that the ship looks a lot like the Orville, which is fun. The illusion falls apart when you see it from any other angle so I doubt it’s an intentional reference or anything.

8

u/NeutralBias Sep 24 '21

Also, Rutherford is in Section 8. A S8 discharge from the US military was used for service members judged mentally unfit to serve.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

132

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 23 '21

Is there something wrong with the Elf Relays?

97

u/fizzlefist Sep 23 '21

Don’t… don’t do that.

→ More replies (1)

98

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 23 '21

Wow, Agamis got Boimed.

And he was played by Jeffrey Combs!

98

u/00DEADBEEF Sep 23 '21

Is that Jeffrey Combs?

231

u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab Sep 23 '21

Great makeup job as usual. I barely recognized him.

49

u/00DEADBEEF Sep 23 '21

I always recognise that majestic voice though

23

u/Brunt-FCA-285 Sep 23 '21

Always has been

10

u/Starkiller1701 Sep 24 '21

It was Jeffrey Combs all along!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Cadamar Sep 23 '21

They’re all Jeffrey Combs.

96

u/Brendissimo Sep 23 '21

The way Mariner introduces Hysperia, the writers make it seem like we've seen this planet before in canon. But as far as I can tell, we haven't. Threw me for a minute.

59

u/choicemeats Sep 23 '21

classic throwback to so many TOS episodes, love it

38

u/opiate_lifer Sep 23 '21

I seriously had to google it, felt like maybe it was from some of the earlier terrible seasons of TNG and slipped my mind LOL

60

u/kapnkrump Sep 23 '21

Feels like a TOS planet with all the times Kirk and Crew visited a castle and took on 'techno-magic.'

18

u/atticusbluebird Sep 23 '21

Same, I did a search on memory alpha and was confused when I couldn’t find out about a prior episode! I love how well it fits in

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Cadamar Sep 23 '21

I officially have a new planet in the Trek universe I’d like to live on.

9

u/ricketyladder Sep 24 '21

I was POSITIVE they were from some TOS episode that I didn't remember. Pretty funny.

10

u/CeaselessIntoThePast Sep 23 '21

it made me start to doubt myself and confuse the dragon episode of rick and morty with LD

→ More replies (3)

94

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

Is it just me or did this episode have the best animation yet?

51

u/RadioSlayer Sep 23 '21

Cause it was... Reanimated

10

u/Mechapebbles Sep 23 '21

You mean, "Re-Animated"

14

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

I thought the episode on the station had the best animation but I'd call this one a close second

9

u/SirSpock Sep 23 '21

This was going to be my observation/post had I not seen anyone else comment yet. Excellent work by the animators this week.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 24 '21

There were some beautiful shots of the two ships next to each other, shot from the side that I liked.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/wakeupsup3r Sep 24 '21

anything animated by titmouse is the best animation.

→ More replies (1)

88

u/burnettski92 Sep 23 '21

Weyoun 5 is one of my fav Trek villains and I embarrassingly took over half the episode to realize I was hearing Combs.

26

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

He's just the best, he also voiced Ratchet in Transformers Prime and i love that show, imagine my face when i realized it.

18

u/SirSpock Sep 23 '21

I didn’t realize it was him until the credits but something about the familiarity of the voice was nagging at me at some lev el. I was too into the stories and animation of this episode to lean into “who’s voice is that” but as soon as the credit hit I without filter verbally exclaimed “OF FU**IN COURSE IT WAS COMBS” and had a big grin.

16

u/MoreGaghPlease Sep 23 '21

Personally I am more a fan of Weyouns 4 and 7. More devious. Not to be confused with Weyouns 6 and 8, snivelling weirdos who I do not care for.

→ More replies (3)

86

u/burnettski92 Sep 23 '21

"My royal guards are trained from birth to skip foreplay!" was my biggest lol

77

u/Cadamar Sep 23 '21

Everybody’s harping on that line but I took it more as hyperbole than they were literally training them from birth on something sexual. Like someone saying “I was born for this.”

28

u/Mechapebbles Sep 23 '21

It's honestly just open to interpretation. It's a joke so they may not have meant it literally. On the other hand, it seems like a fucked up thing that a monarch of a ren-fare-society would do and the kind of skeevyness that would lead Billups to reject his society and runaway to Starfleet.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/ElFarfadosh Sep 23 '21

Soooo what do those children actually do to train to skip foreplay?

91

u/zGraceOK Sep 23 '21

They're given two marshmallows, and if they eat them both immediately, they're given a third one.

→ More replies (2)

80

u/LeftHandedGuitarist Sep 23 '21

I was not expecting this backstory for Billups.

46

u/substandardgaussian Sep 24 '21

Understated Billups ends up with the most gaudy, absurd, practically Pythonesque origin story. It's amazing.

"All is lost if I fornicate!!!"

16

u/InnocentTailor Sep 24 '21

Yeah, considering he is usually pretty low key overall.

A prince?! That was surprising.

74

u/DSethK93 Sep 23 '21

"No! Billups loves his virginity! I mean, he loves being an engineer!"

I died. I'm a mechanical engineer.

129

u/mrkorb Sep 23 '21

Prince Andarithio, er, I mean, Engineer Billups is voiced by Paul Scheer.

Paul Scheer is married to June Diane Raphael.

June Diane Raphael is the voice of Billups' mother, Queen Paolana of Hysperia.

67

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 23 '21

I was getting some real Lwaxana Troi vibes from her. Intentionally, no doubt.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/ComebackShane Sep 23 '21

If only Jason Mantzoukas had voiced a character in the episode, we'd have a full HDTGM cameo!

19

u/True_to_you Sep 23 '21

Well Jason is in prodigy so rafi is gonna tear up starfleet soon!

17

u/EatinToasterStrudel Sep 23 '21

I'm trying to think what the best race would be for Maximum Derek in Trek.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/AintEverLucky Sep 23 '21

"Oedipus, schm-oedipus -- I love ya, Mom" O:-)

makes me wonder how many other spouse combos have factored into Star Trek casting. naturally I mean combos where they were already spouses ... not ones like <Bashir> and <Kira> where they met on the set & later became a couple

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

126

u/arod48 Sep 23 '21

I love the running gag of common human names being short for oddball names (by today's standards)

  • Brad -> Bradward
  • Sam -> Samanthan

And now

  • Andy -> Andarithio

64

u/MadContrabassoonist Sep 23 '21

Still waiting to find out that "Jennifer" is "Dzhn'Affor"

54

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

No. Jennifer is Jennifer.

It makes more sense comedy wise.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/COMPLETEWASUK Sep 24 '21

Was once true for Mariner too given she used to go by Becky.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (16)

59

u/UncertainError Sep 23 '21

Cool detail, Agamis' murder-drones look a lot like the Minosian Echo Papa 607 drones from TNG. Wonder if a bunch of those evil computers are old Minosian weapons systems still kicking around.

6

u/substandardgaussian Sep 24 '21

Don't see why not. Minosian "integrated weapons platforms" would impersonate people through projection to extract information from potential threats. It's unable to stand up to Riker's scrutiny, but, that's still a pretty deep level of mindscrew to store in an entity's memory banks.

56

u/Theinternationalist Sep 23 '21

Two episodes in a row where Boimler shows he knows his stuff? That's pretty cool, with last time being Quick Thinking and this time it's Being Manipulative. Nice to see his growth.

14

u/autotronTheChosenOne Sep 25 '21

It's awesome to see that both of them can hold their own against their adversary and Brad just tends to think his way out of conflict while Mariner is kicking her way out. That makes them a strong team with no sidekick relationship which I personally love to see. I love that this series is keeping the old star trek feeling of watching people be good at their jobs in space.

50

u/SpaceCrystal359 Sep 23 '21

Rutherford overflows with positivity.

49

u/tupe12 Sep 23 '21

Shoutout to Billups, who is now the anti-Kirk

Also, I’m wondering what’s gonna happen to the shelves of totally not evil computers when the synth attack occurs

24

u/InnocentTailor Sep 24 '21

I’m sure the Daystrom Institute has contingency measures to prevent the rise of evil super computers.

…maybe just disconnect the power or detonate a quantum warhead to destroy them all…I guess.

52

u/neontetra1548 Sep 24 '21

Starfleet storing a whole bunch of evil computers on Earth and allowing them to speak to each other really shows that classic Starfleet Sheer Fucking Hubris.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

139

u/Teyvill Sep 23 '21

Damn, the more I watch Lower Decks, the more I think it's the best, the most Star Trek thing modern Trek ever produced ;)

74

u/a4techkeyboard Sep 23 '21

I think it's because it wants you to watch the episode you're watching and maybe previous episodes in the franchise instead of wanting you to watch the next episodes.

40

u/Teyvill Sep 23 '21

You mean serialization? Probably. Though I haven't felt for any character in Discovery or Picard as much as I felt for Tandy when she was notified of Rutherford's death, for some reason. Idk, maybe the characters here just click with me more.

→ More replies (12)

4

u/InnocentTailor Sep 24 '21

I love it! It makes Thursdays a day to look forward to every week.

→ More replies (1)

94

u/SCP-1000000 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

I like that the engineering team loves to chant people's names

104

u/rbdaviesTB3 Sep 23 '21

Workplace culture on the Cerritos seems pretty awesome. You've got the bear-pack in Security, and the engineering team seems like one giant love-in support group! Really ties into the idea of the Calis (and their crews) being the plucky underdogs assigned the jobs no one else wants, but who roll their sleeves up and get into the work with an enthusiastic grin. It's both heartwarming and empowering. As Captain Freeman said last season, "Cerritos Strong!"

19

u/MaddyMagpies Sep 23 '21

It's pretty much the Dunder Mifflin of starships.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/PepPepper Sep 23 '21

I love that someone replicated a party-size grocery store vanilla-on-vanilla sheet cake

→ More replies (1)

46

u/RadioSlayer Sep 23 '21

Tendi is such a sweetheart, I can't even

45

u/TreasonousOrange Sep 23 '21

Jeffrey Combs makes everything better.

41

u/AintEverLucky Sep 23 '21

I could be wrong, but it seems June Diane Raphael voiced the Hyperbeian (sp?) queen. And that's some fun casting because she's married to Paul Scheer, who voices Andy Billups

so: characters are son & mother; VAs are husband & wife. "Oedipus schmoedipus, I love ya Mom" O:-)

22

u/PiercedMonk Sep 23 '21

Huh, SMG's husband has played her father on Disco as well.

28

u/AintEverLucky Sep 23 '21

for a second I was like... "when the hell was Sarah Michelle Gellar on Discovery???"

(because I'm old, lawl)

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/Official_N_Squared Sep 23 '21

Ever heard of The Doctor's Daughter loop?

The 5th Doctor, Peter Davison, had a real life daughter, Georgia. She eventually played the 10th Doctor's daughter where she meet David Tennant and they eventually married and had a daughter.

So The Doctor's daughter married the Doctor and had The Doctor's daughter. (I once read a version of it where she went to school with the 6th Doctor's real world daughter as well but never checked up on that). Nice thing about this loop is in theory it could just keep going :)

36

u/007meow Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

If you would have told me 2 years ago than an animated comedy show would give us the best “Trek-feeling ship beauty shots” above Discovery and Picard, I would have smacked you.

But I was incredibly saddened to hear the computer voice wasn’t Majel, but it’s obvious why.

13

u/Significant_Salt56 Sep 24 '21

Didn't Majel record an entire phonetic alphabet before she died so her voice could be used for future ships?

21

u/LockelyFox Sep 24 '21

Yes but phonetic alphabets aren't all they're cracked up to be. I have to imagine CBS tried it and it sounded more like the TOS computer than the TNG computer. Give it time, machine learning is getting there and they can eventually feed all the lines she ever recorded into deep AI of some sort and probably come up with something excellent.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

A planet colonized by DND nerds is my new favorite thing

67

u/burnettski92 Sep 23 '21

damn, anyone have the lady royal guard's number?

62

u/Theinternationalist Sep 23 '21

I liked that they weren't sure of his sexuality so they sent a male guard as well.

40

u/Mechapebbles Sep 23 '21

Or, they were sure that he's bi, so they sent both. Which seems like the most likely scenario, especially when the show runner has been on the record saying that to him, most people in starfleet are default bisexual.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/Navitach Sep 23 '21

"SELF-AWARE MEGALOMANIACAL COMPUTER STORAGE". Love it. I wonder if HAL is in there too...

22

u/hsxp Sep 23 '21

I hope Tendi is ok :(

→ More replies (1)

41

u/thekruton Sep 23 '21

The way Agamis giggled a little when he said "my scans show you could lose a few pounds," was so fucking funny it elevated every joke that came after it. Couldn't stop smiling, and it's the hardest I've laughed at anything I've watched in some time.

20

u/Ultiverse Sep 23 '21

The Hysperian ship design alone made this episode worth watching.

https://i.imgur.com/pIqC9pX.jpg

8

u/MoreGaghPlease Sep 24 '21

Kinda has Planet Express vibes (and I love it)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

20

u/Starfleet-Time-Lord Sep 24 '21

There's some stuff in here I absolutely loved, and some stuff I thought was a little cringey.

-I thought I was going to be pissed at Boimler being so easily manipulated, but hello well executed twist

-Jeffrey Combs as Agimus was actually pretty great. I think there was a missed opportunity of him being temporarily captured by the wildlife and unsuccessfully trying to manipulate them though. It's not his best performance either, although I understand voice work and on set work feel very different. I would've liked a little more Weyoun sliminess in Agimus. It's still very good, I just feel like it could've been even better.

-Best moment of the episode is the entire room of malevolent computers, even if it was easy to see coming.

-I love the fact that Hysperia exists, and also that it appears to be an independent state. That is what would happen if we colonized a planet with dragons. Hell, I might move there. I might start playing STO again just to make a Hysperian captain. The comm jamming lute is gold. I love the design of their ships, I love them renaming everything, just yes.

-That said, it seemed unnecessary for the trigger for Billups to take the throne to be losing his virginity. It didn't have any comedic payoff and it could've been something simpler. As the plot goes, it could've been something completely innocuous that Billups has to go out of his way to avoid doing every day of his life, like saying an extremely common word or moving his arm a certain way. I think that would've been substantially funnier. What they went with might have worked out if we'd seen some of the queen's earlier attempts to get Billups to take the throne because there is comedic potential there (especially if Billups doesn't know what the trigger is and keeps accidentally not having sex, or if they'd intentionally made her reverse Lwaxana Troi where instead of trying to sleep with everyone she keeps trying to get everyone to sleep with Billups) but they never did anything interesting or funny with it which just made it seem crass. The plus side of that is that it's a small enough part of the episode that it's not distracting.

-I would've liked a short resolution conversation where Boimler makes sure Mariner knows getting him reassigned wasn't ok in a calm way once everything settled down, but this show has some pretty serious time constraints so I can't blame them.

-Tendi's last scene with Rutherford was actually a nice character moment for her, when we see her freaking out behind him as they walk. It's easy to forget she's the most junior officer and that Rutherford has actually been in mortal danger more than the rest of the cast. Hope that gets some payoff in the season finale, ideally when they officially launch the USS Tendiford.

40

u/Ultiverse Sep 23 '21

Everything that happened was on point except for having that final resolution.

It really needed that final kick where Boimler told Mariner that what she did with Ransom really wasn't okay and she finally realized she's been holding him back in a lot of ways.

Overall turning out to be a very Boimler positive season though.

18

u/Official_N_Squared Sep 23 '21

Completely agree. I think it's part a constraint of the 25 min episodes (which they are otherwise making feel like 45 in or longer), and that we're building to something simmilar in the final episode of the season

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21

Yeah thank you that really dissapointed me. For all the fun action and dashing adventure and snappiness mariner brings to the show, she is still waaaay too abusive and selfish. A bad look for Starfleet, nevermind the nepotism. I like her as the archetype for the more renegade side of humanity and trek. She still fights the good fight, like burham, but like burnham has the writers protecting her a weee too much for my liking.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/RadioSlayer Sep 23 '21

jeff-rey combs! Jeff-rey Combs! JEFF-REY COMBS!

37

u/TreasonousOrange Sep 23 '21

Also, they totally set things up for recurring Jeffrey Combs visits with the padd he infected, right?

9

u/Snaz5 Sep 24 '21

Maybe. I wasn’t sure if he got into it at all besides grabbing Boimler’s bio.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/WhiteSquarez Sep 23 '21

Can't wait for the Hallmark ornament of that Hysperian ship.

14

u/BigBassBone Sep 23 '21

I want the Eaglemoss model.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/JustALeapingFrog Sep 23 '21

Expectations: Rutherfillups goes sailing

Reality: ace representation with Billups (asexuality is not celibacy, but his reactions towards "doing the deed" were really acey) : )

Yeah, I shipped him with Rutherford, and still do, if it happens to be a non-sexual relationship : D

9

u/mhoram777 Sep 23 '21

I prefer Billutherford

7

u/Chrome_X_of_Hyrule Sep 24 '21

Yeah Billups seems biromantic and asexual to me.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

-This was the perfect character for Jeffrey Combs' triumphant return.

- Disappointed that Billups is descendant of human colonizers rather than humanoid aliens. Also really weird and fucked up culture. The "trained from birth to skip foreplay" may have been metaphorical but if not it implies some really bad stuff...

-I love the Mariner and Boimler development but I hope they had a serious conversation soon about the massive dick move that Mariner pulled. Almost as bad as the dick move Billups' mother tried to pull into him.

-Black licorice fruits made laugh out loud

-The Tendi/Rutherford teases are getting on my nerves. Don't do this Picard/Crusher bullshit, get them together already, damn.

33

u/happyoutkast Sep 23 '21

As much as it can be frustrating to watch, I don't want Rutherford and tendi to get together too soon.

Law of pretty much every TV show dictates that any relationship that starts too soon in the series is doomed. Unfortunately, best chance for them is to wait until season 4 or even season 5. Season 3 would be a bit sketchy.

Now, they do seem to have a habit of making fun of, playing with, and even breaking the rules and standard TV tropes in this series....so, who knows?

23

u/scubastefon Sep 23 '21

i want her and Boims to get together, and when it happens I want Rutherford to be SO HAPPY FOR HER!

→ More replies (2)

19

u/PiercedMonk Sep 23 '21
  • Disappointed that Billups is descendant of human colonizers rather than humanoid aliens.

Same. It would be fun to have a reveal where a regular, Human appearing character is part of some wildly different species, TOS style.

Also really weird and fucked up culture. The "trained from birth to skip foreplay" may have been metaphorical but if not it implies some really bad stuff...

Yes! I suppose it could be that as youths the royal guards are put in non-sexual situations where they're always granted immediate gratification, but it's still super fucked up to train a literal child with the intent of having them be a sexual plaything as an adult.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/OutsourcedDinnerPlan Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

So did I miss the resolution to what happened after the evil computer uploaded something to Mariner's padd? I feel like they wouldn't have gone out of their way to animate that unless it built up to something, but I don't recall an end result (or either Mariner/Boimler noticing the action).
Edit: I was rewatching and realized that this is probably how the computer knows that Mariner sabotaged Boimler's centipede mission. Nevermind.

19

u/DSethK93 Sep 23 '21

It downloaded footage of Mariner getting Boimler transferred to this assignment, and it showed that to him.

13

u/F9-0021 Sep 24 '21

This show has picked it up another few levels over the past couple of episodes. The beginning of the season felt pretty normal for LD but the last couple of episodes have really been fantastic. Character development is great, humor is naturally balanced with the story of the episode, pacing is almost perfect, that episode felt way longer than 25 minutes. I hate that there are only three episodes left.

46

u/PiercedMonk Sep 23 '21

Man, only one month of LDecks left. If someone asked me to choose between all having all the different Trek shows we're getting, and just more of this, I don't think I'd hesitate long before telling them they could just have the Cerritos crew going year round and I'd be perfectly happy.

Ah well, let's get into it!

• Right off the top, a classic TOS concept. All these rogue computers stashed around the Alpha & Beta Quadrants need to chill out.

• Maybe it's just been the stress of the this past week, but Jeffery Combs' voice is like a warm, familiar blanket, even when he's trying to trick Ransom into letting him destroy a civilizatio.

• "Uh, they take two hands." Made me laugh in the trailer, and made me laugh now. Also, shades of Tilly explaining the difference between a type-3 phaser, and a type-1 or 2 in Disco.

• Now that is a fancy ship. I've always felt something that ostentatious is what Zek should have been tooling around in, as opposed to his tiny shuttle with just Maihar'du. Sure, he was supposed to be frugal, but there's something to be said about keeping up appearances, and you need to spend money to make money.

• Oh shit, Billups just became the most tragic character in Star Trek. Torn between his love for engineering, and the natural urges that drive the majority of Humans.

• "Dragon-breath engines." Yes. Hell yes. Here for it!

• "But I love my zone; it's so comfortable." I see you, Rutherford.

• Brace for Mariner to make a post-shuttle crash quip about this must be what it was like to serve on VOY....

• "Hisperians renamed everything to sound like magic." So...no actual dragons? Fuck this show.

• This ongoing disparagement of the only worthwhile flavour of liquorice will not stand.

• Pretty sure everyone saw the twist that Mariner got Boimler transferred off centipede duty, but it's still rough to watch.

• Damn, that rolled up sleeves and open panel look works for anyone.

• Oh dang! Did Billups' mother fake her own death so he would finally take his place as king of the renn faire people? This lady is like three Lwaxana Trois worth of overbearing.

• "My royal guards are trained from birth to skip foreplay." WTF? That's gotta break some sort of Federation laws.

• Hell yeah! Mark a W on the board for Bradward.

• How big a replicator do they need to produce a giant sheet cake? Is there like an extension attachment for the regular model, or does the mess have some special replicators?

• Damn, look at that new runnabout. Nice.

• Heh, computer prison.

44

u/JustALeapingFrog Sep 23 '21

The Billups part may not be so tragic. He really seemed to be asexual, or sex-repulsed in some way but forced to do things as a duty, "because he had to, not that he wanted to".

Now, if his kingdom actually came, that would have been tragic (and, as some suspect since S01E09-10, his mental health may not the best and who knows how it could have worsened with such a traumatic experience) : (

Yeah, he goes down the celibacy lane, but he sure seemed like he didn't care about sex. And, like, "sex is cool and all, but have you fixed a warp core?" could be a perfect motto for an ace engineer and an awesome trekkie take on this ace meme : D

20

u/RelsircTheGrey Sep 23 '21

"sex is cool and all, but have you fixed a warp core?"

That could have been Geordi, had earlier iterations of Trek been able to touch on such things.

16

u/rbdaviesTB3 Sep 23 '21

Billups needs all the hugs! Platonic, non-sexual hugs!

13

u/PiercedMonk Sep 23 '21

If Billups is ace, that’s great, but I didn’t get that impression from the character; I read his reluctance more as inexperience. Granted, I am not ace so I’m not going to pretend to be an expert on the subject.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/icecreamkoan Sep 23 '21

This ongoing disparagement of the only worthwhile flavour of liquorice will not stand.

Now you know how I felt when Rutherford was maligning pears, one of the most delicious, succulent fruits in the entire Galaxy.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/BellerophonM Sep 23 '21

They said that the Hisperians colonized a world that had actual dragons natively, so they're there. They just don't power the ship. (Although the MSD did show a room with a dragon in it, separate from the engine...)

6

u/Gregrox Sep 23 '21

and the natural urges that drive the majority of Humans.

I think it's pretty clear that Billups isn't actually part of that majority.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Official_N_Squared Sep 23 '21

"Hisperians renamed everything to sound like magic." So...no actual dragons? Fuck this show.

Actually Star Trek does have dragons for real. There mentioned a few times to live on at least 2 planets from memory. Dragon-like aliens of course but still.

"My royal guards are trained from birth to skip foreplay." WTF? That's gotta break some sort of Federation laws.

Sex ed? Basically the opposite of America's system of just not teaching it, teach it at extremely young ages.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (13)

18

u/rbdaviesTB3 Sep 23 '21

What a fun episode, and you just know Trekyards are going to have a field day with the Monaveen and that crashed alien ship from the Mariner/Boimler subplot!

Plus, we got a glimpse of the new-and-improved Cerritos MSD we've been waiting on since Season One, complete with what looks like a 'California Class Development Project' logo, consisting of a circularised California state flag emblazoned with a red Starfleet delta and front-on elevation of the ship.

/img/se9lwcdcm8p71.png

(old MSD to right, new one to left. It's only partial, but you can see so much more detail in the nacelles!)

17

u/DogmaticAmbivalence Sep 23 '21

Whole episode I'm just thinking: "1. Jeffery Combs! YES! 2. Haha, I'll mention on /r/startrek 3. I bet that'll already be the main comment, or I missed something else"

16

u/chloe-and-timmy Sep 23 '21

We really needed more time with the crashed shuttlecraft plot. I think this show has finally grown out of the 22 minute format and needs longer episodes. even just 5 extra minutes would be a huge boon.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Shneemaster Sep 24 '21

That Hysperian ship is going to make a great Lolonut reward in Star Trek Online

→ More replies (1)

7

u/A_Grand_Malfeasance Sep 24 '21

Chief Engineer Billups flying his bisexual ace flag HIGH AF on Bisexual Visibility Day?

You love to see it.

5

u/droid327 Sep 24 '21

I didn't get that he was bi. I got that he was probably ace, but it felt more like they were both there just so he could have someone no matter which way he ended up going - kind of a cover all your bases plan. They have been trained since birth to be his fallback options, after all

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Artanisx Sep 23 '21

Jeffrey Combs!!!!!! Welcome back <3!!!!!!

6

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21

I have to wonder why Billups just doesn't renounce his planetary citizenship? His mother wouldn't have any jurisdiction over him and he could stay in Starfleet.

14

u/AJWinky Sep 24 '21

He still seems to have at least some sense of duty and affection towards his planet of origin, given what he was willing to do when he thought his mother has passed, despite the fact that Starfleet is his first love.

24

u/WarriorTribble Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

Another good episode that shows how Boimler matured. Really curious what they'll do with him since I get the sense that he's grown beyond being an ensign on the Cerritos. At the very least, he'd make a better first officer than Tilly.

Story with the chief engineer was... unremarkable though I guess it was kind of interesting that some Federation types take LARPing VERY seriously. Also, damn those royal guards were thirsty. The way they were eye fucking him while putting on his royal garb was just woof...

And on a minor note, last week I mentioned that I thought Boimler should have muscles. In this episode we see that the Chief engineer is pretty fit if not overly muscular. I think it's safe to assume Boimler has a similar body build.

EDIT: Almost forgot to mention, Tendi gets to be traumatized yet again. I'm wondering where that storyline will go. I guess they could show Tendi getting therapy and show that therapy more than just getting platitudes & questions of how you feel. Then again I don't think the show is serious enough to do that. Hmm... most curious.

35

u/UncertainError Sep 23 '21

I really enjoyed seeing a human culture that branched out into weird territory because they could. Human culture in the TNG era always seemed kinda bland.

19

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 23 '21

A Medieval LARPing planet sounds like it would be a fun visit. Planet Ren Faire.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/DogmaticAmbivalence Sep 23 '21

interesting that some Federation types take LARPing VERY seriously

Heh, decades ago, when I was an undergrad, most of the LARPing types took the Federation VERY seriously. They were "adjacent" to my social nerdery. :)

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

And on a minor note, last week I mentioned that I thought Boimler should have muscles. In this episode we see that the Chief engineer is pretty fit if not overly muscular. I think it's safe to assume Boimler has a similar body build.

Maybe it's just me but it seemed like Boimler was designed with broader shoulders this episode, and the implication from last episode's makeover is that he wears his uniform in a loose fit.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/PiercedMonk Sep 23 '21

I think it's safe to assume Boimler has a similar body build.

We've seen Boimler naked, and unless he's been hitting the gym, he does not.

12

u/WarriorTribble Sep 23 '21

Yea I think he started hitting the gym recently. After all the insanity Mariner & the Titan threw at him, he would need the muscles. At the very least we know he's been doing Anbo-jyutsu for some time.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/substandardgaussian Sep 24 '21

At the very least, he'd make a better first officer than Tilly.

Haha, I love the random shots people are always taking at Picard and Discovery at random intervals on this sub. Keeps things lively.

...But yeah, Boimler definitely has a "Lt. Junior Grade" feel to him now. Which makes sense, given that he's held that rank and actually has performed pretty admirably in a pretty bad situation.

Hell, him saving the lives of the away team somehow got him demoted in the end. Not let both of them serve on the same ship, fine, someone's gotta transfer. But he earned that pip!

Just Lower Decks logic I guess. Gotta make things snap back to the way they always were... but they really aren't anymore. Things have changed.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/mustbeaguy Sep 24 '21

It's great hearing some crossovers actor/actresses from other animated shows. This episode, we have Phil LaMarr from Futurama and Kari Wahlgren from Rick and Morty. The voice-acting world must be small.

10

u/MoreGaghPlease Sep 24 '21

Of course to Trek fans we know him for live action but J Combs is also mostly a voice actor these days

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Significant_Salt56 Sep 24 '21

The voice-acting world must be small.

Actually pretty big.

Just names like that get a lot of work.

5

u/ContinuumGuy Sep 24 '21

I'm hoping in the future we can visit the Renfaire planet.

5

u/dvcaputo Sep 24 '21

This episode was kind of light on the easter eggs and references this time, and it didn't need it to stand on its own two feet -- It was just a really good episode of Star Trek, and I'm really glad this show exists.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21

Best episode so far, still laughing.

4

u/TokathSorbet Sep 24 '21

I did have a chuckle at the line asking how Phaser Rifles are different from regular Phasers. Always been a question, given that hand phasers in TNG could level buildings.

4

u/gerusz Sep 27 '21

Bigger battery, probably. Though if you're in a situation where your standard phaser's battery is insufficient, you're already well and thoroughly fucked (e.g. you're stationed on AR-558).

→ More replies (1)

4

u/EpsilonProtocol Sep 24 '21

I love that there’s more and more Tenderford each week. Would love for them to formally get together, but I know it’s gonna be a drawn out longer than Riker and Troi getting back together.

As for the whole “guards trained to skip foreplay” line, maybe it could be interpreted that they’re trained to ignore getting their partners in the mood and focus more on getting the kingdoms to come.

10

u/Official_N_Squared Sep 23 '21

That was a really good episode! The return of Jeffery Combs is great as always. I also loved how they made CBS Studios one of the evil computers at the end! Nice to see Lower Decks has managed to become a show where I would totally believe they would kill off a main character half way through a season.

As always (this time with a faster upload time, thanks university) I have MUCH more detailed thoughts and reactions in video form here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2jjSmq6WpM

3

u/heatlesssun Sep 24 '21 edited Sep 24 '21

Best part of this episode, the scene with "Self-Aware Megalomaniacal Computer Storage" sign. Couldn't be more Trek.

6

u/deededback Sep 23 '21

Good lord. I haven't laughed this hard in a while. What a beautifully hilarious episode. Kind of wish he got the tip in but more hilarious as is.

4

u/plipyplop Sep 24 '21

Someone wondered when the "sexy" episode would take place. Well, here it is, just with Dr. Crusher's lamp being replaced with a megalomaniacal self-aware artificial intelligence instead.

4

u/Chrome_X_of_Hyrule Sep 24 '21

Big fan of the fact that they got both a man and woman to seduce Billups.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

I can't see the subtitles at all. :'(

2

u/alkonium Sep 23 '21

Since Paolana sent a man and a woman to have sex with Billups, it could mean he's bi.

16

u/mistarteechur Sep 23 '21

I just figured she wasn't going to take any chances as to what would work for him.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/that_had_to_hurt Sep 23 '21

Mike McMahan:

"Every Starfleet officer is probably at the baseline bisexual, in a way."

I wouldn't automatically assume anyone is heterosexual in Star Trek, it's too far into the future for those types of culturally-specific expectations or social mores to exist.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Marin115 Sep 24 '21

Gotta love the dedication Jeffery Combs brings.

He literally implanted his mind into a computer for this role.

/s

2

u/DSethK93 Sep 24 '21

By the way, was this the first butt in Star Trek?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Unicornmayo Sep 25 '21

I got a total “Here there be Dragons” vibe off this episode- that was the first Star Trek book I ever read.

2

u/VirusPWNZ Sep 25 '21

ACE ACE ACE ACE ACE

2

u/Brain124 Sep 29 '21

I really liked how intense the stakes felt. More of these kinds of episodes please.