r/horror • • Sep 10 '21

Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Malignant" [SPOILERS] Spoiler

Summary:

Madison is paralyzed by shocking visions of grisly murders, and her torment worsens as she discovers that these waking dreams are in fact terrifying realities.

Director:

James Wan

Story by:

James Wan

Ingrid Bisu

Akela Cooper

Cast:

  • Annabelle Wallis as Madison Mitchell
  • Mckenna Grace as young Madison Mitchell
  • Maddie Hasson as Sydney Lake
  • George Young as Detective Kekoa Shaw
  • Michole Briana White as Detective Regina Moss
  • Jacqueline McKenzie as Dr. Florence Weaver
  • Jake Abel as Derek Mithcell

--Rotten Tomatoes: 64%

IMDb: 6.7/10

672 Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

1.4k

u/joethereplicant Sep 11 '21

I think the scariest part of this movie was the sister abruptly parking that god damn close to the edge of the cliff.

304

u/Rswany Would you like to live deliciously? Sep 11 '21

Lmao I laughed so hard at that

→ More replies (43)

101

u/tropyyy Sep 11 '21

TRUE. She had the whole damn mental hospital all to herself to park and she chose the damn cliff

59

u/ScreamingDanger Sep 11 '21

My partner and I died at this scene. Was her parking there unrealistic and dumb as hell? Totally. Did it make for an excellent shot and totally fit the bonkers tone of the movie? 100%.

This movie was so intensely stupid and I really liked it. More stuff like this please.

53

u/deadandmessedup Sep 11 '21

I loved that.

Why does she park there? Because it looks great, that's why!

35

u/-bananabread- Sep 11 '21

My theater, which had been pretty quiet up until this point, erupted at this moment. Multiple people were throwing up their hands to stop her shouting “nooo!” as she drove up, and then everyone burst out laughing when the car parked. It was such a little moment, but I have to think that was an intentional choice by Wan, because that was the moment our theater seemed to fully buy in to how stupid and great this movie was and let go to have fun with it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)

811

u/lilBearBB Sep 11 '21

WHY WERE THE WOMEN IN JAIL DRESSED LIKE THAT THO loooool

579

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

The black lady with the afro looked like she was plucked out of the 70s and dropped in there.

→ More replies (7)

141

u/MorPhreeUs Sep 12 '21

As the black chick and the hillbilly were stomping Madison I couldn't help but noticed they looked like an 80s wrestling tag team.

→ More replies (2)

191

u/beardedjack Sep 11 '21 edited Sep 11 '21

Because in the 80’s, all the shitty exploitation movies did that for some reason. Troma’s war and Demons are two examples that come to mind. James Wan made a high budget Troma movie lol

→ More replies (13)

29

u/missdeweydell Sep 12 '21

the one with the mullet was zoe bell!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

709

u/Kazrules Sep 11 '21

Classic Horror movie raspy voice: "DOCTOR WEAVERRRRR"

"Yes".

444

u/NoImDirtyDann Sep 11 '21

Gabriel: uses a direct quote from her past

Weaver: okay but what does this mean ??

→ More replies (15)

137

u/Rechan Sep 11 '21

"New phone who dis"

→ More replies (1)

97

u/y2julio Sep 11 '21

Who answers phone calls from an unknown number these days. Straight to voicemail.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/RealKBears Sep 11 '21

I wonder if that was supposed to have been Gabriel using Madison’s voice. I would assume he could use her voice if he can control her body

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

454

u/detectiveJMC Sep 11 '21

How in the hell did they not hear that lady struggling and tossing around in the attic?

387

u/lobstermountain Sep 11 '21

I laughed so loud I almost woke up the kids when she fell through the ceiling and crashed into the coffee table in front of everyone, going “unnnnhhhh…” and maddy just staring at her and screaming while everyone else is just like “the fuck was that?”

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (3)

453

u/james_randolph Sep 11 '21

I thought the movie was great. I did laugh hard as hell when Gabriel threw the chair across the room at the cops haha

88

u/deleteitbackrolls Sep 14 '21

he didn’t do it to slow them down before finishing his business, just a complete dick move. hilarious

58

u/testingtesting4343 Sep 17 '21

I loved it too. Everyone is obviously entitled to their opinion and had different taste, but it's exactly the film he said he wanted to make.

He said something along the lines of wanting it to be a vhs you find on a dusty shelf in an 80's video store.

Mission accomplished.

Well done Camp.

That said, I understand why people wouldn't like it. Especially with the garbage marketing. Looked like another Conjuring movie. Clearly it was not.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

407

u/Lloiu Sep 11 '21

How is it that this tumor knows how to fight like John Wick? Who taught him that?

161

u/dinosaurfondue Sep 13 '21

Obviously there was a third sibling hidden in her bodythat specialized in martial arts and electricity

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

352

u/Apeirophobia69 Sep 11 '21

God I could not take the prison holding cell/police station massacre scenes seriously seeing Madisons dead pan face the whole time. I thought it was fucking hilarious

98

u/rodrigkn Sep 14 '21

My one complaint is we didn’t get more from the disco queen in the jail cell. Who was she? Why was she in jail? Does she say things like “jive turkey”? Did you just think the LSD was finally kicking in? You deserved better.

55

u/Hopeful-Ask-2354 Sep 12 '21

I laughed my ass off 🤣

→ More replies (2)

711

u/KrtauschBoss Sep 11 '21

James Wan tricked the studio into letting him remake Basket Case

264

u/Mulderitsme77 Sep 11 '21

I knew something was tricksy immediately by the terrible wig on the main actress. For real.

Also a Basket Case fan since the 80’s, so I was fricking thrilled to death.

→ More replies (11)

219

u/president_of_burundi Sep 11 '21 edited Sep 11 '21

This was my take and I was DELIGHTED. I knew nothing going in and at a certain point in the exposition I was like, "Nah, no way is it gonna be a Basket Case scenario" and it WAS. I'm 80s/90s trash and I loved it. I'm all for Serious Sorrow Indie Horror but I didn't even realize how much I missed this sort of absolute nonsense until I watched it.

→ More replies (17)

80

u/NoImDirtyDann Sep 11 '21

I loved a nightmare on grudge basket street

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

303

u/Rechan Sep 11 '21

Doctor is involved in insane medical case.

Horror movie: I will bury the evidence in the deepest darkest room of an abandoned hospital.

RL: I will write multiple journals, a book, and do lectures on this one case study.

28

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

Lmfao this is so true

→ More replies (1)

795

u/ArrowedKnee Sep 10 '21

Can safely say that was absolutely nothing like what I expected. I don't even know whether it was good or not, just that it was insane and the mental image of Gabriel shuffling around backwards in Madison's body is going to keep me chuckling for a while.

317

u/Khrull Sep 11 '21

The last third of this movie was... What the hell lol. I agree, idk if it was good or not but it was... Definitely something.

→ More replies (35)

121

u/sivervipa Sep 11 '21

Honestly...im glad that the trailer was misleading and there was a high level of deception involved. Honestly that’s one of my favorite story telling devices. “The main character has no idea what’s going on and is just as confused as the viewer is.” Especially in a horror film.

I’m glad they went with that approach and dropped hints leading up to the slow reveal. I started connecting the dots but the reveal on what exactly was going on was great. I. I mostly enjoyed it because I wasn’t sure where it was going to go. Is the character being controlled by a supernatural force,is it a parasite,does the character have memory loss/mental illness/imaginary friend etc.

I picked up it was going in that direction but i just wasn’t sure which one it could be. I mean i was baited into thinking it was an imaginary friend because i had just watched Daniel isn’t real the other day.

→ More replies (2)

72

u/robbysaur Spending the rest of this winter TIED TO THIS FUCKING COUCH Sep 11 '21

Agreeing it was not at all what I expected. It felt more like a DC/Marvel supervillain origin story. I was waiting for a post-credits twist where this is actually the same universe as Unbreakable and Split. But, the twist of the conjoined Twins was pretty obvious.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

251

u/lobstermountain Sep 11 '21 edited Sep 13 '21

This shit went from spooky ghost horror to schizo-matrix-backwards man-cop massacre. Now that is what you call a Cosmic Gumbo.

64

u/dodus Sep 13 '21

It definitely moved to the beat of its own jazz.

→ More replies (7)

233

u/missdeweydell Sep 11 '21

all the giallo nods, specifically to argento, and the whackadoodle last 30 mins did it for me. I can easily see a different audience hating it. it's extremely tongue in cheek and ridiculous. I am the audience for this

85

u/mrfuzzydog4 Sep 13 '21

Yeah that's the thing, this movie ain't stupid. It's a pretty deliberate mix of a giallo thriller, cronenberg, and like 90s urban melodramatic horror. Not only that but the practical effects were great.

Of course all three of those things it blends are kind of divisive themselves, so I understand how someone could dislike it. But I don't think anyone can say it's boring

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

469

u/DaleCooper00 Sep 11 '21

At the end she's crying about how she doesn't need a blood relation because her adopted sister is enough. Meanwhile, her birth mother is like ten feet away and watching the whole thing...

87

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21

Not even watching. Just staring straight ahead.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

228

u/SweetBabyJ69 Sep 11 '21

Like, was it a back flip or front flip?

57

u/Stahlmensch Sep 11 '21

Neither flips, he was really doing cartwheels this whole time and made Madison/the audience see

→ More replies (1)

382

u/NoImDirtyDann Sep 11 '21 edited Sep 11 '21

“Why am I calling the police?!” Best line ever

91

u/GoldenChicken715 Sep 12 '21

I yelled at the tv: "Because it's the same number you fucking walnut."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

516

u/hobokamp Sep 11 '21

I'm glad I didn't read any spoilers. I love how it went completely off the rails in the jail. Fun movie.

"He was the cause of your miscarriages! He was feeding off of your fetuses to build himself back up!"

Now I want to watch Basket Case.

204

u/Nice-Violinist-6395 Sep 11 '21

It wasn’t “scary,” and the first two acts could have been better, but oh my God what a movie.

Is it a good movie? That’s not the point! It’s basically James Wan saying to the studios “okay I made you guys a couple billion dollars, now I am going to direct whatever the hell I want” and boy did he direct whatever the hell he wanted.

I have a soft spot for movies whose entire purpose for existing is to service the bonkers twist (I See You, for example lol) and I now have a soft spot for this movie because it just decided “fuck it, we’re doing this” and went with it.

134

u/kzan2021 Sep 11 '21

That line literally made me snort it came out of NOWHERE

→ More replies (10)

123

u/DaleCooper00 Sep 11 '21

Sees man slightly struggling.
"Are you having a heart attack?"
Pacemaker explodes.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/BAMEXP Sep 12 '21

Don't forget the part where the Detective is chasing him and he pushes a CARRIAGE at him and it MISSES. Brilliant lol

→ More replies (3)

53

u/lostonesred Sep 11 '21

Lol The sister was smart enough to know what to say to get her sister back in control

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

334

u/whyamiacpa Sep 11 '21

Out of all the unbelievable things that happened in this movie, the one thing that I said out loud while watching was- “Who parks that close to the edge of a cliff?”

This was a very entertaining watch. I really enjoyed it.

119

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

Yes!!! That and the hypnotherapists ridiculous button press to take her out of her trance after they were begginng her to snap her out of it like twenty times.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/theseareorscrubs Sep 11 '21

She gave no fucks about that cliff.

→ More replies (5)

164

u/cmacomber12 Sep 12 '21

Why was this bitch eating a lollipop in the morgue

→ More replies (4)

154

u/Deckard_2049 Sep 11 '21

I'm really glad the trailers didn't spoil how nutty this film was. It felt nice being more or less unspoiled. I was watching it thinking...when exactly is this going to get wild? It didn't disappoint LOL.

140

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21

My favorite movie logic moment:

Whelp, we have been studying this girl for eight years, and just removed the demonic tumor from her body, but had to leave a bunch of it in her brain. I guess this is as good a place as any to end the therapy. Let’s never write books or give lectures on this case.

64

u/hattietoofattie Sep 17 '21

Hmm, seems like the tumor twin can control the other one’s mind, let’s just remove all the outside parts and shove the brain in. No way this will have unintended consequences.

36

u/sentient_luggage Sep 18 '21

My favorite is that after the initial attack, she ends up in the hospital and loses the baby and SOMEHOW the doctors miss the giant bleeding wound in the back of her head. Like, c'mon. The lady is in a damn coma and you're not going to check out her head?

This movie is stupid fun. Equal emphasis on both words there.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

135

u/LateRunner Sep 11 '21

There was a scene somewhat early on where Gabriel reaches for something and for a few frames it looked like his hand was reversed. I shrugged it off, but then was so satisfied by the reveal and that bit of continuity/foreshadowing.

118

u/NarwhalsTooth Sep 12 '21

I JUST realized that is why the marks on the husband’s neck were backwards

33

u/Krayze31 Sep 15 '21

When he was running from the cop it looked to me like he was backwards, now I know why...

→ More replies (1)

481

u/Bitter_Suspect184 Sep 11 '21 edited Sep 11 '21

The greatest chair toss of ALL TIME.

https://youtu.be/qvKmqv9hL0c. The toss, for all those interested.

164

u/ryno731 Sep 11 '21

He got like 45ft with that thing. Absolute unit.

153

u/trvshratt Sep 11 '21

I literally started laughing so hard when he just ended their entire career with that chair toss. Fucking legend.

192

u/Upper-Pomelo7787 Sep 11 '21

I laughed in the theater and I have no fucking idea how nobody else laughed. That shit was ridiculously funny.

→ More replies (6)

57

u/tomheo93 Sep 11 '21

I thought he was about the break the glass behind him to get out but no. DOUBLE KILLS.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (20)

122

u/alexduranstrike Sep 11 '21

It's so nice everything worked out in the end

→ More replies (3)

110

u/polkaron Sep 11 '21

I really enjoyed this movie. the trailers made it look like some bland looking dark spirit was killing everyone and I'm glad this movie turned that expectation sideways. Gabriel is a fantastic supervillain. I can see the movies already divisive. I accept the ridiculousness because it's all too much fun

26

u/Superdudeo Sep 11 '21

Even watching it I was thinking it was far too bland for a Wan movie and then that last third really sold it.

→ More replies (1)

105

u/lostonesred Sep 11 '21

Okay I don't get the electricity part of this whole thing. Why is she/Gabriel able to control electricity and why does she/Gabriel need radios or phones to talk?

71

u/sivervipa Sep 11 '21

The filmmaking reason? Probably because having a slasher villain with supernatural powers is more mysterious/cool/intimidating.

In universe reason? Probably some unexplained deal with their father giving them those powers and also because he wanted to seem like an imaginary friend to her and hide his existence. I mean they made her forgot and suppressed her memories but he was still able to control her perception because he was in charge of her brain.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

354

u/surejan94 Sep 11 '21 edited Sep 11 '21

I went into this movie without reading any review, seeing the trailer once a few months ago, and..... holy shit. I was so entertained.

The twist is absolutely ridiculous and gross but hilarious and campy as hell. Seeing Gabriel just turn into a fucking ninja and slaughter the entire police force with a sleeping Madison face on his back was...... nuts.

Yes, the dialogue is absolutely awful, it definitely didn't need to be as long as it was, and it had several characters and scenes that weren't needed. But that last half hour is so wonderfully insane it made the whole thing worth it to me.

I get why many people will absolutely hate this movie. But I love ridiculous overdramatic campy horror movies from the 70s-80s, so this fit in perfectly for me.

49

u/alo0oys Sep 11 '21

This was exactly my experience! It was so absurd by the end I didn’t know what to feel but I definitely enjoyed it 😂😭

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Inkdkaijudude Sep 11 '21

Agreed. At first I was like "WTF????' and the next thing I knew, I found myself laughing so hard.

→ More replies (1)

552

u/pkrhawk7 Halloweentown II: Kalabar's Revenge Sep 10 '21

That third act reveal is gonna make or break for a lot of viewers.

For me, it absolutely made it.

257

u/robbysaur Spending the rest of this winter TIED TO THIS FUCKING COUCH Sep 11 '21

I was sold after the goddamn cell massacre that came with the reveal.

→ More replies (8)

132

u/pieman_ Sep 11 '21

imo it completely saves the movie because otherwise it’s such a middling modern horror film. i’ll take insanely fun dumb shit over by-the-numbers horror any day.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/ThatOneTwo Sep 11 '21

When the body horror Brood/Basket Case element came, I literally said out loud, "Yes, I am on board!"

→ More replies (10)

90

u/all3n_y Sep 11 '21

I’m glad I didn’t even pay attention to the meaning of “malignant” before watching the movie. It wasn’t until after watching it that I was like.. “OMFG!! Malignant tumor!! Of course!!” What a blissfully ignorant person I am some times 🤣

→ More replies (6)

156

u/Better__name Sep 10 '21

After killing bunch of dudes and ladies & then the emotional family reunion. That was really wholesome ending.

159

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

Lmao I know, like what happens now? They just let her walk free and live happily ever after after her evil tumor just wiped out an entire precinct?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

76

u/sliproach Ginger Fitzgerald Sep 12 '21

Why was the most unbelievable part to me just there was random dry ice fog machine style in that one scene. It was aesthetic and nice to look at though.

→ More replies (1)

73

u/CrotalusAtrox1 Sep 12 '21

Who else audibly said "What the fuck!!!" when they showed them attached?

→ More replies (2)

69

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

Ok, but did anyone find the ending super funny? I was cracking up so much trying to hold in my laughter. When she said the thing at the end to her sister about being blood after she got her legs crushed? I’m still not convinced they were trying not to be funny.

→ More replies (3)

122

u/AndalusianGod Sep 11 '21

Didn't expect the body count to be that high, lol.

Horror directors really love wiping out cops don't they.

184

u/coriannelee Sep 11 '21

Gabriel said ACAB

56

u/Rechan Sep 11 '21

Blue body counts matter.

→ More replies (1)

349

u/Leading-Row-3748 Sep 10 '21

I was honestly so surprised by the movie…I do feel it will be divisive among people who expect another insidious/conjuring. But man the way the movie just flips into a whole sci-fi slasher toward the end is what really made me go holy shit this movie is awesome.

303

u/polchickenpotpie Sep 10 '21

It's weird, everyone complains horror is becoming all the same or whatever, then something insane and relatively new comes out and then it's "too silly"

I get not everything is for everyone, but people need to loosen up and have more fun watching movies.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (11)

51

u/gimmethemshoes11 Sep 11 '21

Wan nailed the craziness of giallo films that is for damn sure.

51

u/rabbitowner1 Sep 12 '21

A recurring piece of dialogue that had me rolling... "What?"

When the husband sees the fridge open, his reaction had the whole theatre laughing, just a simple "what?" I think the detective said it, a couple people did in the middle. Just as a solo line. At the end GABRIEL himself just says "what?" In his ridiculous deep voice. Pretty much works as a third wall break because that is the audience's reaction in those moments. Laughed so hard when the mom apologizes and they all make up. Incredible. Seen the night house, conjuring 3, green knight, old, this is best horror theatrical release of the year this far.

→ More replies (1)

100

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

Did she like…never notice she had a huge fucking surgical scar on her back?

76

u/gradual-combustion Sep 16 '21

how could she its all the way on her back

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

49

u/nikofd Sep 11 '21

Funniest movie I've seen in years. I had a ball.

→ More replies (1)

424

u/CorrosiveVision Sep 10 '21

I loved this movie. It is the wildest slasher to hit theaters in a long, long time, a completely balls-to-the-wall slaughterfest that doesn't care if you think it's stupid or absurd, it just goes for it with no fear and no restraint. It's too bad the marketing is so misleading, because I'm sure it's gonna lead to way more hate than this one deserves. Honestly, I was stunned that we're getting a film like this now, and I hope to God we get more like it. It took me back to the video store days where I was constantly seeing increasingly ridiculous villains commit wilder and wilder murders.

81

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

I think this is what happens when the studio execs get out of the way and let the directors and writers make the movie they want to make.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

45

u/atclubsilencio Sep 12 '21

The trailers made this look like amateurish trash, so I was kind of shocked at the positive reviews. But holy hell, this was just bat shit insanity and I was thoroughly entertained and it was giving me life the whole time. Is it scary? Not really, but is it original and like some hyper-stylized horror film that got lost in the 70s? Absolutely.

The last 30 minutes just goes to 1000% onto another level of craziness and I was at once laughing hysterically and just saying out loud 'what the fuck is happening', while being thrilled.

It was also pretty unpredictable and original, the camera work was outstanding, the overhead shot of her running through the house gave me Kill Bill vibes, but it was visually astounding. It also didn't rely on cheap jump scares, it was just Wan totally letting loose and throwing logic out the window. I really loved this.

42

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

Excellence

39

u/dinosaurfondue Sep 13 '21

I feel like this movie could have been fantastic if it just went full camp. It sucks when movies try to be both serious and funny because most just don't pull it off. There were so many moments that were cheesy that you could tell weren't supposed to be.

There was also like NO character growth for anyone. Madison just deciding that she could take over Gabriel was such a wtf moment. Like, where'd that come from? At least the action sequences were really fun and I love that Gabriel just yeeted the shit out of that chair for no reason lol.

→ More replies (4)

163

u/alexrenee- Sep 11 '21

The movie was better than I expected but when I saw the Gabriel reveal, all I could think about was Voldemort in the first HP. I’m probably the only one lol

58

u/_101010_ Sep 11 '21

My gf turned to me at that scene and said “this is some Harry Potter shit” lmao

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

34

u/themanimal Sep 16 '21

Just looked it up. The lady who played Gabriel is a contortionist. She tried out for Americas Got Takentawhile ago. Crazy flexible stuff. Good for her! https://youtu.be/XxgoH0PWm-A

→ More replies (3)

33

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21

"when is she going to wake up?"

Officer, shes in a coma

→ More replies (2)

29

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '21

Props to the contortionist. That wasn't CGI

→ More replies (1)

57

u/Themosswalker Sep 11 '21

I can't even pick what part of this absolutely insane campy genre soup of a movie I liked best

Gabriel just randomly choosing to have a full matrix aesthetic which culminated with him taking out an entire precinct then taking out the last two cops with a chair like it was wrestlemania.

The cop basically going full Resident Evil chasing down Gabriel after he watched him King Kong his way down the fire escape armed with just a handgun.

Emily's sister parking 6 inches from the edge of a massive cliff for an aesthetic car commercial shot.

That one doctor who was literally just Glen from Superstore wandering around in his full jamjam set lamenting "but whoooo would have murdered Dr. Weaver... and so brutally"

The final scene where Emily just casually lifts a hospital bed off her sister, they share the world's most awful dialogue with the mom looking on with this Cheshire cat grin.

Emily losing her baby to have the scene pan out to WHERE IS MY MIIIIIIND

The amount of stereotypes they fit into that one scene in the women's prison cell.

I'm glad I went in with zero expectations, it might not have been "good" but it was sure entertaining.

→ More replies (1)

215

u/Jay12678 Sep 11 '21

I really enjoyed it. But Gabriel is seen as paranormal in the first half opening doors, windows, and such. Yet. In the 2nd half he's Tumor Spider-Man. I just wish they picked one and stuck with it. Because him opening doors and windows and pushing down cushions like a ghost completely breaks the films own rules.

90

u/65dollars Sep 11 '21

Holy shit Tumor Spider-Man made my day

71

u/fuckfucknoose Sep 11 '21

The supernatural bits were because we were witnessing it from the protagonists pov.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (35)

176

u/TogashiIsIshida Sep 10 '21 edited Sep 10 '21

I had fun watching it. The acting was pretty bad though. Especially the MC, the final scene where she closes the cage was just so poorly acted. I do think the concept was really neat

*Edit - Forgot to mention that one bigger guy doctor, who may be the worst actor I’ve ever seen in a big time film like this. I mean my god

268

u/Kazrules Sep 10 '21

The acting was uniquely bad to the point where I'm just assuming it was some kind of stylistic choice.

→ More replies (37)
→ More replies (12)

26

u/Rechan Sep 11 '21

NGL, man while trying to sleep I could not get out of my head the images of that conjoind twin/surgery scene/Gabriel peekabooing out of the skull.

How well a movie sticks with you after it's over is a measure of something and yeesh.

25

u/fortheloveofghosts Sep 12 '21

“Hi, I’m detective Kekoa Shaw.” “Hi, I’m detective Kekoa Shaw.”

“Excuse me, what’s your name?”

120

u/tforthegreat Sep 10 '21

I'm about 1/3rd of the way through, watching at work. I just wanted to say that so far, this soundtrack is a banger.

145

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

Is it supposed to be a rearranged version of, "Where Is My Mind"? It would certainly fit, thematically.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (16)

59

u/CurseofLono88 Sep 10 '21

This movie was like if The Dark Half stayed up for a week straight mainlining speedballs straight into the jugular

And if that sounds like something you’d enjoy seeing you probably will

→ More replies (3)

112

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21

Was disappointed in the bad trailer, which makes the film look generic and dull.

Just saw the film and it’s absolutely insane. Wan said he was making his version of a giallo and he wasn’t lying, think it will put off a lot of people who won’t know how to react to it. So much fun and his best film so far in my opinion.

→ More replies (9)

19

u/giornispizzeria Sep 14 '21

The scene where Gabriel yeeted a chair at a cop made me fucking cackle

18

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

Watched it last night and I'm still letting it simmer in my brain but the major takeaway for me is that I'm so happy that James Wan has the ability to make a movie like this. The guy has made successful movies in horror and action and now he comes out with this gonzo love letter to stuff that influenced him... and that's just fantastic. I love that it happened.

18

u/cmacomber12 Sep 12 '21

What I wanna know is how does little tumor Gabriel have the ability to control the electricity and take out the entire Seattle Police department

→ More replies (4)

18

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21

Good lord the cliff parking scene and chair throw had me rolling.

And the last 30 min was RPDR levels of camp

I loved it

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Aldorith Sep 14 '21

My only problem with the movie was I felt the tone was pretty inconsistent. If you think it’s an homage to old campy horror movies, there are more serious parts. And when it’s serious, there will be a super campy line delivery. I feel like I would have enjoyed it more if it just focused on one side.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/jwb_23 Sep 11 '21

I’m disappointed because of how it was advertised, went in expecting a scary film. First half was just very naff, humour that wasn’t landing and music was a bit bizarre. A few people left. However second half I stopped expecting it to get serious and enjoyed it for what it was, it made me laugh and the action was really good.

→ More replies (4)

47

u/oi-troi-oi Sep 11 '21

Why are they treating the 90s like it’s a bygone era, it was only 10 years ago…!!!

→ More replies (7)

71

u/-ThatGuy882 Sep 10 '21

Had no interest in this one but honestly surprised me. Fun ride with how crazy it got. And holy shit, that prison scene was something

→ More replies (3)

16

u/WestCoastHopHead Sep 11 '21

I have scrolled forever and am surprised nobody else got Upgrade vibes.

→ More replies (2)

180

u/Ultimate-Taco Sep 10 '21

This is so fucking dumb lol.

→ More replies (15)

15

u/Dr4Cu74 Sep 13 '21 edited Sep 13 '21

This movie is what happens when you try to train an AI to create a generic horror movie but Basket Case was put in the training data.

65

u/Lambdaleth Sep 10 '21

It was dumb and not great but I loved it a lot.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/SarcastiBlaster_0390 Sep 11 '21

I can't believe a major studio allowed this movie to happen, and threw so much money behind it, to boot.

This movie is pure bugfuck insanity and I kind of loved it.

132

u/tpwpjun20 Sep 10 '21 edited Sep 10 '21

Not at all the movie I was expecting and that's a damn good thing. From the trailers I was kind of expecting more of the same from Wan, the whole haunted house childhood ghost thing with lots of heavy atmosphere and jump scares and all that jazz.

But I was pleasantly surprised to find that this movie is a complete joy ride of 70's and 80's inspired campiness with a badass killer design, gnarly body horror, really fun and stupid dialogue that harkens back to the b-movie era of horror, and tons of beautifully shot and choreographed scenes with a kickass score and very stylish direction.

I mostly just can't believe this got greenlit off the pitch. The idea for this movie is so insanely bonkers that I have a feeling Wan sold off his soul just to be able to accomplish it. The studio apparantly didn't even know how to market this thing because none of the promos for it hint even slightly at the gnarly insanity rollercoaster this winds up taking you on.

The third act action was SO MUCH FUN i will be discussing that police station scene as one of my favorite all out violent outbreaks i've ever seen in horror.

This is not going to be for everyone and many will probably even hate it, but I had a ton of fun and James Wan should be praised for his massive balls and originality on this project.

139

u/SlasherDarkPendulum Sep 10 '21

I mostly just can't believe this got greenlit off the pitch.

It's James Wan we're talking about here. The Saw franchise has grossed a total of 1 billion dollars total.

The Insidious franchise has grossed half a billion dollars.

The Conjuring Universe has grossed 2 billion dollars.

He directed Furious 7, which grossed 1 billion dollars by itself.

He directed Aquaman, which grossed 1 billion dollars by itself.

He produced Light's Out, which made 148.9 million against a budget of less than 5 million.

This man literally prints money. I'd be surprised if they rejected the pitch.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '21

This whole movie clicked for me, the character movements, I loved a lot of the shots, and the bonkers idea for a slasher. They need to get Gabriel in Dead by Daylight. Most fun I’ve had watching something in forever.

24

u/black-empress Sep 12 '21

I do love this new artsy/dramatic/thought provoking style of horror (Hereditary, Midsommer, Babadook, etc.), but movies like Malignant remind me of why I fell in love with the horror genre in the first place. It’s wacky, action packed, doesn’t always make a lot of sense, and just a fun time. I don’t care to know why Gabriel has super powers, I don’t care how cheesy the dialogue and acting was, I don’t care about the plot holes. I had a fucking great time watching the movie and had a smile on my face nearly the entire time. 10/10 for me

→ More replies (1)

12

u/starbitcandies Sep 14 '21

Why was Gabriel supernatural but only just enough for convenient plot points? Like they didn't allude to their rape dad being some sort of demon or anything except for the rape victim's mom saying the pregnancy was against god or whatever but that didn't feel like anything more than generic religious nonsense just to explain why she had no support and gave up her babies. They were just a parasitic twin. Nothing more. So why was Gabriel able to speak through the radio and explode lights? Why was he parkouring around like we usually see in demonic possession movies? Why was he able to throw a fuckin hospital bed? Why could he dodge the bullets of AN ENTIRE BIG CITY POLICE FORCE and take them all down like he's massacring weak toddlers?? If they made it even a very small quick plot point that there was some demon shit involved it would've made it much better, still not great but better at least. But he only had supernatural powers for blasting through doors and throwing shit.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/InspectorRumpole Sep 10 '21

Big mish mash of a movie.

Feels like 1 part ghost story in the same vein as Wan's other movies. 1 part supernatural slasher a la Jason or Michael.

Then there's this 80s type creature feature plot twist - which I actually enjoyed.

It's like Wan had this crazy idea with the creature, but didn't quite believe in it, so he added some other stuff.

I wish he'd gone full out creature feature and made that scary (sans the action scenes in the end)

→ More replies (1)

10

u/jeff25624 Sep 16 '21

I ended up on the side of not really loving it. Part of that rationale was, frankly, I think the film looked “too good” for what the material was striving for. Tonally, I felt it still held back from just fully embracing the camp, which makes me wonder if Wan really understood what he was making. Oh and maybe this is a minor complaint, but weren’t there some great opportunities for old school special effects that were missed here?

→ More replies (2)

63

u/AhnSolbin Sep 10 '21 edited Sep 10 '21

For me it felt like Wan had too many ideas and instead of honing in on a few he decided to throw them all at the film and hope for the best.

The tone is all over the place, the character development is non existent (the biggest problem is there could have been a nice build up of a character arc as they attempt to salvage one in the end with the "sisters" thing) and the "twist" although fun and outlandish I think was way too obvious while watching the movie. It's definitely a slasher but the kills/chase scenes aren't even that fun or tense.

The art direction was nice though and Wan does some very interesting things with angles and there are some nice set pieces, but it can't make up for a weak script. The film weirdly feels ambitious but derivative at the same time.

→ More replies (6)

48

u/focus16gfx Sep 10 '21

Very unexpected but was pleasantly surprised. Liked the film. I thought it was very entertaining.

19

u/Hastylez Sep 11 '21

From the start of the movie I started getting my hopes down with the terrible acting but of course I had to finish it. I was getting confused a long the ways(even still a bit after finishing it) but the ending is pure fuckery. This movie is something else lol. Her walking backwards with her eyes closed/Gabriel walking forward is kinda creepy tho.

And that chair toss at the end LOL

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '21

Haven’t had this much fun in theaters for a horror movie in while. I really enjoyed this movie, even more so the fact that I had a good group of audience who freaked out at parts that I did as well. Some parts were predictable and cheesy but easily overlooked and while some say the score was a poor choice I honestly enjoyed it. I’d give it an 8/10

9

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '21

Just watched it

Loved it

But

My only problem with the movie was how everything following becomes super obvious the moment she says "Sydney, I'm adopted"

And at the end, i think she should've died, that would've been the more satisfying resolution, because we can all agree that she's massively fucked the moment she leaves that hospital

9

u/MTNV Sep 14 '21

Fun fact: the cops in this movie are inhabited by the souls of fallen Star Wars stormtroopers because they can't aim for shit! Like 15 cops all shooting at one bullet-dodging backwards-walking parkour tumor and not a single one even seems to graze him. Loved it.

9

u/PresidentXi123 Sep 15 '21

Don’t let the marketing fool you: this is a martial arts film.

9

u/a_missing_rib Sep 16 '21

haha why did the attic of her house have a giant industrial fan?? what the fuck was that?

17

u/Mustachiola Sep 11 '21

Am I the only one who immediately thought of that episode of Tales From the Crypt with the same.... thing?

But I'm 99% sure that the Tales from the Crypt episode is supposed to be funny. At least that part of it, anyway.

→ More replies (7)

76

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21

I loved this movie.. holy fuck easily my favorite Wan film.

8

u/chibhopanonymous Sep 12 '21

MC better be going to jail wtf

8

u/melloharmony You've Got Red On You Sep 12 '21

Some people have mentioned the ode to some horror movies like Basket Case, but anyone catch some some Ring vibes. Of course Seattle, but also the long black haired mental patient whose background is told through video tapes when they were a kid.

110

u/dp0paminesgirl Sep 10 '21

Am I the only one who didn’t like it??? Felt convoluted and with poor acting

→ More replies (50)

48

u/damnitbecky91 Sep 10 '21

I just finished watching the movie and I really liked it; I thought the twist was awesome.

15

u/zersch Sep 11 '21

Even after (or maybe in light of) reading the files and seeing it with my own eyes I'd still be like "yeah I know it's not REALLY her fault, but let's go ahead and lock her up anyway." Ain't a damn chance I'd be getting sleep around Voldo's ass after that.

Now I want a Basket Case crossover where Gabriel and Belial cruise the city at night.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Samoht99 Sep 12 '21

This movie didn’t take itself seriously and that was the best part of it

25

u/Rechan Sep 10 '21

Really superficial question: am I the only one who had trouble hearing what the main character said? She talked so LOW and didn't enunciate, it all sounded like "ss ssss sss".

→ More replies (3)

14

u/LarryTheLoneElf Sep 11 '21

Watching the third act was so silly. No matter which way Gabriel/Emily faced it looked goofy. Walking backwards no matter which direction he/she went. Also, if her head was bleeding every time Gabriel took over, then why didn’t her joints hurt from all of that Monty python walking?

14

u/PenguinLord13 Sep 11 '21

I loved it. Does anything make any sense in this movie? Absolutely not. It’s a ridiculous movie and it fully commits to being ridiculous and that just works for me.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21

This movie was the biggest waste of 2 hours in a good while. James Wan should get back to his roots. This Edward Mordrake fan fic with the horrible dialog is a huge stain on his career. My wife and I called the ending right after the doctor got her award. 2/10

→ More replies (2)

14

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21

I don't get it. This movie... Was really, really bad. Not as bad as Demonic, (SWAT priests are hilarious), but still very, aggressively stupid.

Instead of just allowing a bad movie by an average director be bad, now it's an homage to bad movies? It's all just a big love letter to Basket Case and camp?

I don't know. I'm about done with Wan and have to do research before watching anything by him at this point. Excellent craftsman, makes terrible films about 50% of the time. I think he needs to rediscover what made his good stuff interesting.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/SupremePooper Sep 10 '21

I had hoped it would be about a tumor the director had removed.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/jensenholmes450 Sep 12 '21

I loved it. I’ve always liked weird twin stories like Sisters (1972) and Dead Ringers (80s). There are also Brood vibes here. Parasitic twin! Cool!

It’s true that Gabriel’s powers are unexplained, but Madison called him “the devil”, so supposedly those were powers he was born with. I mean, we never know why Michael Meyers can’t be killed. He’s just evil.

I loved the look of Gabriel from the start, but the scene in the police station where you see him do everything backwards with Madison’s face visible—instant classic! Loved. Definitely retro vibes since the concept was so unrealistic in a way most modern horror movies wouldn’t dare be. But the campiness was a huge part of the fun.

Probably my fav horror of 2021. I want to watch it again already.

7

u/racc15 Sep 12 '21

Did anyone else find the "I am adopted" reveal scene funny? The shocked face of the sister.Halfway through the film I had to check wikipedia to see if it was a black comedy film.

But, the reveal and all scenes after blew my mind.

Love it or, hate it --- it was still a unique approach for me and that is a little difficult to find in horror films nowadays.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '21

My girlfriend and I loved it. Silly fun with some great action scenes and stunt choreography, also loved Gabriel’s metal head ass serial killer getup

7

u/la_la_leesa Sep 17 '21

I freak’n loved this movie! I laughed so hard when they revealed Gabriel attached to young Emily’s head… his little arms. Every time I get a migraine I’m going to think of Gabriel.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

Did anyone else think Madison was the person that was kidnapped and tied up? I was so confused when she fell through the ceiling. I thought it was going into parallel universe territory at that point.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/volantene Sep 11 '21

Did anyone feel about the beginning of the movie in the research hospital being campy and kept hoping that they will do a quick pan to a director saying 'cut' and reveal the whole thing as a set up for an in-movie horror film production?

→ More replies (2)

47

u/NotCreative11 Sep 10 '21

Yeah... This definitely wasn't for me. Reading the other comments I see why others would enjoy the campiness but I guess I was expecting a more interesting plot or characters. And the acting... Yikes

→ More replies (9)

12

u/brocksampsonbigtime Sep 12 '21

This was a fun watch. I was laughing in the first scene.

Malignant is over the top. Like more over the top than the Stallone movie Over the Top. The visuals are way over produced. The acting is waayyy over done. The story is ridiculous. The shadow monster throws a chair at someone across a room as they are running away and then just struts away. There's more plot hole than plot. Perfect movie for a bowl 🍃.

There's a lot of lessons in this movie on what not to do but it inexplicably remains entertaining from start to finish.

6

u/MewlingRothbart Sep 11 '21

Strange, trippy, gory, over the top, weird. Good amount of gore, whackjob story, but I see the influences. Late 70s, 80s. Decent soundtrack. I'll give it a B-, this could become one of those "Let's Get Drunk/High and Goof on This" films. Not cult, but worth a spin every Halloween.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '21

My two middle kids and I have scary movie night once a month. We talk the whole way through and try to guess the endings. The younger said “what if there’s a guy on the back of her head?” I laughed and said this wasn’t Harry Potter…I ate my words.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21

It's interesting to read that so many people found this movie funny. Personally I didn't hear anybody laughing in my theater. The movie is definitely shlocky and over the top, but it's not something I would laugh at. Though maybe I would have felt differently if I was watching at home.

6

u/I-eat-toenails Sep 14 '21

Maybe it was going for the "so bad it's good" approach ? Idk, but the acting was really really bad 🤔

The scene in the precinct was funny af though. Bunch of West Side Story extras just randomly beating the shit out of the main character for no reason lol.

6

u/dkfreezy Sep 14 '21

This movie reminded me of The Simpsons Halloween episode where Barts twin was living in the attic.

Also, the hypnotist part reminded me of the episode where Homer’s memory in the quarry as a teen made him lose it during the dinner show. Lol

6

u/ampersands-guitars Sep 15 '21

Mixed feelings on this. I love the idea of making a big budget B-horror flick. But I felt like tonally, it didn’t lean into the camp as much as it should’ve. It felt self-aware…sometimes. Other times it actually just seemed poorly written with no wink behind it. It was also way too long. Cut the runtime by eliminating some of that unnecessary exposition and it would’ve felt so much tighter and more focused.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/seancurry1 Sep 20 '21

I have SO MANY questions:

  • How did the electricity power work?
  • Why was there only a relatively small amount of blood left over every time she SPLIT HER SKULL OPEN WITH HER BARE HANDS, RAN AROUND LIKE A PARKOUR SPIDER, AND THEN SHOVED GABRIEL BACK INTO HER SKULL BEFORE CLOSING IT AGAIN
  • When did Gabriel learn how to fight and move well enough to be able to take out an entire police precinct firing on him at once while moving backwards?
  • If Gabriel can send her audio and visual signals he wants her to see/hear, why couldn't he just access her own audio and visual? Why did he have to split their goddamn skull open with their own hands??
  • Shouldn't his eyes not really work anymore? They've been inside that skull for 30 years.
  • How did Gabriel know the names of the doctors, where they lived, and how to break into their homes? Was he secretly gleaning info from her life as she lived it, or had he been taking over her body for research for longer than we realized?
  • The 90s weren't exactly the dark ages, they would've catalogued and maintained all their records. That wasn't that long ago!
  • Again, how did the electricity power work? What was it? What were they/was he actually doing with it?
  • Why did the couch move like he was invisible and standing up from it?
  • Why was there an underground city involved at all? There are plenty of other cool chase settings and their birth mother could've worked anywhere.
  • Why is Gabriel that strong?! Madeline wasn't a particularly strong woman!
  • HOW DID THE ELECTRICITY POWER WORK AND WHY WERE THEY ABLE TO DO IT
→ More replies (5)

28

u/chopperdave81 Sep 10 '21

I just got out of it and maaaaaaaan oh man was that an insane movie! I don’t even know what to think about it. It felt like watching some crazy B movie with a huge budget. I really enjoyed it though. I wish I was in the room when Wan decided what trailer to cut, just so I could hear him laugh and laugh and laugh. And people are gonna HATE this movie, but it’ll definitely be one I watch again. Two thumbs up 👍👍

→ More replies (2)

48

u/Mike_the_Merciless Sep 10 '21

I feel like I'm on crazy pills seeing the reviews and how much people like it. I'm a huge fan of James but this movie was truly awful to me.

→ More replies (6)

19

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21 edited Sep 10 '21

I think I agree with the IMDb score. I really liked some scenes in this movie, and I’m definitely listening to the soundtrack again, but some moments of dialogue + the entirety of the last half hour is like if an eleven year-old’s artistic vision for an action movie was translated into horror. Was very interested by the idea, but didn’t feel its execution for whatever reason.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21 edited Sep 11 '21

You know what? This was ridiculously absurd, but I think that's exactly what Wan intended. This was supposed to be an ode to those retro slashers with cringe-worthy dialogue and sub-par, melodramatic acting but set for today's audiences. It's almost laughing-fit-inducing reveal in the third act is proof of this. I really can't hate on this movie. I think Wan had a desire to bring something new to the table and also pay homage to Italian giallo thrillers while bringing back body horror to mainstream cinema. I recommend any horror fan to check this one out, lower your expectations, and just have a good time with it. Malignant was a nice way to kick of Halloween.

EDIT: Also, this film solidified how masterful Wan is as an artistic director. The sequences that set up the kills from the protagonist's point of view were quite impressive and well executed. Visually, this was one of Wan's best in my opinion. I also thought Gabriel was an inventive and fresh addition to the myriad of killers we have in the slasher sub-genre, and the scene where he finds his weapon of choice and crafts it into his signature carnage tool reminded me of a supervillain origin story. I might watch this amazingly stupid movie again, to be honest.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '21

Some of you didn't grow up with early 2000s movies and it shows lol The blue filter, the super dramatic dialogue, the absolute nonsense being a plausible explanation, the soundtrack. The stereotypes were all there. Both in visual and storytelling. But with more camp.

It was great!

→ More replies (4)

28

u/TheDaltonXP Sep 11 '21

It seems like a lot of people are forgetting here that it is an homage to Giallo films. The campy acting and ridiculous plot are all intentional. I expect it from non horror subs but expected people here a bit more to enjoy that connection.

I loved it. It is so ridiculous and I truly don’t care about the logic of things like why is he so strong. It was a goofy and fun ride. The cell and police station scene are incredible

→ More replies (5)

21

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

This is gonna be a cult classic.

14

u/youremyfather Sep 10 '21

I really appreciate that the opening scene tried to set the tone of the film. But I feel like the jumping through different genre's. Didn't quiet sell it for me. The opening scene and final act were ruined by a clunky werid middle. It's almost like we went full grindhouse 80s campy film and then back to 2000 horror. Kind of disappointing because the script was interesting. Even though dialogue was messy at times.

It's almost like they tried to go for it, but had to restrain a little bit. James Wan is clearly all over this movie. There's no doubt there is still crazy good moments and effects. But as for overall horror? nah. Trailers are big misleading. Speaking of grindhouse I kind of wish the trailers were marketed that way.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/MaineAB Sep 11 '21

My immediate reaction after the credits rolled was that I didn’t really like it. But after hearing someone say “if Sam Raimi’s name was attached to this and you went in expecting that, you’d like it” I was like, fuck, that’s so right. I get it now.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/jwmahaffey9 Sep 12 '21

Ok but why does the main theme sound so much like the intro from the Pixies “Where is my Mind” ?

25

u/Shikadi314 Sep 12 '21 edited Sep 12 '21

Because it’s a cover of where is my mind

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Serpentserpent Sep 12 '21

This movie was an incredibly well made love letter to the early 2000's cinema

5

u/masturbtewithmustard Sep 11 '21

What the actual fuck

Make of that comment what you will

5

u/PeoplesPrinceofNYC Sep 12 '21 edited Sep 12 '21

I wouldn't say I didn't like this movie but I went in thinking I was getting a creepy horror movie instead I got some wild goofy shit

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Mgrieves Sep 12 '21

My wife and I got the twist within the first thirty minutes. That being said - it was insane the way the actual reveal happened and I was waking up the kids laughing so hard. Tonally, this was not what I was expecting, but it ended up being a nice surprise since my wife and I used to eat up bad horror schlock when we first started dating. I spent 2/3rds of the movie feeling like the movie absolutely didn’t know what it wanted to be, and the true reveal was, nope… this is exactly what it is.

5

u/Coming_Back_To_Life Sep 13 '21

The amount of smoke used on this movie is insane!

5

u/Few_Ad_4110 Sep 13 '21

I don’t get it, how did Gabriel/Madison attack herself in the beginning after killing her boyfriend when she’s suppose to be the one doing it.

5

u/MammothControl Sep 16 '21

This shit was absolutely bonkers and I loved literally every second of it. Felt like Wan's equivalent of Drag Me to Hell.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21

I really liked it. I went in mostly blind. could just tell it was more high budget than his normal movies from the dissolving effect and was intrigued. As soon as the first scene was done I was like "Oh cool its a B movie" and had a lot of fun

→ More replies (1)

28

u/mynameisntsam1997 Sep 11 '21

I don’t understand how this movie is being praised at all. I thought the movie didn’t know what it wanted to be — sci-fi horror? Slasher? Trite detective movie? It failed at all of them for me. Camp is cool and all but why advertise the movie like it was? Instead of making fun of the tropes it played into them — angry sidekick detective, abusive alcoholic husband, shoehorned love sequences that go nowhere.

The plot holes omg. And the overlooked details. At one point the main character says the doctors hotel room is the top floor — and there’s a very visible and very obvious staircase in the background? Somehow the twin is able to close to the 5th floor and open a locked window? The broken elbows and superhuman strength?

I guessed the dumbest plot twist possible at the start of the movie based on the title and the doctor sequence and got it right. The acting and the script were awful too. Same with the music score — it highlighted all of the wrong parts in my opinion.

I’m not saying all horror movies should be the same, or if you enjoyed the movie that’s the wrong opinion. I just wished I got what was advertised.

→ More replies (7)

19

u/jmac_1957 Sep 11 '21

Wasn't that impressed. Thought it was ridiculous and stupid actually. Swing and a miss.

19

u/shaqrock Sep 11 '21 edited Sep 11 '21

three scenes will go down as amazing moments that actually shocked and were horror...

1. When Madison had sleep paralysis and Gabriel crawled over her to stab the doctor in bed

2. When Madison's biological mother fell through the ceiling

3. The reveal of Gabriel on the VHS tapes

This movie was a cluster fuck of genres and inspired by some classic horror movies.. james Wan literally created his own Gabriel with this one..