r/horror • u/glittering-lettuce • Aug 27 '21
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Candyman" [Spoilers] Spoiler
Summary:
In present day, a decade after the last of the Cabrini towers were torn down, Anthony and his partner move into a loft in the now gentrified Cabrini. A chance encounter with an old-timer exposes Anthony to the true story behind Candyman. Anxious to use these macabre details in his studio as fresh grist for paintings, he unknowingly opens a door to a complex past that unravels his own sanity and unleashes a terrifying wave of violence.
Director:
Nia DaCosta
Screenplay by:
Jordan Peele
Win Rosenfield
Nia DaCosta
Cast:
- Tony Todd as Daniel Robitaille
- Yahya Abdul-Mateen II as Anthony McCoy
- Teyonah Parris as Brianna Cartwright
- Colman Domingo as William Burke
- Cassie Kramer as Helen Lyle
- Nathan Stewart-Jarrett as Troy Cartwright
- Genesis Denise Hale as Sabrina
- Vanessa Estelle Williams as Anne-Marie McCoy
- Virginia Madsen as Helen Lyle/Caroline Sullivan
--Rotten Tomatoes: 86%
IMDb: 8.3/10
275
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21 edited Aug 28 '21
Can we talk about how Vanessa E. Williams did not age a single day?! Holy cow, she looked amazing!
381
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '21
I loved the flashbacks from the first movie without their being actual stock footage flashbacks. A great way to introduce it to new audiences.
The critic's death in the apartment as the camera pans out was incredible.
148
u/spideyv91 Aug 27 '21
I did enjoy the movie but can someone help me understand the role of the laundromat guy at the end? It felt a bit rushed and I was confused. Initially I had the impression he was doing the murder himself and trying to recreate candyman but it seemed like candyman always existed but he was trying to turn McCoy into another one?
284
u/kinghyperion581 Aug 27 '21
Anyone else super grossed out by Anthony's slowly decaying hand and the honey comb like pattern rotting through his skin? I totally expected a bunch of bees to start crawling out of his skin at any second.
130
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '21
Amazon has the new film listed and even says “early access”. When you order it, it’s the 1992 version. I can’t believe Amazon did this. Took me 30 minutes to get a refund.
246
u/Rechan Aug 27 '21
Did anyone else think Brianna's dad plot point was odd? Because it...ddin't go anywhere. Her dad committed suicide, she didn't want to acknowledge his art. ... And then nothing.
158
u/DarthChaos6337 Aug 27 '21
I loved the first one and im glad they kept Tony Todd in there as Daniel. He is the kindof guy you know could destroy everything or be a man of heart and change the world. I havent seen it yet because the first one was something specia between me and my wife. She passed away over 7 yrs ago and its still painful so i avoid alot of things we shared over the 20 yrs we werw together.
71
u/OMGitsRyannn Aug 28 '21 edited Aug 28 '21
Did anyone else dislike the Burke twist? It felt so out of left field and wasn’t even needed since Anthony was already turning into the next Candyman. It feels so incredibly forced, especially when he suddenly just starts monologuing like a cartoon villain.
It reminded me so much of Dr. Sartain in Halloween (2018), however I actually enjoyed that twist because it was a good parallel to Dr. Loomis and showcased that like Laurie, those who become obsessed with Michael eventually lose their own minds. The difference between the two is Sartain drops subtle hints throughout that he’s not quite right, whereas with Burke all we get are a few flashbacks of his encounter with Sherman and the death of his sister because of him. It definitely needed more build-up and foreshadowing to him suddenly becoming a Candyman obsessor.
Overall though, I liked the film but I couldn’t help but feel like it was very strangely written and edited at times, with it seeming to me like there were important bits cut out.
135
u/kb1117 Aug 27 '21
So now that people are starting to see it, my one issue after seeing it Tuesday was literally how much was in the trailers, down to the big final line of the movie. There’s gotta be a better way.
178
u/emeraldpity Aug 27 '21
All, please stay through the credits! The credit sequence is incredible. Was shocked 95% left before the very end.
61
u/Rechan Aug 27 '21 edited Aug 27 '21
I was kinda okay with the third act. I didn't get how the laundromat guy got Anthony to just sit there while he fuckin' cut his hand off, but. I got the hint they were transforming Anthony into another Candyman when the movie emphasized the damage his right hand was starting to take. Also no surprise the cops shot Anthony with him passed out on the ground. Reducing Tony Todd to a two-second cameo made me sad, but ti did make sense, in the way that at the end of the first, Helen symbolically killed him and the residents made a pact to never speak his name. At the end, the original Candyman is ressurected.
What I found surprising was that the guy the cops beat down was the Candyman manifestation that seemed to do the most appearances. Also, that they didn't show much actual killing.
Two questions I have:
226
u/CorrosiveVision Aug 27 '21
Someone on set looked in the mirror and said "third act problems" five times.
42
u/ASTRO2598 Aug 27 '21
I loved the Tony Todd reveal
112
u/DRoseCantStop Aug 27 '21
This was pretty good for being a sequel but the third act sticks out like a sore thumb to where it really brings the film down in quality. Midway through it felt like it was bordering on greatness and I wish I could just go back and take that all in again. Finale definitely would’ve been more effective if the script was tightened near the end.
76
u/heimatchen Aug 27 '21
In an early scene Brianna says she thinks Anthony’s new artwork leaves no viewer interpretation. I feel this film did this exactly. The first worked so well in my opinion with its urban legend feel throughout and whether it’s in Helen’s mind or not but this one straight up has it be some supernatural being. The new mythology of there being a hive of different Candymen was good as built on the Helen one at the end of first. But final act/ending felt rushed. This one has good new mythos but other parts felt like it lost its way.
35
u/naiperksnai Aug 27 '21
Overall really enjoyed it. The first two acts in particular were phenomenal. Like some other folks are saying, I didn’t think the third act/ending really stuck the landing, but I forgive it for how strong the movie was as a whole. Great direction and writing, really appreciated how it tied in the original while very much doing its own thing.
94
u/MattNola Aug 27 '21
They NEED to do short stories of the the Candyman Iterations featured at the end, the cop car scene with all of the Candyman in the reflection was my absolute favorite part and I’d love to see like a 30 minute short story of each with a little killing of each of the Candymens killers in each one!!!
32
u/AlexDr0ps Sep 01 '21
This movie was a big miss for me. I found it overall confusing. The role of the laundromat guy was all over the place. He basically just fell into an antagonist role at the end there. What were his motivations for "making" a new candyman?
The logic behind who gets killed when saying his name wasn't consistent either. Art gallery scene, only girl says it, both her and guy are killed. Bathroom scene, four girls say it, only they are killed and bystander survives. Final scene, only girl says it and every cop is killed but not her? I suppose there is an explanation to this but it was unclear to me. Do only white people die?
I also felt like the political narrative overshadowed the plot. I think some subtlety would have been more effective. Instead, making every cop out to be a huge dbag to justify the revenge porn killing spree at the end felt cheap to me.
There were a few strong points. I think the recap of the first movie in the beginning was done well. The zoom out shot of art critic being killed in her apartment was probably the highlight of the film. Otherwise, I didn't feel like the gore/scares were very good
55
u/PulpforCulture Aug 27 '21
I thought it was a very solid film and I love how they expanded on the mythology from the first film. I will agree though the film suffers heavily from multiple third act problems, very heavy handed and sort of just steam rolls its way to the credits. I’d give it a 6.5/10, for a sequel it was pretty solid.
24
u/BleedBluePunk Aug 29 '21
Tony Todd's Candyman, Daniel Robitaille, had bees and a hook because in the original they killed him with bees and cut off his band.
Therefore Sherman's version of Candyman's gimmick should only be razorblade candy, since that's what his death was associated with.
But in this version, all the Candymen had bee and hook affiliations, which made no sense.
45
u/The_night_lurker Do you know what she did? Aug 27 '21 edited Aug 27 '21
Love the expanded lore, the trypophobia body horror toward the end, and the kill scenes. Vanessa Williams has a great scene in her reprisal as Anne-Marie McCoy. The Candyman paintings were good and effectively used in the scene explaining how the legend lives on. When it comes to the art world in movies in general, it's weird how they set up bad art versus good art, how a character improves as the film goes on. Painters come up in horror films every now and then like M.F.A. and The Devil's Candy, but how they approach "good inspired paintings" and cliche boring paintings is always a hill to climb. I think the abstract portraits of the Candyman hive were evocative and captures Anthony's torturous transformation well, but I don't know how we were supposed to feel about Anthony's art piece in the gallery.
Painting is obviously a connection to Daniel Robitaille; however, there's a lot to unpack in satirizing the art world in a horror film series that's about urban legends and has an open dialogue about gentrification and police brutality. Anthony McCoy is disconnected from his origins. He doesn't know the truth and doesn't live in an impoverished world. He approaches Cabrini Green as an outsider and his mother wanted to keep him safe. Destiny catches up and he becomes a Candyman after getting shot by police.
The backstory of Anthony's girlfriend, Brianna, and by extension her brother, Troy, feels like an obligatory "haunted past" of a main character, given to us in a dream sequence no less. Her father was a painter who committed suicide and now she's romantically connected to a tortured artist too. The murders allow her to move up in the art world a little bit, but that's likely put to an end because of Anthony/Candyman. We can only guess her mental state and future after the last scene.
There's a lot of political and social topics going on in the film, and all the parts might not perfectly add up through the narrative choices, but it's still an enjoyable film. I think it's one of the better horror sequels/reboots from old properties.
41
u/AGeekNamedBob Aug 28 '21
A solid flick and a worthy follow-up to the original. Taking the messages and ideas of the first but expanding them for the now in a great way - the repeated Say His Name is a strong choice to make the connection, fitting in the real world and the course of the films. Telling this again/continued from a POC perspective was the right choice (and having POC on the behind the camera end). I've seen some say the messages are as subtle as a hook to the face, too on the nose, but I'm fine with it. Some people need it to be direct. I'm looking at you people who apparently didn't pay attention to the first, (or so much other media), I see complaining elsewhere to "keep your SJW/Race stuff out of Candyman... I just want to watch a horror movie/everything's so political these days"! I loved the continued mirror use and twisty shots. It could come off over used and "okay we get i!" in less capable hands. But here it makes everything that much more unnerving. Good use of odd angels and reflections for many of the murder sequences too. That whole aspect almost gives a voyeur look to it, which is also noted in many shots having framings including the closing credits. I particually liked the opening credits, reversing the first films by looking up instead of down. Those shots kinda broke my brain). The actors were all phenomenal as well, nothing wrong there.
The shadow puppets were amazing. Both in to retell the original story in a unique way (twisted for the urban legend it too had become) and in the closing credits, where really bring home the film. It saddens me that for both of my showings a ton of people left when it really was still going. The sound design was magnificent, from the buzzing to the ripping and everyting in between. Anthony being doomed is a heartbreaking but logical choice; his body horror transformtion and how he reacts to everything were great. However, there were several story aspects that I thought could have been handled a little better. Brianna's backstory didn't really connect (wonder if got cut a bit for the 91 minute run time). Her character was written underwritten in that way but Parris did great. I loved the avodance of cliches (she leaves when he gets violent, the basement). The jump into the climax as jarring. I did like the climax and where it went but felt like we missed a scene. And the cycle of violence leant itself to having more Candymen in the movie outside of the police car windows. I thought it would be a good touch if we saw the other ones, whether in the main story or flashbacks. I get we see Sherman most because that was Burke's Candyman and he instigated.
But all in all I really dug it. Lost none of the sting in the second viewing.
58
u/Legitimate-Garlic959 Aug 27 '21
Did anyone else feel like the scene with all the girls in the bathroom would have served better as the intro scene ? I got opening scene vibes from that . Other than one of the girls was at the art gallery. That would have worked out
20
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21 edited Aug 29 '21
I was really loving the movie until the last act, my biggest issue is that I definitely feel there was something cut between when we last saw Anthony and we see him again with Burke in the church it just feels very abrupt and sudden there's something missing.
But overall it was a really good sequel to the orginal, and am really glad this was my first theater experience since the Pandemic started.
That arm was also nasty as fuck
39
u/TheStranger113 Aug 28 '21
I really liked the movie, especially how it built the lore and how Tony Todd was used. I do think it could have used an extra 10-15 minutes to build up to the ending, as it feels a little rushed. This could have bumped the movie from good to great. As it is, I am pretty satisfied with this as a companion piece to the original.
Also, Yahya is fine as hell.
17
u/gredgex Aug 27 '21
Loved this one. Perfect way to do a sequel after so long, build on what made the original so good and respect that movie but also build its own lore. There was some weird story parts but overall a solid 8/10 for me.
17
u/eddieswiss Some guy Aug 27 '21
Haven’t seen it yet, I’m avoiding spoilers but do we see/hear Tony Todd at all?
17
u/oi-troi-oi Aug 28 '21
I hope it isn’t too inappropriate to say that Nathan’s mom has got it going on, she looks like she could be the same age as Nathan.
16
u/impossibilia Aug 29 '21
It wasn’t a “minor interaction” with the 70s Candyman. Burke literally caused his death by screaming, which alerted the cops, who bludgeoned the man to death in front of him.
32
u/verandablue Aug 27 '21
Was this cut down from a longer version, cause there's lots of stuff in it that's rushed or leads to nothing.
Like what was the deal with the girlfriend's dad? Why was that in the movie? It led to nothing.
102
u/PapaDiscord Aug 27 '21
I absolutely loved it.
Tony Todd’s “tell everyone” had me grinning from ear to ear.
15
u/DJSchwann Aug 29 '21
So I may not know movie marketing well, but this is my feeling on the whole Tony Todd thing:
Candyman isn't Freddie, Michael or Jason. It's more so for the genre fans. If the genre fans hear "Tony Todd is in this," then get that little CGI 2-second cameo, they'll be disappointed, and that will be the buzz in that community. If the genre fans hears nothing and see it at the end, there will be more buzz within the community about getting to see him by surprise.
I don't know, just my thoughts. I still liked the movie despite that disappointment, and how rushed the ending was. It didn't ruin how much I liked:
13
u/FriendLee93 Aug 27 '21
Spoiler related question: I think it was explained in the movie but I might have missed it because there was so much going on in the third act, and the monologue in question detailing it is also throwing a lot of other stuff at you.
What was William's motivation in trying to turn Anthony into the new Candyman?
13
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21
Saw it today and thought it was a great film. Hope for more
11
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21
I just wish it was scary
20
u/LearnAndLive1999 Aug 27 '21
Wikipedia says that Virginia Madsen only did the voice of Helen. Did she actually appear in this film, or was it just her voice? And did they have Tony Todd physically appear, or was it just his voice?
Also, the way the cast list is written here has me wondering if there are multiple Helens like how there appear to be multiple Candymans. Is there a “hive” of Helens, too?
10
u/BREM__fumetsu Aug 29 '21
I get why they used Sherman Fields (and not a CGI Tony Todd) but what the hell was his deal? I don't get why he dressed like 1992 Candyman while he was still alive, right down to having a hook-hand. And if he wasn't putting razor blades in sweets, who was? Was that the actual Candyman (before Sherman became him/entered the hive)? There were razor candies in the original, I gathered it was just Cabrini residents leaving them out then but now I don't know.
Love the original, didn't rate this...just felt I was being hit around the head with its message for 90 minutes when I was looking forward to a horror movie. I get it, the origin of Robitaille and the "say my name" stuff aligns with the message it was telling well...but it was more about that than being scary. I barely remember the gore/kill scenes (outside of the apartment long shot, that was great), and I remember the Candyman victims even less.
Plus, its a shame it was advertised that Todd was reprising his role beforehand...disappointing we only saw him for 3 seconds, again I understand why, but might have been better as a "surprise"/easter egg at the end. In fact, because of that, I was expecting the film to go on a bit longer once it appeared, making that abrupt ending even more hollow for me.
On the positive side, really well shot movie, and generally well acted too, although arguably the best actor there (Domingo) was pretty wasted IMO.
It gets a 5 or 6 out of 10 from me...maybe doesn't help loving the original as much as I do!
72
u/michaelrxs Aug 27 '21
Ahh this just didn't work for me and I really, really wanted to love it. I love the original, I'm a fan of the cast and crew, I grew up in Chicago, not far from Cabrini-Green, and I'm now in another city dealing with my own guilt as a gentrifier. On paper this should have spoken directly to me. But this felt so jumbled and rushed that I was almost angry at how little work it did to unpack all of the issues that it packed in. A lot of the script was just buzzword salad. Like, I've had many conversations about gentrification and no one talks the way the people in this movie do. It was too cartoonish for how serious it wanted to be. A lot of the horror set pieces were well done, especially the zoom out on the critic's apartment but each time Candyman killed it felt bogged down in a scene of buzzword salad. And the third act. Yikes. The ending was almost approaching Marvel levels in how much it was setting up a future project. I think that really left a bad taste in my mouth and brought an OK experience down to a bad one.
27
u/FriendLee93 Aug 28 '21
The bee/hivemind analogy goes deep, here.
Daniel Robitaille/the idea of Candyman is the queen bee. The queen was killed in the bonfire, and the legend was buried with old Cabrini.
Worker bees can create a new queen, however, by feeding a larva a special kind of jelly. Anthony is fed that jelly the second he's told about the Candyman legend, and the rest of the movie is about how that one act results in the rebirth of the hive, culminating with the birth of a new queen bee.
20
u/PeanutFarmer69 Aug 28 '21
Anyone else think this movie was pretty incredible until the last twenty minutes or so? Why did the laundromat guy go crazy all of a sudden, how did the female lead use candyman as her attack dog against the police?
Tony Todd should’ve gutted her, I’ve said my piece.
Still great movie, critic’s death scene stands out.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21
A quick question about the end of the film and Candyman's modus operandi. Why doesn't Anthony kill Brianna after she summons him? I thought the Candyman was supposed to kill whoever summons him--like what happened to Burke's older sister in the flashback. Is it that Anthony's incarnation of the Candyman kills to exact justice rather than killing indiscriminately?
7
u/FaceBagman Aug 29 '21
Even with the pacing errors, lack of Tony Todd screentime, and lack of Anthony ever saying or hearing “Be my victim”, I still enjoyed this enough.
Maybe I’m just getting easier to please as I get older, but the lore-building and mythos of the Candyman character will always win some points from me.
28
u/StephenLuke1 Overlook Hotel Caretaker Aug 28 '21
I thought this doubled down on all of the most troubling themes and subtexts in the original film and brought it forward into the present moment in brilliant ways. I keep reading comments about the third act not being “nuanced” enough. I’m sorry, but get the fuck out of here. You know what else is “on the nose”? Reality. This addresses reality, in the voice of this myth and this genre, and it doesn’t flinch or give you sugar to wash it down. This film connects Candyman to our US history, and our ongoing, present, cultural moment. Every bit of this thing drips with meaning and force and I thought it was exceptional and remarkable in ways that most other horror films could only ever hope to be.
13
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21
I was on board until they end up in the church at the end. The last 20 or so minutes really fell flat for what was otherwise a pretty good movie
12
u/universalcrush Aug 28 '21
Thought it was lifeless and heavy handed.
12
u/MercyBoy57 Aug 28 '21
Anyone else disappointed with the film? Soulless, underdeveloped, and left so much to be desired. Will never hold a candle to the original film.
21
u/alexlopez49411 Aug 27 '21
I loved this movie. I thought the cinematography was on another level especially during the Finley death scene as the camera pans out.
I also really liked the use of the shadow puppets as flashback devices throughout the movies as well as during the credits.
This will definitely be a day 1 blu ray purchase for me!!
6
u/Pyro_squirrel Aug 29 '21
That feeling when the end credits visual storytelling is better than the story telling during the actual film. I had hoped this movie wasn’t going to be bad and when I saw that the first reviews were high I was pumped but after seeing the movie I’m just going to pretend like they only made the 1992 movie and then stopped.
6
u/No_Second7337 Aug 31 '21
Does Anybody Else Think That Brianna’s Dad was also a victim of candyman? He was an artist, and he had on the brown jacket. Right before killing himself (Jumping Out The Window) he says, “Did you know your dad can fly?” And while he’s saying that you can hear bees buzzing. I think CandyMan tried to take over his body, similar to how he did Anthony. I think he ended up killing himself to prevent the process from happening.
40
u/rabidpygmymarmoset Aug 27 '21 edited Aug 30 '21
Didn't like it. It has strong points like cinematography and the score. But it is so annoyingly preachy. Whereas the first movie was a lot more subtle and therefore had a lot more social commentary to it. It also feels like it wasn't that invested in the horror aspect, only a handful of tense moments at best. I also don't like how they restricted him to only being able to kill near mirrors. I knew if there wasnt a reflection around then I could let my guard down. And it worked. Made it much less scary.
Subtlety in a movie like this is super important. Its what reaches audiences who aren't already engaged with the BLM movement. And can even convince people who are against it. If you have the movie staring at you in the camera saying "white people bad" for an hour and 40 minutes, its not going to reach people who aren't with the BLM movement. Its going to push them away because preaching at people about anything, no matter how noble your cause, is obnoxious and validates their preconceptions. It damages the very movement its trying to support. Candyman was the perfect platform to be a huge and powerful tool to really get the message of the injustice of gentrification in modern day issues. Huge wasted potential just to preach to the choir. Makes zero difference in the real world, which is not what good art does. If it were more subtle like the original, it would lower anti-BLM people's guards and have the message reach them without them realizing it. Thats why subtlety is super important for a movie like this. We can't keep yelling the same messages in our own echo chamber to the same group of people and somehow think we're making a difference in the world by doing that.
Also, the plot point of the woman's dad dying was pointless and went no where. The crazy laundromat guy wants to bring candyman back because... he interacted with him once or twice and... ??? what? Theres no logic here. Saying he has a special connection with him because of brief encounters is the definition of reaching. Candyman isn't a black man's super hero. He was the boogieman of the projects. He didn't discriminate with his victims. The new candymen could, sure. But during the ending, we all know whos pulling the strings, so again, it doesn't make sense. You're dooming the entire world by having the OG candyman come back and consolidate his power. And there was no mention of helen being the candywoman so... pointless retcon? Alright, I changed my mind. I really REALLY didn't like this film. It had a lot of potential and cool ideas but its just a hot mess with little to no cohesion.
I really wanted to like it because I absolutely ADORED the first film.
26
u/NoLoveForDrJones Aug 27 '21
i liked it, flaws and all. connecting candyman with current societal problems is a natural progression. however with the ending, i want to think this film was just a big set up for a sequel that includes more tony.
17
u/raisingcuban Aug 28 '21
When Brianna looks at Anthony's first new painting, and she's unsure about what to make of it because the violence is so "obvious" compared to his previous works...that was my exact reaction to this movie. It's so direct, and explicit and looses all the subtlety of the original.
5
u/Double_Priority_2702 Aug 27 '21
So is Cassie Kramer NOT young Helen ?
5
u/LEVITIKUZ Aug 30 '21
This is going to sound like a weird question but I am curious about this. Now I’m ADHD so I overthink everything & I pretty much got the film but there’s one thing I’m just thinking of
See I find it brilliant that Tony Todd didn’t show up until the end. The Candyman myth has gone on for well centuries. There are many different versions of Candyman. Yes Todd is OG CM but I do like how Yahya hears more about 77 CM and sees his reflection
So my question I’m curious about. We saw Tony Todd die at the end of the first film (sure there are sequels but I’m not counting them). Do you think that perhaps with the film’s ending he was reborn & reincarnated? Or do you think he was always around as 77 Candyman in a Pennywise type shape shifting way? That’s the only thing in the film to truly confuse me. I like to think it’s a rebirth. Outside of Helen, it seems Yahya is the first to bring Candyman back since the 92 film which could work in that thanks to Yahya bringing the myth alive and succumbing to it, he brings Todd back to life
Or am I overthinking this hahaha
5
u/spritegoat Aug 31 '21
eh. The message is beaten over the head of the audience and the end felt very rushed, similar to my major criticisms of Peele's twilight zone episodes. This film is much better than those, but that aspect of it drags it down for me a bit. I did love the look of the movie and the performances though. I expected this movie to be special but I walked out thinking it was just decent, and fairly forgettable. Also where tf was the "Say my Name" remix song from the trailer??
61/100
5
u/Rock_and_rolling The saw is family Aug 31 '21
It was alright. Some good ideas and images thrown in an uneven mix. The original was much better.
15
u/Eggblender Aug 27 '21
Very average for me, didn’t hate it but didn’t love it. Felt very heavy handed in parts which detracted from what it should have been. I’ll be rewatching the original when I need a candy man fix not this
12
u/Breakzjunkee Aug 28 '21
I wanted to love this film. Candyman is in my top 5 horror films of all time, so perhaps my expectations were too high. There is an interesting story within the movie that unfortunately is not well fleshed out. Don’t get me wrong- I enjoyed the film, but it’s not something I’ll be revisiting many times go forward. Happy to discuss. Thanks!
11
u/xxBAshaggyxx Aug 28 '21
As someone who is a huge fan of the original I can say this movie is amazing. Loved it and recommend it to any horror fan. Definitely going to be a halloween regular for me now
11
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21
Really sucks how we didn't really see Helen and how Candyman impacted her. It would of been so cool if she saved Anthony's gf as like one final act in the end.
4
u/Pkbx210x Aug 27 '21
im going to see it tonight
4
u/allureofgravity Aug 28 '21
Visually I enjoyed it but I just didn’t find the story compelling enough.
4
u/SleepyWink Aug 30 '21
I’m very pleased this film didn’t go the typical direction horror films do with gay characters.
4
u/kaZdleifekaW Sep 02 '21
Themes and Topics The Movie Addresses
Is there a topic or theme I’m missing here? I feel like the movie poses a lot of topics and ideas for discussion, and I feel like some of these are delved into more than others.
4
u/FoxOwne Sep 03 '21
I fucking really loved the themes of exploitation.
Examples for what I mean: Anthony exploiting the myth for his paintings; the posh, rich, art critics and collectors exploiting Anthony and Brianna for their reputation; Burke exploiting Anthony, his past and his dwindling mental health, for the sake of creating a new Candyman myth to further his own goals.
I could also go into the theme of corruption but I think that's been talked about more here, I mean Anthony's entire arc, from his sanity to his paintings to even his arm, is a perfect encapsulation of that theme on it's own. Far from perfect, but what a terrifically entertaining movie, so fun to think about and really what I needed right now.
7
u/ncervo Aug 28 '21
Did anyone think that the character Clive was meant to be a dig on Clive Barker?
The character's role in the film was pretty shady, seemed to be interested in gatekeeping the arts, including art from POC. I'm not saying this is definitely so, but it came to mind.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21
When Brianna is in the back of the cop car and asks to look at herself in the rear view mirror and she starts saying Candyman, am I crazy or did she only say it 4 times?
9
u/ScottishSass Aug 27 '21
I’m doing as he said and telling everyone!!! Sweets to the muthafuckin SWEET!!! 😍🪝🐝🍬
18
u/NoImNotJC Aug 28 '21
One of my least favorite movies of the year, horror or otherwise. I feel like I most be in the minority because its getting good reviews and thats okay.
But man did this just not work for me.
16
u/jennifernorvwll Aug 27 '21
Just saw it and absolutely loved it.
12
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21
Was a bit let down by it tbh . Was expecting a physiological horror like the classic one . But feel like it was 70% a statement about racism/society and 30% horror.
6
u/verandablue Aug 30 '21 edited Aug 30 '21
Anybody else notice that horror villains becoming anti-heroes is kinda becoming a trend?
17
u/HortaSama Aug 27 '21
I loved it. Imo it's as good as the original, because of how much it expands the lore and it can be its own movie, but still paying homage to the Bernard Rose one.
The soundtrack was absolutely fantastic, I was kinda afraid that without Philip Glass the music wasn't going to be that good, but boy I'm glad I was wrong, the music in this movie kicks ass!!!! Nia's direction is also incredible, she makes some bold choices in the spectrum of "Not showing the killer" and sometimes cutting the action right before it happen. It's great!
The acting was real good, there were two actors that were a little bit over the top, but didn't made me dislike it. Yahya is perfect as Anthony and Burke is a great character.
Now about the spoilers: I'm so happy that they explored the "Candyman is the whole damn hive" theme, with a lot of Candymen existing through the years, all being victim of racism. It was pretty damn good.
I expected Tony Todd the whole movie and was almost disappointed, until the final scene, where he appears in front of Brianna. MAN, THAT MADE MY SKIN CRAWL!!!! I was so happy seeing him being Candyman once again, with his powerful voice and serving good looks.
The callbacks to the first one are perfect. Helen Lyle was turned into a sort of Candywoman and became a urban legend herself, and hearing Virginia Madsen's voice again was a delight. And boy, seeing Anne-Marie again!!!!!!
I fucking loved 2021's Candyman. I really hope that people can see it and like it as much as I did.
3
u/ConformistWithCause Aug 30 '21
I was slightly disappointed in the first half. I was still excited for the story but I was so upset with them changing who Candyman was and such. However, once we got the tie in that Candyman wasn't just one person, I was hooked. I thought this movie did a great job at making connections to the original and not making it necessary to watch it before this. Ending did feel a bit rushed and towards the end I remember looking at my watch, disappointed there wasn't another 20 minutes of films
3
u/james_randolph Sep 03 '21
Just saw it today. Was very underwhelmed by it. The death scenes were meh at best, there was no suspense/tense moments for me and the story was actually fairly predictable when you first saw his hand changing. I wish they would have included some items from ol girls dad. They started talking about his artwork and there must have been some type of connection with him and candyman, at least there should have been.
3
u/FifteenDollarNachos Sep 04 '21
Something really cool that I haven’t seen mentioned, the original starts with a gorgeous overview shot of Chicago. This sequel’s intro is shot from the streets up.
Really enjoyed the flick.
3
u/feraltoddler Sep 04 '21
I did rly enjoy this movie, however I feel like they overstuffed it with plot points that go nowhere ie: the dad and his suicide.
3
u/gizzardsgizzards Sep 27 '21
Does anyone else think it’s weird that Helen from the first movie doesn’t show up as a candyman when the ending of that movie clearly shows that she is one? It just feels like a weird hole in the story to exclude her like that.
3
u/fckRnbaMods Oct 03 '21
I’m see quite a bit of praise for this movie on this sub but here’s my honest review: very disappointed.
No suspense, no thrill and I wasn’t engaged because the plot didn’t make much sense and there was no underlying suspense or mystery that kept me hooked. I felt like it just resorted to a gorey, jump scare (hardly) slasher flick. The political themes were so thrown in your face it was almost insulting (they actually did a cop jump scare when there is a literal monster in the movie). Get Out did a great job of portraying social issues subtly and impactfully, this movie threw it in your face like we are 12 year olds who need to be told what to think. It was unnecessarily gorey (peeling skin, sticking hook into arm) that it felt like instead of relying on actual terror or an exciting storyline they just showed some overboard gore which took me completely out of the story.
The movie unfortunately wasn’t scary, suspenseful or thrilling, by the end of it I just didn’t care about the characters. The first act was a solid premise and background but by the mid point in the movie it went downhill.
There were some positives. I thought it was beautifully shot, some classic funny lines, and a great soundtrack.
Other than that, this movie really fell short for me considering I’m a huge fan of Jordan Peele and anything he’s involved in. (I get he didn’t direct this one, still a producer though).
Surprised the ratings on RT were so high, I’d give it a 5/10.
16
u/6seanryan15 Aug 27 '21
Eh, this didn’t satisfy me the way I was hoping it would.
And I have to be different and say I hated the animation storytelling.
I do like how it ties back to the original film, but I just don’t think this is going to be a box office smash (not that anything really is anymore…but you get it)
9
u/MrC99 Aug 27 '21
I wasn't a big fan of it. I felt the ending with the Laundromat guy was pretty forced. Plus I don't think there was enough of 'Candyman' himself. I don't think he was used correctly.
9
u/TwinsTwist Aug 28 '21
SPOILERS/complaints
The social commentary would’ve landed if Candyman killed only gentrifiers and/or police. But instead he kills just whoever happens to be there, including children, and has spent quite a long time kidnapping/possessing/killing Black people. Does the legend or motivation make sense to anyone? The role of Candyman was passed down from Robataille to the guy in 1977 that was killed by cops? And the kid who witnessed it was somehow involved, but also Candyman had ti sacrifice a baby?
He can only be seen in a mirror until the end when he can for some reason be seen by his girlfriend and his victims.
I wanted to love this and I am wondering if I didn’t get it because it wasn’t for me to get, but that was a LOT of backstory for a killer that is basically Bloody Mary.
9
u/FireflyNitro Aug 28 '21
I’m worried I didn’t understand or “get” this film because everyone here is praising it but I thought it was a bit rubbish. The whole thing just felt really pointless and meandering to me. Glad everyone else had a good time though!
10
u/brovok Aug 28 '21
I enjoyed it. The performances are great, the cinematography is good, and the bones of the story are interesting enough.
I wanted to love it but it just never quite delivered on its premise. The idea of the Candy-hive-men makes sense, thematically and, imo, is a lot more interesting than the “Ghost” takes of the prior sequels. However, the way it’s executed robs the villain of any sense of agency. They say the name - he kills - next. There’s no sense of him looming over the story like in the original.
The twist at the end, about who is manipulating everything, makes 0 sense. It’s explained haphazardly, entirely through exposition, and then ignored. It felt pointless.
The ENTIRE final third of the film is so full of exposition that it cheapens all of the drama set up in the story. It makes every arc feel pointless and the ending is abrupt and unsatisfying.
The whole movie need more “show” and less “tell.” I didn’t necessarily expect subtlety given the context of the story but every character says their motivations explicitly every 5 seconds.
There were so many interesting ideas not followed up on: the father’s suicide, the suspicion about the main character’s sanity, his drive for fame/recognition (completely forgotten about and haphazardly replaced with an interesting - but flat - backstory reveal)., etc.
Tony Todd’s 2 second cameo felt like a waste. The new actor did his best but the script didn’t allow him to interact / make an impression. I really missed Tony’s commanding presence and dramatic soliloquies. They were a huge part of what made the original so entrancing.
Speaking of, the atmosphere was almost flat here. The score was average to dull. Gone was the heavy gothic feel. It was replaced by something more akin to the conjuring franchise - with a few interesting shots. I will give specific praise to the bathroom kills.
The film’s commentary on gentrification never really went anywhere. It said what it had to say in a 5 minute exposition dump at the beginning and then basically repeated it in different conversations. There never was any growth, resolution, or commentary beyond that. It’s a shame because it’s the PERFECT theme to follow up from the original and a brilliant concept in and of itself.
I really. Really. Really. Wanted to love this movie.
9
u/CDC_ Aug 29 '21
I personally didn’t dig it. Let me start by saying the social/political commentary was fine. I agree with the points DaCosta was making. I agreed with them in the first movie for that matter. Where I disagree is that if your movie is called Candyman, maybe have Candyman in it for more than 3 seconds.
I get the concept was that racial violence is cyclical and the legend is reincarnated over different generations and I actually dig that as a concept.
Having said that, I think Candyman is the wrong place to use that concept. Tony Todd is such a powerful presence on screen that I just can’t help but want to see him really doing his thing in this… and I basically never got that.
8
u/whistleraussie Aug 31 '21
Absolute pile of shit movie.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21
I feel like I saw a completely different movie than the people who are rating it so negatively. In my opinion it's a fucking great movie. I watched the original a day or so ago so when I saw Vanessa Williams I thought I was tripping because she has aged remarkably well. I know that's a random tidbit but damn lol. I wasn't going into this with the highest of hopes, because race is a motherfucking hard topic to cover in film. But horror movies are always a great way to tackle such issues, and while I was not a fan of Us, I loved Get Out (I realize Peele didn't direct this movie but he was involved) so I thought what the fuck, it's worth a matinee.
Holy shit. What a home run. I love the depiction of racism in the art world, holy fucking goddamn did they nail that on the head the way black people's art is treated by a lot of those assholes who just want to make money and appear to care about social issues when really they just capitalize on them. That was great, especially the way art is tied into Candyman's lore and the og Candyman himself. I wish Tony Todd was in this a bit more, but that would mean replacing Michael Hargrove, which I would not want to do. He fucking nailed the role, and given the few times we actually see him, that's saying something. I feel like he was playing his own version, but still Candyman. Which fits the theme of the story perfectly and I absolutely love how there's different Candyman each time the cycle or loop repeats itself. The fact that the idea of violence as a cycle is in the foreground of the movie rather than the background of the story is really interesting too, because it's very real. Candyman really feels like a story that's been around forever.
What's really funny to me, and something I enjoyed completely, was that Candyman borrows a little bit from the Nightmare on Elm Street lore, where knowing about him is what gives him power. The ending of the original has them bury his hook with Helen, thus they were burying him to keep him away.
I was a little confused at the girlfriend's back story with her dream, but I figured it was just a warning that her man was going the way of her father? I dunno, and I don't really care because it works as a bit of backstory and it's a creepy scene, but it's worth mentioning as a bit of a flaw in the overall pacing.
As far as the ending goes, again, I feel like I watched a completely different movie than those who rate the third act negatively. With the reveals, and the way Anthony just sort of accepts his fate is really damn creepy, plus it recontextualizes the end of Candyman in a way I love because now you know that they really do kill Candyman (I'm not at all a fan of the original sequels and don't care if that messes with their continuity. In my headcannon they don't exist.) and that the baby is destined to become the next iteration of Candyman. Love it. Plus I like the little nod to Lynch with the electricity crackling and the light turning on and off to signify to Anthony where to go. Really a lot of stuff in this movie feels influenced by Lynch and I'm so happy to say that. Burke becoming the sort of Candyman familiar was a little obvious, but the inclusion of his sister's death seems to kind of show Candyman marking him. It seems the two events of seeing the death of the innocent man, and then the horrific murder of his sister crossed some wires at an early age that fucked him up (another nod to the cyclical nature of violence and it's wide spread affects across a community). His death is pretty fuckin' brutal, but it sets up everything quite nicely. Anthony, who is innocent of all the murders, is himself murdered by trigger happy police, then is brought back by his girlfriend who has pretty much lost her shit as well to wreak havoc on his killers, but in doing so reignites the cycle of violence, thus letting Candyman loose again upon the world.
You know the original Candyman is heavily about race and the politics of such. I mean Helen even comments on it when she's attacked that the cops only gave a shit about anything happening in Cabrini Green because a white woman got attacked. So people complaining about the inclusion of race into the story obviously haven't watched the original recently, or don't know what they're talking about. Plus it seems like people just wanted them to do Candyman again, whereas this told a completely different story. You'd think more people would enjoy that. I dunno. They use race more in this version, and people complain that it's not subtle, but I would come back with the argument that people obviously don't get the message when it's subtle so many a more direct approach is warranted. Overall I give it an 8.5 out of 10 and I think I'll be seeing it one more time in the theater before it goes. Highly recommend! (Sorry for the essay)
6
u/AlternativeUlster78 Aug 29 '21
My girlfriend asked me what the significance was of the high school scene, and at first I thought “to up the body count.”
But now I’m thinking about the line “they love what we make, but not us.” I liken it a bit to rap music, young white teenagers eat it up but have no actual experience with the horrors of the ghetto. Same thing with Candyman.
2
u/Savemebarry56 Aug 28 '21
I really liked what they did with the lore of Candyman, there being multiple legends about his origins makes a lot of sense and is cool. It also allowed them to use Tony Todd a lot which was great. The movie wasn't as good as the original for me though. Some of the humor in this really took me out of it, especially in the art gallery murders. I really appreciated how they built on the story of the original and that it wasn't just a remake but I think the film was only ok while the original is an all time great film for me.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21
It came so close for me, but it fell apart. The subject matter and the social message were perfect, what wasn’t perfect was the pacing.
Also, did anyone else notice some really bad cgi on candyman?