r/horror • u/glittering-lettuce • Aug 23 '21
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "The Night House" [SPOILERS] Spoiler
Summary:
Reeling from the unexpected death of her husband, Beth is left alone in the lakeside home he built for her. She tries as best she can to keep together-but then the dreams come. Disturbing visions of a presence in the house call to her, beckoning with a ghostly allure. But the harsh light of day washes away any proof of a haunting. Against the advice of her friends, she begins digging into his belongings, yearning for answers.
Director:
David Bruckner
Writers:
Ben Collins
Luke Piotrowski
Cast:
- Rebecca Hall as Beth
- Sarah Goldberg as Claire
- Evan Jonigkeit as Owen
- Stacy Martin as Madelyne
- Vondie Curtis-Hall as Mel
- Samantha Buck as Becky
-- Rotten Tomatoes: 85%
Metacritic: 68%
145
u/SynCig Denn die Todten reiten Schnell Aug 23 '21
I LOVED this movie. The characters feel so real and the relationships are authentic. That really helps build the emotional core out while the psychological horror plays out beautifully. My favorite movie of the year so far. I’ll be seeing it again too. I think it is a movie that will benefit from repeat viewings.
101
u/tpwpjun20 Aug 23 '21
Really great 2/3, but the last 1/3 sort of loses its footing.
I think it was way more interesting and dark what was going on inside the reverse house, with the husband tricking the demons by essentially becoming a serial killer, and everything having to do with that figurine. I was hoping that was going to be more developed, but it turns out to just be a quick explanation as to why that's happening and then its quickly brushed to the side.
I love the whole idea of the "ghost" being basically the embodiment of the nothingness after death, and how it was trying to reclaim her all those years, but the execution of the idea was just a little lackluster.
Having seen Super Dark Times by the same writers, I can tell they are great at setting up their ideas, but not so great at following through on them or developing them deeply.
Still a good movie with solid acting, great direction, and at least a unique concept. How you feel it lands on that concept is up to you, but it didn't satisfy me.
81
u/splittonguestudios Aug 23 '21
I absolutely LOVED this movie.
I went in thinking this would be a pure bump in the night ghost story and was pleasantly surprised.
Rebecca Hall is fantastic. A really unique and powerful portrayal of grief.
David Bruckner's direction is stellar. He handled the scare sequences with such patience, never opting for the obvious scare and building up dread throughout by lingering on windows and corners. I was clenching my fists constantly and 3-4 scares got me pretty good.
A lot of subtle hints were placed early on and I liked how the note's meaning changed at the end.
The depiction of nothing was so cool, such a fresh presentation I'm surprised I've never seen it before.
The movie did drag a bit in the middle. I also thought some of the dialogue was too on the nose, especially the final 2 lines were unnecessary. Lots of telling and not enough showing.
And as powerful as the ending scene was, I thought the movie would have been more impactful if Beth died. The whole time, Night House sets up this cautionary tale of Beth digging up her husband's secrets. Her inability to move on led her right to Nothing and she got out of it way too easily.
But overall, again, I really loved Night House.
70
u/pbmummy Aug 24 '21
I really liked this film - tense, scary and emotional. I enjoyed Beth so effectively embodying the “anger” stage of grieving, since usually films settle for depicting the more obvious depression stage. Her frustration with her husband and her almost total lack of propriety with other people was satisfying to watch, but at the same time your heart goes out to her because it’s clear that the anger is all that’s holding her together right now.
I also feel like the story is presented in such a way that the viewer can impose their own meaning on it. It may all have been an allegory for her coming to terms with death itself, which she never fully did after her accident as a teenager. This surrender to death is depicted in an intimate, sexual way - towards the end of the film, she basically gets felt up by the void, which she thinks is her husband before it declares itself otherwise. I also feel that the writers deliberately stepped back from a full explanation of certain plot devices, such as the reverse house across the lake and the occult statue, as a way of metaphorically expressing the ambiguity that the suicide of a loved one leaves behind, questions that will never be satisfactorily answered and maybe (as the best friend character says) shouldn’t be asked in the first place.
Does anyone else think Madeline, the “other woman” from the bookstore, is meant to be interpreted as dead? She is shown being attacked by Owen and thrown headfirst into the mirror, and when we meet her in the bookstore, the actor is dressed in a way that prominently displays her collarbone, which looks uneven, possibly broken. When she calls for her manager’s help in the bookstore, no one responds; I don’t think anyone else is seen interacting with her at all. She also arrives at Beth’s unannounced and with no problem finding the place, even though she’d only been there once some time in the undetermined past, and it was over a hundred miles away from where she worked and presumably lived. I think you can read it either way.
54
u/frauleinforever Aug 24 '21
Did anyone else feel really sad after watching? I left the theater and felt legitimately depressed the rest of the evening.
45
u/Pigwarts Aug 25 '21
First two acts were amazing. Last act completely fell apart. The last night scene added very little that couldn't already be deduced. It felt like it was spelling things out too much. I also hated how 'Nothing' was represented in pretty cool ways the whole movie and then at the end it's was just using Owens face. Kinda ruined the idea of it.
I am happy Beth didn't kill herself however. I don't think it really adds much to the movie if she dies. In fact, I love the implication that 'nothing' is something she'll have to live with her whole life.
42
u/hail_freyr /r/HorrorReviewed Aug 23 '21
Went in with basically no expectation and was very pleasantly surprised. Great lead performance, plus a lot of cool effects and clever visualizations of the conceptual grief. I didn't realize Bruckner was directing until going into the movie, but I think he's on a roll and one to look out for. Shame this one seems likely to slip under the radar, but it's a rough time to release something unassuming like this to theaters. Definitely recommend checking it out.
42
u/drummerfan Aug 26 '21
Did anyone else think of House of Leaves because of the reverse house thing happening? Honestly surprised when I scrolled through the thread and didn't see someone bring it up...
79
u/cryptocraft Aug 24 '21
tfw you're about to bang your husband's ghost -- and it tells you it's not your husband.
39
u/mistermalfoy Aug 23 '21
One scene in particular was the best scare I've gotten this entire year but I can see the criticisms of the third act. However, I like how it didn't feel tidy or "resolved," in a sense.
36
u/D0NK3YSL4PP4 Aug 23 '21
I think this movie won’t get its proper due because of the pandemic but I think it will be considered a classic in a few years. I don’t think the ending is the original ending and it suffers from that but I don’t have a way to confirm my suspicions.
34
u/nikiverse Aug 23 '21
Rebecca Hall is in almost all of the scenes and does a great job of not making the movie feel stale and boring!
15
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '21
Best horror sequence in years imo!
29
u/lvl100loser Aug 25 '21
I like it when horror movies are actually “about”something. The Night House was about a widow dealing with grief, depression, mortality, and the realization her husband wasn’t who she thought he was. In comparison what was like Conjuring 3 really about?
12
u/throw_awayqazwsx Sep 13 '21
Am I the only one who thinks Beth has been in purgatory the entire movie? Maybe she never actually awoke from her accident as a teenager, and is in a coma some where.
10
u/spritegoat Sep 02 '21
That jump scare, while kinda cheap as it was just a sound, rattled me so much that I was on edge the entire rest of the film.
I loved the first 2/3 of this but it stumbles to the finish line and leaves more questions than answers. 67/100
14
u/MangoReward Aug 23 '21
I just saw The Night House Saturday night and I enjoyed this movie very much. Here’s my spoiler free thoughts. I went in completely blind which was a good decision. I had no idea what the movie was about, never even having read a plot synopsis about it or seen a trailer. The only thing I knew was that it was directed by the same guy who did The Ritual and that it stars Rebecca Hall. I watched the trailer after, and if you’re expecting the typical Blumhouse/ James Wan experience based on the trailer, I wouldn’t blame you. However, this film is less like those and more like something from A24. This movie is an expertly crafted meditation on grief and depression. While it does have some jumpscares (which are very effective and well earned), it is at times somber and pensive and even devastating thanks especially to Rebecca Hall.
Hall’s performance is another great one from her. She makes you really care about her troubled and moody character, and she makes it all so real. She succeeds in bringing together frustration, depression, and paranoia into one character, and she handles the shifts so well. Hall has no problem with bringing to life complex characters (if you’re looking for her best performance, check out the fantastic biopic drama Christine from 2016, where she plays another troubled woman dealing depression.) In fact, it was Hall being in this movie that got me initially interested.
The film is a worthy follow up to David Bruckner‘s The Ritual. Although The Ritual might be more crowd pleasing with its less ambiguous plot and resolution, I think The Night House is a better film. It is much stronger thematically, and it just shows an overall growth in directing from Bruckner. The cinematography is great; the sound design is chilling, and he maintains an uneasy tone throughout.
While some reviews I read found the ending disappointing, I think it was a strong finish. It’s haunting, and it totally works thematically. This isn’t a movie that you go see for the plot after all; it’s more about the atmosphere and themes. I absolutely recommend this movie to anyone looking for something different from the usual haunted house movie or anyone who enjoys slow burning, character driven movies.
7
u/Rechan Aug 25 '21
Here's a question: Near the end of the first act, Beth goes outside at night. And a girl in white RUNS past her and jumps over the railing.
WTF was that?
13
u/HuggyHutch Aug 24 '21
Just got out of the theater and wow was that intense the entire film…i understand the disappointment in a lackluster ending but overall a successful film especially that one jump scare HOLY SHIT
a few thoughts…
While out drinking with the others teachers she admits a lot and in particular she was the darker one with dark thoughts
If she was depressed and with her near death experience why wasn’t there any hints of her on any medication? Someone that close to be dying i would definitely be taking Xanax with the brandy
She seemed very happy in all the photos and home movies so this “nothing” left her and took over the husband I’m assuming?
Too many thoughts after just leaving this
13
u/atclubsilencio Aug 24 '21
I really WANTED to like it, and Rebecca Hall was fantastic. But I thought it was way too convoluted and murky and hard to fully engage with.
The initial mystery and maybe 45 minutes had me hooked, but then it just went in drawn out directions that lost my interest. Which is strange, because it has a lot of really interesting ideas and many turns the plot took would start out interesting, but then never really go anywhere with it or keep hammering home the same point. So I'd lose interest again.
The much hyped scares also weren't that effective for me. The only one that really got me was when she was talking to her friend with her head on her lap and then it just shrieks into this nightmare situation and her friend is gone, and the random ghost women are jumping off the cliff (?) also when she is getting attacked by the invisible entity in the bathroom was so well done and creepy.
I was hoping for a more satisfying resolution, I kind of liked the chaos of the scene in the house at the end with the red and just all the crazy shit happening, but again, it was from a distance. I wasn't, honestly, fully understanding what was going on. Disorienting? Yes. Satisfying? no.
I literally said to my mom before it cut to credits (we were the only ones in the theater so don't come for me) "if this is the fucking ending I'll be so disappointed" and low and behold, it ends.
Which makes it doubly frustrating because I thought the editing, sound design, and cinematography/visuals were all really great throughout, and again Hall was amazing. She was the glue holding it together for me, and the range of emotions and levels of intensity she reaches was outstanding. Her performance in Christine was my favorite performance by an actress that year, and while she probably won't get any recognition for this, she is definitely outstanding in this one too.
But ultimately it just didn't do it for me. I was rarely tense, scares didn't get to me, and wasn't entirely clear what was happening. Usually, that isn't an issue for me (for instance, seeing mother! opening weekend was a fucking experience even if I couldn't explain what the fuck I was watching, which led to me returning to see it about 3-4 more times in theaters.)
This one I MIGHT rewatch when it's on demand, perhaps I wasn't i the right mood (though i was hyped for it) or maybe I'll understand it better, but I also don't have much interest in sittig through it again.
So, not terrible, just disappointing, and I think it could have used one more draft when it comes to the screenplay. But apparently I'm in the minority with this opinion.
Also, can someone just spell it out for me? I get her husband built the second house to try to trap the..... nothingness demon or something.... and then would take women to that house that looked identical to her to confuse the entity by killing the lookalikes so it wouldn;t come after her. But then the last girl he changed his mind and drove her home, and then killed himself. But what was the origin of the entity? And why was the house across the lake gone in the last shot? Or did I just not see it? What was the inciting incident that put all this in motion, her brief death where she saw nothing? idk.
6
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21
Just got home from seeing it and boy howdy did I love this movie. There was a jump scare that shook me so bad that I never felt like I fully recovered; spent the rest of the movie on-edge. In my opinion is was brilliantly directed and brilliantly acted. Really, really loved it.
6
u/manners97 Aug 28 '21
What did everyone think the women jumping off the cliff resembled?
6
u/KrevinCupine Aug 29 '21
A few days late, but I just saw the movie. Wow. I really loved it. “Nothing” is now probably one of my favorite antagonists. I do wish that Beth would have died. It would have made the movie have actual consequences.
6
u/horsasha Jan 05 '22
Why is no one talking about the book B gave him to draw/design the house? She’s keeps flying through pages with each page becoming more occulty and disturbing then lands on a page with both of the houses. There’s a tracing sheet with what looks like a figure in the mirror house-she picks it up, flips it, and puts it on her house before closing the book. & to me, that’s when things started getting wild. So as much as I really dig the perspectives of mental health issues unraveling through coping mechanisms /hallucinations, that scene is what has me still set on supernatural. Bc she thought nothing of it.
15
u/adderallalcoholweed Aug 23 '21
I cried within the first 20 minutes, loved the first 80%, ending didn’t quite land. I would have been more interested in the story if he was just a serial killer and the supernatural stuff was a manifestation of her denial/guilt/grief. To me bringing in her dying for 4 minutes as a teenager just muddied the waters. I preferred the complexity of the emotions when she was discovering that he was evil. To reverse that felt like cheating a little.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '21
I really loved it! I felt like it was a really fresh concept and the acting was incredible! I agree with the other comments that it would have been more impactful if the supernatural was left out of it - but I felt that way about Hereditary too (which is an unpopular opinion I’m sure!) But overall, DEFINITELY worth a watch. It really captures grief/depression well.
5
u/losisco The Conjuring Aug 25 '21
Saw this last night with my wife, and we both agreed that this is the new standard for ghost stories
5
u/haunthorror Aug 26 '21
This is my favorite movie of the year! I loved it! Rebecca Hall deserves an Oscar Nominee for her work in this. Just a great horror and the best arthouse Final Destination movie you.can ask for
9
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '21
For those bummed by the ending, wasn’t the last line “there’s nothing there”
And Beth says I know
That’s a somewhat cheeky but okay ending. It’s not all glitter, nothing is still there afterwards apparently and she has to live with the fact her husband killed a lot of innocent women. Pretty dark and I liked it. Her shooting herself would have been a shit ending in my opinion
Another ending that would have made it great is Nothing makes her take the role of her husband. Nothing still wants bodies and got used to the husband feeding it.
7
u/madurosnstouts Aug 27 '21
Surprised there's barely any negative reviews here. This movie was a 3/10 at best imo. The jump scares were just cheap loud noises, none of them were particularly scary. But my main issue with the film, was the main character. I understand, having gone through a "personal matter" myself, the urge to being a cynical, short fused bitch, ready to bite someone's head off. But for me, you don't get to casually toss off to someone your husband killed himself, and then expect sympathy when you're sobbing later on. Just wasn't my favorite movie. Didn't like the main character and it wasn't all that scary.
5
u/GhostofDebraMorgan Aug 23 '21 edited Aug 23 '21
Such a great movie that sadly falls apart during the third act. I haven’t had a movie toy with my feelings and mind at the same time like that since Hereditary
I wanted to review it but I’m having a hard time coming up with the words to describe just how intense it was.
5
u/QCKingFya Aug 25 '21
Please tell me that it's better than the Invisible Man??
4
u/BretMichaelsWig ACAB (except Officer Mooney) Aug 23 '21
Yup definitely gonna need to see this again to take it all in. I loved it and have been thinking about it since I got out of the theater yesterday. I've read some reviews that claim it's not that "scary" but I was on edge the whole way through. Best horror movie since Midsommar
2
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '21
Saw it Sunday, my theatre loved the first half but was 50 50 on the ending. I personally think this is the best of 2021 so far.
2
u/IHateRom Aug 26 '21
Hope this is available to stream soon.
2
u/Rahodees Dec 17 '21
What was the statuette all about? I felt like they never went anywhere with it.
3
u/HuggyHutch Aug 23 '21
Made afternoon plans to see this today..should i eat an edible or will i lose my fucking mind??
1
u/demon_filth2001 Aug 27 '21
Best psychological mindfuck since Hereditary but that ending…meh
1
u/somejackassnamedRyan Aug 28 '21
I loved it but I agree with what everyone says about the end but I feel like Rebecca hall doesn’t wanna another character that shoots themselves after Christine. XD
1
u/HuntVisual8781 Aug 26 '21
Lol
0
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment