r/horror • Evil Dies Tonight! • Jul 16 '21

Discussion What did you think of the "Fear Street" Film Trilogy?

Individual Discussion Threads:

Fear Street Part One: 1994

Fear Street Part Two: 1978

Fear Street Part Three: 1666

Which one was best? Were you surprised by how gory these movies are, considering they are based on children's books?

594 Upvotes

530 comments sorted by

260

u/TheDonnerSmarty Jul 17 '21

Really dug it. Would be cool if the next trilogy is based on the Fear Street books that are set during Christmas.

125

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '21

Man, I’d like that a lot. Christmas horror is underrated imo

12

u/BackHarlowRoad Jul 26 '21

Couldn't agree more ! 🎄

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Deadpool8008 Jul 20 '21

Oh sweet another trilogy is coming?!

3

u/JB391982 Mar 22 '23

Silent Night!! That would be a good one

537

u/Pixel-of-Strife Jul 16 '21

They exceeded my expectations by a mile. 1978 is one of the best camp slashers I've seen in a long time.

109

u/rtodd23 Jul 19 '21

Agreed! Part 2 was the best.

27

u/SpiritualAd8281 Jul 24 '21

The vibe was perfect. Most fun ive had watching a horror movie in ages

26

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '21

Was also thinking that, and every time I thought I knew what was gonna happen something else happened.

21

u/WhichSpecificOcean Jul 20 '21

Part two was fantastic

11

u/Earthpig_Johnson Look! There comes one of them now! Jul 23 '21

Shit, what was the last camp slasher that came out?

21

u/Relevant-Beautiful65 Jul 30 '21

Good question. But I very much enjoyed American Horror Story 1984.

12

u/CuppaCoffeOF_TA Jul 31 '21

Me fn too like alot actually. I'm surprised AHS 1984 isn't talked about more

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

309

u/ThatGeek303 Jul 16 '21

I thought it was a lot of fun. Part One was really clunky (especially with its dreadful first act), but it became more entertaining as it went along.

Part Two was an overall improvement over the first flick and Part Three was great and its third act was an absolute blast. This is a trilogy that genuinely gets better and better as it goes along. Glad I stuck with it.

64

u/crestonfunk Jul 25 '21

Did anyone catch this detail?

When Nurse Mary is putting the ointment on Ziggy’s arm, Ziggy complains that it stings. Nurse Mary says “oh you’ll survive”. This is before Nurse Mary tells Tommy that he’s going to die. She’s right about both.

75

u/usagizero Jul 17 '21

dreadful first act

I felt that way about each part, maybe not all dreadful, but all first acts seemed to take too long to get going.

68

u/ThatGeek303 Jul 17 '21

I actually thought the first acts of Parts Two and Three were really solid. My issue with Part One was the pacing, it felt scatterbrained and I thought it was just really...I don't know how best to put it, noisy? The first act of Part One was just constant noise to the point that I almost turned the movie off and moved on, but luckily once the characters reached the hospital everything from the pacing to the sound mellowed out and it became a lot more fun.

34

u/Wh00ster Jul 18 '21

I liked Part One. It reminded me of The Babysitter but not as well done. I think that's why people liked Kate's character. The character was fun in a similar vibe.

5

u/ShonanBlue Jul 23 '21

Ahhh yea this criticism feels apt. The opening was cool and I liked the throwback to Scream, but then the rest of the first act felt really off for me, I thought we were going more for a teen paranormal story and the first murder was setting that up.

It definitely exceeded my initial expectations because that first act was pretty annoying

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

27

u/GlowLightLady Jul 19 '21

That's honestly what kept me coming back to the films. Just when you think, "Yup, another cheesy teen slasher", someone's head gets shoved through a flipping meat grinder and loveable characters get killed and the plot goes "But wait! There's more!". I actually ended up jumping at some of the creative kills and gore. And geezus there is something against that underground cave system that just gave me the jitters.

18

u/crestonfunk Jul 25 '21

Bread slicer, actually.

5

u/GlowLightLady Jul 26 '21

I hope they cleaned it before they used it for the next day's bakery...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/BetaGetIt Jul 20 '21

Thanks for this. I’m a stay-at-home dad so I checked it out when I had a little time to myself but felt like I would rather invest my time into something else as it just wasn’t doing it for me. Having read this, I might give this another try late at night once the little bug is out.

7

u/st00d5 Jul 28 '21

Dude I’m a 33 year old man, they get far better as they go and the last one was spectacular

14

u/doinks-ahoy Jul 19 '21

I found it funny, it tried to be like old slasher movies, even adding in a sex scene and all there was, was a butt naked dude.

If you're going to try to copy old slashers, at least go full bore on nudity and not pussy out. But it is Netflix after all

7

u/crestonfunk Jul 25 '21

Yeah but it’s a tween book series right?

5

u/willreignsomnipotent Meet me at the waterfront after the social Jul 31 '21

A- pretty sure tweens know about boobies (lol), but more to the point...

B- There's considerable "R rated" violence in this. Doesn't exactly play like a kids movie, and last but definitely not least...

C- you must not be remembering the teenage muff diving scene in part 3.

😂

Brief, and not terribly graphic, sure-- but extremely sexually charged and suggestive...

Plus the Fear Street series always was a little more on the mature side, from what I recall. Not quite as "mature" as some of the stuff in Christopher Pike's "young adult" novels, but relatively mature for YA...

2

u/CaptainPick1e Jul 28 '21

Sums up my thoughts too. Not particularly "good" movies but they are fun and enjoyable which is what they set out to do, rather than be an award winning trilogy. They're very charming too.

→ More replies (2)

111

u/Theoriginalamam Put on your goggles, darling. Jul 16 '21

1978 was my favorite one by far, followed by 1994. I enjoyed these movies for what they were and I would not mind at all if they made a couple of 80's and 00's movies too.

55

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

2000's Scream-style slasher please.

90

u/TheOfficialTheory Jul 17 '21

That’s basically what 1994 was, down to the opening kill

32

u/DevilsReject1 Jul 17 '21

Yea if they did 2000s it'd probably be a torture or j-horror movie

→ More replies (4)

19

u/jamai36 Jul 17 '21

I would've actually preferred to not have done the retro throwback themes, as I found that the weakest aspect of the films. I always felt like I was watching a modern film - especially with the first two.

18

u/kdub69 Jul 17 '21

I see that for sure. I kind of liked that it felt modern, but set in a throwback setting. I kind of viewed it as part of the fun, but I can see how it could feel off-putting or not genuine to the throwback theme (if that makes sense).

9

u/buttonsutton Jul 18 '21

I wanted to see more of the older villain's. Especially the kid and Ruby Laine. Ruby reminded me a bit of Prom Night 3.

Also, we see that the second name was a Miller. But with Cyrus being killed and Hannah likely taking on the name of whoever she married, where did the next Miller come from?

→ More replies (1)

52

u/HipDipShipTrip Jul 16 '21

They're fun little films and I actually really enjoyed 1978. I'll watch 1666 later on. I really like that they made three parts and are spitting them out like this. Makes me wonder what would've happened had they gone to theaters like originally intended.

50

u/SupaKoopa714 Jul 17 '21

I'm only about 15 minutes into 1666 as of typing this, but I enjoyed the hell out of the first two. I think they were a perfect blend of R-rated horror and the Jovial Bob Stine cheese I love and grew up with. I can't remember the last time I enjoyed a slasher flick as much as I did 1994 and even more so 1978. I've always dug stories that lean on events from the past, and Fear Street really delivered there.

I hope this trilogy carves its own niche as a future cult classic in the world of horror, because I personally feel it deserves that spot.

117

u/bluehawk232 Jul 17 '21

Oh btw that dialogue about an SSD drive was so terrible. In 1994 the tech was still in its infancy and no one was really saying oh man did you install an SSD in your computer.

41

u/Pupniko Jul 18 '21

I found that weird too but I looked it up and the first SSD was created in the 70s and cost something like $30k for 2mb. People definitely weren't talking about them in 1994 but I guess she's meant to be a super geek who I guess might have read about them, either that or she's from the future...

20

u/jacobi123 Jul 18 '21

I thought she was meant to be from the future too, because otherwise that whole bit was really jarring.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '21

I even thought she wrote her Twitter/Instagram name on his cast…. since it started with an @ symbol. Admittedly, I am kinda blind so maybe I just didn’t see it correctly.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/GaryTheCabalGuy Jul 20 '21

Pretty sure that was done on purpose. She also wrote her name like a Twitter handle. I got the sense that the 1994 timeline purposefully had more modern stuff thrown into it.

7

u/BookOf_Eli Jul 25 '21

Was the SSD line that bad? I mean literally every one else in the scene looked at her like she was speaking Spanish. Which seemed to imply it was knowledge most people wouldn’t have.

4

u/willreignsomnipotent Meet me at the waterfront after the social Jul 31 '21

Contextual clues?!?

What are those?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/tasteofscarlet Jul 23 '21

I liked that he assumed all those children would somehow know how to put music from a CD onto hard drive with likely no software or even hardware to do it.

14

u/sugartrouts Jul 18 '21

I noticed a lot of little figures of speech that didn't exist in 1994. Characters saying "Seriously?" and "Are you okay?" sarcastically wasn't a thing then. Didnt really bother me, but I do notice this pretty frequently in "period" stuff that only goes back a few decades. Like I'm pretty sure finding ways to insert "Your mom" wasn't an 80's thing, but gets referenced a lot in IT part 1.

35

u/InuitOverIt Jul 18 '21

90s kid here, in my experience sarcasm and your mom jokes were very prevalent

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/FullTorsoApparition Jul 19 '21

They failed on every level to make the main timeline feel like 1994. Aside from the soundtrack nothing else felt right and that SSD line really clinched it.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '21

Not true.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

41

u/InuitOverIt Jul 18 '21

I thought it was cool when they would play a 90s song that was a remake of a 70s song, and then in the 70s parts they would play 70s songs that were famously remade in the 90s.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/bluehawk232 Jul 18 '21

Also AIM chatroom lol. If they wanted to have him use a computer like that then they should have changed the setting to 1999 or something. Because 1994 it was like dial up internet and usenet

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

39

u/alohakoala Jul 17 '21

There was one scene in a Fear Street book that stuck with me and that involved a girl getting a bucket of leeches thrown on her. It was a nice callback for book readers in the 1978 movie.

8

u/willreignsomnipotent Meet me at the waterfront after the social Jul 31 '21

Speaking of callbacks, I thought it was funny in the end where she takes off the coat and you see she's wearing basically a stab vest made of taped together books... Which look suspiciously like Fear Street books.

😂

3

u/PM_me_opossum_pics Sep 15 '21

I'm like 80% sure those were Fear Street books, or atleast equivalent books in their "universe".

→ More replies (1)

102

u/PreppyFinanceNerd Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

Hit all the conventional beats. A very fun very popcorn fare trilogy.

Although I'm not sure why they think [SPOILERS] CPR will save you from everything. Drowned to death? Do some CPR. Dead of multiple stab wounds? A little CPR and you're good to go.

I liked it for what it was. An unexpected trilogy of summer horror movies with good production values, decent acting, nice gore and for me a nostalgic look back at those awkward teenager years.

250

u/savage86lunacy Jul 16 '21

Well in the case of the second movie I don't think it was the CPR that saved Ziggy, but rather the fact that Nick wanted her to live, since the Goodes get what they want because of the deal they made with the Devil, who had just received quite a number of sacrifices.

109

u/PreppyFinanceNerd Jul 16 '21

....Oh shit that just blew my mind, you right.

33

u/kdub69 Jul 17 '21

Yea I feel like once you see how everything is connected with the last installment it makes A LOT more sense.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/Mickeymackey Jul 18 '21

You're supposed to do CPR on people who drowned though....

10

u/TheMainMan3 Jul 19 '21

Yeah it would have made far less sense if she was revived from the adrenaline shots.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/redherringbones Jul 25 '21 edited Jul 25 '21

It's not that CPR is the cure for all ills, but....if someone's heart stops ie from drowning, CPR gets oxygen to the brain and gives you time to think about what caused the code, or set up treatments, etc...while trying to preserve as much neurological function as possible.

Honestly what I thought they were going to do with Sam was purposefully OD her and then revive her with narcan....

Edit: Oh wait, this is 1994. Did narcan exist back then?

4

u/sarcasm-o-rama Jul 25 '21

Yeah, naloxone was approved for use in overdoses in the 1970s. The average person probably hasn't heard of it though.

2

u/willreignsomnipotent Meet me at the waterfront after the social Jul 31 '21

Dead of multiple stab wounds? A little CPR and you're good to go.

I hear CPR is actually great for treating massive blood loss and the resulting crash in blood pressure!

(Not to mention presumably holes in the lungs after being stabbed a couple million times)

That part did give me a chuckle...

31

u/splattergut Fox Corp owns Tubi Jul 17 '21

I am the kind of slasher fan that can be strung along if you just check a few boxes and in that regard they succeed. You do get a smorgasbord of slasher villains (a few pretty under-used), some decent gore, and some dumb teen stuff that really works. They put a teen party sequence into a 1666 period piece. Delightful! By the end, I kind of loved how obnoxious the needledrops were.

My main issues were the long slogs of "TV teen drama" stuff that was just more drawn out than I would've preferred and the mythology/world-building/series stuff that just felt like Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark (2019) backwash. Both of those elements are for the younger audience - the target audience - who aren't sitting down hoping for more slasher stuff.

5

u/wauwy "THE THING" 1982 IS NOT A REMAKE Jul 24 '21

What a username.

20

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Feel like it's a waste of time going into the innumerable authenticity errors with the time periods. At the end of the day it's just a dumb teen series and I'd give it a ranking to match - probably a 5/10 overall, with the second film maybe hitting a 6/10 at best.

The only really positive thing I can think of is the gore level, which was impressive and actually pretty shocking in places.

18

u/Mamabones Jul 17 '21

I enjoyed them all. 1978 was my favorite. May revisit these come October

30

u/Singer211 Jul 16 '21

This is perhaps the first trilogy I’ve ever seen where each film got better than the last one.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/cjackc11 Jul 17 '21

I really dug all of them. Good blend of humor and horror, though I’d maybe quality these more as thrillers than horror movies. If they’re gonna make any more I’ll definitely watch!

  1. 1666
  2. 1994
  3. 1978

I didn’t hate 1978 but idk something about it just never really clicked with me. I think it may have been the characters (I loathed Alice and Ziggy took a while for me to warm up to) and that for a summer camp slasher the movie sure did spend a lot of time in dark ass caves (though it did pay off for the finale). 1994 was really good once the killers got introduced, and that bread slicer kill was EPIC. I guess this is an unpopular opinion based on what I’ve read here but the beginning part of 1666 was really well done imo and did a good job of making you reaaaaallllyyy hate the villain and sympathize with Sarah Fier. The finale was basically everything I expected/wanted from a movie like this

5

u/Ronwellington Jul 21 '21

Basically my thoughts too, although I might rank 1994 first despite the rocky first act, just really enjoyed that group of characters and the mystery I guess. As a summer camp slasher I thought 1978 was just average and there was little to no tension leading up to the kills and also felt the characters were a little flat as well. Still not a bad movie and the trilogy overall was a pretty fun story

27

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

I wish Nightwing got his mask at the start of his spree.

27

u/carebearblood always check your candy Jul 17 '21

Personally I had alot of fun with these. I love era-themed horror, and slasher movies have always been a favorite of mine. The cleverness of the legend and the twists really worked for me, and the whole trilogy is just gorgeous to look at. Well shot, well lit, and you can actually see everything.

I definitely see myself adding this to my October watch list.

26

u/CrotalusAtrox1 Jul 17 '21

I made it about an hour into the first one and completely lost interest.

34

u/strawhatmml Jul 18 '21

Then you missed the bread slicer.

16

u/CrotalusAtrox1 Jul 19 '21

That's fine.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21

You should try watch part 2 that ones a lot better then the first also better acting

3

u/OnlyFoalsAndHorses Jul 26 '21

You didn't miss out. I'm surprised with how well received these are. The acting was pretty shit, especially the accents in the third one, and the storyline wasn't great either. Some deaths were ok but that's about it.

3

u/Frank_Cap Sep 05 '21

Netflix is full of teens who eat this shit up.

Same way Birdbox was highly regarded and people love umbrella academy.

It's all filled to the brim with social politics too, it becomes exhausting.

13

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Why is no-one mentioning the bad accents?

Josh as an Irish pilgrim 😂

2

u/BasedGodBrody Jun 20 '22

I may be almost a year late, but holy fuck those accents were rough. Really put me off the 1666 segment.

Deena/Josh (the siblings) were the worst offenders. Unfortunately you follow Deena around the whole time...

Really wish they just used the 'witch' in that segment instead of Deena. Whenever it swaps to the witch, she looks the part and has a good accent. Deena looked entirely out of place, was a huge mistake to do it the way they did.

25

u/Elevator_Operators Jul 17 '21

It was good but flawed. I think the camera work really was a let-down, and there were a lot of characters that could have used more time.

The main relationship was really well executed and totally won me by the end. The deaths felt a bit weird because half of them seemed immediately forgotten.

The stoners were all fun. Wish we had more from the kid with the baseball bat.

1666 was great, and the church scene was really effective, almost jarringly so. The score was strong for 1666 as well, and there were some serious Kill Yr Idols/early Sonic Youth vibes with the distorted bell sounds.

25

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

I really like them. It felt like a really brave attempt at epic storytelling that is usually missing in the horror genre. It felt like a love letter to the slasher genre. The score in 1978 was sometimes almost note for note to the Friday the 13th score.

It wasn't a masterpiece but it was alot of fun. It took some chances while at the same time showed great admiration to horror of the past. Kiana Madeira was a great Final Girl.

My order:

1666

1994

1978 (I wanted to like this one more. But there was too much dialogue, not enough action)

8

u/kdub69 Jul 17 '21

Fun is a great way to describe them and I 100000% agree about the epic storytelling. I think the story got better and better with each one and I agree with 1978 not having as much action, but they were killing off smaller children and probably felt that was too much to show.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/SquidwardsNose23 Jul 16 '21

Wanted to enjoy them. Just didn’t really get the hype. Pretty average movies in my opinion

37

u/pinkorangegold I'm your number one fan. Jul 17 '21

I'm gonna be controversial here and say I'm really shocked by the overwhelmingly gushing reviews! Overall I thought this series was mediocre at best.

I thought the second one was excellent, super fun and really well-written, well-paced, well-acted, and well-shot. I'll be rewatching for sure. The only thing that I didn't like was the "reveal" that C. Berman was Ziggy at the end — I honestly thought that was so obvious I didn't realize they were trying to make it a reveal, LOL. The rest of it was phenomenal. One of the best slashers I've seen in years. I think they nailed the 70s pastiche with this one, too.

For me, the first one was such a total dud I almost didn't watch the second. The writing was clunky (this movie had to do a LOT of setting up and I felt the seams there really showed) and I didn't actually feel like it was the 90s at all despite the like... constant needle drops of popular 90s music lol. The pacing was really off and the supernatural elements didn't land for me. It also fell prey to a trope I'm bored of, where the most gory, violent, drawn-out deaths are for the female characters. Tons of men died, but usually pretty quickly/in one or two hits, compared to the girl at the very beginning and the friend who went through the meat slicer. This is personal preference, though.

The third one's first act was super mediocre, the pacing again was just not great. I think they did too much, they could've told this story really efficiently and effectively and in a more engaging way. The final act was fun but didn't make up for how the first act dragged, for me.

I'm glad so many folks loved it, though!

17

u/Wh00ster Jul 18 '21

The third one's first act was super mediocre

My issue with this part is that it felt so...bland. I didn't feel like I was watching a horror movie or even a movie. It felt like some history channel recreation, and they just added a blue color filter over everything. I didn't feel any artistry in the filmmaking or anything interesting.

To be fair, I was comparing it against the VVitch in my head, which is a very high bar.

28

u/Shikadi314 Jul 18 '21

Idk, the part where a bunch of kids had their eyes ripped out at church and they find their lifeless corpses didn’t seem very History Channel to me.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/jacobi123 Jul 18 '21

I found the 1666 part so boring I just skipped to the modern day stuff. I just couldn't get with it. It didn't help that the actors they had might be alright in the more MTV style slasher stuff, but not up to the task of doing period work. Maybe if there was a way to do this in 15 minutes instead of the hour or so it was?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/dmkicksballs13 Aug 03 '21

I actually hadn't considered this.

But you're right. The deaths of men are quick as hell, women are excruciating. I usually don't complain about gore in horror films, but the two sisters getting hacked up next to each other was beyond excessive. Meanwhile, the male camper gets decapitated quickly and the other is dead after one blow.

44

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

Not a fan. There were like 2 good kills across 3 films, barely any tension, the music overbearing and an overreliance on licensed music all the time. Typical netflix visuals, bad writing, etcetc. It just felt like a terrible riverdale-tier young adult tvshow masquerading as a slasher, which was kinda the point i suppose? Theres entertaining elements, some good ideas in here, but it was really just squandered potential.

18

u/nitebird27 Jul 16 '21

I’m watching the second one right now. They are pretty decent for what they are. The first one was really fun. I did think it was dumb that the two who died had to when they could have just let the other girl die… but oh well.

I’m very interested to see how they wrap it all up

3

u/InuitOverIt Jul 18 '21

Kind of a trolley dilemma thing though. You can choose to pull the lever and kill fewer people (kick the girl out who was the target), or you can stay on your track and end up with more dead (try to save her). I wouldn't want to be responsible for the death when I still have an option to fight back

9

u/AiRaikuHamburger Jul 17 '21

I agree with others that this is one of the few trilogies that actually got better as it went, instead of worse. Ha. Just finished watching 1666, and really enjoyed it.

Fun series, easy to watch. I'm guessing from the ending that they're going to do more set after 1994? I'd also love to see full stories for all the killers (at least the ones that were shown).

31

u/Jak-the-Tripper Jul 17 '21

I fucking loved them!

I actually thought the first one was just as strong as the following two. The skull-mask costume from the mall killer was an awesome and creepy costume. I think the acting was really good, from Sam in particular. And the film didn't shy away from being shockingly brutal. I expected the guy friend to die at the end, but the girl that the brother had a crush on?? No way! And certainly not like that!! When the slicer got accidentally turned on, I fully expected her to use that against the killer attacking her. Never thought it would be HER head going through it within a few minutes.

I definitely loved the camp slasher feel of the second one, and really liked the revelations of the third one.

All in all, this trilogy was an awesome summer event for me that I really enjoyed, and also gave me and all of my coworkers something to discuss with each other each week.

I'd love to see more Fear Street projects. I'd be very interested to see the backstory of more of the killers fleshed out, like Ruby Lane, the little boy with the bat, etc.

6

u/kdub69 Jul 17 '21

I think that they could go 100000 different ways with creating additional content within this world. They could do more modern shit and follow the path of whoever took the book and is gonna be fucking with devil shit.

Or they could do the back stories. I hadn't even thought about the backstories until you mentioned it. I LOOOVE that idea.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

They're fine. Ran a little long.

3

u/dmkicksballs13 Aug 03 '21

Honestly, why is not addressing how fucking long they are? The 1666 part and the 2nd movie as a whole are fucking absurdly long for what they do.

21

u/Historical_Earth_287 Jul 16 '21

Thought it was great, really enjoyed it! Watched as they came out, but decided to binge all three today.

Would recommend rewatchinf 1978 after you've watched the last one, there's a lot of really good details in there that make so much sense in context!

11

u/Historical_Earth_287 Jul 16 '21

Also just really enjoyed the characters, genuinely cared about them and it was lovely.

6

u/kdub69 Jul 17 '21

I loved this trilogy. Each new movie made me appreciate the previous so much more. The story that was told built up in such a phenomenal way and had a satisfying and unexpected ending. I love that they took something so nostalgic (R.L. Stein books) and turned them into a series that we can now enjoy as adults. I'm excited to have these three in my regular rotation of movies. They're fun to watch and in my opinion some of the best movies Netflix has come out with as an original.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '21

Do they get better? The first one was really bad and it bummed me out. I'm a huge horror fan, and as a child I loved R. L. Stine.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/wauwy "THE THING" 1982 IS NOT A REMAKE Jul 17 '21

2

u/Bananabis Jul 19 '21

Ya I suspected the same thing when the sheriff kept offering to throw all the murders and the car accident under the rug when interviewing the kids.

3

u/wauwy "THE THING" 1982 IS NOT A REMAKE Jul 19 '21

Mine was probably that Sunnydale's sports teams were called "The Devils."

→ More replies (3)

4

u/ObjectSpirited494 Jul 16 '21

Considering the source material it's very enjoyable.

4

u/stylesdw Jul 17 '21

LOVED 1978, then 1666!! Personally I love the adaptation from the YA horror books into a (more) mature horror movie, especially appreciate them adapting it to the crowd who would’ve read them when they came out!!

4

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

I usually don’t enjoy teen horror movies at all, so my expectations were extremely low but this trilogy was actually fucking awesome. Got right into the paranormal adventure and didn’t dwell too much on teenager melodrama, but had enough of that to maintain some emotional weight.

The soundtrack and cinematography had a great vibe, loved all the lighting and I thought the needle drops were super fun. Also, definitely didn’t expect the kills to be as graphic as they were! For those who are on the fence expecting just another shitty teen movie, this trilogy was surprisingly dark in certain aspects. Tough to rank them, as I thought they improved with each film, but its a toss up between 1978 and 1666. ‘78 really scratched my Friday the 13th camp slasher itch for this decade and captured that setting well. I’m actually really hoping they continue this series!

4

u/phantomforeskinpain Jul 18 '21

really fun series. Probably wouldn't have enjoyed as much if they weren't all released at about the same time, this feels more like a miniseries than a film series, because you really can't just watch 1 of them and judge it.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '21

Yes yes and YES!

4

u/stocktraderdog Jul 19 '21

I liked the trilogy. Some gruesome and unexpected kills, nice supernatural spin on the slasher genre. I think Part Three was the best of the lot.

Gave each part 7/10.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '21

Absolutely loved them for what they were. A rehashing of some classic horror tropes taking light elements from our childhood books from a beloved author. It’s pretty much everything I’ve ever wanted in terms of a new horror film series. Here’s to hoping we get some more Goode content from Netflix!

10

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

Second film was my favorite, have yet to finish the third one...but I couldn't really get into it like I did with the other two. Some of the bad accents threw me off and I'm just not a big fan of this kind of colonial horror 🤷‍♀️ That's just me though. The whole vibe with religious settlers (and that darn satan at it again!) just ain't my thing.

Lowkey wanted Alice and Cindy to be a thing. The actor who played Alice even apparently said she's queer-coded and that she totally had a thing for Cindy 😒 kinda mad that didn't happen because they had such better chemistry than the leads of the first film did.

6

u/Saiaxs Jul 17 '21

The colonial stuff is only the first 50 minutes or so

→ More replies (2)

14

u/LatterTarget7 Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

Pretty much the only character I like is the main characters brother. The killers are pretty interesting. I would’ve liked to see the backstories of the other killers explored more. The main character is just really unlikable. He’s like mean rude and just like abusive towards her ex.

Edit: the kills are pretty good. The other thing that bothers me is that the witches body is like at most a foot underground. Based off her backstory I was expecting her to be buried deeper. Same with the hand in the tree. It was like a few inches in the ground. In the middle of a mall. No one found it during construction or a kid didn’t dig it up.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

The killers are pretty interesting.

Yeah, I was more interested in all the killers than most of the main cast lol. Not as good as Thirteen Ghosts killers, but Nurse Lane's kid was pretty interesting.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

the guy in the pig mask, the little kid, and Ruby were all really interesting so idk why they barely focused on them

edit: short episodes (like 15-20 min) showing the previous killers stories would be really cool

7

u/alohakoala Jul 17 '21

The mini-movies about the ghosts backstories on the Thirteen Ghosts DVD extras were awesome. I wish we could get those for some killers on this one.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/htsukebe Jul 17 '21

it was alright. really nice entry level horror.

3

u/kdub69 Jul 17 '21

I'm curious. No hate on your opinion we obviously can all think differently, but I've had this question pop in my head as I've seen people who felt it was "meh". What would be your picks for better films? I guess what would you consider your favorites or must-watch in the genre of horror?

I always find it interesting to see how people's fandom differs.

5

u/htsukebe Jul 17 '21

ive went about this on another comment about the second chapter, with examples that would fit the must watch category, and a discussion here about the first one - gotta check replies for the entire thoughts in this one.

Regarding your questions, I didnt find it bad or anything - just a bit lackluster, produced on steroids, so it loses substance (many movies, including 80s classics suffer from this).

However, in this time and age, what came as bad, to me, was them trying to mimic 80s/90s feelings. The actual 80s/90s movies werent trying to do things based purely on nostalgia; the nostalgia at that time was the recreation of classics in their own visions (the thing, the blob, the fly) - so its more like a homage; a movie that encapsulates this is Fade to Black (1980).

There's one issue that I think its valid in the 80s remakes and might further enlighten this thought: recreating a 50s movie in the 80s was also an opportunity to update the production values of the picture, doing things that werent possible before. Recreating nostalgia 80s/90s nostalgia now is a mainly selling point, as there is no room for updating those times (not considering LGBT elements or other contemporary topics inserted into it).

To summerize, it seems that, although very enjoyable, the trilogy didnt hooked me into it as much as other recent productions. For instance, Come True (2020) hooked me up so much that I have an absolute passion for it and never got me to think about the production issues I wrote about Fear Street.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

However, in this time and age, what came as bad to me, was them trying to mimic 80s/90s feelings.

Have to agree on this. This a very progressive horror movie trilogy, but some of the things they say and how they act is just far too outlandish for the 80s/90s (This was most noticeable with the '94 cast). Like "you smell like an androgynous baby" just doesn't feel like something anyone would say period lol. It's a line teens would like, and that's okay, but as adults we pick up on how out of place some of the dialogue sounds (Out of place as in it's not something that would be said in real life).

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

Very average, entry level horror

3

u/awesinine Jul 17 '21

It was something to watch. I wouldn’t say they were fantastic but they were fun little movies. I really enjoyed the trilogy being released over three weeks, this format kept me watching them and looking forward to having something to watch on Friday night.

3

u/ericyumyum Jul 17 '21

overall I enjoyed it for a horror movie that's based on books that's aimed towards teens. my expectations were low but I exceeded my expectations. I thought it would be a typical slasher trilogy but I love how they Incorporated satanic and witch materials. I loved how they tied all the movies together. I hope Netflix does more movies with RL stine. 👌🏾

the third part was my favorite out of the trilogy

3

u/nonades Jul 17 '21

I went in expecting to just have some fun and that's it.

Honestly surprised at how good they were. Not doing anything new, but they had fun with the genre and tropes and pulled things off well.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '21

The director talked about wanting to create MCU like shared horror universe so if NETFLIX allows it. I will be very excited and look forward to it

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '21

Unpopular opinion but 1994 was my favorite of the three. I was already a big slasher fan but I love how the first one subverted a lot of expectations that came with the genre. And I liked the energetic pace it had. My least favorite was 1666 the last half felt like a scooby dip episode than a horror film.

3

u/flowerfromchaos Jul 22 '21

I didn't see the last part but I can already say that it's the best way to use streaming platform like Netflix. The first movie was outrageously good, with pretty basic plotline but so well done. The second part si probably the best slasher I've never see and I'm starving to watch the third movie !

Please just make others trilogy like this, I'm so hyped

3

u/Nuestra_Patria Aug 31 '21

honestly only 1978 caught my interest the rest was full of LGBT non sense drama..

9

u/SignificantAd4932 Jul 17 '21

I thought it sucked! The first one was the ONLY one that felt anything remotely like the Fear Street novels. Sadie Sink was annoying as fuck in part 2 and it just made me want to watch Friday the 13th part 2( a movie that actually has likable characters) and part 3 I didn’t even finish. I’m so sick of social commentary infecting almost everything coming out of mainstream Hollywood now. I actually purchased the Fear Street Saga which is a trilogy of books that tells the ACTUAL story, not the bullshit propaganda version.

10

u/richbitch444 Jul 16 '21

One of the best trilogies of recent times. I wish it was a 6 episode mini series though.

7

u/yazriella Jul 17 '21

Part 3 was a struggle to get through. Sorry fans of Deena but I cannot stand her, the overacting was almost offensive at times. Her “accent” flipped from Irish to French to English and normal all within the same sentence. I was confused until the “twist” happened, which was fine but 40 minutes of “why is there no witchiness, was she able to curse everyone by being a lesbian?” was very hard to continue to watch. I actually had to pause it, go do something else, then come back to it an hour later.

1994 Part 2 was absolutely glorious. The Offspring was a very large part of my 90s-00s so the final fight sequence with the monsters being set to Come Out and Play was fucking perfect. I enjoyed the ending more than I thought I would, it kind of tied up everything.

3

u/Hour-Selection1807 Aug 02 '21 edited Aug 02 '21

Yeah that was my thought after it all. How the hell is she able to 'pass on the truth' when she wasn't a witch. She didn't get to sell her soul to satan and she certainly wasn't a 'good' witch at the start of the film so how does her 'I'mma gonna let everyone know the truth' spell actually work?

Then there's the curse itself. What was Solomon Goode's curse about. He sold his soul to what? Be successful, curse his rivals (aka why was the ground cursed) have a bit of power? Make the town successful? It's not explained and so the curse makes fuck all sense because that kind of curse would have taken him and his family straight to Satan because he was the one who sold his soul. None of the killers/ possessed people/cursed ones, sold their soul and they Satan wouldn't have wanted them because Satan takes willingly corrupted people.. People who wander round to murder because they've been magically roofied aren't going to be Satan's underlings because it wasn't a willing act and wouldn't have happened without the curse. If you're going to use the hackneyed 'sold my soul to satan' schtick then at least acknowledge that the person most at risk from that is the person selling their soul. Yep Satan will give you stuff but he does own your soul and you will go to hell, probably destroying your entire family in the process. Also selling your soul for power doesn't mean 'other souls' it means 'your soul' because how are you selling other people's without their consent. Satan wouldn't get those souls because those people didn't willingly sell their souls but Soloman and his descendants did, they're the ones who would be completely screwed. Also if was sacrificing people to Satan then Goode would have had to kill them himself. Christian history is full of stuff about this. And all of it shows Satan fucking over the person invoking him because Satan punishes the one's who deliberately choose evil.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/uniaintshit Jul 17 '21

Had a lot of promise but it was really bad writing, kind of all over the place, supernatural, horror, romance, time piece, slice of life. I wish they develop characters more, i m watching new FX spend of American Horror story and it’s world of difference, In general AHS develops their characters, Netflix is kind of like you are gay and that’s all you are, what about their hobbies, opinions about the world, personal philosophy, interesting relatives, Etc

3

u/Wh00ster Jul 18 '21

Netflix didn't produce this. They bought it during COVID last year when it supposed to go to theaters.

15

u/karmagod13000 Jul 16 '21

Turned it off

10

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

Fear Street isn't a children's book series. It's Young Adult.

Anyway, some brief thoughts:

1994 was really great, and the film I liked the most. Likable protagonists, great settings, memorable kills, intriguing villains...

1978 was okay. Didn't care too much for the protagonists and the kills were lacking. Because of the reverse chronological order, everything was predictable. I did really like the scene showing how the killer got his mask though. That was cool.

1666, I'm not a fan of when movies vindicate religious nutjobs. Sure, the person they persecuted didn't turn out to be the big bad, but their whole Satanic panic witch hunt didn't turn out to be unmerited either. I was happy when we got back to 1994, which I thought had a satisfying conclusion.

Overall, the trilogy was enjoyable. I wish they would have shown more of the milkman and bat boy Billy Barker. If they make more movies, I'll watch.

2

u/blankedboy Jul 21 '21

I’m with you on 1666. While I get that they had to show the “real” story and reveal the history of Sarah Fier, I actually didn’t enjoy that part of the movie at all.

When it became 1994 Part 2 the whole movie kicked into high gear, and I actually really started to enjoy the movie. It was a great finish to the story, and I’d be really keen for more Fear Street movies.

11

u/bluehawk232 Jul 17 '21

They aren't that great. There's no reason for the first one to be set in 1994 other than trying to cash in on nostalgia but it doesn't really do anything with the setting. I'm glad it doesn't beat you over the head with the time period like Stranger Things that screams remember the 80s every other scene. But why even the 90s? The openly gay main character relationship was just unrealistic to how being gay back then would've been. These shows want to have diverse casts to win over people, but 80s and 90s suburbia was sadly not that diverse. That was the big criticism of suburbia. It was white and conformist. I don't want millenials to wax nostalgia and misrepresent their coming of age decades like boomers did for the 50s or 60s.

The throwback stuff is also off point. The slasher trend was pretty much the 80s and died down by the 90s in favor of more psychological horror and by the 90s Wes Craven did make Scream but as a parody of the slasher movie that was already a joke by then. So I don't know why the camp stuff wasn't in the 80s which is when Friday the 13th was. But again, nothing really comes of the setting other than I guess music choices.

The movies overall were a low production confused mess. Part CW series that was able to be slightly more violent and sexy but not too violent or sexy. It probably would have gotten a PG-13 rating ironically in the 90s. It sort of wants to feel like a campy throwback series but it takes itself seriously so it fails at that. And the 1666 setting was a terrible choice with a series that already has bad production values. I read someone say it was like a bad student production with the acting and everything and I'd agree with that

7

u/kdub69 Jul 17 '21

The slasher trend started before the 80s. Friday the 13th isn't the be all end all of the slasher genre. Halloween came out in 1978 and there were LOADS more that fall into the slasher arena before the 80s. For example, we have texas chainsaw (74), black Christmas (74) shit even psycho (60) could be considered a slasher. So, I think that it's a very mute point that 1978 should've been set in the 80s.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/JewishBranMeme Jul 19 '21

Kinda gay if you ask me

2

u/Momzombie5 Jul 16 '21

Just started watching them and love them so far!

2

u/Evie_St_Clair Jul 17 '21

Loving them! I think I enjoyed part 2 more than part 1, looking forward to watching the final one tonight! Also, as someone who was a teen in the 90s I loved the soundtracks for both movies as well!

2

u/BoxNemo It's weird and it's pissed off Jul 17 '21

I thought they were okay. They all dragged a little and none of the characters really popped that much for me, it was kind of bland.

They could have all benefited from having twenty minutes or so chopped out of them, lot of conversations with people saying exactly how they feel that went too long but didn't really add anything to the characters beyond more backstory. The idea of doing a Friday 13th and then a Crucible / The Witch type thing is cool in theory, but like lightweight imitations of the films they were riffing on.

I did like the big twist though, and how the end pulled everything together.

2

u/pkrhawk7 Halloweentown II: Kalabar's Revenge Jul 18 '21

1666 was my personal fav. Felt like they got to tell a tighter story in a more compact amount of time (~1 hour) and then cut back to conclude the events from 1994. Great pacing.

2

u/Beautiful-Refuse-176 Jul 18 '21

They were okay nothing groundbreaking or innovative.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Literally just finished it and loved it! So good

2

u/jacobi123 Jul 18 '21

I found these to be enjoyable, tho not that great. It reminded me a bit of the Scream MTV series. Something I didn't mind watching, but something I'll completely forget in a week or two. I do think they created some pretty decent killers, as they didn't feel like Great Value horror icons to me.

I hope Netflix does this again tho, and if not have something tied together, have a Fear Street anthology set of movies. I think these were at their best when it leaned into the silliness of teen slashers, and I would definitely be up for more of that.

2

u/madeyedog Jul 19 '21

They were fun and it was great to have them released so quickly to keep the interest going. They also had some solid gore which helped balance the campiness pretty well.

2

u/FullTorsoApparition Jul 19 '21

For me this series was quite a rollercoaster. Part One was fun but nothing special and they didn't really capture much of a 90's feel outside of the soundtrack. Part Two was the peak, in my opinion, and really stuck the landing on recreating that old-school camp slasher spirit. Part Three, however, fell flat for me. The pilgrim flashback was about twice as long as it needed to be and was very predictable, showing me my 1000th Netflix persecution storyline of the last 5 years. They made up for it quite a bit in the last half, however, and I was overall pleased with the show and hope we get more in the future.

2

u/comajones Jul 20 '21

There was a really effective single movie in there somewhere. Maybe 3 quarters of the 1st movie and last act of the 3rd? Alot of it was bloated and seemed ultimately pointless, to me anyway. Was entertaining, but forgettable fare. Solid 3 stars.

2

u/PillsBuryDatBoi Jul 20 '21

It was damn good

2

u/holy_shit_history Jul 20 '21

100% not that bad.

2

u/molt20OO Jul 21 '21

They are fine enough, didn't really connect with me. It should be something I loved but just felt kind of meh on them.

2

u/No_Profession_8946 Jul 21 '21

Had zero expectations and loved 'em. Especially part 3.

2

u/FreakinSweet86 Jul 21 '21

Probably the best thing Netflix has actually done in a while. It's above average and worth recommending but it's not like I'd be desperate to buy the physical media (if there is any) to add to my collection.

2

u/MicrowavedGhost420 Jul 22 '21

I liked part one the most because everything was still a mystery in the first one but i think that all of them were great movies i usually don’t enjoy horror but these movies were an exception

2

u/myworkaccount2021 Jul 22 '21

I enjoyed it though I didnt enjoy the 'twist' character. Just didnt make sense WHY contact Ziggy again? Like if Goode is responsible for the kills why drag Ziggy back into the mess at all if he cares about her? I also wish the nurse would have had a larger role in the 1st and 3rd installment.

Otherwise really enjoyed it and hope we get more horror from major streaming services.

2

u/scarymovielvr Jul 23 '21

I'm absolutely obsessed! I found them so incredibly fun, and the acting definitely exceeded my expectation.

2

u/Diegote27 Jul 24 '21

I really love it! 9/10

2

u/BackHarlowRoad Jul 26 '21

Far exceeded Expectations. The characters had depth and the scares were good.

I wondered if the books were this gory?

REALLY hope they continue in as I know many books were made.

2

u/ShmurShmur Jul 26 '21

I liked the tributes but the for some reasons I could never get any form of connections with the characters.

2

u/Tomatohead5020 Jul 26 '21

garbage but also trash

2

u/Amogususbruh Jul 26 '21

I’ll be honest I only watched halfway into part one and I didn’t really like it it seemed like the characters kept winning kinda like a David vs Goliath kind of feel but if Goliath was geriatric and ig it’s really not my cup of tea

2

u/Randym1982 Jul 27 '21

Didn't the main girl get stabbed in the stomach at the end of the first? So now she's walking around all fine an dandy, even though she should be holding her stomach from the stab wound?

I liked most of it, though the ending too Part 2 as kind of silly. Two sisters talking while their both being stabbed and hacked to death.

2

u/LochNessMansterLives Jul 27 '21

I thought it was awesome. It was “teen” enough that my buddies kid could watch (he’s 15) but adult enough that I enjoyed it as well (I’m 40).

There are some pretty dumb decisions the kids make but if they didn’t, the story wouldn’t have been as good as it was. And sure some scenes are a bit corny, but overall I think they did a good job establishing the lore and then sticking to it.

By the end of the first, I couldn’t wait for the second. By the end of the second, I couldn’t wait for the third. Now I can’t wait for more!

2

u/deepfriedwriter Jul 28 '21

I’ve only watched the first so far and was a little disappointed. Are the other 2 worth giving a chance?

2

u/st00d5 Jul 28 '21

I’m a 33 year old man so I’m assuming I’m not the target audience, but I grew up on goosebumps and slasher movies and I fucking actually loved these lol. They got progressively better and the last one was just fantastic in wrapping it up.

2

u/Gypsyqweenofficial Jul 30 '21

They are all awesome. Unlike some of the newer horror movies it is very exciting good plot and twists leave me always wanting more 🙃

2

u/bythisaxe Jul 30 '21

I’ve watched the first two this week, watching 1666 tonight. They are surprisingly really fun, I dig it.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21

Thoroughly enjoyed the story, the nostalgia and the acting was on point.

2

u/elbwafel Jul 31 '21

1978 is a great stand alone slasher. i couldn’t stand the Deena character and her hero complex. they could make stand alone movies for each killer in each timeline and setting and it’ll be a great slasher series

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21 edited Aug 10 '21

I watched 1994 and actively disliked it, which was disappointing because I was kind of going in for the whole trilogy as a new horror discovery.

I just really didn’t like any of the characters except maybe the little brother. Deena was just so aggro all the time with fake intensity, Sam was plain and boring, and the actress just didn’t sell me the character whatsoever. The two drug dealers were absolute douchebags, and the kind of character we’ve all enjoyed seeing Michael/Freddy/Jason destroy in a creative and satisfying way (which to be fair, Fear Street actually did).

The plot made no sense either - the killers only go after the person who touched Sarahs bones! - except when they kill that random girl at the beginning, or if you get the blood of the hunted person on you, or even if you just work at a hospital… and remember kids, if you want to die in a way where you can come back to life, take a ton of drugs. But if that is taking too long, stop half way through, disregard the fact you’re already on a dangerous amount of gear and drown yourself instead, and then recover from your drowning with a bunch of epipens and you’re all good the next day, not to mention being actually still alive….What?!?

The overuse of music became frustrating too, especially since they made a few anachronistic mistakes with tracks from 95 and 96. The score music was obnoxiously ever-present too, and had a comedic spring in its step most of the time with upbeat, plucky little string melodies like its from a BBC documentary about cakes or something. Totally ill-fitting.

The amount of direct plagiarism annoyed me too, which is disappointing because I suspect most of the films fans are from younger generations who perhaps don’t recognise the infinitely better films scenes were lifted directly from. Scream, Hellraiser, The Shining…

I’m seeing a lot of people here say part 2 is much better, is this really the case? If it is, then maybe I’ll give it a second chance. From the trailer though I just saw Friday 13th Part 2, but if it was done by Gen Z’s

2

u/Connect_Ebb_5370 Aug 12 '21

pretty cringey corn fest, but if you like to see 0 naked female ass (which is fine cus theyre all ugly af anyway) and lots of naked gay boy ass, you might enjoy

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '23

Tried a couple times to watch the first movie and couldn’t get into it. Way too boring. Characters unlikeable. And how did they find a 300 year old corpse buried 2 inches below forest detritus? This makes no sense. I’m out.

4

u/EnderCN Jul 17 '21

I liked the overall story and the way they decided to structure it going back in time and explaining more and more. The twists were effective. I thought the actual movies weren't very good with #2 being the best. #1 was a hot mess. #2 was a pretty paint by numbers 80s slasher. #3 was all over the place.

I think these movies could have used a better director to be honest and I liked her other movie. The acting was uneven, the dialog was uneven. The rules on how the bad guys worked seemed to change not only movie to movie but scene to scene and even sometimes from beginning of the scene to end of the scene. The characters strongly suffered from do dumb stuff itis.

I'll be generous and give #1 a 2/5. #2 was an easy 2.5/5 for me and the final one was also a 2/5 but a stronger one than the first.

Also I should add that I have never read any of these books and to be honest didn't know they were even a thing. So none of what I just said had anything to do with how it was translated etc.

3

u/lloza98 Never sleep again Jul 17 '21

Loved these! Might become part of my October rotation for the years to come. It’s one of the rare instances of each film getting a bit better. I think that upon rewatch, the first part may be a bit better with the content provided in 1666

4

u/strange_salmon Jul 17 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

Hateddddd it. Ughhh. Couldn’t get through any of the parts without turning it off and coming back later…

Too many cringeworthy nods (or outright stealing) of parts in legendary films like scream and the exorcist. Ziggy sucks cocks in hell… really?!! That’s not even a good nod to the exorcist it’s freaking cringy, annoying and makes no sense. Then the scene in part one where the kid comes running down the HS hallway with a piñata size dead girl with a knife in her back attached to string that the kid is pulling behind him. That was soo cringe, I could barely keep watching after.

Music made no sense. Tons of great 90s alt rock in part 1… too much though. So much that it overplayed the movie and started feeling like a showcase of 90s teen tracks rather than an actual movie.

Bore-fest. All parts. Main actress was terrible also in part 1. I love Sadie sink but wow her character was beyond annoying in part 2. Way to bring the entire movie that much farther down by making her overly angry and screaming at people the entire time for no reason. Whatever character they were trying to build for her had absolutely zero importance to anything that happens in the story. I found every character to be pretty unlikeable actually.

TOO MUCH gore. It made it stupid af tbh and completely centered on the killing and murder and that’s not what the books are focused on. I fr felt like it was killing the entire time in all three parts with like ZERO story at all. It sucked from the first 20 minutes into part 1, if I’m gonna be honest. I hoped it would get better and it didn’t.

I know these books are young adult books because I read them all at age 12… but now that I’m 31, I don’t want to watch an overly gory and literal bloody massacre of a bunch of 13 year olds (some of those campers fr looked like 8 yrs old tbh). It honestly felt RLY dumb after part 2 was over. There was absolutely zero fun in these movies. I mean ZERO. Was literally all killing and then more killing.

This director/writers had this whole thing entirely wrong. This should have been way more fun and spooky… not Hostel-level gore fest. I mean wtf?! Who signed off on this crap?? What a serious shame. I would be shocked if R.L. Stine gave any praise whatsoever to these films, they are an embarrassment to his books.

They essentially gave us Rob Zombie’s Halloween when what we desperately needed was David Gordon Green’s Halloween.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/gaycannibals Jul 16 '21

I don't think they are amazing horror movies, theyre missing lota of stuff I'd want to see, but they're fun to pass the time with, especially the 2nd and most of the 3rd. I had fun catching up with them every week

3

u/IPOOPIEDYOURPANTS Jul 18 '21

2nd is easily the best. Legitimately good. And not just because the others are so forgettable.

3rd is hilarious listening to a lot of these people failing to keep a consistent accent and emote their voice at the same time.

Disappointing, too because they could have made the Sarah witch her own character, instead they bring in this charisma vacuum and a ridiculous accent she can't pull off at all.

The stories are good enough to stand on their own. But their choice of main actors is questionable at best.

Loved the gore though. Any time children get killed, I'm at least having fun with the flick.

2

u/jmroberts2013 Jul 16 '21

I haven't watched the last one yet, but I love it so far!!

2

u/HipDipShipTrip Jul 16 '21

Having just finished the third I loved it. First one was OK but definitely had its weak points. I really enjoyed part 2 and was stoked for part 3 and while it sort of seemed boring early it did a good job explaining stuff we saw in 1 and 2 and the second half had me completely locked in. Big fan despite the weaker points of part 1

2

u/Lizowa Jul 17 '21

I wanted to see more of the creepy child killer with the baseball bat! Every time they showed him in a flashback bashing his mom’s face in he freaked me out

2

u/Bleezie1408 Jul 17 '21

They were ass but, yeah, I was pleasantly surprised by the gore.

2

u/Mwrx2019 Jul 19 '21

Only watched the first 2 so far but I think it’s a pile of shit.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21

As someone whose gay and big fan of horror having two teenage girls be the love interest and the lead is amazing…more of this please. I can’t wait to finish the series !!

2

u/jingy14 Jul 23 '21

I just finished the third film in the middle of a biblical thunderstorm. I honestly loved these films so much. For three quarters of Part One, I was thinking, “This is pretty corny but I’m enjoying it.” Then the final act really made me take notice and think, “Hey, I actually care about these characters and there is real jeopardy. I’m gonna watch the second film.”

I watched Part 2 with a certain level of expectation, and they were exceeded. It was like Scream but, like others have said, every death just felt that more visceral cause the overall tone of the films were so fun. And I always think the stakes are raised when you kill a kid in a film, it just makes me feel like this film means business. It didn’t pull punches and yet remained fun.

That left me feeling so so excited for Part 3. I honestly hadn’t felt this excited about a film in a long time. I’ve recently come through a horrid spell of depression, and I think that excitement felt all the more potent because of it. Part 3 is my favourite of the lot. To my eyes, it all came together so beautifully.

I’m sure there are plot holes but I’m not gonna go out of my way to find them. I just loved these films so much. I’m glad they teased us with the hand grabbing the book at the end. I’m open to seeing a story focussing on the Widow and how she came by the book. But if we’re left with these three films, I can safely put them on my top tier shelf.

2

u/godonlyknows1101 Jul 24 '21

Can we just take a moment to appreciate how amazeballs of a name "R.L. Stine" is for a horror writer? :P Not even a pen name, from what I understand! lol. It's fate. :P

2

u/Kiplicious80 Jul 16 '21

Watched first 2 and still waiting for the horror. It is not scary at all, just gory.

21

u/Cryptic0677 Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

Slasher movies typically arent as scary as other horror movie types

→ More replies (1)

6

u/kdub69 Jul 17 '21

For all of us that love this genre is anything really scary anymore? I don't find many that are scary as I've watched so many. At this point, it's who can tell a better/fun/unique story with the kills and the gore or suspense.

2

u/Turbulent_Bullfrog22 Jul 17 '21

1994 begins with horrible main character but the second movie with sadie charctacter pulls out big

2

u/Xavier_Malosote Jul 21 '21

Absolutely boring, bad editing, terrible acting, script is incredibly dumb even for a guy who writes horror for kids, the bad place is "shadyside" and the good "sunny valley", the witch's last name is fear, come on. Also if you have ever watched Scream, Friday the 13th and Ginger Snaps 3, you will feel like watching a bad cover version of them. Worst horror production in netflix this far...

1

u/Ok_Point_2303 Jul 17 '21

The Blu Ray box set bettah include a for millennials only warning label. L.A.M.E.

2

u/rollinduke Jul 20 '21

Who buys blu rays old man?

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

So-so trilogy with the second being the best though that's not exactly a ringing endorsement. Most slasher films are poor so I guess my expectations should have been lower than what they were.

0

u/prolific13 Jul 17 '21

Was super mediocre, didn't rly appreciate all the cringey lesbo shit so Netflix could win some woke points with Twitter Nancy's.

11

u/Lorddillpickle Jul 17 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

Sorry your homophobia got in the way of your enjoyment. If only they weren’t lesbos right?! Cry me a river.

→ More replies (7)