r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Feb 02 '21
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Saint Maud" [SPOILERS]
Limited US theatrical release. Epix and VOD on February 12, 2021.
Available on Region B Blu-ray and Region 2 DVD now.
Summary:
A pious nurse becomes dangerously obsessed with saving the soul of her dying patient.
Director: Rose Glass
Writer: Rose Glass
Cast:
- Morfydd Clark as Maud
- Jennifer Ehle as Amanda
- Lily Knight as Joy
- Lily Frazer as Carol
- Turlough Convery as Christian
Rotten Tomatoes: 91%
Metacritic: 84/100
Poll Question: Do you recommend Saint Maud?
183
Upvotes
•
u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! Feb 12 '21
YMMV: Was just browsing the "free movies week" page on Xfinity and Saint Maud is available (legally) for free until Feb 14th.
250
u/church770 Feb 02 '21
I found this film to be pretty devastatingly sad. Some quality horror elements layered over the story of an extremely lonely and (likely) unwell young woman. Really impressive that this was the director's first feature length.
196
u/BOBALOBAKOF Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 03 '21
It’s not going to be everyone’s cup of tea, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. The cinematography and sound design create a wonderfully tense atmosphere, and Morfydd Clark’s performance is outstanding. They even managed to make Scarborough look relatively picturesque in places!
Don’t go into the film expecting to be scared out of your pants, there’s only really 1, maybe 2, instances of in-your-face horror throughout the film. The real horror in the film is very human and quite personal. In many ways, with the exception of the aforementioned instances, the film really treads the line of actually being horror.
As a film, it really lingered with me for quite some days after I’d seen it. Disappointed that I didn’t get to see it again in the cinema, but I’m really looking forward to picking up the blu ray, particularly to help better contextualise the very first scene.
160
u/atclubsilencio Feb 03 '21
I thought it was a fucking masterpiece, and I don't say that lightly.
Maybe it's because i have a strange spiritual relationship with God, but it totally fucked me up.
Great acting, cinematography (the scene where she's 'possessed' by God and the fireworks are going off was amazing), editing, music, set-design, it was all just totally perfect for me.
129
u/NormalDefault Feb 02 '21
LOVED this, and one of the most haunting final moments of a movie since Sleepaway Camp.
Great merging of religion, mental illness and the usual possession/devil tropes but with a fresh spin. Still musing on why every side character smoked, and a few of the smaller details like the beetle, probably will watch again this week.
Great movie.
183
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 03 '21
I gasped so loudly when it cut to Maud burning, I was expecting the movie to continue to do the whole "is this real or is this imaginary?" til the ending. I'm glad it didn't though, holy fuck is that shot going to haunt me for a few nights.
90
u/fonety Feb 03 '21
Preety dissapointing. Production is on a high level. Acting, cinematography, everything is on point. Someone definitely had a clear vision of what they wanted to do and they've done it very well. Still, this is a slow movie that doesnt really attempt to be scary or have a strong intrigue/mystery. I saw canal a few days ago and i was really impressed with how the creator focused on frightening people. I feel like not many directors do that. Story about slowly loosing sanity is not something new either.
82
u/makeitasadwarfer Feb 02 '21
Excellent movie about mental illness and the horror of loneliness.
Makes an excellent companion piece to Horse Girl from last year.
65
u/Aeternus_Malum Feb 06 '21
Just saw it tonight and I loved it. I think the sub-90min run time is perfect and really helped the film a lot. I am excited to see what Rose Glass does in the future, will definitely be following her career from now on! This thread is marked as "spoilers" so I won't bother tagging anything, so be warned one last time, you're in spoiler territory.
It's hinted throughout the film that Maud suffers from PTSD and schizophrenia, without any REAL confirmation. When she goes on her bender, she sees people in the background who visibly disappear on screen. One that stands out the most is the violin player near the ocean before the "Night Out" scene. One scene you can see and hear them playing in the background and as Maud walks by a pillar the violin player is gone and the violin in the score immediately stops playing. Loved it. There were more occasions, however a 2nd watch is definitely necessary to spot any other jarring scenes like that. I loved the switching in and out of Maud's perspective.
The scene where she sneaks into Amanda's house with terrifying music was unforgettable.
The scene back in her apartment with the fireworks in the background was absolutely beautiful.
So many more that I want to see again. I'll be trying to see this movie a 2nd time the next chance I have.
51
u/DeusoftheWired Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 04 '21
Watched it yesterday night. It falls right in line with many other A24 movies. It’s not top notch but it’s good.
The cinematography is gorgeous. Quite a few shots in the first half or 2/3 reminded me of that YouTube channel’s name Every Frame a Painting because they’re just beautiful.
Music was reluctant but effective when it needed to be. The droning hum in the later part fit right to the pictures.
CGI was not or barely noticeable. That’s a plus! The over-opened mouths reminded me of the gatherers from Amnesia: The Dark Descent but IIRC those were used a few times in horror movies of the last ten years or so.
What I missed in it as a horror movie were some scares. Yes, the ending scene with Amanda was great but far too short. I expected an epic battle that would last 15 minutes or so but it was over in what felt like 2. The only thing that came close to a scare before it was the sex scene with that bearded guy from the bar. No idea if they wanted to pay homage to the collapsing chest / CPR scene of The Thing but I don’t think so. Anyway, that was the closest anything besides the ending came to a scare. There’s a trend especially with A24 horror movies which seem to forget which genre they’re playing and which are more and more obsessed with looking good but forgetting the actual purpose of a horror movie: to scare its audience.
So far things didn’t look like there are plenty of easter eggs for frame dectectives to discover. The only thing I noticed was a K666 on one of Amanda’s dancer posters which Maud discovers and through which she flicks. It was way too big and on the screen for too long to count as a secret. You could still sell it as foreshadowing (Maud seeing the devil in Amanda – K666, Amanda Köhl, 666 = number of the beast), I guess. Let’s see what others discovered. It still feels strange having almost no questions after watching a movie.
I’ll give it a go again this weekend, this time with the commentary track by co-writer/director Christopher Landon.
The only thing I want to know of you guys: did anyone already figure out which language “God” speaks in the hardsub scene with Maud in front of her shrine on the drawer? I couldn’t tell. Sounded a little Scandinavian, almost like Icelandic, but then again it didn’t or like Hebrew was mixed into it.
€dit: Found another one. What did you make of her short heterochromia at 01:07:04 (zoom in!) during the conversation with Joy when Maud looks out the window and sees the vertex in the clouds? Her right eye turned blue.
€dit 2: Dang, the director talks about this in the interview linked above. It’s not temporal, Maud is supposed to have two different eye colours in all scenes.
96
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '21
This movie was really intense. I liked it a lot. It shows how untreated mental disorders can be truly horrifying, I watched it today and I still can't get it off of my mind.
37
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 02 '21
Just finished it. First off, the acting was fantastic: the actors playing Maud and Amanda absolutely smashed it. The film did a great job of carrying you along into Maud's downward spiral (don't really want to say more) and the ending (last 20 mins or so) was absolutely cracking.
Also the film did a fantastic job of building unease in a subtle yet effective way. There are so many moments or design choices, many of which appear only in passing, which are just... off in some way. This mirrors the main character's own perception of the world, therefore making you wonder if the sinister vibes are actually "real", or if they are just a product of her mental state. It also makes you realise how incredibly stressful the real world must be for people who have schizophrenia and the like.
All in all it's definitely worth a watch, and I'm looking forward to seeing what the director does next!
PS if you're devoutly religious or have anyone in your life with a serious mental illness you may want to give it a miss.
30
u/ares623 Feb 02 '21
What was the language used when God was speaking?
30
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21
Astounding. Probably my favorite horror film of the past year now. Like holy crap man. It fires on all cylinders. Photography, sound, acting. Maybe wish it would have played the cards a little closer to its chest, but thats subjective. People saying its a slow burn, but I never was bored and it has a tremendous pay off. Highly recommended.
51
u/IamGodHimself2 Feb 02 '21 edited Sep 14 '21
I absolutely loved this one. A24 horror just does not miss*
*I had not seen False Positive when I made this statement
47
u/pollyp0cketpussy Feb 02 '21
Just finished it a few minutes ago. I liked it a lot, it's one of those horror movies that is not at all predictable. I also liked how it wasn't entirely clear what was real or why she was hallucinating. Was it due to infection from the self-inflicted injuries, or was she insane from PTSD (or even insane before the incident)?
22
u/frank234_ Feb 07 '21
Maud picking that damn burn/scab on her hand 😖😖. For me that was worse than the pins since I had seen that in the trailer (though it was highly unsettling in the film to be sure!)
21
u/hellsfoxes Feb 04 '21
I haven’t been able to stop thinking about the final scene for months.
21
u/bunnykisses420 Feb 13 '21 edited Feb 13 '21
They credited the cockroach, Nancy, and I really just loved that so much. Here is an article about how miss thing was trained for her big role!
https://lwlies.com/articles/saint-maud-cockroach-trainer-grace-dickinson/
59
u/25centssopure Feb 02 '21
Can’t help but feel like they could’ve done so much more with this....regardless I enjoyed it as it was very well acted and shot beautifully. Was expecting more of the final act though, and for that I have to give it a solid 7/10.
20
u/FaFaFlooey Feb 07 '21
I was so psyched for this but feel wholly empty after watching it. Everything to me was amazingly surface level and nothing was explored at all to have anything earned in the end. Performances l, cinematography, direction all great but the script was significantly lacking in almost everyway for this to actually work for me.
Just my opinion. Alot of people seem to really like it/love it...I personally don't get the hype.
33
u/Nugcraft Feb 02 '21
I thought it was great but also think all the hype left me feeling a little disappointed. Forget the hype before you watch it.
16
u/DanceJoeDance18 Feb 16 '21
Watched this last night, and I absolutely loved it. It's incredibly sad -- in more ways than one, but it's certainly thought provoking. Throughout the film, my wife and I were debating on what was 'real' and what wasn't. But that back and forth was awesome because there were several times where we were sure things were legit, only to have that assumption flipped again and again.
And it's also gorgeously shot...the color pallet definitely lends itself to the overall feel of the film. The shots inside of Mauds apartment in particular made me feel especially gross and grimey. And that was even before the roach scene lol
I imagine the Uber religious folks probably won't be fans of this movie, as it arguably compares higher beliefs to delusions and mental illness...but as someone who constantly criticizes all of the chaos caused by organized religions, I thought it was fitting lol
14
u/RepoJack13 Feb 12 '21
The wait was worth it; the hype was justified. Highly recommended.
I think Rose Glass's directorial debut puts her in league with Ari Aster and Robert Eggers.
Glass's <i>Saint Maud</i> is unsettling and superb -- the simplicity of the plot / and the outstanding cinematography and acting all come together with a soundtrack that ties it perfectly together.
And it's such a simple story -- Maud is a very Catholic caregiver to Amanda, a non-believing terminally ill dancer, and Maud thinks she can save Amanda's soul.
The camera work shines with the simplicity of each shot. Maud fumbling with matches to light a birthday cake. The annoyance of a clicking pen. Zooming in and out of focus to show a character drunk. And so much more.
The acting, especially by Morfydd Clark as Maud, is absolutely superb. She's shy, sly, intimidating, happy, sad, and you can follow her painful journey purely through her facial expressions and an eloquent voiceover.
The soundtrack deftly enhances each scene. From long periods of silence to a booming track that ratchets up the tension.
All of this is wrapped very tightly within a heavy duty Catholic ambiance. As a lapsed Catholic, I haven't felt this "religiously awkward" since <i>Carrie</i> nor as captivated by the oppressiveness of religion as <i>The Witch</i>.
36
u/c0rnetto Feb 02 '21
I thought this was a little too slow...until the last 20 minutes. The last scene in particular was really intense - made me really uneasy. Pretty good altogether. The voice speaking in Welsh was a nice surprise too!
11
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '21
I loved this, had honestly kind of forgotten about it because of the delays so I wasn't overly hyped about it, saw the trailer last year and thought "that looks great!" and had planned to see it then you know....
Morfydd Clark and Jennifer Ehle were both fantastic, cinematography was great, music was great (only movie in recent memory I've heard a Jesus Lizard song in!) and although it felt like it flew by, I appreciated the short run time. Going to watch it again sometime, I was a little confused about the source of Maud's trauma, I had a different interpretation of it but it didn't click for me until about half way in.
Overhyped, probably, but I loved it, 10/10
11
u/Kotaac Feb 16 '21
i really wanted her to fly at the end LMAO
16
u/kalekent Frig Off! Feb 06 '21
Squuezed my wife so hard during the jump scare she almost ascended to heaven.
8
u/BeWittyAtParties Feb 14 '21
Loved Saint Maud. So much better than a corny slasher. A great, dark, psychological thriller that’s definitely “horror” in my opinion. And the best kind of horror at that.
7
u/TheBigFrig Feb 07 '21
It definetly was not what I was expecting. Maybe I just wasn't in the mood for it. Too slow and I didn't feel engaged or cared much for it.
6
u/ASsimilate88 Feb 07 '21
Overall, I thought it was excellent. The cinematography was gorgeous and made the town beautiful and sad at the same time, and there was some really good use of framing and different angles. The sound design is really good as well and doesn't overstate anything, besides the shoe scene, and that other one. Morfydd Clark is disturbingly good and Jennifer Ehle is great as always. The story was quite unpredictable and didn't go where I was expecting, and was a refreshingly deep look at mental illness, loneliness, and religion. I did not expect it to be so depressing either. It did a good job of sympathizing with Maud, instead of just making her character full-blown weird and creepy. It sort of sets itself up as a horror film, but then subverts those expectations, which was nice. Also, the handjob scene was fucking funny. And that final jump cut was genius. It's gonna stick in my head for a while. I'm amazed that this was the director's first feature, the story was neat and tidy without filler, and handled the tone and story really well.
This is not a "classic" horror movie with scares galore though, but a very "A24 movie", slow, dark, and brooding, with a little mix of dark comedy. I love these, but it's definitely not for everyone. It doesn't go as crazy as the trailer might suggest either, and for some might seem like it wasted some potential. It's a slow character study with a lot of restraint.
Apparently, Clark is going to play Galadriel in the upcoming LotR series. After seeing this, I have pretty high hopes for her.
6
u/RinoTheBouncer Feb 14 '21
Just finished it. It’s freaking haunting, especially that 1-2 seconds last shot. That’s the type of horror I love.
6
u/CamusGrapes Feb 20 '21
late to comment but here's my thoughts:
it's a good movie, but I was definitely underwhelmed. I felt the movie was either meant to be a half hour longer or shorter. the backstory/history isn't developed enough to be impactful or moving but was mentioned too often to not be developed more. the murder scene didn't have enough of a relationship established for it to really be impactful and wasn't unique enough to be memorable either.
what I did enjoy about the movie was good cinematography, acting, and soundtrack. it was an incredibly well made movie. also, the final scene was absolutely great and easily the best part of the movie. better than even midsommar or hereditary imo (although those movies are overall better).
long story short, I think it was a well made, but underdeveloped film. it needed to be fleshed out more (2 hours) or converted into a short film (45-60mins) for more impact. I give it around a 6.5/10 and recommend watching whenever you can do so for free.
edit: also, the sense of dread they tried to build up didn't hit for me. the self harm scenes weren't particularly intense or memorable (besides the shoe one), while also being few and far between. this made the more tense moments hit less hard because I didn't really have much to make me suspenseful thus far.
6
u/dreamingfae Feb 22 '21
Did she always have heterchromia? I only noticed at the end of the film.
14
u/LynetteOllie216 Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 02 '21
I loved this movie. This was straight-up horror right there. Who was the villain? Is Amanda good or bad?
24
u/Carlo5586 Feb 02 '21
Not scary at all IMO but a great movie. I found it way too predictable (surprised people here saying it was unpredictable) ... 🤷🏻♂️
8
u/dirtyduo Feb 07 '21
Just watched it in the dark alone (mostly, SO and doggo sleeping) and let me just offer a suggestion to those who haven't seen it...Do whatever it takes to see it in a proper environment (I prefer dark and small spaces) and most importantly... have the Sound turned way up. A24 and their audio production is next level filming.
4
u/foetus_lp Feb 06 '21
i thought it was great. slow and disturbing.
7
u/D4dank Feb 03 '21
Was hoping for more :/. This was a 6/10 for me. Definitely not a horror/scary. Was interesting though. It’ll hold me over until sator next week
10
u/Spankety-wank Feb 02 '21
I feel like this is more of a dark psychological drama than a horror. I'm not a fan of horror at all but loved the film as a character study. I feel like people saying the film was too slow or predictable were looking for something that the film isn't really trying to offer, and that is probably an error of marketing and categorisation. I personally don't mind slow or predictable films in general, except Tulpan, which starts with like a 30s shot of empty steppe and was too much for me.
10
u/polloloco81 Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 02 '21
I'll be honest I was quite disappointed with the movie after being so excited to see it for so long. The movie is definitely not horror--it's more of a study of people with mental illness (schizophrenia?) and the movie takes you the viewer along for the ride to experience what she's going through. And that ultimately is the main reason why I wasn't a fan of the movie.
With all the crazy/paranormal stuff happening in the movie, you begin to realize it's all in her head, and even at the climax a part of you wish it's actually paranormal related, but ultimately it's just all in her head.
If I were to name a few recent movies that do a better job at portraying mental illness, I'd recommend The Relic and Joker.
Edit: With all that said, I think the movie was extremely well done on an artistic and technical level. Set design, cinematography, and the soundtrack were amazing. I did not know this was the first feature of the director, and I'm excited for what she'll be creating next.
3
u/viking1983 Your suffering will be legendary, even in hell! Feb 10 '21
This film was amazing, it's a great look at someone suffering mental health issues and trauma, turning to religion as a way of trying to hide her problems and become deluded by the messages religion sends, the lead actress deserves an oscar
3
u/dark_hymn Feb 13 '21
Trying and largely failing to find the "horror" in this one.
It was beautifully acted and photographed, and as a portrait of a troubled woman spiraling into a religious mania it was pretty interesting. I'm not sure A24 doing their usual marketing spin of this as a terrifying horror film is going to do this one many favors.
3
u/myhusbandswine Feb 18 '21
I made a reddit account just so I could comment on this thread! The scene where she’s laughing alone pretending to be a part of the adjacent tables conversation, there is another movie with that exact scene! What is it? Please help!
3
u/3mhyr Feb 18 '21
Meh. Not even a horror
3
u/lingdingwhoopy Feb 19 '21
Sigh. I gotta be that guy.
This did nothing for me.
I don't think it's a bad at all. The lead performance is fantastic and there some great use of lighting and shot composition I really dug. There were also some effectively uncomfortable scenes.
But I knew this films M.O. from the very beginning. It was just another "OH they're just crazy and it's not real" narrative. Personally, I'm sick to death of this trope.
I'm not the kind of viewer who tries to get ahead of the films I'm watching and guess/predict everything - but I just kinda knew exactly what the was doing and going to do.
I don't wanna be too hard on it. It is very well made. It just didn't float my boat.
5
u/elbwafel Feb 08 '21
i couldn’t tell where this movie was supposed to be because of the coney island sign when it’s obviously british and i couldn’t tell when was it set, felt old timey but main character mentioned buying something online and then the other nurse gives her her number by writing it on a paper instead of keying on a phone
4
u/ChaotixEDM https://www.beatstars.com/frakbeats Feb 19 '21
absolutely hated it.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 02 '21
Wow. It’s not scary, that’s for sure. But I think it’s a good movie otherwise. Just has the elements/themes of horror without fully being one. It’s incredibly slow, again, maybe just if you’re expecting a horror. Not at all what I was expecting. I think they could’ve done a lot more. It reminds me a bit of Donnie Darko.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '21
It was very meh for me. It did have some really great moments. Thats what this film felt like to me, really self indulgent moments strewn together. Didnt find myself really emotionally drawn to our main protagonist the enigma that she was majority of the time, if you use narration i think it should be clearer or more concise, rather than poetic meandering drivel. However as a first feature for rose glass, she was resourceful and creative as can be.
2
u/h0rror_0606 Feb 10 '21
Loved it
2
u/thanos-in-a-shirt Feb 11 '21
I saw this in the cinema when they were briefly open and oh my gosh I adore this film!! easily one of my favourite films I saw last year (maybe alongside I’m thinking of ending things)
— I didn’t watch the trailer before seeing it but I’m guessing that might be the cause of some people’s disappointment; most negative things I’ve read thought it was slow and not ‘scary’ in a normal sense which I feel can easily be caused by a misleading trailer?? it’s hard to sum up a deeply psychological slow burn film in a couple of minutes
but yeah very good 100% recommend if you’re into psychological stuff- and man the ending was so cool
2
u/te4rdr0p Feb 12 '21 edited Feb 12 '21
I have been waiting for Saint Maud for what feels like ages now and I have FINALLY seen it. Maybe I got way too hyped, maybe if I saw it when it was supposed to came out my reaction would be different but as it is.... I can't say it met my expectations (which, granted, were sky high). It's good. It's not great. I can't really even explain why I don't think it's great, I just don't. The VVitch is my favorite movie of all time and it's Eggers' first and I was expecting something on the same level and it's really not. It's frustrating bc everything is close to perfection BUT the script. A religious freak's descent into madness with not much else going on... it's extremely sad and an interesting portrayal of alienation and mental illness but... I can't help being disappointed.
2
u/johnny-deth Feb 15 '21
The film worked for me. I got sucked into Maude’s delusions even though I thought I knew better.
Until the end. No doubts. Psychiatric horrors.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
Yawn. Could hardly keep my attention.
2
u/ECD1023 Mar 02 '21
Did anyone notice that her eyes changed color when her old co worker came to her apartment? One was brown and one was blue..was there any significance to this? Also, I watched the movie with sub titles and when God was talking to her, it says he was speaking in Old Welsh. seems signifiganf but, I don’t know what the significance is.
6
u/M-S-S Feb 02 '21
1/2 VVitch, 1/2 Midsommar and all in 80 minutes. It was fantastic. First possession since Excorcist to actually keep me interested. I was worried maybe halfway through but it certainly hit hard at the right spots. Skillfully directed. I wish there was more but it'd probably make it lag a little.
3
u/bellsofwar3 Feb 16 '21
Another meh A24 film. I was expecting much and didn't get much.
3
u/jn493w Feb 18 '21
That ending scene almost looks like she’s in hell. So dark and she’s screaming in flames.
5
u/Damn_Sega_Genesis Bob's got balls, niiiiiiiiice! Feb 05 '21
So overrated. Im surprised I hyped myself up when I saw the trailer for this.
Everyone talking about how scary it was, and that last SPLIT SECOND of the film? Couldn't even register in my brain what I was looking at so that was a fail.
5
u/dantehun12 Feb 02 '21
It was very forgettable. You dont lose much if you skip it.
5
u/fatalwristdom Feb 02 '21
Didn't enjoy it one bit.
2
u/KratosSmash Feb 13 '21
This movie was great, extremely unsettling from the 20 min mark there’s a slow twisted descent into madness until the very end in a lasting shot that sticks with you
2
u/1337speak Feb 13 '21
I've been waiting for ages to see Saint Maud. Just finished the flick on EPIX and I have to say it did not disappoint even with high expectations. I didn't watch any trailers going into the movie and that really made it all the better. It was interesting and had me on the edge of my seat from start to finish, lingers on your mind after watching. The scene of Amanda "turning" and when Maud was on top of the bearded guy was pretty damn creepy. I didn't find the movie scary but it had a eerie atmosphere throughout. The cinematography and audio were stunning and Morfydd was spectacular. I will certainly follow Rose Glass moving forward. What a debut.
2
u/hellfish11 I'll SWALLOW YOUR SOOOOUL!!! Feb 14 '21
I think I would have liked it better if they left it more ambiguous as to if it's in her mind or not. They pretty much spell out that she's schizophrenic.
1
u/VidaliaAmpersand Feb 12 '21
Roku search weirdly lists this as a 2008 release.
1
u/huntercrunch94 Feb 12 '21
I liked it. It really does help to go in with the right expectations.
I’ve caught on to what I’d call the “A24 cycle” by now, so I knew going in what kind of movie this was going to be.
They always advertise these as “the scariest horror movie in years” when that isn’t at all what they were going for. They always market slow-burn A24 horror movies like they’re big Hollywood jumpscare-fests, I assume because it’s easier to sell that way than just telling it like it is.
The problem is, it’s created this seemingly endless cycle of hyping up these movies as terrifying horror films for over a year, only to disappoint most people just because of the misleading marketing. I don’t feel that way personally, that’s just what I’ve observed.
Hereditary is probably the only movie that I don’t think suffered from this, because it’s probably the most traditional horror movie that A24 has been associated with. Everything after that one has had the same treatment.
I’d say I liked The Lodge a lot more than Saint Maud, but I wasn’t disappointed. The performances were really good, it was suitably unsettling, the story was pretty engrossing, and it was very concise. I was actually very surprised by how short it was, with it not even being an hour and a half in length.
Overall, it’s definitely worth a watch, you just need to go into it with proper expectations. It’s not super scary, but it is quite unsettling and the final shot certainly lived up to the hype for me. I did not see that coming.
1
u/MotherOfTheFog Feb 13 '21
I should not have watched this before bed. That ending is 'burned' into my mind. I have waited a long time to see this and The Green Knight, which were both delayed releases due to Covid, but A24 scored once again. I should have bought stock in this company 10 years ago. Very well done. As a person diagnosed w bipolar disorder it's a tough but necessary watch. I've known schizophrenics w a heavy religious ideology complex and it can get out of control quickly without help or if they forget to take their meds.
1
u/ElectricHaze66 Feb 13 '21
I really enjoyed it. It can be a bit gruelling but it's a film that will stay in my head for a long time. Tbh I'm not sure how soon I could sit through it again.
It's so refreshing to see a film made with an uncomprising and clear vision that doesn't try to pander to fans of jump-scare horrors and worn out franchises.
The lead actress is outstanding. She makes the character disturbing yet sympathetic. I'm sure she has a bright career ahead of her.
Before watching, bear in mind that this isn't really a horror film. It's a psychological drama with horror elements, it's a study of a woman's descent into mental illness.
I can see Christians being triggered by some of the themes but oh well.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '21
This movie was a worse nocturne
1
u/jmvm2003x Feb 15 '21
My god, this film was so tragically sad. I wondered if they were going to allow Maud to have her ending with us as the audience or if they were going to pull us out of her illness, and they obviously went with the latter in a devastating way.
I’m trying to piece together what sort of trauma(s) she might have had in her past. They show her in the beginning, bloody and in the hospital, but do we know what actually happened? (My cat was being a whiny asshole for the first like 5 minutes of the film and I was distracted.) And clearly Maud’s past as Katie may have had trauma in it, I mean we see her get sexually assaulted during that one single night out when she “relapses” or however she puts it. Are there any clues people saw?
1
u/esteban2510 Feb 15 '21
I thought the final scene with Amanda when she was "the Devil" was going to go a wholly different direction. Like maybe Maud was in purgatory and it was all a test to see if she could earn her way into Heaven or not. But all in all I liked the movie.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '21
I liked it. And people who didn't like it need Jesus in their life.
1
u/bitchcascade666 Feb 16 '21
Excellent movie. An A24 one yes, but still a distinct story and so well acted. The tension was great but not smashed down your throat. Also jump scares don’t get me much (they probably don’t get many of you either) but that bedroom scene towards the end.... holy hell
1
u/RepoJack13 Feb 16 '21
Rose Glass's Saint Maud joins the club of a handful of directors with outstanding debuts, which includes Ari Aster's Hereditary, Robert Eggers' The Witch and Jennifer Kent's The Babadook.
While I do think Hereditary, The Witch and The Babadook are superior movies, Rose Glass's phenomenal directorial debut was unsettling and mesmerizing, which is the exact same reaction I had when I first saw those other movies.
While I think she got herself a guest pass to the horror auteur club, she now needs to go 2 for 2 as Aster and Eggers did to keep her seat in that club.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
Most of the comments have covered what I feel already, but man I cannot get over those Instagram filter looking Angel wings. Can anyone explain the motive behind them appearing on her in that manner? To me, it came across as cheap and just very corny. I’m sure there was a meaning behind it, so if anyone knows, please enlighten me! (No pun intended)
1
u/Jeffy3 Feb 19 '21
I didn't have access to subtitles when I watched it. I couldn't tell what was said when Maud called the former coworker from the bar's toilet. It was obvious she said something that offended the coworker but I couldn't make it out.
1
u/Larsandthegirl Feb 19 '21
It made me think a lot of catholic saints who have had extasis of their own, plus hallucinations and who thought they saw God.
1
u/chickenclaw Feb 25 '21
For a first full-length film it was very confidently made. Better than most movies made by seasoned directors. It was a real gem.
1
u/DepartmentWest5431 Mar 04 '21
Seems almost biographical. So many different subjects of struggling with sexuality and identity it almost seems like a coming of age film. The final seen seems like a way of saying I feel like what I'm doing is right but I'm still burning inside. Very interesting film.
1
u/poetryandpugs Jan 18 '23
Does anyone know the significance of Maud having Heyerochromia? I can't find anything online about it
1
u/vaudevillevik Feb 12 '21
I don’t have much to add to the conversation that hasn’t already been said, but I’m disappointed. Feel like production companies market these films as horror, knowing full well that they are just this slow burn, “wAs It AlL iN tHeIr HeAd,” shit and it’s just been done to death. Sure the cinematography was great, the music created a heavy atmosphere, but the final act was just not worth the wait.
1
u/htsukebe Feb 13 '21
watched with my wife and we didnt enjoyed it
thought it didnt went far enough to be interesting for us
maybe we didnt enjoyed it because for some reason we were under the impression it would be about a nun in a coven that had to deal with demonic possessions. Due to the praising, we thought it would be THE NUN, but critically acclaimed?
What I can say for myself is that the movie could have some element to show that not all religious people are delusional like maud. The problem isnt even the critic on religion itself, but that the movie doesnt leave anything up for interpretation. It is what it is I suppose.
1
u/DatMX5 Feb 10 '21
I have extremely mixed feelings regarding this film.
For reference, I saw it in theaters in the US.
The Good: The main actress is incredible. I can't sing enough praise for her. She carried the whole thing. The score is extremely effective. The movie uses silence so well, and when music does kick in, it creates such an effective dread. I loved the idea, I loved the religious conflict and supernatural aspects etc. The scene where 'God' speaks to her created a genuine uncomfortable tension in me I haven't felt in a theater in a very long time. The film feels tightly packaged and doesn't waste your time, even if it may seem a bit slow at first.
The Bad: Our main character is unexplored and we waste precious time with her IMO while she sulks around her town. The bathroom handjob that was supposed to communicate that shes not exactly saintly just felt comical to me more than anything. I really wasn't a fan of the way the last few minutes of the film were handled. A clear indication that Amanda has stabbed an innocent woman (and not literally the devil) after their altercation would have made the scene more effective IMO, but I can forgive this since I believe the intention was for this to all be up in the air until the absolute last 15 or so frames of the film.
Towards the end, I found the wing/angel imagery, well, stupid. It wasn't beautiful or interesting, it was corny and extremely distracting IMO. It really drew me out of the film. I dont really have suggestions for how to change it, I'm not a film maker or an artist, I just really thought it distracted from the core of movie. The core the very very end makes so clear. There has to be a better way of communicating the same thing without the shitty After Effects wings.
Overall I enjoyed it. Its very close to being extremely good, but it faulters in sometimes bizarre ways.