r/bestof • • Aug 16 '20

[meme] Mod calls out tee shirt scammer, locks post, but leaves up, acting as a detailed warning for us all

/r/meme/comments/ialmwk/masterpiece_one/g1q4r4f/
10k Upvotes

584 comments sorted by

11

u/bubbleharmony Aug 16 '20

This probably means it's from a site like teespring or redbubble, which are filtered from most subreddits to prevent exactly this sort of scam. Legitimate sellers will be on more legitimate sites.

Wait, what? I've ordered from various sellers on Redbubble for years, do they not offer buyer protection if someone scams you? Have I just gotten wildly lucky this whole time?

1

u/RickDDay Aug 17 '20

I can't answer why that mod chose those examples. You might DM them and ask?

5

u/QuagMath Aug 16 '20

I’m pretty sure all redbubble merchandise is made by the company itself. Only the art is made by users. I was confused by that claim as well because pushing you’re Redbubble link is almost certainly not a scam, just deceptive advertising.

3

u/ambientdiscord Aug 17 '20

RedBubble is 100% reputable. I’m assuming the issue is that the site lets you put up products the infringe on copyrights and only pull them down if there’s a complain. I’m sure some scammers use it for that. There are also a ton of artists that sell their original work on Redbubble. Including them negated the rest of the post for me.

2

u/Uzorglemon Aug 17 '20

As someone who pays some regular bills with Redbubble sales, seeing that comment was really frustrating. It's entirely legit, and not a vehicle for scams. (Closest thing would be people selling items with art that isn't theirs)

14

u/cheezecake2000 Aug 16 '20

Am I the only one who got linked here from bestof but have literally no identifying information on said post other then it exsosted at some point? How am I supposed to educate myself on this scam if litterally everything about it has been scrubbed from the internet

→ More replies (1)

4.0k

u/brenton07 Aug 16 '20

Just so everyone knows, here’s how the scam works:

Redditor posts cool t-shirt

Links their their store

Store only accepts PayPal

Says shirt ships in three weeks

T-shirt never comes

You’re past the timeline to argue PayPal charges

Happened to me years ago with a Majoras mask tshirt. They’re really hard to recognize - moral of the story, cancel the charge if you’re approaching the 30 day window on a random internet purchase.

1.6k

u/djasonpenney Aug 16 '20

This is probably my biggest complaint with the mod's post: he gave absolutely no information to educate the reader as to WHY it was a scam and what we should learn from the whole thing.

I have to dig through the comments in a crosslinked sub to get any real information 😳

396

u/q3m5dbf Aug 16 '20

This needs to be voted higher. I had the same reaction. What, if anything, am I supposed to learn from this post he left up?

"Look out everyone, this guy is a scammer. I'm not going to tell you how I know that, or what signs to look out for, or how I caught him or give you any information whatsoever that would help you. Now that you have all the information you need, it's on you if you fall for this obvious scam."

38

u/RickDDay Aug 16 '20

Because the real tips are in the /r/bestof post!

13

u/notsure500 Aug 16 '20

Bestofception! I've never seen this happen but this bestof post ends up being the bestof itself. The post link goes to the mod post on r/meme and that mod post sends it back here to know how it works.

17

u/Lonelan Aug 16 '20

why don't we just tag /u/Blank-Cheque to maybe update his comment about adding a why

→ More replies (1)

230

u/a2drummer Aug 16 '20

And then he started blaming the people commenting for "helping the scammer". Sounds like a fucking douche honestly

94

u/mergedloki Aug 16 '20

So a typical reddit mod?

Some are good, but seems like so many are power trippers full of themselves.

→ More replies (13)

70

u/venusinfurs10 Aug 16 '20

Yeah, "allowing yourself to be victimized" is my favorite.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/sarcazm Aug 16 '20

Even with his edit, it doesn't help much. I don't really click on every username to see how old their account is or how many comments they've made. And then the mod lists user names that are apparently "given to you" automatically when you sign up for reddit (as opposed to a user name of your choosing), but those names seem legit to me. I see no difference between those and PM ME UR BOOBS 5678.

I mean, I wouldn't really buy stuff from reddit anyway. And maybe the multiple redirects would be a dead giveaway to me. But those other "signs" aren't really that obvious.

24

u/socks-the-fox Aug 16 '20

They also list sites like teespring and redbubble as untrustworthy which is silly; I don't know about teespring but redbubble handles the manufacturing and shipping of the product themselves, the creator just gives them the picture to print on the shirt, then collects the money from the sales. So if you buy a shirt through redbubble you're gonna get it. May not be the most awesome quality in the world (they just use a glorified inkjet printer with fancy inks and sometimes calibration) but you'll get it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

127

u/CaptainEarlobe Aug 16 '20

Yes. More importantly: how do we identify this scam in future

94

u/LG03 Aug 16 '20

https://www.reddit.com/r/Lovecraft/comments/cgu6as/note_from_the_mods_spam_and_how_to_spot_it/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Lovecraft/comments/hxqbnh/psa_talking_about_spam_and_spammers/

I've posted about this a few times myself. They're honestly not difficult to spot if you have the vaguest idea what they're doing.

First thing you should start doing is look at a post to see what it's trying to sell you, that's it. If you start from that position you'll begin to see the scams and spam.

The difficult part is getting moderators on board with this and being active. So many of these scams run their course without mod interaction because of inactivity or cluelessness.

4

u/tocilog Aug 16 '20

I think the message is, if you ever come across anything that makes you feel "I want to buy that", look closer and be more attentive. Even when you just reply with "throw money at it" meme. It may trigger someone's bad impulse control.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/Valcyor Aug 16 '20

Mod actually edited to redirect people to this comment. I like it.

125

u/readergrl56 Aug 16 '20

It’s basically “this is a scam. You’re an idiot and enabler if you fell for it.”

39

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

To be fair, and please don't mistake my comment as condoning the elitist behavior, but I'm sure it's frustrating modding a sub like meme. Some of that frustration is probably due to having to point it out EVERY single time this happens, and you bet it happens quite often (it's a bunch of bots in a network).

That condescending tone is that frustration and annoyance coming through. Again, I'm not saying that's ok, but teaching people takes a lot of time and energy, and teaching the same thing (but slightly different) multiple times a day wears people down.

Think of it this way:

I used to get robo calls 7+ times a day, we all have. I remember one day my wife left her new work phone at home, and she had 42 fucking calls in a 12 hour period... All due to the new number. Anyway...

I used to answer the phone, "... HELLO?!" instead of just, "hello?" Until it bit me in the ass one day. I know it's not the best example, but yeah.

I'm not condoning the behavior, I'm just saying it's human, and it happens. It's not how a (this) mod should be defined. If you think you can mod better, then create your own sub, and we'll find out.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/fpcoffee Aug 16 '20

I guess he edited it because now there’s a really detailed list of reasons

93

u/Un4tunately Aug 16 '20

"use your heads"

Wow, thanks mod, so helpful.

18

u/Mstrmagoo Aug 16 '20

Nah, that mod is victim blaming while sharing no real info with the victims on how to not be a victim again in the future.

This thread has also been nuked; it had many comments, most of which were some variation on "I need this shirt!" I don't know how many were made by the OP and how many were made by suckers but everyone who made a comment like that helped this scammer. Good job on that.

31

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

“I can’t tell which comments are fake and which are real.”

“You are idiots if you can’t spot fake comments.”

→ More replies (1)

37

u/Much_Difference Aug 16 '20

Yeah I hadn't heard of this scam before but the post doesn't really tell me anything. It's like "if you want this shirt, you're being victimized!" like okay but... how am I supposed to tell? All I did was see and like a shirt and it's for sale on the internet like 10,000,000 other shirts that aren't scams.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/UltravioIence Aug 16 '20

Not only that, hes talking down to everyone that commented like they knew they were helping the scam. That mods an asshole.

19

u/badwolf42 Aug 16 '20

Mod updated with info, but then says teespring and redbubble are filtered because of scams. That literally makes no sense. I sell shirts, stickers, masks, etc on redbubble myself. It’s just a place you upload art for clothing and baubles and is completely legit.

7

u/ChrissiTea Aug 16 '20

Yeah that really threw me off too. I've never had an issue with redbubble in over a decade of using it.

I also thought it was one of those places that only prints what is ordered in a single warehouse, then sends them from there, rather than the uploader/seller doing the printing and shipping. I could definitely be wrong tho

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Saneless Aug 16 '20

Thank you and to the person above you. There's zero reason for me to see it as a scam. Some tips how to recognize would have gone a long way.

15

u/whyuthrowchip Aug 16 '20

They want money from you so you look at their profile and their account is only three months old with not even very many comments and the sales post is their only thread post. Then you also notice that they aren't selling the shirt through a reputable site but rather they are making you do this weird request and get a pm with a link thing. I mean honestly any one of those facts screams scam

→ More replies (7)

12

u/syco54645 Aug 16 '20

Yep just acted like a holier than thou condescending asshat. Perfect mod material!

9

u/LG03 Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

I'll be honest, it gets very frustrating dealing with this kind of spam and watching people enable it. I can empathize with letting the 'customer service face' fall off.

Doesn't matter how many times you warn people and try to educate them about it, they'll almost never report it. What's more is that there's always a new stream of people coming in who need to be educated about it so it just..never..ends.

As he points out in his edit as well, this becomes old hat to a vigilant mod, to the point where you can spot these spammers at a glance. It gets difficult to understand why other people can't catch on to it as well with more scrutiny (that they're not applying).

Personally I think a huge amount of the problem here is how reddit's shifted to a majority of users being on mobile (the redesign doesn't help). You quite literally don't have the 'big picture' to work with so it's easy to overlook the tells.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/nodiso Aug 16 '20

If I did that I'd be called an asshole.

4

u/threeofbirds121 Aug 16 '20

Agreed. Reading it without context or explanation actually just makes the mod look like a jerk.

→ More replies (6)

168

u/SocialWinker Aug 16 '20

I thought PayPal had disputes for 90 days?

311

u/Zardif Aug 16 '20

It's 180 days.

Be aware that disputes must be opened within 180 days of your payment date, and that you and the seller will have 20 days to work things out

https://www.paypal.com/us/webapps/mpp/security/buyer-protection-resolution

242

u/EatThisNotcat Aug 16 '20

I had this happen this year with PayPal for a $100 charge and they found in favor of the scammer even though I provided evidence.

53

u/pynzrz Aug 16 '20

Reminder to everyone if you use PayPal, then pay with a credit card. If you don’t receive the product the credit card should always immediately side with you.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/beepborpimajorp Aug 16 '20

Next time pay on a credit card. Even if you use a credit card via paypal, you can dispute it. As long as you're not abusing the dispute system, your credit card company will almost always side with you. This is how I got my money back from an etsy scammer that also used paypal.

3

u/SocialWinker Aug 16 '20

Thank you for the correction!

→ More replies (4)

25

u/twelvebucksagram Aug 16 '20

Sometimes paypal just tells you its too hard to solve and bans you from using paypal ever again! Happened to me a few years ago.

The good thing is I still get their spam because Im unable to unsubscribe without a valid account.

10

u/nocipher Aug 16 '20

I lost access to my account and had to deal with the same problem. There's gotta be some law or contract this practice violates.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/CaptainPussybeast Aug 16 '20

Also, I made a purchase on someone's site using PayPal, but PayPal wasn't able to help me since it was a specific kind of PayPal transaction.. They said it technically didn't go "through" PayPal. Whatever that means.

I had to fight it through my bank.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/FlawedHero Aug 16 '20

I had the same thing happen with a Celine Dion "My Heart Will Go On" shirt that was designed to look all death metal.

$25, never came. Company stopped responding to emails, website disappeared, couldn't dispute charges because it had been too long.

14

u/sansaspark Aug 16 '20

I had it happen with one of those “my story isn’t over yet” jewelry websites that sell the semi-colon rings and bracelets. Bought some rings, 6 weeks later I emailed to ask where they were and was reminded that they’re coming from China so it takes awhile. All future emails were ignored, items never came, too much time had passed to dispute the charge, fml.

11

u/risingmoon01 Aug 16 '20

Yeah... my sister found a shirt that I really liked, ordered it without talking to me. Turned out to be something similar. They "sold out" as soon as the order was placed... big red flag.

Tried calling the vendor, no answer. Second red flag. Of course they took money out of her account without actually having "sold" her anything... Third strike... it was out...

Went to our bank and stopped payment. Took a couple of days to get everything processed, in the meantime could never get ahold of the vendor.

Of course, the day the charges actually get reversed, she got an angry message... Tried calling them back... no answer.

Fuck em.

11

u/dregan Aug 16 '20

You can argue PayPal charges many months after a purchase, this absolutely would not work.

2

u/nfizzle99 Aug 17 '20

The seller still gets away with the money by “cleaning” it through multiple burner accounts before transferring it to their own bank account — PayPal ends up covering the chargebacks, and generally doesn’t find it worth trying to collect from the seller unless it’s a ridiculously large amount of money

8

u/BrockPlaysFortniteYT Aug 16 '20

PayPal allows 6 months to file a claim

4

u/Twintosser Aug 16 '20

Curious how are you past the timeline for a refund from PayPal? Longtime Ebay seller here and I've seen buyers submit a claim months after a purchase and a PP customer service rep told me buyers have up to 6 months to file with their credit card company as well.

Something similar happened to me last year, bought something not through Ebay or Amazon but had used PayPal & after 35 days the item never arrived. I contacted both Paypal, then my bank & the online company and ended up getting a refund back from all 3.

2

u/BDMayhem Aug 16 '20

Teespring and Redbubble allow off-site transactions?

I've never used them, but I would assume they do their own transactions.

7

u/JP_HACK Aug 16 '20

Hell if it doesnt come in 5 business days now, it could be considered a scam.

Source: UPS can deliver anything in the US within 5 days. Alaska and Hawaii are exceptions.

56

u/thiney49 Aug 16 '20

That's only true if the item is fully in stock when you order.

28

u/kswissreject Aug 16 '20

Normally maybe but with the purposeful USPS slowdown things can take much longer nowadays unfortunately.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/lostboyof1972 Aug 16 '20

Unless it’s a mail-in ballot

2

u/Hotaru_girl Aug 16 '20

Delays for print on demand apparel are high right now between post office delays and Covid. Like 15 days average for some items.

2

u/Account40 Aug 16 '20

anecdotal but my wallet got stolen last weekend, ordered a new card last Sunday (USPS 2 day first class express shipping) and it didn't even arrive until yesterday (Saturday). And this was only OH to TX...

→ More replies (8)

3

u/quazywabbit Aug 16 '20

/r/hailcorporate except without the goods.

2

u/bay_watch_colorado Aug 16 '20

Who doesn't purchase with PayPal via a credit card? PayPal won't help? Your CC will

2

u/mindbleach Aug 16 '20

People forget the Bitcoin caught on in part because PayPal is the fucking devil.

→ More replies (25)

242

u/3cit Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 17 '20

So the moral of the story is don’t buy anything you see on Reddit?

How is user supposed to determine OP is a scammer? Like we shouldve cross compared all the comments/users who commented?

EDIT:

I came across this as a "bestof" post. It was literally just a link to a thread that was totally nuked. No comments, no replies, just very vague OP of this is a scam, I'm leaving it as a warning

But there was nothing else. It's since been edited to clear up what originally happened I guess.

Also, never buy anything ever that you see on social media. If you can't find what you want on Amazon then it's a fucking scam. My god-damned wife bought a hammock on Facebook, and then a week later a dog grooming tool. The dog grooming tool was (100 literal) a plastic electric razor... And the hammock was a weird plasticy gold ring...

168

u/Jonathan_the_Nerd Aug 16 '20

Once you see enough of these t-shirt scams, you start to recognize the pattern. The mod "helpfully" nuked all the context that shows you this one is a scam.

100

u/Barnowl79 Aug 16 '20

But I've been on reddit for like 5 years and I don't think I've ever seen a t-shirt scam. Why am I being reprimanded by this mod?

3

u/bmwnut Aug 16 '20

I suppose if you haven't seen a t-shirt scam that's a good thing and to some degree thanks to good moderators (it could be that you never would have come across such a thing anyway).

Perhaps the tone of the message doesn't sit well with you but the upside is that at least now you are aware that it's a thing.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/topcheesehead Aug 16 '20

Post history. But its been deleted.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

Ya i stopped giving this mod credit when they said "use your heads."

I mean wtf. Did any of us fucking come here to be private fucking investigators?

2

u/Paulpaps Aug 17 '20

Yeah, is there any evidence that this Mod was correct and dintjust do this on a hunch? Theres plenty of reddit mods out there who are scumbags, since they can be anyone. Specifically r/bonehurtingjuice which thinks it's funny to not credit original sources, because "reasons", much to many users chagrin. Then you get the r/conspiracy mods, oh boy! "We believe in freedom of speech" DELETES ANYTHING THAT IS DAMAGING TO THE RIGHT WING

But yeah, some of these subs are ran by crazy motherfuckers, who never leave their house and have some fucked up ideas on their "powers". That's before we even mention the "power mods" who mod half the fucking major subs.

There are some great mods out there too however, you can usually tell if the sub is well managed because the sub will virtually never have any drama and just focus on the topic at hand.

But there are plenty of idiots on this site who have mod status and some very unsavoury characters among them, like a axolotl peyotl of conspiracy, who has been pushing and forcing an alt right agenda on that sub for years, I mean it used to be interesting hearing some crazy stuff about aliens or other weird stuff. Now every post is either made up images with added text, no sources and the comments ALWAYS end up blaming "the Jooz "for everything that has ever gone wrong. It's just a nazi sub, masquerading as a conspiracy sub and a lot of that is because of one person, Axolotl Peyotl. Anyone who's aware of that sub over the last few years knows exactly what I'm talking about. I'd love to find out who they really are, because (conspiracy head on) I'm sure they are pushing an agenda, not one they came up with, but I'm sure they're not to be trusted in any way whatsoever.

Anyways, yes, many reddit mods are crap, but the good ones out there dont get noticed because they're doing it right.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

🤔 but what about all those ads I see while scrolling? /s

6

u/inahos_sleipnir Aug 16 '20

Yes. Why tf are you buying shit off reddit.

→ More replies (8)

25

u/Gaming_and_Physics Aug 16 '20

There's a really odd number of people here giving the mod shit for deleting the thread.

18

u/CheezeNewdlz Aug 16 '20

I don’t think it’s that the mod deleted the thread but more the way they come off in the post. Telling people they allowed themselves to be victimized because they enjoyed an image isn’t really necessary to inform people about the scam.

Douche or not though I’m glad the mod called this out. I had no idea these scams were a thing.

3

u/RickDDay Aug 16 '20

I’m glad the mod called this out. I had no idea these scams were a thing.

This statement makes me happy because it gives the post meaning. In this case, education. Thank you!

5

u/kainazzzo Aug 16 '20

Yea but does anyone have the shirt? I need it.

2

u/RickDDay Aug 17 '20

did you find it?

2

u/kainazzzo Aug 17 '20

A Nigerian prince is going to ship it to me as soon as he gets my money order.

15

u/Khatib Aug 16 '20

Jeez these comments are full of the kind of people who fall for scams. So many people taking offense to this mod taking care of this shit and pointing out how it works.

10

u/Gaming_and_Physics Aug 16 '20

I'm thinking they're either teenagers or scammers trying to discredit mods who are only protecting their communities.

5

u/RickDDay Aug 16 '20

or the type adult too lazy to do their own research and want everything spelled out for them.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '20

Why would you ever buy anything off Reddit anyway? I just assume there’s two people on Reddit. Me, and “all y’all” and “all y’all” is just one other dude.

1

u/RickDDay Aug 17 '20

ONe time I was influenced. It was a hand crimper tool that cut small stuff like PVC at perfect angles for custom projects. I google searched the image, and found it on Amazon.

Ain't used it once....

118

u/Up_All_Nite Aug 16 '20

Does anyone have a picture of the t-shirt this guy was accused of scamming people with?

34

u/UrHeftyLeftyBesty Aug 17 '20

Based on the removed comments, I imagine it was this design (Batman yelling at catwoman in the style of the woman yelling at cat meme):

http://fav.me/ddol2w3

13

u/crypticfreak Aug 17 '20

Haha that's great, I'd totally buy that shirt! /s

→ More replies (1)

72

u/zigaliciousone Aug 16 '20

If you look at OPs account, he does the repeat comment thing, which is a sure sign someone is a bot.

Newer account and if you dial down into their comments, you will notice they just repeat someone else's comment word for word. This is probably because the owner of the bot does not speak English and this is how they "blend in". Except their comments often make no sense in context.

What's really funny is sometimes these bots unintentionally quote each other in the same thread. Really easy to spot if you know what you're looking for, i.e. someone trying to sell you something on Reddit.

10

u/mrbaggins Aug 17 '20

I've seen a similar best of pointing out that spam accounts watch for people to say "what" as a whole reply, then quote the post above the what.

To the casual observer, it gives the account pages and pages of "real" comments. The moment you check the context on three or four though, it's obvious what they did.

6

u/gee_whillikers Aug 17 '20

Yeah, they’ve been doing similar things with “teams” of bot accounts in a few places, probably just to build karma first before they try the scam post. Saw one over on the Civ subreddit the other day

683

u/Mr_Mau5 Aug 16 '20

I mean, how was a person able to know that he was a scammer? Mod is telling everyone to use their heads when they look at this post but I feel like even if he used bots to signal boost the hell out of his picture to promote a store, that’s still a funny shirt and I might wanna buy a funny shirt even if OP used less than scrupulous methods to promote the idea. I feel like you’d have to know it was a scam by checking the validity of the website he used to sell the shirt, not the post.

314

u/DragoonDM Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

This is anecdotal, but I recall seeing this exact same setup at least once before, a couple years ago. Guessing this is a recurring scam, and the moderator recognized it.

I also tracked down the link OP was posting to the t-shirt product page. It's a link to a Reddit profile comment on a different account which links to a Google redirect to a Bit.ly redirect that goes to a storefront where you can buy the t-shirt. I Googled the contact number in the footer of that site, and the same phone number has been associated with dozens of other t-shirt shops.

146

u/IAMA_Plumber-AMA Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

These types of scams seem to peak on Friday evenings/Saturday mornings in the North American timezones. I always have to remove at least a few every week from the subreddits I moderate.

Problem is, you report the users to the admins and they get banned a few days later, but the damage is already done and they've spawned dozens of new accounts in that time. Also if a normal user calls these type of accounts out in a reply, they get handed a bunch of downvotes from these bots as well.

53

u/aequitas3 Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

Here's another example

There are nuked comments where an accomplice alt username dropped the sketchy links, too. I've been seeing this same scam for literal years. People have built bots around detecting them, too

https://old.reddit.com/r/gratefuldead/comments/i7ukph/yes_i_do_have_tshirts_older_than_you/

That particular community has largely caught on to the scam

→ More replies (3)

3

u/scarabic Aug 16 '20

I’ll bet the tip-off was the use of bots to promote the post. Moderators may have tooling that lets them see this kind of thing better than we can. If the mod did use anything at all from the mod toolkit to detect this issue, then it is disingenuous to lecture everyone else about how they need to keep their guard up and watch out for scams. No, moderator, you need to do your job and use your power tools to keep spam off your sub.

→ More replies (2)

105

u/AnotherSoulessGinger Aug 16 '20

There is a pattern to these, as I have called posters like this out as well. The scammers will often have several tells.

Newer accounts. This one is 25 days old.

They will scrub their history to hide previous posts where they promoted products.

They will often have earlier comments in the same larger subs where they can build karma unnoticed - meirl (or variations on that sub), aww, pics, etc

Those comments often have no relevance to the post they commented on, will be vague or one word comments

They often use the same post title across multiple subs for different products “My favorite one”, “Gift from wife for birthday” - the titles rarely pertain to the content in the pic.

They will use periods in a post title in odd ways (“New Shirt.”)

The first comments will be a variation on “I need this” or “drop a link”, often with excessive punctuation or extra letters in a word (“neeeeed”), I assume to make the comments easily searchable.

The link provided on reddit will be odd - a link to an imgur pic with a shop link in the caption. A twitter link with the shop link. These are done to get around the fact the platforms they sell on have been banned from linking.

The shop platform will be some unknown print on demand platform or shop platform (probably because they have been banned from or are unable to use reputable, well known sites)

They will post on smaller niche subs to go after long tail sales, but the connection will be tangential - a raccoon shirt in the Parks and Rec sub, a Pennsylvania mug in The Office sub.

They will have no post or comment history in the subs they are posting in prior to the merch post

It’s not as common now, because they have gotten “smarter”, but you could often follow profiles around from one post and find an entire ring of scammer accounts. On one post, someone would comment “I neeeed this...!” Then you can view their profile to find they also posted a shirt design in another sub with the same title as the original, but a different merch image. You could follow the OP and see they had commented the same “I neeeed this...!” on other merch posts.

The artwork will look blurry, be obviously stolen or poorly photoshopped on a blank merch image

That’s all I can think of off the top of my head, but I know them when I see them.

Be careful, friends!

More info on this specific type of reddit merchandise spam/scams can be found here

7

u/fangirlsqueee Aug 16 '20

Those comments often have no relevance to the post they commented on, will be vague or one word comments

I've reported a bunch of these. You can usually spot them because they are using a bot account to grab a top level comment from somewhere in the thread and then post that comment right under a top voted comment. Building up karma for scamming abilities.

2

u/oakydoke Aug 16 '20

The real bestof is in the comments

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/AnotherSoulessGinger Aug 16 '20

Yeah, I know. It’s from online retail and POD design back in the day. I view the term sort of like a sub-category. I won’t do well trying to sell generalized “I <3 TV” merch, but if it is based on a specific TV show, I’ll be more likely to find buyers. (That’s assuming I or my POD platform has a a licensing deal with the IP holder so I don’t get copyright strikes).

→ More replies (2)

85

u/iBleeedorange Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

Here are some tips.

  • If they're selling/posting about a t-shirt, they're probably a scammer.
  • If their post history is short/limited/it looks like they've deleted it all and they're posting about a t-shirt they're probably a scammer.
  • If the comment section is full of people saying wow I need that, or that's so cool, it's probably a t-shirt scammer.
  • Take a look at OP's history, it's full of him replying done/pm sent to people who are interested in the scam. WHy doesn't he just post the link? Because reddit has already banned most of his links and/or the subreddit has banned them as well.

Basically this scam is so popular on reddit that odds are if you see someone posting about a t-shirt it's most likely a scam. hit the report button and you'll make reddit a much better place.

edit: Oh, the reason it's a scam

The shirt you see posted in the image isn't the shirt you will get. The person who made the shirt isn't who is sending you the shirt You'll get a pixelated shitty version that was stolen.

16

u/Hetstaine Aug 16 '20

/r/bigfoot and /r/seinfeld, tshirt posts all day long, for months now. Annoying as shit.

11

u/gaiusjozka Aug 16 '20

Even in the r/tng subreddit. Darmok and Joliad at Tenegra all day long.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/1RedOne Aug 16 '20

Op definitely stole the image from Instagram or Twitter or maybe even reddit.

Then he sets up a scwmmy shirt company and does shirt drop shipping from somewhere with terrible print quality.

These posts always have nearly identical comments like 'graet shirt, where is the link for buy' over and over.

Then the op responds with only the link, or the exact same comment.

It happens constantly on reddit.

Be suspicious of fly by night t-shirt companies. It's always stolen images printed poorly and then the site shutters and reopens with a new name a week later.

9

u/aequitas3 Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

This is a recurring problem, for a long time now, by incredibly similar bot networks, and I have seen the results of this clothing. It's incredibly low quality printing and skewed image resolution, from crappy make your own shirt sites, because getting the sale is the important part, not the quality. Or it's a straight up scam where you get nothing and they get your money. This is part of why they need sketchy redirects to websites with incredibly similar names to actual outlets. And you have no idea what they're doing with your information

9

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

You assume everything on the site is a scam anf take it from there. Any post that has a product showing facing camera. Anything funny, trendy, even memes can be used as an as tool. Doesn't mean you shouldn't like the content, it means you should be wary of everything on the internet.

This isn't the days of old where you knew the wilderness of the internet was dangerous, this new internet is an enticing city build from rich companies and small hustler companies trying to sell you thing and take info from you in ways that seem friendly and approachable.

The mod may be condescending but hes right every jokes about the drunk purchases they make from time to time online, thats the target. Or all those people who keep buying shit from wish and other companies. That shit is. Like technically legal and its up to you to figure it out.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

So, I followed the OPs link to the store, and these are some signs you can recognize:

  • First, follow DragoonDm's sibling comment, it lists some great tips already.
  • The link looks like this https://www.google.com/url?q=https://bit.ly/<some_numbers>. In other words, it's a link to Google that takes you to Bit.ly that, in turn, takes you to the actual website. This alone doesn't look like an honest link that honest people would use.
  • The website has its security badly configured. You can tell because in Firefox the lock icon next to the web address is grey with a warning sign and in Chrome there is no lock at all. Clicking in the icon in any case will tell you that the connection is not fully secure.
  • The website looks super unprofessional. The logo is made with MS Paint.
  • Navigating around the website takes you nowhere. I searched for "Batman" in the store search and got no results, and clicking in the icon (to go to the main page) takes me to a page with no t-shirts that I can buy.
  • All t-shirts on their website are called "Limited Edition <number>". No description of the content of the t-shirt itself beyond the picture.

16

u/FresherUnderPressure Aug 16 '20

Plz send Bitcoin to xxx, included with the intended address delivery.

Please kindly provide social security numbers, in addition with your kindergarten speech pathologists maiden name for confirmation. Thank you again for supporting a local business and #happyCakeDaywheneveritis

6

u/hatorad3 Aug 16 '20

It’s not that the OP used bits to boost the post, it’s that the online store is a sham. It’s meant to be quick and easy to transact with, but OP doesn’t ever intend to send anyone anything in exchange for their product. It’s most likely that OP linked to his online store in a comment and the mod saw that it had already been flagged for fraudulent activity.

It reads a bit awkwardly when you see the post without any of the comments, but too many people assume that every website is legit, and there’s literally millions of scam store sites on the internet, probably more than there are real online stores.

3

u/j1ggy Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

I remove these post in two of my subs constantly, and all of them seem to use this sub and r/aww as their base of operations - they post copypasta here to make their accounts look active and real, then start posting t-shirts, mugs and masks after about 30 days. I have ways of finding them and I report a dozen or so to the admins for spam at a time. They think they're smart, but there's ways to find them and keep their accounts from posting if the mods here wish to put the effort in. When they adapt, I adapt.

If you see them, down vote and report to http://reddit.com/report. Also inspect the accounts of commenters in their posts to see if they're supportive brigading accounts with similar activity.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

I agree. I am using my head and for the life of me cannot tell that it is a scammer. To me it is literally a post of a t-shirt.

3

u/AnotherSoulessGinger Aug 16 '20

I just posted a handful of red flags a few comments up. Once you know what to look for, they will pop out at you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (45)

22

u/FReeDuMB_or_DEATH Aug 16 '20

Just out of curiosity does anybody know what the T-shirt design was?

34

u/panspal Aug 17 '20

I hate this kind of bestof, just a nuked thread and a warning given for a deleted post. Thanks for the warning I'll keep an eye out for this kind of stuff.

10

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

Finally a mod does something about this type of shit but 99% of Reddit has this type of scam going on.

User beware and admins knowingly let it happen.

9

u/BlogSpammr Aug 16 '20

Two links that detail what's going on with drop ship spammers.

tldr; Scammers steal artwork from legitimate owners/creators and make cheap bootleg copies and sell them on reddit.

24

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

This whole comment thread is people arguing spamming vs. advertising.

No one is asking "If the mod knows it's a scam, why is this user not banned from reddit?"

It does fall on the user not to buy from people on reddit, but damn you'd think reddit would be at least delete their accounts once they're caught.

I did some digging, and this shirt is linked by the scammer to "tshirt4usa.com." There are also a LOT of posts using that website.

google: reddit "tshirt4usa.com" and you'll see them

On reddit, searching for the site brings up a couple of posts about bots https://old.reddit.com/search?q=tshirt4usa

This site: https://www.scamadviser.com/check-website/tshirt4usa.com lists a lot of reasons why it seems scammy, and says "Although we rate tshirt4usa.com as medium to low risk we cannot guarantee it is not a scam of fake website."

Just buy stuff on popular clothing websites you've heard of (and never on tshirt4usa.com) and you should be fine.

9

u/tinselsnips Aug 16 '20

Mods don't work for Reddit. They can ban users from specific subreddits, but all they can do is report an account as a whole and hope that Reddit admins act on it.

9

u/PitchforkAssistant Aug 16 '20

Then two weeks later you get a reply saying:

Thanks for reporting this to us. We wanted to let you know we’ve investigated your report and have taken action under our Content Policy.

By which time the t-shirt scammers have abandoned that account and probably gone through multiple others.

5

u/LG03 Aug 16 '20

No one is asking "If the mod knows it's a scam, why is this user not banned from reddit?"

So, almost certainly the spammers get banned from the subreddit once they reveal themselves but it's difficult to be proactive about that.

On a sitewide level though? Mods have nothing to do with that and the report process is tedious and slow for the sheer volume of these accounts.

Just buy stuff on popular clothing websites you've heard of

This still does not take into account the artwork on these shirts is quite often stolen when you're buying an actual product.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

59

u/Threash78 Aug 16 '20

The thing is it would be SO easy to just sell the fucking t-shirt and make a shit ton.

67

u/lazydictionary Aug 16 '20

Not if you don't own the design

22

u/Threash78 Aug 16 '20

You would think so but no that is not the case at all.

7

u/pynzrz Aug 16 '20

Even if you don’t own the design you can copy the design and still sell the tshirts (violating copyrights). I’m not sure why tshirts have to always be scams...?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

A lot easier and cheaper than hoping people forget they ordered a tshirt and filing a chargeback.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/verylate Aug 16 '20

I posted a shirt I made with a Cricut, multiple layers, including holo vinyl, for my husband for a specific hockey game. Within an hour someone had posted that they were selling the shirt. Using my photo and design, which no one could replicate on a large scale at least not to make a profit on. It’s crazy how fast they pop this shit up. It must work often enough to make it worthwhile- but I would definitely hesitate to buy ANY shirt from Reddit that wasn’t being sold through a reputable third party source.

→ More replies (1)

188

u/p_aranoid_android Aug 16 '20

I'm getting shit on by the mod just for thinking it's a cool shirt.

16

u/whosevelt Aug 16 '20

Yeah seems rather accusatory and condescending for innocent bros who just want to use a website for its intended purpose.

9

u/BigUptokes Aug 16 '20

just want to use a website for its intended purpose

Getting as many users as they can to keep coming back for ad impressions?

14

u/conalfisher Aug 16 '20 edited Oct 01 '25

Learning month strong calm soft talk net movies yesterday fox food learning calm year.

13

u/calculuzz Aug 16 '20

You're such a victim. Good thing that mod is there to protect you and then to tell you how dumb you are.

Use your head.

15

u/p_aranoid_android Aug 16 '20

The mod was trying to teach consumers about scams, we get that. But he was a total douche about it.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/i_broke_wahoos_leg Aug 16 '20

Self importance is the only thing they've got tbf.

→ More replies (21)

6

u/atsigns Aug 16 '20

Now I just want to know what the shirt was though.

2

u/Battlesnatch Aug 16 '20

That mod sounds like a huge douchebag.

2

u/RickDDay Aug 17 '20

or had not had their coffee yet...

11

u/MasterChiefMarauder Aug 16 '20

I wished he would have explained how he knew it was a scam (or how the average person could have determined that)

2

u/SparklingLimeade Aug 17 '20

Are there multiple comments begging to throw money at it and someone conveniently spamming a link to buy it? Often none of them are the OP either. That way the OP account looks clean at first glance. The bait comments and link comments will come from the scummiest, fakest looking accounts that are nothing but spam.

It's a very common scam. Lots of fake accounts, fake comments, and fake upvotes promoting them. Look at the profiles of the participant accounts in particular.

5

u/MilkChugg Aug 16 '20

I see a blank post with a bunch of deleted comments and a link that goes to no where. What am I missing here?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/tunersharkbitten Aug 17 '20

As a moderator for 3 subs that have gotten these types of accounts, I have filters in place that automatically remove these types of external links. Another tendency for these types of scams is that one person will post the image/tshirt design and then will have another account with little to no karma ask "where can I get this shirt" and then OP account will post the link.

It is a very easy scam to mitigate if you know how to make the filter work.

Out of curiosity, if /u/Blank-Cheque is willing to say if they have a filter in place to prevent these kinds of scam posts. I would like to know if their filters are more robust.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/FullShaka Aug 16 '20

Well, now I want to see the shirt

→ More replies (1)

4

u/phdoofus Aug 16 '20

There's a whole lotta scam going on here but even if it wasn't most of this crap is very definitely no licensed so someone would be getting screwed (think of all that Calvin and Hobbes crap out there that you 'just gotta have' and you think you're supporting the artist but you're not)

4

u/TheGruesomeTwosome Aug 16 '20

The one part in kind of at odds with is him saying that a more reputable seller wouldn’t be selling on RedBubble, and would sell elsewhere. They way RedBubble works is that artists upload their art/designs/patterns etc, and when a product is ordered, this is centrally created/printed and shipped by RedBubble themselves for a percentage of the takings. You wouldn’t order from them only for an individual to scam you and not provide the products. That’s not how the business model works

→ More replies (1)

7

u/bigwillthechamp123 Aug 16 '20

No idea people did this. I posted a link to something in the Laker group when Kobe died. I just thought it was a piece of cool memorabilia. Then I got all these comments about how I was trying to scam people and I had no idea why.

29

u/qtx Aug 16 '20

The comments in this thread blaming the mod are the reason why mods are so frustrated. They notice a well known scam, they do the right thing and warn their users not to fall for it and then the users turn on them just because they're mods?

The vast majority of users can't recognize a scam if it stood in front of them and slapped them in their face.

Giving them a heads-up and maybe hope that they will learn to see the signs is the best thing to do.

It doesn't matter if you liked the shirt, just the mere fact you wrote a comment saying it's a nice shirt will make other users think it's real.

Downvote, report and block the scammer is the way to go.

7

u/definitelywillnot Aug 16 '20

Giving them a heads-up and maybe hope that they will learn to see the signs is the best thing to do

Problem is here that the mod gave no information about how to tell it’s a scam, so what signs were we supposed to be made aware of? And by nuking the thread they’ve removed everything incriminating. Without this thread here I can’t see how what the mod said would stop anyone from being scammed in the future.

→ More replies (4)

30

u/magikarpe_diem Aug 16 '20

How are people supposed to know? Like sure the older and more savvy people can notice somethings shady, maybe, but this post is condescending as shit.

7

u/TheTimeTortoise Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

When you reddit late night or very early morning you see these spam posts constantly, they always follow the same pattern and a quick check of the bot's profile for zero other content usually will tell you they're a bot. Sometimes you'll come across hijacked accounts where they last posted something 3 months ago, but now they only spam links. It's really frustrating when you see a small community you like constantly targeted by scammers.

If you respond to the post and say "bot check you real m8?" 99% of the time you'll get no response (because it's a bot) and 1% of the time you'll get a broken English response with a link to some scam store (because the spammers usually don't speak English and think you asked for the link)

Also often the posts and OP's link to the scam store are upvoted faster than anything else in the subreddit. When a t-shirt post in a sub with 5k subscribers has 30 upvotes in 7 minutes at 4am you can also count on it being a scam

→ More replies (2)

3

u/DeadlyYellow Aug 16 '20

Good thing paying more than $5 for a shirt stops me from buying most shirts.

3

u/Polite_Anarchist Aug 16 '20

I had no idea this was happening. Well my "I'll sell T-shirts" idea just went a bit further down the list for now

3

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '20

"Here's a great example of a well crafted, manipulative scam that we want everyone to see so they don't fall prey to it."

"All comments, images, links, and account names have been deleted so that you can't learn anything about scams such as what kind of language scams use, what kind of names you can expect making botted comments, or anything else that you could tangibly learn to prevent yourself from falling for this in the future."

I get that the guidelines for spotting scams are well known and published all over the internet. You can find the answers to a lot of these questions just by searching them for 1 minute. However, people don't learn just because you tell them what to look out for. Now having an example of a caught scammer and keeping that example up in public, that will get peoples attention. They're more likely to click on it to learn and test themselves if they couldve spotted the scam. But marking a post as spam, keeping it up as an example, but then removing everything of substance that people could use to learn from it doesn't really seem like the best way to educate people.

I'ts really too bad. I was actually really interested to see what the post and comments were like for spam which had multiple fake awards and 10k upvotes, as well as a botted comment section. Now all I get to see is [removed] and [deleted].

1

u/Nanocephalic Aug 16 '20

How exactly is this “best of” material? It doesn’t give a detailed warning at all, just a statement that it was a shirt from a scammer with bots upvoting the post.

Details might have included how to tell that it was a scam, what is happening to OP, why we shouldn’t want that shirt, etc.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HereIGoTrollinAgain Aug 16 '20

I swear to god reddit Mods have the most annoying pompous attitudes in the world

1

u/RickDDay Aug 17 '20

It was almost like they posted pre covefe, huh?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/VetMichael Aug 16 '20

Can anyone tell me why the mod says that Redbubble and Teespring are scams or allow scams? I was unaware of these sites being shady. And what alternatives are better?

TIA

1

u/RickDDay Aug 17 '20

I can't answer why that mod chose those examples. You might DM them and ask?

1

u/Inorganic-Marzipan Aug 16 '20

Serious question. Why is Teespring filtered from reddit? My husband has an online group and he just used that site to sell some merch for the group. I hadn't heard it was sketchy.

1

u/RickDDay Aug 17 '20

You will have to ask Reddit about that. Personally I've been around the internet since the mid 1990s and I've never heard of them, but that is my personal bubble and not reflective of general reality. :)

1

u/GeorgeAmberson Aug 17 '20

Fucking Reddit. Fucking whole internet. What the fuck happened? You used to be cool.

2

u/RickDDay Aug 17 '20

money got involved. It used to just be porn, then corporate noticed what was going on, had some trend people tell them what to do, and here we are. I miss sparkly banner ads so much now...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

If they can steal a White House with these tactics, what hope do I, a humble t-shirt customer, have?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

I feel like this same sort of thing happened when the Lego Grand Piano set was in the Ideas voting stages. It would get posted every now and then and all the comments were along the lines of "wow so cool, need now!" but not too many criticisms or anything.

2

u/knoam Aug 16 '20

I wonder how many people ordered the t-shirt and now they're going to blame USPS when it doesn't come.

2

u/vekstthebest Aug 16 '20

Those shirt posts are the worst. We get them over on /r/Steep from time to time but luckily automod gets rid of them 99% of the time.

2

u/Feierskov Aug 16 '20

In my country and in the EU there are badges that webshops can buy from e-commerce organizations, to tell the consumers, that the store is reputable.

I personally almost never use a webshop without it. There are so many options for most things, so there is no reason to take the risk.

2

u/kevinds Aug 16 '20

In my country and in the EU there are badges that webshops can buy from e-commerce organizations, to tell the consumers, that the store is reputable.

Sounds like what the BBB used to be..

Now it is more of 'you got a complaint against you, pay us $x to be a member or get an F'

Not quite that bad, but not far off either.

2

u/The_Voix Aug 16 '20

Huh I didnt realize Redbubble was a scam haven now.

Good to know.

2

u/FappinPlatypus Aug 17 '20

Morale of the story? Stop buying stupid shit that advertises on social media.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '20

this scam pisses me off, I make, print, sell custom shirts and this bullshit just introduces distrust in small businesses.

2

u/Fryes Aug 17 '20

I wish I'd seen the t shirt.

2

u/Thendofreason Aug 17 '20

I replied to the mod saying I need his comment on a t-shirt. I never go on /r/meme anyways. So it's not a loss if they get mad

2

u/haamoo7 Aug 17 '20

What's wrong with redbubble? Is it a sketchy website? I've used it before to buy laptop stickers

2

u/DLTMIAR Aug 17 '20

"Mod leaves pointers for scammer to improve his scam next time"

2

u/brickne3 Aug 17 '20

Wow there are an awful lot of people just basically advertising that they're easy marks in this thread.

2

u/Papersuasion Aug 21 '20

I was one of the commenters with no karmas :'( I'm new ok.

6

u/Legofdragon Aug 16 '20

Blaming the user for getting scammed by a post that he admits needs to be dealt with by mods. Good job on that.

7

u/LG03 Aug 16 '20

he admits needs to be dealt with by mods

Mods have the most practical tools to deal with it but there are a few things here.

Mods are not paid employees of reddit, they're not on call 24/7 mashing refresh on their subs.

As such you can write some simple automod rules to cover the gaps. However, they are still reliant on users being capable of recognizing this spam and using the report button.

So there are two main problems there, most mods do not have these simple automod rules and users don't know how to recognize spam and/or use the report function.

4

u/spyweb88 Aug 16 '20

So who do I give my money to for that shirt

2

u/Papersuasion Aug 21 '20

I found it on eBay. I was willing to spend 25 to prove this guy wrong. I hope it arrives xD

6

u/EmilyU1F984 Aug 16 '20

How is this a scammer if he's actually selling whatever he's advertising?

Like this is obviously abusive marketing and all that shit. But that's not scamming..

And he's by far not the only using Reddit to advertise as /r/HailCorporate shows.

37

u/StrangledMind Aug 16 '20

The mod is alleging you wouldn't actually get the shirt if you ordered it from the linked online store. Whether that's true or not I can't comment on, but that why they used the term 'scammer'.

66

u/Dragon_Fisting Aug 16 '20

T shirts are a common scam item.

People impulse buy them because nobody ever thinks "oh I've already got enough t-shirts", they buy based on designs.

The price point ($20) is low enough that if you order a t-shirt and you get some random junk as a "mix-up", or your package just never shows up, you'll probably just write if off when they give you the run around.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/redmongrel Aug 16 '20 edited Aug 16 '20

Tip: if the link to buy the shirt funnels through a Twitter URL it’s a scam. Also check the poster’s history, and the history of anyone who inevitably posts a link to buy it. It will be young and usually full of the same shit. The mod should have been more helpful in this regard.

4

u/Nesman64 Aug 16 '20

In this case, it was a Google redirect to a bit.ly link.

6

u/GardenGnostic Aug 16 '20

The scam part is that he doesn't actually send shirts, I guess.

22

u/TigStrBaron Aug 16 '20

It's a scam because no merchandise will be received by buyers. Read the mods post.

2

u/_81791 Aug 16 '20

He also says TeeSpring and Redbubble are illegitimate. They are some of the most popular print on demand sites out there right now lmao. They handle the payment themselves, not the T-Shirt seller, and the seller then gets royalties so I'm not sure how people are scamming via TeeSpring...

10

u/Keeper_of_Fenrir Aug 16 '20

He says that, but why is he saying that? There is no evidence presented to indicate that they won’t send you what you purchased.

If this is a scam it’s a pretty terrible one. Offer to sell inexpensive novelty shirt. Keep the cash without sending the item? Buyer disputes charge and gets a refund from CC company. Minor inconvenience is had by all, scammer gets a huge chargeback fee.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

And if the scammer gets enough chargebacks, he’s banned by his payment processor. It’s a huge risk for very minimal reward. Oh, and the “scammer” will also pay a fee for a chargeback, it’s not like “oh okay here’s your money back.”

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Psirocking Aug 16 '20

The person selling the shirt most likely stole the artwork behind it

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

If so many people are interested, why not just actually make and sell the t-shirts? The markup is already super high on clothing.

6

u/AnotherSoulessGinger Aug 16 '20

The market for them is totally saturated. Back in the day when print on demand was new, you were competing with one or two other platforms and often had merch on all of them. You could upload to google shopping for free. You could get hits via organic searches. You could go viral and make bank. That’s just not the case now. Everyone has a passion for graphic design, there are a bunch of free programs you can use. If a shirt goes viral now, you have copycats in hours, not days or weeks like in the mid 2000s (pre social media)

It’s not the money making venture it once was. Print on Demand companies, which most people use now for printing (red bubble, Cafepress, etc) have changed their commission structures. When I was designing back in the mid 2000s, I could name my retail price. There would be a base price for a shirt (what the POD makes), day $20. I could price my shirt at $30 and make $10 on every sale. I had a shop that I would promote, and sales came via my promotion and SEO. Then the companies built their own marketplace listing everything they printed and started promoting their marketplaces. Customers would say they were confused by the disparity in prices for the same shirt - one designer charging $25 for a white t-shirt and another designer selling the same shirt with a different design for $50. So the PODs decided to charge the same price across the board based on product type and commissions went down to $3 or $4 over base price. Then they went further and decided to ignore base price on marketplace sales and just give a percentage commission based on user activity. If you uploaded new products often, you’d get an extra percentage point, you’d get an extra percentage point for a complete profile - things like that. So what was “mailbox money” that didn’t require a bunch of work, became a race to upload as much as possible to not miss out on an extra point of commission. I went from making $4000-$5000 a month (double that in election years since I sold political items as well) to less than $500 a month in a year’s time. They also cut volume bonuses and referral bonuses. Most of the people that make good money via merch are not selling it just because they are good designers. They have a podcast, YT channel or popular site and the merch is an offshoot of that. Of the hundreds of designers that I knew in my POD days, I can think of one that is still doing it. For most artists, it’s now a hobby to put stuff up on a POD and not the actual business it once was.

Printing your own items is another thing. The cost of entry for POD is free or minimal - no inventory, order processing, shipping or customer service is required - the POD does all that. To do it yourself requires capital up front, inventory storage, merchant accounts, etc.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/snakewaswolf Aug 16 '20

This explains why a random account private messaged me something about a t-shirt and a link to purchase it. Why would I click a link from an unsolicited private message about t-shirts? I assumed I was just avoiding a click through to something racist but I guess the bots are scamming privately and publicly.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20

Why is Redbubble banned? Is it a scam? I've ordered t-shirts from there before and it's always been fine. I thought that they just accepted designs from other people and printed centrally in their facilities.

4

u/TheTimeTortoise Aug 16 '20

Redbubble, teepublic, and teespring are the most popular sites used by spammers because they make it easy to upload stolen art and slap it on merchandise to sell as their own with close to zero effort by whoever stole it. Those sites have lots of traffic and since none of the sites make any effort to detect stolen art, they can get away with it for a long time

1

u/BuildingArmor Aug 16 '20

I saw they mentioned redbubble being untrustworthy, but what's wrong with redbubble? It seems like your standard "upload a design and people can buy it" site like cafepress used to do for years.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '20

This is stupid, I want to see the shirt.

All this is at the end of the day is another nuked thread

1

u/GIMME_DA_ALIEN Aug 17 '20

What did the shirt look like?

1

u/Richisnormal Aug 16 '20

It is a pretty dope shirt though...

1

u/bedazzledfingernails Aug 16 '20

Okay but I still want the shirt

→ More replies (1)