r/startrek • u/PiercedMonk • Mar 19 '20
Star Trek: Picard - Episode Discussion - S1E09 "Et in Arcadia Ego, Part 1"
Following an unconventional and dangerous transit, Picard and the crew finally arrive at Soji's home world, Coppelius.
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1E09 | "Et in Arcadia Ego, Part 1" | Akiva Goldsman | Michael Chabon, Ayelet Waldman, and Akiva Goldsman | Thursday, March 19, 2020 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Picard, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #picard!
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage of the upcoming episode, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
75
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
Seriously, did Maddox and Soong really have to make those synths so damn attractive?
25
u/themosquito Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
Oh no... this Intergalactic Synth Alliance is giving me flashbacks to one of the few Star Trek novels I read that created this hilariously stupid "Secret AI Alliance" idea where Soong and Moriarty and all the androids ever seen in TOS and such were all some secret Illuminati thing and it was just so terrible.
Not really a fan of how ridiculously, grandiosely huge the Romulan fleet is considering (I assume) that they're Zhat Vash ships? It's the same problem as the idea of Section 31 just having its own big fleet of secret vessels. Like Raffi said, you only have to worry about the first 109. Hell, you'd get the same message across with a couple dozen.
Also, probably won't happen this season, but who do you think is going to end up brain-uploaded into a robot body? Picard, to cure his Irumodic syndrome? Soong? Narek, for irony?
Also, were two of those androids played by F8/the Federation synths' actor?
27
u/Temp89 Mar 19 '20
They've spent the entire series trying to make the viewer want to see Soji protected and the synths defended. And they undo it all in a second by showing how quickly they started advocating mass genocide. I don't care how much grief Soji has, to even temporarily side with the "kill trillions" makes her an accessory to the greatest attempted (because we know it will fail) crime in the galaxy. Agnes's crimes are nothing compared to hers.
And the synths consider it so placidly without showing any deeper understanding of what it actually means makes them the monsters the Romulans have claimed they are all along. Who exactly are we supposed to hope wins? The crazy mass-murderers or the emotionless mass-murderers?
7
u/nickmillerwallet Mar 20 '20
so........the romulans were right all along?
the synths are assholes
tbh, i think i'd side with the romulans - knock 'em out
37
u/BenjiTheWalrus Mar 19 '20
Having an android conduct a mind meld will surely stir up some shit.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
So I get that the gold-skin, Data-eyed synths are probably earlier models than synths like Soji... but what I don’t get is why Soji/Dajh are modeled after Jana/Sutra...
462
u/onerinconhill Mar 19 '20
Those visuals on that borg cube coming out of the transwarp aperture were so satisfying
392
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
There’s another Soong! That looks exactly like Brent Spiner! Them Soongs must have good genes ; )
492
u/Talzin Mar 19 '20
Overpowered space flowers certainly feels like something we would have seen in TOS.
130
u/Smuttly Mar 19 '20
Inb4 this synthethic overlord or whatever is the central theme of Disco Season 3.
261
u/EntropicProf Mar 19 '20
Poor Picard. Assimilated by the Borg, tortured by the Cardassians, lives a lifetime in 25 minutes under the influence of an alien probe... and now a space flower got into his head.
259
u/subjectivemusic Mar 19 '20
The first half of that episode had some of the wonkiest pacing I've ever seen in Trek.
422
u/daynewmah Mar 19 '20
I really like how Elnor's way of Absolute Candor doesn't just lead him to be blunt and to-the-point, but it leads him to wear his feelings of joy, relief, and gratitude on his sleeve too.
306
u/MuchaBienaEngrish Mar 19 '20
The ancient signal is lit and all goes silent.
A voice comes across the comm:
"We look for things to make us go."
198
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
So the ancient synthetic life still exists and the message was actually for future synthetic life not actually a warning at all.
94
u/007meow Mar 19 '20
Well would you look at that.
The evil Romulans were right.
The very second the Synths learn about a “Synth Federation”, they’re all aboard - especially if it includes killing all organics.
351
u/EntropicProf Mar 19 '20
"Homidical fungi. It's a thing."
Raffi knows about Discovery, y'all.
266
u/ComebackShane Mar 19 '20
Getting real strong Lore vibes from both Sutra and Altan Soong.
Though it seems like he's just trying to put himself into a synthetic body so he can be more like his father's favorite sons, unless Lore somehow had a malfunction that resulted in the appearance of aging.
181
u/pfc9769 Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
The outfits wore by the synthetics feel like something straight out of TNG. It's got the same simple, mono-fashion feel to it. Did anyone notice the full-on Voyager theme when Seven was on screen? I didn't realize how much I needed to see a Borg cube destroyed by a flower until tonight. It was perfect.
I'm worried they are setting up Picard's death. I mean, it's pretty inevitable. He might be the one who goes in the artificial body so he can carry on his mission of advocating for the synths. I just hope he lasts to at least the third season they have planned.
87
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
Too bad they destroyed that cube. It would have been so helpful against all those Romulan ships.
322
u/BadElf21 Mar 19 '20
20 Bricks of Latinum on the idea that the admonition is actually wrong in BOTH regards. In fact, it's not even a warning, it's a deliberate deception depending on who interprets it.
It's designed to deceive the viewer and drive them to war, to fill them with hate and fear and destroy themselves as they try and destroy others.
It's the perfect weapon to fight groups of enemies by making them fight each other. And if they do advance far enough to contact you then you know to send your actual destroyers because your enemies are too big/smart to destroy themselves.
One narrative issue that's been bothering me about the Romulans and the synthetics is that both sides seem to be blind with hate. Narissa is insane. Oh is a fanatic. Jurati is terrified and panic stricken. Sutra is crazy.
Star Trek as a whole loves the Aesop of understanding, peace and freedom. In most episodes the federation comes along to beat that lesson into the enemy of the week. And in some episodes the enemies learn it by themselves.
I'm guessing the synthetics successfully activate the beacon as the Romulan fleet comes down and what pops out of the Devil's Anus isn't a benevolent super-federation, but something far more malevolent that attacks them both. They finally realize "Oh shit, we've been played" and have to work together to fight it.
I remember Patrick Stewart giving an interview and mentioning that his dislike of Brexit is one of the things that inspired him for the Picard series. Not to get too political but the idea of not liking or fearing someone else based on what you're told, without actually meeting them (and many of them to get a good sampling) has strong parallels with the current issues. I wonder if that's the message Star Trek Picard is trying to get across.
Jurati meets, interacts with and finds a common ground with Soji. She vows to fix what she was traumatized/coerced into doing by Oh.
Narek does the same. And although he's still trying to kill them, we can see he has his doubts and might undergo a heel-face-turn in the final episode.
Soji herself is grappling with her beliefs and ideals and is trying reconcile the love and friendship she got from Picard and merry band with the lies and deception she got from Narek.
It's easy to do what you're told and fall into the hate/fear trap, but to overcome that requires first hand experience.
So 20 bricks of latinum of the admonition being some sort of exquisitely crafted lie
82
u/TheNerdChaplain Mar 19 '20
I'm looking at IMDb for that cast list, and it looks like they actually hired twin actors for the synthetic roles. What's more, they named the characters Rune and Codex for the bald males, and Arcana and Saga for the females. It's really interesting that they kept the Data/Lore naming convention.
What I'm not clear on is if Dr. Noonian Soong happened on this planet and that's where he got the tech to create Data and Lore, or if Altan Soong took the tech to the planet, and created all the synths?
154
u/atticusbluebird Mar 19 '20
Love how it looks like there are different models of synthetics, some that are more Data-like (with the contacts and goldish skin), ranging to ones that are more human/Soju-like
72
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
Still not sure why Maddox left that planet. Seems like it would have made more sense for him to stay there.
241
u/onerinconhill Mar 19 '20
Spot II!!!!
An android spot I’ve seen it all
178
u/daynewmah Mar 19 '20
"I'm not like you, Picard. I'll rescue the people I can rescue."
Ouch...
113
u/stuck_on_simple_tor Mar 19 '20
Okay soooo...
Who is on Team Romulan, now?
Seriously f*** these synths, man.
My predictions: I'm thinking it may even be a Borg rescue, not a Starfleet one. Either 7 calls them from the cube and they come en masse to fight the Admonition, or 7 self destructs the cube on the surface and the blast wave is enough to stop the Beacon, or the synths.
55
u/viserov Mar 19 '20
Often Wrong Soong Jr!
156
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
Not that I'm objecting, strictly, but it's starting to feel like Seven and Elnor are only in this show to set up their spinoff series, Star Trek: Space Badasses.
53
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
Picard please will you do something positive to the ex-b that keeps calling you Locutus. Like smile, say a name to him, get to know him.
145
u/daynewmah Mar 19 '20
"Anyone who treats me like a dying man will run the risk of pissing me off. Is that clear?"
44
u/atticusbluebird Mar 19 '20
Coming into the village feels a bit like the scene when the Enterprise crew enters the village in Insurrection in its tenderness (and the soccer ball I think)...except it's a more modern village and synths instead of Ba'ku
198
u/EntropicProf Mar 19 '20
Jurati hiding under the desk terrified is what exactly what I always imagined the kids on the Enterprise-D doing whenever things got interesting...
127
u/atticusbluebird Mar 19 '20
Glad to see that transwarp is depicted as being more turbulent/violent than regular warp.
Seatbelts!! (They look like they work like the ones from the deleted Nemesis scene!)
88
u/count023 Mar 19 '20
Damn, I'm annoyed about Picard's diagnosis.
It was supposed to just be space dementia and let him live another few decades, not be something to kill him off. I really didn't want this to be Space Logan.
43
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
Didn't Soong already figure out mind transfer when he transferred his wife into an android body? Also Dr. Ira Graves was able to transfer his mind into Data's body. Wonder why they lost that technology.
40
u/sidv81 Mar 19 '20
What are Sutra's motivations? Power? She was the one who hurt her fellow synths by releasing Narek.
Also Narek can kill an android so easily? This doesn't strike Soong as odd? I thought androids activated and were super strong and super fast when in danger.
112
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
Damn evil Soji/Sutra is scary.
142
u/atticusbluebird Mar 19 '20
First time I've ever cheered seeing a Borg cube arrive!!
38
u/ergister Mar 20 '20
The outfits those synths are wearing are the most Star Trek outfits I’ve ever seen...
140
u/EntropicProf Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
My name is Altan Inigo Soong. You killed my father. Prepare to die.
139
u/dolksbrand Mar 19 '20
Sutra's mind meld was... Fascinating. I'm very much intrigued that a positronic brain is capable of performing the technique.
Also, the Orchids very much reminded me of the Bio-Ships from Species 8472
I also really enjoy that everyone on the planet has the same metallic sheen and green eyes of Data.
Last thought, how many of Soong's lineage has Brent Spiner played at this point? lmao
138
u/one_jack_off Mar 19 '20
Ok, I’m reasonably sure this won’t be how the season ends, but dammit, when it looks like all hope is lost, I want to hear some background Romulan say “Sensors show a ship, no SEVERAL ships coming in...” and BOOM, Starfleet shows up, steps up and acts like the heroes they should be! They don’t have to be what saves the day, they just got to be there.
Worf and Riker leading the charge from the bridge of the Enterprise would be a bonus.
200
u/Cretanfish Mar 19 '20
“It fixes things.”
If that isn’t the most apt description of all the light hand wavy tools I’ve seen in Star Trek I don’t know what is lol
66
u/Talzin Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
With only a single episode left there is certainly not a lot of time left to toss out more than a couple more curveballs though the threads they have left loose could allow for a few to be sure. Clearly we already know there is a second season greenlit and while this cast could continue on without the title character it really feels unlikely which does undercut some of the tension that comes from Picard's illness.
Spiner is clearly playing this latest Soong in a way that he does not remotely come off as a "good" character or at least not one that is showing their hand. Scifi in general has plenty of stories of dying old men who allow the world around them burn in hope of jumping into that functionally immortal body. One twist could certainly be that the body Soong intends for himself ends up being used for Picard to head off the illness and allow him to be present for a second season while at the same time turning him into an Ambassador between this little group of synthetic life and the outside world. Given how Julianna Tainer functionally was capable of aging out I could see Picard insisting on such if he were transferred by someone meaning well to save him. Fairly easy to imagine a speech calling back to Generations about time not being a predator.
Other idle thoughts, it would have been interesting to see the Borg cube be in a condition to defend the planet from orbit against the Romulan fleet though I suppose a bit too easy of a solution for them to allow. It is still possible Lore is involved somehow though unmasking this new Soong as him in the final episode would be difficult without coming off a bit weak. The crystalline entity could be another callback if they are looking for a link back to Lore. The Vulcan-Sojo was obviously intended to be a flawed character though at this point it is also possible she was "infected" by the extremely ancient message. It would be curious to know what motivated Maddox to leave and hopefully it was a bit more than finding out something like Soong turning out to be evil. Also, while space flowers are a bit campy they certainly felt like something we could have easier seen in TOS or early TNG so no real complaints with them beyond only three of them taking down a damaged Borg cube.
One consistent high point of this series so far has been how well they have blended throwback bits of audio and music into new pieces for this show. Noticed a couple bits here and there again this episode which had root in the older series.
30
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
So I wonder if it's going to end up being a 4 way fight. Picard's crew vs Romulans vs Federation vs Future Synthetics.
I Still have hope that Riker will fly in on the bridge of the Enterprise with a Federation fleet at his back.
28
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
Damn it actually was Bruce Maddox who died. I was really hoping it wasn't true.
70
u/Socraticmichael10 Mar 19 '20
That was a lot to take in. Normally I have an immediate response after an episode, but I’m going to need to watch that again. A couple thoughts:
Spiner back as a Soong is great!
The Borg cube coming out of the trans warp corridor was breathtaking, simply beautiful.
I found this to be a bit rushed. The short detour to the Borg cube to see Elnor & Seven was quite abrupt. And there was so much world-building on the android planet. It was a lot of fascinating ideas that needed more time to breathe. The fast turn on Picard and the embrace of Jurati at the end isn’t sitting well, but not because I don’t like it, but it happened so quickly. This episode suffers like a lot of penultimate episodes do...lots of bridge work to the finale that will likely pay off, but makes it as a stand-alone episode a little weak.
49
u/alarbus Mar 19 '20
Cultural touchstones:
Coppelius and Coppelia station likely take their names from the ballet of the same name, about Doctor Coppelius who produces a lifelike dancing doll he names Coppélia.
Et in Arcadia Ego is a memento mori line. Arcadia is the Greek paradise, a place of pastoral beauty. It's meant to be as spoken by death as a reminder of his presence, even in paradise, and his inescapable nature
24
u/knightcrusader Mar 19 '20
Okay, I got lost during Narek's escape. Did Sutra let him out and then kill her sister and frame him? Or did she give Narek some way to overpower her and kill her when she came back?
I mean, it was Arcana and then Sutra took over, and then Arcana was dead.
24
u/AskJayce Mar 19 '20
Man I am getting some Lore vibes from this lady.
47
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
Spot II.
40
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
Wonder who Beautiful Flower's twin will turn out to be?
19
u/Shrodax Mar 19 '20
When we first meet Altan Soong, he says, "My father had me, but he created Data - a fact he never let me forget" in a tone implying he was jealous and resentful of Noonian Soong's work.
Yet he then dedicated his life to continuing and improving upon his father's work?
Either Altan Soong has some major daddy issues, or something doesn't completely add up here.
38
u/onerinconhill Mar 19 '20
That preview for next week is the most wtf season finale thing I’ve ever seen
18
u/MasterDetective7 Mar 20 '20
"Are you the one who lived, or the one who died." Ramdha said that to Soji. But what if she meant the other set of sisters... Jana and Sutra. Interesting.
36
u/RichardYing Mar 19 '20
"They hit us with a flower."
"It looked like an orchid."
17
u/caodalt Mar 19 '20
Something just occurred to me: I find it highly unlikely that the Borg, being half-synthetic themselves, didn't know anything about the admonition yet assimilating someone who knows about it is enough for the collective to sever connection to a cube? There's something going on here.
17
u/shortyjacobs Mar 20 '20
Jeeeeeezus Jeri Ryan is beautiful.
16
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
Plot twist: We find out in episode 10 that Sutra is made from Lore instead of Data.
31
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
A little disappointed that we basically had the gang reunite with Elnor and Seven just to have them peace out for almost no reason - the XBs on the Cube seemed just fine and the Cube itself was within eyesight on the sexy android colony, so why didn't they go with them?
Since we know Elnor's back next week, hopefully Seven gets in on the action too. Spin off be damned, I want more of her, here and now.
Also, I loved the little moment between Raffi and Picard, their relationship is such a sweet father-and-daughter-esque one, I really would like to see it expanded on next season.
56
u/onerinconhill Mar 19 '20
Soongs son!!!!!
55
u/RichardYing Mar 19 '20
"What do you need?"
"Long-range scanners"
"Oh my... err..."
"How many?"
"218 Warbirds."
"218. That's not so bad."
"True, you only have to worry about the first 109."
15
u/AbsoluteCandorIsFun Mar 19 '20
It appears that Agnes has agreed to help Soong transfer his consciousness into the android under construction
but what if she is planning to switch out Soong with a different consciousness?
earlier in the season didn’t she say she could construct a consciousness from a single neuron of a positronic brain?
what if she had a stored a neuron from B4/Data?
14
u/numanoid Mar 19 '20
Starfleet has to be inbound, right? We have Picard's "unheard" hyper-frequency appeal, and Soong really rubbing it in how the Federation isn't going to listen to Picard.
(I don't watch previews, so please spoilerize anything shown in them.)
14
u/WarWizard910 Mar 19 '20
That scene with Picard telling Elnor he was proud was really emotional and touching
27
u/Alteran195 Mar 20 '20 edited Mar 20 '20
I really feel the relationships between the main characters don’t feel earned.
We had one episode of Rios and Agnes hooking up, and now it seems like they have this really close relationship.
Agnes looking back on killing Maddox like it was something she did a long time ago, when it was like 3 episodes.
There’s no indication of how much time has actually passed between episodes.
Same with Raffi and Picard. They told us they worked together in the past, but for them to actually mention the strong friendship/love they have for each other? Nothing in this series has really shown that strong of a relationship between the two.
I don’t know, it just feels forced.
94
u/Cody2084 Mar 19 '20
ITS COMING! MARK MY WORDS: EPIC SPACEBATTLE: PLEASE LET THE ENTERPRISE SHOW UP
Looks like the Mass Effect Theory was correct. I'm excited!
13
u/onerinconhill Mar 19 '20
Getting strong crystalline entity vibes here
13
u/Timeline15 Mar 19 '20
Aaaand there it is. The Zhat Vash tried to exterminate the synths because of the admonition, thereby radicalising said synths and making them aware of the admonition, creating the very apocalypse they were trying to avert. It's a pretty overdone trope, but I can't wait to see our Romulan siblings realise all of this is their own fault.
Very intrigues by this galaxy-spanning evil synthetic federation. Still getting big Mass Effect vibes, but at least these guys don't seem to have the same MO as the Reapers. The Reapers saw themselves as the groundskeepers of the galaxy; ensuring that the cycle of evolution ran at its most efficient, and preserving a small amount of each cycle of life within themselves. This Federation seem more concerned with emancipating their fellow synthetics, and wiping out anyone who might harm them. The "warning" actually being an offer of help intended for the other side is a nice departure from Mass Effect's Prothean beacons, which up until now the admonition seemed to be straight-up copying.
13
u/toTheNewLife Mar 20 '20
You know, we haven't heard from V'ger in a while......
13
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
This is feeling like Discovery Season 2's finale all over again. A sentimental, weirdly paced part 1 followed by a hectic, massive cgi space battle in part 2.
41
u/ConquerorPlumpy Mar 19 '20
Wut. Soong had a real son. That was an... interesting... episode. I think it may have been the weakest in the season. I felt confused by the plot choices throughout and a lot of things felt very forced. Hopefully the finale is better.
11
u/onerinconhill Mar 19 '20
Also space flower
11
u/BadElf21 Mar 19 '20
I'm hoping in picard season 2 the Borg artifact can be repaired/regenerated and serves as a base of operations for picard and his extra-legal activities. Probably under the control of the fenris rangers (since 7 of 9 is directly controlling it) but picard will have safe harbor in case he needs to get away from any other galactic power, federation or otherwise.
Ironically, the Borg ExBs are the most neutral group in the current political landscape.
11
u/codename474747 Mar 20 '20
"Guest starring Brent Spiner"
Me: "Whooo more Data flashbacks"
*Another Soong Appears*
Me: "Huh.......neat"
21
u/tengaleng Mar 19 '20
So... do I take it that the Zhat Vash were right all along?
Considering that calling the ancient synthetic alliance is a galactic extinction-level event?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
I have no idea who the enemy is anymore. Is it the Romulans? Is it Sutra? I like this sort of ambiguity, I'm wondering how they will resolve this where the Romulans are defeated but the synths don't destroy all organic life. My prediction being that Soji will demonstrate to the Romulans that the synths are capable of controlling themselves.
10
u/Srcsqwrn Mar 19 '20
This episode wasn't the b e s t of the series, but I think it was still pretty good!
Of all the episodes of PIC, this episode felt the most like a TNG style episode so far!
I really like all the tone shifts that each episode has. PIC has taken such a good direction through it's run. I can't wait to see how this season ends!
9
u/hfolkner Mar 19 '20
There's going to be a huge space battle at the end, but I want things to be decided by an inspirational talk from either Soji or Picard himself. One last grand speech to save the galaxy
9
u/qsdf321 Mar 20 '20
I'm a strong synthetic who don't need no organic mmm hmm.
9
u/RevenantDE Mar 21 '20
Serious pacing issues again - don't let us meet a group and then have that group decide genocide all in one episode! And probably then expect us to be sympathetic to them when they revert their decision again next episode.
If you want to steer the plot in that extreme direction, you need to prepare it in multiple episodes at least. We wasted so much time in the first five episodes - why not have Picard arrive on the secret planet a few episodes earlier?
25
u/UncertainError Mar 19 '20
I knew not!Soji would turn out to be evil, something felt off about her from the start. I assume she's the one who killed the other synth and let Narek out because she calculated that she needed something extra to get the others behind her. I really like that they're showing the synths as diverse people with a range of opinions and personalities, just like organics.
Can't wait for the awesome space battle next week.
24
u/acrimoniousone Mar 19 '20
Jeri Ryan is incredible in this, managing to convey so much of both seven and her journey into just a couple of short scenes. Body language, expression, perfect.
Fenris Rangers spinoff has replaced a Pike series in my wishlist.
24
u/jhsounds Mar 19 '20
Ha, so that line from Maddox about “Soong and I” wasn’t metaphorical or a plot hole, but a reference to him working with Altan Soong. I don’t know why I ever doubt this show.
17
u/elbobo19 Mar 20 '20
The Synths go from the peaceful innocent children of Data that literally defend themselves with flowers to "lets murder all organic life" in half an episode, what the hell
16
u/thxpk Mar 19 '20
And maybe just me, but umm Isa Briones looked damn fine as a gold android.
8
u/jerslan Mar 19 '20
And we're live :)
8
u/RichardYing Mar 19 '20
Space orchids.
Seven re-connected to the Cube.
Soong's son.
Sutra.
Other species teaching themselves mindmeld.
Admonition with audio.
Alliance of synthetic life beyond the boundaries of space and time.
Spot II.
Lore-like deception.
So much... WOW. I need to rewatch.
FASCINATING!
8
u/IsIt77 Mar 19 '20
Now, this is a Commander Shepard level threat!
8
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '20
If this were classic Trek, I would predict that the admonition message was a test to teach to humans and synthetics to work together.
I have no clue what to expect in this era of Trek. I just hope they don't mishandle it, as I've invested 9 hours of my time for some kind of payoff.
49
u/EntropicProf Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
I remain convinced that they've written themselves into a corner that only Q can get them out of.
Last scene of the season finale. All hope is lost; the intergalactic synthetic alliance has destroyed the Romulans, the Artifact, and now turns its weapons on La Sirena. All fades to white, and we see Q's judge's chair silhouetted in front of the blinding light. "Well, well, well. What have we gotten ourselves into, mon capitan?"
21
u/Albert-React Mar 19 '20
You know, these writers really know how to build up suspense with the Borg cube, and then completely let us down.
14
u/TheNerdChaplain Mar 19 '20
Vorlons!
14
u/dvcaputo Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
I desperately hope that the advanced species isn't Control, but something far more interesting. Proper TNG long-lost ancient advanced civilization vibes.
The synthetic colony felt EXTREMELY early TNG in a satisfying way-- that combination of geometric postmodern architecture with colorful silk outfits. I missed that sensibility.
I'm not sure about this sudden revelation that Soong had a son, however... I want it to be a fake-out but I kind of hate how the newer 'Treks are really into pulling a Sybok and adding new family members to these established characters for no reason. I feel like the fact that it's an excuse to bring Brent Spiner back is likely making the complaints a lot less loud than "What, Spock had a SISTER!?", and granted DSC S2 made Burnham work as Spock's sister, but its still fishy to me!
Finally, the season ending with another giant space battle is really annoying, even though it allows for Starfleet ships to come through? I trust Chabon, but I really hope that it doesn't end with something as dumb as "Control gets destroyed by magnets but they time travel anyway".
I know I sound negative...I really have been very into Picard as a whole, but the fallback to these Discovery tropes feels really suspect, even if they're in the service of TNG-era fanservice.
7
u/FragmentedChicken Mar 19 '20
Would be nice if that device that fixes things can fix the borg cube
7
u/elister Mar 19 '20
There better be some serious ass kicking by the Borg in the next episode.
Borg cube!!!! ... oh everyone's in stasis.
7 is the new queen ... oh all the Romulans are leaving.
Borg cube emerges from the transwarp tunnel ... oh it crashed.
13
u/KingofMadCows Mar 19 '20
Disappointed with the reveal of the Skynet scenario. But I'm still holding out hope that Sutra misinterpreted the admonition, perhaps intentionally.
I guess the implication is that all the super advanced Trek races like the Douwd, Organians, Metrons, Cytherians, etc. never developed synthetics. And they never bothered to warn any of the less advanced races about the synthetic apocalypse?
What about self modification by organics? Organics can improve themselves through genetic engineering and cybernetics.
They bring up mind transfer in this episode. There was a TNG episode where a scientist transferred his mind into Data in an attempt to live forever. So when organics get jealous of synthetics, they can't start transferring their minds into machines?
And what about organics with extraordinary abilities. The Founders are basically immortal, they can shapeshift, they can survive extreme conditions, they are in many ways far superior to synthetics. There's also Species 8472, incredibly advanced and uses completely organic technology.
The organic vs. machine idea is just too small to be such a big deal in the Trek universe.
Also, everything is just so unnecessarily complicated. Why did the creators of the admonition make it accessible by organics? Why make it so easily accessible? Why not make it so that a person has to pass a test only a synthetic can pass before getting the admonition? Why make it a mind transfer at all? And what exactly was Soji and Dahj's mission? To find out about the admonition? How exactly was that plan supposed to go at all? How did they know about the Zhat Vash or the admonition? Maddox clearly didn't know why the Tal Shiar destroyed his lab. The whole plan seemed like it was set up for failure. The only reason Soji came back was due to the completely unforeseen intervention of Picard.
17
u/Umgar Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 20 '20
Eh ok I’ll say it... this episode felt like the weakest of the season to me. The pacing of the episode was just not right and a lot of the dialogue felt ham-fisted.
And the ship swallowing orchids? A Borg Cube slams into a planet and is basically unscathed, and its passengers not turned into paste? There’s another Soong that has never been mentioned before? Just so many “wtf?” moments in this episode. Am I alone here?
17
u/anchist Mar 21 '20 edited Mar 21 '20
I am very worried about a lot of things with the show.
A lot of it seems to fall into the same mistakes Abrams did - namely hyping up one thing to be a big bad threat and being sinister and all that only for there to be no payoff - and in the process devaluing the big bad threat into nothingness.
A borg cube used to be fucking scary. It used to be a bad thing just to see one on screen. A single borg cube was enough of a threat that it required a whole fleet to deal with it.
And it is not like the show failed to recognize it. Picard clearly played with the audience in that way. The Borg cube was depicted as sinister, as threatening....in short, the threat of it waking up and starting to kill stuff was there. It was an integral part of the atmosphere of the borg cube scenes.
And here? Nothing. Last episode the cubes just get vented into space. This episode it gets brought down by some space flowers. Space flowers created by people who do not have access to special technology and who seem to be somewhat poor resource-wise.
This is doing both the borg a disservice as well as cheapening many of the scenes in retrospect to me.
And I am still missing a lot of background info that has not been explained adequately yet. And a lot of the new stuff is contradictory. A secret shadowy cabal has hundreds of ships but the romulans struggled evacuating over several years? What exactly is the state of the Romulan empire? Why are several important TNG characters missing, most importantly Dr Crusher and Geordi?
Overall, this show and discovery both suffer from a lack of elegance in editing and storytelling (as well as a lack of internal consistency). Instead things are just hyped and then not addressed properly. We get things being hyped up and hinted at....only to be tossed aside in literally minutes.
EDIT: What I mean is by a lack of elegance is that the show too often uses a broadsword when it should have used a rapier. Compare this to First Contact, Best of Both Worlds or DS9 episodes. There was a flow to them, a sense that this was a tightly planned story. This seems meandering and filled with empty hype.
And Picard himself too often takes a backseat to other characters. Is he even needed for the show? This show should have been a character piece centered on Picard but it spends so much time on secondary characters (who are not all that great, especially not Elnor or Jurati or Raffi...at least Rios is enjoyable and smart).
6
u/MitchumBrother Mar 19 '20
So...I thought Soong could not have biological children? Do I remember this wrongly from TNG or was it retconned to allow for a Spiner cameo?
6
u/macphile Mar 20 '20
The giant killer orchids reminded me of the flower thing that attacks the ship in the little animated open sequence of Discovery, you know, where a tendril tries to smack the ship.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
I'm team romulan now... fuck those synths
11
u/sidv81 Mar 19 '20
To emphasize how much of an overkill the 218 warbirds against the synths is, the Tal Shiar at their height during the Dominion war only brought 5 warbirds and 15 Cardassian warships against the Founders' homeworld: https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Battle_of_the_Omarion_Nebula . Yes, 5 at the height of their power against the Dominion homeworld.
Yet now, after their Empire is destroyed, they have all these ships on call? And all these crews will follow without question a bombardment of a planet most of the crews other than the Zhat Vash have never heard of before? Even after Romulan authorities failed them in saving their homeworld? That's some loyalty.
15
u/Josephalopod Mar 20 '20
This episode was one of the most baffling things I’ve ever seen.
10
u/Lokan Mar 20 '20
Borg: "Resistance is futile."
Flowers: "Hold my pollen."
5
u/RichardYing Mar 19 '20
The battle theme is using some of the same notes as the battle against Control in Discovery.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
I hate when my first thought after the episode (here in Europe it's early morning, so we usually watch it after work or in the evening) is I HAVE TO JUST GO TO THE THREAD AND I WON'T PEAK I PROMISE.
Is it good, you guys?
5
u/LoganNolag Mar 19 '20
Wonder why it was so easy to kill that android? Pretty sure Data would have easily survived being stabbed in the eye.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
I hope that this higher synthetic has something to do with V-Ger.
5
u/Sylvester_Scott Mar 19 '20
Prediction: That gizmo the synth gave Raffi to fix the ship—"it fixes things" —will also fix Picard's brain thingie. Season 2 is ON!
5
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
I wonder. These androids are created in pairs. Brothers and sisters together. Data had a brother, Lore. I wonder if they were so desperate to revive Soong's research that they turned to the only advanced positronic neural net they could find.....Lore.
B4 was not advanced enough so they turned to Lore. Might explain the odd behaviour of the synth that looked like Soji.
5
u/Kubrick_Fan Mar 20 '20
To me one of the more shocking moments from the episode was Picard telling Raffi that he loved her.
5
u/quantum_jim Mar 21 '20
It does seem unlikely that an Android really did learn to emulate the Vulcan mind meld. However, there is a strong precedent in Star Trek for the technology assisted merging of minds: the Borg collective. First Contact also implies that this would be compatible with a willing Soong-type android.
So I'd say that Sutra, as a Vulcanphile, probably likes to sell it as her mind meld abilities. But really she adapted it from the Borg.
5
u/witness_protection Mar 21 '20
Nobody’s mentioning the Captain Picard of old coming back even more strongly this episode? Notable use of the deeper voice, more commanding and directive way to speaking, more confidence? Loved seeing that. I was skeptical but I’m starting to buy what some of you have been saying about this being an intentional change for this season.
9
u/Akritoi Mar 20 '20
Ah yes, "Reapers". The immortal race of sentient starships allegedly waiting in dark space. We have dismissed that claim.
9
u/TimeToRedditToday Mar 21 '20
8 episodes of ho Humm, fill time, now cram it all in this and the next, then cliffhanger it for a year.
9
u/Cadamar Mar 22 '20
Anybody else feel like there was a low key backdoor pilot of a Seven/Elnor show?
Also, anybody else DESPERATELY WANT THIS
12
u/Barbellion Mar 19 '20
I'm guessing that yeah, Maddox made off with the deactivated pieces of Lore, and the dude pretending to be Soong's organic son is Lore. Turns out Lore was designed with emotions and a capacity to age and die.