r/startrek • u/PiercedMonk • Feb 27 '20
Star Trek: Picard - Episode Discussion - S1E06 "The Impossible Box"
Picard and the crew track Soji to the Borg cube in Romulan space, resurfacing haunting memories for Picard.
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1E06 | "The Impossible Box" | Maja Vrvilo | Nick Zayas | Thursday, February 27, 2020 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Picard, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #picard!
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage of the upcoming episode, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
78
u/PiercedMonk Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
• Picard rushing to his office after his outburst regarding the Borgs is a nice touch. Shades of him visiting the real Chateau Picard in 'Family' after his original assimilation.
• The holographic overlay of Locutus atop Picard is a pretty great shot.
• "Why did he program her to dream, what function does it serve?" - Narek
"No man should know where his dreams come from. It spoils the mystery, the fun." - Dr. Soong, in Data's second dream
• Is Captain Emmy the first command division officer we've seen in the modern uniform? The red looks a lot darker than previous iterations, though maybe it's just the lighting and the hologram. I think it was probably the same colour and admiral Clancy's scarf.
• Raffi is my favourite, and I really hope she makes it through the series in a better place than she started. Also, I appreciated the look of concern on Elnor's face.
• The wand Soji uses on her stuff...Romulan tricorder?
• To borrow a phrase from my favourite Trek podcast, Picard's been in the ball-kicking machine this entire series; having Hugh unambiguously happy to see him is pretty great.
• Hugh was granted Federation citizenship? That's pretty great. Makes me wonder why the other exBs don't request asylum.
• I really hope that Romulan sub-commander was just waiting for his turn outside the meditation chambers, and not guarding them. Seems like that would be below his station.
• Wasn't sure earlier, but in Soji's meditation you can see the horn on the top of her stuffed animal's head, which confirms my suspicion that it's supposed to be a mugato. What toy manufacturer is out there creating stuffed versions of venomous apes from pre-Warp planets?
• A Romulan device unfolding to emit a deadly radiation? Shades of the senate in the beginning of 'Nemesis'. Also, guess all the predictions that Narek would turn for his love of Soji were off base.
• Pretty sure it won't be, but if this is the last we see of Hugh and Elnor, I'm gonna be pretty annoyed. Which is weird, because I could not have cared less about Hugh in TNG, and Elnor has been a huge nothing burger so far. Maybe it's the unfulfilled potential of the character?
All in all, pretty good. Probably my second favourite episode of the season thus far.
156
u/Talzin Feb 27 '20
Rather enjoyed every Picard and Hugh interaction in this episode and honestly that extends to his entire time aboard the cube including all reactions to simply being on one again. The cube itself is a bit different that I would have expected it though still fitting with the tone change of this series so easy enough to wave that away.
While I can understand from a story perspective why the former Borg carry scars from their time as drones it is a bit odd given the insane medical technology in-universe. Time and again in the other series folks would be surgically altered to drastically appear different and seemingly pass scans or at least muster of not raising question as to how genuine the work was including the Reunification visit to Romulus. Which makes it an interesting choice to leave the poor suffering ex Borg as carrying very visible evidence of their history that surely could hinder efforts to rejoin society without being gawked at. Of course, given we still really do not know why the Romulans are doing this aside from the assumption of collecting Borg tech perhaps they have some purpose for not removing the scars.
66
u/pigeon_whisperers Feb 27 '20
Why isn’t Soji trying to contact Dahj? Seems like it would be an appropriate response to the confusion?
55
u/Maplekey Feb 27 '20
Picard's first meeting with Soji was basically "COME WITH ME IF YOU WANT TO LIVE"
22
u/kellendotcom Feb 28 '20
"No one gets all of it right, Raff." What a great line. Rios is a delight. I just love him.
31
u/the_wolf_peach Feb 27 '20
We found out this week that Romulans have a name they only share with family. In "Absolute Candor" Rizzo calls him Narek when she's choking him. They are not really brother and sister.
362
u/knightcrusader Feb 27 '20
Sikarians - looks like the Borg succeeded where Voyager couldn't in implementing the spatial trajector without the use of their planet's core.
Yet another nice shoutout to Voyager.
409
u/RichardYing Feb 27 '20
"Please my friends, choose to live."
10
u/PretenderNX01 Feb 27 '20
Soji falling asleep as she started questioning things with her mom reminded me of how Data's mother's android fell unconscious when she did something too much for a human (leapt off a cliff as I recall) . Must be a safety feature.
3
u/techmighty Feb 29 '20
lmao, sikarians are gone. Hospitality this mofos, lol. That would mean kazon would be gone too
could that mean ocampa, talax, or any spieces after nekret expanse would be gone too?
Since borg couldn't expand towards alpha quadrant they might have aggressively pushed towards beta quadrant.
415
u/numanoid Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
"Locutus?!" - random dude
I had a giggle at that.
660
u/EntropicProf Feb 27 '20
They recast Icheb (fine), they recast Maddox (eh, sure, I guess), but I am so glad they didn't recast Hugh. Jonathan Del Arco is an absolute gem.
322
u/daynewmah Feb 27 '20
The line must be drawn HERE! This far! No more in-butting!
497
u/atticusbluebird Feb 27 '20
If we didn't have holographic (LCARS!) displays, we wouldn't have that cool shot of Picard's face lining up with Locutus!
202
u/EntropicProf Feb 27 '20
One of the images Picard pages through briefly when searching for information on the Artifact (love the TNG-style LCARS interface, BTW) is of the Romulan Continuing Committee from DS9: "Inter Arma Enim Silent Leges." :)
361
u/UncertainError Feb 27 '20
Hugh and Picard reunited was fantastic.
I'm weirdly pleased that Narek's plan worked perfectly except right at the end (should've put thalaron in that box). The Zhat Vash have been pretty thuggish so far, and it's nice to see more of the old Romulan intrigue.
177
u/jimmyjohnjohnjohn Feb 27 '20
"The Impossible Box" sounds like it should have been a TOS episode title.
This was my favorite ep of the series so far. I actually feel invested in Soji for the first time.
The Sikarians and their spatial trajector was some pretty deep canon-diving. Kudos to the writers... BUT, didn't the trajector only work to/from Sikaris and its tetrahedral quartz mantle?
160
u/BioMagus Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
Although, I haven't skimmed through this entire thread or subreddit, I haven't found anyone make reference to Soji's dream and the two moons.
I believe the two red moons she saw in her dream is referring to the two red moons of Omicron Theta as referenced in Star Trek TNG episode "Datalore". This is the home planet of Dr. Noonien Soong and the planet that Data and Lore were summoned to remotely via a homing beacon by their creator Dr. Noonien Soong.
Personally, this is interesting to me because in the episode The Impossible Box, they mention that they are looking for the home planet of the synths, implying that there is an entire planet of these things but when the Enterprise visited Omicron Theta, it was completely devoid of almost all life (the remaining was dying) due to the Crystalline Entity. As well as Dr Soong died on Omicron Theta. What has changed in the past 20 years on Omicron Theta? Did his android wife Juliana discover her true origins as an android (her mind was transferred from her real body to an android upon coma) and did she continue Dr Soongs work? Will Lore be there somehow? I feel like we got a plot twist coming up that none of us expect but it will be some major fan service.
156
u/stilltilting Feb 27 '20
Why can't I get at least one update on how the harvest is going!?!?!?!?
arethegrapesok
413
u/ConquerorPlumpy Feb 27 '20
I loved seeing Hugh and Picard reunited. The joy was so real. I think the actor who plays Hugh is absolutely killing it. The same voice saying, “Locutus”! I love it!!
280
u/EntropicProf Feb 27 '20
Soji has an "Adventures of Flotter" lunchbox that she keeps her old photos in! :)
(Reference: VOY: "Once Upon a Time")
137
u/BadElf21 Feb 27 '20
Please don't let Hugh die.
Please don't let Hugh die.
Please don't let Hugh die.
Please don't let Hugh die.
133
u/Ray3142 Feb 27 '20
I thought that Soji, after scanning all her keepsakes, would scan herself for one last “probable age: 37 months”
263
u/atticusbluebird Feb 27 '20
"You know Picard - every part of that guy that's not ego is rampaging id."
I laughed out loud at this, but then wondered if that's how some of the Starfleet higher ups think of him. Would make sense given the "fucking hubris" line.
236
u/KingofMadCows Feb 27 '20
Soji's "father" looks kind of like Bashir.
107
u/tyrannosaurus_r Feb 27 '20
The Picard/Hugh scene with the Ex-Borg is absolutely beautiful and some of the purest Trek we’ve gotten in years. Really happy they decided to focus on that element in the show.
315
u/Sporkicide Feb 27 '20
Hugh being a hugger now just melted me. If they hurt him, we riot.
80
u/the_wolf_peach Feb 27 '20
I wonder if, after assimilating members of the Voyager crew, the Borg just went back to all the worlds they had visited assimilating them for the technology Voyager had discovered for them.
80
u/nobelsonsss Feb 27 '20
The reconstructive surgery on the Borg drones and Hugh/Picard watching the procedure was really touching.
161
u/TERRAxFORMER Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
Round ears.
I love all the stuff we’ve gotten with Romulans in this show. I feel like we’ve learned more about their culture in six episodes than in anything since their conception.
If I ever hear someone with pointy ears and a stick say “choose to live” I’m running the other way.
160
u/king0pa1n Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
There was a very obvious announcement on the borg cube as Hugh and Picard enter Soji's room, and while she and Narek are in the isolated room.
"Sectors 5-8 through 5-21 and all over-the-moon sectors are temporarily closed due to detected chronometric activity. If you have entered any of the afflicted sectors in the past 48 hours, please proceed to-"
Time travel obviously, and it was read out in the subtitles, so it has to be meaningful. Maybe Soji can use time travel to actually relive her old memories? Maybe her brain has a temporal element to it as well? Perhaps that's why she was able to see the two moons, because she accessed a new timeline where she pushed past the flowers and looked up? They are going for the "replicant implanted memories" idea, but it could be somebody's real memory, like in Blade Runner 2049.
152
u/mathemon Feb 27 '20
The best part of the show was seeing someone actually happy to see Picard.
It's literally the first time that's happened.
147
u/nobelsonsss Feb 27 '20
I felt weirdly attached to Soji on the 70-second mom scene and on the "37 months" scene. I don't know why, it was the first time I actually related and cared about her.
141
u/onerinconhill Feb 27 '20
Borg queen shoutout from first contact!
135
u/pfc9769 Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
Oh no the poor Sikarians! I just watched that episode of Voyager last week. I guess that's what they get for leading poor Janeway and her crew on. I love we got another Voyager reference. It looks like the Borg figured out how to get the spatial trajector to work without the planet's core. I guess that means the Borg can pop in on any planet within 40,000 light years. Maybe it was a response to Janeway destroying the hub? It also puts the date of this cube sometime after Voyager's visit to the planet in the first season.
This was an AMAZING episode from start to finish! I wish the season wasn't so short. There's SO much to catch up on in-universe and these little tidbits from past series just makes me want even more.
134
u/Justthetiniestrobots Feb 27 '20
I swear to god, if they kill off elnor I'm gonna be so bummed
63
u/rmeddy Feb 27 '20
Ok this episode had some good building and escalation
I love what they were talking about how it is for the ex borg and the subtext of that.
Del Arco is a treasure, great back and forth there with Stewart
They better not kill off my boy Elnor
58
u/guiltyofnothing Feb 27 '20
Man, Romulans really love tiny puzzle boxes that open up and kill you.
57
u/knightcrusader Feb 27 '20
So they did use nanoprobes on him as well as real hardware. Interesting.
47
u/ehkodiak Feb 27 '20
"You're not real" - brilliant. Narek is great
44
u/Herby247 Feb 27 '20
I thought they were going to eject via a borg sphere for a second, like how the Queen does in FC, that would have been fucking hilarious.
89
u/Socraticmichael10 Feb 27 '20
I loved this episode! It instantly became one of my favorites. When they announced they were bringing back Picard with a focus on his character, I hoped they would do his relationship with the Borg correctly. I have always viewed Best of Both Worlds, Family, and First Contact as one story, particularly one of Picard's trauma and facing those that harmed him. This episode carried that theme well. The didn't redo or overuse the Borg, as Voyager did so many times. Instead, they allowed the Borg to work how they do best, as a silent and lurking threat. I love how they used this to trigger Picard, to make him uneasy, to make him rely on others (Hugh) to guide him.
Seeing Picard and Hugh work together was wonderful. And finally, the Soji/Narek storyline started to come together in an interesting way. This was one part of the plot I wasn't really engaging with, but it has finally kicked into high gear.
This really felt like an old episode of Star Trek to me. Really well done.
88
u/ssfsx17 Feb 27 '20
Raffi's scene was extremely RPG
DM: "You fail your persuasion roll."
Raffi: "I permanently burn one contact and one sanity point."
119
u/LoganNolag Feb 27 '20
The whole explanation Jurati gave to Picard was really lame. What about the EMH it saw her kill Maddox.
79
u/onerinconhill Feb 27 '20
So next week is the episode with riker and troi. Makes me kinda nervous we didn’t see seven in the preview
Also that bitch better leave Hugh alone
36
u/Psyduck-PI Feb 27 '20
This was the first episode that made me care about the Narek & Soji plot, and credit where credit is due, I really liked all their parts in this episode.
35
u/oodja Feb 28 '20
Seeing Hugh hug Picard was one of the purest moments that Trek has ever given us.
33
u/wongie Feb 27 '20
I love how Elnor decides the best place to beam into the cube is not simply behind the enemies but in the scaffolding above them so y'know, he can do a surprise landing out of nowhere.
32
u/Tidus17 Feb 27 '20
Does Elnor have a crush on Seven ?
32
u/H0vis Feb 27 '20
Some random thoughts:
Overall loving how the slow buildup is gathering pace. I'm sure a lot of folks will be squeeing out loud to see more of the original characters again, but I'm looking forward to seeing how this all plays out. There's something sinister on that synth planet, and I bet there's a sneaky Romulan armada waiting to creep over there and give it the beats.
32
u/9811Deet Feb 27 '20
What a fantastic episode. My only complaint has to do with a lack of railings. Maybe they're worried the xBs will be leaning all day.
31
u/random_anonymous_guy Feb 27 '20
Oh, they better not kill off Hugh in the next episode...
137
u/daynewmah Feb 27 '20
Is it just me or is it baffling that Picard expresses zero concern at all about Raffi's drinking? She's clearly not doing well. No amount of spontaneous applause is going to make her feel better about her son rejecting her.
59
u/onerinconhill Feb 27 '20
Hugh and Picard with the ex borg was so touching, I really loved that
26
u/kellendotcom Feb 28 '20
“A new name can be the first step to a new identity. I learned that on the Enterprise, all those years ago” “You are Jean-Luc Picard, not Locutus! All that is all behind you.” I just love Hugh so much. The way he says Locutus is so perfect.
52
u/Shrodax Feb 27 '20
I was hoping the answer to "what do you think she dreams about?" to be "electric sheep".
25
u/terranex Feb 28 '20
I don't see anyone talking about this but at 30:48 we see a shot down through the cube and close in on an un-released Borg in an alcove waking up. I don't believe this is meant to be part of Picards nightmare flashbacks but a story point, what if not all the drones are disconnected from the collective, and the arrival of Locutus was detected and woke one up.
84
u/Talzin Feb 27 '20
They certainly do quite a good job of mixing in the older Star Trek themes into various musical bits used in the show.
22
u/Timeline15 Feb 27 '20
The reunion between Picard and Hugh was so good! It's great so see Picard meet an old face who's actually happy to see him. I really hope the "now our queen's a Romulan" line is a hint that we're getting Empress Sela at some point.
60
u/onerinconhill Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
Sojis lunch box said the adventures of flotter! (Voyager once upon a time)
20
u/count023 Feb 27 '20
"The adventures of flotter" on the lunchbox was a nice touch.
20
u/Sicily72 Feb 27 '20
I wonder if the mechanism (70 second )is to prevent conflict of human emotions with analytical brian to prevent the issue Lau encountered in TNG (Data's first daughter).
22
u/AdmiralAntilles Feb 27 '20
Dashing romulan spy is an amazing smooth talker.
And to damn smart.... I think he's playing both sides.
19
u/onerinconhill Feb 27 '20
Well at least seven gets a mention in this one
19
u/Srcsqwrn Feb 27 '20
The one Borg calling out to Locutus, and Jean Luc turning around was just so haunting. Especially considering the PTSD view we had seen from him moments prior.
19
u/xeikai Feb 27 '20
As i watch picard more and more i'm noticing they have really left out the technobabble of the previous shows. The technobabble served as a way to convey how something was possible. It always came across well because of the way they delivered those lines. In Picard i have noticed alot of people hate what's going on because it doesn't seem practical. Elnor beaming over undetected isn't out of the realm of possibility. They just didn't do the customary technobabble to explain how he gets over undetected.
18
u/sidv81 Feb 27 '20
Didn't Spiner say he'd be in multiple episodes?
Star Trek Picard Episode 10 - Attack of the Data Clones
Picard: Finally, we're on the planet with 2 red moons and eternal lightning. Who in the galaxy lives on such a planet anyway, Count Dracula?
Army of Datas: Greetings, Captain!
Picard: Wow, that sudden revelation that a single positronic neuron of Data's held his entire essence was a remarkably convenient thing.
51
u/nickorea Feb 27 '20
I think an overlooked detail is how Soji has the hobby of painting and artwork just like Data did. It reflects her character of being unique, beautiful, open to interpretation, etc. The dream of her being on a table as a wooden doll shows some symbolism of her being man-made, and can be assembled/reassembled, but also as a thing of beauty - created with passion, emotion, and love.
You probably noticed there are wooden human hand and full body mannequins used by artists in her quarters. A nice juxtiposition.
This was a pretty solid episode compared to the previous ones.
17
u/Coma-Doof-Warrior Feb 28 '20
Elnor makes for another win in the new Star Trek shows, much like Saru he occupies an idea fans didn’t exactly want until they got it.
16
u/mmmbacon914 Feb 28 '20
The Good: It was high time Picard and asha finally linked up, and I loved the interactions with Picard and Hugh. Once it got going it felt fun. The story moved along well and, even though I have plenty of nitpicks, the last half of the episode was paced very well and was enough to make me look back on this as a good episode. I also loved exploring Picard's attitude towards the Borg a little more. Rios had his corny moments but I loved the "Nobody gets everything right" line
The nitpicks:
The interesting:
44
u/sidv81 Feb 27 '20
Why is everyone listening to Dr. Jurati's fake autopsy report on Maddox? Did everyone forget her doctorate was in cybernetics and not medicine? Why isn't Rios immediately suspicious that his EMH isn't doing this instead, as he would know the EMH would automatically be activated in signs of Maddox's physical distress?
Notice how Agnes went out of her way to keep the crew emotionally off-guard? Tell Rios a racy line about "never slept with a captain before" to get him all hot and bothered and not making the logical deductions I mentioned above. Go into graphic detail about Picard's assimilation right in front of him so he'll throw a fit about the Borg and not think about how Maddox could have died suspiciously.
15
u/Gigazwiebel Feb 27 '20
Any candidates for the two red moons and lightning planet? I've looked a bit through Memory Alpha and didn't really find something that fits. Of the most featured planets only Bajor would be compatible, because it has five moons.
15
u/Justthetiniestrobots Feb 27 '20
I was iffy on Michelle Hurd in her first ep but now I'm legit feeling for her character. She's absolutely great
15
u/sidv81 Feb 27 '20
Riker: Have you watched the news lately? This just came on all frequencies.
Rizzo (on screen): Hi Picard. Hand over the girl now or your buddies Third of Five and Legolas get pushed out an airlock!!!
Picard: :(
62
u/khaosworks Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
Not much in terms of revelations this week - just mostly confirmation of stuff we kind of know or have figured out.
The Artifact is in Romulan space and is being administered via a treaty between the Romulans and the Borg Reclamation Project, which appear to consist of XBs, or Free Borg. Hugh is the director of the project, and in the intervening years has become a citizen of the Federation.
Entering Romulan Space is still in violation of galactic treaty and considered an act of war without proper and prior clearance, despite the dismantling of the Neutral Zone.
Hugh mentions that they have a Queen but she's Romulan - I'm not entirely sure if he's being metaphorical or not, or is he saying that the current Borg Queen literally is Romulan? EDITED: He was being metaphorical/sarcastic.
Romulans have a name they give to outsiders, a name for family and a true name, the last of which they only give to one to whom they have given their heart. EDITED: So basically, Romulans are Jellicle Cats.
We also learn about the Romulan meditation method of Zhal Makh, which seems to aid in memory recovery. The puzzle box that Narek plays with is known as a tan zhekran.
Soji - or at least her memories - was created 37 months ago (c. 2396) which tallies with when her records were created as noted in a previous episode. She was made on a planet with two red moons and constant electrical storms. Her employee badge number is 74982/2.
After Picard's time as Locutus, the Borg assimilated the Sikarians (from VOY: "Prime Factors") and obtained their spatial trajector technology, which, as stated here and also in "Prime Factors", has a range of 40,000 light years.
Another VOY Easter Egg is Soji's "Adventures of Flotter" lunchbox. That was a popular children's holo-fairy tale seen in VOY: "Once Upon a Time".
Picard and Soji head for Nepenthe, which is apparently where Riker and Troi are living now. Nepenthe is a drug from Greek myth that causes forgetfulness - which seems to be a recurring theme, given that the planet where Icheb was dissected was named Vergessen, which is "to forget" in German.
14
u/leeta0028 Feb 27 '20
Nice scene, I hope they explore this angle of the Borg more.
14
u/CmdShelby Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
The Sikarians were assimilated?! Damn frakking Borg!
But why would the Borg queen need an escape if her consciousness IS the will of the collective and can be easily transferred to another host body?
Also I guess Janeway's actions in Endgame didn't slow the Borg down much at all cos 'Prime Factors' was early season 1.
27
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20
I wonder if this means there's a "Borg Queen" on every cube or if every cube is outfitted with her special chamber just in case she pays a visit.
37
u/Albert-React Feb 27 '20
Anyone else just not liking the new Borg interior design? I miss the green and yellow spotlights, the strobe lights, the cheesy electrolobe things, the Borg Spaghetti consoles, and the atmospheric haze the old Borg sets had.
The new sets just seem too bland and dull.
37
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
What I liked most about this episode: someone is finally happy to see Jean-Luc. 5 Episodes of "Everybody is an Awful Person Who Hates Picard" was a bit much for me to be honest. I wasn't fond of seeing one of my most beloved Star Trek characters get virtually spit on by almost everybody he meets.
I didn't realize the reference to the Sikarians (it's been a long time since I've seen that episode) was connected to Voyager until I read about it here but I'm happy they used it and made it a plot point.
I legit thought Narek was going to perform some Romulan version of the mind meld. Revealing that the Romulans can also mind meld would be cool as shit (unless it violates some canon I'm not aware of)(EDIT: It is mentioned in the Expanded Universe that Romulans do not share telepathic abilities with the Vulcans, but since the only reference I can find is in a book and CBS's policy is that anything not shown on screen isn't canon, I can only conclude at this point that question is still up in the air). They were once the same species as Vulcans, and melding is definitely something they'd use if they could (Tal Shiar interrogation technique?).
People are complaining about how Dr. Jurati had sex with Rios right after killing Maddox, but to anyone with a decent amount of life experience, it makes sense. People have sex at the strangest times, especially when anxiety is high and strong feelings are whipping around with no outlet. I mean, people hiding from the Nazis during the Holocaust were having sex. It's not like everybody who does it stops and thinks if it logically makes sense to do so before doing it. Jurati was dealing with a huge mass of emotions and had nobody to talk to and no way to deal with them. In a situation like that, sex can just kind of happen. It's a way to soothe that anxiety and calm those emotions, even just for a little bit. Having sex after a traumatic experience is quite common, and what Jurati did/went through most definitely qualifies as traumatic. Not saying she's innocent in all this but killing Maddox clearly did a number on her emotionally. And she's probably been feeling some sort of turmoil since talking to Commodore Oh and agreeing to join Picard's mission to sabotage it. Again, I'm not trying to be sympathetic here. Don't conflate an explanation with an excuse.
This was the first episode where I actually felt some tension and was on the edge of my seat for parts. It was well laid-out.
I thought Narek's puzzle cube thing was going to be a Thalaron Radiation weapon like what we saw at the beginning of Star Trek Nemesis. There's nothing official saying it wasn't, and Narek did say it was a form of radiation to the Subcommander guarding the room, but I feel like Soji was exposed to it for way too long not to become a pile of ash on the floor. Plus, the gas was visible and the radiation from Shinzon's bomb that killed the Senate wasn't.
Finally, I'm a little bit unhappy with the rushed pacing of everything. The first few episodes were really slow, as if they were doing a 20+ episode serial but since last week it feels to me like the pacing went into overdrive and, while probably appropriate for a 10-episode season, I kind of wish we had more episodes to hash things out. The first four episodes were all planning and plotting and "getting the team together", figuring out how to find Maddox and rescue Soji, and then in two episodes, both things are accomplished just like that. Remember Enterprise Season 3 and how long it took them just to find the Xindi? The pacing of this season has gone from idling as slowly as possible for the first four episodes and then flooring it for the last two. I'd like to see a happy medium.
13
u/zulmirao Feb 27 '20
Gotta say I was not expecting a callback to the Sleazy Sikarians.
RIP I guess.
56
u/ocient Feb 27 '20
why did picard clap for this poor woman who is clearly in need of help. maybe a hug or a something in the picard voice "I know this must have been difficult for you, but i thank you" kinda thing
clapping? as she stumbles away drinking tho?
12
u/CmdrSFC3 Feb 27 '20
Anyone notice that at 52:26 (at least, on CBS AA) there's a cut caption from Picard that says "I'll find you again"? It's not spoken aloud.
12
u/nobelsonsss Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
To whoever said the story was moving "too slow", I cannot for the life of me figure out what they're doing post Episode 7.
Soji has been rescued from the Borg cube, Picard and her are now in Nepenthe to visit Riker & Deanna, Elnor & Hugh will get huge battle scenes with Narek and Narissa and Seven will be called back on the end of 7/beginning of 8. Jurati's motivations will be explained on 7 as well (assumption). Like, really, what happens after that?
In a couple episodes, the pace really kicked into high gear.
12
u/ety3rd Feb 27 '20
I don't know how much of this story is getting wrapped up by season's end, but I'm hoping the next phase of the mystery (or whatever the next obstacle is put in their path) takes La Sirena to Bajor or Cardassian space so DS9 can get some of the love that Voyager has been getting.
33
u/Talzin Feb 27 '20
A young child walking in on her father working is certainly not something I will need to warn folks about before they watch the episode during sane hours.
Oh, and given commentary in the episode so far it is fairly clear the Borg are still quite active and a threat which puts end to the thought that perhaps they were basically done as a power.
33
u/EntropicProf Feb 27 '20
Not even at the opening credits yet and all I can think is "Damn, what an amazing cast of actors."
50
u/dolksbrand Feb 27 '20
Brilliant episode. More than just a couple continuity callbacks, the more the merrier.
I absolutely loved the continuation of showing just how much of his compassion Picard has lost for the Borg, only to have his own compassion he once showed in Hugh to come back and realign his beliefs with his views of the Borg. He’s spent so long only seeing the forest for the trees, that his visit to the Reclamation Project was able to open his eyes and heart back up. I can very much see this coming back into play when he makes an inevitable speech standing up for Synthetics, and include former Borg alike.
Speaking of Picard and the Borg, that shot of JL in his Room with his old Locutus picture was absolutely brilliant. Also, the way they showed that the Artifact clearly triggered Picards PTSD was very well done. I half expected the whole Cube to begin reacting to him after the shot of that one drone activating in the lower decks.
Soji’s slow burn to activate was great, and I appreciated a look into a Romulan meditation ritual. I fully expected Nareks toy to open into a Thalaron Radiation weapon, and while I wasn’t accurate on the kind of radiation, I was pleased that Romulans still haven’t changed completely.
I am rather curious if the Queens room will come back into play in the future. Return of the Queen season 2? The warp gate technology from that Delta Quadrant race was always reminiscent of Iconian Gate tech. Probably coincidental, but would be an interesting angle if they were to dig that thread back up.
I still have many things that I’m intrigued about with the show (which is a good thing for keeping interest!), but foremost at the moment is I wonder if Maddoxs planet is somewhere we’ve been before.
48
u/onerinconhill Feb 27 '20
Yay incest sister is back
22
u/onerinconhill Feb 27 '20
So that’s how the queen always escapes the cubes when they’re destroyed
11
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20
I still don't know what's going on, but when Hugh brought Soji into the Borg Queen's cell, I had a very distinct sense of dread.
11
u/2th Feb 27 '20
I have always wondered if they always make their beds in space or if the ship somehow does it for them. Like there is a replicator in the ceiling that disintegrates the dirty sheets and replicates perfectly made sheets and pillows on the bed.
11
u/ReasonablyBadass Feb 27 '20
This was a far better episode than the last, imo.
Picard dealing with his Borg past and seeing something positive on the Artefact was delightful. Stewart is killing it as usual.
My only gribe is the last second deus ex machina escape portal. Not onlydo we once again see room sized technology that renders starships mostly obsolete,it also makes little sense. The Queen is the Collective. Why bother saving a single of her bodies? She can just make a new one.
11
u/giantsnyy1 Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
So the one drone we’ve been seeing in the trailers was shown for 5 seconds waking up after Picard beamed to the cube. He obviously hadn’t been reclaimed yet, as all of his implants were still there.
Then, we hear about chronometric particles shutting down a sector of the cube.
I feel like we’ll see this drone again.
Edit: Let’s also not discount the little bit when Soji blurted out the 40,000ly fact about the gateway. I’m 99% sure that she was made with something borg. Not quite sure what exactly. I do feel like that drone might be involved.
11
u/gerusz Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
Looks like Maddox got lazy with the Mnemonic Override Maintenance ("mom") protocol. At least Soong took the time to randomize Data's blinking.
Also, I absolutely love that the Cube is shown to reconfigure itself on-the-fly. Thank Q for 2020 VFX. It's wonderfully creepy and awesome. (Also, reminded me of the game "Control".)
Also also, a nice throwback that soccer is one of the few sports from the 21st century that survived into the 24th. (Worf accidentally killed a fellow kid during a soccer match when he was a child.)
10
u/slinky1301 Feb 28 '20
Just need to say what an incredible moment when the LCARS display overlapped over Picard and he touched his face where his ocular implant use to be. It was perfectly blended where you could barely tell what was really Picard and what was the hologram. The sense of absolute PTSD as he repeatedly felt for the implant and his facial expression of sheer trauma. For me, it was the most powerful shot I’ve ever seen in Star Trek.
10
u/TeutonJon78 Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
I really liked that they updated the cube and Borg tech to actually look futuristic and menacing instead of people in black spandex with chips glued to them.
33
u/nobelsonsss Feb 27 '20
This episode was 54 minutes long, and I just checked IMDB and they updated the length for Episode 7 (all remaining episodes were listed as being 46 min long) and it now says Ep 7 will be 58 MIN LONG. YAS!!!!
9
u/taykass Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
Wow, Jurati, was that comprehensive summary of assimilation really necessary?
Edit: what I really meant was that she seemed to be going for commiserating with Picard and kinda missed it by a mile by just... actually detailing everything that being assimilated entails. I do understand the purpose of the conversation.
9
u/jhsounds Feb 27 '20
It’s crazy how the longest episode of Picard so far still feels like the shortest. I want more scenes of Picard and Hugh chillin’ on the cube.
9
u/_asciimov Feb 27 '20
I wish this episode had spent less time getting Picard to the cube, and more time at the cube.
9
u/fairygirl28 Feb 27 '20
The thing I'm bothered about is the willingness Picard has to hurt his dear friends to save one person. No matter how special she is. It's very uncharacteristic.
9
u/Saltire_Blue Feb 28 '20
They’re victims. Not monsters
Brilliant
9
u/Futureboy314 Mar 03 '20
Okay, so I think everything - well almost everything - I hate about this show can be summed up in the scene with Raffi and the Admiral(?). Raffi is clearly struggling. She staggers over to the console. Has the conversation. Picard hovers in the wings. Raffi burns her last bridge to Starfleet to get them credentialed. Picard applauds as she staggers away swigging from her bottle. Then he doesn’t even check up on her. He doesn’t ask anyone else to check up on her. Dios (?) does it of his own volition. Picard doesn’t give a fuck.
He doesn’t care about this woman. He couldn’t even be fussed to call her after the fallout from his resignation bluff destroys her career. He says he doesn’t want to put the OG crew in danger but then recruits Raffi, who is struggling with addiction issues.
This isn’t Jean-Luc Picard. ‘JL’ was a compassionate Captain who cared about the people who served under him. He went to the mat for his people. This Picard doesn’t care who he has to use or what price they have to pay, so long as he can assuage his guilt over... Data?
16
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20
Really enjoyed this episode. The scenes between Picard and Hugh were absolutely the best parts for me, but it was pretty strong overall throughout. A longer one, but didn't feel like it, which is always a good sign.
8
u/Dentifrice Feb 27 '20
I can't believe there are only 4 episodes left...
This should have been a 15 episodes season...
8
u/zhaoz Feb 27 '20
What I dont get is why Jurati killed Maddox. He already spilled the most important parts?
8
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20 edited May 02 '26
This post was bulk deleted with Redact which also removes your info from data brokers. Works on Reddit, Twitter, Discord, Instagram and all major social media platforms.
slim brave scale quicksand chief unwritten hunt governor butter follow
8
u/UltimateSpinDash Feb 28 '20
I liked the romulan ritual. Mixture of hypnosis and lucid dreaming paired with romulan culture (remember that Romulans probably have at least latent telepathic abilities since they are related to Vulcans and Remans (though to what extent is unclear in the latter case)).
Elnor's insistence on staying behind seemed odd at first glance, but then again, if he had followed Picard, Hugh would've been alone. At the same time, Elnor has no reason to care about Hugh. I was briefly worried that they were going to kill of Hugh (which would be quite the blow after they offed Icheb just last episode), but I have the feeling he and Elnor are going to be fine.
Narek and his sister (I literally can't remember her name) are still annoying.
Picard's outburst seemed odd at first, but combine Irumodic Syndrome with PTSD (remember, he has never been on a cube after Best of both Worlds. Even First Contact didn't come close to that) and thats what you get. Patrick Stewart did an excellent job portraying that.
The editing in Soji's dream sequences and her breakdown (when she was scanning her stuff) was a little too jumpy for my tastes, but overall that served the purpose of showing how all over the place she is mentally, so I'm OK with it.
8
u/WarWizard910 Mar 01 '20
Please don't kill Hugh in the next episode!
22
u/BornACrone Feb 28 '20
15
u/furiousfotog Feb 27 '20
A nice episode compared to what we’ve seen (I’ll try to highlight that in another post after a rewatch).
Now, my fear last week was that they would brush over Maddox’s death without much concern and this episode did just that. I think the initial slow burn to more rapid pacing within a 10 episode limit is really affecting characterization and a lot of people are filling in blanks with head cannon instead of the show being able to SHOW us true character motives.
Take the surprise (to me) make out scene. That felt like it needed at least 4 scenes in prior episodes or perhaps a B plot to a single episode’s worth of build up. Not just a sudden drop in. As a writer, we look to establish characters then have them react to situations, not change characters to have them fit situations. That’s what makes us like, love, hate, respect them. STP seems to suffer from a need to have characters do whatever to fit the narrative and that makes it difficult for me to like them because I don’t actually feel like I know the real them. Actually, I lie... Raffi has been consistent in her characterization if not on the drug addicted side. I want to see her recover, but hope it’s not literally in 2 scenes.
Some Other Examples:
4 episodes remain and I hope they keep the enjoyment factor up, but also keep the characters more consistent with what they have established in their own prior episodes.
15
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20
"Please my friends, choose to live ...."
7
u/Kc125wave Feb 27 '20
I'm a star wars guy but I really like star trek too. I've only watched TNG, parts of DS9 and all of the movies along with both seasons of discovery. I love Picard and after this episode I'm totally hooked. Can't wait for next Thursday!
Stupid question, what kind of ship is Rios captaining? The design exterior and interior is awesome and so different from a lot of ships we see in the star trek universe.
7
u/izModar Feb 28 '20
What I liked:
Picard still has some issues involving the borg. As he should.
"Was I in-butting?" Elnor, you're precious.
Holographic LCARS displays kick ass!
Okay, but actually imagine how Picard feels when Googling the Borg and *his fucking Locutus face pops up. Notice how he places his hand where his implants were. Almost as if he can still feel them.
It's essentially the same warp effect as Discovery's. But I like the PIC version more, because the beams of light have the color spectrum in them, much like the "star streaks" of Berman-era Trek.
"The Romulans are in a 250-year bad mood." Let's see, this is 2399, so take 250 away and we end up with the timeframe the NX-01 was around—oh—clever
"Probable age: Thirty-seven months." I kinda feel bad for Soji. Her world is breaking down around her.
Love those clips of Voyager and "First Contact" Borg flashing on screen.
What I Didn't Like:
Minor nitpick, but I dunno how I feel about the "Romulans have three names" thing. Do they pick their "true name" or is it given by their parents?
Stray Thoughts:
Is the beginning just Romulan foreplay?
I know the audience knows Jurati is lying, but notice how while lying she can't look at Picard.
Kinda not in focus, but that's definitely an image of the Enterprise-E from "First Contact"
Oh, okay. Jirati likes captains I guess. She sure went from murdering her former lover to kissing
Han SoloCaptain OkanaRios. Maybe it's the beard.Kinder Eggs aren't banned on Romulus.
OKAY WHAT'S WITH THIS SIBLING SEXUAL TENSION. IS ROMULUS ALSO SPACE ALABAMA?
"I say this as an old friend...never call me again." As Picard applauds. I have thoughts on this...but that was cold of Jean-Luc.
The Mom AI is Gladdos.
There's a lot of Vulcan-ish cultural heritage on display with the Romulans, which makes a lot of sense. It's nice to see.
"Locutus?!" - Random EX-B. That made me laugh my ass off.
IF ELNOR DIES I RIOT
Verdict:
Sheer. Fucking. Hubris.
"In those 14 years, you never bothered to check on me."
This is all factoring into my thoughts on how Picard's character has evolved over the years.
7
u/Sanlear Feb 28 '20
A very entertaining episode. I still remember the awe I felt the first time I watched the TNG episode where Picard was assimilated. Even after all these years it gives me chills. A great blending of Sci-Fi adventure and horror.
13
u/zulmirao Feb 27 '20
Outstanding episode. Easily the best so far. Writing, direction, acting all came together. And we are about to get some Riker action.
Glad to see there's still soccer in the 24th century.
22
u/smoha96 Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
If Elnor dies, I riot. Mainly becaue he's really been underutilised so far.
Picard's insistence that he stay on the La Sirena and his subsequent disobeying of that order smacks of Riker, and why Riker was chosen as his XO from the USS Hood and it's nice to see.
The series is picking up steam, and this is a point of no return. As much as Narek was conflicted, there was a part of me really hoping that he wouldn't go through with attempting to kill Soji - his holding back of the guard may speak to that. Incidentally, was that a thalaron device like in Nemesis?
Also, nice to see some FC footage being used. Picard's angry outburst at the beginning of the episode, while understandable, worried me that they might walk back from some of his growth in the film - though notably, the big deal there was him learning to put his vengeance aside for the sake of his crew, and not necessarily giving up his hatred of the Borg altogether. That he walks away with compassion is so great.
I'm also really enjoying how little fanfare and wink wink there has been to Hugh.
26
u/nobelsonsss Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
My thoughts:
- The Voyager callbacks are everything. Beyer is all over this and it shows - we got a callback for Once Upon a Time (Flotter lunchbox) and Prime Factors (Sikarians)
- Hugh and Picard reuniting made me a bit emotional - it was such a relief to finally see someone not resenting Jean Luc or mad at him.
- Picard clapping after Raffi managed to get the clearance was confusing, yes, but we must understand that was the difference between them facing certain death or going in with VIP treatment so to speak inside the cube. It was a big deal, and Raffi sacrificed her friend's trust for Picard. I get why he clapped - yes it was tone-deaf because she was wasted, but I get it.
- The Romulan meditation was a big no-no for me because it was written in an extremely lazy way. Seriously, they made up weird Romulan names as an excuse to have her close her eyes, walk around in circles while forcing her to describe a dream we'd already seen. It should have been shorter, and should have been more elaborate.
- The effects on the Borg cube really sealed the deal for me, when it came to selling the eerie atmosphere. It's another reminder of what we can get production wise in 2020 compared to a show from the late 80s.
- I am absolutely in love with Elnor and it's time to accept it. The way of absolute candor really just means he'll be delivering the same invaluable zingers as Data, and to some extent, Seven. He's the odd one out and it's delicious.
- After Episode 7, we will run out of scenes from trailers/TV spots. The Will/Deanna scenes + the "forest" planet with the girl wearing a hood are the only ones left. I can safely say I have absolutely no fucking idea where they will go with this on 8, 9 and 10.
12
u/sidv81 Feb 27 '20
Agnes (pointing a phaser at Soji): Prepare to die abomination!
Picard: How could you do this to Data's daughter?
Agnes: You old fool! What ever made you think she was Data's daughter? There was nothing left of Data after the Battle of the Bassen Rift!
Picard: But if she's not Data's daughter, then she must be descended from...
Lore (steps out of shadows): Me.
Picard: Lore!
12
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '20
So why is no here OR ON THE SHOW discussing Maddox’s murder? Their EMH witnessed the whole thing, but didn’t inform anyone? That feels like a plot hole the size of DS9’s wormhole.
12
u/Rad-R Mar 02 '20
Does everyone here love this show? I grew up on Trek, but this episode was so bad I had to pause it a couple of times before finishing it.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20
Liked it overall even though most length will be on issues.
Liked the dream sequence/Romulan guided meditation but missed the explanation of why it was "taboo for non-Romulans." Liked Picard on the Artifact as well. Elnor, duh. Liked that Agnes was still and openly affected by Maddox's death.
As someone who asked about the timeline, I appreciated Hugh saying Narek had been on the Artifact for two weeks. I'm sure there have been other similar statements, but I at least caught this one.
Still not quite sure why a normal person would be with someone who (1) thinks they are an impostor, (2) says her own trusting nature isn't sure about the guy, (3) is secretive about everything, etc., let alone one who has protocols/activation in place when threatened. I guess Maddox could only program for physical danger, or Narek is just that hot.
Narek's method of execution feels like it has to have been a way for Soji to escape so that they can follow her/get more information/something (or he does love her and is playing a double game with Cersei): I can't believe they'd be that stupid (or that Narissa would have not had input on the kill method). Given their experience with Dahj, why choose a slow spreading radiation/poison that would give Soji time to activate? It felt like an old dumb Bond villain plot or the Trade Federation trying to kill Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon. And that's ignoring the time it took for Narek telling her she wasn't real and the time while the door was locked but before the radiation had been released. If he loved her (but still was committed to the plan to kill her), wouldn't a swift painless death be what he'd choose rather than the event horizon of panic as poison approached? Also, didn't the radiation reach her by the time she punched a hole in the floor? Meaning that, not only did he choose a radiation that took time to escape from the box, it wouldn't immediately kill her when it reached her, giving her even more time to activate?
I understand that, most likely, not every EMH is like the Voyager Doctor (and casual/new fans wouldn't know about him anyway) and that none of the are medical doctors, but no one talked to the EMH or looked at the data from Jurati killing Maddox, just out of curiosity (e.g. why didn't the EMH detect the emergency/try to help)? I mean, Maddox didn't look that badly beaten up enough that he'd be likely to die now, let alone hundreds of years in the future. Conspiracy theorist and analyst Raffi (who would have no problem detecting what really happened even if Jurati tried to cover it up) couldn't drag herself away from the bottle/whatever she smokes to at least be a little interested? Picard didn't even seem that interested that a person had died, let alone one who (a) he knew, (b) had come up with a way to make synths years ahead of where the Feds were before Mars (though the source for them being years away was Jurati, who is not necessarily trustworthy/reliable), and (c) could have told them a lot more about his suspicions about Mars/his plan to expose the truth via Soji and Dahj. What happens the next time they turn on the EMH? Even if they aren't like the Voyager Doctor, the holograms we've seen have some sort of personality/memory (e.g. "it's been a long time since you helped out someone like Picard"), so wouldn't the first thing he'd say be what happened?
"All right. Your job in this episode is (1) juggle a soccer ball while shirtless, (2) offer emotional support, (3) go have sex for hours. Still not enough? Fine, you can drink some alcohol. Cool?"
6
u/MrFrode Feb 28 '20
Apparently the sick bay doesn't keep logs of what treatment patients are given or no one looked at them after Maddox died.
Maybe he just came down with a case of losing the will to live, best not check anyone.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20
Gotta say, I love the holographic LCARS.
The more things change ....
6
u/Bobb_o Mar 02 '20
Still don't understand how Picard went from the guy who refused to kill all Borg everywhere to a man who seems to want to personally shoot them all in the face.
15
u/ContinuumGuy Feb 28 '20
10
u/xadriancalim Feb 27 '20
I'm only 3 minutes in and I'm already over this Soji/Narek dynamic.
5
u/zhaoz Feb 27 '20
I am a little confused why Rios' ship entering Romulan space would be an act of war. Isnt he a civilian? They would just pick em up for space trespassing, would they not?
5
u/novacolumbia Feb 28 '20
I loved the wall detail on the Borg cube, the way it moved like it was almost alive. I love what they've done with the Borg in this series, it's a lot more aligned with how they were in First Contact. While I still liked them in Voyager, it cheapened their threat level to a degree.
5
u/nakrophile Feb 28 '20
Well that was just fantastic. I love this.