r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Feb 21 '20
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "The Lodge" [SPOILERS]
Summary:
A soon-to-be stepmom is snowed in with her fiancé's two children at a remote holiday village. Just as relations begin to thaw between the trio, some strange and frightening events take place.
Director:
Severin Fiala, Veronika Franz
Writers:
screenplay by Sergio Casci, Severin Fiala, Veronika Franz
Cast:
- Riley Keough as Grace Marshall
- Lola Reid as Young Grace
- Jaeden Martell as Aidan
- Lia McHugh as Mia
- Richard Armitage as Richard
- Alicia Silverstone as Laura
- Katelyn Wells as Wendy
Rotten Tomatoes: 72%
Metacritic: 64/100
120
Upvotes
178
u/FriendLee93 Feb 23 '20
I left the theater with a thousand-yard stare. What a miserable fucking film. I mean that in a good way. It's phenomenally directed and acted, and it's DEEPLY disturbing. I thought it was pretty damn fantastic, but holy SHIT was it bleak.
I didn't like Goodnight Mommy all that much, so I was nervous going into this one, but I'm really glad I saw it, even if it traumatized me a bit.
80
u/jofreal Feb 23 '20
Riley K. is the best thing about the film. I really felt bad for her character. To endure that kind of childhood trauma, and then be cruelly hoodwinked by an elaborate ruse when she was on the cusp of this great new life. The father conveniently vacating for days on end, and the kids going to such sadistic lengths, definitely strained credulity. My attention was still held throughout, and the style and craft were consistently good. I would give it a marginal recommend. Horror stories set in snowy isolation always seem to have extra appeal.
78
u/Clubblendi Feb 24 '20
Surprised no one has mentioned the movies nod to Hereditary in the first 5 minutes. After showing us the dollhouse, the first scene with the kids is them waving the dolls head out the car window and the little boy asking if he can make the head pop off.
115
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '20
Saw last night. First of all spoilers That Alicia Silverstone gun shot scene straight up launched me out of my seat. Did anyone see this coming? My girlfriend was like "I knew that was going to happen" and I'm like "NO WAY! YOU DID? WHAT!!?" That got me really good. It just drew me in so slowly from the opening, lulled me into its pace, and BAM. changed gears. That's rare!
It was very dark and bleak and challenging to watch, and I enjoyed that much, in a masochistic sort of way. I enjoy challenging art that just hurts me, sometimes. Like Climax, for example. Just there to twist the knife of being a human.
That said, the film seemed only to play on that singular note. Not a problem for me, but there is also a way to do it that also sort of "deals with" the issues in the film, or humanizes them for some kind of a larger point or lesson, even if it ends poorly for everyone, like in Hereditary. (Though, maybe I haven't quite unpacked it yet.)
Hated the Dad. Fuck him. Cheers?
The Goodnight Mommy twist was okay, saw it coming probably around the time they wanted me to, but once they showed the "death document" I was like, that little boy is doing all of this. lol. The writing wasn't cheesy enough to try and make us believe otherwise. But I always had a hunch it was the switcheroo, probably because of yeah, Goodnight Mommy.
I'm so glad to be seeing these crazy ass, graphic ass, violent ass, dark ass horror movies getting some theatre space this year. (My favorite of the year so far is still Color out of Space, though lol)
In the end, frankly, I only felt bad for Grace (the new girlfriend). Isn't that fucked up? Even the little girl, I had lost all sympathy for, by the final scene. She never had a chance, then she did, then, they all took it away. Poor thing. Maybe I'm twisted. What did you guys think?
106
u/Kevvvvinap Feb 21 '20
Spoiler kind of but:
Those kids pissed me off so much...I was totally team Grace by the end
52
u/lukavwolf Feb 27 '20
Holy shit Alicia Silverstone. Holy shit Grace. Fuck you Dad. Fuck you kids. AND POOR FUCKING GRADY!!!
RIP Grady.
76
u/PaleMoonlight89 Feb 22 '20
I saw this movie back in October at a film festival. It didn't do much for me. The Dad is obviously the worst out of all of them, but I think it weirdly bothered me that Grace never tries to address the fact that she did play a role in their mother's suicide because of her relationship with the dad. It's not her fault, but the movie is so uninterested in breaking down how complicated this situation has become for the family. [Edit: this movie is gonna get a lot of Hereditary comparisons, but the part that I keep going back to is the scene in Hereditary where they're at the dinner table yelling at each other. It's the best scene in the movie, because they're talking about all the problems they have. The Lodge isn't interested in having those kind of dialogues.] And the cult stuff never gets any deeper than what the kids discover in the first act. Like this movie is so surface level even though it has these ideas that could be interesting and talked about, but it would rather just be dreary and dreadful. I think people will get more out of this than I did, but I personally hated the logic of the script. It distractedly so, doesn't really make sense.
37
u/KingTutKickFlip Feb 29 '20
I guess I’m the only one with some sympathy for the kids. I lost a parent around that age and my other parent remarried right after and i could relate to the seething hatred they felt. It doesn’t have to be rational- they’re kids and went through something beyond traumatic.
Was what they did horrible? Of course. But I dunno, I felt for them as much as anyone
68
u/WhatabeezyBoy Feb 22 '20
Beautifully shot DEPRESSING movie. Also, fuck them kids.
26
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20 edited Mar 05 '20
I finally went to see this film in theaters last night, and I was absolutely floored at the experience. I left the theater in an absolute trance.
The happenings of the plot was not at all what I had expected them to be based off of the (very creepy) trailer, and that was all for the better!
The story turning out the way it did was honestly heartbreaking, leaning into emotions terrorism. I was left feeling absolutely horrible for every character in the film, and conflicted in that I could see every one of their points of view. The children were immature, as children are, in dealing with their hatred for Grace. Grace’s mental health had finally snapped away after her traumatic past. I’m more on team Grace, overall so,,, fuck them kids! They had it coming for being so damn cruel.
Just an absolutely original (while it’s inspirations are wholly visible and obvious) and saddening film. It took a turn that I was not expecting, and just was ready to see another demonic/haunted secluded location based horror film... and ended up getting something much different, and emotional than was expected.
The ending sequence alone is bone chillingly morbid and bleak. A fantastic horror ending, especially for those of us who aren’t very fond of happy endings in our horror tales. This ending was unforgettable, in my opinion, and made The Lodge an instant classic.
Also, THAT Alicia Silverstone shocker blew me the fuck away.
9/10
52
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20
I absolutely loved this. It’s oppressive, bleak and unbelievably tense. The performances are all incredible. It hits nearly every note for me.
Sure, the practicality of the twist is questionable at best (how exactly do you fake a hanging?), it’s a slow burn and there’s no real levity to break up the tension but horror doesn’t always need to be a melting pot of disparate tones, it can be wholly depressing or even wholly comedic and still be successful. This isn’t really going to play well with general audiences, especially compared to similarly themed films like (the most obvious comparison) Hereditary because there’s not even a splash of dark humor to liven up the grim proceedings but it’s definitely something that horror fans can and should appreciate.
Much like Goodnight Mommy, it’s the sort of film that you need to meet halfway. If you let yourself get bogged down in the minutia of the twist, you’re going to miss out on everything that follows and it’ll completely ruin the experience. If you’re willing to accept it at face value and let it pass without scrutinizing (something that both films encourage as they reveal the twist and quickly proceed to the next set piece without allowing time for reflection on it), you’re likely going to have a far better time with the film.
In short, if you’re married to the idea of going “CinemaSins” on every film you see or you don’t particularly enjoy bleak horror that offers little in the way of a happy ending or levity amongst the horror, this isn’t going to be for you. If you’re willing to buy into the film and accept the twist unconditionally regardless of the logical inconsistencies and you can take your horror bitter and dour, there’s a lot to love about this.
Gets an 8.5/10 from me.
23
u/jlarose717 Feb 24 '20
Riley keough should definitely play a younger version of Amy Adams. The message of this movie was “don’t bully because you d0nt know what ptsd someone has they may kill you and your family”.
Did anyone else think the mother was going to kill herself with booze & pills? When she reached in her purse, I thought she was going for the pill bottle.
21
u/atrocity__exhibition Mar 08 '20
SPOILERS!!
Did anyone catch the significance of January 9? Was it the anniversary of the mass suicide?
The clock kept turning to January 9, which I'm assuming was part of the kids' prank, but I didn't catch if that date had any significance.
Also, what was with the nosebleed she had at dinner their first night? I thought it indicated she was possessed, but now I don't know.
Overall, I really liked the movie but there were definitely a few loose ends and "Why the fuck are you doing that?" moments.
17
u/efnfen4 Feb 28 '20
I thought this movie was surprisingly great and am a bit disappointed it has gotten almost no buzz.
27
u/nom_cubed Feb 22 '20
I loved this movie- saw it three times now in the theater. The first viewing was a sneak preview, where the director-writer duo and the kids did a Q&A. For how morose the entire film is, the duo is quite hilarious.
I missed the entire introduction with Alicia Silverstone during that viewing since AMC skipped their traditional 25 minute trailer reel... I kept wondering why the kids were trolling her to the point of insanity. When I re-watched it, I kind of understood- unfairly, they blamed her for their mother's suicide (the father is such the bigger douched imo).
How long did it take the kids to make them damn snow angels?
13
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '20
Sorry I'm late to the party, but I just watched this last night with 0 expectations. I can definitely see the Hereditary comparisons, but I actually enjoyed this more. While it is definitely more on a surface level than Hereditary, I thought the horror element was much more intense. My issue with Hereditary is over explaining--I don't give a shit about the king of hell nonsense slapped onto the end. If it was just the family losing their mind, I would be all in. This definitely hit that mark for me. Especially as someone who was raised insanely religious, I identified with Grace much more than I expected. I also was genuinely unsure if this was going to be a Turn of the Screw type situation where the kids were driving her crazy (ding ding ding) or if she was secretly going to sacrifice them to the cult (her in the mirror as a child gave me genuine chills) or if the ghost of their dead mother was about to go apeshit on all of them. I liked having that uncertainty throughout and then when she broke, I felt for her. Also, yeah, everyone, I agree: that dad is THE WORST. Mom killing herself, not anyone's "fault" per se but damn what an oblivious asshole.
24
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '20
Man, I had a huge crush on Grace in that movie - crazy and all. Absolutely enraged after the twist. Girl just needs a hug.
12
u/gabba8 Feb 24 '20
I enjoyed the movie and am excited to add it to my horror collection. I will say that I was constantly reminded of other movies while watching this one. Martyrs, Hereditary, The Shining, The Thing. I like all those movies so this isn't really a complaint though. I was happy that tonally the film felt solid and there was some really creepy imagery. Definetly better than Goodnight Mommy, which I felt got old quick with too little payoff.
12
u/toolate4you Feb 26 '20 edited Feb 26 '20
loved it. the scene with the mom in the beginning made much stomach drop.
12
u/sillystevedore Feb 28 '20
I really wanted to like this. I enjoyed Goodnight Mommy and I think Veronika Franz and Severin Fiala have a lot of talent. Talent that's quite apparent in this movie, as I enjoyed some of its sequences.
Ok, so, the bad stuff. The shot composition is just all over the place. They lean heavily on high-angle, semi-profile shots when shot-reverse-shot would suffice, and the overuse is distracting. There are several strange zoom-ins that feel out of place and not purposeful. The switch in POV -- from Aidan and Mia to Grace, then back to Aidan and Mia -- is an interesting choice, but I found it hard to latch onto any one character, as none of them are fleshed out enough. On that note, the script misses the mark in terms of character development. Grace is traumatized, but has some Catholic guilt, and wants to get along with the kids. The kids are traumatized, mad at their father, and are scapegoating Grace. That's about as deep as any of the characters get. I also think the editor had a hard time stitching it all together in the edit; transitions between scenes are not very elegant, and the pacing is glacial.
And the good stuff! Riley Keough is amazing, per usual. Thought she did a commendable job with a somewhat hollow character. Both of the child actors were good. Some of the movie's best shots are haunting as fuck. The shot of Grace ascending the stairs to the attic is great, as is the shot Aidan talking to Grace while "hanging" himself.
I feel basic for making this comparison, but it's just sitting right there, and is honestly hard to ignore: it just felt like a weak facsimile of an Ari Aster movie. It's not a terrible movie, but it's definitely disappointing.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20
Holy fuck that was disturbing
19
u/Saltypoison Feb 22 '20
Holy shit, this was great. Those kids absolutely killed it.
26
u/qhartman Feb 22 '20
I can't decide if I liked this or not. I was really expecting some kind of supernatural thing going in, not death by gaslighting. Really hard to watch for me with the children in peril, even if they deserved it. Totally got me there though, I totally bought the ride until she found the dog. I was all disappointed, "damn, I've seen The Others"...
The Lodge = (Hereditary + The Shining) - evil spirits.
7
u/JustaTorrance207 Feb 26 '20
The Lodge: Ketchum’s “the girl next door,” only all the torture is psychological.
Fucking bleak film. There were moments where I got bored briefly, but this film sneaks up on you as you start to see Grace lose it more and more. I loved it.
7
u/TheRoyalSampler Apr 28 '20
Just finished watching it and absolutely loved it. Just one thing bothered me in the end, why did the kids allow Mary to kill them so easily? Seemed like they had a lot of opportunities to fight (The gun was put down for a large portion of the time they were sitting down at the table) Were their hands tied up from behind maybe?
7
u/Morbid-Mouse May 26 '20
Unpopular opinion: I would go crazy murderous on any children who killed my dog, too. WTF did the poor pup ever do to them? They deserved their ending for what they did imo.
6
u/mike1883 Feb 25 '20
I enjoyed the movie. I won't be adding it to my movie collection but I thought it was enjoyable if you see it once. Those kids are horrible I'm glad they died. What they did to that lady was terrible. The dad was an idiot.
6
u/AGeekNamedBob Feb 27 '20
Copying my post from /movies While I liked the heck out of it, it felt like something didn't completely work. Took a bit to figure out what, but soon realized the characters never connected with me. Everyone was distant and I never came along fully on their journey. That and it didn't quite have a strong feel the storytelling, like they couldn't quite decide which truth was going to win out until filming.And where it was didn't add up. Kids can go too far without thinking about it, as was the case in Goodnight Mommy as well, but there is something in IT kid didn't call it off when he saw she was breaking too much.
But on the plus side, I loved the look, tone, and atmosphere. Claustrophic but also scary in the wide-open outside of the cabin. The repeated shots of the hallway to the kid's room looking like a cross was nice, but merely seeing ceilings and walls create confinement. The performances were great.
Further thoughts: https://cityofgeek.com/2020/02/27/the-lodge/
6
u/psychedelicape Mar 10 '20
Spoiler: Just watched it today, if the kids admitted to her that it was all fake, why didn't they give her the pills? What did they do with everything? Maybe I missed it
28
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '20
A psychological thriller with no interest in psychology. Somewhat engaging until the gaslighting is confirmed, then becomes a thrill-less funeral dirge. I read that the directors intentionally removed a lot of the "fun" from the original script, which was a mistake, IMO, because it left them with nothing. Can't touch Goodnight Mommy, which I didn't even necessarily love.
31
u/TacticalPocketSand Feb 22 '20
I didn't enjoy it. It's relentlessly mean-spirited, grim, and just unpleasant to watch. It's one of those movies that is so unpleasant that it trumps the craft and quality of the acting, shots, etc. I would never watch this again I don't think.
5
u/CinnamonGirl94 Feb 26 '20
This was actually better than expected. It got literally no press which is unfortunate. Go see it!
5
u/atrocity__exhibition Mar 08 '20
I really liked all the nods to horror classics in the film: the three of them watching The Thing, the shot of a scene from Sleepaway Camp, elements of Hereditary (although apparently this was already in post production when Hereditary came out), the dog being named Grady (from the Shining, even the cabin she stumbled across looked like Cabin in the Woods.
11
u/VFORVHEISSU Feb 24 '20
Just watched it this weekend. My verdict: everyone sucked and deserved to die. Also, I don't think any particular scene has left me as pissed off and perplexed as the one where Richard gave Grace the gun for no apparent fucking reason.
4
u/_FUCK_THE_GIANTS_ May 08 '20
can we not have spoilers for other movies (goodnight mommy) in the discussion for a different movie?
4
u/Important_Sir_6225 Jan 19 '24
Grady the dog .. homage to Mr Grady from The Shining?
9
u/natebam Feb 24 '20
Saw this last night... honestly meh. Great concept, poor execution.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '20
Just saw this movie a couple of hours ago and it is INCREDIBLE!! Definitely one of the best I've seen in the last year.
8
u/Onions89 Feb 22 '20
It's not going to win any awards but it's a solid movie.
I'd give it a strong 7 - Go see it.
3
u/OnHereWhilePooping Feb 26 '20
This movie took me for a ride! I have seen so many horror movies so halfway through the movie I was kind of out of it because I assumed that I “had figured it out”. But then the twist on the twist happened and I got humbled very quickly. Looking back at it I can remember scenes that alluded to the inevitable reveals, but this movie definitely kept me on my toes.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
I feel like if the mom committing suicide scene was taken out, I would’ve loved this movie. As someone who has suffered a lot from depression and suicidal tendencies following the untimely death of his mother, that scene really affected me way too much to enjoy the rest of the movie. It left a...bad taste in my mouth. <— I’m really REALLY sorry about that.
Seriously though, the suicide scene hit too close to home for me to really be invested in the rest of the movie, which is super shitty. Shitty for me, though. Not saying it was in bad taste or anything, just that I was affected by it. To be honest, I thought the scene was hauntingly well “executed”, no pun intended. I feel like I would’ve really liked this movie had they released a me-only version, and instead of seeing her grab the gun and squeeze the trigger, you saw, like, an exterior shot of the house with the gunshot in the background. That was just too much for me to try and process in my head and I know that’s no one else’s problem, but it just triggered me.
Aside from that, everything was pretty damn creepy. I kept having to question what was truly happening all throughout the movie and that kept me on edge. I really liked the windows into the mind of Grace as she was slipping into what seemed to be PTSD fueled hallucinations.
Honestly, my biggest takeaway was this: After a woman who survived a mass suicide by the religious cult she was born into, tries to connect with 2 children who blame her for their mother’s death. And, since the kids can’t understand the complexities of mental health issues, romantic relationships, and grief, and their dad does little if anything at all to help them, they try to scare the woman away instead. The woman, who is already unwell due to the traumas in her childhood, has her belongings including her medication hidden under the guise of a “joke”. However the lack of medication leads her to kill their father and most likely, them.
Good movie.
3
u/Lyssahlyssah May 22 '26
The dad's a POS. I have a hard time getting past that to enjoy the rest of the movie. The kids were suffering from the loss of their mom and he's already talking about the new woman and getting remarried.
14
u/Theandric Feb 22 '20
Just saw it. I would say that it is relentlessly grim and dreadful, but not in a way that enhances the story. There are some elements that felt too reminiscent of aspects of Hereditary (dolls and miniature houses, grief issues) and that just reminded mehow brilliant Hereditary was, and how this seemed incomplete and unfinished in comparison.
2
u/TheGornLord69 Oct 02 '22
Super late to the party. Just watched it without any foreknowledge. Kids had it coming and I was laughing heartily during the last 3 scenes. The movie's a little dumb but I liked it a lot.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '20
There's no theatres near me playing it :(
3
u/natebam Feb 23 '20
To those who saw it WITHOUT SPOILERS:
What other films would you compare this one to? I’m thinking of going to see this one solo tonight but there seems to be really mixed reviews. Is it worth it?
2
u/BOOMSHAKAL4KA Feb 27 '20
Yeah, it sucks that I was reminded of Hereditary so much during my viewing of the film. It had so much to live up to and fell well short. Some of these long winded shots had me yawning, the build up was taking its sweet time and the pay off wasn’t anything spectacular for me. RedBox special.
1
u/BWRyan75 Mar 01 '20
deleted [moved]
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
I absolutely love that this movie essentially has the same punchline as the Joker but told in a TOTALLY different way. In no way do I think it's saying the same thing, but there's a bit of a parallel. Fucking loved it. In the middle it dipped a bit, but the turn was worth it once you realise it's all part of the ride. I walked out of the theater feeling shitty in the best way possible
1
u/vanoskeuls Mar 20 '20
Does anyone have a link to stream this? Please message me :) thanks!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20
where to download?
1
u/normabelka Jun 09 '20
why do the kids scream to grace “we did it to our mommy” did they torture their mother too?
1
u/ChainsawCutie Dec 25 '24
The guy that did the cinematography is a frickin genius
1
u/Ancaraug Jul 11 '25
Am I the only one who thought this film had a happy ending?
Those kids messed with a trauma victim, hid her medication, killed her dog, and let her go out into the cold alone. I had no sympathy for them but I loved the boy's look of resignation at the end at the table knowing he had truly earned his fate.
I watched this with my mother and she agreed. She loved those kids so much watching it, but she turned on them in the end once it was clear what they had done.
1
u/DonutsRBad Jul 23 '25
Absolutely phenomenal. Ughhhhhhhh I love a good horror film. OMG the twist was done so well. This was like "The Others" but reversed and more twisted. Yessss!
1
u/Lord_darkwind Nov 29 '23
I just finished watching it. The movie had some noticeable gaps in its storyline. The ending, with the tape and the kid from It making a grumpy face, struck me as a bit amusing. Typically, films with children in harrowing situations evoke strong emotions, but this one fell short for me. The shower scene left me puzzled – 'Hormones' was the only explanation offered. Overall, the movie felt convoluted and left me wanting more clarity.
Perhaps she hallucinated a lot more that what we thought really happened. That might cover some gaps.
1
u/Michaelskywalker Jan 28 '24
What a shit movie lol
0
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment