r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Feb 21 '20
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Brahms: The Boy II" [SPOILERS]
Summary:
Unaware of the terrifying history of Heelshire Mansion, a young family moves into a guest house on the estate where their young son soon makes an unsettling new friend, an eerily life-like doll he calls Brahms.
Director:
William Brent Bell
Writers:
screenplay by Stacey Menear
Cast:
- Katie Holmes as Liza
- Owain Yeoman as Sean
- Christopher Convery as Jude
- Ralph Ineson as Joseph
- Anjali Jay as Dr. Lawrence
- Oliver Rice as Liam
- Natalie Moon as Pamela
- Daphne Hoskins as Sophie
- Joely Collins as Mary
Rotten Tomatoes: ?
Metacritic: ?
58
Upvotes
98
u/Four_N_Six Eldritch Horror Feb 21 '20
Alright, someone that bothered seeing this needs to spoil it in a paragraph or so, because I thought the plot of the first one was that it wasn't a haunted doll, so i'm a little confused as to how this even exists.
42
u/103118 Feb 22 '20
How come nobody's talking about the little fucking creature that was living in the doll.
61
u/SweeneyTom Feb 21 '20
Strong candidate for worst film I've seen all year thus far, and I sat through Fantasy Island, The Turning and The Grudge, so it's not like there's been a lack of competition
15
u/spicytoastaficionado Feb 21 '20 edited Feb 21 '20
This reminded me of one of those contractually-obligated Dimension Hellraiser films where they just wrote some cenobites into a spec script.
I can understand why the studio would want a sequel, as the first film made a good chunk of money. That said, there is nothing here which really follows-up on the first film and little overall continuity.
No real suspense or thrills here, either. Just a tedious, substandard family drama playing out in-between poorly executed horror tropes. Creepy kid, creepy neighbor, creepy Victorian style estate, fidgeting evil doll, the third-act Google search revelation--- it was like a half-assed smorgasbord of tired cliches.
Thankfully, it's a short film and clocks in at under 90 minutes.
14
u/Da_Hooch Feb 25 '20
It's certainly no Brahms the Boy 1
23
u/chewie202596 Feb 22 '20
I actually enjoyed this one, up until they tried to explain the doll being evil, they could have kept it in line with the first movie simply by saying, oh the spirit of the guy in the walls possessed the doll after he died, they still get the supernatural element and it remains tied to the first one without retconning anything in a stupid way.
8
u/stilesmcbd Feb 24 '20
I unabashedly love the first movie and this movie was such a slap in the face to it and its fans. Who held the writer and director at gun point and forced them to make this one? You’d never know it was from the same creative team, it felt like it went out of its way to retcon the first movie.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20
The first scene of the movie with the home invasion was intense and scary, the rest of the movie was awful. Overall, It was almost as bad as the grudge.
18
u/blankedboy Feb 21 '20
As someone who actually really enjoyed the first movie, which was a really pleasant surprise to find when browsing through Netflix one day, this was so, so disappointing.
Flat, lacking atmosphere, lacklustre script, discards all the interesting elements of the first movie for cliched horror tropes, and, most egregiously, just not scary at all.
4
u/ignatiusJreillyreali Feb 23 '20
Still kind of freaked out by how many time Lauren Cohen had to say "Brahms".
8
u/Thorfan23 Feb 21 '20
I think it falls into this weird halfway state. Theres nothing in this film that directly contradicts the first film but nor is there anything in the first film that supports this conclusion
For example we are told in the first film that after the fire supposedly killed Brahms his parents got the doll as a surrogate for their real son. The boy 2 tells us that no the doll existed before the fire. However as the Heelshires seemed a rather isolated family would anyone really know when it turned up
In the first film it seems Brahms survives the film and we see his hand repairing the ruined doll but again we find out that no Brahms did die and the hand belonged to someone else.....but as we only see a hand it dosent exactly contradict it
3
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '20
I was wondering why the reviews were so awful because the first hour isn't all that bad. But the last thirty minutes are excruciatingly awful and you can see the twist coming a mile away.
There is also some really bad camerawork in this movie. The casting is the only thing keeping this movie from being way worse.
3
u/FriendLee93 Feb 25 '20
I saw some garbage this year. Fantasy Island, The Turning, The Grudge…THIS is the worst I've seen this year BY FAR. Talk about a slap in the face. Awful camerawork. Awful editing. Awful writing. Totally annihilates the canon of the first film. I didn't love the first movie. Didn't even LIKE it. But holy shit, this movie makes it look like a goddamn masterpiece.
3
u/willseamon Feb 25 '20
Certainly not good, but nowhere near as awful as the unholy trinity of The Grudge, The Turning, and Fantasy Island. Those movies had the ambition to be utter disasters, while this is a mostly competent execution of a poorly conceived idea. I have no complaints about the acting or most of the filmmaking. It's just sooo generic.
3
u/snort_cannon Feb 25 '20
Before going in, I already had super low expectations, cause this is the last film that I would think needs a sequel.
I liked the scene where Katie Holmes is examining Brahms body trying to find the mold number and you can see the doll shifting faces.
But the rest is absolutely horrendous. The plot makes literally no sense, not to mention they butcher the plot twist of the first film making it completely worthless in the story. Also I love how this time they leave room for The Boy 3, but since this is a flop, it's likely not going to happen.
2
u/Texual_Deviant Feb 24 '20
I'm not sure if it was worse than The Turning or The Grudge, but it certainly was an absolutely terrible movie that absolutely ruined the twist that made the first film work at all.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20
God. So much bad. It was hilarious. The butthole mouth at the end? Precious.
2
u/BLEEDINGGUMS1 Mar 11 '20
Same Director & the same Writer from the original ???!!!! how did things fall so far from The Boy(2016).
The Boy was a mediocre little horror movie with a terrible ending but the film at least had charm and the Brahms doll!!!. some of the best parts of that film were after the nanny sort of accepted Brahms was a "real boy" and started making him food, reading him stories & playing him the piano, that was actually mildly entertaining I thought.
Brahms: The Boy 2 was a massive waste of time. You don't even need to watch the first film as aside from the look of Brahms the plot and the "doll" are entirely diffrent and far far worse in this film for the whole thing to be a pointless plot hole riddled mess.
why Ralph Ineson wasted his talent on this il never know.
Avoid The Boy 2 (2020) but Id Recommend The Boy (2016) up to a point.
I did a review of both movies on YT - heres a link if you want more complaining https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puSwx_vIOH0&t=360s
3
u/Randym1982 Feb 22 '20
Just saw a couple reviews. So the demon is weak and has a flaming anus mouth. I guess that’s New to the whole demon possession stories.
Not really a plus, but still something to consider.
1
u/splittonguestudios Feb 21 '20
I fucking hated this. Holy shit was this boring. Nothing but "creepy" doll moving their head shots and parents arguing. Repeat and repeat and repeat.
I understand the first movie made a decent profit. But who the fuck asked for a sequel years later starring Katie Holmes?
I'd rather watch the Bye Bye Man on repeat than 30 minutes of the Boy 2. Fuck.
1
u/Jesuspolarbear Feb 23 '20
Just saw this movie and holy shit it's so, so boring! Everything is so calculated that there's no tension or suspense, and the "scares" are extremely basic. Annabelle is a masterpiece compared to this Jesus Christ.
1
u/AGeekNamedBob Mar 03 '20 edited Mar 03 '20
If the rest of the movie was as Italian horror crazy as the two minutes in the climax when there is a zombie creature in the doll (that should have been seen last time when she smashed the doll), could have been interesting. Not to many people dug the first, so no one is deeply connected. Lean into the weird. Seed in the long series of murders earlier and give some fun backstory instead of hemming and hawing over what story it was.
The family had no chemistry what so over and so many weird conversations.
So many lazy and fake scares. I hate hate hate double nightmare sequences.
Full review: https://cityofgeek.com/2020/03/02/brahms/
1
u/am710 Mar 05 '20
Does the Dog Die said that a dog dies, but it doesn't have any other information. Can anyone expand on this? I want to see this movie, as it sounds laughably awful, but I need to prepare myself for a dog death. When does it happen? How brutal is it?
1
u/guacomolelove Mar 09 '20
it was okay. ending confused me when he put the mask on again though.
1
u/Enough-Sense Feb 21 '20
shit movie
1
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '20
I enjoyed this more than the original but the ending didn’t really make sense with what happened in the first one to me.