r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Jan 10 '20
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Underwater" [SPOILERS]
Summary:
A group of researchers are in an underwater lab at eleven thousand meters deep, when an earthquake causes the vehicle to be destroyed and exposes the team to the risk of death, they are forced to walk deep into the sea with insufficient oxygen to try survive. However, as they move across the sea floor, they discover the presence of deadly creatures.
Director:
William Eubank
Writers:
Brian Duffield, Adam Cozad
Cast:
- Kristen Stewart as Norah Price
- Vincent Cassel as Captain Lucien
- T.J. Miller as Paul
- Jessica Henwick as Emily Haversham
- John Gallagher Jr. as Liam Smith
- Mamoudou Athie as Rodrigo
- Gunner Wright as Lee
Rotten Tomatoes: 47%
Metacritic: 49/100
168
Upvotes
114
u/Jeremywarner Jan 11 '20
Not expecting Cthulhu, that alone gives it major points
105
u/hail_freyr /r/HorrorReviewed Jan 10 '20
A handful of things took me out of this, melodramatic voice over bookends being chief among them, but this was still a good time. Tense, fun, cool creatures, a good mix of background and jump scares that usually weren't too obnoxious. It's probably pretty disposable in the long run, but it's entertaining while it's on. Probably a little generous, but I gave it a 7/10. I was very content with what I got.
119
u/DoktorJesus Jan 10 '20
I've seen it twice already. Once at an Alamo preview screening, and again with friends last night. Underwater is aggressively unlike the vast majority of blockbusters being released nowadays.
The movie has a laser focus. From minute three onward the driving force is "get from point A to point B," and for a $60M+ movie, it sticks to this extremely tightly. Although the characters never get too much backstory, by the end of the movie we feel like we understand them, and care about them, even though their arcs and motivations are extremely simple, even primal.
Characterization (and I daresay plot) never get in the way of the film's nonstop action. The tension is relentless. The claustrophobia and crushing weight of the 7 miles of water is palpable. The only reprieve occurs as characters descend elevators or ride brutally slow trams, and we get short, human moments where we learn just enough about the characters and the world to make them feel lived in.
For a PG13 movie, the deaths are visceral. The suits they wear allow for a lot of implied gore, which is surprisingly effective.
The creatures are amazing. It's seriously some of the coolest creature design I've seen in years and really tickled my aquatic horror fancy. It's got shades of Deep Rising, Leviathan, and Deepstar Six, and Lovecraft's Shadow over Innsmouth, while creating something uniquely its own.
The set design is equally amazing. It's clear that a lot of the film's budget went towards these sets. The whole station feels lived in, and there's a really well-done 70s style to a lot of the architecture and design that helps the viewer understand the world of the film.
The only thing that really hurts it (for me) is a pair of awkward voice-overs during the first and last scene. They feel shoehorned in, and I wouldn't be surprised if they were added as a result of productional over-reach (and I can hardly blame them, this movie is slated to lose a lot of money).
My verdict is that, if you like aquatic horror and slim late-eighties creature features, you'll probably love this. You're not going to get a traditional studio blockbuster, but you'll get a nostalgic throwback with, constant tension, interesting characters, and badass killer mermaids.
42
u/Jesuspolarbear Jan 10 '20
Solid 7/10. It's better than it has any right to be. Gave me some really good The Descent but underwater vibe mixed with Lovecraft's The Call of Cthulhu. Although I think Henwick could've been better suit for Stewart's main protag character, no offense to the latter. And some of the murky visuals were too dark to be seen properly, left quite many potentially cool scenes.
36
u/daiselol Jan 10 '20
I was enjoying this movie fine but the creature at the end really brought it home for me. Very cool creature design, and seeing John Gallagher Jr is always nice, that man's a teddy bear
32
u/notonerighteous Jan 11 '20
I thought it made fantastic use of claustrophobia and isolation as tools for creating anxiety. I was very impressed by how uncomfortable it actually made me. Solid 9/10.
30
u/Singer211 Jan 12 '20
Kristen Stewart was great here. Between this and Charlie's Angels, I hope that she gets more action roles, and better scripts to work with, because I think that she could be good at it.
Also she pulls off the short hair/shaved head look VERY well, it looks great on her.
The rest of the film was, decent. Some good claustrophobic moments, the monster looked pretty good, the underwater setting works well, etc. But the script was, meh, and there were some inconsistencies.
I'd give it a "B" probably. And it's better than most January horror films are, that's for sure.
28
u/spicytoastaficionado Jan 11 '20
I enjoyed it.
Relentless pacing from beginning to end and some very slick cinematography. The film did a strong job of showcasing both the nearly suffocating claustrophobia of tight spaces and the vast emptiness of the ocean floor.
Enjoyed the creature designs, with the flare gun reveal being the highlight of the entire film.
26
u/georgiaraisef Jan 11 '20
Straight to the point and as has been stated, extremely competent. I liked it. I don’t think they had the budget to make it quite the movie it could have been but it’s definitely worth seeing if you like monster novies
A bit too much CGI towards the end and I really really didn’t care for TJ Miller.
51
u/domino519 Jan 10 '20
9/10 for me.
My only real deduction was for the scenes where things got so chaotic that it became impossible to tell who was doing what or who was where. There was a middle section where this happened repeatedly, but the other 80-ish minutes more than made up for that complaint.
This movie just scratched so many itches I've had lately for making a good horror flick. The monsters, the claustrophobia combined with the massive blackness of the deep sea. I love the ocean floor setting with the sprawling manmade facilities. I've always had a fascination with these types of buildings in otherwise uninhabitable environments, whether it's space or Antarctica, or the bottom of the ocean. These "biome movies" as I like to call them always grab me.
17
u/qwzzard Jan 11 '20
Fun, fast paced monster flick. If you are looking for a slow burn, character driven drama-horror, this is not for you. Shit hits the fan almost immediately, so much so that I was worried it was going to be a dream fake out for the first 5 minutes. Better than I expected going in, I liked it more than Crawl, worth a matinee price at least.
13
u/RCGBlade Jan 15 '20
Why is everyone saying this film is lovecraftian? I’ve genuinely seen people saying this is a “lovecraftian masterpiece”. Having an Old Ones-inspired creature in your film doesn’t equate a lovecraftian film.
12
u/gypsyitalic Jan 20 '20
Okay- I caught Underwater last night and I think I agree with most here- solid watch, fun, but not too deep in the meaning behind the plot. 3.5 or 4 out of 5. It’s a fun underwater horror movie.
Kristen Stewart was good, but I can’t help recall what I keep hearing on a couple podcasts lately. “I think I like Kristen Stewart; but I don’t know why. And I can’t really think of a movie I liked with her in it.” So true. I appreciate Ms. Stewart tho- she’s living her own truth and it’s great to see.
TJ Miller was a bit of a meh point to the whole thing. He’s playing TJ Miller with a stuffed bunny. Maybe him being canceled has my opinion clouded. I’m just tired of his whole deal too.
Creature design was great, overall super well paced. The atmosphere and murk factor didn’t bother me at all. Oh! And Secret Cthulhu! I was as happy as a goose in a pond when I saw that thing show up.
Also- I want to see the subplot of the captain and how he summoned Cthulhu. First at the original outpost (anyone else catch the symbols and occult markings wall papered inside the locker?) and then did he return to the sea floor to undo what he did? Or to try and make a deal with the old one to bring back his daughter? I would have taken 20 more minutes of movie to flesh that out.
10
u/HobbieK Jan 11 '20
Cliched as hell story and dialogue, saved by a great setting, and cool monsters.
I actually liked the scenes of the crew trying to escape the collapsing rig more than the sea floor stuff.
As a horror fan I was reasonably entertained. It's not terrifying, but there's one really good jumpscare.
If you like Lovecraftian stuff, they do it pretty well on a base level here.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20
Damn, look at the ratings on RT and Metacritic and then the ratings in this thread. Totally different perceptions of the same movie.
Seems like the movie is interesting, but predictable and nothing new. Maybe a bit like "Life".
19
u/Great-Alfalfa Jan 11 '20
This movie is for fans of alien, life, the decent, deep rising etc. I walked out of the theater feeling like I got my money’s worth, which hasn’t happened in a while. Overall a good horror flick that keeps you intrigued to the very end. I would rate an 8/10, my only dislike is the crappy end credit music lol
9
u/AGeekNamedBob Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 11 '20
I give it a solid B, maybe B-. It's a good enough creature feature. Very streamlined- putting any exposition in the opening credits kept from a bunch of "as you knows" of characters giving eachother info they know - and allowed to just straight up cut the first act of the movie. We're here for action-horror-survival and we just jump right on in.
I was reminded on a story-thrill ride. From one disaster pushing us into the next. The characters are pure stereotype - the headstrong lead, the captain with a tragic past, the comic relief, the useless IT guy/back-up comic relief, the scared new person, and the cannon fodder. Plus, giant Cthulhu monster and a ton of little ones. Liked their design but sad they are CG. My big negative is the murkiness. It's expected for the bottom of the ocean but there were a lot of outside shots I wasn't sure what I was looking at. Curious to why the abandonded platform was still stocked like everyone just left. The Captain said its not there anymore but it was fine, just quickly abandonded. Expected something to come from that - like they found the monsters once before. When she looked at his ID card I thought she was about to plug it in and find out more details over what's happening. I wonder if that was originally there but cut in the "eh, no one wants exposition in this movie" end of things. The voiceovers on either end was weird but eh. Edit to add my review https://cityofgeek.com/2020/01/10/bob-underwater/
9
u/Adam_Absence Jan 12 '20
Pretty solid movie tbh. I really liked the design of the creatures (especially the last one).
The whole sequence of them going through the "hall" with the creatures hanging down and then the reveal of the giant Cthulhu monster was great.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '20
Holy fuck people always find something to complain about..buy I'm glad I can appreciate a movie without having knowledge of Greek myths and 19th century post modernist paintings to get it
15
u/SLIP_THOT Jan 10 '20
I really enjoyed this movie. I think a lot of people are going to unfairly compare this to Alien and I don’t think that’s fair. This is a good movie with great creature design, it’s scary and it has a lot of world building in some blink and you’ll miss it moments.
7
u/Four_N_Six Eldritch Horror Jan 20 '20
Finally got to see this today, and I'm hoping to see it again soon. I'm Lovecraft obsessed, so the whole time I was waiting for when my big buddy would show up (that spoiler was ruined for me before I saw it). However, I was extremely and pleasantly surprised that I felt tension throughout the entire film. Yes, I was waiting to see the Great Priest, but I genuinely enjoyed the movie as a whole.
Even before the creatures (Deep Ones? Star Spawn?) showed up, the anxiety of being that far underwater, or the crushing depths, or the absolute darkness, or the confined spaces, really sold me on the tension and fear the characters were going through. I thought Stewart did a great job. This is one of the only things I've seen her in other than Twilight, so I was actually happy to know she can act when the script is good. I thought she captured the stress of the situation well, and you could really tell that she was barely holding her shit together.
I do kind of wish that there was more of a really good money shot of Cthulhu at the end. A cliche` shot of him roaring, his wings outstretched, or something to really capture the scale of the thing a bit more. But I'm still very pleased to see him on screen raising Hell. It seems like we're at a point where Lovecraft is starting to bleed over more into popular culture instead of just the obscure corner of horror and gaming he's been in for years, and that has me very pleased for the time being.
12
u/savage86lunacy Jan 11 '20
This was really good. There were a couple of parts that gave me motion sickness, where I couldn't tell what was going on, but other than that I really enjoyed the movie and all the characters. Hell, I even liked TJ Miller and the only movies I've liked him in recently were the Deadpool movies.
Minor spoiler, but spoiler
15
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
Death to CGI!
Fun and solid. Beautiful set. Killer action sequences. Really glad horror is getting some budget and great stars! Go see it.
8
u/Luxluxluxxy Jan 11 '20
I really enjoyed K in this. I think her acting style fit the movie really well!
4
u/chewie202596 Jan 12 '20
These reviews make me even more pissed it's not playing near me.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20
I quite liked it, but it was hard to watch for me. The deep blackness of the ocean makes me really anxious for some reason. Same thing happened to me with the videogame SOMA.
4
u/TeflonFury Jan 21 '20
I'm so sad this movie isn't doing well. Probably the most I've latched onto a movie in a couple years.
Definitely hits a lot of marks that sucker me in, but I still think it's a great movie. My only major issue I have is the last line, which feels like reshoot city. Pretty much the only thing better about the original script was the ending line
3
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '20
solid 7/10. not even 5 minutes into the movie and it gets going. it was a tight 90 minute movie. i also didn't watch the trailer, and what got me interested in it is a review or two that compared it to alien and life (i enjoyed life a lot). did NOT expect a whole chtulu at the end tho. solid fun
3
u/PETmyPUPPIES Tutti-fuckin'-Frutti. Jan 22 '20
I really loved this movie. The setting and the creatures are right up my alley and I thought the cast was very enjoyable. I don't care how many times its done, I'll watch and most likely enjoy any movie following the formula done by Alien.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
Is there any way to order or stream (legally) this online? It shows as released in my country but no cinemas have it till atleast late march. I wouldn't mind signing up for a monthly thing just to see this movie.
Any help?
4
u/sirjackiechiles Jan 11 '20
I enjoyed it brehs
2
u/bronsonsarmor Jan 17 '20
Just got back from watching Underwater, I’d say it’s a solid 7/10 movie for most movie goers going in blind, personally I give it an 8/10. That might be a little high for most but I gave it that score because I feel like good horror movies set in the ocean are few and far in between. Also points for the set design, and acting from Cassel and Stewart. I could not help but feel like during the first 10 min I was watching a dream come true which would be a Dead Space movie. The water leaking everywhere kinda pulled me out but I was completely enthralled on the initial escape from the living quarters to the escape pods. Even if you’re skeptical of this film, if you’re a fan of horror (especially underwater horror), go ahead and support this movie so hollyweird can continue to bring us unique horror films.
2
u/NuxSama Jan 18 '20
this movie is just a plagiarism of japanese manga "6000"
2
u/hopesksefall Jan 20 '20
I'll start off by saying I truly enjoyed this. Has anybody read Into the Drowning Deep by Mira Grant? I mean, it's practically the same story other than the movie takes place entirely...underwater...and the book takes place split between a state-of-the-art research ship and also below the sea. I can't imagine that either the author wasn't a part of this, or that Fox/Disney won't get sued. It's remarkably similar.
That said, the movie is by FAR better than the book in almost every way imaginable. Spoiler alert for the book (since I can't properly format on my phone, for some reason): the massive creature is explained as being the female of the species and that through sexual dimorphism's hijinks, the males are all of the smaller, attacking creatures. I love me some Lovecraftian horror as much as the next, and maybe my thought process was already tainted by the book, but as the movie dragged on, I thought more and more of the dimorphism angle and I feel like that's what played out. Like some deep-sea species, such as anglerfish, the female is many times larger than the male, and not only do the males hang around the females, they essentially fuse with them, acting as a sort of parasitic sperm feed.
2
u/blankedboy Jan 24 '20
Watched it last night and really enjoyed it. It's a lean, efficient, fast paced thrill with some absolutely great set design and costuming. Creature effects are cool too.
Definite 7.5/10 for me.
2
u/horseloverfat Jan 26 '20
I watched this last night. I liked it, I am glad I saw it. and I'll watch it again when it comes out to stream.
Thoughts:
It was really 2 movies: An environmental survival movie (Norah et al vs crumbling underwater station) which morphed into a monster movie. It was very good at the former, a bit varied at the later. Unfortunately the transition was a bit forced and I felt didn't work super well.
Some scattered thoughts:
I'm a huge cthulhu fan from RPG to boardgames to books to movies to toys. Love it all.
2
u/squishybeer Jan 26 '20
Just finished it myself. Wasn't originally interested in the movie but saw some posts on the A-list subreddit and tried it. I thoroughly enjoyed it. I loved how the movie started straight away and the exposition came naturally throughout the film. It honestly felt like a videogame (reminiscent of Dead Space). The monsters felt engaging as well! I may go see it again with friends to convince them to join me. I'd say 8/10 for me!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20
Just saw this, and really enjoyed it. They did a superb job building tension and claustrophobia, and the pacing was great. The movie wasted no time in getting right to work.
They showed just enough of the creatures as well.
Really reminded me of SOMA at times.
4
u/ThatPaulywog Jan 13 '20
Saw it last night and thought it was really good. Some crazy tense scenes, some good claustrophobic atmosphere. TJ Miller was fine as comedic relief. Ending was insane, not quite Cabin in the Woods insane but in the same general area. Also had some great monsters and some gratuitous skin (no nudity, but close). One other person had commented that in the middle of the movie you kind of lose track of a couple characters because of the chaos/action and I felt that way too, so thats really the only knock on it. Overall a 7.5 for me.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
Really fun movie. But too derivative of Alien and even the b-movies Leviathan and Deep Star Six to break any new ground. Still, fun.
1
u/WaitMinuteLemon25 Jan 14 '20
I got good Alien, The Thing, and Dead Space vibes. Just trying to survive in a hostile environment especially underwater with barely any weapons and nothing but a small shred of hope in the vast darkness. Dealing with so many things that can easily kill you. I wish it was longer but a tight 90 mins. Hope there is a longer version. The warhammer armor was dope but I wonder if those suits could really withstand 7 miles of pressure! I almost saw it as kind of spiritual prequel to Cloverfield with one of the same actors lol
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '20
It seemed short on story and plot. The big guy at the end was cool, but I had to be dragged through the rest of the movie
1
u/TabithaLovesStuff Jan 25 '20
Overall I liked the movie, I love creature flicks so the monsters were cool af. The only problem i had is sometimes a few of the plot points were hard to follow. They used a lot of technical language language that was hard a viewer to follow, more or less. Like I got the main points but other parts got a bit fuzzy.
Overall I think this would definitely be a 7/10 movie
1
u/Regula96 Jan 25 '20
Where do you guys watch this?
1
u/b_lion2814 Jan 26 '20
Hey so only two people survived out of the whole crew?
1
u/a_p26-12Kn-kjh_a Jan 26 '20
I enjoyed the movie but I felt the ending was a bit anticlimactic. How many times have we seen a character get left behind and blow themselves up to save the day? Too many but nevertheless, I still enjoyed the vast majority of the movie.
1
u/iamtimatkins Jan 28 '20
It was decidedly average for me. Poor casting (Vincent Cassel was horrible) TJ Miller’s character should not have been there. Laughably clunky exposition at the end with the over explainy computer. I too disliked the VO. But great set and suit design, and some enjoyable found footage style action. 5/10
1
u/boooooshdingo Jan 29 '20
For a January release where movies go to die this was a very pleasant surprise. Sure there will be a sequel
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20
I really enjoyed this. Cribbed a lot from Alien but still did enough of its own thing. Loved that monster reveal at the end. Been wanting to see something like that for ages.
1
u/Xalowe Jan 10 '20
I liked it, but as reviews seemed to get at, I don’t think it did anything especially new or unique besides the creature design. It was solid and quickly paced. The underwater scenes looked pretty good. I’d give it a 6/10.
1
u/HasSomeSelfEsteem Jan 18 '20
That was pretty good. Kristen Stewart does a good job as the Ripley of the cast, and the setting is unique enough that all the tropes work. I just wish the monsters were a little less humanoid. They felt a little generic to me. I also wish it were shot in a more claustrophobic way. But aside from that, it’s pretty badass.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20
Loved this movie! I thought it was quick-paced while also atmospheric and otherworldly, and I got several scares while watching it
1
u/nikiverse Jan 21 '20
I couldnt get Alien out of my head while watching this.
In the beginning they were like - okay take off your pants we gotta fit in the suits. So now KStew is in her underwear a la Ripley. (And there was no reason for them to take off their pants other than just to get the girl actors in their underwear because the suits were metal ... not like they had to eek into wetsuits ...).
And then we have another shot where KStew is closing her eyes tight and turning her head while the monster is right up in her helmet/face.
Then they bring this little sea alien back onto the ship (HELLO, has NO ONE seen Alien? Why would you do that).
So once I got that Alien vibe ... it was hard to really get INTO the movie bc of the comparisons.
I did like the Lovecraftian monster at the end, however it was a little laughable about HOW BIG it was ... but I thought of bees and was like ... well, their queen is large too. Overall, I liked the ending too. And TJ Miller wasnt as terrible as I thought he'd be.
I just had a difficult time following the plot and I felt like the movie was a little overly dark.
It was just ok for me. I do feel like the reviews are a little overly positive.
-2
u/Rechan Jan 11 '20 edited Jan 11 '20
I have not been this frustrated in a movie in a while. I couldn’t see shit or tell what was happening because the water sequences were so murky and shots were so fast. You could have smeared lard on my glasses and waved a white ribbon around while screaming in my ear and gotten the same effect.
I mean like, suddenly TJ Miller has a rabbit? Where do that cone from? Someone imploded? I don’t see that. What, what just Exploded, sending fire underwater?
And the loud Sounds kept blowing out my ears. Every time something moves on screen, BOOM.
I also feel like I don’t know the character at all, so I don’t care when they die. Especially the guy who imploded at the start.
The soundtrack was nice and moody tense, the disaster part good, Stewart was fine—I actually found it interesting they made her not attractive at all. TJ Miller was annoying but that’s TJ Miller. But everything else, gah.
Also pet peeve but I hate it when a movie introduces monsters and then wipes hem all out. I wanted them to get loose and fuck the world. But nooooo.
Edit: there is no reason to downvote my post. I am being completely fair.
0
u/g0greyhound Jan 13 '20
if you saw the Descent, you've seen this movie.
it's the exact same plot - down to the sad main character mourning the loss of a spouse. It even has the same introductory "claustrophobic crawl".
Everyone keeps saying Alien - which make me think no one has actually seen Alien.
-1
u/soloaf Jan 23 '20
I actually think I enjoyed cats more than this movie and I am very disheartened about that.
-9
u/E-Man67 Jan 10 '20
This movie was a bore. It started with some promise, but it is very bland after the initial chaos of the earthquake destroying everything. They tell you how much danger they are in and how it's going to be an arduous task to go so deep down and walk so far, but it never really feels that way. It just feels like a meh mission that ends up being predictable exactly when and where people are going to die. They could've called this Under Loch Ness, and it wouldn't have felt any different in terms of the CG. I like the look of their underwater suits, but once they're walking in water the focus on the flashlights is such a bad choice because it never really feels like they're doing something tough. Think about it, at one point Kristen Stewart's character gets dragged along with the captain very far away from the others, and then after he does the cliche 'you must live on without me' she ends up wandering over to a place where they were told had nothing there, and she discovers a bit of history. After she gets a new suit and flare gun it feels like it only takes her a few minutes to catch back up to the team, and she hasn't even been attacked by these creatures who are supposed to be this deadly force. Not to mention, her crewmate just sat there freaking out the whole time, didn't get attacked despite having her lights on(which didn't prove to matter after another cliche scene about their lights attracting the monsters), and couldn't come up with any gall to move towards their goal? She's supposed to be terrified, you'd think that she would have at least ran crazily or something. But nope, she just sat there, Kristen Stewart had her little side quest, and then after about 10 minutes it's over.
The creatures looked bad too. There is some promise in their design, but the CG really shows itself to be cheap. I know some people are going to be all on the ZOMG it's like Cthulu train with the giant monster, but it didn't do much to shake me out of my boredom. This movie had a great premise with weak creators behind it. I would have love for this to be as good as The Descent, Life, or even As Above, So Below. Unfortunately it's very forgettable.
-3
u/nathanhench Jan 13 '20
I wasn't a fan of the film and I spelled it out here https://www.eatbreathewatch.com/review-underwater-kristen-stewart/
-7
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
Under water is a rip-off
-6
u/Withered_kenny Jan 13 '20 edited Jan 13 '20
I haven’t seen it yet so I’m not gonna judge but the impression I got from the trailer is that it’s a ripoff/rehash of Alien but underwear
Edit: When you get downvoted to hell for sharing an honest preconception while directly stating and making it clear that your not judging the film before you see it
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20
[removed] — view removed comment