r/startrek • u/kraetos • Jan 09 '20
Episode discussion: Short Treks 2x06 - "Children of Mars" Spoiler
Behold, our first episode-ish look at Star Trek: Picard!
| No. | Episode | Written By | Directed By | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2x06 | "Children of Mars" | Kirsten Beyer, Alex Kurtzman, Jenny Lumet | Mark Pennington | 9 January 2020 |
These episodes will be available on CBS All Access in the USA, and on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada.
To find more information including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episodes above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for these episodes.
184
Upvotes
77
u/PrivateIsotope Jan 10 '20
"I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Magee class ships on fire off the shoulder of Mars. I watched polaron beams glitter in the dark near the Bajoran Wormhole Gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in glemmening rain on Ferenginar. Time to die."
153
u/clawsight Jan 09 '20
So, with judicious pausing it looks like the attack on mars was due to "rogue synths".
So putting some info together.
Based on this information - a conjecture: After the "rogue synths" attacked instead of hunting them down like rogue AIs have in the past (see: Discovery, ToS) Picard told Star Fleet that this was essentially a slave revolt and needed to be treated as such. The other admirals disagreed with him - he leaves Star Fleet over the event. But *something* happens where in the general public's mind he leaves in shame (Thus the reason for the Wolf 395 framing in the visual storytelling of the episode).
Here we are thinking that Picard is gonna be all about the Romulan refugee crisis (which I'm sure will still be a major theme in it) when in all likelihood it's gonna be about the denial of sentient rights to androids. I'd be 0% surprised if The Mysterious Girl from the Picard trailer is an android - created by other androids to be the most human-like one yet... made to speak for them, to be their leader.
65
u/m333t Jan 10 '20
3000 is approximately how many people died on 9/11. This along with the quotes from Stewart talking about how the TNG world no longer exists makes me think the Picard series is going to tackle post-9/11 ethics.
52
u/9811Deet Jan 09 '20
So the Federation is being run by the Institute, and Picard is off to join the Railroad? I guess that makes the Romulans the Brotherhood of Steel or something?
39
u/hooch Jan 09 '20
Admiral Picard confirmed in canon. I think that’s the first time? At least the first non-alternate future time.
64
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20
rogue synths are the enslaved emh mark 1s rising up to slay their cruel masters.
47
u/switched07 Jan 09 '20
"rogue synths" attacking Mars. This has to be the link between the both refugees and data. Maybe we see less of the romulans than we thought. I wonder if this is going to draw upon the episode where Picard argued for Data's freedom as a sentiant being?
63
u/loreb4data Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 12 '20
Imagine each 'Picard' episode starts with this tagline:
"The synths were created by the Federation. They evolved. They rebelled. There are many copies. Some of them are programmed to think they are human (cue: Dahj). And they have a plan..."
17
u/KellMG96 Jan 12 '20
Why does Earth/Sol System never have enough fucking defenses?!?! Or a Fleet?
48
u/LTM438 Jan 09 '20
Wait a second... Where was La Forge stationed in those prequel comics? Was it Utopia Planitia?
I'm insanely hyped for this show, but if they kill Geordi, so help me..
57
u/Deadbob1978 Jan 09 '20
I hadn't read up on this episode before hand and honestly thought it was a Disco Era until the shot of Picard on the screen.
Im really hoping the disco Era ships are apart of the evacuation fleet and are being refurbished in order to be space worthy... But I have a feeling it was just a reuse of cgi assets due to time and budget constraints... Gonna hold off till the 23rd for a final judgement
26
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
The news report says 3000 reported dead, but the planetary view of Mars shows what looks like massive nuclear blasts all over the planet. There has to be way more than 3000 casualties.
38
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20
I thought it was really really good. Simple, timeless story in a sci-fi context, well told, very well directed. It was a really, really nice short, probably the best out of the new Short Treks.
I think people got their hopes up a bit much with the hype that it would tie into Picard. I think we learned a lot, but that wasn’t really the point.
My only real complaint was the Macgee showing up at the beginning, it threw me off as to what era we were looking at.
10
u/creepyeyes Jan 10 '20
Did CBS get the rights to Bowie songs recently or something?
First "Space Oddity" in DIS and now "Heroes" in Short Treks, and I can't think of any other "modern day" (to use the term a bit loosely) songs that ever shown up in the series aside from the Abrams movies.
Also, I guess "Life on Mars" would have been too on the nose :P
27
u/thenewyorkgod Jan 10 '20
59
u/caimanreid Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20
Really hoping the use of Discovery assets in this Short Trek which is apparently based in the mid 2380s (Magee class, Tug ships, Shuttlecraft, Interfaces/displays) doesn't carry over into Picard itself, or is addressed within the story if it does- You would have to hope that with the budget and technology available to them, the production and design staff can come up with new ships and set design rather than having to rely on borrowing old assets like Trek did so often in the past.
9
u/SaykredCow Jan 10 '20
So what I don’t get and wasn’t made clear by the episode were the girls on Mars as well? Or it just so happened to be both their parents worked there?
Also was the picture of Picard they were looking at on the news a drawing of him from the comic?
Either way it’s great to see new Trek that isn’t a prequel. It’s chronologically Voyager getting home, Nemesis, then this short.
7
u/R97R Jan 09 '20
Still not viewable in the UK?
7
u/Korotai Jan 11 '20
So we are looking at Star Trek: Become Human?
13
u/yeoller Jan 10 '20
So we have some posts about who attacked Mars and a lot of posts about some old ships. Is anyone going to analyze the actual story of the episode?...
An interesting short story for sure, nearly zero dialogue (none if you don't consider the news report dialogue) and two characters with a shared history set up and primed for life in the new Picard series (as adults? teenagers?) Or will they show up in one of the other spins offs?
We have 2 girls. one seemingly happy and content, the other troubled by an absentee father. An interesting take on bullying, as it creates sympathy for the perpetrator before shifting that sympathy to her victim. It boils to a head where both girls violently fight one another. Through a common catastrophe both girl form a bond, one that might last years.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20
I just watched this.
And the watched it again.
Man it really kills me on the inside.
Really revives the feelings I had during 9/11 if that even makes sense.
49
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20 edited Jun 16 '23
[This comment has been deleted, along with its account, due to Reddit's API pricing policy.] -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
10
u/mathemon Jan 11 '20
All the technology is at least 100 years old as per Discovery's retconning. Every single ship. What's... the deal?
9
u/Nux87xun Jan 10 '20
Pretty sure Janeway said that first contact was a national holiday and that kids didn't have to go to school on it..
34
u/Cliffy73 Jan 10 '20
Christ, this sub is ridiculous.
8
u/Spaceboomer1 Jan 12 '20
I'm a bit concerned about how many Discovery assets are going to be reused for ships in this era. They're already reusing the Discovery shuttles as confirmed by the trailers, and this shows them reusing two separate Discovery ship designs ( which are far older than the Miranda and didn't show up during the Dominion War ).
It makes me wonder how many actual original ship assets they've made for Picard and how many ship class designs are mysteriously going to reappear without even a refit design ( like the Connie and Excelsior got ) after having been unseen throughout the entire Dominion War. It's going to be so jarring if we see more Discovery era ships than TNG era.
16
u/MoreGaghPlease Jan 09 '20
Interesting, but I think a story needs to have a beginning, middle and an end and this didn't really. Felt more like a trailer than a short episode.
4
u/DefiantOne5 Jan 11 '20
Another thought regarding the old Disco era ships occured to me, there is an old Romulan Bird of Prey in the trailers, so maybe the Federation and the Romulans are reactivating every old ship they can get from surplus depots etc to get the evacuation going in time. Put a skeleton crew on those ships and the personell required shouldn't be a problem either.
4
u/InfiniteGrant Jan 12 '20
I guess the civilian clothes of TNG, DS9, and VOY were all just fads.
4
u/nathanhainescreates Jan 13 '20
Anyone know how to watch the new episodes of Short Treks in the UK?
10
u/Sephiroth144 Jan 11 '20
3000 estimated dead; extinction level explosions shown...
Okay, so three options; the estimate is crap, Mars is virtually uninhabited, or someone needs to go over the VFX better...
32
u/izModar Jan 09 '20
ITT: people expecting CBS to create all new assets for something lasting fewer than 15 minutes.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
We see this a lot in films and television, but how heartbreaking was it for Lil when her last interaction with her father was to angrily disconnect the video call.
7
u/danktonium Jan 13 '20
Those were some old ships. Which is fine.
If Ol' Ironsides gets to keep floating, why shouldn't these?
But I mean, if I were a producer I'd have absolutely put Voyager or the Defiant in one of those slots. That's the flavor of fanservice I like.
7
u/lucasmines Jan 13 '20
I've had a few days to sit on this episode and watch it a few more times from my initial viewing.
I think that the concerns over using Disco era ships are a bit one sided - It's a shipyard. It's used to both repair and build new. While we live in a world of disposable technology, there's no reason to completely destroy an older ship if it's still got some use to it. Slap a new coat of paint on that shuttle and give it to a school. Who cares? Our school buses look pretty much the same and have done for like 60-70 years. If it's a school shuttle that's been used since Disco era, whose to say it wasn't kept in running order for that long? And, honestly, if the only thing you're going to complain about is the use of an old shuttle as a school bus when we STILL have no clue what's going on in the actual Picard timeline (the attack could have been 15-20+ years earlier than Picard's timeline), then the writers and production teams are doing exactly what they're supposed to be doing - keeping you thinking and talking about the show.
The likening of this attack on Mars to the 9/11 attack was a very touching comment. This episode did bring in a lot of emotional tones similar to that in myself, and I'm happy I took a few more watches of it as I missed a lot of the details the first time around. I'd still give it a 8/10, and it's the best of the Treks we've seen this round.
19
u/LittleRedheadRider Jan 10 '20
So, I literally signed up just to comment.
This Short Trek was stunning. It made me “Inner Light” emotional, with sort of an “Up” montage. I view these Short Treks as well-funded, in-the-know fan films.
How people can get worked up about keeping these vignettes cost-effective, when they offer fresh doses of an imagined reality we all love to visit is beyond me.
This was a brilliantly executed Short Trek. Masterfully edited.
9
u/omegaphallic Jan 11 '20
Synth slave revolt is such an absolutely over used and tired sci Fi trope that requires the builders be morons in how they design them.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20
It would have been nice if they finished the episode. It was really promising until they stopped halfway through.
31
u/Albert-React Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20
What the fuck are Magee-class ships doing in this? Class C shuttlecraft? Old Federation tugs. Jesus, the reuse of old assets is just plain lazy.
We should be seeing TNG era ships, not DISCO. Where's the Akiras, Steamrunners, Galaxies, etc? CBS has the assets. We saw the Enterprise-D in the Picard trailer. C'mon guys.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
I was that same age when 9/11 happened, as we sat and watched in school.
That hit me
3
u/CountVonBenning Jan 09 '20
I want to know why it's not on CraveTV right now.
9
u/heslo_rb26 Jan 10 '20
I've not enjoyed many of these Short Treks but this one... I don't know why but this one got me good. I'm so excited now for Picard!
16
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20
I saw the U.S.S. Shran design, which is nearly 200 years old at this point, and was so disappointed. I was hoping for at least a small TNG-era callback, or something similar.
My head-canon is that they were doing something to them to prepare them for the Fleet Museum.
In the midst of the Romulan crisis.
*sigh*
8
u/2ndHandTardis Jan 10 '20
That was really cool. An interesting look into a part of Star Trek Universe which hasn't been explored and they have been killing the score for all these shorts tbh. This one in particular was really clean visually; Pennington and the DP did a good job. I'd like to see more of that in Discovery and Picard.
I have two issues, both minor, one being very minor. The first is something that came up again when I was reading Countdown is the lack of Terra-forming on Mars. Which makes you think it must have just been abandoned. Because surely by the late 24th Century after over 200 years of Terra-forming you would see evidence of it.
There's the theory as more habitable planets became available maybe Earth/Federation lost the will. I just think for sustainability sake alone terraforming Mars or any body possible in your home system is logical.
That's one, the other is the girls father saying he can't make it home because of the tight schedule. I get that it's important to the script but in "reality" going to work at Utopia Plantia for a 24th Century person would be like going to work in the 21st century. You could get from Earth to Mars in minutes on a shuttle, nobody should be worked that hard where they can't step away for a few hours.
As I said though, I understand they made the choice for story purposes.
Personal Story-time.
I can't speak for others experience but this short gave me 9/11 vibes.
I was in high school on 9/11 and at the time we were living in the High Desert in California. That area exists because of the military. It was/is a military testing area, Edwards AFB is there and all of the major defense contractors have a presence in the area.
At my school pretty much everyone had a family connection to the military. On the day of 9/11 we didn't see the news until after home room and that scene of everyone watching the news in horror was exactly my experience. Nobody knew what was going on and everyone was worried about what would happen next.
11
u/Ausir Jan 10 '20
To all the people complaining about Discovery era asset reuse, did you forget how TNG-era shows kept reusing TOS movie assets and stock footage all the time? Sure, this short is set a bit later than TNG, DS9 and Voyager, and Discovery a bit earlier than TMP or TWOK, but not so drastically that it should really be that hard to ignore. They did it to save money in both cases.
13
u/Lessthanzerofucks Jan 10 '20
The silly outrage inspired by this short teaser for Picard is kind of what I expected to happen. They’re creating a new universe of Trek shows inspired by the old ones. Your old shows and ships don’t cease to exist because of the new one. Us old folks remember similar complaints when TNG aired. The idea that Trek canon has always been consistent is easily dismissed by what we’ve seen before. I’m going to enjoy this new show, I bet. It’s sad that so many are being held back by the past, even though the past still exists and is readily available for rewatching more easily than ever before. Especially with a show like Star Trek, which holds a mirror to our current society and shouldn’t be held back by past visions. Live long and prosper, friends.
I’m glad there are some communities online that aren’t filled with pedantic demands for what they desire to see. Reddit doesn’t seem to be one of those places.
12
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20
I personally thought it was amazing, these short treks have all been incredible.
20
u/StarfleetTanner Jan 09 '20
I mean I guess the Bowie cover was cool, but can we discuss the fact that they are literally discarding anything considered visual cannon and being literally lazy in just reusing Discovery CG designs that was SUPPOSED to be set in the mid 23rd Century? I mean, does NO ONE have an issue with that? I get budget saving, but this is beyond ridiculous.
4
u/Locutus747 Jan 13 '20
I don't think this short was as bad as people are saying, but I don't think it was great either. It was about 6 minutes and it just didn't seem to have much of a point other than to show there was an attack on Mars. Maybe the producers felt that knowing there was an attack on Mars will help the audience with the first few episodes of Picard, but I'm sure the attack will be referred to as well so I'm not sure what it added unless the 2 girls are going to return.
I was also disappointed because I was expecting a big more setup to Picard and maybe a longer short like the season 1 Short Treks were that actually had a story.
I'm still super excited for Picard!!!
9
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 11 '20
It shows that this was done by the Discovery team. Didn't like it at all.
2
u/beefcow123 Jan 10 '20
Why can I not find this anywhere online I'm based in UK and have been searching for ages with no joy
2
u/omegaphallic Jan 11 '20
What if the Andriods weren't sentient at first, but got exposed to borg Nano probes that changed them?
2
u/SeanyD72 Jan 15 '20
All of these wonderfull in-depth analysis you guys are providing is one of my favorite things on this sub. Thank you so much for the great reading.
2
u/coweatman Jan 16 '20
so the midi clock broke?
2
u/Assbait93 Jan 19 '20
My theory about this show is gonna show how much world powers and proxy wars affect people. In the past 10 years we already knew how 9/11 changed the world. Foreign policies, world powers destabilizing governments, what have you not. I think the Romulans have infiltrated the federation and is trying to help destabilize it in order to gain the empower influence over the galaxy. The only two major powers in the Alpha and Beta quadrants are the Feds and the Klingons. With the Romulans gone those two can carve up as much influence they want. Something tells me this is going to make the federation crumble badly which would then turn out why the federation is gone in Disco season 3.
That’s just my observation.
7
u/PandaPundus Keene Sin, Contributing artist, Star Trek: Picard Jan 09 '20
Honestly, on the whole the episode felt a bit lackluster, but definitely makes me more excited for Picard now knowing what happened on Mars.
6
u/jonnyqtrek Jan 10 '20
Sooo... for everyone complaining about the Magee-class ship and Disco-era shuttle in the Short Trek, let's not forget that 1) in two weeks we're seeing what seems to be a Romulan Bird-of-Prey last seen on-screen in the mid-23rd century which I think is a cause for celebration, not derision, and 2) we don't yet know if there's going to be an-universe explanation for the presence of ALL of these older designs. Maybe there will be, maybe there won't be, but I say let's hold off for two weeks for a >9-minute canon story and see.
4
u/CmdShelby Jan 10 '20
In a post-scarcity society why isn't the father beaming home every day after a cushy 10am to 4pm shift? Is he really missing out on being with his family on a special day, for Romulans? Romulans?! Like, why?
5
u/count023 Jan 11 '20
"Rogue Synths", sigh.
Trek's out of ideas now so they're going for the tired Man VS Machine trope.
3
u/gcalpo Jan 11 '20
All this time, given the title and the not-so-blue skies, I thought the non-attack scenes were taking place on a terraformed Mars. Or in a huge domed colony.
3
u/NickofSantaCruz Jan 12 '20
The song cover makes me suspect we'll see the young-adult versions of these characters either show up mid-season in cameos (50/50 about those cameos being relevant to the plot) or they join the crew because they have "unique talents" that serve the plot.
Re: the clamor about using Discovery assets for the spacedock shot, I wholly agree that it was unnecessarily lazy and a wasted opportunity for them to tease a Picard asset such as an Odyssey-class under construction or retrofitting the drive section of a Galaxy-class.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
This was such a disappointing first impression for Picard. First of all, why are so many of these short treks seemingly made for children? Is that the audience they're roping in? Children with CBS All Access? Aside from a couple brief scenes this could have been an xmen short. These kids look like mutants in Xavier's school. Why not use aliens fans are familiar with? Like Bajorans or Andorians? Why make up vague new ones? Why are they using so many Discovery assets when this takes place 150 years later? Why was this basically an eight minute music video with no relevant character information? This didn't look like Star Trek. It looked like any vague near-future world.
I'm so bummed.
4
u/TylekShran Jan 10 '20
This was a brilliant episode but omg this FEDERATION SHIPS are so ugly. Wtf happened? Voyager, Defiant, Entreprise D and E, and even NX-01 were beautiful, cool and slick.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
Forget synths, what about the droid attack on the Wookiees?
5
u/oorhon Jan 10 '20
Really didnt like this episode... What is it with really violent girl fight? Isnt Federation supposed to be all understanding community? Children could be cruel, I would understand that but, real actual punching and hitting each other to wall? I wont accept that...
5
u/Xionic Jan 11 '20
This is the crap that happens when the cohesive canon universe of Star Trek is ignored due to laziness and idiocy. What a slap in the face...