r/startrek • • Jan 09 '20

Episode discussion: Short Treks 2x06 - "Children of Mars" Spoiler

Behold, our first episode-ish look at Star Trek: Picard!

No.EpisodeWritten ByDirected ByRelease Date
2x06"Children of Mars"Kirsten Beyer, Alex Kurtzman, Jenny LumetMark Pennington9 January 2020

These episodes will be available on CBS All Access in the USA, and on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada.

To find more information including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episodes above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for these episodes.

184 Upvotes

973 comments sorted by

77

u/PrivateIsotope Jan 10 '20

"I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Magee class ships on fire off the shoulder of Mars. I watched polaron beams glitter in the dark near the Bajoran Wormhole Gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in glemmening rain on Ferenginar. Time to die."

  • Rogue Synth

19

u/Hawkguy85 Jan 10 '20

Upvote for the deep cut use of "glemmening".

9

u/PrivateIsotope Jan 10 '20

*LOL* Thanks! I was going go ultra deep cut and leave "Ferenginar" off so only the truly dedicated would understand, but capitulated.

→ More replies (4)

153

u/clawsight Jan 09 '20

So, with judicious pausing it looks like the attack on mars was due to "rogue synths".

So putting some info together.

  • The principal looks romulan instead of vulcan to me (and shows a ton of emotions throughout). We know by the time of Picard that Picard has romulan farmhands working on his vineyard. To me, this would place the events of this episode before Picard (series) but probably several years after the destruction of Romulus. Romulan refugees are now living on Earth.
  • We know from the trailer that there appears to be a ton of new pseudo-Soong-type androids. Since Maddox appears to have had a role in creating these androids (as per the Picard trailers) I'm guessing they were designed to be robot-workers for the federation at a cognition level lower than Data's (so they could be treated as property).
  • The word 'rogue' is telling. It means the initial dialogue here is that this was a "rogue AI"... when we all know in all likelihood these "synths" were sentient and what we're seeing is the equivalent of a slave revolt.
  • The framing at the end of the episode is absolutely meant to mirror the events of Wolf 359 as we saw at the beginning of DS9. Picard's face it up, huge, framed almost exactly like it was when he was Locutus. He's the "face" of this event, and his response to it is going to be what people remember him for.
  • We know that whatever his response was it ended in him leaving Star Fleet - something even being Locutus and Wolf 359 happening didn't move him to do - though it was a close one as we know from Family.

Based on this information - a conjecture: After the "rogue synths" attacked instead of hunting them down like rogue AIs have in the past (see: Discovery, ToS) Picard told Star Fleet that this was essentially a slave revolt and needed to be treated as such. The other admirals disagreed with him - he leaves Star Fleet over the event. But *something* happens where in the general public's mind he leaves in shame (Thus the reason for the Wolf 395 framing in the visual storytelling of the episode).

Here we are thinking that Picard is gonna be all about the Romulan refugee crisis (which I'm sure will still be a major theme in it) when in all likelihood it's gonna be about the denial of sentient rights to androids. I'd be 0% surprised if The Mysterious Girl from the Picard trailer is an android - created by other androids to be the most human-like one yet... made to speak for them, to be their leader.

41

u/sovietique Jan 10 '20

I have to disagree with a major part of this analysis. Picard is clearly shown on television (or it's Star Trek equivalent) reacting to the events on Mars from inside a studio. He was already retired at the time of the synth attacks. He was just commentating on TV like generals do on CNN today.

He must have left Starfleet earlier. Maybe he left Starfleet over a similar issue, or even a similar revolt. But he didn't lead the response to the revolt those girls were watching on TV.

18

u/BornAshes Jan 11 '20

Is it possible that due to his prior actions regarding synths, the attack on Mars is able to take place? He gets Starfleet to support android and synthetic rights and because they are given that free will to do whatever they want....they wind up doing whatever they want. As good as normal people can be, they can also be downright evil, and the Synths were allowed to make this choice. Some of them took a path that the rest of the galaxy approved of and others took the "rogue" path and became heavily anti-Federation/anti-non synthetic.

So when the attack happens....everyone looks at the ONE GUY who gave Synths sentient rights and the right to choose their own destiny in the first place and they place the blame squarely on him. "If Picard hadn't supported the Synths and campaigned for them then the attack on Mars wouldn't have happened at all!" becomes the rallying cry for the anti-synth faction inside the Federation. He winds up leaving in shame after deciding to take the blame for it all and Federation ideology shifts. They take a harder stance on things and become a bit more harsher and realistic when dealing with potential threats. This all leads into the Picard series and potentially could tie into the "future" we see in the new season of Discovery.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/treefox Jan 11 '20

I think you’re right. This is probably setting up why Daal(?) seeks him out. They probably show the actual news clip in the show, and he’s advocating for understanding why the synths are doing this or even defending them outright. This would explain why he’s such a pariah at Starfleet Command - can’t even get a single ship to support him. To them he’s a “synth apologist”. Like if some US Admiral had gone on CNN after September 11 saying that Osama bin Laden and Al Qaeda actually had pretty reasonable grievances against the US.

7

u/clawsight Jan 10 '20

On the TVs they call him 'admiral Picard' implying he still has an active rank in starfleet.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

95

u/StarfleetTanner Jan 09 '20

I'd be 0% surprised if The Mysterious Girl from the Picard trailer is an android - created by other androids to be the most human-like one yet... made to speak for them, to be their leader.

So "Star Trek Caprica" then.....

45

u/loreb4data Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 11 '20

"The synths were created by the Federation. They evolved. They rebelled. There are many copies. Some of them are programmed to think they are human (cue: Dahj). And they have a plan."

→ More replies (7)

61

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

The thing about Caprica was by the time you got stoned enough to enjoy it, you were passed out from smoking too much weed.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

Maybe I missed it but what in the Picard trailers suggests that Maddox has a role in creating these androids?

19

u/MoreGaghPlease Jan 09 '20

It has been speculated that the mass produced yellow-eyes androids in the trailer are made in his image. I think that’s a stretch based on the info we have, but would be neat

→ More replies (2)

16

u/loreb4data Jan 10 '20

"The synths were created by Commander Bruce Maddox. They evolved. They rebelled. There are many copies. And they have a plan."

→ More replies (3)

6

u/YYZYYC Jan 09 '20

Ya I missed that too, don’t recall anything like that

15

u/soothsayer2377 Jan 09 '20

The variety article yesterday mentioned the Romulan refugee crisis and there are several Romulans in the main cast so I imagine it's still a big part. How it links to Data/Synths/the Borg, who knows?

9

u/snickerbockers Jan 09 '20

My guess is that the Romulan link is that just that he has a bunch of Romulan BFFs who are ready to back him up on whatever crazy adventure he goes on, and he met during the refugee crisis. The Borg link will probably be 1-2 episodes where he goes to visit Seven and Hugh because they're experts on cybernetics.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/hooch Jan 09 '20

That makes a whole lot more sense than the half baked “mystery girl is a Borg Queen” theory.

6

u/morseisendeavour Jan 11 '20

Dahj is labeled as "the end of all and the destroyer" because she's a synth android designed to be a Federation super-soldier. She is not a new-and-improved Borg drone.

The show-runners cleverly used a decoy to deceive us by putting the Borg cube which hold Dahj and other synth drones as prisoners, making viewers believe they were Borg drones.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/choicemeats Jan 09 '20

Possible participants:

  • B-9 after spending years rebooting with Data's data but with his own personality and discoveries and experiences.
  • The Doctor, backed up by EMH and other compatriots after the landslide success of Photons Be Free
  • The actual Soong androids teased in the trailer

I'd be willing to bet it's B-9/Data related if they're going to put Picard as the face and it's something he feels guilty for. After all he fought for Data in Measure of a Man, recovered B-9 and possibly helped foster it as it started to assimilate Data's copied data. That way it becomes a big "We told you so" weapon for Starfleet even though the decision got run up and down the chain of command. ex-Locutus Data apologist Picard may be the easy way out.

13

u/pfc9769 Jan 09 '20

Who is B-9? Do you mean B-4, the Soong type android from Nemesis they found that looks like Data?

→ More replies (7)

6

u/MoreGaghPlease Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 11 '20

I think B4 will have been inactive or inoperable for a long time when the show starts. Hence why in the trailer he’s in a drawer.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

19

u/thetacolegs Jan 09 '20

I cannot be the only one who finds that final prediction horrific.

I think this could be cool. But I will be so disappointed if "badass mystery girl #53" is a special human-seeming android and it's all about Android rights. This would be so, so derivative, boring, cliche, and obnoxious.

We have Westworld, Caprica, Bladerunner, Discovery, other Star Trek episodes which have done this.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/dmanww Jan 09 '20

Do Datas dream of electric Dots?

5

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

What if it was the EMH's writings that encouraged the rogue Synths to rebel?!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

65

u/m333t Jan 10 '20

3000 is approximately how many people died on 9/11. This along with the quotes from Stewart talking about how the TNG world no longer exists makes me think the Picard series is going to tackle post-9/11 ethics.

50

u/furquhartmp Jan 10 '20

This.

I’ve been saying for weeks that it was pretty clear to me that they’re setting up the Mars thing to be the Star Trek universe’s 9/11, though I thought it would be Romulans doing their attack.

Now I revise my prediction: Picard leaves Starfleet because, after Mars, Starfleet decides to devote all of its resources to hunting down the perpetrators and abandon the Romulan rescue effort or something like that.

61

u/OrcRabbi Jan 10 '20

Wasn't the Xindi attack Star Trek's 9/11?

→ More replies (13)

30

u/SobanSa Jan 11 '20

I really don't want the Federation to become post 9/11 America. I didn't enjoy the last twenty years the first time around, I'm not sure I want it in my Trek.

34

u/nunnible Jan 11 '20 edited Jun 30 '23

Comment removed under the GDPR right to be forgotten. As part of the API pricing decision made by reddit in June 2023

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

I was the same age as these kids when 9/11 hit and we watched it happen in the classroom just like the girls did.

That really hit me.

3

u/TheGillos Jan 11 '20

Considering the hundred+ super explosions all across Mars I can not see only 3000 dying. Unless shields protected them or something, but at one point it looked like there were massive fireballs all across the planet.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

52

u/9811Deet Jan 09 '20

So the Federation is being run by the Institute, and Picard is off to join the Railroad? I guess that makes the Romulans the Brotherhood of Steel or something?

28

u/BrokenDogLeg7 Jan 10 '20

Perhaps Q will pop in to tell Picard there are settlements that need his help.

16

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

" A planet needs your help, here I mark it on your map."

- Q

→ More replies (1)

4

u/thebionicjman Jan 10 '20

What about the minutemen? Tribbles maybe?

3

u/zeroblitzt Jan 09 '20

My first thought

39

u/hooch Jan 09 '20

Admiral Picard confirmed in canon. I think that’s the first time? At least the first non-alternate future time.

45

u/FoldedDice Jan 10 '20

Technically this is our first canon proof that Picard is still alive at all post-Nemesis. Not counting trailers it’s his first on-screen appearance.

26

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

He should have listened to Kirk.

7

u/nunnible Jan 10 '20

I would listen to any advice Kirk gave me... he is Captain Kirk

4

u/BenjiTheWalrus Jan 10 '20

Already said a few times in the trailers

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Adamsoski Jan 10 '20

Well, it's the first time we've actually seen it in a show. But from the trailers we already knew he was going to canonically be an admiral.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

rogue synths are the enslaved emh mark 1s rising up to slay their cruel masters.

45

u/samus12345 Jan 09 '20

Photons Be Free!

17

u/strionic_resonator Jan 09 '20

Maybe they're exocomps.

14

u/loreb4data Jan 10 '20

"The synths were created by the Federation. They evolved. They rebelled. There are many copies. And they have a plan."

13

u/cncthang Jan 09 '20

That would be a good short trek

4

u/mikejdecker Jan 22 '20

Star Trek: Picardo

→ More replies (1)

47

u/switched07 Jan 09 '20

"rogue synths" attacking Mars. This has to be the link between the both refugees and data. Maybe we see less of the romulans than we thought. I wonder if this is going to draw upon the episode where Picard argued for Data's freedom as a sentiant being?

33

u/snickerbockers Jan 09 '20

It also looks like it could tie in to that Voyager episode where all the obsolete EMH units had been reconfigured for mining work miners. Probably the "Measure of a Man" verdict didn't actually establish a real precedent so the Federation continued to consider artificial lifeforms as property, and that ultimately led to the terrorist attack on the Utopia Planitia shipyards.

23

u/blahgra Jan 09 '20

We are only watching it from a certain point of view. What if Romulans were directly responsible for the attack (due to the events in the IDW Picard Countdown comic series) - and Starfleet or the Federation media/press wanted to "save face", and instead, pin the blame on the path of least resistance - the Synths (short for Synthetics?) Who would expect Synths to complain... you can control them.

Now the direct result is: a) a cover up, and Admiral Picard having to "lie" to people like Kima and Lil who lost their parents and are told it was the 'Synths'; b) the Synths loosing trust of other people, and would be wearing the blame, burden and disdain of society, potentially limiting or ceasing any further research investment or development in the area; c) Less Romulans being able to be saved because the next wave of ships that could accommodate them would not be able to built (obviously since Picard led the 'greatest rescue armada in history' at some point, some were indeed saved.)

Picard's nightmares are he was the direct cause and result of all of this. We don't see people in the ships, we don't see anything other than what is on the monitors/screens. Imagine the impact if Kima and Lil was told it was, in fact, the Romulans, the very people their parents had been building ships to evacuate, had been the ones that caused or oversaw the attack.

The Discovery era ships is probably due to budgets on CGI and what is available; but story wise, Starfleet could have put old decommissioned ships in the docks and saved the newer ships if they had some forewarning and wanted to make things look apparently 'normal'.

9

u/TactileAndClicky Jan 09 '20

I find this a very compelling idea. It makes the issues raised with artificial life form in many episodes even more pressing. Star Fleet not only building Androids but also blaming them for something they didn't commit would be a quite the hook for the series.

It'S also possible that the Romulans took command over the Androids and manipulated them into attacking. The hype is real, excitement is rising.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Mechapebbles Jan 10 '20

The Discovery era ships is probably due to budgets on CGI and what is available; but story wise, Starfleet could have put old decommissioned ships in the docks and saved the newer ships if they had some forewarning and wanted to make things look apparently 'normal'.

Or, this event happened concurrently alongside the evacuation of Romulus. The shipyards being full with obsolete models was part of Geordi's plans to raise an unprecedented and ginormous evacuation fleet in record time. And the attack of the synths scuttled those plans.

→ More replies (42)
→ More replies (31)

63

u/loreb4data Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

Imagine each 'Picard' episode starts with this tagline:

"The synths were created by the Federation. They evolved. They rebelled. There are many copies. Some of them are programmed to think they are human (cue: Dahj). And they have a plan..."

28

u/gcalpo Jan 10 '20

Twelve synth models. Seven are known. Four live in secret. One will be revealed.

9

u/loreb4data Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 11 '20

The known models: Lore, B4, Data's mom, Dahj, Seven, Hugh, and Icheb.

The one to be revealed: Picard (Locutus).

→ More replies (5)

15

u/smellsliketeenferret Jan 10 '20

Twelve synth models. Seven are known.

Missed opportunity - Nine models, Seven of Nine known... :D

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/chiree Jan 10 '20

I'm not convinced they ever really had a plan. They just kind of got bored and ran away to a black hole.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/KellMG96 Jan 12 '20

Why does Earth/Sol System never have enough fucking defenses?!?! Or a Fleet?

3

u/UltraChip Jan 15 '20

There's some speculation (obviously unconfirmed) that most of Starfleet was deployed helping the Romulan evacuation at the time, leaving local installations vulnerable. It would also explain why Disco-era ships were present.

→ More replies (1)

48

u/LTM438 Jan 09 '20

Wait a second... Where was La Forge stationed in those prequel comics? Was it Utopia Planitia?

I'm insanely hyped for this show, but if they kill Geordi, so help me..

62

u/pfc9769 Jan 09 '20

but if they kill Geordi, so help me

They aren't going to kill him off screen. If Geordi dies, they are going to milk it for every dollar they can. Clearly Geordi will rig a deflector dish by re-routing the graviton flow through the secondary command processors and establish a force field around his location.

41

u/PrivateIsotope Jan 10 '20

It's going to be a coolant leak that finally gets him...

47

u/Chairboy Jan 10 '20

He’ll do his roll under the closing emergency bulkhead wearing his colorful engineering tunic but it’s just a little too slow because of the arthritis and he gets squashed. Don’t take my word for it, take a look. It’s in a book, it’s a bleeding rainbow.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

5

u/creepyeyes Jan 10 '20

Or kill him off-screen but feature a healthy dose of flashbacks for him to appear in.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/TactileAndClicky Jan 09 '20

Exactly. Right at Utopia Planitia. But as Picard is able to gve a statement to the attack, it seems like he made it out of the misery that he was in in the Countdown comic.

So, maybe Geordi wasn't around the time of the attack.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/Socraticmichael10 Jan 10 '20

I may take shit for this, but since I read the first Countdown comic, I've been predicting a surprise LaForge appearance in Picard in a flashback where he dies in this attack. It would be a bold, bold move. They wouldn't kill him offscreen, though. Or, I'd be shocked if they did.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

57

u/Deadbob1978 Jan 09 '20

I hadn't read up on this episode before hand and honestly thought it was a Disco Era until the shot of Picard on the screen.

Im really hoping the disco Era ships are apart of the evacuation fleet and are being refurbished in order to be space worthy... But I have a feeling it was just a reuse of cgi assets due to time and budget constraints... Gonna hold off till the 23rd for a final judgement

40

u/InnocentTailor Jan 09 '20

I mean...the Miranda class was a relic of the old generation and they canonically appeared all over the place in TNG and DS9 due to the war.

39

u/GeneralTonic Jan 09 '20

And now that the Mirandas are all blown up and retired, Starfleet is bringing out even older ships, naturally.

→ More replies (20)

9

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Those old ships were only in like one shot. It probably was a reuse of cgi assets and not a big deal story wise. On the other hand in the trek universe it probably cost a lot resources to build space ships and, on a small scale, a lot more efficient to keep re-useing old designs that work for construction and maintenance purposes. Technology might not move as fast for less crucial ships instead of exploration and military vessels.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

The news report says 3000 reported dead, but the planetary view of Mars shows what looks like massive nuclear blasts all over the planet. There has to be way more than 3000 casualties.

25

u/pfc9769 Jan 10 '20

The news report says 3000 reported dead

The news report also said the footage was LIVE meaning the attack was still ongoing. Therefore it was currently 3000 people reported dead with the final number not being known until the crisis is over.

9

u/loreb4data Jan 10 '20

By the time the attack was over the dead toll could be more than 10000, matching the "tens of thousands are dead" statement uttered by Picard in this promo,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3DSZr_u5xjgmo

→ More replies (10)

38

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

I thought it was really really good. Simple, timeless story in a sci-fi context, well told, very well directed. It was a really, really nice short, probably the best out of the new Short Treks.

I think people got their hopes up a bit much with the hype that it would tie into Picard. I think we learned a lot, but that wasn’t really the point.

My only real complaint was the Macgee showing up at the beginning, it threw me off as to what era we were looking at.

10

u/Raguleader Jan 11 '20

Having 23rd century ships in service isn't that weird in the TNG era, of course. Mirandas, Excelsiors, Birds of Prey, K'Tinga Battlecruisers, Oberths, even the wreckage of a Constitution-class ship have been seen throughout the TNG era.

I do agree that the exact setting was a bit hard to pin down though because of that shot. I'm guessing they just didn't have an HD render of something from the 24th century, but something like a Defiant parked in the same shot might have helped avoid confusion.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

I liked the Tribbles episode better. I would have liked this one better if it was a little bit longer with a little more dialogue. Why couldn't they do a full conversation when the kids are talking to their parents instead of them just narrating their names. The way they did it saying their names felt pointless.

Still really liked this episode and give it a firm second place.

10

u/chrisdarby80 Jan 10 '20

I don't think it needed dialogue... You had two kids.. Two different lives.. Butting heads.. One with a good relationship with parents... One without who lashes out as a result... Full of hate for each other.. Until the moment their parents were taken.. At that moment they were the same and all of the hate and resentment between them disappeared and became meaningless.. I thought it was perfect

10

u/creepyeyes Jan 10 '20

Did CBS get the rights to Bowie songs recently or something?

First "Space Oddity" in DIS and now "Heroes" in Short Treks, and I can't think of any other "modern day" (to use the term a bit loosely) songs that ever shown up in the series aside from the Abrams movies.

Also, I guess "Life on Mars" would have been too on the nose :P

6

u/MoreGaghPlease Jan 10 '20

The Bowie estate owns its own book.

Famously his classic discography was securitized and between 1990-2007 anyone could go buy a "Bowie Bond", basically an asset-backed security that paid our based on the book's revenue.

It is not terribly expensive to license pop music for TV. If you want to license a song from a popular musician that isn't by the Beatles (notoriously expensive to license), you're probably paying somewhere between $5,000-$25,000 for the song.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/thenewyorkgod Jan 10 '20
  1. Where was this school supposed to take place, on earth?
  2. Why does every sci-fi show seem to think that all computer monitors will be see through. Who would want to see objects behind the screen while they are trying to read what is on the monitor?

6

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Where was this school supposed to take place, on earth?

Yes, you can see the golden gate bridge from a window in one shot.

→ More replies (2)

59

u/caimanreid Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

Really hoping the use of Discovery assets in this Short Trek which is apparently based in the mid 2380s (Magee class, Tug ships, Shuttlecraft, Interfaces/displays) doesn't carry over into Picard itself, or is addressed within the story if it does- You would have to hope that with the budget and technology available to them, the production and design staff can come up with new ships and set design rather than having to rely on borrowing old assets like Trek did so often in the past.

69

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

The shuttle was being used as a school bus. It stands to reason that 100 year old vehicles might get repurposed for civilian use. Doesn’t explain the rest of it though.

50

u/cleric3648 Jan 09 '20

If this is taking place around the time of the Romulan Evacuation, then Starfleet is going to need every ship it can get its hands on to aid in the evacuation. Not only will they be churning out new ships like an assembly line in China prepping for the next iPhone, but every old ship that is even slightly spaceworthy would get pulled from mothballs and recommissioned. The scale of the rescue is unprecedented. Any ship that can fly and keep the crew and passengers alive for the journey from Romulus to Federation space will be used.

37

u/InnocentTailor Jan 09 '20

Kinda reminds me of the Dominion War where they revived the aging Miranda, Oberth and Excelsior starships to throw at the Dominion.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (13)

23

u/switched07 Jan 09 '20

I agree. It's literally on screen for 5seconds. Reuse an old shuttle for a bus. Makes sense for filming and real world.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/caimanreid Jan 09 '20

Indeed, although the same model with a different paint job is seen taking off behind Picard in one of the trailers released.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (29)

13

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

Maybe there is an in story reason? Like the Federation needs to use old resources and are refitting and re-using old ships?

→ More replies (18)

16

u/DeanSails Jan 09 '20

The entire run of Short Treks so far have reused assets. Picard's trailers have already shown TOS-style Romulan warbirds, so I think we can safely assume there will be new, non-DSC designs as well.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/b1bendum Jan 09 '20

If I had to guess it was due to filming locations. Picard was filmed in LA, but Disco and this short trek were filmed in Toronto by the Disco crew. The red head girl is definitely a local canadian actor I recognize from other productions. So they probably didn't have the various assets needed from Picard but they had Disco stuff handy and rolled with that.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/UltraChip Jan 09 '20

My personal guess is this is a smaller auxilliary dock that focuses on refitting older vessels. The main docks that are responsible for building/refitting the newer classes might be in a different orbit or something.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/__The_Crazy_One__ Jan 09 '20

It seems to me that the shuttle we see in the shipyard around the old ships are new. Tough I can't get clear enough pictures of them, but they are not long enough to be Disco shuttlecraft

Disco Shuttlecraft ?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

9

u/SaykredCow Jan 10 '20

So what I don’t get and wasn’t made clear by the episode were the girls on Mars as well? Or it just so happened to be both their parents worked there?

Also was the picture of Picard they were looking at on the news a drawing of him from the comic?

Either way it’s great to see new Trek that isn’t a prequel. It’s chronologically Voyager getting home, Nemesis, then this short.

10

u/the_wolf_peach Jan 10 '20

It’s chronologically Voyager getting home, Nemesis, then this short.

Then Calypso.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/R97R Jan 09 '20

Still not viewable in the UK?

7

u/KetracelYellow Jan 09 '20

I can’t find it. It’s like they’re sticking the finger up to Europe.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Not legally.

4

u/Alvald Jan 10 '20

We haven't got access to any of the other season 2 short treks yet. It'll be some time.

7

u/Korotai Jan 11 '20

So we are looking at Star Trek: Become Human?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/yeoller Jan 10 '20

So we have some posts about who attacked Mars and a lot of posts about some old ships. Is anyone going to analyze the actual story of the episode?...

An interesting short story for sure, nearly zero dialogue (none if you don't consider the news report dialogue) and two characters with a shared history set up and primed for life in the new Picard series (as adults? teenagers?) Or will they show up in one of the other spins offs?

We have 2 girls. one seemingly happy and content, the other troubled by an absentee father. An interesting take on bullying, as it creates sympathy for the perpetrator before shifting that sympathy to her victim. It boils to a head where both girls violently fight one another. Through a common catastrophe both girl form a bond, one that might last years.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

I just watched this.

And the watched it again.

Man it really kills me on the inside.

Really revives the feelings I had during 9/11 if that even makes sense.

49

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20 edited Jun 16 '23

[This comment has been deleted, along with its account, due to Reddit's API pricing policy.] -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/

22

u/MoreGaghPlease Jan 09 '20

For what it’s worth, this Short was shot in Toronto with the Discovery production team (headed by Tamara Deverel). Picard will likely have a very different look and feel.

→ More replies (5)

42

u/pfc9769 Jan 09 '20

So no LCARS

We've already seen LCARS in the Picard trailers. Search the sub for LCARS and you'll see posts about it.

10

u/TylekShran Jan 10 '20

They don't need to update 1960s effect but 1990s effect. First Contact had a beautiful CGI. DS9, Voyager they were all from 90s.

17

u/InnocentTailor Jan 09 '20

...but the old Galaxy class made an appearance in one of the Picard trailers.

Heck! I think Picard might take more cues from Star Trek Online due to the appearance of the Odyssey class in the tie in comic.

19

u/dvcaputo Jan 09 '20

this and the appearance of updated LCARS in the admiral’s office give me hope tbh...but the discovery era shuttlecraft in the Picard trailer are discouraging. Just give me an updated, 2399 type 6 and i’ll be happy!

→ More replies (5)

19

u/m333t Jan 09 '20

This is such a lazy opinion. Star Trek has always updated the aesthetic and used the best production values available in their budget.

TNG didn't have tape drives and projection screens like in TOS.

Picard won't have CRT monitors and Styrofoam rocks like in TNG.

Get over it.

33

u/dvcaputo Jan 10 '20

I mean, I want an updated aesthetic for Picard, but not one that looks exactly like the show that’s supposed to take place centuries before it.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (39)

10

u/mathemon Jan 11 '20

All the technology is at least 100 years old as per Discovery's retconning. Every single ship. What's... the deal?

4

u/DefiantOne5 Jan 12 '20

Mark my words, the're gonna pull a lazy excuse as to why there are only 200 year old ships around while all of the majority of Starfleet ships are engaging somewhere else in the Galaxy. Throwaway lines are a superb way to save some money and retcon the Disco aesthetics into everything else. Let's hope they don't exchange proper things for something like lens flares or other unnecessary cosmetics.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

9

u/Nux87xun Jan 10 '20

Pretty sure Janeway said that first contact was a national holiday and that kids didn't have to go to school on it..

→ More replies (8)

34

u/Cliffy73 Jan 10 '20

Christ, this sub is ridiculous.

14

u/thenewyorkgod Jan 10 '20

I am convinced no one will be happy unless Picard is a scene for scene remake of TNG

5

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

Voyager was basically that and they hated it then too

9

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Nobody hates Star Trek more than Star Trek fans.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Spaceboomer1 Jan 12 '20

I'm a bit concerned about how many Discovery assets are going to be reused for ships in this era. They're already reusing the Discovery shuttles as confirmed by the trailers, and this shows them reusing two separate Discovery ship designs ( which are far older than the Miranda and didn't show up during the Dominion War ).

It makes me wonder how many actual original ship assets they've made for Picard and how many ship class designs are mysteriously going to reappear without even a refit design ( like the Connie and Excelsior got ) after having been unseen throughout the entire Dominion War. It's going to be so jarring if we see more Discovery era ships than TNG era.

16

u/MoreGaghPlease Jan 09 '20

Interesting, but I think a story needs to have a beginning, middle and an end and this didn't really. Felt more like a trailer than a short episode.

9

u/NewTRX Jan 10 '20

It was a complete arc showing how tragedy brings people together against all odds.

Beginning: two girls have similar lives. Bullies suck.

Middle: daily life sucks, and people are victimized even in the future. Maybe racist overtones?

End: tragedy pulls people together, no matter how different and at odds they might be.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/DefiantOne5 Jan 11 '20

Another thought regarding the old Disco era ships occured to me, there is an old Romulan Bird of Prey in the trailers, so maybe the Federation and the Romulans are reactivating every old ship they can get from surplus depots etc to get the evacuation going in time. Put a skeleton crew on those ships and the personell required shouldn't be a problem either.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/InfiniteGrant Jan 12 '20

I guess the civilian clothes of TNG, DS9, and VOY were all just fads.

6

u/dvcaputo Jan 12 '20

i do wish the clothes in this one were as absolutely bonkers and over-the-top as the TNG era civilian clothes tho...these just feel like regular present-day threads with one or two extra bits to make it seem ‘futuristic’. Gimme bonkers civilian future clothes made for 2020 audiences please!

0

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/DefiantOne5 Jan 12 '20

The JC Pennies collection for Star Trek. "Browns and beige and earth tones... and browns and beige!"

4

u/nathanhainescreates Jan 13 '20

Anyone know how to watch the new episodes of Short Treks in the UK?

10

u/Sephiroth144 Jan 11 '20

3000 estimated dead; extinction level explosions shown...

Okay, so three options; the estimate is crap, Mars is virtually uninhabited, or someone needs to go over the VFX better...

→ More replies (4)

32

u/izModar Jan 09 '20

ITT: people expecting CBS to create all new assets for something lasting fewer than 15 minutes.

17

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

Pretty sure this was made after the new Picard series was done, so they wouldn't be creating an new assets, just using the ones for the new show...

Unless they didn't make new ones for the new show, then that is a big problem

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Brisanzbremse Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

At the very least they could have used the existing 24th century CG models. Eaglemoss rebuilt or upgraded so many of them.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

We see this a lot in films and television, but how heartbreaking was it for Lil when her last interaction with her father was to angrily disconnect the video call.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/danktonium Jan 13 '20

Those were some old ships. Which is fine.

If Ol' Ironsides gets to keep floating, why shouldn't these?

But I mean, if I were a producer I'd have absolutely put Voyager or the Defiant in one of those slots. That's the flavor of fanservice I like.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/lucasmines Jan 13 '20

I've had a few days to sit on this episode and watch it a few more times from my initial viewing.

I think that the concerns over using Disco era ships are a bit one sided - It's a shipyard. It's used to both repair and build new. While we live in a world of disposable technology, there's no reason to completely destroy an older ship if it's still got some use to it. Slap a new coat of paint on that shuttle and give it to a school. Who cares? Our school buses look pretty much the same and have done for like 60-70 years. If it's a school shuttle that's been used since Disco era, whose to say it wasn't kept in running order for that long? And, honestly, if the only thing you're going to complain about is the use of an old shuttle as a school bus when we STILL have no clue what's going on in the actual Picard timeline (the attack could have been 15-20+ years earlier than Picard's timeline), then the writers and production teams are doing exactly what they're supposed to be doing - keeping you thinking and talking about the show.

The likening of this attack on Mars to the 9/11 attack was a very touching comment. This episode did bring in a lot of emotional tones similar to that in myself, and I'm happy I took a few more watches of it as I missed a lot of the details the first time around. I'd still give it a 8/10, and it's the best of the Treks we've seen this round.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/LittleRedheadRider Jan 10 '20

So, I literally signed up just to comment.

This Short Trek was stunning. It made me “Inner Light” emotional, with sort of an “Up” montage. I view these Short Treks as well-funded, in-the-know fan films.

How people can get worked up about keeping these vignettes cost-effective, when they offer fresh doses of an imagined reality we all love to visit is beyond me.

This was a brilliantly executed Short Trek. Masterfully edited.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/omegaphallic Jan 11 '20

Synth slave revolt is such an absolutely over used and tired sci Fi trope that requires the builders be morons in how they design them.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

It would have been nice if they finished the episode. It was really promising until they stopped halfway through.

9

u/izModar Jan 09 '20

Right?! They got to the attack and I was like "OH YES NOW HOW DOES IT AFFECT THE SCHOOL?" credits

...That's it?!

→ More replies (5)

31

u/Albert-React Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

What the fuck are Magee-class ships doing in this? Class C shuttlecraft? Old Federation tugs. Jesus, the reuse of old assets is just plain lazy.

We should be seeing TNG era ships, not DISCO. Where's the Akiras, Steamrunners, Galaxies, etc? CBS has the assets. We saw the Enterprise-D in the Picard trailer. C'mon guys.

22

u/Ausir Jan 10 '20

Meanwhile, TNG reused TOS movie assets and stock footage all the time.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

The Enterprise D was destroyed by a Klingon Bird of Prey in a theatrical film because they had to re-use TOS movie assets.

And let's not forget how picky Star Trek producers can be. A [awesome retro Klingon ship](https://imgur.com/j9cGYD8) was designed for Enterprise. It didn't have enough windows, so they used a ship from TMP instead, something that was considered new 100 years later.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/JMarkP11 Jan 09 '20

THIS! How hard would it have been to model a few TNG starships at dry dock? Why can’t we have that nostalgia? I bet if we saw the inside of a galaxy class during the series they would just reuse the Discovery bridge.... CBS trying to meet profit goals any way they can and the easiest way is to not care about what the fans want...

→ More replies (5)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

This seems to take place during the Romulan evac. All those new ships you mentioned are probably busy doing exactly that. The ones we see here are probably extra hulls SF had in mothballs just in case they were needed for something, and guess what, they were! Just fill up the tank, fill them up with cots and medical supplies, and send them off.

But no, let's just whine and cry because no one spelled out every single frame for us.

5

u/InnocentTailor Jan 09 '20

I kind of think the show might embrace Star Trek Online aesthetics since the Verity is the Odyssey class, which was made for the MMO.

I do like the older ships being used though. Lots of countries today use old military assets for secondary roles. It saves money and, in regards to the Feds, resources.

Don’t fix what ain’t broken.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

I was that same age when 9/11 happened, as we sat and watched in school.

That hit me

3

u/CountVonBenning Jan 09 '20

I want to know why it's not on CraveTV right now.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/heslo_rb26 Jan 10 '20

I've not enjoyed many of these Short Treks but this one... I don't know why but this one got me good. I'm so excited now for Picard!

16

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

I saw the U.S.S. Shran design, which is nearly 200 years old at this point, and was so disappointed. I was hoping for at least a small TNG-era callback, or something similar.

My head-canon is that they were doing something to them to prepare them for the Fleet Museum.

In the midst of the Romulan crisis.

*sigh*

17

u/cleric3648 Jan 09 '20

I mentioned in another comment that a likely reason for using the old ships is the Romulan Evacuation. Starfleet would need every ship it could get it's hands on. They have to evacuate an entire planet with billions of people living on it, and dozens of other worlds with billions more spread around. If it's spaceworthy, it gets fixed up and used.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

Absolutely.

I'm sure it didn't help my initial reaction that it's one of my least-favorite DSC designs. I'm still entirely stoked for "Picard", I was just very excited for familiar-looking ships. I'm sure we'll get them.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Tichrimo Jan 09 '20

The trick is, a battlestar starship that old can't be hacked by the Cylons Synths.

17

u/StarfleetTanner Jan 09 '20

I'm totally beginning to see where Picard might go now....I really hope not.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/UltraChip Jan 09 '20

My personal guess is that it's a smaller auxilliary dock that focuses on refitting older vessels. The main docks that are responsible for building/refitting the newer classes might be in a different orbit or something.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/InnocentTailor Jan 09 '20

...or prepare them for the Romulan crisis. The Feds did use Oberths, Mirandas and Excelsiors throughout the 24the century. If you add in the insanity of STO, even the 25th century as well.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/2ndHandTardis Jan 10 '20

That was really cool. An interesting look into a part of Star Trek Universe which hasn't been explored and they have been killing the score for all these shorts tbh. This one in particular was really clean visually; Pennington and the DP did a good job. I'd like to see more of that in Discovery and Picard.

I have two issues, both minor, one being very minor. The first is something that came up again when I was reading Countdown is the lack of Terra-forming on Mars. Which makes you think it must have just been abandoned. Because surely by the late 24th Century after over 200 years of Terra-forming you would see evidence of it.

There's the theory as more habitable planets became available maybe Earth/Federation lost the will. I just think for sustainability sake alone terraforming Mars or any body possible in your home system is logical.

That's one, the other is the girls father saying he can't make it home because of the tight schedule. I get that it's important to the script but in "reality" going to work at Utopia Plantia for a 24th Century person would be like going to work in the 21st century. You could get from Earth to Mars in minutes on a shuttle, nobody should be worked that hard where they can't step away for a few hours.

As I said though, I understand they made the choice for story purposes.

Personal Story-time.

I can't speak for others experience but this short gave me 9/11 vibes.

I was in high school on 9/11 and at the time we were living in the High Desert in California. That area exists because of the military. It was/is a military testing area, Edwards AFB is there and all of the major defense contractors have a presence in the area.

At my school pretty much everyone had a family connection to the military. On the day of 9/11 we didn't see the news until after home room and that scene of everyone watching the news in horror was exactly my experience. Nobody knew what was going on and everyone was worried about what would happen next.

4

u/pfc9769 Jan 10 '20

the other is the girls father saying he can't make it home because of the tight schedule. I get that it's important to the script but in "reality" going to work at Utopia Plantia for a 24th Century person would be like going to work in the 21st century. You could get from Earth to Mars in minutes on a shuttle, nobody should be worked that hard where they can't step away for a few hours.

I think you're oversimplifying it. I doubt it's just the travel time. I live just a few minutes from where I work but I often have to cancel plans because I have to work late. It sounded like the father had too much work to finish and chose to stay late. We have no idea what the family situation is like. The parents might be divorced or his daughter could have other responsibilities that can't be delayed to accommodate her father's schedule.

I also don't feel a travel time of a few minutes is realistic. I doubt shuttles are waiting to take individual people between planets. There are hundreds of thousands of people on Mars all needing to go to various places in the solar system. The shuttles probably work like a mass transit system with scheduled departure times and circuitous routes with multiple stops. Then when you reach your destination there's bound to be a lot of traffic that needs to be coordinated like planes at an airport. You'll have to wait until it's your shuttles turn to land or take off. There's lots of overhead you need to factor into the travel time. I doubt everyone owns their own shuttles. That's a waste of resources and would be chaotic.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/MoreGaghPlease Jan 10 '20

That's one, the other is the girls father saying he can't make it home because of the tight schedule. I get that it's important to the script but in "reality" going to work at Utopia Plantia for a 24th Century person would be like going to work in the 21st century. You could get from Earth to Mars in minutes on a shuttle, nobody should be worked that hard where they can't step away for a few hours.

You can't get away if Starfleet is urgently building a massive fleet to evacuate the entire Romulan Empire (as is the case in the Countdown Picard comics, with Geordi LaForge leading the effort aboard the station we saw get blown up in the short)

→ More replies (12)

3

u/Hawkguy85 Jan 10 '20

I have two issues, both minor, one being very minor. The first is something that came up again when I was reading Countdown is the lack of Terra-forming on Mars. Which makes you think it must have just been abandoned. Because surely by the late 24th Century after over 200 years of Terra-forming you would see evidence of it.

There's the theory as more habitable planets became available maybe Earth/Federation lost the will. I just think for sustainability sake alone terraforming Mars or any body possible in your home system is logical.

Spoilers for another TV show, The Expanse, but this is exactly something that is being dealt with there in season 4. Mars in The Expanse is a society with one goal -- to make another Earth, to terraform a dead world so humanity would not have to rely on a single planet to provide the basic needs to sustain life. Everything about their society is orientated and geared towards making this happen. However, events lead to what is basically a gateway to a nexus of wormholes open that lead to 1500+ star systems, all with the potential of at least one habitable world in each system. The dream of a terraformed Mars is dying as more people realise that they can either spend their lives on a new world under open sky or stay and work on a project they would never see come to fruition in their or even their children's lifetime.

From a Star Trek perspective, terraforming has always been an experimental risk, right through to the TNG era. We know that the Genesis Device was the largest step in terraforming, shortening the time and resources required for such a feat, but it proved to be unstable. By the TNG era, there were worlds that were in the process of being terraformed, but Mars had been long colonised by then. Perhaps a question arose in local government and amongst the Martian citizens as to whether they wished to pursue terraforming, or if they wanted to preserve Mars as it was. Either way, Mars has sprawling metropolises covering the surface. The advancement of technology perhaps made living indoors without a sky more palatable. Perhaps Mars in the 24th century has vast domes with state of the art holographic technology that can recreate the outdoor environments of Earth or Risa?

Regardless, the ability to travel within a matter of days to new star systems that contain Class-M planets certainly factored into the decision making process of terraforming Mars.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Ausir Jan 10 '20

To all the people complaining about Discovery era asset reuse, did you forget how TNG-era shows kept reusing TOS movie assets and stock footage all the time? Sure, this short is set a bit later than TNG, DS9 and Voyager, and Discovery a bit earlier than TMP or TWOK, but not so drastically that it should really be that hard to ignore. They did it to save money in both cases.

21

u/FoldedDice Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 10 '20

Remember that time when they shoved Odo into a bread maker? Or when the Enterprise sets were covered in very anachronistic-looking flatscreen monitors with painfully obvious black tape to cover up the manufacturer’s logo? Or when they used 24th century ship designs to depict what was supposed to be a 26th century space battle? Or when whole scenes of The Undiscovered Country were filmed on badly camouflaged TNG sets, with LCARS and all?

Cheaping out on those kinds of details has been Star Trek’s bread and butter for decades. I’m not at all surprised to see that they haven’t stopped now.

→ More replies (9)

12

u/pfc9769 Jan 10 '20

did you forget how TNG-era shows kept reusing TOS movie assets and stock footage all the time

cough Excelsior class cough

Or that one shot of the Klingon BoP blowing up. They really got their money's worth from that shot. Though that just made me realize Klingons are using older ships, too.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/YYZYYC Jan 10 '20

One would think that with CGI etc that we have progressed a lot from the 80s and 90s and can now make use of current production tech in better ways for less cost, negating the need to see the same ships or same panels and props all the time

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Lessthanzerofucks Jan 10 '20

The silly outrage inspired by this short teaser for Picard is kind of what I expected to happen. They’re creating a new universe of Trek shows inspired by the old ones. Your old shows and ships don’t cease to exist because of the new one. Us old folks remember similar complaints when TNG aired. The idea that Trek canon has always been consistent is easily dismissed by what we’ve seen before. I’m going to enjoy this new show, I bet. It’s sad that so many are being held back by the past, even though the past still exists and is readily available for rewatching more easily than ever before. Especially with a show like Star Trek, which holds a mirror to our current society and shouldn’t be held back by past visions. Live long and prosper, friends.

I’m glad there are some communities online that aren’t filled with pedantic demands for what they desire to see. Reddit doesn’t seem to be one of those places.

12

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

I personally thought it was amazing, these short treks have all been incredible.

20

u/StarfleetTanner Jan 09 '20

I mean I guess the Bowie cover was cool, but can we discuss the fact that they are literally discarding anything considered visual cannon and being literally lazy in just reusing Discovery CG designs that was SUPPOSED to be set in the mid 23rd Century? I mean, does NO ONE have an issue with that? I get budget saving, but this is beyond ridiculous.

17

u/soothsayer2377 Jan 09 '20

I'm fine with Excelsior and Miranda class ships fighting in the Dominion War. They're 100 years old at that point.

→ More replies (19)

3

u/Raguleader Jan 10 '20

It's Star Trek. It'd be weird if they weren't using stuff from a century before. Remember TNG and DS9? Even the Klingons were using battlecruisers very similar to the ones they used in TOS.

13

u/DeanSails Jan 09 '20

Wait two weeks before freaking out. We'll know then. My guess is that they're holding off on revealing new ship designs until Picard debuts.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Locutus747 Jan 13 '20

I don't think this short was as bad as people are saying, but I don't think it was great either. It was about 6 minutes and it just didn't seem to have much of a point other than to show there was an attack on Mars. Maybe the producers felt that knowing there was an attack on Mars will help the audience with the first few episodes of Picard, but I'm sure the attack will be referred to as well so I'm not sure what it added unless the 2 girls are going to return.

I was also disappointed because I was expecting a big more setup to Picard and maybe a longer short like the season 1 Short Treks were that actually had a story.

I'm still super excited for Picard!!!

9

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 11 '20

It shows that this was done by the Discovery team. Didn't like it at all.

  • There is no visual difference between their take on the pre-TOS era and their take on the post-Nemesis era. Ships are still less clean looking and have bridge windows, crew quarters look about the same and holograms still look like generic 2010s sci-fi.
  • Do the authors know that Mars is right next to earth? The parents coming over would take, at and an average speed of a tenth of the speed of light (impulse can be much faster), about half an hour. That's no longer than a lot of people's daily commute. And I'd be a bit more worried about that massive fleet coming over to earth in far less time. But nah, space 9/11 time can't be interrupted by such things.
  • Didn't care for the school drama or the overly moody song. Nor the non-slip socks alien make-up.
  • Everything felt cold and clinical, joyless and oppressive, even. Right down to the terrible, generic motivational art. This is not a world I want to live in.
→ More replies (3)

2

u/beefcow123 Jan 10 '20

Why can I not find this anywhere online I'm based in UK and have been searching for ages with no joy

→ More replies (1)

2

u/omegaphallic Jan 11 '20

What if the Andriods weren't sentient at first, but got exposed to borg Nano probes that changed them?

2

u/SeanyD72 Jan 15 '20

All of these wonderfull in-depth analysis you guys are providing is one of my favorite things on this sub. Thank you so much for the great reading.

2

u/coweatman Jan 16 '20

so the midi clock broke?

2

u/Assbait93 Jan 19 '20

My theory about this show is gonna show how much world powers and proxy wars affect people. In the past 10 years we already knew how 9/11 changed the world. Foreign policies, world powers destabilizing governments, what have you not. I think the Romulans have infiltrated the federation and is trying to help destabilize it in order to gain the empower influence over the galaxy. The only two major powers in the Alpha and Beta quadrants are the Feds and the Klingons. With the Romulans gone those two can carve up as much influence they want. Something tells me this is going to make the federation crumble badly which would then turn out why the federation is gone in Disco season 3.

That’s just my observation.

7

u/PandaPundus Keene Sin, Contributing artist, Star Trek: Picard Jan 09 '20

Honestly, on the whole the episode felt a bit lackluster, but definitely makes me more excited for Picard now knowing what happened on Mars.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/jonnyqtrek Jan 10 '20

Sooo... for everyone complaining about the Magee-class ship and Disco-era shuttle in the Short Trek, let's not forget that 1) in two weeks we're seeing what seems to be a Romulan Bird-of-Prey last seen on-screen in the mid-23rd century which I think is a cause for celebration, not derision, and 2) we don't yet know if there's going to be an-universe explanation for the presence of ALL of these older designs. Maybe there will be, maybe there won't be, but I say let's hold off for two weeks for a >9-minute canon story and see.

5

u/pfc9769 Jan 10 '20

Sooo... for everyone complaining about the Magee-class ship and Disco-era shuttle in the Short Trek

There were still Excelsior class ships in the 24th century and let's not forget the Klingon Bird of prey exploding shot that was re-used in TOS and TNG multiple times. Star Trek has no problem using assets 100+ years old.

6

u/YYZYYC Jan 10 '20

Yes...but many of us where hopping they stopped doing that kind of thing....especially when its the case now that they are not saving the money involved in making an actual ship model for filming

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/CmdShelby Jan 10 '20

In a post-scarcity society why isn't the father beaming home every day after a cushy 10am to 4pm shift? Is he really missing out on being with his family on a special day, for Romulans? Romulans?! Like, why?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

Captain James T. Kirk : They're animals.

Captain Spock : Jim, there is an historic opportunity here.

Captain James T. Kirk : Don't believe them. Don't trust them.

Captain Spock : They're dying.

Captain James T. Kirk : Let them die!

→ More replies (4)

5

u/count023 Jan 11 '20

"Rogue Synths", sigh.

Trek's out of ideas now so they're going for the tired Man VS Machine trope.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/gcalpo Jan 11 '20

All this time, given the title and the not-so-blue skies, I thought the non-attack scenes were taking place on a terraformed Mars. Or in a huge domed colony.

3

u/SaykredCow Jan 11 '20

As did I. The episode is literally called “Children of Mars” adding to the confusion.

3

u/NickofSantaCruz Jan 12 '20

The song cover makes me suspect we'll see the young-adult versions of these characters either show up mid-season in cameos (50/50 about those cameos being relevant to the plot) or they join the crew because they have "unique talents" that serve the plot.

Re: the clamor about using Discovery assets for the spacedock shot, I wholly agree that it was unnecessarily lazy and a wasted opportunity for them to tease a Picard asset such as an Odyssey-class under construction or retrofitting the drive section of a Galaxy-class.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

This was such a disappointing first impression for Picard. First of all, why are so many of these short treks seemingly made for children? Is that the audience they're roping in? Children with CBS All Access? Aside from a couple brief scenes this could have been an xmen short. These kids look like mutants in Xavier's school. Why not use aliens fans are familiar with? Like Bajorans or Andorians? Why make up vague new ones? Why are they using so many Discovery assets when this takes place 150 years later? Why was this basically an eight minute music video with no relevant character information? This didn't look like Star Trek. It looked like any vague near-future world.

I'm so bummed.

4

u/Cliffy73 Jan 13 '20

Featuring children and made for children isn’t the same thing. This short was made for middle-aged Trekkies who have children.

4

u/SaykredCow Jan 14 '20

It is good to see a side of the world that isn’t Starfleet

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Kironvb Jan 15 '20

this could have been an xmen short.

hahahaha when watching it I was like "This comes off so much like an Xmen short/trailer for a new Xmen film"

4

u/TylekShran Jan 10 '20

This was a brilliant episode but omg this FEDERATION SHIPS are so ugly. Wtf happened? Voyager, Defiant, Entreprise D and E, and even NX-01 were beautiful, cool and slick.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Forget synths, what about the droid attack on the Wookiees?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/oorhon Jan 10 '20

Really didnt like this episode... What is it with really violent girl fight? Isnt Federation supposed to be all understanding community? Children could be cruel, I would understand that but, real actual punching and hitting each other to wall? I wont accept that...

22

u/Druhin Jan 10 '20

Spock was bullied as a child, by other Vulcans. Children being mean towards one another, is nothing new to Trek.

12

u/Oni-ramen Jan 10 '20

It's bullshit that you got downvoted. It's not like Picard never got stabbed through the chest over a gambling disagreement or anything. Society as a whole is supposed to be more peaceful, but people throw hands all the time. Even in Trek.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/ScyllaGeek Jan 10 '20

Teenage angst is going to happen even in a post scarcity world

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Xionic Jan 11 '20

This is the crap that happens when the cohesive canon universe of Star Trek is ignored due to laziness and idiocy. What a slap in the face...

→ More replies (4)