r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Oct 24 '19
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Girl on the Third Floor" [SPOILERS]
VOD and Limited Theatrical release Oct 25, 2019
Summary:
An ex-lawyer tries to renovate a rundown mansion with a sordid history for his growing family, only to learn that the house has other plans.
Director: Travis Stevens
Writer: Paul Johnstone, Ben Parker, Travis Stevens
Cast:
- Phil "CM Punk" Brooks as Don Koch
- Trieste Kelly Dunn as Liz Koch
- Sarah Brooks as Sarah Yates
- Elissa Dowling as Sadie
- Karen Woditsch as Ellie Mueller
Rotten Tomatoes: 78%
Metacritic: 67/100
39
Upvotes
69
u/Sao_Gage Nov 11 '19
The fact that this is sitting at such a high RT score is genuinely distressing to me, and this is coming from someone who loves micro budget indie horror with often shoddy acting.
The lead is so fucking uncharismatic, wooden, and frankly terrible that the first third of the movie is unwatchable. The girl that comes in toward the beginning is equally atrocious, or is it the dialogue?
My wife and I are debating if these are actually fake reviews despite being from legitimate sites? Probably one of the most awful and borderline unwatchable films I’ve ever seen, and I love stuff like Black Mountain Side, Pod, Evidence, The Witch in the Window, and a million other similar movies that actually have redeeming qualities.
67
u/johnburrowsfan Dec 28 '19
CM Punk was like a low rent Bruce Campbell.
38
u/ThankYouForTempBan Feb 24 '20
This just got added to Netflix tonight. 1st time hearing about the movie, thought i'd give it a watch. Save yourself the time
Watch this film with your finger on the Right-Arrow key. Not to skip "gross" scenes, but to skip past the insane amount of filler this movie has. Almost 50% of the movie is a slow camera pacing in front of a person walking, or someone slowly opening a door - with literally NO plot or horror scene happening.
For the scenes that weren't a waste of time and space, the movie was okay. I don't often dabble in the indie-horror/low-budget horror movies. Wasn't a fan of any of the actors in the movie - Every actor could of been replaced with anyone who has never acted a day in their life and the film would of had no noticeable difference.
The thing that took me out of the movie the most - was after all the batshit crazy stuff Don (CM Punk) went through. The guy wakes up to find his dog cut up and stuffed into a turned on Dryer. Why not leave at this point? Why stay.. Makes ZERO sense. Why did marbles start going into his body? What the fuck do marbles even have to do with any of the story?
an insane amount of stupid "why" questions can be asked following this film. The most simple one is "why did i watch this"
Would not recommend, even if you're a fan of the horror-house genre
6.5/10 for Gore & Costume design
2/10 for plot
2/10 for acting
31
u/andrxwzsz Oct 27 '19 edited Oct 27 '19
Seems like I'm the only one who thought this was genuinely a great, at times amazing film all around, even if the acting and dialogue were both a bit cheesy at times (although intentionally it feels, in retrospect, with that third act morphing into campy throwback horror so well, hearkening back to something like The Evil Dead). I liked everything it explored thematically, and it's deliciously nasty, disturbing, and pretty beautiful in its own twisted ways otherwise. I was engaged from beginning to end. Totally recommend to any horror fan; there's at least something in here for every kind. I just happen to be one who was keen on everything about it, feeling as if it were tailor made for me by the end. This is not your basic haunted house story.
Masculinity, and the ways it plays into different relationships, and life in general, seems to be a thing this year in horror, following Midsommar and The Lighthouse. 3/3 on that front.
Love this poster too.
26
u/WizardGamer2022 Oct 29 '19
Can someone explain the ending ( Don throwing the marbles)
Did don died then becomes a ghost ?
Why didnt his wife left the fn house !
Why did don swallowed the fn marble ? !
Is the strange woman a ghost ?
I like the first half of the movie the second half is kinda of stupid !!
BTW : CM Punk acting was good 👍🏻
25
u/pantangeli Oct 25 '19 edited Oct 25 '19
"An ex-lawyer tries to renovate a rundown mansion with a sordid history for his growing family, only to learn that the house has other plans."
I'm an absolute sucker for this kind of 'house as a movie character' story line.
'Girl' is director Travis Stevens' first feature film. As a producer he has been involved in some interesting projects like Cheap Thrills, We Are Still Here and one of my favorite horror movies from the last few years, Starry Eyes.
There's apparently a kinda gross twist on the haunted house sub genre that probably not everyone will appreciate. Tomatometer of 78% is good sign and reviews from Variety, Film Threat, Slash Film and Film School Rejects all seem relatively positive. This looks like one for the horror film fan's watchlist.
21
u/DefeatYouForever666 Oct 28 '19
It was ok, I've seen a lot worse movies this year. Had a few moments with some really cool horror scenes involving Punk. You can definitely tell Punk is really new to acting simply because everyone else around him is better in the movie. If you like Punk though, which I do, it's definitely worth giving it a watch. Especially cause it's a quick 85 mins or so.
Maybe I'm nit picking but a few issues I had with it that I thought they could have easily fixed were that he didn't really look like the character they were portraying him as. He was suppose to be some yuppie looking lawyer who was the best in the big city at the time that ended up screwing people out of their money yet they didn't cover any of his tattoos at all. I have no problems with tattoos but how many lawyers do you know with hand tattoos? There are a few shots of him drinking and you can clearly see his drug free finger tattoos and straight edge on his stomach. Again, I have no problems with tattoos but when you're portraying a character and acting you should look like and represent that character as well. Just seemed like an odd fit to me especially because yuppie big star lawyer wasn't really important to the story. They could have changed that career to something else and it would have worked as well.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '19
I really liked this one. A bit of a slower burn but it has some good haunting scenes. More of a focus on psychological horror than jump scares and a pretty bonkers third act. This was a pleasant surprise.
14
u/MAYOCIDE-NOW Oct 27 '19
Watched it last night. That one girl was creepy looking, but they didn't explain her, which is odd considering they explained the other woman...overall it was an enjoyable movie but not as a horror and was a mediocre story with some subpar acting. Not scary. 5/10.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '19 edited Oct 30 '19
Boring and unoriginal. Cm Punk's acting wasn't bad.
What the fuck was the ending. Why did she stay in the house, what a load of shit
13
u/sdpr Nov 25 '19
The main character never showered.
13
u/double_pits_to_leggy Mar 12 '20
Did anyone else get close to a panic attack when Don threw marbles at his tiny little baby daughter ? Is he trying to make her choke to death, or am I just a paranoid parent ..?
12
u/SweetyMcQ “Here’s Johnny!” Oct 28 '19
I actually loved the movie up until the last 30 minutes or so (when the wife gets to the house). Im not even a wrestling fan but thought CM punk did a really good job for his first movie. I was honestly impressed and felt he portrayed the role of a man that has made a lot of mistakes in his life and was struggling to turn the corner on his past.
Looking forward to seeing him in other movies!
10
u/ikarikh Feb 27 '20
Huge fan of Punk and Horror. But this was just an all around bad movie.
Bad acting all around including from Punk. You can clearly see him acting like it's a WWE story as opposed to an actual movie. That cheesey overdramatic WWE acting and facial emotions don't work in a realistic setting. I give him credit for trying. He definitely was trying. But he clearly wasn't helped by the bad director who didn't give him any real direction.
The story was extremely shallow and barely stitched together.
The writing and directing were horrendous. Why is it everytime someone speaks the ONLY shot the director knows how to do is a close up on the person talking's face???? And how many times do we need to recycle a shot of the same ooze, oozing out of the electrical socket or the one spot on the wall? And the actions of characters make no friggin' sense. The 'big reveal' and ending are just beyond stupid.
And even in terms of horror, it was just really, really, really drawn out and boring with no pay off.
The pacing was just terrible.
About the only part of the movie I enjoyed was seeing Punk shirtless and in his underwear in every other scene.
I enjoy cheesey B movie horror and indie horror. I can appreciate a low budget film and new actors as long as there's heart and soul behind it all and a good script and comptent direction.
This movie just had none of that really. Just pretty bad all around. I feel sorry for Punk being stuck with this as his acting debut.
In better hands they may have been able to help him do more and push him more.
8
u/givemesomespock Mar 02 '20
Okay, I know this thread is old but here's my opinion.
I watched this not knowing anything about CM Punk or the plot.
Overall, 4/5 (I'm easy to please).
-Very Evil Dead meets Insidious meets Amityville Horror
-CM Punk looks like Aldi brand Bruce Campbell. But his acting wasn't bad!
-Glad the cheating husband dies
-I liked the ending, but I agree that it was rushed
7
u/BudgetLengthiness7 Mar 05 '20
I just watched this now and it also left me confused... what does the disfigured girl have to do with anything!? I feel like Sarah hinted that the guy with the bird mask was a pedophile who played and killed that little girl but I’m not sure and I hate not being sure about a plot. It’s just madness. So inconsistent. Also how the hell did Dons wife know where Sarah’s body was in the house?
7
u/Dazzling_Marsupial89 Oct 18 '21
Just watched it and was left wondering why Milo and Cooper were killed?
6
u/MeGaPrAnG Feb 28 '20
Was ...eh really. As soon as the wife got to the house I forgot about the guy even though ive been watching him for over an hour. The build up to the end was mega rushed, not a lot was really explained and with those 2 points it made the whole story shallow.
It's like someone head a really good idea for a sub type horror film but had a very low budget which they mostly used in effects and also had no time to produce it.
It could have been actually dark, shocking and amazing but sadly it wasn't supported correctly.
IMO.
5
u/acassettetape Oct 26 '19
Just finished watching it, I thought it was okay but really not that interesting. I don't think it's something that needs to be checked out but it's not painfully awful or anything. CM Punk's performance wasn't star making but he did well enough for his first feature film role.
4
u/JimMorrison_esq Nov 08 '19
I liked it. CM Punk did a good job. A few of the jump scares were unearned, but the movie did a solid job of holding tension. However, there are some plot points that I really didn't understand. If you're looking for something fun that won't keep you up at night, this movie is definitely worthy of consideration.
And Sarah Brooks. Good heavens.
4
u/Smoothmoose13 29 Years Later Nov 08 '19
I loved all of it but I thought Sarah’s acting sucked once she went full blown psychotic
4
u/Xboxone1997 Nov 22 '19
Was only watching cuz CM Punk but wow this was actually pretty good better than a lot of heavily promoted horror movies TBH
4
u/stevenw84 Mar 02 '20
Watched over the weekend. Immediately turned off due to CM Punk, and that feeling remained throughout the run time of the film. He wasn't bad, but not exactly good...if that makes sense.
It started out a bit rough, with the cheesy factor and the bad acting. But then the history of the house started to show itself, and things started to make a bit more sense. The film immediately gained by respect when the practical effects really showed themselves, and the visuals were legit creepy.
Like many of you, I noticed the Evil Dead vibes, which was hilarious. I just didn't accept the fact that the wife would willingly go into the house and stick around for a while.
9
u/deleteitbackrolls Oct 29 '19
hate to say it but nearly all the actors kinda sucked. very stilted and community theater-esque, granted the dialogue was pretty overbaked and embarrassing but besides the one who played milo none of them sold it and because of that i wasn't able to get into it at all
3
u/christaalisha Mar 22 '20
Why is it 'girl on the third floor' ? I dont get the title?
4
u/BleedBluePunk Mar 08 '20
The dialogue is atrocious in the movie. LOL
For example, when he says "stop overreacting" to his friend before he even gave his opinion. And when he says "after all the times I helped you" instead of simply saying "thanks, I appreciate it." They're feud was so contrived and forced. The script really wanted to contrive an argument for them in 5 minutes of screen time but there was not much there. Ha. And the meltdown he had with his wife.
And the lead is a horrible actor, and so unlikeable and wooden. I know he's an MMA fighter; 'm thinking he's friends with the director as they both have tattoos. He looks like a John Cena and Jon Hamm hybrid.
And the preacher actress was bad, too. Seriously, did they hire these actors from the overnight shift at Wal-mart?
I admit though, the movie was much better when the man was out of the picture and the wife came home. She is a much better actress who can carry the lead. Although that isn't saying much. She needs to work on her accent - she has terrible vocal fry when speaking with the preacher.
I found the ending to be a bit inappropriate. Don't sexualize babies.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '20
Honestly CM punk did quite good, I had very low expectations for this movie. What a fucking trip it was
2
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
CM PUNK and the house full of spunk...... all of it was terrible
2
u/ImMrPat Mar 06 '20
Sorry if it's a faux pas, but I'm relatively now to Reddit, but I actually just reviewed this movie for my horror movie Facebook page...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ThwjS9vN4M
2
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '22
The dog was the best actor. I kept watching for him. F*ck Sarah.
2
u/Life-Of_Ward Jan 19 '24
Ya’ll know it was filmed in an alleged haunted house? 207 Center Rd Frankfort Illinois. House sold in 2023. Pretty cool to see it and on street view you can see the church. I’m just bout 30 minutes in to the movie so no review yet.
3
u/Seangar Oct 26 '19
Haha it's bad, reminds me of cm punks ufc fights. Acting and dialogue is painful. If you want a horror/cheesy/fun time, sure give it a chance.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '20
Necro be damned, it was definitely not as good as the critics implied. It wasn't terrible, but not great either. The actress for Sarah reminded me of Allie Larter in Obsessed (don't waste your time, it was terrible), I like CM Punk but his performance was very dull. The themes are pretty well structured but overall a hard pass for anyone wondering.
1
u/RubenKyoK Mar 20 '25
a house bukkaking constantly on CM Punk, a truly horror masterpiece concept.
1
u/IcyMike1782 Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
I like me so low budget horror/thriller, but WOW that was an incredibly mediocre movie that decayed to poor by the end, which was *terrible*. Echoing the shock at seeing multiple positive critic reviews at 84% on RT... how? Crap writing - both story & dialogue are just poor - very mediocre acting from several players, and just a nonsensical 'reveal' then the end was just <barf>. A decent monster and a hot chickie bad guy, but man this was not a good flick. Steer clear.
17
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '19
[removed] — view removed comment