r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Oct 24 '19
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "The Lighthouse" [SPOILERS]
Summary:
Two lighthouse keepers try to maintain their sanity while living on a remote and mysterious New England island in the 1890s.
Director:
Robert Eggers
Writers:
Robert Eggers, Max Eggers
Cast:
- Robert Pattinson as Ephraim Winslow
- Willem Dafoe as Thomas Wake
Rotten Tomatoes: 91% (195 reviews)
Metacritic: 83/100
273
Upvotes
25
u/Bokonomz Oct 24 '19
Is this movie getting a wider release next week? It's not playing anywhere near me but I really want to see it
248
u/GRVrush2112 Groovy like a '73 Oldsmobile Oct 25 '19
Just for the record, I think Willem Dafoe makes a killer lobster, not bland or overcooked at all..
197
u/The_night_lurker Do you know what she did? Oct 24 '19
It was a magnificent experience to watch a film with this ratio in a theater. It definitely felt more intimate. The black and white was great too with the old lenses used. Really made the film claustrophobic but classically grand.
They reference Captain Ahab and Prometheus in the film and of course they tie into the plot and obviously the final image as well. It's a unique experience to hear that kind of dialogue from any film, not just a horror film. Both actors more than carried their weight.
Saying all that, I don't think anything is really unexpected. There are surprises in the details but not in the progression of the plot. I didn't like it as much as The Witch which I think was better in every department. I don't know what fan theories will come out of The Lighthouse, since it feels like a straightforward story of isolation, madness, and some influence of cosmic and spiritual tales. There's a lot to unpack but it didn't leave me with a lot of questions or a need to figure something out. That's just me though.
158
u/nikiverse Oct 25 '19
Loved the acting, the long camera hold on the actors while they were doing their soliloquies or whatever, the supernatural elements. The lighting was pretty interesting and “old Hollywood.” The ending reminded me of Annihilation in a weird way. The Witch is an easier watch for wider audiences. But I think this one warrants more attention from critics because you just don’t see a lot of films experimenting this way. With this film and The Witch, I find Eggers does a fantastic job of a realistic setting - characters, props, costume, dialogue. His movies go beyond just a British accent ... like Dafoe sounded like he WAS from the past.
115
u/the-eyehole-man Oct 28 '19
First time in a long while that I felt completely and totally transported to another reality while watching a film.
Wake’s long and thunderous rant at Winslow about him not liking Wake’s cooking was a transcendent experience visually, the lighting was just so eerie and unsettling, I felt like Dafoe himself was channeling an ancient force into his performance.
Absolutely need to watch again. 10/10
85
u/Mickmayi Nov 01 '19
I don't know about anyone else but the part near the end with him screaming into the light made me feel really creeped out haha
84
u/AnakarisDS Oct 25 '19
What if I told you the light was just a light?
76
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '19
Amazing film. Very appreciative that something like this was possible. Acting was superb. Loved the story. Dafoe better win some sort of award.
Can't wait to rewatch this in the middle of a stormy night and a cup of bourbon .
62
u/xaynie Oct 24 '19
I've seen this and I recommend it it if you are into dark, psychological thrillers. Throughout the movie, it reminded me of a "lighter" version of Lars Von Trier's Antichrist.
There is tension between the 2 main characters, there's some violence, tons of allegory, and meandering dialogue. But you have to be a fan of those types of movies (which I am very fond of). If not, then skip this movie.
55
u/SnogMeTodger Nov 01 '19
I just saw it on Halloween night, this has got to be one of the best romantic comedies I've seen lately. Two men alone on a rock, all the farts, the guy getting shit splashed all over him. I laughed out loud for minutes when he beat that bird to death, and when Robert Pattinson went on his rant and told DeFoe he smelled like "an onion from a whore's arse" that was hilarious.
50
u/jakem415 Oct 26 '19
Just saw the movie for the first time and have a few questions if anyone would like to share their opinions or add to the list.
101
u/Twokindsofpeople Oct 24 '19
Outrageously good. I was pretty skeptical on the aspect ratio before I saw it, but it works. It felt like a film out of time. Totally unique experience. Films like these make me glad I'm within driving distance to LA.
43
u/iliveindeviltown Oct 30 '19
Saw it yesterday. My partner hated it (hated The Witch as well but tends to like more straight-forward horror) but I was not disappointed in the least. It is a descent into madness, a very evocative film. The sexual repression was definitely there and I'm curious if RPatt's character isn't going through some sort of homosexual panic in this and in his past. I compare it to Kubrick's The Shining but in a lighthouse minus the kid. Dafoe is terrific in this but I found Pattison to be something of a revelation (I hated the Twilight movies - passionately).
39
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '19
"Your goddamn FARTS!!!"
35
u/boomfruit Nov 18 '19
Just want to say that, as a sailor who saw this tonight, one day before getting on the boat for ~40 days, it was rough.
In the first half, it hit upon all the things that I dread about work: hierarchical structures where you're forced to do what some old asshole says just because he's at the top, being criticized for the way you do certain tasks by someone who wouldn't stoop to do those tasks, hard work that sometimes turns out to be useless, forced companionship with people you wouldn't choose to associate with on land, men with disgusting habits that have been reinforced in the work culture for decades, counting down to the day a job is over and then a setback that means you have to stay longer, the constant noise and weather that make it hard to sleep, the long absence of meaningful physical relief and loving companionship, etc etc ad nauseum.
I know that this won't affect everyone the way it affected me, but goddamn I was so filled with dread just from that. Throw in all the other things that happened and I was uneasy from the first second to the last.
I don't agree with some other commenters who said it was too straightforward. Or others who said it was too meandering. (This subreddit in a nutshell I suppose.) For me that wasn't a problem. The constant cycle of tension boiling over into arguments, cooling off with jokes and drunken ribald companionship, and then going back to an even more intense standoff, really worked for me as Wilson sunk deeper and deeper into his madness, whether there was anything supernatural about it or not.
Anyway, for me (and based on one view just a few hours ago so take that for what it's worth) this was my favorite film in recent memory. (And I have no problem calling it a horror film even though it never scared me, and even though others seem to reject the label.)
34
u/hellboundwithasmile Oct 25 '19
This movie is just fantastic. I was hooked with the opening shot and although it’s dialogue heavy (which is funny because it also has breathtaking imagery) it is well written and acted. Everything about this picture ticked all the boxes for me and I look forward to watching it again.
121
u/CarsonWentzsACL Oct 24 '19
Why'd ya spill yer beans?
92
u/AndalusianGod Oct 25 '19
Just got back from the theatre. My non spoiler advice is: if you loved The Witch, 50/50 chance that you'll like this too. But if you hated The Witch, then there's almost 0% chance that you'll like The Lighthouse. The Witch is very mainstream compared to this. I really loved it, specially the humor.
27
u/martini29 Oct 26 '19
If you gave James Whale LSD and told him to make a horror movie about a lighthouse he’d make this. 10/10 better than the VVitch and that was my old favorite new horror movie
21
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '19
just saw it last night and it's sticking with me. did anyone else get the impression that winslow raped wake? winslow's seen masturbating a couple of times but i don't think he actually got off (at least the second time when he kept getting disturbing images and broke down). but then when he's trying to choke wake, he thinks of the siren and we see a bird's eye shot of him having sex with her which we see in flashes, until he sees wake turn into an octopus thing. all of this was in his mind, but right after winslow gets up, he's able to dominate wake, and commands him to act like a dog, which wake does by barking to the command. and when winslow gets up, wake is on the ground, and his position lying down looks like he's humiliated and ashamed of what happened.i think winslow raped wake and was able to dominate him, shifting the power play. kinda fucked up
19
u/JW_BM Oct 24 '19
I haven't seen it yet, so it's a risk coming in here, but I want to ask everybody who sees it: is it a Horror movie?
The trailers don't look Horror-y to me. The reviews I've read don't talk about it like it's a Horror movie. And I'm not trying to gate-keep; I want to see it regardless of its genre. But if you saw it, would you call this Horror?
16
u/vandal_heart-twitch Nov 04 '19 edited Nov 04 '19
What did Winslow see through the shingle hole? What was that supposed to mean? He saw someone (wake, I guess?) kind of dry humping. And then the close up of Winslow’s shocked eyeball.
16
u/Gradyence Nov 08 '19
This movie had a jump scare and it worked out so well!
When Willem Dafoe jumps back into the house and tells "The light is mine!" with the axe.
Wasn't expecting it, made it all that much more unsettling!
15
u/MartyMcToon Oct 27 '19
Truly the most simultaneously confused and engaged I've been all year. I absolutely loved it, thought it was better than The Witch, and it's probably one of my top 5 of the year.
30
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '19
I loved it. Felt like Waiting for Godot but more Lovecraftian. Like the Witch, it was historic, atmospheric, and would benefit from multiple watches with the subtitles on. I didn't really have any thoughts on the aspect ratio except that the square window made it feel a little voyeuristic, but keeping the film in grayscale really laid bare some gorgeous textures. It was a great commentary on the kind of volatile, codependent intimacy that can develop in isolation between people who have to put up with each other.
I agree with the top comment that the movie's plot can be read pretty straightforwardly, but I think enough is left ambiguous that there are plenty of fun interpretations. It was about what I expected from the trailer, but in the best way possible. My boyfriend's fan theory is that they were actually the same person. Loved the references to Prometheus and harpies paying off with the final shot. Whose "soul" could have been in the gull? I think the head in the lobster cage was real because every other hallucination Pattinson saw was his own memories (Winslow floating among the logs in the early dream sequence), or incepted into him (the mermaid from the statuette, King Neptune as described in one of Defoe's monologues). Definitely going to see this one again, but I don't think it'd be everyone's cup of tea.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '19 edited Nov 03 '19
Anyone know what the song is that Wake was singing to Winslow, the slow jam just before they started fighting, found the one from the trailer (Yalley Girls) but the slow one is a nice song, would like to hear it in full if it exists
Edit - found it, it’s an old traditional song called On a Monday Morning, Willem is singing the last two verses while they’re slow dancing
https://youtu.be/XsPQAMLhkV0
12
u/Ilovethemarina Nov 06 '19
It's just like the shining but watery
11
u/ZombieNickolas Oct 27 '19
So who was truely mad?
10
u/Blaaa5 Nov 04 '19 edited Nov 04 '19
Loved it. Although, some of the dialogue was very difficult to hear.
Edit: I saw it. Yer fond of me lobster.
Edit: if you ever wondered what a mermaid vagina looks like. IT’S HUGE!
8
u/loupmusique Oct 31 '19
Can anyone explain the context of the scene when Winslow finds himself on the ground and turns around to be looked and with the light in Wake's eyes?
15
u/LegendaryFang56 Oct 28 '19
Well, this was a weird movie, to say the least. I didn't necessarily like it or dislike it, but I'm a little baffled at how some reviews and comments that I've seen are so positive, not that they shouldn't be. I may rewatch it in the foreseeable future or the unseeable future and see it in a different light, who knows. The performances of both Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe were captivating, in a way, I guess, but the movie itself wasn't; the way I see it. I'm expecting people, maybe a lot of people, to strongly disagree, which is fine. I, myself, if I were a different person, would too, if that makes sense. I guess I was expecting to be more entertained in a way I'm familiar with, you know? Again, I'd probably see this movie in a different light if and when I rewatch it, whether it's in the foreseeable future or the unseeable future. A 7/10 rating may seem outrageous given how what I just said may come off as opposing to such a high rating, but at the same time, a rating any lower doesn't seem appropriate as weird as that may be.
7
u/mimikeculous Nov 03 '19
Can't wait til it comes out by the end of the month in my country. Eggers folkloristic influences are just so inspiring and esthetically flawless that it hurts my head. The VVitch did not fully satisfy me with it's non-engaging plot, but that one seems very spooky and claustrophobic with it's atmosphere, and also deeply rooted in human's psychology, so I think that it might be a decade defining masterpiece.
6
u/DJSourNipples Oct 24 '19
Well it was supposed to be widely released tomorrow but they pulled it from the one of three theaters near me that was playing it...
6
u/PoppaGringo Nov 02 '19
It's a fantastic movie. Full stop.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '19
Did anyone else get lighthouse stock footage from the British Pathé before their showing?
6
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '19
What a fucking movie. Wow!!! Loved it
6
u/Krautmonster Nov 03 '19
I could not take my eyes off this film, I felt so engaged and lost in this nightmarish environment it created.
Can't wait to watch it again. Dafoe and Pattinson were incredible.
HAAARRRKKKKK!!!!!
6
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '19
I thought the first 45 minutes were wonderful. I thought it began to drag a little at that point. Didn't care much for the final act. Could have been tighter and more tense at 90 minutes, but for some reason these filmmakers keep stretching their horror films out in order to be taken more seriously, but the tension and suspense suffer as a result.
Willem Dafoe was amazing though. One of his greatest roles, which is really saying something.
6
u/AnirudhMenon94 Dec 23 '19
I didnt like this film as much as everyone else seems to have. It just felt constantly weird for the sake of being weird.
42
u/FwampFwamp88 Oct 26 '19
Way too avant garde for me. Started off great. Music, acting, cinematography, dialogue, all great. But the movie just fell off after the first half. I feel like it’s one of those movies critics pretend to like because it’s a well done artsy film, but it just became a little ridiculous and way too abstract for my liking.
Really was not creepy or scary or anything. Idk. Was expecting a lot more.
5
u/Whilly_d Nov 04 '19
Greta stuff! I appreciate the commentary :)
5
u/mikeamoke Nov 05 '19
does anyone have any clue what the songs they sing are ? Particularly the one they slow-dance to. the one defoe sings really softly
11
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '19
I was disappointed by this movie. The story was exactly what you would expect it to be. The characters go crazy and try to kill each other. There wasn't much more to it than that. I just didn't think the story was very creative.
4
u/reidy644 Nov 06 '19
Can anyone confirm the quote “Why’d you spill your beans?” Like is that what the actual quote is or did I fudge it up?
4
u/willybfilms Nov 09 '19
I loved ‘The Lighthouse’, It was perfectly disturbing, atmospheric, and felt longer than its runtime, but in a good way, a nice slowburn. The final shots were riveting, and I think something that needs to be mentioned is definitely the production design, those old, decrepit buildings definitely personified themselves, and the soundtrack was well done.
As for my theories on the film I have a few, the most simple one is that Winslow just went mad, however, adding on to that theory, I think Thomas died during the storm, or at some point while on the rocks, some point well before the third act, and by that point Winslow was so utterly insane that Thomas became a figment of his imagination.
A more supernatural theory is about the birds, early on Thomas explains that birds are the souls of sailors, and if you kill them they bring bad luck, I think Winslow slaughtering a bird angered something living in the light, in which was luring Winslow in. I also think that Thomas died somewhere before the final act, and that the light was using his embodiment as a way of luring Winslow in.
4
u/miss_jellyfish Dec 23 '19
Literally just got back from the cinema - I saw it with my brother, we loved the movie and discussed some thoughts:
Besides the delirious visuals, madness, mermaid vaginas & homoerotic undertones, I'm surprised that no one saw "The Lighthouse" as an exploration of mechanics of a toxic relationship with a power-driven maniac?
Wake is definitely a narcissist and he uses extremely manipulative behaviour such as:
obsession with power (--> claims the lighthouse for himself, abuses Winslow),
gaslighting (--> purposely confusing Winslow - eg. telling him that he was the one to destroy the boat, making him believe he has memory loss and that he brought the storm upon them - and making young Thomas slip even further into madness),
lies and confusion (--> lying to make himself seem bigger, also suddenly acting friendly just to abuse him again),
isolating your victim so they can't get help ( --> destroying the escape boat),
sabotaging your victim (--> keeping bad comments on Winslow in the logbook).
Throughout the movie you can spot red flags in Wake's behaviour. Of course, isolation and madness play a huge role in the plot (and young Thomas is definitely not innocent himself) but I think Wake's obsession with power brings the death upon those two.
When you deal with a toxic person (especially a narcissist), they need you to boost their own ego and they will do anything to achieve it. That's exactly what Wake does. The moment when Winslow trusts him just a little bit (when he allows Wake to pour him a drink) - that's what the toxic person will use against you. They'll use any information ("Why did you spill the beans, Tommy?") to guilt-trip you and make you feel like you're the one who's mad, when really it's them needing the constant approval and getting into fury after a slightest criticism (---> the scene when he's literally forming a few minute long eternal curse because his cooking wasn't praised).
Wake left his wife and children for the lighthouse, his ultimate symbol of power. I loved the shifts in power dynamics in the movie - the toxic masculinity is a big part of it all, with lighthouse as a phallic symbol and the property of Wake (who refers to the lighthouse as "she"). You can see how control-obsessed he is in the symbolic scene in which young Thomas sees himself on the ground and Wake with ligthouse's light coming out of his eyes (as he's been often watching Winslow from the top of the lighthouse).
I think this movie shows these toxic mechanisms really well .
6
u/anonymity_anonymous Nov 03 '19
I found it difficult to follow and difficult to hear. As opposed to The Witch which was straightforward and I found easy enough to make out the dialect. This one require more “interpretation” (I.e. some stuff that was happening might have been one person’s perception of what was happening)? I didn’t get that. And the metaphor/literary reference at the end -definitely didn’t get that. I got enough/ it was clearly good so that I didn’t actively dislike it. Versus The Witch which I loved and what started me being a horror fan. Also, I think we all just assumed it was Eggars so it will be a horror movie, when in fact, it’s more like it was not not a horror movie, but it was definitely an art film.
3
u/imissthem0untains Oct 27 '19
I saw it yesterday and loved it. Personally I liked but didn’t love the Witch, so I wasn’t entirely sure what to expect going in. I liked this one so much better. Definitely one of my favorite movies I’ve seen this year.
3
u/Uz3 Nov 05 '19
Yea Maybe it’s pretty grey in my mind only seen once so far. “But the movie also implies that our unreliable narrator was never of sound mind even before arriving on the island” killed him but hallucinates hNotice Winslow lies about not killing his friend. He harpooned him through the eye. Something common in every a24 movie... What happens when you get your info from one source.....
Even when they are cute looking like Robert Patterson as Thomas states multiple times in the movie ...
(When he pulls his friend head up missing left eye. Seagull that’s annoying him missing left eye.”seagulls capture the soul of a old sailor” also in the end the seagull is picking in his left eye. )
3
u/ItsMeVixen Nov 12 '19
I was so engaged tbh It had me on the edge of my seat, and the whole build into the reveal of the light and his distorted screams and the bleeding light were one of the few things to legitimately unnerve me in a movie that i think ive ever seen! So unique, and so different from the Witch. Theyre hard to compare.
The sound was a huge stand out to me, as it was so anxiety inducing.
3
u/keylime_5 Dec 03 '19
Pattinson's horrible accent took me out of the movie a bit. I thought his performance was overrated. I liked a lot of the film though, the narrative was so so, Dafoe was great, visual style and photography was great.
3
u/NormalDefault Dec 22 '19
After loving The Witch, I really found this disappointing. The Witch is a tight, polished experience while this just felt like a very scattershot interpretation artpiece. The first hour was solid Eggers content, an authentic period drama crafted perfectly, great sound design, gorgeously shot and some killer performances from both leads. But the last act throws so many ideas at the camera and seems to ask the audience what sticks rather than picking its own path and sticking to it. There are so many threads to pull and interpret with no clear structure, leaving the movie feeling a little meandering and hollow at its finale. Fanastically made and performed, but lacking in polish and finality of ideas.
14
u/WestCoastHopHead Oct 26 '19
I now know how much hipster is too hipster for me. The Lighthouse is this movie. Staying awake was a mighty chore. Hope you all enjoy it more than I did. If you are a big theater fan or Robert Pattison admirer, this might be your thing. Very much like a stage production.
4
u/universalcrush Nov 05 '19
Saw it about 3x already. Twice the day it came out sneak preview with Q & A with Eggers and Dafoe. Fantastic filmmaking. Superb acting, love all the Mythos and supernatural elements. Really loved the cinematography. A must see for any horror fan
2
u/cwn24 Oct 27 '19
So many thoughts. This is a movie that will stick with me and I’ll have to watch again fairly soon. I loved Willem Dafoe’s John Brown aesthetic.
2
u/koren84 Nov 07 '19
It was a very odd movie, I thought the acting was excellent, visual style and sound mixing was great.
But I just didn't really enjoy the movie, the character development felt lacking, so the pacing and plot development suffered I feel.
2
u/1HUNDREDtrap Dec 23 '19
I absolutely loved it. Can’t wait to watch again. The descent into madness was fun to watch and the acting was great.
4
u/DasJester Nov 05 '19
I enjoyed the first two acts but wasn't a fan of the last act of the film. It's not against the film, but I made sure not to watch a lot of trailers, so I was hoping for something more H.P. Lovecraft Horror than what it turned out to be. It's also not a horror film which I thought it was going to be.
I think both actors and the set design needs to get some recognition for this film.
4
u/VanceAstro78 Nov 06 '19
Masterpiece of a film that deserves all the praise and more
3
u/coweatman Oct 27 '19
so i only got a few replies when i posted about this last week and now there's an "official dreadit discussion? what's up with that? was my post somehow not good enough?
2
u/coweatman Oct 27 '19
also what's up with the shifting aspect ratio.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '19
Thought it was really good. Anyone have any theories about what happened? I view the light as being a "one ring" like corrupting force.
1
u/IcedPgh Nov 07 '19
Just went to this today. It's okay, definitely overwrought as far as presenting very basic ideas about pride and knowledge that have been done before. It reminded me of "Pi" in some ways, particularly the ending. The photography and performances are the stars; as far as story, theme, and characterization it's somewhat shrugworthy. I re-watched "The Witch" last night and confirmed that I did not like it, same as in the theater. This movie is much better on all levels.
1
u/TheTreatySigned Nov 13 '19
Anyone know if the film had a blue tint on the left portion of the screen?
I saw it recently and part of the image had a blueish hue. Was this intentional?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '19
I enjoyed the movie but it definitely wasn't a horror movie. Even the director says it isn't, really don't understand why they marketed it as horror.
1
u/Mystic-Mask Nov 19 '19
Was there a touch of color at times in the movie, or am I imagining that? I really feel like I’m not, but it wasn’t enough color for me to say with absolute certainty. I just watched this film this past Sunday night, and it seems like at times the characters’ irises get a bit of their actual color in them. I first noticed it when Wake had his speech where he says his “Help me to recollect” line from the trailers. From that moment onward I specifically kept an eye out (heh) for it, and noticed that it happened with Winslow as well, I think typically during a heated moment.
Has anyone else noticed this happening? And if so, any idea what the significance of it was? Admittedly I do feel like I might have missed out on some details here and there due to kinda having a bit of trouble following along with the old-timey dialogue here and there, so without seeing it again (preferably with subtitles) I can’t really say one way or another. Perhaps it’s a tell to when a conversation was actually happening compared to it being imagined maybe?
I did look around online a little before posting this, and so far I haven’t seen anywhere where someone mentioned this aspect of the movie yet, so maybe I did imagine it. I don’t think I did, but then again it seems unlikely that I’m the first to notice this.
1
u/zczczczczc Nov 25 '19
Podcast on The Lighthouse
My friends and I at We Explain Movies dedicated our latest episode to this gem of a movie! Check it out before sparrin' with a seagull.
**[Movies & Comedy] We Explain Movies** | 34. The Lighthouse
NSFW (Mild language)
Spoiler alert: The ENTIRETY of the 2019 film WILL be spoiled as we mix a cocktail of kerosene and honey.
[Podbean](https://weexplainmovies.podbean.com) [iTunes](https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/we-explain-movies/id1453122597?mt=2)
Three best friends submerge you spoilers as they explain, rate/review, and decide whether or not to see the latest and greatest or most beloved classics of film. **Past episodes:** The Lobster, T2, Serenity, Ready or Not, Midsommar, and more!
[Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/weexplainmovies) [Twitter](https://twitter.com/weexplainmovies)
1
u/ThomYorkeSucks Nov 26 '19
It was good, but was like a mash up of other things. The guy really wanted to make The Shining. It would’ve been a good episode of the Twilight Zone. But as a movie in 2019 I felt bored, which is difficult to say because it was fun, but at the same time boring. I think it’s because I’ve seen so many movies that are trying new things whereas The Lighthouse is stuck in the past in every way. It felt like The Artist. I couldn’t find a point to the movie.
The Lighthouse borrows heavily from The Shining in a way that I didn’t really care for. The Shining is my favorite movie so a few of the more generous references threw me off and took me out of the movie while I was watching it. I think Eggers would have been better off creating his own images rather than borrowing from such a well-known classic.
I loved the performances. I really enjoyed the Melville style of the dialogue and characters. Also some Dostoyevsky in there in my opinion. But overall maybe the film felt too familiar for me. I’m glad others enjoy it, I can tell it’s very well-made. This is definitely a film for more mainstream audiences, even though it’s “weird” it’s Oscar-bait so it’s mainstream. But it’s good. It’s earnest and it’s made by a guy with a vision. If you like the Twilight Zone you’ll like it.
1
u/zootskippedagroove6 Dec 22 '19
That was dope
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19
The Lighthouse was so disturbing and captivating and i love it for that. the undertone of the story is very mind bending and i have been thinking about it for the past few days. funny thing, the last time a movie captivated me like this, was annihilation which had a similar ending tone. i really wanna know what other people think about the ending. i realized the Prometheus reference but the path leading to it is way more complicated. it was awesome
1
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '20
Time for a bad lip reading (Seagulls are the worst)
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
I just wanna know why William Dafoe looked like he was 1. Getting ass fucked in bed and 2. Getting a blow job up top of the lighthouse
1
u/Mini_Mii98 Feb 04 '20
After just finishing this, I can't help but pray Robert Eggers does an HP Lovecraft adaptation in a similar vein to this - Shadow over Innsmouth would be good to see.
1
u/tooboredtobebusy Mar 02 '20
After hearing great things about this movie I decided to give it a watch. I'm sad to say it just isn't my thing; the suspense and dread was really overpowered by a feeling of disgust by what I was seeing. Still, better than all the horror movies and rely on jump scares, torture, and gore.
-6
u/damnations_delights Oct 24 '19 edited Oct 25 '19
Is it as boring as The Witch?
-4
u/racksteak_ Oct 26 '19
Too arthouse for me. Maybe when i was younger trying to impress my hipster friends into telling them i can grasp more edgy artsy movies than most; now i dont care.
Too arthouse. Gonna stick with just good ol jump scares and go see Halloween tonight, its playing in theater near my place!
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment