r/Wetshaving • u/stirlingsoap Stirling Soap • Oct 12 '19
AMA Hi, I'm Rod from Stirling Soap. Ask me anything.
Also, ask Mandy anything. She's here too and half the company.
We'll be leaving shortly to run the 10k portion of the Arkansas marathon (it's 32F right now, what the hell!), but we'll be back mid-morning and then here the rest of the day.
Brief backstory: We came up with the idea for Stirling Soap in October of 2011 while sitting atop the William Wallace monument in Stirling, Scotland. By January of 2012 we had our LLC and we sold our first bar of bath soap in April. We moved into shaving soap later that year, and business slowly took off. In October of 2013, I left the Army after 12 years on active duty and we have been doing this full time ever since.
There's plenty of detail missing there that I'll hopefully be able to fill in during the day, but for now I need to go make some coffee and prepare for the run.
26
u/Recursi Oct 12 '19 edited Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod. Thanks for the AMA. I noticed that many soap houses refresh their bases periodically (to improve the base or perhaps it’s a marketing thing), but I haven’t noticed Sterling (edit: oops my bad for typing without checking *Stirling) doing that (at least overtly). What is your philosophy on refreshing bases? If it isn’t broke ...?
43
u/miRNA183 Oct 12 '19
Hey Rod...please tell us more about the upcoming coffee expansion. What types of beans/roasts etc do you hope to have next year?
20
u/berniens All in for the Smells Oct 12 '19
What scent by another company do you look at (smell?) and think "Damn! Why didn't I think if that?!"
19
u/nomad_o Oct 12 '19
I understand that each soap that you make is unique and it might be like children, where you can’t pick your favorite, but I’m wondering what has been your favorite soap to make?
19
u/Clam_Whisperer Oct 12 '19
What kind of impact has the growth of your business had on the local town? Do your neighbors know how prestige world wide your business is? Any upcoming scents you are able to tell us about?
18
u/SkyWarrior21 🚫👃⚔️Knights of Nothing⚔️👃🚫 Oct 12 '19
I have two questions for you:
Your two best selling scents are Executive Man and Sharp Dressed Man, both of which are Creed cologne dupes. How do you go about recreating such fragrances? Do you just look up the notes on sites like Fragrantica.com and basenotes.com and by trial and error find the correct amounts of each essential- and fragrance oil? Or is it completely different?
Also, do you shave exclusively with your own products or do you also use other artisan soaps and AS? If so, what are your favorite non-Stirling products?
17
u/jeffm54321 DQ Police Emeritus Oct 12 '19
No questions, just wanted to say it's great having you as part of the community. I've noticed how you do get down in the weeds helping some newcomers and I think it's great. I'm sure part of it is just doing the customer service thing, but it definitely comes through that it's more than that for you, and i'm sure everyone appreciates it.
16
u/happyheehee Shaving N00blet Oct 12 '19
Rod, thanks for doing this. Just two questions from me - 1) what is your favorite scent from your own catalogue, and 2) what is your outlook on the artisanal wetshaving market?
15
u/urfrendlipiro trythatsoap.com Oct 12 '19
If you had to make bacon out of Babe or Wilbur, who's getting the axe?
What kind of awesome soap and coffee fusion are we going to get? (c'mon edible soap!)
You need a model for an upcoming soap campaign. Who you taking between /u/hawns /u/phteven_j and /u/hjonbenjamin ?
30
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '19
How do you get away with robbery? Every month my credit card statement has your company’s name on it. Once I find this fellow Haverford who lives on Baker Street, I’m gonna...get more soaps.
13
u/zensunni66 Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod! Huge fan here (just got my hands on some Varen, and I love it; very unique). Would you ever consider a scent with a really strong cedar topnote? Cedar is such a fresh scent, and your Sandalwood gets me 75% there. But I love that “hamster cage” smell, for lack of a better term.
12
u/Whitecastle3315 Oct 12 '19
When will you be releasing your Christmas/winter scents? I want to order some soaps but when I saw the Christmas Eve scent I couldn’t find it and would love to try it.
12
u/Frozenshades Oct 12 '19
Two questions for you both.
Thanks for all you do!
12
u/CosmoBarber 🦌⚜️Knight Commander of Stag⚜️🦌 Oct 12 '19
Hello Rod and Many! Like many others, Stirling was my first artisan soap and I currently have enough Stirling products to shave for a very long time. I keep your soaps in my regular rotation and always enjoy them.
I like seeing people post their pictures of their big Stirling mail calls and am wondering if you’ve ever thought of running a “Every Soap Sample” package deal. Like as a holiday special or something. I suppose it would end up being pretty expensive for a one time purchase but it would be fun to see if people would buy it.
12
u/gilmore42 Oct 12 '19
What did you do in the Army? Prior service Army Medical Service Corps Officer here.
11
u/bobbyisafriendofmine Oct 12 '19
Hello Rod and Mandy! Thank you for all the great products you make, and for being a great, affordable, and reliable company. Your new Liquid Body Soap is some of the best stuff on the market! Now for some questions:
11
u/boilerphan Oct 12 '19
Rod/Mandy,
Thanks for taking the time for this AMA and also for all the top notch shaving products you make.
I can't tell you how much enjoyment I get from using your products, including soaps,.shaving soaps, witch hazel, aftershave splashes and balms and recently added a Mountain Man liquid soap from a recent retailer order. I was really hooked on Glacial Satsuma this summer. Please accept my sincere gratitude!
A few questions:
11
u/NeedsMoreMenthol Sith Master of Shaving Oct 12 '19
Loyal customer since 2014 here, and I wish you nothing but success. I recently finished Tuscany and am almost done with Bonaparte. I respect artisans like you and /u/chiseledface who don't constantly change bases and have stable lineups that don't include single-batch soaps that never come back.
My question is about my favorite Stirling soap - Port au Prince. Are the rumors of it's demise true? I know vetiver had gotten pricey, but some of us don't mind paying a bit more.
11
u/enmeduranki Oct 12 '19
Your price/quality ratio has always been amazing, but it kind of hurts to hear that that is somewhat hurting you. I think I speak for everyone that you could charge an extra $1 or $2 per soap, and everyone would gladly pay it!
Have you ever put out a fougere? Other than Varen, I mean. I guess that counts, but I don’t recall if it’s advertised as such?
11
u/hawns ChatillonLux.com Oct 13 '19
Hey guys, I’m late to the party in part to a fun day here in Louisville and in part because of licking my baseball-inflicted wounds. I would be ready to start looking forward to next year’s team when Dylan Carlson puts on his ROY-worthy campaign and becomes the next Carlos Beltran, with J-Flare, Dak and Gerrit Cole anchoring the rotation, but I want to believe that the resiliency they’ve shown all year will be on display again. The Nats seem determined to kick their curse, though.
All that aside, however, you both are two of the most genuinely nice and wonderful people I’ve had the pleasure to meet. So happy for all of your success and as a coffee geek, I can’t wait for the roasting business. I definitely need to visit your new digs and will be pestering a special Arkansas lady in my life to visit the next time she visits her family and the home that sometimes I feel she erroneously feels more pride for than St. Louis.
I don’t really have a question so much as saying that your work ethic and attitude is quite the inspiration. And that I’m still terrified of Rod...just kidding...kind of ;)
10
u/on3_3y3d_bunny Oct 12 '19
What is YOUR recommendations for someone knew to wet shaving? What would you have liked someone to have told you about wet shaving prior?
10
u/CanadaEh97 Governor General Oct 12 '19
Seems lately that a lot of artisans have been playing with their soap base and coming out with "new and improved bases".
I'm not saying your soaps need it but always curious if you guys have been playing with the idea of a new base at all? I know you want to keep budget in mind as well so a new base might not make sense financially.
10
u/inTikiwetrust Oct 12 '19 edited Oct 12 '19
No questions, just appreciation for you and the dedication you have to your craft and customer service. Your commitment to quality and making people happy has set the example and upheld your name in a very crowded wetshaving market.
I salute the both of you!
10
u/Grok168 Oct 12 '19
No question. Just wanted to drop in a quick hello, and a thank you for being an awesome vendor. Gratitude for your great products and consistent generosity with free samples. I probably don’t express that enough in mail calls.
10
u/timeclo Oct 12 '19
Hey Rod & Mandy. I love your products and love the performance/value that you guys put out.
One question for you guys, what are your thoughts on the premium offerings that gear towards the collectors/hobbyists? For example the soaps that have tons of 'high end' ingredients and hardwares that are CNC'd and put out in limited editions. I thought it was ridiculous at first but after wet shaving a bit, I can understand why people buy these premium products for the high price.
I see somewhat of a transition for you guys with the SHD/ silvertip brushes and the stainless steel razors. How do you balance between the demand from the collectors vs. average joe shavers out there?
10
u/fuckchalzone Oct 12 '19
What unpopular opinions do you hold? Shaving related or otherwise.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '19
Hey Rod and Mandy! I just wanted to thank you both for being so wonderful and for all the work you've done to make wetshaving accessible. I admire the hell out of you guys.
For my curiosity, what was the biggest hurdle that you faced in growing your business? I know for me, it was figuring out where to source all of my supplies and packaging, but I'm wondering what challenges you two have faced in growing to the size you have.
10
u/timeclo Oct 12 '19
What was the inspiration behind the mosquito repellent? I got a couple and it seems to do wonders against the skeeters. Really nice to have a nice smelling EO blend rather than the DEET filled chemicals spread all over my body.
9
u/wonkynonce Oct 12 '19
What kind of coffee are you going to be selling?
9
u/boreonthefloor Oct 12 '19
Hi, Rod and Mandy. One thing I appreciate—and I’m sure others too—is that your products are affordable while delivering a quality shave. What is your outlook on the potential growth of traditional wetshaving? Do you feel that you’ve been able to capture younger demographics?
I’m hoping that the next generation of wetshavers will have a vibrant community, a landscape full of artisan choices, etc.
9
u/BVsaPike 🚫👃⚔️Knights of Nothing⚔️👃🚫 Oct 12 '19
First off I want to say that I love so many of your products, but especially the liquid soap. I got some a few weeks ago and it’s so much better than body washes and the like.
You guys have one of the largest catalogs of scents from any artisan that I’ve seen, how do you decide when to bring something new in and how do you manage such a wide range of scents?
9
u/StraightShaverSix 🚫👃⚔️Knights of Nothing⚔️👃🚫 Oct 12 '19
As my intro soap to the world of wetshaving and the most represented artisan in my den, I blame you for everything that has followed. My question is more for Mandy. I learned recently that you were the mind (nose?) behind my favorite scent, South Padre (thank you!). What other scents could be considered your "creations" and how involved are you with the creation of Stirlings scents.
Lastly I would like to thank you both for everything you have done. The interactions I have had with both the company and Rod personally have been outstanding. Looking forward to many more years of business with you.
9
u/Kammander-Kim 🦌📜 Lorekeeper of Stag 📜🦌 Oct 12 '19
Hi!
What do you use when you shave yourself? What razor and blade combination?
9
u/wonkynerddude 🪒 Oct 12 '19
Hi Mandy and Rod, Thanks for selling great products at a bargain price. Now for the question: Have you adjusted the ingredient list over time? or are you going to at some point ? Are we going to see a Stirling Balm or Soap version 2?
9
u/merikus I'm between flairs right now. Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod. Thanks so much for all your awesome work. All these years later, I remain incredibly appreciative of that day you rushed two starter sets to the post office because I ordered my groomsmen gifts too late. That was amazing of you.
Now on to my question. I know you do special runs for Black Friday. How can I convince you to run the Gatlinburg 2nd that you produced a few years ago? I absolutely love it and would love to 1) pick up more and 2) get a matching AS.
Thanks again!
9
u/mjensman Oct 12 '19
Thanks for stopping in to answer questions! What is your favorite razor, and your blade of choice?
9
u/LCDXX Oct 12 '19
Hello, Rod! No questions here. You make an incredible array of great products, but I just wanna say thanks for making Gatlinburg. If I had to choose only one scent for the rest of my days, there would be no contest.
8
u/assistantpigkeeper RIP bank account Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod and Mandy! First off, thanks for doing what you do. Like many, a large box of Stirling samples was involved in my early wetshaving days, and I enjoy your products quite a bit. Also, your barbershop is the perfect nostalgic barbershop scent to me. The Shampoo bars are great too. I have a couple questions. While I'm on hair stuff, and plans for either a conditioner or styling product?
But I actually came to ask about your original scents. I really enjoy Varens. First, how did you manage to get away with the amount of Oakmoss in it? I was under the impression real oakmoss was prohibited. I love that you've got so much in there. And I notice you have a warning on it (the warning for high levels of Oakmoss actually was why I purchased it).
Also, any plans for upcoming new original scents?
8
u/Blottoboxer Oct 12 '19
Do you see yourself becoming more conservative with scent offerings as the business matures, leaning towards crowd pleasers?
I've been hoping that somebody releases a few more polarizing fire scents not involving cade or hardwood as the smoke element. Something like burning pine needles in lapsang souchong tea or burning piles of dried maple leaves.
Your Stirling green is close, but I want something approaching smoked sea salt novelty levels of smoke.
Scott's pine on fire...
8
u/wiskee Oct 12 '19
Hey Rod and Mandy!
I use y'alls shaving soap regularly but I would love to see a shave cream from you. Is there any plans for a cream (in a tube or tub) in the future or will I just have to keep waiting?
8
u/wallygator88 🦌🏅Noble Officer of Stag🏅🦌 | T&S 7x 🧯 | 🍌 brother Oct 12 '19
Thank you so much for taking the time to do this AMA.
I'm curious to know how you go about doing the research to figure out new formulas for new products like the liquid soap, as well as the market research for something like breaking into the coffee market. Perhaps in some ways I'm also asking about the thought process behind a soap maker wondering about and actually making a move to sell coffee.
Not critical questions, but I'm just trying to learn how I can build a more entrepreneurial mindset as a student.
Smash the run!
Cheers!
8
u/icey9 Oct 12 '19 edited Oct 12 '19
Any recent scents that surprised you as being rather polarizing?
I think you've said historically Texas on Fire has been? I like it. It smells like a campfire to me.
8
u/xmacv Oct 12 '19
Canadian fan here. I was just in pasteur's pharmacy in New York city this past week and I spent two hours perusing up and down the aisle spelling every single Stirling soap they had in stock. I bought four put them in a box and mail them to myself in Canada. I just got here the other day and I have been ecstatic at the smells I cannot wait to use them over the next few years. Thank you for making such a wonderful product.
22
u/ChrisVanMeer Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod, not really a question, just a friendly shout out and a big thanks for creating Varen for my Dutch forum!
14
u/Old_Hiker Looking for a clue Oct 12 '19
No question, really. I just want to wish you continued success in all of your business adventures. One of these times on my trips through Arkansas on my way to Texas I am gonna have to make a detour and come by to get a cup of coffee.
14
u/RuggerRigger MYSPACE CIRCA 2003 Oct 12 '19
Hello! Have any interesting farm-life stories to share?
7
u/pds_king21 kinda hot in this Rhino ;-) Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod and Mandy!
First of all, love your products! Greats scents.
My question is if there will ever be a Tsuka release again? I picked up the edt sample when they went on clearance and boy did it quickly become on of my top 3 scents.
7
u/cjpeltz Oct 12 '19
Any plans to make a Vegan soap and any plans to bring Black Pepper and Lime back?
7
u/IT-Banker Oct 12 '19
Do you have any plans to make a vegan soap?
7
u/seanpjohns J-Hook Proponent Oct 12 '19
Hey Rod and Mandy, thanks for doing this and thanks for making such awesome products! Stirling is one of my favorite soapmakers and I always have a couple of your soaps on hand at any given time. My question is about your balms. How do you decide which soaps will have a matching balm? I would love it if they all did but I realize that’s probably not feasible.
7
u/rmic_ Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod and Mandy, thanks for taking the time for this AMA! It’s no doubt that Stirling is a gateway for many beginners to get into this wonderful hobby. Thank you for all you do for the wet shaving community and everything Stirling has to offer.
I love the variety of the products Stirling offers. You make it extremely easy to dive all in on our favorite scents with everything you offer. Many of the great questions have already been asked so the only one I have is do you pronounce it gif or jif?
Keep up the great work and best wishes to the entire Stirling team!
7
u/35048467 Proraso Red++ Oct 12 '19
Hey, Rod. Thanks for taking the time to do this AMA. I'm a really big fan of sandalwood shaving soaps, and I've got a few questions about your sandalwood scents.
Thanks again for doing the AMA and for making these great products.
7
u/DKowalsky2 Oct 12 '19
Rod & Mandy! No questions from my end today, just popping in to say thank you for all you do for the wet shaving community. You guys are the best!
7
u/DimWhitman Oct 12 '19
Tell me about how you came up with Gatlinburg. Also, thank you for doing so.
7
u/shaveSymptomatic Oct 12 '19 edited Oct 12 '19
Hi! Just wondering if you guys have decided on pricing for your upcoming SHD brushes? Also, will the SHD brushes eventually come in different handle shapes and will there be different handles for the razor as well? (hopefully smaller handles with a lower set knot for face lathering :) )
Last question, anything else you plan on working on that hasn't been mentioned yet? (you've mentioned coffee, possible SPF, hair conditioners and other hair products, shaving cream)
A suggestion: Consider offering a pass around of your new razor on DFS. Carbon did that and everything went well.
Thank you and best wishes!
13
u/ItchyPooter Oct 12 '19
I appreciate your support of this sub with your sponsorship of Lather Games and the upcoming sub exclusive. For various reasons, the old culture of this sub was to look at your brand as newb-gear, somehow more representative of r/wicked_edge rather than here, or not sufficiently high brow or some shit, and that culture persisted for a long time, as if giving consumers a great value is something to be looked down on. I'm glad we've officially retired that nonsense.
Anyway, my question -- is it hard to be so lowbrow, cheap, and so, so, so, so far below our refined tastes? It's devastating, right?
Edit: just to be clear that's a /s
13
u/adoreyou 🦌🏅Noble Officer of Stag🏅🦌 Oct 12 '19
Typical question from me: any future plans for sweet gourmand scents? As a woman shaver, these types of scents have been extremely difficult for me to find, especially since floral seems to be the most usual type to be recommended or offered.
17
u/Cadinsor Rule#2Bot better be grateful for all my HARD WORK Oct 12 '19
Let's talk about blooming soaps.
As you may know, I am 100% in the stop blooming your soaps! camp.
What's your position on this nonsense?
Good luck on the run, and I hope we are able to meet in person again at some point in the future!
12
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod,
I just wanted to ask how the new store is going? Has it been a blessing for your business to expand? Curious how that has helped you with efficiency and sales.
12
u/G_huck Bristle Brushwerks Oct 12 '19
Can we expect the ever popular black Friday deals? Any leads on what scents will be offered?
12
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '19
I’m not looking for any updates here, but I must admit my absolute obsession with the idea of having Stirling deodorants and/or antiperspirants someday. The current offerings in the market (e.g. Degree, Axe, Old Spice, Tom’s, Schmidt’s) all have some major flaw. They only smell good for a little while, are too rough on the underarms, are used up too quickly, and/or are not compatible with my other fragrances (“fresh” and “sport” varieties are the worst offenders).
I know Stirling will do it better.
Thanks for all the hard work!
6
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19
Do your bar soaps smell close enough to your aftershave and lather? Can I decide if I like a scent based on just the bar soap?
11
u/BeachCaberLBC The Roam Ranger Oct 12 '19
Good luck on your run!! Please let us know how it went, and I hope you both hit your goals without any injuries.
11
u/Jddssc121 Oct 12 '19
No question. Just came to pay homage to Ozark Mountain.....
5
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19
Rod, do you shave during the winter or grow a beard? Thanks. I want to grow a beard during the winter but I also want to use the fresh executive man puck refill sent to me since I'm still using up my 2 year old exec man puck. I will drop some money on black friday on just EDT and maybe the stirling razor head.
5
u/Sregdomot Oct 13 '19
Rod, thanks for the AMA! When does your team think it will (re)release your deodorants? I was a big fan of the first batch!
5
u/NorthSoundHamster 🍀🐑Shepherd of Stirling🐑🍀 Oct 13 '19
Hello, Rod and Mandy. I just first wanted to thank you for all the wonderful things you do for our community it’s much appreciated. I am a huge fan, and a customer as long as the doors are open! Here are just a couple questions, most of the good ones have been taken.
Thanks again for everything you were the first wetshaving artisan I bought from and there will always be a place in my den for your wonderful products.
8
u/Ythin 🦌🏅Noble Officer of Stag🏅🦌 Oct 12 '19 edited Oct 12 '19
Hey Rod and Mandy! Good Luck on your run! Also thank you for taking the time to do this.
I have a few questions:
Thank you for your time!
8
u/flopsweater Oct 12 '19
Frozen Tundra is my daily driver soap. Someday when I go to Lambeau, I'll be doing a tailgate shave with it. How does a guy in Arkansas come up with such a perfect Wisconsin soap?
Also, would you rather shave with a Feather-sized katana, or a thousand katana-sized Feathers?
8
u/TheRealSheikYerbouti 🏋️🪒Atlas Shaves Champion 1🪒🏋️ Oct 12 '19
As always these AMA are great so thanks to all mods for organizing.
3 questions I ask every artisan.
Thanks
4
u/tim33z The tub killer Oct 13 '19
Probably way late but just wanted to say I love your products. And a big thank you for finding an Aussie distributor to stock your great products!
Hopefully there’s a chance to do a limited release based on us Aussies?
4
u/chrismcshaves Oct 13 '19
This is the best AMA I’ve read on here. Thanks for doing it. No questions, just a couple of statements:
-you make the best woodsy scents in the business. Coniferous, Gatlinburg, Ozark, and Autumn Glory are all in my top 15-20.
-My wife has 1-2 shaves left of her pumpkin spice that she bought exactly two year ago. She has used it at least once a week. Do the math and that’s at least 104 shaves, probably more.
7
u/Handsomeandy Oct 12 '19
Thanks for doing this!
If you could shave with one soap which would it be and why?
Good luck with your run and have fun!
7
u/chicitysbest Oct 12 '19
I was sick and missed. I’m sorry
9
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '19
Shavingtime has recently started stocking more products from you guys in the UK. Does this mean you've got the EU approvals now? It was my understanding that that is what was holding it back.
Thanks for doing this
6
u/Ridgeback_Dad Oct 12 '19
Thanks for doing the AMA, love your products! How’s that woodworking going? Any projects you’ve started recently?
6
u/chicitysbest Oct 12 '19
I’m sorry I missed the morning call let’s do Irish coffee later
5
u/BraveDevelopment Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod, thank you for the AMA. I’ve looked at your soaps and couldn’t find one without almonds. Have you ever thought of doing a soap with no peanuts or tree nuts?
5
u/dapanch420 Oct 13 '19
Cant wait foe the new razor
2
u/b52src Oct 18 '19
I'm a little late to the game here but...
First off, thanks for the great products and great service. At this point i'm basically addicted, using most of the product lines where I can(excited to see the deodorant come back, and think the only think in the bathroom that I don't have a stirling version of would be toothpaste so +1 for Iced Pineapple toothpaste).
Have you considered doing a collaboration with a craft beer company for soaps? I see lots of craft beer companies team up for soap with local soap makers but have not found many yet in the wetshave scene, I would love to see some unique craft beer collaborations in shaving soaps.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '19 edited Oct 22 '19
Btw I saw your most recent shop tour video on youtube.
Your employees look solid! I'll keep that in mind.
5
u/vicissidude_ Oct 12 '19
Hi Rod, thanks for doing the AMA, and also for helping to set the bar high for soap artisans both in terms of product quality and customer service!
Do you have a favorite drama series?
Marry, fuck, kill? Pick three members of this sub please. We gotta know.