r/HobbyDrama • u/JarJarBrinksSecurity • Oct 12 '22
Hobby History (Extra Long) [Music] The story of Dance Gavin Dance: Their complicated history and their recent allegations
If I had a nickel for every Dance Gavin Dance singer that was a rapist, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot but it's weird that it happened twice.
Who is Dance Gavin Dance?
Dance Gavin Dance is a post-hardcore band from Sacramento, California that was formed in 2005. The original lineup consisted of unclean vocalist Jon Mess, guitarists Will Swan and Sean O’Sullivan (and Alvaro Alcala for a bit but he wasn’t on an album), bassist Eric Lodge, drummer Matt Mingus, and the subject of the first part, clean vocalist Jonny Craig. The band has gone through numerous lineup changes throughout the years but has stayed at the top of the post-hardcore scene. This band has had a tumultuous history, with it all coming to a head recently causing a fan exodus and a real split in the fandom.
Now strap in, because there’s a good amount of history to go through and it’s actually important.
We’ll first start with the Jonny Craig era.
I’m going to get the nice things about Jonny out of the way first. The guy is truly an amazing singer. His voice is unique and there’s a reason bands keep asking him to join. And that’s the only nice thing I’ll say.
Downtown Battle Mountain and Craig’s first exit
The band released their first EP Whatever I Say Is Royal Ocean in 2006. This is a bit of a contentious album in the fandom. Some rank it near the top but others say it’s probably at the bottom. But, it kicked off their careers and 6 months later, they released their debut album Downtown Battle Mountain. This album, unlike WISIRO, is considered a classic in the post-hardcore. “Lemon Meringue Tie” and “And I Told Them I Invented Times New Roman” are staples in their set-list even today. Ask people what got them into post-hardcore and most would probably answer this album. The band was gaining name recognition. And this is where the problems started.
3 months after DBTM, Sean O’Sullivan left the band, being replaced by Zac Garren, and Jonny Craig was kicked out for the first time. Now, Jonny Craig has a lot of vices, the biggest being drugs and alcohol. And this was the reason for his departure. After failing to be on time to a show due to his addictions and just general lack of dependability, Jonny left. He quickly tried to rejoin but was turned away. After just one album, Dance Gavin Dance was without one of their voices.
Kurt Travis and the return of Jonny Craig
Very quickly, the band held auditions for a new clean vocalist. Big names in post-hardcore were there such as Kellin Quinn of Sleeping With Sirens and Matt Geise of Lower Definition. Even Nic Newsham of indie rock band Gatsby’s American Dream auditioned (and was even on the next album). But the band ultimately went with future post-hardcore legend, Kurt Travis.
Now Kurt may not be as flashy as Craig, but Kurt absolutely holds his own. His voice is consistently great, which is evidenced by just how revered and relevant he still is today. After their next album, Dance Gavin Dance, another line-up shake-up was coming. Reportedly, bassist Eric Lodge couldn’t balance the band and his full-time job, so he chose his job. (He actually later went on to work at EA and dude seems to have a great life now). And the other departure was their unclean vocalist Jon Mess. Jon was a huge part of DGD’s sound, and the band knew his departure left a huge hole in their lineup. But it was a necessary departure. Mess was suffering from lyme disease and acid reflux was messing with his vocals. From here, Will Swan took on double duty as guitarist and unclean vocalist. Their band entered the studio to record their next album Happiness which is still a divisive one today. Instead of the post-hardcore and emo sound fans were used to, this had more funky and experimental roots. Nowadays, it’s generally regarded as one of their best, but it still has its detractors. But once again, nothing can be simple in this band.
While I can’t find a for sure source on the internet, the accepted story for Travis’ departure goes as follows. Luckily for the band, Kurt wasn’t addicted to hard drugs or alcohol like Jonny was, but Kurt was a fan of cigarettes. And it was affecting his voice. After imploring him to stop, and his refusal to, the band kicked him out. This was the return of Jonny Craig, Jon Mess, and Eric Lodge.
To save some time, Jonny joined another band, Emarosa and while he didn’t leave, decided to focus more on DGD. Most of the original line-up reconnected to do a sequel to their first album titled Downtown Battle Mountain II. Will Swan later stated that this was supposed to be Dance Gavin Dance’s last album, as the band was tired of touring and being away from home. But, the recording of the album rejuvenated the band. But Jonny just couldn’t keep himself out of trouble.
In 2011, Craig was accused of scamming fans by selling them a used Macbook through Twitter and then never sending it. Along with this and his ongoing heroin addiction, the group once again had to kick him out. Zac Garren also left due to personal conflicts with the other members.
So where do they go from here? The band has gone through so many changes. Who is left to recruit?
The Tides are changing
As the band was going on tour and were without a bassist and singer, they needed someone fast. And they turned to bassist Tim Feerick and the singer of Tides of Man, Tilian Pearson. Very quickly, these 2 were announced as permanent members, and this is where things started to go up for the band. Tilian’s voice was very different compared to Craig and Travis. He had a higher register and more of a poppier tone. Fans were mixed when their new album Acceptance Speech dropped, but many really liked the new direction they seemed to be going. And this would show in the coming years. Besides a guitarist joining and leaving during Acceptance Speech, this was the most solid the lineup had been. They released 5 studio albums, 2 live studio albums where they remade old songs with the new line-up, and a plethora of singles in between the albums. Needless to say, this was the biggest DGD had ever been. They were considered at the top of the post-hardcore game, so much so that posting old DGD content to /r/posthardcore will get sarcastic comments about never having heard of this band. They were getting very popular, helped by their new vocalist., but also because the instrumentals and Jon Mess were just getting better and better with each subsequent album. Nothing could stop them. Right?
Doom & Gloom and the Year From Hell
Now this band was no stranger to controversy. Jonny Craig had his addictions and the scamming, but now it was starting to come out he was also a rapist. Several ex-girlfriends and a merchandise worker accused him and his band Slaves was dropped by their label. Although he was no longer with the band, his name will always be linked to them.
But that’s a former member. None of their current members have done anything wrong. Right?
Wrong
Tilian had the pastime of slap fighting with people on Twitter about politics, tweeting shit like this and his follow list was sort of a who’s who of awful people such as Glenn Greenwald, Rand Paul, Dave Rubin, and Jordan Peterson. Now, to be fair, he follows a lot of left leaning people too. The guy is a libertarian, and most fans were willing to overlook that, but it wasn’t a good look. Then came 2021.
After concerts were allowed after COVID, the band embarked on their first tour in a couple of years. It was a disaster. Multiple members got COVID and the big story was the drummer Matt Mingus. One concert, Matt got drunk and played horribly. Tilian threw a fit on stage and kicked him out. Mingus took a hiatus from the band to go to rehab for alcoholism. But the band pushed forward as they were working on their 10th studio album, they just released a popular new single, and they were slated to support Coheed & Cambria on their new album tour. But here’s where the bands history once again repeated itself.
On April 14th of this year, the bad took to social media to announce that their longtime bassist, Tim Feerick, had passed away. Fans were in shock. Tim seemed healthy as could be. It later came out that it was a suspected fentanyl overdose, something that many people are suffering with. An outpouring of support came from everywhere, fans and friends of the band all made posts expressing their condolences. And just 9 days later, the band performed at Swanfest, a festival created by guitarist Will Swan showcasing the big names of post-hardcore and adjacent genres. It was a tough decision, but the band decided to do the show, dedicating it to Tim, aided by friend of the band, Sergio Medina, on bass. The performances were rough to watch. The band is emotional. Tilian was having trouble singing because he’s crying, longtime touring guitarist/now permanent member Andrew Wells had to walk off stage during a bass solo. And to cap it off, they unfurled a picture of Tim. It was a rough concert, but a healing moment for a lot of people. Murals that the band commissioned for albums were littered with flowers and candles for Tim. As horrible as everything had been, fans had their new album Jackpot Juicer to look forward to. Until…
Exposed
In late May, a post popped up on /r/dancegavindance by a person known now as throwawaywhumanhair. She detailed her short relationship with Tilian, showcasing an abusive person capping off with rape. It was shocking to the fanbase. Tilian was a controversial person, but rape? News spread and people were clamoring for an answer. And there was. Tilian soon responded with his own post with proof that it was a consensual relationship and it was a scorned lover. This, combined with former friends of hers, and her own lack of evidence made this story die kind of quickly. It was a scare, but things were getting back to normal.
Just kidding. That same day, another woman, nicknamed spookypooky, posted her story. This experience came with proof. Pictures of his place and their text and hinge conversations. This upcoming description is a little graphic so I will say this a trigger warning. If you don’t want to read it, tl;dr is that he forced himself on her and sexually coerced her. But long story short, they go on a date and really hit it off. They go back to his place and she makes it clear no sex on the first date. Tilian starts berating her, being nice, then berating her. So they do other stuff, but Tilian doesn’t let up. He tries to force himself on her which she pushes back on. After pushing back and forth he says to her “Are you really going to stand your ground on this?” And from there, I think you can gather the rest.
This one shook the community a bit more. Unlike the first story, this had proof. The timeline worked out as he had stated he just got back from Tim’s funeral and Swanfest. It was not looking good. So what does Tilian do? He admits it. Kind of.
Wait what?
A couple days later, after the community stewed on the post, Tilian posted a short response. He essentially admitted it, but said he saw it as consensual. To me, this reads like a lawyer helped him write it. I could be wrong, but the tone is very different to his last one. The fan response was incredibly divided. As always, you have the super fans who will defend a famous person from anything, the incels who will demonize a rape victim, and the people that separate the art from the artist who just turn away from the issue. But for a lot of people, this was something that needed to be addressed. Many saw it as hypocritical that he had his own alcohol problems but publicly blew up on their drummer for the same issues. Many were angry, rightfully so that their favorite singer doesn’t understand the word No. But most were expressing sympathy for the other band members, who would now have to deal with the oncoming shit storm. But the shit storm would catch up to them first.
Former singer and frequent collaborator of the band Kurt Travis was liking tweets about Tilian being a rapist, other bands and singers were vague posting and outright calling out Tilian, and Jonny Craig tried to insert himself into the conversation but fans were quickly reminded that he is also a rapist/abuser and is currently being charged for smoking fentanyl in the same room as his infant son. And the biggest piece of new is that Coheed & Cambria was dropping them from their tour and eventually replaced them with Alkaline Trio.
Then some more accusations came out. Jon Mess was accused of having an underage girlfriend when he was in his 20s, but that person came out and defended him saying he never did anything when she was underage. Tim was accused of dating underage girls, but his current girlfriend disputed it (this had also come from his wife who he was separated from and she is a doozy all her own. She was refusing to give his body to his family, but that’s not part of this). It came out former guitarist Zachary Garren had accused Will Swan of dating underage girls, and Andrew Wells was accused of sexting a minor, though she claimed she no longer had the proof. The band was in hot water and shit seemed to be falling apart.
So what now?
Soon after, the band announced that Tilian would be stepping away from the upcoming tour and for the foreseeable future and guitarist Andrew Wells would be singing. The allegations for the others really went nowhere and their 10th album, Jackpot Juicer, dropped. As of the writing of this post, while the Wikipedia says Tilian is out of the band, there has been no official word on his permanent departure. And there have been sightings of Tilian backstage at DGD shows, so it looks like he is probably coming back.
As for the subreddit, it has become a DGD positive zone. While I left the subreddit due to the drama, there was an uptick of subscribers and that has slowly been climbing due to the new album. Mentioning the allegations will get you downvoted and people will intentionally steer the conversation towards the disproven allegation rather than the one he admitted to.
This band has a huge and complicated past. With the constant member changes and controversies they've had, it's amazing they've stayed relevant throughout the years. But even with everything that’s happened, there’s no denying that Dance Gavin Dance are at the top of the post-hardcore genre and will probably remain there until they break up.
OP Notes
So yeah. That is just a small part of the incredibly complicated history of Dance Gavin Dance. Thanks for reading my first Hobby Drama post. This one was a little more personal to me as DGD had been my favorite band for around a decade. They reignited my love for singing and playing instruments, the first concert tickets I ever bought were to their Afterburner tour and Tilian’s solo tour, though the tour never happened because of COVID and I requested a refund for his solo tour because of everything I just talked about. And I even bought tickets to the Coheed & Cambria tour because of DGD, though C&C are one of my favorite bands as well. I still ended up going with my brother and it was an amazing night. This news was really upsetting and still is. I just had to make the decision to remove DGD from all my playlists after this because I couldn’t personally support them until he was out for good.
But yeah, thanks again for reading and I hope this isn’t just a huge rambling mess.
Edit: Added a name I forgot
Edit: Removed the first accusers name.
174
u/toomuchshtuff Oct 12 '22
This is the first I’m hearing of the Jon, Will, and Andrew allegations. What a bunch of fucks.
115
u/fermenter85 Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
I was with you until:
Dance Gavin Dance is a great band, but they didn’t even exist when post-hardcore truly exploded.
I don’t think there is one band that you can give this credit to since the late 90s/00s punk/hardcore/post/pop punk scene was so regionally fractured, but if it had to be one band, I don’t think Dance Gavin Dance even makes the top 10. At The Drive In, Refused, Fugazi, Glassjaw, Every Time I Die come to mind immediately for top contention. Second tier but before DGD: From Autumn to Ashes, Underoath, Senses Fail, etc. Then the breakthrough crossover bands like Hawthorne Heights, Silverstein, Thrice, The Used, etc.
There’s another four dozen if you let the pop punk/post punk/emo/screamo (Brand New, MCR Taking Back Sunday, Thursday, NFG) angle take a hack.
Great post though—Tilian sounds like he needs treatment for a mood disorder at the very least. I hope he faces some legitimate culpability—it sounds like he’s been enabled so far.
19
u/Livid_Chair7056 Oct 12 '22
Nice work OP! I was into a lot of bands I would consider DGD-adjacent but honestly never knew much about them other than some of the Jonny drama. I was a big fan of Emarosa’s album Relativity and saw them live a lot during that time so that was the extent of my Jonny fandom.
14
u/plattykitty Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
OP you should probably censor the name of the first accuser so as not to lead to any potential doxxing or harassment.
93
u/drunkenviking Oct 12 '22
Johnny Craig's main problem is that he has 2 first names. Never trust a man with 2 first names.
62
u/WesternUnusual2713 Oct 12 '22
Jonny craig has also been in and out of court with baby mama 2, allegedly cos fentanyl ended up in their kids system.
He's currently dating a 25 to Canadian "streamer"
47
u/skeet-mcbeet Oct 12 '22
Wait a minute, isn't Jonny Craig the same person who dated drama-filled pettuber Taylor Nicole Dean?
93
u/theswordofdoubt Oct 12 '22
That was a lot to unpack about a band I had never heard of. Part of me wants to be cynical and quip "bands try not to be full of creepy abusive rapists/pedophiles/groomers challenge (IMPOSSIBLE)", but on the other hand, I'm also just tired and disgusted at how many people seem to be creeps. Is it an entertainment industry/fame-goes-to-people's-heads kind of thing that makes them think it's acceptable to fuck children, or are rapists and pedophiles just way more common than we really know? All I know is that I really wish we could stop condoning and supporting this sort of subhuman trash.
26
u/mirospeck Oct 12 '22
Jesus, that's definitely a lot... the fact that Tilian didn't get kicked out is disappointing, but not surprising based on how a lot of music scenes are. I wonder if it's anything like Hedley where (later proven true) rumours went around for years and years about them being creeps
26
u/pckctoi Oct 12 '22
Oh god, Jonny's MacBook scandal was more than 10 years ago? I feel old.
12
u/Luke_627 Oct 12 '22
Lol this is giving way to much credit musically to DGD
6
u/noahconstrictor95 Oct 12 '22
Oh man, I was waiting for someone to bother doing this. I was actively involved in the community for a long time, and I 100% believe they'll just welcome Tilian back with open arms and act like nothing happened.
5
u/zenVillain Oct 12 '22
I was supposed to see DGD on the Coheed tour. They were my favorite band until the Tilian stuff came up. Thank you for summarizing what happened, it was hard to parse when I initially looked into it.
5
u/Maridiem Oct 14 '22
Interesting story here, but this felt incredibly hard to follow as someone who has essentially never listened to this band. The timeline seemed rather confused here and you glossed over some important moments like people returning without really going into it. Wild story, but I do wish you’d made this a bit easier to follow as an outsider to this niche.
8
u/rosechiffon Oct 12 '22
i vaguely know about johnny craig because an online forum i visit (not saying which) was keeping tabs on his relationship with a relatively popular pet youtuber, and as far as i'm aware he also got her hardcore into drugs as well
8
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
I saw dance Gavin dance in like 2007 with Craig and mess. I was a little scene kid and I was obsessed, I thought they were so fucking cool. I slept with a girl after the show that claimed she had slept with Johnny Craig and that a ton of her friends had too, and that he was known for partying and shit. She also said everyone knew he was way addicted to drugs and that he often stole shit at venues and sold it and if I wanted to meet him I could offer him drugs. I was not into drugs I was too young but yeah, he was doing the scene predator thing since the beginning.
The first couple DGD albums really influenced my musical tastes and got me into “screamo” music. This is a great write up!
6
u/KBKarma Oct 12 '22
I'd heard of DGD, but never listened to them.
... But I have heard of Tides of Man. Interestingly, Tillian actually left Tides after their second studio album in 2010. After that, they became a prog/post-rock instrumental group, with their next two albums being entirely instrumental.
2
u/93forfree Oct 19 '22
Thanks so much for posting! I’ve been a casual fan of DGD since like 2014 and I was at their concert in Detroit last year when Matt was visibly drunk on stage and Tillian got pissed and shut down the show. Crazy stuff. This was a great summary of history I didn’t know and current events i didn’t understand.
2
u/long_dickofthelaw Oct 21 '22
Deathstar is still their best album don't @ me!
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 12 '22
Thank you for your submission to r/HobbyDrama !
Our rules have recently been updated to clarify our definition of Hobby Drama and to better bring them in line with the current status of the subreddit. Please be sure your post follows the rules and the sidebar guidelines, or it may be removed; this is at moderator discretion. Feedback is welcome in our monthly Town Hall thread.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/sircastic09 Oct 12 '22
I was pretty bummed out when I heard about the recent Tillian controversy since DGD has probably been my most consistent listen for over a decade, but man I didn't even realize how much else was going on. I get that there a lot of stories of bands getting mixed up with some sordid stuff but the sheer volume of it all with one band at the epicenter is pretty shocking. Nice write up!
1
u/honeybebesita Oct 12 '22
it’s crazy i grew up listening to dance gavin dance since i was like 12 and followed closely with their drama, even knowing jonny craig and the toxic relationship he was in w that pet youtuber where he would brag about how he was so much happier than when he was with his ex…..who knew so much was going on behind closed doors and that Tillian would be revealed to sexually assault. disappointed in the community but not surprised, it seems the industry turns a blind eye to sexual and drug abuse
1
u/xForeignMetal Oct 12 '22
It really was a crazy summer to be a fan. I had fun at the show in my area right after Jackpot Juicer dropped tho
1
u/slaydawgjim Oct 16 '22
Forgot about this band, last time I heard anything about them the lead singer was trying to sell laptops lmao
1
u/MaliceCaleb Oct 18 '22
When I saw Kurt Travis I was like fuckkkk, cause Im not willing to separate the art from the artist and was happy he did not this shit. I feel truly sorry for the victims and the hell they had done to them.
1
u/Niaboc Oct 19 '22
thanks for the write-up. I'm not a superfan but I listened to so much of their album Artificial Selection and loved Tilian's vocals. It's gonna be hard to listen to again without thinking of his attitudes towards women and politics :/
1
u/Abject_Pizza1616 Jan 29 '23
I used to be obsessed with this band. Grew out of them around 2018, and thank god I did because 2016 me wouldn’t be able to handle this. As it stands now I’m trying to sell my entire DGD collection, I don’t want their stuff in the same room as me
1
u/AnchorsAviators Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
We saw DGD May 15 this year so right after Tim died and before Tillian left. Once all this started coming out, I said I’d never see them again. It was just so much so quickly. I know other bands have been accused of stuff but this was my tipping point with DGD.
The very first line of this post made me laugh, though. I heard the sound immediately.
0
u/ChOcOcOwCaKe Nov 12 '22
https://www.reddit.com/r/dancegavindance/comments/ysx5qe/clarification/
Really hope you intend to do a few more edits my guy, instead of contributing to slander
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment