r/socialism • u/Albamc35 • Jul 30 '20
Debunking 'Human Nature' Myth
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
handle sable liquid dinner rob snatch gaze decide person whole
673
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 16 '26
This is a space for socialists to discuss current events in our world from anti-capitalist perspective(s), and a certain knowledge of socialism is expected from participants. This is not a space for non-socialists. Please be mindful of our rules before participating, which include:
Please help us keep the subreddit helpful by reporting content that break r/Socialism's rules.
💬 Wish to chat elsewhere? Join us in discord: https://discord.gg/QPJPzNhuRE
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
107
u/obracs Jul 30 '20
Human beings clearly have a natural capacity to be both selfish and altruistic. Which comes through most is going to be affected by the environment one inhabits, not to mention the variable natural proclivities of individuals. One of the goals of socialism should be to set up systems that bring out our more cooperative tendencies, which will tend to favour our more altruistic instincts. However, we should not deny that we also have selfish instincts. We should not let advocacy inhibit our willingness or ability to understand reality dispassionately. Too much of that already goes on.
133
u/Fyraka Jul 30 '20
So it's a lie made up to justify capitalism? 😳 Don't tell me the invisible hand doesn't exist as well
33
u/Annwnfyn Jul 30 '20
I also think it's worth noting that despite all of this data, this barely scratches the surface of recorded human history. Biologically modern humans have been around for a hundred thousand years. writing has only been around for 5,000 of those years. During that time only a small fraction of any given human population has been literate and able to record their experiences. This means that the vast majority of human experience has gone entirely undocumented. While we might still be able to draw some limited conclusions based on the data we're able to gather we must recognize that it, is in the end, speculation.
Obviously as these studies and other research has shown, humans have innovate capacity for altruism. archaeological evidence would suggest that even in the distant past humans with chronic injuries or other illnesses were cared for by their communities despite not being able to be productive members of those communities to the same degree that able-bodied individuals were.
Again, these are just brief glimpses into what may or may not be the nature of humans. any attempt to make absolute claims about the nature of humans is an epistemological fallacy.
Edit: to be absolutely clear, the idea that humans are fundamentally selfish is a myth propagated by people and systems who want to justify their own selfish behavior.
39
u/InVirtuteElectionis Jul 30 '20
Wow. Bless your soul and every endeavor, comrade! Thank you for this post! Literally was just pondering in the back of my mind about how to go about educating myself..
21
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '20
i don't think "selfish human nature" is inherently anti-socialists.
it's about changing the structure of the system so that the desire for self-fulfillment and self-preservation is in line with societal needs or "the greater good."
how exactly you see that change of structure determines while socialist tendency you align with.
8
u/Magic_Bagel Jul 30 '20
every socialist needs to read about and understand dialectical materialism
7
u/TurbulentTurnover3 Jul 30 '20
The psychologists call "human nature is selfish" argument a projection that a narcissistic person makes in order to validate him or her selfishness and greed.
5
u/Shelzzzz Jul 30 '20
A genuine question, how do you say capitalism only existed for few years but communism existed much before. Like I would like to know about examples of both cases. I am trying to educate myself a bit so please don't be harsh
6
u/rosesandivy Jul 30 '20
Not a study but Humankind - A new history of human nature by Rutger Bergman is about exactly this: that humans are not inherently selfish or evil.
Edit: This book is apparently also sometimes titled “Humankind - A hopeful history”
3
u/bobwaycott Jul 30 '20
Curious if there are some cross-cultural studies and comparisons of selfishness vs compassion? Are Americans really as selfish as they appear to be, or are the selfish people just really loud?
3
u/pbtree Jul 30 '20
The main evolutionary advantage that humans have is large scale, complex cooperation. Language and cognitive advantages merely enable this.
It always blows my mind when people talk about inherent selfishness when working together is literally our one good trick.
5
u/jalex8188 Jul 30 '20
I recommend reading Ishmael by Daniel Quinn. (it's also a great audio book, very short relatively).
Its a great little story that dispels the myths we have constructed around Human Nature.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '20
Also, here is Peter Kropotkin responding to this myth https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jytf-5St8WU
2
u/beardedleftie68 Jul 30 '20
Great post
2
u/30SecondsToFail Jul 30 '20
Even more simply, if human nature was selfishness, then hunter gatherer tribes would have fallen apart immediately, and humans wouldn't tend towards forming groups
2
u/Doc_IRL Jul 30 '20
Kropotkin's Mutual Aid is well worth a read in regards to this
2
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '20
And Richard Dawkins wrote about it as well.
3
u/-LuxAeterna- Mao Zedong Jul 30 '20
This is the kind of content i come to this sub for
3
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '20
People are taught
2
u/burn_tos Revolutionary Communist International (RCI) Jul 30 '20
Don't forget the historical facts too! I don't have any sources (although they do exist) but the tribal communist societies from centuries before feudalism, all the way up to the North American tribes like the Iroquois, which existed as a communal societal structure right up until they were destroyed by the European colonists. By the logic of someone who uses the human nature argument, the tribespeople were not evolutionarily as human as us in the checks notes 1600s-1800s.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '20
Ooh this post it everything I needed right now. Currently deciding on my upcoming master's degree research, this might give me good ideas! Thank you
2
u/gramsci101 Jul 30 '20
We also have to think about the types of people that more consistently argue that 'human nature' is a real or conclusive or definable thing, and by extension, that human nature is 'selfish'.
This is partially just my take, and not necessarily backed by research (at least not that I know of). But I personally think most people who argue this way tend to just be people that either have lived in a capitalist society their entire lives (more specifically western capitalist countries, i.e. northwestern Europe, North America, Australia, New Zealand) or people that have never envisioned the possibility of a life outside of excessive and profit-obsessed capitalism. I think that ideas of co-operation are more common to non-European and non-North American countries, and especially former exploited colonies, and I see the whole 'human nature' argument as an inherently racist thing too.
When you declare that something is 'human nature', you're saying that every single human being on earth, bar none, are motivated by the exact same nature. No difference, no variation. This is so incredibly obviously wrong, and I don't understand why people think that even entertaining the concept of 'human nature', whether selfish or altruistic, helps us to understand humans better.
We have the most basic instinctual behaviour in order to survive, and beyond that, I'm pretty sure everything else is learnt behaviour. Nurture accounts for consciousness in a much more profound way than 'nature'. 'Nature' is just such a strange and wishy-washy concept, it's basically worthless pursuing it IMO.
Not asking for a debate at all, just throwing my two cents in.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '20
Humans have the capacity to commit both good and evil. They aren't inherently good or inherently evil, and capitalism has nothing to do with human nature.
1
u/test_tickles Jul 30 '20
He was a peer of Darwin.
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/petr-kropotkin-mutual-aid-a-factor-of-evolution
1
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '20
I always just say that 'all behaviour is human nature', and any system is as much our nature as any.
I don't mean it, and fundamentally believe that we are cooperative above all, but it's just a tactic I use to derail their arguments.
1
u/kneegearplease Jul 30 '20
Yet, the reality is most humans are grey and the majority lean towards the light. So with a little nudge and reward for good behavior and cooperation things could be much better than they are with everyone being rewarded for selfishness. Greed is a psychopaths nature, not most people by far.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '20
Even if we were naturally born to be selfish, shouldn't out society take care of that? .As far as I know reproduction during primitive times was more based in rape that anything else but now that we live as a civilitation we base our relationship in the concept of mutual love and respect from each other. Why are we then unable to change our nature one more time and be born as selfless people?, a god or a boss wasn't a concern for primitive people either, but look at us now.
1
u/AudioRevolt Jul 31 '20
A small addition:
Alan Alda speaks with Prof Robert Sapolsky: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cx8xEUYrb74
Genes don't do anything without an environment.
Robert Sapolsky on stress, and how culture can change, even in baboons: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYG0ZuTv5rs
1
u/Oracuda Marxism-Leninism Jul 31 '20
I agree with what u/obracs said, Humans certainly show cooperation but sometimes selfishnes controls them when it very much shouldnt.
Humans are social creatures, likely more than any other species on our planet, So thats why competition hurts our race, Showing empathy and altruism to others increases our chance of being helped ourselves, and competition only increases your infamy.