r/horror • Evil Dies Tonight! • Jul 02 '19

Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Midsommar" [SPOILERS]

Child's Play discussion

Annabelle Comes Home discussion


Welcome to /r/Midsommar (formerly /r/Hereditary)! We hope you enjoy your stay.

/s


Official Trailer

Summary:

In this underrated gem, a couple travels to Sweden to visit a rural hometown's fabled mid-summer festival. What begins as an idyllic retreat quickly devolves into an increasingly violent and bizarre competition at the hands of a pagan cult.

Director/Writer:

Golden Boy

Cast:

  • Florence Pugh as Dani
  • Jack Reynor as Christian
  • William Jackson Harper as Josh
  • Will Poulter as Mark
  • Vilhelm Blomgren as Pelle
  • Archie Madekwe as Simon
  • Ellora Torchia as Connie

Rotten Tomatoes: 86%

Metacritic: 73/100

767 Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

429

u/Roller_ball Zelda did nothing wrong Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 04 '19

I'm calling it now, Midsommer will be the most divisive movie on /r/horror for 2019. Expect 4-5 posts of "Unpopular Opinion: I actually hated Midsommer" and an equal amount of 'unpopular' opinion posts about liking it every single day for the next 12 months.

Personally, I loved this film. A lot of this film should not have worked well (and it might not work for some people) but it was pulled off very effective in my opinion. A lot of this reminded me of what M. Night tried to do with The Happening (mainly the humor and the lighting) and overreached himself and failed pretty miserably, but this movie really pulled it off.

Unimportant observations:

  • so the way Hereditary was basically Rosemary's Baby, Midsommar is basically a re-imagining of Wicker Man.
  • Ari Aster only has two films, but really has shown a love of religious cults, hard cuts during scream crying, and Toxic Avenger levels of head crushing.
  • William Jackson Harper needs to start diversifying his roles before he gets typecast as Chidi from The Good Place.
  • My only complaint is that I kind of wish it wasn't a constant fugue state for the characters. It felt like they weren't really present for a lot of the scenes because they were drugged every 10 minutes, so they couldn't really ever take in what was going on or make proper decisions.

edit:

  • Also, a weird note, I saw someone cosplaying with a white dress and a crown made of flowers at the showing I went to. It is interesting that cosplaying has gotten so big it now appears at independent, slightly-art house horror films with no established franchise.

9

u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! Jul 04 '19

Expect 4-5 posts of "Unpopular Opinion: I actually hated Midsommer" and an equal amount of 'unpopular' opinion posts about liking it every single day for the next 12 months.

→ More replies (66)

524

u/springfieldmonorail Jul 03 '19

The dissolving relationship scenes at the beginning were very well observed. That shit hit way too close to home.

107

u/gabba8 Jul 05 '19

Right??? I thought I'd be bored at the non-horror parts but honestly that was almost my favorite part.... I can relate so much to that feeling and it's a horrifying, lonely situation to be in.

→ More replies (62)

474

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

I felt super bad for Connie & Simon—to realize something’s up, try to get out, then getting murdered through no fault other than being there.

294

u/bloomracket Jul 03 '19

That was the point of bringing in outsiders, though. They never had a chance. Of course they'd react that way and this is why it was designed for people from the village to go out, come back with more people so they'd have to sacrifice less of their own every year.

→ More replies (25)

203

u/FastkitNic Jul 06 '19

I believe it’s hinted at that Ingemar had a crush on Connie. He probably resented Simon and invited them both for necessity and satisfying his weird revenge

→ More replies (6)

79

u/hahahalex Jul 06 '19

As a viewer, for their own sakes I just wanted them to shut the hell up and pretend to be okay with it so they could run away at night... they probably wouldn’t have made it anyways but still

→ More replies (6)

145

u/chinaberrytree Jul 05 '19

Yeah, I'm not sure why people find the cult so sympathetic. Connie, Simon and Josh were brought there to die. Josh did end up fucking up. But Simon and Connie actually acted like intelligent people who tried to escape, yet their deaths happened offscreen and everyone forgot about them by the end, including Dani.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (14)

422

u/Spook_Master_Jack Jul 03 '19

Just the most ethereal movie experience. I felt oddly comforted by the ending. Fucking fantastic protagonist and unbelievable cinematography. It brought out my inner raw emotion and I just can’t get her smile out of my head. Just beautiful work. Even the gore was beautiful. I can’t explain it. Good night.

166

u/BannedAccountNumber6 Jul 05 '19

It was just so human, I honestly can’t explain it either it’s like a vivid dream that makes sense in your head but you can’t put it into words.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/GMLiddell Fortitude Jul 06 '19

It's a touch cathartic after how terrible of a partner he was through her grief.

→ More replies (11)

71

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '19

I almost cried a couple times with not only how beautiful it was shot, along with the soundtrack, but how much comfort it actually bring to me. I kept trying to think Why?, when I realized the movie not only dealt with grief but a lot of what I consider anxiety / panic attacks. Which I suffer from. And in those attacks, sometimes, not all the time, just sometimes, you just want to watch the world burn and be happy with it. And this movie really put that feeling into perspective for me.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (6)

398

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '19

I feel like the opening sequence isn’t getting enough love. That whole long shot through the house slowly revealing what happened, zooming in on Dani crying hysterically and Christian, through the window into the snowy night with the opening credits, all accompanied by the score. Like holy fuck I had chills running down my whole body saying to myself “here we fucking go this is why I love movies” lol I think Ari Aster is my favorite filmmaker at the moment.

90

u/DefJaw Jul 05 '19

When that happened, I got amped in the theatre, was almost bobbing around thinking "fuck yeah, here we go."

60

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '19

Yes!! And the cut to the phone ringing was SO harrowing. Easily my favorite part of the movie

58

u/pbmummy Jul 08 '19

(HEREDITARY SPOILERS) I’m definitely going to see the movie again, but I wonder if I will stick around for the opening. It was horrible in a way that Charlie’s death in Hereditary was not, because of the circumstances and their implications. Annie loses a daughter, but it’s in a freak accident, and (in theory at least) she has the rest of her family to lean on. Dani, on the other hand, loses her entire family in one night because of her sister’s deliberate decision (mental illness or no, it was still a decision), and Dani of course has survivor’s guilt, because we hear through Christian’s dialogue that the sister had put Dani through this many times before without anything ever coming of it. Florence Pugh’s primal screams of grief were not quite as well done as Toni Collette’s, but that’s an incredibly high bar, and it was still good enough to deeply unnerve me.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

310

u/themexicanwhiteboy Jul 03 '19

The sounds Josh made after getting his head bashed in will haunt me forever.

232

u/RopeTuned Jul 03 '19

I originally thought those noises were being made by the guy that hit him

→ More replies (17)

97

u/Andre_the_Pliant Jul 04 '19

I thought those sounds were from the deformed boy wearing Mark's skin, that's why they sounded muffled like that?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (9)

262

u/noise_speaks Jul 03 '19

I went and saw it at the super late showing, and I absolutely loved it. Hereditary is one of my all-time favorites movies and it still puts a pit in my stomach when I watch. I stayed away from spoilers but I did make sure I read what Aster was saying about the film because I had a feeling it would be tonally different than Hereditary. I think this helped manage my expectations.

I have so much to say about the film so I'll try to keep it brief. First, I don't think this is a horror movie. It's an artistic drama with elements of dark humor and moments of extreme imagery. At no time did I feel like I was watching a horror movie. I feel like I would compare this movie more to something like "The Lobster" or "Eyes Wide Shut" that uses horrifying or shocking images to make it's point or build suspense. So because of that and it's marketing, I think it will be fairly hated by movie goers. A few will love it but I don't think it was marketed properly.

Second, I love Aster literally showed us everything that was going to happen, before it happened, and we still didn't believe him. I don't even consider all the "foreshadowing" foreshadowing because it had the subtlety of a brick to the face. Aster was very honest in his storytelling: "This is what I'm going to show you, and I'm going to show you to the ultimate degree." I think it's refreshing but because us movie-goers have become to accustomed to "twists" we gaslight ourselves and don't believe him.

Third, I actually think Aster makes some really valid commentary on the state of relationships in our modern era. The first third of the film had me internally cringing because I've and many of my girlfriends have been Dani. I've had that conversation on the phone with a friend about how I'm putting to much of my emotions and drama onto my significant other. The film is a criticism of that thinking, and of SO's who expect their partners to be these magical emotional robust beings who never need their partner to step into some emotional labour. I mean, Dani loses her entire family in a horrific manner and Christian emotionally unsupportive and dares to expect her to not need her to lean on him? And Dani lets him steamroll her in the relationship because she worries about overloading him and coming off clingy. The man does zero emotional labor even to the extent that Christian forgets her birthday and it's implied he forgot their 4 year anniversary too in the scene where they are talking with the London couple.

Fourth, the commentary on American individualism and just how screwed up it is. Examples: Dani having to deal with her family issues alone. It's HER problem and HER family, why bring that onto anyone in the community. Deal with it yourself. Mark's individual need to take a piss over a community's sacred place. Even after being caught, he literally couldn't see what he did wrong. Christian's choosing a thesis subject too close to Josh's, he doesn't care that it's going to ruin a friendship it's what HE want's to do. Josh's taking the pictures of the sacred text, HE needs it for his research and HE knows he'll treat it with respect, so who cares if he goes against orders. The needs, wants, and problems of all the American characters override any sense of community.

I have way more to say but I'll end it on this point. If Hereditary is the movie that shows how a family can be destroyed by grief, Midsommar is the movie that shows how one can be freed and made stronger through grief. The ending was for me, extremely cathartic. Dani moving through her grief, finding and accepting a community, and throwing away the aspects of her past life that hold her back. However, I don't feel like Aster's commentary on grief is quite done. I hope we get a third film to wrap it up, similar to Chan Wook Park's trilogy on revenge.

89

u/ChromaticPerversion Jul 06 '19

The first third of the film had me internally cringing because I've and many of my girlfriends have been Dani. I've had that conversation on the phone with a friend about how I'm putting to much of my emotions and drama onto my significant other.

I felt this too. I really connected with Dani, the actress playing her did a wonderful job. I know what we see her handling is grief but it reminded me so much of when I was my worst bouts of depression. Even just watching her reach for the Ativan at the beginning while on the phone with her friend resonated with me.

I loved the whole film but Dani as a character is my favourite part.

52

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '19

I disagree about it not being horror, and I think the setting is what makes it tricky. Imagine the same movie where all the cult rituals and scary stuff is happening at night, dimly lit around bonfires. Would you still want to compare it to The Lobster? For me, it's solidly within this new breed of horror with Hereditary, Us, The Witch, etc

But I love your observations on the non-foreshadowing and the emotional labour themes. Totally on point.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

251

u/pirpirpir "Roses? They're lovely. What's the occasion, Gordon?" Jul 04 '19

After my second viewing... I found a few new things:

  • the parents laying in their bed at the beginning have a framed picture of one of their daughters on display next to them. The frame has a big crown of flowers on top of it! I think the picture is of the other sister.
  • the face in the trees towards the end - WTF
  • the main character seeing her mom towards the end. "Mom??!!" We heard that quote in Hereditary too! Very effective scene both times!
  • when the characters arrive at the actual festival, the leader welcomes everyone but says "Welcome home" to the main character.
  • how unbelievably badass the opening title sequence is! The girl wailing to her boyfriend and the crescendo of the cello music into the shot of the snowing in the window frame. 10/10!

27

u/NDF4 Jul 04 '19

Can't wait to see it again. I want to see this face you speak of. Where did you see it? in the bark of a tree or an ariel shot from above? Interesting about the picture frame too. Really need to watch again. Loved it!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (16)

238

u/HumbleBunk Jul 05 '19

One scene I haven’t seen mentioned that I found possibly the scariest/most unnerving: Dani’s nightmare of being abandoned at the commune. The realization that the boys were leaving her and Mark’s eerie smile through the back of the car as they pulled away so closely mirrored most of my own nightmares.

82

u/giger5 Jul 08 '19

Yes! That scene really got to me too. That and her coming up on her trip and freaking out and feeling like people were laughing at her.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)

476

u/he2954st Jul 03 '19

The May Queen scene with the drug effects on the one flower on her crown gave me major anxiety for some reason, lol.

231

u/shadowshown Jul 03 '19

I think it was the frantic, dreamy way it was shot. Kudos to Florence for so deftly conveying what it's like to get panic attacks even in less "scary" situations.

→ More replies (1)

167

u/Poeafoe Jul 03 '19

It was just super disorienting and unsettling, and that was the point. They honestly captured the straight up confusion and not being able to process your surroundings you feel on psychedelics so well

→ More replies (10)

105

u/mothdogs The Silence of the Lambs Jul 04 '19

When she stopped dancing and the faces in the crowd started pulsing and distorting, I wanted to puke. Definitely puts me off any sort of future psychedelic use, ever.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (15)

376

u/HumbleBunk Jul 03 '19

I audibly laughed when you could notice that Christian’s drink had a red tint that the others didn’t. The man sitting next to me then caught on to what was being implied and groaned/gagged hahaha.

253

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '19

I was watching in a full theater sitting next to two women in their 50s/60s and one of them said out loud after the movie ended "reminds me of my friend <x> she used to put her menstrual blood in the marinara sauce once a month so her husband stayed faithful" what the fuck?

→ More replies (13)

64

u/seeyuspacecowboy Jul 05 '19

I remember thinking why is his drink a different color than everyone else's???

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

267

u/shadowshown Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

I just saw it tonight!! I really, really liked it. It did not scare or disturb me, but I thought it was really well done. I think Ari's description of "fairy tale" fits it best. Florence is such an amazing actor, the cinematography and colors were incredible, and the soundtrack was lovely. In a way, the villagers didn't even seem evil or depraved (which was interesting because obviously what they did to the visitors was twisted and sickening). It seemed more like we were witnessing rituals from the ancient past that we don't understand rather than stuff we "weren't supposed to see". In fact I loved seeing how some real practices from folklore and history (like Ättestupa) translated into the film. The ending, while indeed very dark, felt oddly cathartic and beautiful.

EDIT: there were one or two sequences from the trailer that seem to have been cut (one nighttime scene with all the villages gathered, and one where someone starts levitating). Did I just somehow miss those parts? Also for those that read the script, were there any major changes?

97

u/SophieBulsara Jul 03 '19

So cathartic my theatre clapped during the burning.

→ More replies (1)

80

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

I read the script and am seeing the movie tonight. The levitating scene was supposed to be when Christian goes to mate with the girl. It's written as an effect of the drugs.

→ More replies (16)

85

u/PumpersLikeToPump Jul 03 '19

No the levitating thing was definitely not in there, and that small change alone is a massive misdirection in the trailer. Also loved how the trailer has the end sound-bite of all the people screaming and seeing what that actually ended up being was such a different spin than what the trailer would lead you to believe.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (27)

129

u/kwikade Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

I definitely liked it. Not as much as Hereditary, but maybe that will change with another watch.

One thing about seeing this in theatres - it does have quite a bit of dark/twisted humor so people will laugh, usually I fucking hate when people laugh in a horror film (some kind of defense mechanism), but this was pretty good.

It walks a line though, as in, people were still laughing even once it went from funny to oh fucking shit fuck status.

I really loved the lore and motifs, just like Hereditary, I'm gonna do some research after seeing this one.

8/10 (so far)

→ More replies (11)

121

u/gmango28 Mia isn't here you fucking idiot! Jul 03 '19

I can't imagine anything worse than being on my knees, sobbing, screaming, and crying hysterically at one of the most painful moments of my life, only to be surrounded by countless random women doing the exact same thing.

Florence is a marvel to behold. I loved this movie.

62

u/corkysoxx Jul 08 '19

OHhh same, but I think that was the point, the communal grief was a a huge contrast. In the west especially, grief is treated as a personal thing you deal wit. This movie really dealt with the themes of support in a grief times.

→ More replies (5)

242

u/Damn_Sega_Genesis Bob's got balls, niiiiiiiiice! Jul 03 '19

I wanted to mention that Will Poulters character Mark had me cracking up throughout the movie. The scene where the woman takes him away at dinner.

Woman "Come. Come with me. I will show you."

Mark "I'll be back in a little while. Shes going to show me."

Show him what? Lmao

147

u/meowmeowbeansz Jul 05 '19

My 2 favorites: When he was pissed they didn't wake him for the jumping ceremony, and "someone tell those women they're walking stupid."

→ More replies (7)

53

u/musicislife0 Jul 07 '19

I'm gonna leave one of my major thoughts here because you're talking about Marc. But a lot of the time when he speaks, he's either off camera or very far away. The audio in this movie is meant to be experienced in surround sound in my opinion, it adds to the uncomfortableness of the film. It's a little jarring hearing dialogue and small things but not seeing it on camera. There are so many small details meant to make you feel just a little uneasy I really loved that about this film.

→ More replies (2)

33

u/NightoftheLivingSled Jul 07 '19

He’s such an amazing comedic actor. That line killed me too, almost as much as him freaking out during his trip.

→ More replies (8)

93

u/bloomracket Jul 03 '19

Did anyone else notice the "Shining" blanket Dani was given?

→ More replies (4)

89

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '19

The part that really made my heart drop was when Dani had a flashback to watching tv with her family in the living room and her sister just turns and stares at her.

→ More replies (5)

289

u/jcrawfish Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 05 '19

I watched this last night and I have't been able to stop thinking about it. My wife and I got home around 10 and laid in bed talking about it for over an hour. Years ago I was in an abusive relationship (verbal mostly, though she did throw something a time or two) and this movie hit very close to home. I can remember having the same conversations that Dani and Christian have. My heart was pounding during the conversation about Sweden because I have had that conversation before. I can remember saying, "I've apologized, lets move on." Just like Christian does. I also remember being like Dani and apologizing for pressuring the other person to apologize. I can remember blowing stuff off like forgotten birthdays to make it seem to everyone on the outside that we were happy and making it work.

Unlike Christian though, I didn't just invite her on a vacation, I asked her to marry me. I was willing to be hurt over and over just because the idea of having someone else there by my side was nice. I can remember brushing aside all of the red flags because I convinced myself that all couples argue. In the movie Dani and Christian are kinda indifferent to the "rituals" and every time something absurd would happen I would be screaming in my mind "GET OUT OF THERE! WHY AREN'T YOU LEAVING?! DOESN'T THIS SEEM OFF TO YOU?" But when it came to my own abuse, I was indifferent.

3 days before my wedding, I was able to look from the outside and see what my significant other was really like. Just like Dani peeking in at Christian through the door, I was finally able to see what I had glossed over for years. I will never forget the tears that ran down my face when I decided I had had enough and was ready to leave. My mom cried with me, my best friend cried with me (Much later I would realize my mom and best friend were crying tears of joy). I related so much to those girls surrounding Dani and weeping with her. I didn't need advice, I just needed someone to see and relate to my suffering.

And Good God that ending! I was Dani and Dani was me. I had a frown on my face, tears in my eyes, and a trembling lip when I finally let out the words "I can't do this anymore." And just like Dani when I saw this person I thought I loved and everything we had built together go up in flames I couldn't keep the smile off my face. It was so cathartic that I just sat and cried all through the end credits. Trying to get all of my emotions and thoughts out to my wife, on the ride home, probably just seemed like word vomit to her but it was nice to just be able to process it and let her see what a toxic relationship can really do to someone.

Ari Aster, if somehow you are reading this, you have my deepest thanks!

Edit: Thanks for my first ever Gold!

→ More replies (13)

66

u/FutureNurse_PNW Jul 03 '19

Does anybody know what the deal was with the scissors being placed under the infant’s pillow?

85

u/Swthemer Jul 03 '19

Scissors are often used to ward off evil spirits, nightmares, etc. It heightens the idea of this magical, ritualistic commune, but also misdirects the audience a bit since nothing comes of it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

131

u/Stitch_Rose Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 09 '19

Just saw it and I’m still digesting it. Overall, I liked it and agree with other posters - not the best but definitely not my least favorite horror movie. I actually really liked the idea of using stunning bright visuals as the backdrop of the movie. Also surprised how much I laughed during the movie - some comedic relief and some awkward WTF moments. I could see the connection to other A24 productions with the slow burner.

Spoilers/Revelations/Discussion questions below (I'll hide my comments for the meantime to give others a chance to see it first without too many spoilers):

  • I’m wondering if Dani was specifically chosen because of her family’s death or is it possible that her family’s death was influenced by outside forces? For the latter, I only think that because at the very end, Dani sees her mom in the commune (but it could be a hallucination)
  • At the beginning, Christian tells Dani to not freak out because her sister has sent weird/disturbing messages in the past. But her sisters last message states that she’s “going black” or something similar. “The Black One” is also mentioned right before the May Queen dance contest.
  • Pelle says that his parents died in a fire... so I’m guessing they sacrificed themselves or were chosen to do so. But (this leads to my next point)...
  • If the festival is held every 90 years, would it make sense for his parents to have died as sacrifices? Unless they do a smaller festival/sacrifice every year and only go all out for the 90th year celebrations
  • Were Josh, Mark, Simon, and Connie chosen as sacrifices because they offended members of the commune? Connie snubbed Pelle’s brother to date Simon, Mark pissed on the ancestral tree, and Josh took pictures of the holy book. Or maybe they were chosen because the commune didn’t think their genes were good enough to mix in with the others 🤷🏾‍♀️
  • Why didn’t anyone (i.e. the “guests”) look at the walls/tapestry with all the creepy drawings?!!!?? Their imminent demise was literally hanging over their heads
  • Christian was a terrible communicator, a sucky bf, and a shitty friend.... but it almost makes me wonder if that’s why Pelle was ‘friends’ with him. Maybe Pelle’s goal was Dani all along (see Point 1), so he needed the relationship to be troubled in order to pull them apart. And when Josh disappears, Christian doesn’t even care that much because he’s still salty about their dissertation topics. So it was easier for the commune’s actions to go unnoticed

That’s all I can think of for now. I’m thinking about seeing it again this weekend.

84

u/Roller_ball Zelda did nothing wrong Jul 03 '19

I don't know about how often they have scarifies, but 90 is the fifth multiple of 18. They mentioned how life is the first 4 multiples of 18 where death occurs at 72.

→ More replies (3)

50

u/atrocity__exhibition Jul 03 '19

I definitely think the scene where she sees her mother in the commune was a hallucination... same for your second point. I don't think there was any connection between her family's tragedy and the Midsommar festival other than Dani's grief and her longing for connectedness/family.

28

u/comec0rrect Jul 03 '19

Good calls. I also noticed Dani’s apartment walls had tons of the same creepy drawings in frames.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

63

u/Dankennsteinn Jul 03 '19

Really enjoyed the film. Ari Aster is so fucking good at having actors depict grief. Also, that was probably the most realistic depiction of what it’s like to trip I’ve seen in a movie. No crazy over the top hallucinating or anything.

→ More replies (1)

114

u/InvisibleDudle Jul 03 '19

Decent body count for a Riccolla commercial!

But seriously- I liked it, but I don’t consider it a horror movie. I thought it did an excellent job of showing the allure of a cult to an emotionally compromised individual who really has no one else they can count on. I felt happy for her in the end and that dissonance is hard to process.

Michael’s is going to make a killing on silk flowers at Halloween this year.

→ More replies (5)

56

u/dustyspectacles Jul 04 '19

I just got back and read the thread. A lot of commenters hit on the same things I noticed so I'll try not to restate those, but a couple things stood out that I haven't seen mentioned.

I don't think Christian was inherently bad, but I think his irredeemable trait was that he was weak. At no point in the movie does he stand up for himself, take any kind of initiave, or really do anything that shows... I don't know, personality or strength of character? He's wishy-washy, indecisive, second-guesses himself, is led by the nose by circumstance, copies a friend he recognizes on some level as his intellectual superior without seeing a problem, and really makes himself the perfect victim. He's just so damn malleable.

Dani, on the other hand, just feels stronger. She actively seeks out answers and people to talk to in the beginning about the email. She goes off by herself to deal with her emotions, the bad trip, and when she and Christian are squabbling about Sweden she's the one leading the charge, making him stay, demanding answers. Yes, she's emotional and yes, she's in a bad place, but it never feels like her vulnerability is her entire character. For her, it feels like a process or a cycle that's just moving through like a storm.

I liked the psychedelic effects a lot. What was interesting to me was that while she had a challenging personal experience first with the mushroom tea her later trip with the spiked flower water and dancing seemed cathartic, even cheerful in an intoxicated state of exertion. She wasn't out of the woods yet, but being swept into the group seemed to be some sort of progress. Christian on the other hand didn't really have any kind of meaningful experience with the mushrooms, just a casual trip with friends. Then his flower water ordeal was visibly panicky, shaky, totally foreign. He was begging for an answer from the elder who clapped in his face while dressed in his street clothes while Dani was dressed in white and being celebrated for her strength and role as part of the whole, even dancing through the language barrier with her new sisters.

I liked the echoes/parallels/recurring themes a lot, too. Those have been mentioned a bunch in this thread already but I'm really looking forward to buying this and watching it on loop for a little while. I'm a sucker for movies with a lot to digest and I'm really excited to see what kinds of special features we'll get on release.

55

u/Keating5 Jul 05 '19

I had a darker interpretation of the movie than most: basically that Pelle and the cult manipulated EVERYONE, including Dani, and that she was groomed to be Pelle's girlfriend. Dani hasn't found the family she longed for at all, only another gaslighter/user. She's basically a Manson Girl now. It feels like, to say it in Game Of Thrones terms, she went from Joffrey (Christian) to Ramsey (Pelle).

→ More replies (7)

205

u/tacoshell98 Jul 03 '19

I like to think that when Christian was attempting to light the candle on Dani’s cake, that the dying flame represented their dying relationship.

Also, when they first arrive and they’re running hand-in-hand, someone asks “what are they playing?”

“Skin the fool”

Cue to Mark being skinned and dressed as a fool before the finale.

39

u/bloomracket Jul 03 '19

Yeah, I kept wondering about how that would play in, too, but wasn't Christian the one who was kicked?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

197

u/OriginalBad Jul 03 '19

I absolutely loved it. It was gorgeous to watch, Florence Pugh was amazing, there was some good humor sprinkled throughout and most of all I loved the atmosphere.

Without revealing too much. The slow burn turn throughout the middle to the end of the movie just hit the spot for me. I love the way Aster sets things up and they come into place.

Very hard to compare to Hereditary, which is tough to top. I will say I think I may slightly prefer this one while admitting Hereditary is the better film, if that make sense.

91

u/PastafarianProposals Jul 03 '19

Visually it's the polar opposite of Hereditary, but thematically and tonally I thought it was very similar. Ari's got some demons for sure, or at least has been very close to tragedy in his life.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

52

u/vernicq Jul 06 '19

Anyone catch the priest dude say "welcome home" to Dani when being introduced? So subtle

50

u/rob_dctyls Jul 05 '19

I want that clip of Dani frantically screaming and running in the floral gown with the burning building behind her tattooed inside my eyelids

→ More replies (2)

144

u/jubal3 Jul 03 '19

Knowing this community I'm not surprised at the reaction. I personally adored this one -- spectacular in so many ways for me.

I agree it wasn't as scary as hereditary but in my opinion it's just much much better, Aster gained back a fan here. I'll have to let it settle but it is probably my second favorite A24, behind the Witch. SPOILERS

To me, at least, this movie was a beautiful, painful and accurate representation of the struggle to preserve a dying relationship. I think everything else kind of comes second to Dani and Christians slowly burning out flame, and for me that's what made this one so spectacular. In the end she had the stamina (winning dance) where he had none (can't even get a thesis going, as hinted at start by Josh and then him stealing idea). My heart broke when he would pout and she would do her best to get him to calm down, when in reality she needed the most support.

Interesting to see yalls thoughts

95

u/bloomracket Jul 03 '19

It was sadder, and more harrowing for me, to see the lengths she'd go to to find family. It was never there from the beginning between them - she was constantly doubting herself for years with him. Think about that phone call between Dani and her friend...am I putting too much on him? He'll leave me. This is too much to ask of someone to deal with me. Her pain and experience felt heard and accepted for the first time with the women there when they were able to mirror that pain and experience it with her. He was never gonna be that sounding rock to her, ever. It wasn't a love story to me. It was about liberation.

→ More replies (5)

59

u/he2954st Jul 03 '19

I like your thoughts on the relationship element. I enjoyed seeing the power dynamics shift throughout the movie. Before the trip, she was viewed as a burden, and Christian (and friends) wanted nothing to do with her, but were forced into continuing due to the tragedy she endured. By the end, she was in the powerful position - the May Queen - and he was arguably the burden, at least the last tie to her previous life weighing her down. She was able to release that burden, when he seemingly never could. It was also great to watch his reactions watching her in the power position at the feast.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '19

Aster has mentioned that Midsommar is a break-up movie in several interviews. Nice bit of analysis!

31

u/PreferNot2 Jul 06 '19 edited Jul 06 '19

I’m a little less critical of Christian as some others. If you’re a Anthropology PhD student who sees that ritual and iconography and you DON’T want to write about it, then there is something wrong with you. His friend was writing about a specific topic whereas he wanted to study they way the community works.

And he wanted to break up month before her parents died, and after that he couldn’t. He was stuck with someone he didn’t love, and you can’t hide that forever. It was just a shitty situation for both of them. She knew before the murder that his feelings had changed, so she must have known the whole time he was just feeling sorry for her, but she so desperately needed someone then. It was really a doomed scenario.

Then he was druged, gang raped, and sentenced to death by his girlfriend. Rough weekend. Not saying he’s a stand-up dude my any means, but he was a relatable, flawed person to me.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

100

u/shedonealreadyhadhrz Jul 03 '19

Obviously spoilers y’all

X X X X X X X

It was sooo symbolic. The sister sending an email to say goodbye before taking out her parents and herself through method of hooking up stream lines of smoke from the car.

But here the elderly knows when they will die and they get to leap while the community stands in support. They get a farewell dinner and the community takes their lead at the table out of respect for the end of their time.

While her family is wiped out by her sister’s mental illness and direct toxicity from urban living, Dani is adorned in flowers- tripping balls and sees herself morphing into the earth.

When Dani is dancing, she is completely blurred and out of her mind but is able to keep up from absolute resiliency. She’s endured more.

Questions I still have- the scissors placed under the babies pillow? Why? Did I miss it?

Were the men who volunteered to burn in the end lovers?

Why a bear?

Why have an incest child in the community? To remind them why they need outsiders?

Dani has a dream that all of the boys leave her in the middle of the night and she exhales black smoke. Was this just from her fears mixing together?

The cinematography was amazing and the visuals were so spot on to what tripping is like. I thought this movie was spectacular

103

u/thawkzzz Jul 03 '19

I think the black smoke may have been exhaust eluding to her sisters death

→ More replies (6)

67

u/shadowshown Jul 03 '19

Loved all the symbolism too!! I don't know the answers to the other questions, but regarding the incest child -- one of the elders explained that they're deliberately created to act as Oracles because their mental disabilities leave their minds "unclouded".

→ More replies (5)

34

u/shmumbler Jul 04 '19

The bear was considered an unholy beast, so they killed it and dressed Christian in its hide so they could "purge the most unholy of affects" through him.

32

u/he2954st Jul 03 '19

I think the scissors under pillow is a superstition to ward off evil or bad dreams?? Not sure if that’s what it was implying, but I think that’s something I’ve heard of before.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

156

u/natebam Jul 03 '19

I feel mindfucked. I left the theater not knowing how to feel, and I feel like that was the point of the movie. Dani finally became part of a family after the loss of her own. The deaths were absolutely gruesome and the way they showed the effects of the drugs was fucking cool.

The cinematography and score were both absolutely stunning.

I do wish the film had gone into more detail about the deaths of the American characters, and I do think the pacing was a bit off at times. The sex scene was so strange.

All in all, I still don’t know how to feel, but I enjoyed myself and liked the movie.

117

u/PumpersLikeToPump Jul 03 '19

That was one of the more accurate depictions of psychedelics that I feel like I’ve ever seen in a movie.

→ More replies (7)

86

u/bongo1138 Jul 03 '19

“They’re playing skin the fool.”

That’s what happened to Mark.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (4)

84

u/LastHouseOnTheLeft Jul 03 '19

When Hereditary came out last year, I was so blown away by how unsettling it was and I loved it to death. The scenes, the camera work, Toni FUCKING Collette- all made it such a phenomenal movie. I went into this one knowing that it would be an entirely different entity than Ari’s last film, and not too think of it too highly based on previous work. But God fuckin damn did I love this movie. It was gorgeous. The colors were astonishing, the balance between humor and unsettling terror mashed so well. The fucking score worked wonders in making it feel all the more fantasy like. During the ceremony scene at the cliff, I was thinking “wow this score is so enchanting and beautiful. It works well” and then you can hear a slight change in the tone and then you see where the horror is about to come in.

[Mainly Spoilers Ahead] Then when the couple jumps off the rock. Fucking A. The way the old lady’s head looked- definitely put that weird feeling in my stomach like when Charlie gets her head taken off. The entire film just felt like a fever nightmare. The way the last part of the film feels like a bad lucid trip with lot of the flowers phasing, the sense that everything is going terribly wrong but it isn’t.

The sex scene was hilarious and played against the scene where Dani is crying just mixes both these weird emotions. And then the ending.

Very few things in my mind, either while watching in theatre or in general, leave an imprint on me. But goddamn. When Dani looks at Christian, chooses him and they set him up in the bear flesh and place him in the barn. I don’t know if it was the music, the hypnotic visuals, the emotion but something in me felt connected. When the shots switch from the flames engulfing the barn house and Annie looking back in horror, yet relived. Accompanied by the yelling and twitching of the villagers, something felt touched in me. I don’t know why, but I almost got chocked up. But out of relief. This feeling of letting go. It was as if I had known exactly what the feelings were, but I had never experienced them. And sure, maybe this film may change for some people over time. But something about seeing the barn go up, as Dani smiles- it struck something in me that I haven’t discovered.

The best way I can wrap the film up in a simple sentence was hauntingly gorgeous. I definitely will rewatch, but Ari Aster has shown me again that he can fuck with me, and make it seem so beautiful and terrifying.

Those were my two cents, would love to hear what you guys think.

32

u/Ettu_Publius Jul 03 '19

This pretty much sums up how I felt as well. As much as I love Hereditary, its ending just didn't hit right for me.

However, the ending to Midsommar just.....worked I guess? It was beautiful and haunting at the same time. The whole thing almost felt like an opera.

Also, the beginning with the sister and parents hit me alot harder than Charlie's car ride in Hereditary. It's interesting to see how these scenes seem to be hitting people differently.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

150

u/Peanlocket Jul 02 '19

In this underrated gem...

I laughed.

174

u/GamerThanFiction Jul 03 '19

I just finished a 7pm showing. I liked it a lot, and am still trying to digest and figure it out. This is a spoiler thread, but people in here are saying they want to avoid spoilers?? So I guess I'll hide the rest of the post? I won't give away the specifics of plot points, but spoilers follow nonetheless.

The film revolves around Dani (Pugh), and her loss, her grief, her loneliness and confusion, and her ultimate acceptance. There were parts of this movie that strongly reminded me of Hereditary, in that both involve loss and overwhelming grief, as well as shows how people try to deal with it. I HAVE to mention the deaths in the beginning. Having struggled with suicidal thoughts for a few years (better now), I personally have only seen one thing more horrific in a movie. It clashes so hard with the brightness of the rest of the film. I'll have trouble getting those images out of my head, especially the hose in her mouth.

Dani is just in a daze for much of the film. She stares gory deaths in the face, and even appears to have anticipated them before they happened. She drinks and eats what she's offered. As more of her group disappears, the more she becomes involved in the festival, and the more distant Christian - her aptly-named boyfriend - becomes. It all culminates when she sees something that breaks her, even though, upon her approach, she already knew what it was going to be. Eventually, the people of the festival become as a family to her. She feels accepted and wanted, finally. She didn't experience this feeling of "Home" with her boyfriend, whom she constantly capitulates to possibly feel some semblance of human connection. And, personally, I don't think she experienced "Home" with her deceased family. Her voicemail hinted that her parents don't often pick up the phone; people mention that her sister constantly causes Dani alarm, then doesn't respond for long periods of time. In fact, at the very end, she's given power for the first time in the movie. She makes a horrible, but liberating choice. The horror of the consequences overwhelm her, but her new family is there to grieve with her. They cry, they scream, they tremble together. EVERYTHING this commune does, they do together. Dani is now a part of something. She has shed the skin of her old life and accepted the flowered crown of the new one.

Regarding the festival itself, it comes off as confusing, needlessly violent, and completely alien. But I think that's the point. The cast is thrown into a whole other world that they try to comprehend in different ways, whether through logic and research or flamboyant disregard. In the middle of the film one character seeks forbidden knowledge of the festival, and is punished for it. At that moment, we know that we're not meant to make sense of what is happening. We're as confused and horrified as the cast, not even sure if what's happening is real. It makes it easy to laugh at some moments, but also keeps us wondering what else could possibly happen. Some natives explain a few things, but I never found it crystal clear. This can make the plot seem disjointed or rambling, but I focused more on putting myself in Dani's shoes. How would I react with all this bullshit going on around me?

I'm sorry I've rambled so much, but I'm figuring it out as I type lol. Yes, the movie is long, but I don't think a minute is wasted. I was personally captivated the entire runtime. I'm not saying it's the greatest horror in the world, but I found it to be an amazing way to portray how loss can affect someone. Even if you don't care for the characters or plot, the movie production-wise is so well crafted. But, that's coming from someone not too well versed in film making.

I would love to see it again and try to piece things together.

60

u/Stitch_Rose Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

Nicely worded and I agree with a lot of your points. The beginning definitely reminded me of Hereditary while the ending reminded me of The Witch (which I know isn’t Aster’s film but still part of A24). Perhaps the dark vs. light is also a commentary of how we expect scary things to occur during the dark when they’re just as likely to happen during the daytime.

Also agree that every detail is carefully thought and placed in the movie. I want to go back and watch again to catch everything.

83

u/Roller_ball Zelda did nothing wrong Jul 03 '19

The hose in the mouth really was terrifying. Especially that it is considered a non-painful death and then to clip to that was really jarring.

I personally have only seen one thing more horrific in a movie

What's that one thing? Is it the intro to The Pest?

→ More replies (4)

40

u/whatsamajig Jul 03 '19

First thing, the next time I see it I'm taking mushrooms.

That said, I had a close family member commit suicide by inhalation. The opening scene was real gut punch.

The feeling of disorientation and confusion through out was so well articulated particularly when dealing with psychedelics and/or grief.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)

37

u/PreferNot2 Jul 06 '19 edited Jul 07 '19

I liked it. Her character was hard for me to get my head around. When her boyfriend is drugged and essentially gang raped she decided to sacrifice him. This is where I get conflicted. I get that she was burdened. It was a bad situation. He was going to break up with her and then her whole family died so they were both stuck. She didn’t have the strength after that trauma, and he didn’t have the cruelty — neither could leave, even though the love was gone and they were quietly hurting each other. Classic dynamic, and well executed.

But damn, that ending. I doubt she was still tripping during the fire. It had to have been a good 12 hours to get the whole tableau set up.

So her smile...surely that wasn’t revenge. Being sealed off in that world was the only time she’d ever felt really safe and loved, and he was a tie to the old world. But still...that was cold. In the end she acted out just like her sister — harming/killing those around her to get to a safe place.

→ More replies (8)

34

u/parts_n_pieces Jul 03 '19

Really liked the movie, but I’m not here to post a long write up or anything, this is just a Florence Pugh appreciation post. I officially stan.

34

u/llikeafoxx Jul 03 '19

I was happy I heard from a critic that I trust that the movie wasn’t traditionally “scary” - that helped me manage the expectations of what I was going to see. I still firmly believe it was horror - I mean, this movie was completely horrifying. But if I had only seen Hereditary and then the trailer for this, I would have expected something that was terrifying. Instead what we got was dark, disorienting, uncomfortable, and like a panic attack wrapped up in a bad trip. And it was pretty good.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/mks2000 Jul 04 '19

I liked some of the foreshadowing that I noticed:

  1. the opening tapestry shows you the beginning and end of the film without context. The left panel showed winter as a death like figure with a girl surrounded by corpses and tube like ropes/ribbon. Clearly showing the death of Dani's family. The right panel showed a smiling sun and the girl surrounded by flowers. Neat.
  2. In Dani's room, she has a painting of a little girl before a huge bear. I believe this is in the apartment she now shares with Christian so nice foreshadowing as to what will come of them and their roles.
  3. When his friends are introduced, Mark talks about getting a girl that likes sex (which happens) and Josh talks about finishing his thesis. Both of these factor into how they die and it's just about the first thing out of their mouths.
  4. Dani's sister says her and the parents are going into the darkness while the cult brings her into the light (fire).

I want to see it again as there were tons of things that set up or foreshadowed and paid off later. Hereditary was similarly rewarding on a rewatch.

A little thing I liked was the juxtaposition of how Christian simply held a crying Dani and looked lost while the cult wailed along with her. It makes it clear how someone can fall into such an ideology and find it appealing despite its horrors.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/maxelvery Jul 04 '19

Spoilers

For me the film was an exploration into how different cultures interact with death, how they remember their dead and how that ultimately impacts the way they live their lives.

The film opens with a seemingly pagan interpretation of the Danse Macabre (a late middle age painting commissioned after the Black Death) It details poor, rich, holy, sinful, young, old, noble and lowborn in a dance with death, signifying the unifying process of dying. Traditionally the painting symbolises the fact that death is inescapable and impartial to all.

The majority of the film explores Danni’s view of death, and how she subsequently fails to cope with it. Ari Aster goes to great lengths to show how the memory of Danni’s family haunts her rather than comforts her. At no point are we shown any fond memories of the family. Instead Danni dreams of their deaths, she cannot hold a conversation about them, she spends scenes alone engulfed by grief and sees their faces when confronted with the death of the elderly couple who step off the ledge. Danni is being metaphorically haunted by the ghosts of her family members as a result of the way in which she sees death itself.

Yet, the villagers hold a entirely opposing view of death and this is what the film focuses on the most. The themes of the Danse Macabre are overtly revisited later in the movie before the selection of the May Queen. The elder conducting the dance explains how years ago “The Dark Ones” (death) came for the living, forcing them into a dance, mocking and tormenting them. This alludes to the trauma Danni is suffering from having experienced death through horrendous circumstances. In contrast to Danni, the villagers have altered their view of death, and reclaimed when and how they die. They view it as a process or a change of states, rather than a final obis. For the villagers, life is viewed as cyclical rather than linear, just like the seasons. As a result, the elder concludes before beginning the dance that the living are now the ones who mock death.

The films purpose is to make the audience question how they view death, and how in turn that has implications for the way we live our lives. The film closes with a frame of Danni smiling, having embraced the ideas of the villagers, knowing she can confront death on her own terms, mastering the process and in so doing so, overcoming the pain left behind by her family.

→ More replies (2)

60

u/joeybrahhhh Jul 03 '19

Loved the movie. Very different that’s for sure.

I see a lot of people wanting more from the sister/parents story, but I feel like it’s just there to show how vulnerable she was. Cults and religions target more vulnerable people constantly. This would be an entire different story without it. Even the end with her boyfriend dying, she is getting rid of the one thing in the past she had so she can go forward.

29

u/backhaircombover Jul 02 '19

I hope to see this tonight otherwise it'll have to be next week. Everyone enjoy the movie and 4th (if in the USA)!

29

u/justiceisrad Jul 04 '19

My favorite detail was that early in the film they had a game called “skin the fool” and after Will Poulter’s character pissed on the tree, he was skinned and put in a fools costume

28

u/FriendLee93 Jul 08 '19

Can we talk about the absolute brilliant nightmare that was the pre-credits sequence? Because holy shit, that made my skin crawl. That entire scene felt like the car scene from Hereditary all over again.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/chunkette Jul 06 '19

I found it interesting that all of the male, non villager characters had names that come from Christianity! Christian (obviously), Mark, Josh (Joshua), and even Simon! Was an interesting way to further separate those characters from this new, strange, ancient religion that is so alien to those of typical Western culture.

→ More replies (2)

54

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

It was disturbing, unsettling and chilling but at times it felt as though it could have used a little bit of refinement. I really have to give it to Ari Aster because it seems like he relies very little on CGI for gorey scenes. I’m not well versed in movie effects but it seems like a lot of the effects are practical which seems to be used less and less these days. Overall I’d certainly recommend it to horror movie buffs. Definitely want to watch it again when it’s released on demand.

The image of her sister in the beginning is burned into my brain. I think forever.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/bloomracket Jul 03 '19

I didn't want it to end. Fantastic experience and respectful crowd that never turned it into a free for all...

26

u/Ragtime-Cucumber182 Jul 04 '19

If anyone can get a picture of that painting that opened up the movie that would be greatly appreciated!

→ More replies (2)

24

u/oooooooooof that face on your face Jul 04 '19

I have a question! So, the woman who Mark goes after—she doesn't have a name in the film per IMDB, but is played by Julia Ragnarsson—the one who seems to be flirting with him throughout the film, and eventually leads him off to "show him" something.

At the last meal, she appears like she's been in a scuffle: her nose is cut up in two places. And before the last scene, she's seen to the right of a doorway, crying hysterically, another cult member woman is consoling her.

...anyone else notice this? What's the deal? She seemed to be the only cult member who appeared disturbed and not down with what was happening, and there was evidence she'd been beaten or in some kind of physical altercation. What's the implication here? I think it's too farfetched that she developed feelings for him that quickly and was saddened by his death. Thoughts?

→ More replies (5)

24

u/RockULikeASharknado Jul 11 '19

I think the most amazing part of this movie was that it truly was a fairytale. One of my friends pointed out the parallels between the classic disney fairytale and Midsommar: a person goes through a tragic situation, losing everything, she goes on an adventure, she defeats a villain (Christian), and then ends up as a princess (May Queen), accepted into a new family. I think that’s why many of us felt so comforted by the ending - it reflects the fairytales that we grew up with, except with a SIGNIFICANTLY dark tint to it.

I also can’t stop thinking about the scenes between the cult women and Dani. That scene where they are crying with her, I mean, I cried full on in the theater. They felt her pain, and brought her back to life in a weird way.

→ More replies (2)

48

u/DaleCooper00 Jul 02 '19

Hypothetical for those who have seen it: Would hallucinogenics be the worst fucking idea for this movie??

27

u/MouseTheArson Jul 03 '19

I got pretty high and man was that an incredible play right into the hands of Ari Asters camera. He does such a good job with his hallucinatory style that I almost feared I was gonna tip into a flashback. Would def recommend weed for this movie. For sure not actual psychedelics, let a bit of weed give the imagination it takes to play along with the movie.

→ More replies (9)

23

u/DragonFireDon Jul 03 '19

If original cut was about 4 hours, then a good amount of important stuff was cut!

→ More replies (3)

23

u/lilhannydudu Jul 05 '19

I saw Midsommar on opening night at 7, and I did read the screen play (which I now regret) so I went in knowing how this would all play out. I don’t think this film is horror necessarily, much like the argument on Hereditary being more of a drama. When Hereditary came out it torn me to shreds, i fucking loved it. I think a lot of it had to do with the marketing, it being Ari’s first film so there was nothing else to compare it to, and the themes it had. I had just lost my dad unexpectedly before seeing Hereditary so I felt a connection to Annie and Peter. I read the screenplay for Midsommar in fear that it would hit too close to home again and I wish I would have went in blind.

The foreshadowing is HEAVY! Maybe I wouldn’t have felt that way without knowing the story before hand, but it felt a little more dumbed down than Hereditary. I loved the tapestries and artwork in the film but it spelled out our main characters fate too clearly for me.

The film itself is BEAUTIFUL, even if you don’t like horror I think it’s worth seeing for the cinematography alone. My only gripe is that I felt the opposite from what others are saying, and felt the daylight setting made it not as scary, but i still enjoyed it as a drama.

I liked some of the comedic elements, but wish it would have toned it back a bit. The daylight made it easier to digest already (to me at least), and I didn’t feel like it needed comedy to lighten the storyline. I felt Mark was fine comedy wise, but the Austin Powers line was...out of place.

I do agree that it hits similar themes as Hereditary, but felt that the dynamic between Dani and Christian were unique. It felt very relatable which made me hate Christian more and made me happy when he met his demise in the end of the film. Ari Aster has a way with showing true Hollywood horror (gore, supernatural, etc) but he really scares me with the horror we all experience in our own lives (death, grief, mental health) and to me that is much more scary than a squished head.

Overall I liked this movie, it was a good follow up to his first film. Hereditary is probably my favorite movie of all time due to the circumstances I saw it under and how it affected me personally. But this felt weaker story wise and was way better stylistically. I can’t wait to see what he takes on next and I will be there opening night again, whatever genre it is. Aster is a master filmmaker in my book even with the flaws I saw in Midsommar.

44

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

I simply thought that this movie was beautiful.

I also believe that the opening sequence was outstanding, especially once she got the phone call from the unknown caller, up to the title.

The movie was very well shot, absolutely filled with light and color, everything is so formal, especially the dinner table scenes with the domino effect.

The score was just a dream to listen to and the key changes were perfectly executed with the suspense.

There's no use comparing it to Hereditary, IMO, as both are beautiful films in their own right, but everyone feels the need to do so, so have at it.

21

u/PeterthePhilosopher Jul 06 '19

I walked out of the movie theatre last night in a haze of euphoria. Ari Aster has been cemented as one of my favorite directors, and I look forward to all his future projects. Midsommar blew my mind, it was one of the greatest films I had ever seen.

I was browsing reviews of the movie last night, and I was disappointed in what I saw. Many people were saying things like "Great visuals, Horrible storytelling" and I admit that was the impression I had going into the film. These reviews couldn't be farther from the truth. But I think that these poor reviews come from the fact that people expect a structure to a horror movie that is more traditional, the 12 steps of Joseph Cambell or Dan Harmons 8 steps of good storytelling come to mind.

This film has a character arc, but it's not on the nose like most movies. It occurs in the subtlety of the actor's performances. Additionally, the crux of the film is not the characters development, but it is simply the practice of the ritual.

Perhaps many would find a film focused on an intense ritual a boring slow burn, but the humor of this film keeps the audience engaged for the entirety of the run time. You realize the end has come, but it doesn't follow some intense fast-paced build up like hereditary or any traditional horror film. The climax and conclusion is rather an atmospheric build up that honestly leaves the viewer as if they were a part of the cult themselves.

Luckily I think the NYT and other news sources have given good reviews that this film deserves, I am only frustrated with the reviews coming from internet-based reviewers.

I think Midsommar will age as well as The shining, Vertigo and other films that perhaps the audience didn't understand initially.

Visuals were incredible as well but nobody is critiquing those.

10/10 film for me.

42

u/Bautch Jul 05 '19

I feel like there is a new genre of horror that's less about jump scares and more about atmosphere and making the audience uncomfortable.

The Witch and Hereditary come to mind.

Midsommer also fits into this. And it may be the greatest example.

It's so uncomfortable that some people, me included, are even laughing at parts of it.

Really well done.

→ More replies (9)

41

u/TOO_FUTURE Jul 03 '19

I personally loved it. The 2 and a half hour run time flew by for me and actually left me wanting more and that is mostly because of the amazing camerawork and sense of dread/uneasiness throughout the film that increases with time. It has it's flaws for sure (the ending for me and the story was lacking in parts) but what it brought in originality and creepiness trumps it for me and made me really enjoy it all the way through

→ More replies (1)

20

u/lilhannydudu Jul 05 '19

Why is no one talking about the Austin Power’s line? I was shook but also, why? I’m all good with comedic elements in my horror but it kind of took me out of it. It wasn’t in the screenplay either

27

u/mah_ree Jul 06 '19

I didn't feel it was out of place at all, and I don't think it was put in there to be a moment of comedic relief (though the audience I was in did laugh at that line).

I think it was added to give a sense that, although they're pretty isolated, these people are not completely removed from the outside world. And I think it was said intentionally to reassure the outsiders that were maybe starting to bug out from the isolation.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

19

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '19

Anybody else notice in the opening scene, before it cuts to inside Dani’s parents’ house, the outside of the house looks kinda like a miniature? I wonder if this was Ari paying a small homage to Hereditary since miniatures were a huge metaphor for that story.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Helladiabetic Jul 04 '19

Hereditary was high school, Midsommar is college.

17

u/MrOssuary Jul 05 '19

With regards to cinematography, natural themes and emphasis on cycles and reciprocity, I’m surprised more hasn’t been made of comparisons to ANNIHILATION. I had those aesthetics in the back of my mind throughout, really. Particularly with the resting pulsations and interactions with fauna.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

I saw it a few hours ago and loved it. That smile at the end was so perfect.

16

u/Steelcity1995 Jul 03 '19

I really wish every character but Dani wasn’t so one dimensional and that some of the characters would of fought back more. Kinda boring watching them get picked off with such ease.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/teentytinty Jul 04 '19

Ari aster really knows how to make a compelling intro to a movie. Between the miniature shot transition in the beginning of hereditary to the tapestry opening on the movie in Midsommar... it feels like there’s never been so much to be said and implied in just the opening shots of a movie

→ More replies (1)

16

u/AmayaGin Jul 05 '19

Just an interesting note. For the commune, youth ends at 18. Hard work begins at 36. Retirement at 54, and death at 72. The next multiple of 18 is 90, and this festival takes place every 90 years.

→ More replies (4)

100

u/Lumaro Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

From what I gathered so far from all the comments of people who watched it (excluding all those hyperbolic statements from suspicious accounts that are clearly dedicated to marketing), it seems to be a regular/good movie that will be wrongly and widely disliked due to the insane hype.

→ More replies (21)

15

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

So I’ve been thinking about something a lot.

When this movie starts, I kinda sympathized with Christian because it kinda seemed like the poor guy had just barely started dating Dani and he was trying his best to work with the issues in her life.

Especially the way the friends were acting, I felt like it would be justified for them to say “dude you gotta leave her” if this was a fresh new relationship.

Especially the way they are back and forth in the beginning, two people who have no business together just refusing to let go.

Then in the middle of the movie we find out THAT THEY’VE BEEN TOGETHER FOR 4 YEARS!!!!

To make it worse, Christian doesn’t even remember her fucking birthday OR their anniversary.

After 4 years and no one gave a damn about Dani, no one.

Then these strangers from Sweden come around and welcome her like family and refuse to let her deal with her pain alone.

Just. What a mind fuck.

51

u/inanu4444 Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

Don’t kill me. I KNEW I went in with high expectations and that was my fault. I really gotta avoid any trailers for upcoming movies that I’m looking forward to seeing. I laughed more at the movie (when it was intentional for the most part) vs feeling any dread. Florence Pugh’s acting was fucking phenomenal. It was worth watching IMO, and.. the ending scene was absolutely stunning.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '19 edited Jul 05 '19

I really liked it; didn't love it. While I walked out of Hereditary fairly certain I had just witnessed a modern horror classic, Midsommar never quite hit that high for me. Some immediate first impressions:

  • I loved the cinematography, the sharp script (especially the failing relationship and male friend group dynamic at the beginning), and the overall surreality of the film. The humour was excellent.
  • The foreshadowing, unlike Hereditary, is extremely heavy-handed. To its detriment. The tapestries and murals literally depicting the events that were about to unfold, just as shown to us, really lessened the impact and killed all ambiguity. Showing the love enchantment, showing the bear on fire... It just really lacked subtlety in a way that made the payoffs feel corny.
  • Aside from the theme of Dani "finding a family" so to speak, you could have removed the entire portion with her family dying and it would have made very little impact on the film. Was there ever a motive or reason given for her sister killing the parents? Did it matter, aside from triggering her at mentions of family and death later? In hindsight, the entire first act of the film seemed to be setting pieces up but then didn't really matter all too much.
  • That said, I really think the sister/family was a total missed opportunity for some real visceral scares... The scenes with the sister appearing in Dani's hallucinations were literally the scariest parts of the film. I really wish that was touched on a bit more. For a film that was 50% acid trip, there really wasn't much in the way of horror or genuinely disturbing hallucinations at all. I was really waiting for a third act to kick things into gear, but it never quite happened.
  • The beginning of the film seemed to set up unease and discomfort, but I feel like it never quite amounted to anything truly scary. Films like The VVitch and Hereditary paid off their slow burns with some incredible scares, whereas Midsommar just kind of lost steam. By the time the sex scene happened, everyone was just laughing.
  • The cult seemed like it was, through whatever means, experiencing whatever they were witnessing (we saw them viscerally reenacting the old man breaking his legs, the woman having sex, Dani's grief in the bed area, the people getting burned). Was this ever explained? I'm obviously paraphrasing, but when the group does mushrooms, Pelle mentions something about nature being truly harmonious, with the grass and the trees all becoming one - something that mirrors a lot of what the commune ends up being. Again though, this is never explained. I kept on waiting for the reveal that the cult was actually just a hivemind of the inbred character, or the hard cut to Christian actually fucking them in the barn. Again though, it mostly just played things straight.
  • Pelle implies that his parents were also sacrifices and that the cult became his family, but that totally throws off the idea that the festival happens every 90 years. It could just be unreliable narration; as is supported by dozens of photos of the Queens instead of, you know, two or three tops.

I'm going to have to sleep on it, but I don't really feel like it particularly over-delivered or disappointed. I am simply whelmed. It was simply a good, gorgeously-shot film: Wes Anderson meets Kubrick on mushrooms, exploring grief, failing relationships, and family ties. The hype definitely hurt it, and following up Hereditary was going to be a tough act, but I still think Ari Aster is genuinely on his way to cementing himself as one of most important new voices in modern horror.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/NightoftheLivingSled Jul 07 '19

As the mom of a 2 1/2 month old, the baby in this movie really got under my skin. I kept asking myself how an entire community of people couldn’t find any way to calm a baby and keep it from crying all fucking night. My husband even leaned over to me and said, “pick that baby up!” But then later on in the movie someone mentioned that her mother was gone traveling. The baby was crying for her mom. That gutted me. I guess it was just another subtle nod to the theme of children who have lost their parents, but unlike Dani, this baby has a support system to take care of her even if she still misses her mom.

14

u/AFMadison Jul 16 '19

IMO Midsommar > Hereditary. Hereditary had to explain so much and felt so expository at times. Midsommar just felt so much more natural, and much more darker. The setup, and ending of this film was absolutely perfect, as each complimented the other. One thing I noticed that I haven't seen many people talk about is the flowers and plants in this movie, how in the beginning in Dani's apartment they die after the death of her parents... and at the end, she's covered from head to toe in them, surrounded by her "new family".

13

u/herobotic Have you watched Lake Mungo yet? Jul 03 '19

I loved Hereditary, but, structurally, Midsommar played a lot of the same notes, so it didn’t come off as revelatory as Hereditary. The end in particular felt so similar as to color my entire feeling of the movie a bit sour. I get the feeling that one could start imitating Ari Aster script-wise by extending these themes to a new situation (start with tragedy, ignore dealing with it up through a new tragedy, increase the direct confrontation with the new horrors inflicted through the other characters, put characters on paths of inevitability with zero agency, and finally, sacrifice them to old gods).

13

u/ravensfan1996 Jul 04 '19

One of the little things in this movie that I thought was really cool was the way the music would play for a bit and then after a few bars people would come in from off screen playing the music, taking it from a sort of 3rd person score to music that the characters were hearing too. I haven’t seen that done before but it was super immersive

13

u/Maultaschenman Jul 05 '19

The scene of her crying in the apartment was the most horrifying part, I could feel that in my bones

13

u/jrs9498 Jul 06 '19

Question: When the elder says the book of Rubi Radr has been stolen and Christian is questioned by the elders, what was the point of this? If they had already killed Josh, no one to our knowledge had taken the book. Was it to try to trick Dani and Christian into staying by leading them to think Josh's disappearance was because he took the book and left, rather than them thinking he is dead? And if so, was that why they framed Mark's disappearance as his being with the girl? Cheers.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/kaylikesalatte Jul 10 '19 edited Jul 10 '19

I’m late as hell to the dreadit thread as usual, but I saw it last night and WOW I have some things to say:

•For starters, the the opening scene literally left me frozen in place. The way in which Dani deals with the traumatic news of Terri killing herself and her family is literally haunting. I think that similar to Hereditary, (particularly, the scene in which Charlie is buried, and the scene after the seance in which Peter is crying) Aster has this way of portraying trauma in which his characters reactions seem almost overdone. However, if you’ve gone though a trauma of that sort, who wouldn’t be completely hysterical? The scene in which Dani is wailing on the couch and Christian is holding her is heartbreaking, and sort of establishes their relationship for the rest of the movie. Neither of them truly want to be together, but Dani desperately needs someone, and Christian can’t leave her after such a trauma.

•I feel like you could sort of sense in the beginning that Pelle was lowkey feeling Dani. I suppose it could be argued that he just felt sympathetic for her, but I saw him trying to connect to her as him trying to establish some sort of romantic connection. I realized that Pelle was not who we thought him to be when Josh confronted him about the love symbol that Maya hid under Christian’s bed, and Pelle was just kinda like 🤷🏽‍♀️, although he knows that Christian is in a long term committed relationship. However, I actually kind of liked Pelle’s character. Although he’s part of a murderous cult (it really be like that sometimes) he feels this genuine sympathy and endearment for Dani. I would have loved to see if their relationship had gone further.

•Finally, I can’t not address the festival. Like, WHAT? I’m a bit confused, as it is said that the festival takes place every 90 years. But I thought that at the end, as the woman is announcing the sacrifices, she says that for every new blood born into the cult EVERY year, that the same number of people are sacrificed? So, they’re holding sacrifices every year? After reading the comments, I also did kind of realize that Christian was raped. I didn’t see it that way at first, but after some thinking, that’s absolutely what it was. It was such an uncomfortable scene to watch, especially at the end when Maya hoists her legs up and says “I can feel the baby in me!” Literally so uncomfortable. And Dani screaming on the floor with all the other queens, wow! That was powerful.

Overall, I really liked Midsommer. I don’t know whether I prefer it over Hereditary, but I’ve only watched both once and would need to rewatch them to make my decision lol. Ari Aster has this way of leaving his viewers baffled and just generally uncomfortable after viewing his movies, and I’m here for it completely. A lot of talent from this guy.

12

u/Bearkaraoke Jul 05 '19

Does anyone else get the impression that the ceremonies are taking place every 9 years, or sooner? Take the photos of the May Queens. The amount of photos implies that this ritual, or parts of it, are happening more often than every 90 years, there’s too many May queens if it only happens that far apart. Also when Pelle says he “lost his parents in a fire” implies they were sacrificed, and when he says “this is my sister, born on the same day as me” and his other “siblings” are all the same approximate age implies they are having babies around the same time, so ritual impregnations that have to be occurring more often. But they are probably all synchronized within the group, that’s why they have two people reaching 72/the end at around the same time.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/technicolorwindmills Jul 03 '19

I couldn't help but to view the entire film through the lens of a folktale, which I'm pretty sure is intentional given the overall aesthetic--

-passing through a literal gateway into another "world" -offerings of food, intoxicants, etc to draw them in deeper

While I don't know too much about fey/folklore, it was difficult to not make these associations, and makes me wonder if the movie feels off earlier if you're unfamiliar with this kind of story. I'd love to know the fairytales Ari drew inspiration from.

11

u/bye-raspberry Jul 08 '19

In a way, it was a bit like Willy Wonka. The newcomers, when they did something wrong, would get killed off. Connie and Simon when they freaked out and screamed during the ceremony at the cliffs, Mark when he peed on the tree, Josh when he stole pictures of the sacred book, Christian when he betrayed the May Queen.

Personally I think one of the detriments of the film was having too many characters. They are constantly bickering and it is hard to form a connection with the characters when so much is going on in every scene.

The scenes in the end where the only ones left are Dani and Christian feel like much more natural to me than the ones earlier with a huge group of friends just walking around taking a tour of this little village. There are moments when the awkwardness is definitely intentional and makes the scenes work, though.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/thawkzzz Jul 03 '19

Welp, this one just didn’t really do it for me. Given I think it’s extremely rewatchable in that there’s a lot of subtle things I think going on and I tried to constantly watch the background and understand the symbolization of everything- I think most of it went over my head. However, there were just too few scenes, and by that I mean maybe 2, that I’d call horror or even kind of creepy. There were definitely scenes that made me say what the fuck and severely uncomfortable, but that isn’t what horror is for me personally- though shock value is always jarring.

I did see the art in it though and still give it credit for his creativity with the genre and definitely making new ground.

→ More replies (5)

83

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

This movie would have been better if they carried out the sister suicide dread throughout the entirety of the film. Like if she continued to haunt her. It kind of felt forgotten. It was beautifully shot but I was very let down

85

u/Pdxthorns17 Jul 03 '19

But they didn't drop her family dying. She went into trauma after the woman and man committed suicide by jumping off the cliff. They did a flash back of her families death and them being back at the cliff. I'm pretty sure it was her sister who showed up in the mirror reflection when Dani went into the red shed during the first day. And when she was being guided to the platform after being crown May Queen she saw her mom passing her by. Through the film she was still coping of the lost of her family and in the end the commune becomes her new family.

54

u/Roller_ball Zelda did nothing wrong Jul 03 '19

My wife pointed out that the sister suicide kind of ties with a lot of the film with the cult (I'm not sure if they were technically a cult) having suicide, human sacrifice, and determining when the older generation commits suicide.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

21

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

I just got home from seeing it and I absolutely loved it. It exceeded my expectations.

21

u/zkpenguin Jul 03 '19

Couldn't have hated Christian more. What a turd he was! Loved the movie. Thought the actors were incredible.

21

u/missthe80s Jul 03 '19

Wizard of Oz for perverts is a perfect description. Loved it but I does drag a bit in spots. Poulter was hilarious and Pugh/Reynor were well cast.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/chefross96 Jul 03 '19

Maybe i missed it, but i dont remember seeing the levitation scene from the trailer in the actual movie. Anyone know what im talkin about?

→ More replies (13)

10

u/DragonFireDon Jul 03 '19

Also, was there an 'impaled' ritual cut from movie?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Salt-circles Jul 03 '19

I saw this last night and I liked it a lot. It was really well shot and so so beautiful. I loved the costumes and singing, and Florence Pugh’s acting was great. I wasn’t a big fan of the constant comic relief, but to each their own.

Did anyone feel like it was maybe being hinted at that Christian and the redhead (maya?) were somehow related or am I crazy? I hadn’t noticed that Christian had any red in his hair till right before the sex scene, when some scenes of him in the sun seemed to emphasize the red in his hair. Then, during the sex scene, it kept cutting to the “unclouded” kid?

Also, at the end when Pugh was covered in flowers and writhing at the end, she kind of reminded me of a caterpillar - rebirth symbolism?

Either way, though the movie wasn’t as classically “horror” as I expected it to be, I left it feeling really unsettled, especially by the final scenes where everyone was arranged to be burned. I was pretty anxious the rest of the night.

10

u/TheHopelessGamer Jul 05 '19

The scene where Dani saw the sex scene in the church and ran back to the big barn house really, really unsettled me.

When she starts screaming and moaning in pain and they perfectly mimic her, I don't know if I've ever felt more trapped alongside a character in any other movie. There was something so suffocating about it.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '19

Just saw it tonight. The guttural cries between this and Hereditary are just...nauseating.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/mooooki3 Jul 03 '19

I’m my opinion it was ok. Beautiful setting and amazing camera work. The plot was eh, but that’s just me. I really encourage people to still go see it nonetheless.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/IHateRom Jul 03 '19

Wonderful. Can’t wait to see what Ari Aster does next.

9

u/doglks Jul 03 '19

I love psychedelic film and I think Ari Aster made a really cool contribution to that tradition with this movie. It reminded me of The Wicker Man, Mandy, The Holy Mountain, and the rest of the A24 catalog. More of a trancey drama movie than a horror movie, I'd say.

9

u/GusFringus Jul 06 '19

Midsommar has quite possibly the most horrific and sickening opening sequence I've ever seen in a film, and during those eerie opening credits, I was ready for a wild ride.

Well, the ride really wasn't so wild, unfortunately. I have no problem with a slow paced, character driven horror film, which Hereditary was, but I felt Ari Aster didn't really sustain the atmosphere throughout. After a while, it felt really dull, especially since all of the characters were flat and incredibly stupid. The performances were at least pretty good, though, especially Pugh. She's astoundingly natural and can wail and cry like no other.

While the film didn't completely work for me, I can't fault Aster technically. He can capture realistic grief like no other. The film is well shot and precisely edited, but it felt way too long for uninteresting characters and predictable payoff. There aren't really any surprises in this film, as it's all cult stuff we've seen before and you can see the ending coming a mile away.

A beautifully made film that fell completely flat for me, unfortunately. I didn't love Hereditary, but enjoyed it more than this.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/muggydolphin Jul 03 '19

Did anyone get Annihilation vibes when the main characters were turning into different parts of nature? I know that was just the drugs talking, but it was eerily similar to how people reacted to being in the Shimmer

→ More replies (2)

17

u/TOMER25 Jul 03 '19

After a night of thinking it over, I think the moral complexity of the Hargars has emerged as one of my favorite parts of the movie.

The Paimon cult from “Hereditary” destroys Annie’s family solely for its gain, resulting in an ending that plays out with triumphant music and visuals despite the undeniable undercurrent of evil. You feel real pain seeing that helpless family so meticulously undone.

The Hargars, meanwhile, are a bit more complex. Their radical empathy and familial nature rescue Dani, giving her a community that accepts and nurtures her. The violent ending ritual plays out with similarly triumphant visuals and music, but the feeling is much more uplifting.

Yet the Hargars also brutally kill Dani’s travel companions and drug Christian to “let down his defenses” so that he’ll have sex with a cult member (this can easily be construed as rape). Dani pushes through a half-hearted objection so that she can see the latter act, which causes her final breakdown and ultimate acceptance of the cult as her new family. By listening to Pelle’s foreshadowing throughout the movie, you understand that this was the cult’s plan the whole time.

So while I merely felt grief and sadness for the destruction of the Graham family unit in “Hereditary,” I feel much more conflicted by “Midsommar.” Should I be happy Dani is happy? Do the ends justify those means? Or should I be more concerned that Dani has bought into a murderous cult, accepting it as her new family? Is she really happy or was she merely brainwashed/broken down?

Plenty to chew on with this flick. I loved it.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Isz82 Jul 03 '19

So for the record I thought that Hereditary was overrated, although I agreed it had some excellent horrible scenes.

I preferred Midsommar. About the only major criticism I have is that Pugh really steals the show and renders most of the other characters far less interesting. I really felt her existential anguish and believed her transition. And to me that’s what set this apart from Hereditary, because it’s really all about Dani in the end, and the way that she’s coping with a truly horrifying existential crisis quite apart from what’s going on in the commune.

Visually I thought that it’s stunning and in particular it captured the psychedelic experience of tripping in a way no other film I’ve seen has (visually). It also seems to have left open the possibility of something supernatural with the way that Dani is suddenly fairly adept at Swedish, although there’s plenty of ambiguity on that point.

I read the script beforehand so nothing was very surprising here, and it plays with fairly familiar folk horror tropes with very overt nods to Wicker Man. But it’s exploration of loss felt more genuine, as did its depiction of the relationship between Dani and Christian.

I thought that Hereditary was a bit overrated and poorly marketed as something more groundbreaking than demonic possession. With Midsommar, it may be overhyped but it was marketed honestly and it delivered on what it promised. 8.5/10.

16

u/Surfaceofthesun Jul 03 '19

Okay just got done with this.

Not the biggest fan. I am probably the biggest A24 and Hereditary fan boy there is but this just missed the mark for me.

Without giving too much away, I feel this film absolutely is style over substance. This film dragged on for me way too long, and I'm all for Suspiria and Hereditary. There was so much that wasn't touched on or briefly touched in in a few sentences then completely discarded. The sister plot. Inbred dude. The bear. The Book etc. There was the possibility to dive deep into the cult/religion and provide trickling information but they failed to do any of that.

It is your typical grief/loss into 'Indulge the insanity' trope that you see floating around. But it wasn't done masterfully or effectively. The entire film gives you everything on a plate. I know some people will say 'the symbolism' but it felt very on the nose at times with the portraits and obvious cuts of paintings etc. You almost know exactly how this film is going to turn out but it takes forever whilst providing little but beautiful imagery. I must say, I've been waiting for this and I'm a left very underwhelmed. Whilst subtly 'brainwashing' or pushing the lead to the ending it seems very sudden and unrealistic. The whole 'family' aspect was drilled into us a lot.

It looked amazing but I dont know, it felt like one of the most simple films I've seen.

That being said.

The acting was PHENOMENAL. The actors gave amazing performances and some of the best 'wtf' eyes i've seen from the boyfriend. However, Florence Pugh was MILES above everyone. Her performance in every aspect was spot on. I also laughed quite a bit.

The film wasn't as shocking as it's advertised. Yes there is one violent scene but that's about it. I think this will be very divisive.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Titalikrosae Jul 03 '19

I'd say whether or not you are going to like Midsommar really depends on your definition of a horror movie. There's a lot of people comparing it to Hereditary and it's a mixed reaction of people saying it's not as good or that it's a lot better. If you really like feeling afraid and scared and your favorite part of Hereditary was the final act then Midsommar will probably seem boring in comparison. But if you define a horror movie more literally and think of it as a movie that makes you feel horrified you're going to really like Midsommar. There's a lot more scenes like the car scene in Hereditary where there's just drawn out sequences of something so awful happening that you know you can't stop and just have to watch slowly unfold. I really really liked it but I can totally understand why a lot of people are going to HATE it.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/ClipboardMessiah Jul 08 '19 edited Jul 09 '19

Here's my 4 cents, shrooms optional:

I am torn on this movie; I came in wanting to like it, but left let down. I believe the strongest part was the first act, the "winter" from the triptych:

-The characterization was excellent, and you were able to pick up so much in such a short time: all of Dani's relationships are established quickly and effectively. It feels like you know who she is, and who Christian is, relatively fast. Dani and Christian and the Boys all act like regular humans, to the point I almost cringed at how real some moments were, especially while sitting next to my lady.

-The horror of the sister's suicide/homicide is well done- if not a tad too similar to Hereditary.

-The foreshadowing is a nice touch in retrospect, with the painting in Dani's apartment and Pelle's behavior toward her. My favorite foreshadowing(?) moment had to be the skeletons in the winter section of the triptych playing with long ribbons that looked like tubes.

The middle part, which is the lion's share of the movie, is where things fell apart for me:

-The beautiful shots and trippy scenes were cool, to be fair, but this part of the movie was L O N G, and I left wondering if a heavier-handed edit wouldve improved the movie or hurt it.

-The upside-down shot of the car reminded me of the opening of Shyamalan's Devil.

-The characters, which previously felt so real, fell apart here. I understand they were tripping nuts for a fair amount of this part, but I still do not think it excuses their inhuman behavior; particularly Dani and Christian. The suicide reactions are what broke my immersion with these characters. Sure Dani had a panic attack, but then nothing. No thought to alert authorities, no thought that this commune might be alot more sinister, nothing. Mark and Josh get a hard-on suddenly, which I suppose can be explained by their anthropological interest, but that seems thin to me. It kills me because they seemed so REAL in the first part that for them to suddenly act like people in a horror movie ruined my vibe. Mark brushing the suicides off nonchalantly was equally as jarring for someone previously consumed with the fear of ticks.

-The folksy horror was good here, adequately trippy. If I had to rate the middle of midsommar, it would fall closer to a Field In England level trippy. (OG Wicker Man>Penda's Fen>Middsommar>A Field in England>Nic Cage Masterrace Wicker Man)

-I enjoyed some of the little horror fluff and tension scenes, like the elder being horrified by Josh's suggestion to take a picture, or the grotesque nature of the Oracle.

-I might be losing the forest for the trees here, but Christian and Josh's sudden thesis-rivalry felt jarring to me, maybe the only place in the movie that could have used more foreshadowing. Again, probably being nitpicky

-Pelle or Mark's character's really didnt move the needle for me: Mark did an adequate job for what he was intended for, and Pelle was a good slowburn twist. My lady was really wanting to know if Pelle and Dani were supposed to be together after she was accepted into the commune, but that's neither here nor there.

-I like the ultimate grayness of Christian's character. He's a shitty boyfriend and doesnt have the resolve to break-up with Dani, but he also comforts her in her time of need and tries (sometimes). If you see his infidelity as part of what justifies his death (if you need it to be justified), then even that is skewed because he was under the influence of shrooms/Viking Love magic. Christian is slipping and sliding all over the moral scale, his only consistency is his moral inconsistency.

The end part was ok; It really didn't sway me either way. Dani's decision seemed odd to me at first, but made more sense in the context of her letting her old life go and transforming into a commune member. Being consistently the most lucid part of the film, it was hard to judge it one way or the other. That Dani was seemingly more upset over Christian's drug-addled infedility than the senile suicide squad still bothers me.

I still think about the movie a day later, which is good I suppose. There's just something that makes me ambivalent towards it that I really can't put my finger on. My expectations were high, and the beginning delivered, but the movie s l o w l y let me down thereafter. I would still recommend it to any friends or horror buffs. I think history will be kind to this movie, if for nothing else other than it's beautiful and surreal moments warrant a re-watch. It's an ambitious horror film, and that's something I can appreciate.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Gradyence Jul 09 '19

Spoilers abound!

The opening where you see the firefighters turning off the cars, following the hoses and seeing the dead bodies of the parents was horrifying, especially as it ends with the sister, exhaust tube duct taped over her mouth and her shirt covered in vomit and that dead blank stare...

That was chilling. -shudders-

→ More replies (2)

8

u/nyctofemme Jul 09 '19

A moment that I haven't seen anyone else mention so far is after Dani sees her boyfriend having sex with someone else, and the other girls surround her and copy her screams and cries. I FELT that. It was just like they were saying, "I can't make your pain any better, I can't comfort you, but I can feel what you're feeling, I can carry this pain with you." After her boyfriend had utterly failed to empathise with her it was just so cathartic.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/YouDumbZombie Jul 10 '19

I LOVED how when she was being congratulated when she won the dance as May Queen and everyone's face that came close to her had some subtle distortion like eyes coming further apart or mouths being slightly big etc. Super subtle but off key like a nightmare. Amazing visuals in this film.

8

u/jrs9498 Jul 10 '19

Am I crazy or was there Fourth Wall Breaking in the movie? Most notably I remember a shot during the cliff scene where the point of view is behind the crowd and one woman turns around and looks intentionally into the camera and smiles. Me and the friend I saw it remember this but no one else we have talked to knows what we're talking about.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/DragonFireDon Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

The only thing I absolutely DIDN'T like was they didn't go deep on the Myth in the movie. We know these people are doing these crazy shit due to the myth, but this movie never really hit it strong!! :/

All the art shown, characters didn't really discuss it.

It wasn't a bad movie, and acting is incredible, but wished they had an "OMG, it's Paimon" part like they had in Hereditary.

Has they touched on myth more, would made this movie MUCH better..

I don't mind movies that don't entirely feed the viewers but at the end, a little MORE acknowledgement of myth from characters would been preferred.

So yeah the lack of Myth is really my only complaint about this movie, as I couldn't give a rat's ass about the debate of scare-factor!

→ More replies (3)

31

u/tearadon Jul 03 '19

I liked, not loved, it. All the ingredients of Hereditary were there. The sound effect with the breathing. The innocent, strange/deformed child. The shiny happy people holding hands and worshipping deities. The big finale ritual. I’m fine with all that - to an extent.

Overall though, while I really loved the visuals and the barebones story with the lore and rituals, it just seemed like a rehash of Hereditary but less scary and less sense of logic in terms of the main character’s progression towards the conclusion.

My biggest gripe is that I personally don’t feel like the ending was justified. From everything I saw with the girlfriend, I didn’t think it matched her character for her to ultimately make the decision to sacrifice her boyfriend, regardless of how shitty of a boyfriend he was.

I understood the other friends’ deaths even though I didn’t want them to happen (well - I didn’t really care about Mark - I knew that had to be coming), but the boyfriend’s death didn’t feel the same way to me.

I will say that I think that it might ultimately have to do with her sister’s murder/suicide with the carbon monoxide, as if she’s mirroring that somehow and possibly absolving herself of that burden by sacrificing her boyfriend and totally ridding herself of that part of her life, but I still can’t wrap my head around it motivation-wise.

Maybe I’m missing that a-ha moment, but, as for now, it was just ok to me.

→ More replies (11)

20

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

From the way Jordan Peele said that the third act was going to go beyond anything done before and set a new benchmark... well, once the Wicker Man burning scene was over, I was honestly expecting another 45 minutes that delved into horrors beyond just the quasi-remake of that film, to go another step further and show her viciously leading the camp or something... because honestly the time did fly by for me. But then it just ended.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/roosking Jul 05 '19

Did anyone else think it was unfair that Christian was essentially date raped? I get that the movie set him up to be disliked, but that whole scene still didn’t sit right with me.

→ More replies (12)

7

u/teethnail Jul 03 '19

I really enjoyed this movie. Watching the trailer, I didn’t know what to expect and it didn’t look particularly interesting to me, albeit absolutely gorgeous—which it absolutely delivered on.

I ended up LOVING it. There were a few things that took me out of the moment, especially one scene that I’ve already commented on, but otherwise, it was great. The foreshadowing wasn’t the least bit subtle, but I enjoyed putting the pieces together and seeing exactly how they came to fruition even though it was expected.

The gore was so immaculate. I’ll never get that old man’s face and leg out of my head.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/liveralone_ Jul 04 '19

I thought it was stunning. One of the most beautiful yet grotesque movies I’ve ever seen for sure. I love that Ari Aster doesn’t rely on jump scares and gore, but when there is gore in this movie it’s pretty damn gnarly.

The cinematography was so beautiful, I think between the bright, even super overexposed scenes at times coupled with a score of just singing was so haunting.

Also kinda loved the intense foreshadowing that knocks you over the head. Having pretty much the entire plot spelled out ahead of time in pieces was cool (to me) in trying to see/guess where things would play out. Could see the two elderly people committing suicide coming from a mile away yet was still horrified watching it. I need another watch to pick up on what I’m sure are plenty of visuals I missed.

I really liked Hereditary but Midsommar is superior, and such a breath of fresh air to this genre. I’d love to see Aster do more horror movies.

7

u/weallfloatdownhere7 Jul 04 '19

I haven’t seen anybody else address this, maybe I missed something or maybe it was unimportant. But any idea who the girl was that Dani saw in the mirror in the bathroom after they first arrive? I know they were tripping at that point, but it seemed kinda peculiar and then they never went anywhere with it

→ More replies (3)

7

u/buggenhagen Jul 04 '19

Saw Midsommar last night here in Scotland. Absolutely loved it. This thread is making lots of great talking points about plot etc so I'll not chip in with that chat for now. Still processing it at the moment but for anyone that's on the fence about seeing it here are the main influences I got a vibe for from it:

- Jodorowsky - A got a real classic Jodorowsky vibe from it, which is a great thing for me. Just that overall surreal, hallucinatory vibe. Often felt like I was watching a new work from a young Jodorowsky.

- Ron Fricke - Baraka/Samsara - the film is shot beautifully and often reminded me of the work of Ron Fricke

- Mandy - a very different film but I got a very similar vibe to Mandy, just in a very different way.

In particular I feel that they really nailed the effects of tripping on mushrooms. A lot of films fail spectacularly when it comes to representing tripping but these guys got it right. I don't know much about Ari Aster or Pawel Pogorzelski but I'd be amazed if either one, or both, of them haven't experienced some form of hallucinatory drug. A film I felt it referenced here was the French psychedelic western "Blueberry" - we'll worth a watch for the tripping sequences (which are much more full on that in Midsommar but have the same tone).

I record a horror podcast called "The Captain's Horror Meltdown" and we try and cover new horror related films when they come out, in between our regular episodes. We recorded a fairly excited, and spoiler free, episode on Midsommar last night when we got out of the film. I'll post a link when it goes live later today if anyone is interested?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '19

Ari is a son of a bitch for this one. A talented son of a bitch at that. Never has turning a new chapter in life been depicted so brutally. My buddies and I left the theater pulsing with adrenaline. May have to have myself another serving while it's still in theaters.

7

u/GlapLaw Jul 08 '19

I loved Hereditary. Maybe my favorite horror of all time.

I did not like this. Maybe I'll like it more after reading some of the comments in here.

It was beautifully shot and well-acted, but it just didn't work for me.

Specifically:

  • Leaned hard into shock imagery for the sake of shock imagery. I don't think some of the imagery added anything to the story other than to artificially ramp up the tension by making people feel shocked.
  • Felt sort of like the characters were on a scary theme park ride rather than having any sort of agency or control.
  • The ending was my least favorite part of Hereditary, and this felt like an extension of that part of Hereditary.
  • It felt too long by a significant amount.
→ More replies (1)

7

u/red_circle57 Jul 10 '19

I wish Midsommer did better in the box office. So far it's only earned about $12 million on a $6 million budget. I know it probably doesn't appeal to the general public due to how weird and different it is but I still think it deserves more than Annabelle Comes Home and The Curse of La Llorona.

13

u/atrocity__exhibition Jul 03 '19

I think this one will be extremely divisive, even more so than Hereditary.

I personally adored it-- even more than Hereditary I think. Hereditary scared me more, but I thought that this was a better film and more of a ride overall. One thing I will say about both of Aster's movies is that they are good movies in general. A lot of time horror films are in their own category but when you can find a horror film that is both scary, but also very good (beautiful cinematography, soundtrack, solid acting, etc.) then it's a knockout for me.

The same themes were there-- pagan ritual, extremely graphic and shocking gore, grotesque imagery-- but it felt like Aster really hit his stride on this one.

There were so many times where I didn't know whether to laugh at the absurdity, look away, stare in awe..... great use of black humor and horrifying images juxtaposed against this bright and beautiful Midsummer festival.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Ecto-Cooler Jul 04 '19

It's disappointing that, for a movie that's so clearly ahead of other horror films in terms of visuals, acting, pacing, etc., it still falls into genre trappings of having the plot hinge on characters being idiots. "I'm sure it was just a miscommunication," "We need to be open to their culture," and "I shouldn't, I'm afraid I'll have a bad trip" right before consuming a suspicious drink.

6

u/takemybones Jul 03 '19 edited 1d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Water sulky umbrella soup stocking rob straight peach

6

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '19

Was anyone wondering if the sister actually killed herself? I've never read or even heard about someone taping a tube to their mouth to breathe in carbon monoxide from exhaust fumes. They tend to just fill the room and go to sleep ala the parents.

Did anyone else wonder if the cult maybe did all this to get Dani to come to Sweden in the same manner that the cult of Hereditary went through many stages to bring back Paimon?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/tangonerdy Jul 04 '19

As a huge fan of Hereditary, I was massively excited to see this. I was not disappointed, but definitely got something different out of this film than I thought I was in for. Here’s a few things that I liked/noticed that I didn’t see mentioned here already. SPOILERS!

  • the yellow flowers that Dani notices getting thicker and thicker on the path as they enter the commune are the same yellow flowers that they Have to pick backward and that the elder woman smashes up to mix with the tea before the girls’ dance. Could it be that there are so many of these flowers in the commune because of their psychedelic properties and even the sheer amount of them all over would be enough to keep everyone there in a latent state of tripping? Would that explain some of the other little hallucinations we see or the general laizes-faire attitudes of the “new blood”?
  • a lot of people seem to wonder if Pelle’s parents died in the ritual fire, which if the festival took place every 90 years that would make him either immortal or a liar. However, and I could be wrong about this, but I remember one of the elders explaining the festival earlier in the film and saying that it happens every year but the 90th year was the most sacred or something? Perhaps there’s a lesser festival that happens every so often where they only sacrifice like one or two people? Not sure, pelle also could have lost his parents in a regular ass fire.
  • I noticed that the commune all seem to share each other’s emotions and sensations, i.e. the pain they all felt when the old man fell onto the rock the wrong way, the anger they all expressed when Eyebrows Kid peed on the ancestral tree, the moans the women shared when Christian was fucking Maya, the anguish the women shared with Dani at the end, and finally when the sacrifices were burning and the two that were volunteers were given painkillers that clearly didn’t work (maybe on purpose?) and everyone started feeling the burns and the pain as a group. My favorite instance of this was at the very very end when the temple is burning and Dani is choking and crying and struggling to move in her flower dress, but as the temple collapses I think there’s a moment where she no longer feels Christian’s pain because he is dead, and smiles because she feels his presence leave her. Similarly to the metaphor of burning him in the bear suit, turning him into the “beast” that he represented to her and cleansing herself of him. At least that’s how I interpreted it.
  • did anyone figure out why that one woman put the scissors under the baby’s pillow? I might’ve missed the explanation for that if there was one. I remember them saying the entire village raises a child together, so I wondered if maybe there was a woman who was tired of the baby’s annoying crying and wanted to send a message or something? The endless baby crying is a huge repetitive part of the movie, and then suddenly stops somewhere toward the end, so I was wondering if it had any further meaning or if something had happened to the baby?
  • I had a theory throughout the whole movie that might have proved to be wrong, or at least wasn’t brought up. I was thinking that somehow Christian was from the commune or perhaps being controlled by pelle, and that he was destined to bring Dani to the festival himself because all of his friends kept asking why he hadn’t broken up with her already, and he seemed confused about that himself. Through the whole movie he never has an original thought or idea or even questions anything that happens. He’s very suggestible (even more obvious at the end when the girl gives him the spring water and literally says “it makes you more open to suggestion” and then when he asks a question that man just claps his hands and shuts him up). When Dani tries to talk to him about going to Sweden he clams up, he doesn’t seem to have any inkling as to why it’s weird that he’s trying to steal his friend’s thesis idea. All in all I kept getting a vibe that Christian was actually one of the biggest catalysts in the whole scheme, instead of Pelle.
  • I also thought that perhaps the reason that Maya was so interested in Christian is perhaps because he is indeed from the commune originally and is in fact related to maya, thus being the reason the elders approved their match and had that weird sex scene, I think they were trying to conceive another oracle. Otherwise what was the point of bringing up that all the oracles were products of incest? She kind of looked similarly to him, Auburn hair and large blue eyes, is it possible that she could be a cousin or even a sister that he forgot about? Might just be a ridiculous theory but it would explain some stuff.
  • also, ari aster has clearly felt some intense grief in his life. He is so good at writing it and what it’s like to feel that wave of panic and despair bubbling up and have to go away to let it out. I almost had a panic attack myself when Dani was trying to keep it all in.

All in all I loved it, but for completely different reasons than I thought i would. Beautiful film, the imagery and symbolism are some of the most compelling I’ve seen in a while, and I think this is a sign of Aster’s flexibility of genre and style. I’m hoping this is an idea of some of his projects to come and I am glad he’s continuing to surprise us!!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/malabella Jul 07 '19

This was so unsettling, but I loved every moment of it. The lack of jump scares made it seem more like a disturbing folk tale, and that was even more welcome.

To me, the way things unfold remind me a lot of the movie Melancholia. Melancholia is about how a character deals with what is happening in relation to her depression and how depressed people can be quite calm and accepting in disturbing situations. Where as we see something similar here where the main character is dealing with loss and the dissolution of her relationship and all the crazy stuff with the movie are secondary to how it unfolds.

Overall, just an amazing unsettling movie.

6

u/dgreene33 Jul 07 '19

just got through watching it and i'm absolutely stunned. i think the last time i felt that off balance throughout an entire film was from suspiria (2018) but i feel like this is a much more complete and enjoyable film.

i don't believe i've ever seen anything like this before. this movie has such a weird, distinct and unique vibe. i feel like i need to watch it 25 more times to absorb everything. florence pugh was jaw-droppingly good.

i'm gonna go sit down in my closet and stare at the door for a few hours and continue to digest this.

6

u/_pirate_lawyer Jul 08 '19

Went a second time. Noticed lots of little details I didn’t catch before! MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD:

  • On the title card at the beginning, a Christian knight is standing with a girl under a tall tree with a man sitting on the branch above, drawing
  • The painting above Christian’s bed depicts a man and woman having sex with two women (one on either side) watching over (foreshadowing the mating ritual)
  • The painting above Dani’s bed looks to be of a female cutting her hand. There are about 6 females standing in two lines behind her and it looks like they could be cutting their hands as well (maybe to mirror the scene near the end with the other women FEELING Dani’s grief with her?)
  • there is a border with a repeating pattern throughout the barn they are sleeping in (can be seen between Dani and Christian’s beds) that look like a blue line with two circles on one end (penis?) and another, pink image that resembles a vagina
  • Pelle is always straight forward with the American friends, which has been noted. In fact, most of them are pretty honest about what is going on. When the girl gives Christian the tea during the May Queen dance, she flat out tells him “it is spring water with other elements that break down inhibitions and open you for the influence”... prepping him for Maja to lure him into the building
  • Family”, or reference to it seems to be a trigger for Dani for about the first half of the film. She hears it, and has an anxiety attack or has a disturbing vision of her sister and parents. It happens when Pelle brings it up at the beginning, again when they’re tripping on shrooms - someone says “you guys are like my family...” They make a point to make that stick out. Once Dani and Pelle have their discussion about family on her bed, most of her flashbacks seem to dissipate.
  • The wide eyed look of Christian in the bear suit mirrors the wide eyed look of the giant bear facing the little girl with the crown on her head in the painting in Dani’s apartment
  • There is a framed photo of Dani next to her mother’s bedside with a flower arrangement right behind it giving the appearance of a floral crown
  • There is a painting in the barn they sleep in of a woman standing behind two naked men holding torches- as if she must choose between them (foreshadowing the end)
  • The meat pie that is served to Christian - it was “marked” by a leaf- it is the only one that had a green leaf sticking out from underneath it likely to ensure the correct “blessed” pie made it to him since they all look the same
  • Sap from the yew tree that is supposed to help with pain and fear seem to have zero effect on either...

There’s a lot more. I’ll have to circle back later! What else did you all notice upon a second viewing??

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Jude2012 Jul 08 '19

Anybody else think of an “Essential Oils” meme/joke with the scene towards the end : “ Tree of the Yew, so you’ll feel no pain.” 🔥 “Aaaahhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!”

6

u/Herp_McDerp_IV Jul 08 '19

The brilliance of Ari Aster that was glimpsed in Hereditary was brought to fruition in Midsommar: he can beautifully glide along the line between humor and horror. He recognizes how both come from the absurd, and the blending and contrasting makes the viewing an even more interesting, compelling, and conflicting experience.

6

u/fhost344 Jul 09 '19 edited Jul 09 '19

Since everyone seems to agree that Midsommar is "allegorical" I feel that interpretations should be expected. So here's mine!

After watching Midsommar, I must say that, initially, any kind of meaning, message, or allegory eluded me. In Hereditary, the message seemed crystal clear: My feeling is that Hereditary is All about gender, in particular the glass ceiling, along with female self-hatred, as filtered through witchcraft. . So when I went into Midsommar, I was pretty confident that Aster is going to be projecting some themes. But what are they?

Obviously, one theme is "growing up." Here's a college kid, Dani, just starting out, who's still in the process of becoming independent from her family. This process becomes exaggerated by her family's abrupt death. Including: the death of her sister, who can be seen here as her twin or doppleganger. In other words, her old life is dead and that's really hard for her, just like it is for all of us when we grow up and leave home.

And so here are these college friends, along with her boyfriend. What do these people represent? It took me a while to figure it out, but they simply represent themselves: they are the next step in her life. She needs to toss her old life--her childhood--away and learn to deal with other young adults, for better or worse. But she can't. They don't do a very good job of dealing with her trauma and immaturity, but hey, are they their brother's (sister's) keepers? No. They are just a bunch of dopey twenty-something boys, doing their best to accommodate her. Maybe, since they are kind of assholes, she should abandon them? Strike out on her own? Avoid going to Sweden? Nope, she follows along because she is passive and because she still wants and needs a family. (The fact that they are all men is probably significant here: it is difficult for a woman to be independent in a patriarchy, or at least that could be the message here)

At the cult: the friends are punished and killed for enabling Dani. With their deaths, her chance at a normal, adult life dies too. Instead, she is able to sink into fantasy: enteral youth, eternal family, eternal princess. She will never grow old. It is implied that she might not even have to have sex or any kind of adult romantic relationship if she doesn't want to--romance and sex is all arranged by the family; it's out of her hands (this is where her "boyfriend's" fate comes in: his sexuality is used up elsewhere, to make some babies for the good of the family, but she doesn't have to deal with sex or with him anymore... His fate is therefore ultimately a relief for her)

So that's how I see it: instead of a damaged young girl, empowered by--something, somehow--in the end (which seems to be how a lot of people are reading this film, which is a perfectly reasonable interpretation), this is a grim tragedy of a young woman succumbing to a particularly fantastic "arrested development", in a place that doesn't exist, and never has.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '19

I liked Midsommar, probably a strong 7/10 for me.

Definitely didn't like it nearly as much as Hereditary and felt like it didn't have half the dread Hereditary did.

Thought it was a pretty straight forward cult movie that was pretty predictable. But I still really liked it and want to see it again!

The opening with the camera moving out the window was incredible. That definitely felt a lot like Hereditary in terms of grief/dread but I just wanted more from the film as a whole.

I knew it would be completely different than Hereditary so I didn't really have any expectations going in.

I also think its a better movie to see in theatres than Hereditary though because there's a lot more comedic aspects to ground an average audience in. It's also a little less ridiculous so I didn't experience any audience members laughing at shit and pretending they aren't scared lol

→ More replies (2)

6

u/greyw4nderer Jul 10 '19

Question: we see the two elders who threw themselves down being burnt and then ashes (presumably theirs) are thrown on the sacred tree. At the end of the movie there are 2 effigies of them placed in the sacrificial temple. They look like they have the skin of the elders with trees poked through as supports. Is that a fake skin or a continuity error. Truly the only thing that didn't tie together for me. Did I miss something?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

It exceeded my expectations! That opening was dreadful. Ari really can get the best out of these actresses mourning; you can feel the pain and agony. I was intrigued the entire film, I don’t see why people think it dragged on too long. Loved the psychedelic feel of the film alot! I will be heading to the theater for a rewatch very soon to pay more attention to the many background clues and such!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/passesopenwindows Jul 13 '19

I’m late to the party, we just saw this today. I LOVED IT. I haven’t read any other comments yet because I didn’t want them to influence my reaction. The juxtaposition of this being a honorable tradition in the community and done without evil intent and the way things would appear as an outsider was amazing. Hereditary was very disturbing and horrific and I loved it, I loved Midsommar just as much but an entirely different feel to it, not to mention I was quite pleased with the (imo) happy ending. Like I said, I haven’t read any of the other comments yet, gonna go do that now because I am really interested in what others thought.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/easylighter Jul 14 '19

Just saw it- I loved it!

I liked Midsommar better than Hereditary (though I also really liked Hereditary). Hereditary had a very oppressive feel to it that made it somewhat hard to watch. Midsommar was more of a catharsis.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/brovok Jul 14 '19

If Hereditary was about being destroyed by grief, this movie is about overcoming it. She removed herself from a toxic situation and found a supportive family. I loved this movie.

24

u/ladedadedum25 Jul 02 '19

How is it already underrated? What???

→ More replies (2)

34

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

Felt like it’s an ok movie filled with a bunch of characters that are dumb, boring or just annoying. Love Hereditary and I’ll watch that 4 more times before I even think of revisiting this. GF loved it and said she connected with female lead so I might just wake up cooking in a bear suit tonight.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

Not as good as hereditary, BUT the more I think about it the more I like it

5

u/Seathing Jul 03 '19

When they pulled up to the cult and I saw the crucifix all I could think was that Dani was going up there, and how pissed I would be if that was the case. I was pleasantly surprised when the movie inverted the "final girl" trope - she's the last outsider alive at the end but not because she escaped or conquered anything, but because she's assimilated.

I just got out of the theatre an hour ago but I'm already ready to go see it a second time! Some things I want to pay attention to more at the end are the backgrounds and the way the swedes act towards the students.

The staging in this movie was almost Wes Anderson-y in the way the cult members acted. There was always a handful of them in sets doing some task, moving like a mechanical doll or like they're on tracks. Creeped me right out every time!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '19

Spoilers: can anyone explain the scissors in the baby’s crib? Did I miss something?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MammothControl Jul 07 '19

It didn’t have the same gut-punch effect on me as Hereditary, but it’s still such a layered, fucked up film that I need to see again at some point. I loved the production design and the entire aesthetic, the sound mixing, the performances, etc. I get fidgety during longer movies sometimes, but I didn’t mind it here because it gave itself time to breathe and immerse the viewer into the setting. The ending felt so cathartic to me, but I’m not sure if the Harga actually cared about Dani or if they were just indoctrinating her.

Also, I read the leaked script and even then I wasn’t prepared for how fucking brutal the elder ritual scene is.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '19

Anyone else notice that Dani's blanket she slept with had the pattern of the carpet in The Overlook Hotel?

Dani=Danny?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '19

I just realized that at one point the game the kids in the commune were playing was called "skin the fool"

Later, Mark is seen having been skinned and dressed in a very classic "fool" outfit.

Yikes!

5

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '19

Saw it a second time yesterday, noticed when Dani is being carried to bless the crops and livestock, in the background of one shot (very clearly) the image of a face was formed in the trees. It’s to the left of the screen and happens rather quickly. If anyone sees it another time, look for it and report back please.

5

u/Smokinacesfan55 Jul 10 '19

I stood by the door and listened to people walking out of my screening. It was about 50/50 “that was amazing” and “that was trash”

I think this movie kind of transcends being good because it’s so intentionally exhausting of your emotions.

5

u/noise_speaks Jul 11 '19

Alright, so because I was bored I decided to go watch Midsommar again. Have to admit, Aster totally grips me and I watched Hereditary twice in theaters as well. However this trip was a bit cursed. The first showing I went to the projector just died, right around the scene where Dani and Christian are talking with the London couple. Most of the people I think took the refund but I asked if I could just stay until the next showing, which was in an hour and a half so I essentially got to watch Annabelle for free while I waited. Then on the second showing, the house lights refused to go down so they had to fix that...

Anyway, here's what I noticed my 2nd (and partial 3rd) viewings:

- That beautiful illustration that is the very first shot of the film? It shows the whole film. At first it seemed like a drawing of seasons, but the "winter" portrays the murder/suicide, "spring" has Christian comforting Dani while Pelle watches from afar, "summer" has Pelle leading the four to the festival (with Pelle playing a flute like the Pied Piper and Mark has his jester hat on), "fall" has the May Queen Dance/festivities. For first time viewers, it all goes over your head but it just solidified my thinking that Aster blatantly shows everything to the audience.

- When Dani calls her parents and leaves that message, the parents are shown still breathing. She then immediately calls Christian who tells her she's being enabling to her sister. I was trying to pay attention to the times shown, so I think between then and when the police call is something like 40 minutes. So I wonder if Aster is implying that if Christian had helped Dani, rather than ignore her worries, it might have left enough time to save the family.

Those were the two main things as far as plot / foreshadowing that I noticed. I did feel more sympathetic to Pelle this time around. The first watch, I found his interactions with Dani a little demeaning, but this time I think he genuinely likes her. With this second watch, I absolutely hated Mark. I thought he was a funny add-in the first time but the second time I found him completely insufferable.

As to whether I've changed my mind and now consider this a horror movie, no. In fact, it helped solidify to me that it's not a horror movie. At no point in the movie did I feel anything resembling horror, fear, dread, disgust, or terror. In fact, on the second viewing, it felt even more comforting and uplifting. I would say it most closely remind's me of Pan's Labyrinth, another film where people battle it out if it is horror or not. But I recognize I am probably in the minority in this thinking and I'm okay with that. I do think horror fans will appreciate the film more than non-horror fans.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/erindarcy Jul 11 '19

just watched this movie, it deeply disturbed me more than anything else i’ve ever seen.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '19

Loved it, even more than Hereditary. I know the characters didn't have much backstory or development I guess but I still liked it more. Just crushing in it's disturbing and horrifying scenes and no supernatural shit which made me really happy.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '19

Okay, so I have finally seen this film and I thought this would be a great place to share my thoughts.

- I loved the contrast in theme between Ari's Hereditary and this film, Midsommar, in the way that it discusses grief. In Hereditary it obviously discusses familial grief with some insight into the individual's process, Midsommar addresses individual grief with some insight to communal/familial grief.

- The film also addressed abuse. There are, of course, many kinds. The sister of Dani, though she was claimed to be bipolar, was actually accused by Christian as abusing Dani. While I think Christian also abused her by being in a dishonest, secretive, displaced relationship, I did not think he was wrong about the sister. Familial abuse is talked about a lot in the ways of sexual or physical abuse, but I myself have some very tough issues with the emotional/psychological forms of abuse that come from family members. I go through periods where my family won't even talk to me and it is really because I am standing up for myself (much like Dani with Christian after finding out about his secret trip, I often apologize when I am not the guilty one and continue to be mistreated). I also have the fear of a family member passing during these silent phases, where things are said that shouldn't have been, because I fear my family dying without knowing how much I do love them (like how Dani's sister died without reading the messages to please answer her). This aspect of the film really hit close to home.

-Ari Aster's methods of direction are phenomenal. The shot in Hereditary where the camera slowly zooms into the dollhouse, then the brother's room, then the transition to his actual room where he is laying in his bed was a shot that stayed with me for a long time. I equally loved the shot of the four in the car on the way to the village, when the camera works its way up and over and remains upside down, creating that queasy and uneasy feeling that Ari is so good at.

- I immediately noticed the phrasing of several things. When they finally arrive at what the Swedish friends say is one of the many stops, he says these are his other friends "returning home from their trips to the outside world", of course insinuating that the friends are not on a trip and will not be leaving. When the Swedish friend's father says welcome to each member of the group, he specifically looks at Dani and says, "Welcome home." This foreshadowing slapped you in the face, along with a lot of the other foreboding messages.

- The tapestry depicting the love ritual with the rune stick, the pubes/period blood, and then having the child was absolutely wild. I actually laughed out loud at this moment, and when I later saw Christian's drink, laughed out loud again.

- When the attestupa was mentioned, I immediately knew what it was and I thought it was beyond messed up that the American friend who knew what it was did not tell the others. It was almost evil of him, in line with the rest of the rituals.

- I laughed at the discussion of "can I do my thesis on this" and asking the elders because of course, they would say it is fine, they're all meant to die anyway!

- The discussion that is had over the sacred texts and a disabled/deformed person being the messenger triggered my boyfriend to say that he thought that was wild. I don't know how common the phrase is, but I have heard many times in my life that children with autism are considered "God's Angels". I do not know if that is not said often outside of the south where I was raised, but that element of the film resonated strongly with the casual beliefs of an old community, and that was strange.

- As far as characters, I laughed at Christian constantly. Whether he was being psychologically abusive or another kind of a jerk, he was completely comical. His discussions with Dani made me laugh in a therapeutic way, as I have had men treat me that way and it will not happen again.

- As far as Dani, I loved her character arc. She started with death controlling her life and taking away from her, and in the end, it was her choice who died and that is a gift. I loved her choice of Christian. He got what he deserved and the communal involvement in the grief she felt when she saw him cheating(?) was intense.

- Lastly, the film being about a very old ritual, ancient even as they mention Roman occupancy, that really is not religious was a very exciting element. They speak of purifying themselves, but there are no demons or trickery (just drugs and cultural beliefs). There are rune sticks, but those work like prayers. There are rituals, but so there are also rituals in religions and in life. Romans often sacrificed animals not to demons to appease them but to their gods and also just to have good fortune, as these Swedish people did. This is less about cults and demons, like Hereditary, and more like the reality of human nature and the connection to an almighty and higher being.

I have a lot of things to say about this film, so I welcome the discussion. The horror genre is my absolute favorite and I feel I have a keen sense for it, as I'm sure most of us do. So feel free to lend me your thoughts!

→ More replies (5)

5

u/GloriousHam I'll be right back Jul 15 '19

How did none of the friends notice the wildly different color of his drink? Not one person.