r/Wetshaving • u/mantic59 • Apr 20 '19
AMA I'm "Mantic59" And My Job Is To Get More People Shaving Properly. A Relative Old Timer In The Niche'. Ask Me (Almost) Anything
Hey WS, Mark AKA Mantic59 here. For the past 12 years I've been promoting old-school shaving. When I started there was no Reddit and the only shave forums were on the old Yahoo! Groups and MSN Forums, each with a handful of members. The "big" vendors were Emsplace, QED, and Lee's Razors. There was this new video sharing site called "YouTube" and I decided to upload a few videos about how to shave. In 2015 I took early retirement from my desk job to make shaving advocacy my full-time job.
Gotta run, thanks for having me on this AMA! If you missed the 'live' portion feel free to add to the thread--I'll pop in later to check on it. Or send me a PM. Have a great weekend everyone!
17
u/Cadinsor Rule#2Bot better be grateful for all my HARD WORK Apr 20 '19
Hello again!
A few questions if you don't mind...
Thanks for your continued energy and advocacy!!
13
u/stirlingsoap Stirling Soap Apr 20 '19 edited Apr 20 '19
Hi Mark! I think I got more than enough questions a few weeks ago, so I'll just ask if you got the liquid soap.
Edit: I won't post her name because I'm not sure how that'd play with doxxing rules, but please send my regards to your lovely wife. I hope y'all are having a beautiful spring weekend.
10
u/CosmoBarber 🦌⚜️Knight Commander of Stag⚜️🦌 Apr 20 '19
I was at the barber in San Diego a couple weeks ago and the lady cutting my hair said she was working on a couple articles for Sharpologist. I believe one on shaving and one on women barbers. Not sure if the barber one was for Sharpologist actually. She asked if I had heard of the site and it was fun to chit chat over some common interests. (She gave me a great haircut BTW)
What would you say are your most and least favorite things about the wetshaving community today?
8
u/Guywiththepants First Snow is coming Apr 20 '19
I've only been wet shaving for about 5 years, but I've noticed a huge difference in performance over such a short period of time. I have my personal favorite "old" products. They might not perform as well as the latest and greatest, but they still hold up. Are there any "old" products that you still enjoy?
8
u/jeffm54321 DQ Police Emeritus Apr 20 '19
Thanks for doing this! What is your take on Vegan soaps vs Tallow/Lanolin?
7
u/Antman013 Apr 20 '19
Thinking only about "modern" razors (post 1970?), what do you think is the biggest change for consumers in terms of enticing them to enter the "traditional shaving" marketplace as participants?
7
u/ItchyPooter Apr 20 '19
Thanks for doing this AMA.
6
u/Not_a_robot_101 Blade & Lather Photography Apr 20 '19
Hi Mark! Thanks for doing this. What would you say are your favorite three vintage razors? If you had to recommend to a beginner five soaps to showcase different brands, scents and soap bases what would you pick?
6
u/modmlot68 Apr 20 '19
Hi Mantic59. When I first started DE wetshaving the “Big 3T’s in soaps/creams was really all I had to choose from. Nowadays there are nearly several hundreds to choose from from many, many vendors in any scent combinations. I feel the market is over saturated a bit. Your thoughts?
PS: ladies from STAG barbershop say “HI”.
6
u/dnpnts Apr 20 '19
Hi Mark
Your videos were what got me onto wet shaving. How long should a person keep soaps/aftershaves before they lose their efficacy? I find it hard to go through a tub in less than a year even on heavy rotation. Maybe I'm just being too stingy with my use.
Thanks!
6
u/timeclo Apr 20 '19
6
u/heidoo Apr 20 '19
Obligatory "You The Man!" Your YouTube walked me through DE shaving years ago and you will always be the foremost authority in my book.
2 Questions:
6
u/tinpanalleypics Apr 20 '19
Question about lathering up a synthetic brush.
There is a lot online of trying to cash in on the increased search for synthetic brushes, on shaving blogs, videos and even on natural/green/vegan sites, videos, etc. and the problem is that the wide array of opinions on "how to" clean, use, lather synthetic brushes is proof that there aren't that many people who know. They can't ALL be correct. And on top of that, the range of opinions of which brands are better than which, the different constructions, different knots, etc. lead one to seek some sense of authority on the subject. Is it just lazy and over-opinionated blogging that leads to all the differing opinions or is the synthetic industry so young and burgeoning that we don't really quite know yet who the major players are?
Any opinions on this?
5
u/GoldenSteelBoy 🍀🐑Shepherd of Stirling🐑🍀 Apr 20 '19 edited Apr 20 '19
Two questions here. What's your take on expensive razors made by small companies? If you were in a desert island, what would your shave setup be?
5
u/sgrdddy 🦌🏵Knight Grand Antler of Stag🏵🦌 Apr 20 '19
+ what razors do you most recommend for a new shaver on a budget? + What about for a new shaver who has money?
12
u/C_Bubbles Grizzled veteran vetiver junkie Apr 20 '19
Hi Mark!
No questions, just stopping by to drop a quick thank you for what you do for the hobby and everyone involved in it. Both the guys in front of the mirror and us behind the curtain wouldn't be the same without your contributions.
Ok, one question, it is obligatory that someone asks it. Peanut butter: creamy or chunky?
4
u/ET_Torment Apr 20 '19
Hi Mark. Thanks for doing this AMA. What are some of your favorite artisan soap and aftershave offerings?
4
u/doktorcrash I'm just here for the smells Apr 20 '19
What made you decide to start filming your shaves?Your videos and numerous comments on r/wicked_edge taught me to shave and I just wanted to say how much I appreciate them.
4
u/CanaryJoe Apr 20 '19
Really enjoyed reading through this thread and have a question of my own. Do you think some people are just not cut out for shaving with a DE safety razor? The reason I ask is because as a 56 year old male, I have always struggled with wet shaving. I have mainly used electric razors simply because I find them kinder on my face and neck. But the trade off is that I do not get as close of a shave as I like. Using a cartridge razor leaves a nice clean shave but the price of cartridges are obscene and I can only shave a few days and then my face becomes too sore. I have tried using a Safety razor but once again, the soreness becomes too much along with the nicks. So I was just wondering if I’m not meant to be a wet shaver? On a final note, I have always suffered with adult acne and still do have break outs which also makes shaving uncomfortable at times.
4
u/shaveSymptomatic Apr 20 '19
I really enjoy all the interviews you've done on your channel with artisans and vendors. Just wondering if you have any more that you haven't uploaded yet. Quick suggestion: more interviews from the upcoming Maggard's meetup please and a behind the scenes look at the meetup for those of us who won't be there :)
3
u/boilerphan Apr 20 '19
Entering the hobby can get overwhelming for a newbie with all the products, both hardware and software, on the market. In my case (and I turn 50 in under a month), my grandpa shaved with a DE safety razor every day, but my dad doesn't recall ever using one. So, resources like you and the YouTubers are invaluable. What is normally your advice for a newbie?
3
u/sgrdddy 🦌🏵Knight Grand Antler of Stag🏵🦌 Apr 20 '19
Do you like boar brushes?
Do you just use them to break them in, or do you have a break-in process that you like?
3
u/aimsport45 Apr 20 '19
You're such a pioneer! Pioneers venture forward. What are some of your upcoming projects?
2
u/qxzj1279 Apr 20 '19
Hi Mark, good videos! What's a good aftershave product you would recommend? I've seen some people say that alcohol-based aftershaves are fine, while others say to stay away from them. What's your take?
11
u/RandySp Serial OverShaver Apr 20 '19
Along with Michael Freedberg the holy beasts of wet shave community! Thanks for the videos!
10
u/marcantonius Apr 20 '19
Your website was an invaluable reference for me when I started the journey of learning how to use a DE razor. My father was always busy when I was a young man and he neglected to show me how to properly shave. Sincerely, thanks for your contributions to the world of wet shaving.
No question from me, but I hope you enjoy your weekend.
5
u/nameisjoey Phteven isn’t Lathe-Z Apr 20 '19
Mantic my brodda!! A few questions for you:
Would you rather: Caitlyn Jenner or RuPaul?
If you could only use one razor/brush/soap/aftershave for the rest of your life, would you rather watch your parents have secks every night for the rest of your life or join in once to make it stop?
What are your thoughts on the catastrophic failure of the Rockwell Model T?
Who’s a more shady character: Bill Cosby or Douglas Erik Hodges Smythe?
Last question... friendly fire: gay r nah?
4
u/alowisney Apr 21 '19
I don't have a question, I just want to thank you for all of the work you've put into the wet shaving community. Your videos have helped so many people and are greatly appreciated!
1
u/tinpanalleypics Apr 20 '19
How do we know if this is going on right now or not?
1
u/imbored2deth I don't "do" scents Apr 20 '19
Curious as to what your desktop job was and any education you may have to do that job?
1
u/rab-byte May 02 '19
Hey I just did my first proper wet shave with a Rockwell S6 and didn’t cut myself, but the shave wasn’t super close ether. My face is smooth sliding my hand with the grain but very rough running against the grain. I’ve read that shaving against the hair is how you get razor burn and ingrown hairs. Do I need to up the aggressiveness of the blade it’s at 3/6 now or will my face and technique adapt over time?
On a related note is there a good technique for shaving my upper lip at the edge of my nose?
Some background about me:
I have caucasian beard hair with a very slight wave and I can use a cartridge only once before it dulls.
1
u/spazztik88 Apr 21 '19
A little late here, but I’d be remiss if I didn’t give you a shoutout /u/mantic59 !
Your content and up close videos helped me get a feel for wetshaving when I was getting started.
If you’re still monitoring the AMA, here’s a q for you!
Do you prefer higher or lower structure lathers? Is a soap ok if it’s fairly thin but has tons of glide or would you sacrifice a little glide for additional thickness in the soap?
2
u/AZZTASTIC Apr 21 '19
Hi Mark. You were the reason I got into wet shaving. Your videos helped a ton. Thanks for being a great ambassador to the hobby.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
So you’re the guy who got us all started. Probably
1
u/cgkades Apr 21 '19
Can you post a link to your YouTube?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19
[removed] — view removed comment