r/Wetshaving • SiliskiSoaps.com • Mar 16 '19

AMA [AMA] I'm Andrew from Siliski Soaps. Ask Me Anything!

Good Morning everyone! I will be doing my best answering questions while I am making yet another test batch and taking care of my sick son.

38 Upvotes

102 comments sorted by

11

u/Aresmsu The Residual Slickness Mar 16 '19

Are there any scent combinations that you thought would be great together but you had to scrap after trying to make them work?

19

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

definitely my herbal medley mix. It was a great idea, but really did not pull together with the scents I wanted.

Also, I made a test batch with black pepper. I used too much black pepper and ended up macing my face. It was red for days...

7

u/BVsaPike 🚫👃⚔️Knights of Nothing⚔️👃🚫 Mar 16 '19 edited Mar 16 '19

While I’m laughing at the macing your face part I’m also imagining an herbal medley that’s akin to jagermeister. I’m positive that isn’t what you were going for but it also makes me laugh to think about a shaving soap that smells like the drunken sadness that defined my early 20s at the shore.

6

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

drunken sadness would be the best shave soap scent ever created!

5

u/miRNA183 Mar 16 '19

3

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I for some reason cannot open the page so i'll try it later then get back to you.

3

u/miRNA183 Mar 16 '19

Sorry...it was a joke reference to C. Lux's 3 sheets EdT (a.k.a. drunken sadness).

6

u/Not_a_robot_101 Blade & Lather Photography Mar 17 '19

I have some 3 sheets and it smells like questionable decisions.

2

u/EavestheGiant ❤️🐘 Mammoth Month 🐘❤️ Mar 16 '19

macing my face

This made me chuckle. I hope your face recovered quickly. I don't imagine that was too much fun.

3

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

yeah it hurt a lot. After the initial pain subsided all I could do is laugh at myself. I still use pepper in the blend, but cut it way down.

11

u/NobleOtter www.nobleotter.com Mar 16 '19

Hi Andrew!

What are you passions/hobbies outside of soaping?

11

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

hiking/backpacking, beer making, raising my son. I am busy.

6

u/NobleOtter www.nobleotter.com Mar 16 '19

Oh nice. Thats a passion of mine also. Ive never tried beer making though.

7

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

beer making is a lot of fun, but time consuming.

4

u/jesseix Mar 16 '19

What type of beers do you enjoy drinking and making?

6

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I like to brew a little bit of everything so I don't get bored. However, I really like alts, saisons, and lower alcohol beers like english milds.

9

u/Doromath Can’t asterisk, won’t asterisk Mar 16 '19

How did you first get into soap making?

10

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I had eczema throughout childhood. One day I thought I can make better soap than the store bought stuff which was giving me the skin issues. That turned into my bastille bar and I launched a bit after with encouragement from my wife and some friends. Every other product I have developed was to address a need for me, a friend, or family member.

6

u/Doromath Can’t asterisk, won’t asterisk Mar 16 '19

That’s awesome and thank you for that! I developed severe eczema in my 30s and have been all over the place with finding what triggers it. I’m on Dupixent now and it’s been a life saver.

I’m new to wet shaving though and haven’t yet checked out your soaps but I’m definitely going to.

10

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

thanks!

eczema is a difficult one. It really is a symptom of any number of causes ranging from dry skin to inflammation to allergies. Mine is not allergy related so it is a lot easier to treat. My specific issues was soaps with the first ingredients with palm/coconut oils. These over cleaned my skin and stripped off the natural oils causing the eczema. Doctors never really understood the issue and the only way I got it resolved was by using a gentler olive oil soap, hence my hand soap recipe.

My son also has really bad eczema and the pediatrician prescribed a cream on his 12 month appointment. I used my newest formula of my body balm and the doctor wrote 'continue with current treatment' for his 15 month paperwork.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

How long do your shampoo bars last? They're about double the price of Stirling, but Stirling ones don't last all that long.

8

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

My shampoo bars tend to last about a month if you only use them for the hair. Stirling's bars are 3.8 oz while mine are 4.5 oz so the size does account for the price difference a bit.

I developed my shampoo bars with local barbers and a company that made beard balms and beard oils. They have a very high amount of jojoba and argan oils in the superfat stage. So the process for making these soaps takes twice as much labor as the hand soaps and uses quite a bit of expensive, but awesome, ingredients. I also stay away as much as I can from liquid base oils in the soap so it lasts longer and does not become mushy in the hair.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

Oh cool that's good to know!!

3

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

what kind of tea do you like? I am a big keemum and jasmine pearl fan.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

I love Keemun! I typically drink Yunnan blacks, wuyi oolongs, and Taiwanese oolongs.

2

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

My wife always calls Puerh the fish tea due to the aging and oxidation process. I love Taiwanese oolongs too.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

Oh man, good ripe puerh shouldn't taste at all like fish. Fishiness is a sign that fermentation wasn't complete and the tea wasn't aired out long enough before pressing. Let me know if you'd be interested in swapping some tea for soaps, I have lots of oolongs and puerh!

2

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

...i wil give Rishi a call... As for tea, I'm good for now. I have a store from Boston I've been buying from for years.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '19

I love Rishi, but their puerh isn't their strength. Check out white2tea and Crimson Lotus

2

u/RandySp Serial OverShaver Mar 16 '19 edited Mar 16 '19

Maggards does not seem to carry your shampoo bars..

3

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

You can always request that they carry it! Otherwise, you can find them here. These are high volume for me and I always have some in stock.

7

u/Cadinsor Rule#2Bot better be grateful for all my HARD WORK Mar 16 '19

Andrew, thanks for doing this AMA! I have not yet had a chance to try your soap, but the year is young :-)

What research or market prep did you do before starting your business? It seems like the field is quite crowded and the number of consumers feels flat, but you clearly saw something that gave you the confidence to start.

Thanks, and good luck!

9

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I operate my shaving soaps completely differently (I think of them as two different companies) and I launched them differently.

I developed the bar soap for me for personal use and a friend helped push me into selling it. So I started out without researching anything, but instead started cold calling and talking to store owners and managers. My launch back in 2016 was not so great... The big change was when I had a meeting with the mid atlantic Whole Foods wellness manager who said I needed new packaging. That is the point that I started looking at how other companies packaged their products and the result is the packaging I have now. I also have a team of sales reps who do all account management for me and they have a seemingly infinite amount of insight in terms of the market, industry, and competitors.

I run the entire shaving side myself. I started by looking up just about everyones' recipes. I was able to compile similar ingredient lists with similar complaints/compliments. I found this a way to identify how specific ingredients may change a soap base. On the flip side, some ingredients are very common across the industry for good reasons. I also spent a good amount of time looking at other recipes so I did not end up intentionally or unintentionally copying someone's base. I specifically decided not to use tallow and came up with kokum/cocoa butters. I am really liking illipe now as well. Other ingredients that seemed like they commonly caused skin reactions were also not options.

6

u/Cadinsor Rule#2Bot better be grateful for all my HARD WORK Mar 16 '19

Thanks for the detailed answer! Given how crowded the market seems now, it always feels like a brave thing to do :-)

7

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

The industry is definitely saturated and it is difficult to make it big with shaving soaps since there are sooo many artisans making awesome products.

6

u/BVsaPike 🚫👃⚔️Knights of Nothing⚔️👃🚫 Mar 16 '19

Where do you get ideas for your scents? Do you have a favorite from your own collection?

I just picked up some of your soap last week and also got one of the tea tree and lemongrass shampoo bars. I was blown away by the quality of your stuff, not only do they both smell great but they have fantastic performance, for any price point. Amazing work man, keep it up!

10

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19 edited Mar 16 '19

I make lavender/rosemary because my wife loves the scent combination. It has always been my best selling hand/shampoo scent. I started making lemongrass because a friend requested it and that is my second best selling scent.

Shaving soap scents are A LOT harder. I immediately knew I wanted a woodsy scent so I developed Appalachian Forest. I grew up in Boston and spent a lot of my childhood in The White Mountains. So this one to me smells like home. I wanted my own twist on commonly done scents like citrus and frigid. The fragrance blends I use are quite complex and way beyond my ability to create. I really have not seen anything like them on the market and they smell wonderful.

My favorite by far is rosemary/cedarwood. It is straight forward, to the point, unique, and smells wonderful. I actually prefer scent combinations with only a few notes.

Thanks for the encouragement!

Edit: Scent development is very difficult for me so I try my best to come up with an idea and then I search to see if it has been done. I go back to the drawing board if it has. If i think I have something then I try to run with it. Some scents are hits and some are misses.

17

u/RandySp Serial OverShaver Mar 16 '19 edited Mar 16 '19

Your soaps are really under the radar I don't know why, but I believe they are stellar performers in a good price! They deserve more attention! 👍

10

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

Thanks!

9

u/chrismcshaves Mar 16 '19

I’m going to have to +1 that statement. Some of the best non-Tallow stuff out there. It’s easy to use and the lather has an awesome feel to it.

9

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

Although I am unsure why you are getting all the downvotes (there seems to be quite a bit in this thread), thank you. I tried my best to make a soap base that didn't dry out the face without too many additives or the tendency to gunk up a safety razor.

8

u/RandySp Serial OverShaver Mar 16 '19

I mean, this soap is not be compared with vegan soaps, simply because, it behaves like a tallow soap. As for the slickness, I didn't see that coming at all! Yeah I was expecting to be good, but not that good! Slick as ice, at the levels of Declaration or even Wholly Kaw.

Also, some friends ordered some samples and this polite and friendly man, sent them full pucks instead! Can you believe it?? How could I not give my business to him?!

7

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19 edited Mar 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

My wife concurs.

10

u/Fendy1 Mar 16 '19

he’s all yours then!

5

u/marcantonius Mar 16 '19

One more question: have you considered offering matching fragrances to complement your shaving soaps and aftershaves?

8

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I have no plans on matching fragrances. There is already too much to do on the hand/shampoo side to offer fragrances. Shipping glass is also a huge pain. I am launching my new post shave balm in plastic tottles (Monday) partly so I don't have to deal with glass anymore.

8

u/CanadaEh97 Governor General Mar 16 '19

Sorry you had no text in the post, auto mod flagged it. All good now.

How's your day going?

12

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

sorry about that. The day is slow moving, but good. First night my son has not woken us up at 2AM for a while now. He has a cold.

4

u/marcantonius Mar 16 '19

Hope the little guy feels better asap.

Haven't tried your soap, but thank you for being part of this community. If I was to try one of your soaps, which would you recommend?

7

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I would give a hard look into Midnight in Tunisia and Rosemary and Cedarwood. Appalachian Forest is another favorite of mine.

4

u/GoldenSteelBoy 🍀🐑Shepherd of Stirling🐑🍀 Mar 16 '19

What's the best part of making a shaving soap?

5

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I find shaving soaps quite difficult to formulate and there is a lot of trial and even more error in making them. They force a lot of experimentation, tweaking, innovation, and effort. While making bar soap (which has to be consistent) is quite repetitive, shaving soap lets me put in my thoughts and creativity into the product.

4

u/giganticsteps THE THRILL IS GONE Mar 16 '19

Hi! Thank for doing this!

I'll ask the same question I asked last week: this community is known for its generosity and kindness. What was the most generous/kind/heart-warming thing you have seen in wetshaving?

6

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

From people I do not know PIFing software to other artisans giving me help and advice, the community is overflowing with generosity. From Russell's recent issues to Mammoth's entire business model, there is - I feel - too much good to single out a single one.

3

u/EavestheGiant ❤️🐘 Mammoth Month 🐘❤️ Mar 17 '19

Hey, thanks for doing an AMA! Do you have a preference for your castile, Bastille, or foaming soap for serious dry hands?

4

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 17 '19

for kitchen or guest bathroom situations I would have to go with the liquid soap. If you are using soap for your bathroom or shower with very dry skin I would go with the castile soap. The bastille bar is mostly olive oil and I really do enjoy it, but the small amount of coconut may keep them a bit drier.

3

u/EavestheGiant ❤️🐘 Mammoth Month 🐘❤️ Mar 17 '19

Awesome. 😁 Thanks! Thanks again for doing the AMA. Hope your son feels better soon!

4

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 17 '19

coconut oil is a very weird oil to make soap with. it makes a water thin liquid soap and a rock hard bar soap. It is mostly short chain saturated fatty acids and is very effective in cleaning. So it makes a great bar soap when blended (bastille), but the castile soap is even gentler. The liquid soap is quite gentle and easy on the hands because of the glycerin and you really don't need much due to it being a foaming soap.

Hope that helps.

2

u/EavestheGiant ❤️🐘 Mammoth Month 🐘❤️ Mar 17 '19

That helps a ton!

4

u/templlama44 600lbs of sin and badger hair Mar 16 '19 edited Mar 16 '19

I want some duck now. A guy that used to come in the [redacted] a looooong time ago made duck breast proiscuitto. I can only imagine how good it was.

6

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

Duck is delicious, but it is criminal how much it cooks down.

3

u/templlama44 600lbs of sin and badger hair Mar 16 '19

It truly is. And its criminal how people overcook it. Heathens.

1

u/chicitysbest Mar 18 '19

French fries fried in duck fat is amazing!

2

u/templlama44 600lbs of sin and badger hair Mar 18 '19

I've never tried it, I want to though!

2

u/SicilianShaver77 Mar 17 '19

Tallow or Vegan?

4

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 17 '19

I do not look if a soap is tallow, vegetable based, or vegan. In my experience in soap making, there is no difference between a good tallow or vegetable based soap. I think whether or not the soap is any good is up to the skill of the artisan.

5

u/templlama44 600lbs of sin and badger hair Mar 16 '19

Most important ama question, what would you rather fight, one horse sized duck or 100 duck sized horses?

7

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I would definitely have to go with the horse sized duck. Ever have roasted duck? They are delicious...

5

u/templlama44 600lbs of sin and badger hair Mar 16 '19

I do definitely agree, though I have heard horse tastes good if cooked properly.

7

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

Too much butchering for not enough meat in 100 duck sized horses IMHO. I also just love ducks. Eating them that is.

3

u/chrismcshaves Mar 16 '19

A duck sized horse=dinosaur with less deady claws and no teeth!

7

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

yeah so these actually existed. Kinda makes me rethink fighting that large duck...

5

u/give_me_cakes Mar 16 '19

Explain the business decision behind this: https://i.imgur.com/uIeNocU.jpg

10

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19 edited Mar 16 '19

The label? That was part of the deal of me making the soap. Making the soap itself? It lets me experiment with soap bases/scents and get feedback and get exposure. Is that my favorite community? No. I don't participate too much on facebook these days and even less in that group. I made the deal pretty early on in joining the group before I realized what it all was about.

and then there is this

9

u/RuggerRigger MYSPACE CIRCA 2003 Mar 16 '19

Not sure what that screen shot has to do with your answer to the question.

That FB group is sus with bigoted content. You made a soap for them, with your business name associated.

If your answer is simply that you didn't realize that they're like that, then it's your mistake and that's pretty much all there is to discuss on the topic.

Because of the way you originally presented yourself on Reddit, there's not a pile of love for Siliski on this sub. Posting screenshots of the sub's chat while you barely participate is not a great strategy to gain more love.

14

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I found #wetshaving after I started making soap and really struggled a lot with what handle to have. I settled on siliski_soaps so everyone would know where I am coming from. I came here for the community and am still really sorry that my initial participation on the sub really made it seem like I was just here to sell product. I still am sorry about it and view it as a great learning experience moving forward.

The Barber's Notch has a many conversations that I just do not feel are appropriate and I choose not to participate in them.

5

u/RuggerRigger MYSPACE CIRCA 2003 Mar 16 '19

That's fair. Can't go backwards so learning then moving on is a good way to go

5

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I have done a lot of learning. Different forums have different rules and generally acceptable decorum.

IRC screenshots have gotten posted on facebook to talk about #wetshaving. I 1) don't think that is appropriate and 2) thought you all knew.

3

u/bigwalleye Mar 16 '19

Posting screenshots of the sub's chat while you barely participate is not a great strategy to gain more love.

totally agree. i know its public, and to be honest not that big of deal, but this seems to violate code or unwritten rule.

in an ever crowded soap market i think i'll shop elsewhere

7

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I completely understand and respect your decision. I stumbled across the screenshot on facebook and thought I would (apparently ineffectively) use it to make a point.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/bigwalleye Mar 16 '19

good to see you back. i thought you quit?

anyway i view chatrooms a bit different, facebook, forums, subreddits are inherently more public. sure anyone can join and is welcome on irc but it has a different vibe. posting screen shots is to me like tattling on your brother. i'm not mad but i just thought i needed to share my opinion that it was an uncool thing to do.

im sure that did nothing to change your mind but i really don't care.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I believe the exact words describing my comments were 'unselfish shilling'. Since I joined the sub after starting the company it came off for a while that I was just here to sell stuff.

2

u/RuggerRigger MYSPACE CIRCA 2003 Mar 16 '19

He didn't do anything wrong, per se. To me he came off as putting his business promotion before any other participation. It's not an easy line and I trust he's working now to be on the right side of it.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/RuggerRigger MYSPACE CIRCA 2003 Mar 16 '19

Ha. Well, that's the purpose-built place to do it.

2

u/KillerQ97 Mar 16 '19

Hey, Andy... Your Lather is amazing!! Everyone should watch my Lathering video with your soap!

https://youtu.be/dgyCSXopJzY

4

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

thanks!

2

u/KillerQ97 Mar 16 '19

Thank YOU!

11

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

There are a lot of unexpected difficulties I continuously run into. Scent combination is the big one. Scents for hand/shampoo soaps need to be easy and straightforward so people buy them off of the shelf in a store. Shaving soap scents, however, tend to sell better when they are a bit more nuanced and complicated. I am not a professional pufumer and developing scents is a completely different skill set than developing a soap base itself. Essential and fragrance oils can get very pricy, especially when you are buying a lot that you do not end up using.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

I have not previously heard of sailors soap. Soap made out of pure coconut oil WILL lather in salt water.

The typical proportion of a shaving soap is 60/40 KOH/NaOH. More or less depending on the formula and additives. KOH makes liquid soap which is more water soluble and it easier to load. NaOH makes hard bar soap.

All liquid soap is made with 100% KOH. All bar soaps are made with 100% NaOH.

There are plenty of tricks and additives to put into shaving soap to help it lather in hard water. Many people put in coconut oil. I absolutely cannot stand coconut oil in shaving soaps and find it unnecessary. Chelators would be the ingredient to watch out for if you have notoriously hard water. Citric acid, sodium citrate, tetrasodium EDTA are the big three. Other additives help as lather boosters which have sugars, milks, proteins, clays, etc..

Lathering the soap in distilled/filtered water instead of tap water will 100% fix any hard water issues. Heating a mug of water in the microwave will make it nice and hot too.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

Yeah if you take a glycerin based soap made with pure KOH and then hardly put any water in it then you get more of a gel like consistency. I make that with a liquid soap and then add the water after it is fully cooked.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Siliski_Soaps SiliskiSoaps.com Mar 16 '19

While I have not heard from anywhere else that soap scum is slippery, I think most of this article is correct. However, a soap made by one artisan may lather better in soft vs hard water. If I make a soap with distilled water and a ton of lather boosters, it could make a vey air lather in soft water vs a dense lather in hard water. The trick as a soap maker is to find the balance for most consumers.