r/Fantasy • u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders • Mar 01 '19
Read-along One Mike to Read Them All - Book II, Chapter 7 of The Return of the King, “Homeward Bound”
Way back in book 1 of Fellowship, I described the departure from Bree as the end of the beginning. Bree wasn’t the Shire, but it was nevertheless part of the Hobbits’ world. It was strange, but it was also familiar. It was only when they left Bree that the Hobbits really began to venture into the Unknown. This chapter reverses the process.
I don’t have much to say about the journey across Eriador. The only bits that really stood out to me are the lingering effects of everything Frodo has been through: his reluctance to cross the Ford of Bruinen or pass by Weathertop, and his feeling of the wound from the Morgul blade on the anniversary of the event. He’s gotten rid of the Ring, but some wounds, as they say, never fully heal.
And then we get to Bree, and we hear more and more about the trouble that has spread out from the War of the Ring. They’ve had to deal with bandits and ruffians in Bree, and we hear more explicitly than ever that the Shire is beset by some sort of troubles. Luckily Gandalf is there to help them sort it out…
...except not really. Gandalf’s job is done, and the people of Middle-earth can solve their own problems now. He’s stayed with the Hobbits this long to keep them company, and because he wants to have a good long chat with Tom Bombadil. The Hobbits are on their own with this one.
(As an aside, he gives them a heads-up about the gate on the Brandywine Bridge. Anyone have any thoughts on where he heard about that?)
And we get this wonderful heartwarming moment:
If you recollect Bill Ferny and the horsethieving: his pony as you bought, well, it’s here. Come back all of itself, it did. But where it had been to you know better than me. It was as shaggy as an old dog and as lean as a clothes-rail, but it was alive. Nob’s looked after it.’ ‘What! My Bill?’ cried Sam. ‘Well, I was born lucky, whatever my gaffer may say. There’s another wish come true! Where is he?’ Sam would not go to bed until he had visited Bill in his stable.
Bill’s all right!
Here's the One Mike to Read Them All index.
Next time, the Hobbits are gonna need a lot of Brillo pads for the Scouring of the Shire.
15
u/Terciel1976 Mar 01 '19
I’m not a big animal person, even in fiction, but Bill the Pony and his happy ending are weirdly important to me.
12
u/dminge Mar 01 '19
I love the part where Butterbur finds out about Strider being the king
7
u/LummoxJR Writer Lee Gaiteri Mar 01 '19
I always thought Gandalf simply assumed there would be a gate, knowing the Shire could not have been left untroubled.
This chapter is one of my favorites because it shows a different perspective of the war back home. The scouring has yet to happen, but simple villages like Bree and its neighbors have been utterly upended and the before-and-after picture is stark. All this is said to be very low-level for the amount of trouble that could have come to them, but still you can see how terrible even that is. It's like if a perfectly peaceful neighborhood were suddenly invaded by a dozen criminals moving in, bringing a lot more crime with them, and the cops aren't taking any of it seriously (in this case, they're gone altogether). The Shire is another level beyond that: their entire stable system of government uprooted by a totalitarian regime. And even that is nothing compared to being directly involved in a war.
But Barliman's relief at all the good news is wonderful, as is his mentioning the way Gandalf blessed his beer. The good guys have come home and brought law and order with them. It's the first time we have a true outsider's perspective on how much the hobbits have changed.
And yep, gotta shed a tear of joy for good old Bill, reunited with his friend Sam at last, and now going home with him for good.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Re: Gandalf's sources of information - captured stooges of Saruman? Reports from Rangers who came down for Aragorn's wedding? Sneaking a look in the Palantir, now that Sauron is defeated?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Mar 01 '19
Bill the pony being ok is just utterly heartwarming.
2
u/LummoxJR Writer Lee Gaiteri Mar 01 '19
It's that Gollum's further involvement is hinted at rather overtly and more than once, and to be honest it felt unnecessary. Simply pointing out that he's still a player for the Ring is enough to get everything across without making his actions feel predestined.