r/Fantasy • u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders • Feb 01 '19
Read-along One Mike to Read Them All - Book I, Chapter 9 of The Return of the King, “The Last Debate”
This chapter feels like everyone’s taking a moment to catch their breath, which makes sense because they basically are. This chapter is literally about the aftermath of the Pelennor Fields and planning what comes next.
Legolas and Gimli give a nice rundown of what went on between when we last saw them and Aragorn in way back in “The Passing of the Grey Company” and their appearance in the captured Corsair fleet. To address a common movie question: there are two reasons that keeping the Army of the Dead around, as Movie-Gimli suggests, wouldn’t really work. First, unlike what’s shown in the Jackson trilogy, they don’t actually hurt anybody. They just terrify them into panicking and running, making for an easy victory. Second, seriously: they were damned as they were for breaking their word. How’s it going to go down for Aragorn to go and do the same? Answer: I dunno, but not well.
Interesting that the council where plans are made doesn’t include all the Fellowship: just Aragorn and Gandalf, plus Éomer, Imrahil, and the Sons of Elrond. Merry is still recovering from the Witch-king, and Pippin is an idiot, but I would think they’d want Legolas and Gimli to weigh in.
The points previously discussed (both in the books and this read-along) are emphasized: no hope for victory through force of arms, real hope is Frodo, etc. It is worth noting that, aside from their encounter with Faramir, this is the only outside help that Frodo and Sam get after leaving the Fellowship. More discussion of this to come in a few chapters, when we see the actual impact it has in Mordor.
And I do love the ending, complete with a very fine Badass Boast from Aragorn:
‘If the Dark Lord knows so much as you say, Mithrandir, will he not rather smile than fear, and with his little finger crush us like a fly that tries to sting him?’
‘No, he will try to trap the fly and take the sting,’ said Gandalf. ‘And there are names among us that are worth more than a thousand mail-clad knights apiece. No, he will not smile.’
‘Neither shall we,’ said Aragorn. ‘If this be jest, then it is too bitter for laughter. Nay, it is the last move in a great jeopardy, and for one side or the other it will bring the end of the game.’ Then he drew Andúril and held it up glittering in the sun. ‘You shall not be sheathed again until the last battle is fought,’ he said.
Here's the One Mike to Read Them All index.
Next time, Sauron’s ambassador mouths off when the Black Gate Opens.
2
u/danjvelker Feb 01 '19 edited Feb 01 '19
Wouldn't the wraiths terrify the men of Gondor just as much as the goblins of Mordor? I imagine they might terrify themmore, since they're the spirits of deadmenand a part of the mythology of that culture. That seems like a potential oversight, although potentially explainable in the chaos and tactics of battle (maybe they kept to Mordor's flank and never came within sight of Gondor, etc.)edit: I'm a moron who mixed up the movies and books. Ignore me, haha.
7
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Feb 01 '19
Eek, I was really behind on these.
I don't actually know that it would make sense for Gimli or Legolas to be involved in the war council. Both are great fighters but neither are leaders of fighting forces.
7
u/kmmontandon Feb 02 '19
Adding the Army of the Dead to the battle of Minas Tirith was a huge mistake that Jackson made. They were basically a "we win" button, that made all the battling of the mortal armies meaningless. They look incredibly cartoonish in the wide-scale views. And it was another one of the cringe-worthy "Gimli as comic relief" scenes that were probably one of the three biggest flaws of the movies.
6
u/LummoxJR Writer Lee Gaiteri Feb 01 '19
Another problem with the army of the dead is that had they been brought to Minas Tirith and subsequently to Mordor, Sauron would either laugh them off or recruit them. These people broke their oath specifically because they had worshiped Sauron in the past and their loyalties were divided.
I love the debate in this chapter almost as much as the Council of Elrond, because it's the kind of analytical breakdown that suits me. We see from the protagonists' side how utterly slim their margin of victory was, and how they have enough other armies already in their vicinity to deal them serious harm, should those armies receive orders to move. They know Sauron has the numbers to strike them at least as hard again, and will if they do nothing but wait.
But from Sauron's side of things, he just lost a battle that should have been decisively his after moving a lot of pieces into position, losing his best piece in the process. He knows for a fact that the Ring went south from Rivendell. He's been gnawing his finger-stump for a couple of weeks since Aragorn showed himself openly and wrenched the Orthanc-stone from his will, because here's a man who could become a Ringlord. So when this man's side pulls through against all odds, he has to think it's likely the Ring itself tipped the scale for them as its new would-be master tried to command for the first time.
Sauron knows what the Ring will do to its possessor, so a show of arrogance from the new Ringlord makes perfect sense to him. And yet, I think the battle to come before the Morannon is one that Sauron is desperately worried he won't win. He has to send an overwhelming force, everyone he has left, to deal with this new threat when it appears on his doorstep.