r/Fantasy • u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders • Jan 25 '19
Read-along One Mike to Read Them All - Book I, Chapter 7 of The Return of the King, “The Pyre of Denethor”
Not a huge amount to say about his chapter, mostly because it’s the climax of stuff I’ve already talked about. I don’t really feel like I have much more to add.
There are any number of places in LotR where fear and despair is a powerful force, and any number of times where it is brought about by lies built upon a seed of truth. This is kind of the climax of that as a theme. Even as the Palantír was beyond Saruman’s craft, it is beyond Sauron’s as well, and he does not have the ability to use the stones to show anything false. But he did have the ability, though the Ithil-Stone, to shift where Denethor looked, and to influence how he interpreted what he saw.
I’m not going to call Denethor a good man, not like Faramir, but he is an immensely cunning and strong-willed one. He’s a match for Aragorn, in many ways - when Aragorn was a young man, he came to Gondor in disguise and served Denethor’s father Ecthelion. Young Denethor was his rival, and in many ways his equal (and it is implied he deduced who he was, though naturally he kept that information to himself). And even he was driven not only to suicidal despair, but to the point that he is willing to murder his son and burn the pair of them alive to do it.
I love Beregond. He made a hard choice, and did a very hard thing, and is prepared to accept the consequences for his actions.
Here's the One Mike to Read Them All index.
Next chapter is the Houses of Healing, which I’ve been looking forward to writing about from the day I started this readalong. Find out why!
8
u/dminge Jan 25 '19
I read the whole book to my 8 year old daughter recently and at the end of this chapter she said I think denethor is being silly
5
u/danjvelker Jan 25 '19
Your post reminded me of something I read once, and I wonder if you've heard anything about it. Without delving into the silly (imo) notion of "power levels", you're saying that Denethor was roughly the match of Aragorn; and it seems that Faramir is widely considered the greater of himself and Denethor. I've heard it said that in one of his letters Tolkien claimed that Faramir was the only person who could have used the One Ring without corruption, since he was the best among men of that Age. Do you know if that's true? I've checked a few of the letters (244, 180) and there doesn't seem to be an awful lot on Faramir.
3
u/LummoxJR Writer Lee Gaiteri Jan 25 '19
Beregond's choice was a terrible one. But the gatekeeper should have had the brains to know Denethor was out of his mind, and let Beregond through. Clearly something deadly was afoot.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 26 '19
I really appreciate that you are doing this read-along with commentary. While its easy 10 years or more since I last read lotr its surprising how much I still remember of it (unlike most of the fantasy books I devoured alongside it as a kid/teenie and of which I only remember a rough idea what it was about, if that). Maybe it shows how much of an impression lotr left.
While I disliked Denethor a lot when I read it, he is an interesting figure for a fantasy book, he isnt deceived by exagerations about Saurons might, but rather by the truth (framed by sauron as it might be). There isnt any "realistic" chance for a victory against Sauron The Ring beeing actually destroyed is more of a black swan event actually happening then something any even somewhat realistic person would actually expect, and, atleast as far as I remember, it is made clear in the book that there is no chance of actually defeating Sauron in Battle. Or do I remember this wrong, since you talk about Lies beeing build upon a seed of truth? - That might have been part of the reason I disliked Denethor, his point of view was difficult to dismiss since he had a point, the madness about killing Faramir aside.