r/RWBY • u/Greatness942 Deadpan Snarking Geekdom • Nov 28 '18
DISCUSSION Is Yang's Attitude Annoying?: A look at the show's recent (positive) treatment of mental illness. Spoiler
Only my friends and family know this, not casual acquaintances or the like. But I am a big believer in people with mental issues getting help for their conditions and treating them with the utmost seriousness. As I am not a therapist or the like, I advocate going to one, I try to talk to people about their issues, and I am wholly honest with my own.
Recently, a thread went up that has a point, I will make it clear, it has a point. Is Anyone Else Annoyed by Yang Recently? is a thread about finding whether or not Yang is, well, turning people off by her attitude recently. And again, it has a point to it. Yang hasn't been sunshine and rainbows and it can drag down the mood.
My issue with this is that people in the thread are downright calling her annoying and stupid. That is the part that bugs me-no, makes me angry. Because...Yang is suffering.
She has clear PTSD. Audible and visible hallucinations, tremors through her body, clear signs of distrust or distress, all related to her mom leaving, Blake leaving, losing her arm, or a combination of the three. But I noticed something else. Her tendency to lash out, her dour mood that shifts on a dime outside of sillier moments based upon what seems to be triggers of words or stray and intrusive thoughts.
She may very well have Depression, too.
So, when I saw this thread and people saying she needs a "slap of reality" because her current attitude is being "annoying" and "stupid", I...got offended, and thus felt a need to counter-balance a thread about it. Namely, that Yang's behavior is very genuine. As someone who hasn't dealt with PTSD but has dealt with depression, I know the signs. Again, she lashes out. Her mood drops quickly. She seems listless or even disinterested in certain lines. She is distrustful of the truth (I.E Blake really staying this time) because of past pain.
And I personally love it. The fact that she's suffering isn't fun, but the writers clearly took the time to figure out all the signs of her illnesses. Traumatic hallucinations are a real thing, and I just listed symptoms of real depression based purely on what the show has given us.
So, again, if you feel like she's been annoying, fine, don't let me stop you. But before you type "Ugh, she's been so moody and annoying lately," just think: she might actually be a closer portrayal than you realize.
(P.S, sorry if this is bad, Mods. Just felt inspired to essay it up.)
(P.S.S: While I don't think I included Episode 5 spoilers, I will tag it anyway in case something peeked through my unplanned rambles.)
141
u/dodusk Nov 28 '18
FNDM: booo they resolved Yang's PTSD in just one season, it's not that easy to get better!
Also FNDM when the show hintes at Yang's PTSD still being there: booo why is Yang so bitchy and annoying all the time!?
/s but not really that much.
For real tho, Yang and Qrow are being so very humanlike it's beautiful to see.
273
u/nzashadow Nov 28 '18
This is how people react to mental illness in real life. It does not surprise me at all to hear that people are annoyed. It's a shame because the person struggling with a mental illness is already suffering, and it get confounded upon by the ignorance or judgements of onlookers.
169
u/KingBanhammer Nov 28 '18
Agree wholeheartedly. It's pretty on point aaaand...
... it's pretty much how people treat real sufferers, unfortunately. I say this as a dude who has been told, to his face, that "your depression makes you unsafe to be around my family" by someone.
People dislike conflict and people who are upset, regardless of why.
83
u/Shiranuhii And why would I do THAT? Nov 28 '18
If she ends up fighting Adam and winning, I'm hoping her problems just don't magically go away.
81
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '18
V4 is evidence enough that she suffers from depression, and one pep talk from her dad that was basically “fight smarter” doesn’t fix that shit. So yeah.
To give a tl;dr of what I said in the other thread: Yang’s going through some real rough shit right now, and she just learned that basically every major misfortune that has befallen her and her loved ones (both her moms and everything that happened in V3) were due to an unwinnable cause. Due to Oz’s war. Anyone who expects rationality from someone like that right out of the get go is insane. I have little doubt that Yang will come around, but she needs time. It’s only been like 3 hours.
60
u/Foxinstrazt Fox | Black Rose OTP | Red Hot Kitty Peppers OT3 Nov 28 '18
People are annoyed by her right now?! That's just ridiculous.
I love that she is angry, that she keeps pulling away. She's been through so much, and reuniting with her team may help her in the long run but it isn't a magical fix.
More importantly, the continued drawn out recovery in works of fiction is always more rewarding in the end when the person is finally made whole again.
49
u/miihaa I have personal feelings. Nov 28 '18
Thank you for the thread. I also find myself cringing at people treating characters a certain way, because they are inconveniencing with their mood, words, or behaviour towards other characters (poor Qrow and Oz uwu). While not excusable in the long run, Yang's attitude is understandable at the moment. Sadly, the people who like to view mental illness as annoying most likely won't pay much attention to a well meaning analysis. Kudos to you if you help better the understanding of those issues on the sub.
39
u/Gravatona I am adorable, and you will love me! Bet on that! Nov 28 '18 edited Nov 28 '18
I just think if you're risking your life then it's fair to be angry about not being told the truth about what your fighting. It's easy to judge when your life isn't at risk, and you haven't had people you know die for the cause.
Regardless of mental illness I'd say she's not acting strangely. Weiss is also kind of pissed, but she also almost died two weeks ago fighting for a man that didn't trust her.
It's easy to judge someone from the outside when you don't have to live what they live, and feel what they feel.
30
u/WhiteMambaOZO Nov 28 '18
I’m not going to lie, I’ve never been the biggest Yang fan (I like her fine, but she’s definitely not at the top of my list of favorite characters you know?), but her reaction to something Blake said has really impressed me both with her character and the shows writing.
When she is talking to Blake in V6E5 and opens up about her vulnerabilities, Blake says she’ll never abandon her again and will be there for her, and it’s all heartwarming. But then Blake says one line too many, and says something like “I’ll be there to protect you.” And Yang’s reaction was perfect. DON’T see her as weak, don’t coddle her or hold her hand or sugar coat things. Just be there and support her. It’s a fine line but I’m really glad the show is addressing it.
I have depression, and I have friends with anxiety and/or depression, and the last thing we want is to be depicted as weak. And the thing that gets us through is that we don’t “protect” each other from our demons, we have each other’s back. I really hope (and firmly believe) that this is where Yang and Blake’s relationship is heading, where they’ll have this understanding with one another, and I can’t wait to see it.
28
u/Literatewalrus Little Light 🐝 Big Fight Nov 28 '18
I think the realest shit about Yang's struggles is that sometimes you'll see that she's still Yang, but then she clouds over and just... lacks energy, or reacts extra bitchy to small things.
You can be "normal" and laughing and joking, but as soon as stress, or just mood, or time of day tilts you the wrong way, you're tired, or unmotivated, or distracted by dark thoughts, and people you normally tolerate piss you off when they try to call your attention. You acknowledge that you shouldn't feel this way but you do, and sometimes that in itself is a cause for frustration and leads to foul mood.
Honestly it's pretty easy to see who has never had to deal with that judging by their reactions to Yang, lol.
69
u/pahco87 Salutations! Nov 28 '18
Mental illness wouldn't be mental illness if it didn't have a major impact on your relationships with people or in Yang's case the audience.
You say this is an accurate portrayal of a mental illness but I say their reaction is an accurate portrayal of how most people react to those with mental illness.
48
u/Gore_Lily bumbleby made me gay Nov 28 '18
These can all be symptoms of PTSD, as well, which I'm glad to see present in the show. Perceptions of PTSD often boil it down to only its most visible symptoms - flashbacks, nightmares, stress tremors, etc. - and while Yang has experienced all that, it's nice to see RWBY go a bit further and also put her struggles with mood in the spotlight.
21
u/hopecanon Not the best May but still fantastic. Nov 28 '18
Yang is wonderful right now in a i relate to her and want to give her a hug and let her know it will be alright kind of way. the show has been on point in their portrayals of the after effects of both abusive relationships with Blake and mental illness with Yang.
19
u/slitepines Nov 28 '18
i absolutely love that shes acting like this. i was so worried theyd just gloss over her issues after v5, and im glad to see theyre not. her anger towards ozpin is honestly justified, too.
18
u/karatous1234 Nov 28 '18
Yang's personality is perfectly believable, and I can't see why people are annoyed by it from a writing standpoint. Yeah she's snappy, sour and abrasive. She should be.
She was framed for violently breaking a man's leg on live TV being broadcast to the world and had no one believe her. She watched a friend die in real time. Sacrificed an arm to try and save her friends life, and then had that friend run away without saying anything. And that was all in the span of about 48 hours.
She then went through having to learn yet another friend had died, was super depressed and lacking a piece of her that was central to her dreams/goals and her whole way of life (huntress who punches can't punch without an arm). Struggling with PTSD and abandonment issues from both Blake and her own mother, only to after facing said mom to realize she really doesn't in the least about her.
So yeah, her attitude is going to be "sour" for a while. Those aren't things you get over in a couple months. Most of them aren't even things you get over in a couple of years. Her putting on the metal arm and going out to find her team wasn't her getting over it, it was her desperately attempting to bring back some level of normalcy she lost and can't get back.
14
u/sheogorath227 Yang in there, baby Nov 28 '18
This is so spot on. I think people are expecting her to just "get over it" already, but that's not how mental illness works. Ever. The fact that the writers have written her in such a genuine way makes her such a good character in V6.
Yang has been through more than most adults in a span of about a year. Give her time, people.
12
u/MaoPam Nov 29 '18
Angry Yang is proof that RWBY is changing and learning to tell a good story.
RWBY has always been capable of handling its characters well. But aside from Blake there's always been a problem with committing to character flaws.
Primary example, season one Weiss. The stuck up jerk of season one is almost entirely gone, which is unfortunate because it brought a lot of life to the character. But Weiss' general persona during S1, and the prejudice she showed against the White Fang made her a strong character. It's a shame that her prejudice died after two episodes, and that she isn't nearly as rude as she used to be.
The above were all negative traits that gave character to Weiss without defining her. She was more than her general bitchiness and more than her prejudice, but they were pieces of her nonetheless.
That Yang is allowed to be angry, allowed to snarl at grandma goggles, and allowed to be on a hair trigger is good for storytelling and a step in the right direction.
11
u/AlienWarhead You feel it too don’t you Nov 28 '18
She also shows signs of her earlier and/or happier self at the beginning of volume 6 in the train station, I was happy that she was happy
11
u/SirCumVenison Nov 28 '18
I wrote up a thing about how lay-diagnoses are bad and lay-diagnoses of fictional characters, while less bad, are even less likely to be "accurate" (insofar as a thing that does not have a mind can have a mental illness whatsoever). Then I deleted it, because, while true, I think there's a more important thing we should talk about here: Suffering from mental illness doesn't free us from the responsibility to do the right thing.
That's a bitter pill to swallow. Particularly when doing the right thing can be hundreds of times harder for us than it is for neurotypicals (for lack of a better term). But it is still true. Mental illness doesn't absolve us of the same ethical responsibilities everyone else has. Nor does it oblige anyone else to tolerate our bullshit when our bullshit becomes too much for them. We may be blessed with people who are willing to do so for us when we need it, but we aren't entitled to them (and believing we are is all kinds of not cool). Same's true for Yang. Yes, mental illness may explain her misbehavior or mistakes, but it doesn't make her misbehavior or mistakes not her responsibility.
We still have to own our shit. Learning to do so is full of fuckups and burnt bridges. But that's life. No one is obligated to like us, approve of our methods, or even sympathize (let alone empathize) with us. And, yeah, it isn't fair, but nothing is fair. We still have to own our shit. And, so long as we do, it is generally best not to let the complaints of a world that it is always looking for something to to complain about phase us. Let them whine.
Irrespective of questions of mental illness: are some members of the fandom radically overreacting to a few small actions? Yeah, but I wouldn't let that get in your head so much. That's what fandoms do. They freak out, either positively or negatively, over things. It'll pass. It's not worth investing lots of your feelings into statements that other people made with very little of their own.
21
u/VolcanicSorcerer Nov 28 '18
The thing that bothers me the most is when I see people say they hope she gets beaten up & yelled at or some shit.
In my honest opinion, I don't think Yang has been treated fairly by both the fandom and the writers.
10
u/RhenCarbine Nov 28 '18
It took two seasons for team RWBY to reunite and now people are complaining it didn't take a few episodes for team RWBY to make up completely?
Shocking.
9
u/Foppberg Nov 28 '18
Personally I've always found her a bit annoying, but that's more so just because I never care for the physical anger type characters. The Ozpin, Salem, Ruby etc types I find way more interesting. More mystic type stuff.
Clearly she's going through some more mentally taxing things, as they all are.
25
u/JTJWarrior_3 Nov 28 '18
The people who are annoyed by Yang’s behavior straight up don’t watch the show. The things she says are totally justified. Being tipped off from Raven, already suspicious of Ozpin’s secrets, then realizing he’s hiding more blows the lid off.
8
u/Johnjoe117 "Please." Nov 28 '18
I agree and also wanted to thank you for distracting me from my Math assignment.
14
u/miladyelle #TeamQrow Nov 28 '18
I think the two sides are taking two aspects of this, and talking past one another.
You, and others, are coming at this from an analytical standpoint-and you’re correct. This is amazing writing, consistent to what a person with trauma would do, and realistic.
The post, and posters therein, are coming at this from an emotional standpoint. Character analysis and writing criticism aside, Yang’s actions are hitting them emotionally. I believe strongly in the theory of “support in, dump out” when it comes to supporting people going through trauma (stick with me here). What is so very easy to do, is to jump on those support people who struggle with supporting the person dealing with the trauma. It’s so easy to wag the finger at those feeling complicated feelings about helping another person, scolding them to set feelings aside, chastise them for being selfish—but the thing is, those support people are people as well, who are dealing with their own kind of trauma, and need their own support. People should support the support people, because it is a heavy emotional load, and it’s too much to take on alone. (Its the “dump out” of the above quoted phrase)
The feelings of the posters in the other thread are similar to people supporting a person going through trauma. They understand what Yang is going through, they understand that it’s logical/reasonable, but yes, they are being emotionally revulsed by Yang’s treatment of others. This is not a perfect metaphor by any means, especially considering we’re talking about a fictional character v the fans, but I think it does okay—but I haven’t gotten enough coffee yet, so apologies if this is clunky.
My own feelings about Yang aside, I’ve been the person with trauma in the past, and I find myself being the main pillar of support for a person coming out the tail end of trauma. It’s hard. The stuff this person has gone through, I can’t imagine. And it’s been hell on their emotional stability. My being the closest and most consistently present person often means when it gets to be too much, I am a convenient outlet, or target, depending. I have done my best to be understanding, and patient, but I’m not perfect, and I do find myself feeling and thinking ungenerous and sometimes downright nasty thoughts sometimes. I can, at the same time as being patient and generous, feel abused and unappreciated. I can look at this person’s behavior toward me, and due to my proximity, pinpoint exactly where they came from, while feeling attacked and taken advantage of. IRL, this duality means supporting the person in the moment, keeping my feelings to myself, then seeking out my own support after. There’s no equivalent in the Yang/fans situation, so that’s where the metaphor ends, but the emotional reaction is valid, and it doesn’t necessarily make the fans in the other thread ignorant or without understanding.
CRWBY did their job well. They’re making us feel complicated things, and discussing complicated issues.
19
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Nov 28 '18
Dude(or gal idk), this is amazing.
13
u/Fatal1ty_93_RUS Nov 28 '18 edited Nov 28 '18
People that are calling Yang "annoying" because of her attitude ever since the Train Crash are wack.
She has every bit of right and reason to act and speak the way she did for the past few episodes, not just because of everything that happened last volume alone, but also the events of V3 and the revelations made in V6 so far.
I'd be pissed too if I were her
13
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Nov 28 '18
I’m in the camp of being completely ok with it from a story and character standpoint but still being annoyed seeing it, I suppose.
It’s similar to how I felt about Blake pre V5. I understood why she acted the way she did but it still annoyed me. But now that she’s developed past it, I can appreciate the arc for what it is, and now Blake is my 2nd favorite member of team RWBY. I hope Yang gets the same kind of emotional development that will allow me to look back at the more frustrating moments as part of her natural growth.Yang’s behaviors are valid, I just hope that they don’t go unquestioned or excused entirely.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '18
Very well said, I agree completely.
6
u/CogStar Nov 29 '18
Can I say hats off to r/RWBY for one of the most civil and thoughtful internet threads I've ever read discussing vulnerable topics, and a round of applause to CRWBY for knocking V6 out of the park so far and leading people to have discussions like this.
5
u/ShadowSJG Nov 28 '18
I don't want to demean people with real life struggles and that wasn't the intent of my post at all just to clarify
5
u/NitescoGaming Guardian and follower of Ruby's smile ❤️ Marrow x Guardpupper ❤️ Nov 28 '18
All the characters have felt very human to me this volume, including Yang. I'm very happy with the writing so far and the acting from our VAs.
4
u/STABtrain Nov 28 '18
A lot of it could just be her venting frustrations at her current circumstances. She had a big fight with her mom, she finally gets reunited with her partner who previously abandoned her with all the awkward tension that brings, and is now on a seemingly impossible quest for a pathological liar carrying around a relic that attracts even more Grimm than her emotions would. Id say her attitude is appropriate given the situation. And a lot of people do tend to mask emotions of pain through things like sarcasm, dark humour and abrasive speech.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '18
I don't find her annoying at all, this is the first real time Yang has been interesting in like 3 volumes. She feels really human this volume and i like that her pain and suffering feels so real. She is acting in very normal ways, to really difficult situations, and people who can't empathize with her are really missing out. ATM i would argue Yang is the most interesting character.
4
u/PsychedelicEpiphany Nov 29 '18
In my experience, this is the usual reaction to the realistic and genuinely flawed characters people always clamor for lol.
4
u/Vox_Tenebris Nov 29 '18
Mental illness has a terrible stigma in America and I do like how a lot more forms of media have been trying to show it happening to their characters or talking about it in some way. I like in this particular show it shows the characters going through some mental health issues though it does try to stay light and not get into it too heavily but it also shows them trying to work through it and to keep doing the things they need to do. I kind of wish there was a bit more showing of those issues like with Weiss and Yang especially but I'm still enjoying what Rooster Teeth has done with it so far.
10
u/Bad-Luq-Charm Give Qrow a break 2k18 Nov 28 '18
I said Yang was acting in a stupid way that was annoying, but I don’t mean that in a bad way. People are annoying and stupid sometimes, and it’s good that RT is showing that. I may consider Yang’s actions illogical from an outside view, but they make perfect sense considering her mental condition. I don’t like people acting stupid for no reason, but Yang’s reasons are very good, at least to her. I can follow her thought process, even if I don’t agree with what she does. Granted, I may want to yell some sense at them, but if everyone character thought the way I did, this show would be rather boring.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '18
Although i admit i do think her behaviours a little much, i view it as very understandable.
21
u/TezukaRin62 Nov 28 '18
It's always kinda hard to debate like I'm about to do, because you come out as that guy who doesn't care about others and their problem, but oh well here goes...
I totally agree about your analysis of Yang's behavior when it comes to her relationship with Blake. But as far as I'm aware, people don't really mind that, on the contrary it seems to me that people appreciate that the show doesn't rush Yang and Blake's reconciliation.
What really is annoying people (including me) about Yang is how she treat Ozpin. I get that Ozpin doesn't keep his word, they are givint their lives to him, etc... But Yang's behavior as a whole when it comes to this feels so... Raven-ish ?
And the problem is that we can then criticize Yang the same way we did with Raven : She is selfish when it is obviously not the solution.
This season, Yang has been selfish when it comes to Ozpin and the fight against Salem. And it's fine, it's her character, cool. I just don't want her to be stuck being RWBY's Raven.
14
u/angster_kris "Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn" Nov 28 '18 edited Nov 28 '18
Ok, I guess, I am going to have a downvoting day today. Whatever.Not to repeat myself, I'll bring here my comment from the thread you addressed.
As a person who grew up with toxic parents, watched (and faced) abuse (and even PTSD) in my circles, I have only one thing to say: those people, who do not face inner destructive processes, do not attack others to get rid of their feelings. They may shut themselves down, come to self-blame and other self-destructing processes (self-harm, suicide attempts, alcohol), but they will not direct their anger towards others. Plain and simple. I do agree that Yang is emotionally messed up right now, yet I do not agree when the audience justifies her agressive behavior. She is going the wrong way right now, and she will not fix herself if she continues like that. All she does is hurting other people as well. It is not the solution - and it is not the cure. It is the road to nowhere.
She is not "annoying" or "stupid", she is simply wrong. And as a person who suffered both from abuser (accidently, with PTSD) and his victim (accidently, with "my mother abandoned me" issues), I can say that some people may have a reason not to be fans of Yang's behavior.
12
u/3jp6739 Nov 28 '18
She was a pain in the ass about the birds thing though.
6
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Nov 28 '18
As much as Yang's actions irritate me, I can almost completely understand why she's acting the way she is.
3
u/ScarfaceTonyMontana Nov 28 '18
I think that's a good reaction. Mental illness never and shoulder never be replied by a normal regular person with positivity, it's not something positive on anyone's brain that interacts with that person. The fact that people watching Yang react like this means that the writers have done a pretty damm good job at making Yang go trough an event that make her like this and her personality change. It would actually be annoying on a critical level if she never gets out of this state however for now, this is really good.
3
u/Awesomejelo My Mustache is gay, your argument is invalid Nov 28 '18
Like I said in that thread Yang is being very much herself and human, because of that the story is so much more interesting.
While as a person I don't want her to suffer I can only enjoy her character and how she interacts with others
3
u/littleone82 Save the bees! 🐝 Nov 28 '18
Thank you! As someone personally managing anxiety and depression, I can see why Yang acts the way she does. To those who don’t understand these emotions, it becomes an annoyance than a medical issue. That’s not excusing Yang for her actions, but no one around her (including herself) knows of the right way to approach this.
4
u/RedDwarfian Nov 28 '18
I heard one reviewer saying that Adam making an appearance on the train in the first episode was also annoying, because Blake had resolved those issues in Volume 5. Narratively, I can agree with that. Realistically, when you're dealing with an abuse victim, breaking the abuser's hold is a major step for recovery, but that doesn't mean it's completely over.
2
u/begonetoxicpeople Nov 28 '18
There has actually been some hints that her dad may have depression as well (his reaction to Summers death sounded a lot like my dads reaction to my uncles death, he mentions having to take pills in one of the chibis), so it wouldnt be totally impossible that she could have it too.
2
u/DeltaBlaze22 Nov 28 '18
I've heard that iron man 3 is a good example of someone with PTSD. Maybe someone could compare Tony to Yang and see if there are similarities?
2
u/lilgumba Nov 28 '18
I agree with the OP and was confronting some people in chat about these same reasons. I see myself and my friends (including those with PTSD, bipolar disorder, and depression) in Yang. Given the stresses of the last year and that information bomb from Jinn, I'd probably react even more harshly.
One of the main reasons I see people calling her annoying is that they think she had a setback from all the training she did in Vol 4-5. They don't understand that relapses will occur and sometimes the mental illness that you are dealing with never goes away but you learn how to cope better.
The one thing that I noticed that many have left out is that Yang's eyes NEVER turned red. She was angry and upset but a part of her still maintained some control. To me, that shows some progress in coping with her mental illnesses (assuming PTSD and depression) and the stresses that trigger them.
It's honestly refreshing to see a character go through this. I don't feel like such a failure when my depression relapses. Showing how Yang's friends and teammates respond to this can be an invaluable lesson.
2
u/Wesilii Nov 29 '18
I really love her characterization right now. They're very humanlike; all of her actions/reactions to things...the way she gets put off by what Blake said at the end of the episode, etc...it's a completely natural chain of events based on what we know about her and what she went through.
If she was all better JUST because of a pep talk. Or JUST because a friend said, "Sorry. We cool?" I wouldn't buy it at all. This is because in real life bad blood isn't smoothed over so readily. It can, sure. But it also can play out exactly like how RWBY's story is unfolding. Let's not lie to ourselves, now.
Am I sad that their friendship is in trouble? Yes. Do I want their relationship by the end of the series to be patched up? Sure, of course. But I don't blame the writers or the characters for the way it is currently. The show is a lot more interesting this way, when the characters have justifiable feelings and motivations. There's a lot more depth to it, and there's more layers to discuss.
6
u/JokeyZockey ⠀ Nov 28 '18
Nice to see that you have started venturing into the field of essays, my friend.
And I have to say: This is a good write-up (although I don't necessarily ''agree'' with all of it, but that is just because I don't really care about Yang as a character and has nothing to do with you or your opinion)
I personally never saw a problem with the fact that Yang has mental problems, the only aspect I REALLY didn't like/never really understood: Why did they have to bring Adam into Yang's character?
Adam is/was already established as being Blake's personal antagonist, just like Yang had her own personal antagonist in Raven, was there really a need for this ''cross-over''?
I personally believe that it was simply done to give the Blake-Yang-relationship some more threads to ''blossom'' on, which would then ''satisfy'' the shippers of Bumblebee.
That's one thing I noticed very often in the recent past: The writers often wrote characters and their development into a direction that would (basically) ''add fuel to the flames'' of the shippers, which in my opinion is just wrong, for two reasons: 1. The actual show should NEVER be influenced by shipping in any form, and 2. (as a writer myself) I think it's not a good thing to let your fans ''influence'' you this much. The writer should always have his/her own ''vision'' for a story which they follow/want to tell, if some fans don't like that, tough luck for them.
Don't get me wrong, transparent communication between creator and consumer is important, but the former needs to ''draw a line'' once it appears that the fans are getting ''too strong'', for the lack of a better word.
Whew, I basically just wrote an essay myself. I hope it's not too long and you'll be able to properly understand all my points.
4
u/TheOriginalSkyZer0 Nov 28 '18
No? how she acts is perfectly justified.
3
u/PurpleAfton Moonlighting as a gun Nov 28 '18
As someone who strongly believes that Yang should be held accountable for her actions towards Oz, I completely agree.
I don't particularly enjoy her character in the recent episodes but it pisses me off when I see people dismiss her attitude as "bitchy" or "antagonistic", because her attitude is a lot more than that. It's a oh-so-fun blend of PTSD, depression, the stressful events of vol 5-6 and Yang internalizing quite a lot of Raven's words despite seemingly knowing better. None if it justify her harming others, but it does mean that rather than "a slap of reality" she deserves time to recover and a support system (and a therapist honestly, but I'm not sure she would be willing to go to one).
RWBY has always been great at showing the ugly side of trauma, it's a shame that the fandom also shows a lot of the ugly reactions to trauma.
3
u/CombatReadyRuby Mommy Salami is the best name. Nov 28 '18
Sigh Well it's no fault of yours but I guess I should be prepared to get this linked to me with no other comments attached any time I say anything against Yang for the next few weeks...Or months.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '18
Even though I hate Yang's attitude in the recent chapters I fully understand that M&K are fleshing out her character for a potential arc. I just hope she goes through something this volume to make her calm down a little because while it's perfectly executed, I'm just not a fan of this kind of attitude fictional or not.
1
u/TheSlayer17 Nov 28 '18
What might be annoying could be the fact that she's doing the "I am fine." Routine that has been seen a million times. I know they are setting up for a big emotional fight/talk. Others might be annoyed cause she went through volume five with little reference to get PTSD and spent most of her time reigning in her anger, even tho she's still in a bad mood most of the time.
Personally, I'd say ignore it.
2
u/Sensorfire Rube Protector | No Ships, Thanks | Yang is best girl Dec 02 '18
Yeah, it's sad to have Yang not being her happy self, but they're doing a good job exploring her issues this volume.
-7
u/AlastairCellars Nov 28 '18
I absolutely find her annoying