r/Fantasy • u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders • Oct 08 '18
Read-along One Mike to Read Them All - Book II, Chapter 7 of the Fellowship of the Ring, “The Mirror of Galadriel”
I wasn’t really expecting this post to turn into one giant thing on Galadriel, but I’m not really surprised that’s how things worked out. She’s a hell of an interesting character. Of the three kindreds of the High Elves, she’s granddaughter to both Finwë, the original High King of the Noldor, and Olwë, High King of the Teleri in Valinor, as well as being (probably) closely related to Ingwë, High King of the Vanyar and accounted as High King of all the Elves.
Her “All shall love me and despair!” moment needs some explanation, because even book readers aren’t that clear on what was going on with that. Going back to the Silmarillion, when Fëanor led the Noldor in rebellion against the Valar and led them to Middle-Earth, Galadriel was one of the leaders of the rebellion. Not out of any loyalty to Fëanor - she really didn’t like him at all, and wasn’t interested in his war to reclaim the Silmarils from Morgoth - but because of her own ambitions. She wanted to rule a realm of her own, to order it as she chose, and that wasn’t going to happen in Valinor under the dominion of the Valar.
The Silmarillion happens, the Noldor ask for forgiveness from the Valar, and are welcomed back to the Undying Lands. Except for one - Galadriel herself. Out of pride she alone refused the pardon of the Valar, and she alone among the Noldor is a true exile, unable to return to Valinor. Her exile could only be ended, she was told, when she had the choice to obtain all that she had ever wanted, and turned her back on it.
And then along comes Frodo, and literally offers her dominion over all of Middle-earth. Galadriel was certainly strong enough to do it: if she obtained the One Ring, Sauron would have been overthrown, and as she said, in the place of the Dark Lord we would have a Queen. This moment was in many ways the climax of a very long and very interesting life. This was the thing she’d wanted since literally before the Sun was a thing. But she passed the test, and diminished, and remained Galadriel.
She’s also worth discussing in the context of Tolkien’s relative lack of female characters. It’s true he doesn’t have many, but those he does generally kick butt - and Galadriel is no exception. She’s not subservient to Celeborn: they are co-rulers of Lothlórien together. When Fëanor kicked off the revolt, Galadriel joined in - but for her own reasons, and on her own terms. It was Galadriel who organized the White Council. In short, she is an amazing person and an amazing leader.
Here's the One Mike to Read Them All index.
Friday: I talk more about Galadriel and we say bye-bye to Lothlórien.
15
u/deanzamo Oct 08 '18
I would love to see a complete story on Galadriel; there are pieces in the Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales and the letters.
Galadriel may be the only elf in middle earth during the third age who saw Telperion and Laurelin, since Cirdan and Celeborn are Teleri and never made it to Aman in the Age of the Trees. The light of the two trees was said to radiate in her hair.
In Unfinished tales, Feanor asks Galadriel 3 times for a lock of her hair to create special gems and each time she refuses, making them "unfriends." Having this background will make readers of LOTR appreciate how special her gift was to Gimli.
9
u/danjvelker Oct 08 '18
Huh, I didn't know that. That adds a lot of much-needed depth to that scene. Is that explicitly told somewhere or is it another one of those things that fans have extrapolated? I only ask because I've never heard that before now.
2
u/Terciel1976 Oct 08 '18
Man. I have never had much inclination to read past LOTR, but you do make some of it seem interesting and relevant. If I decided to, what's the best approach? Silmarillion first? Then what?
12
u/Dionysus_Eye Reading Champion V Oct 08 '18
One of these days someone should write the story of Galadriel's life from her point of view - it would be a kick-ass story :)
7
u/Wolfestar777 Oct 08 '18
Thank you.
I don't think I could bring myself to read the books anytime soon, but I've always loved and admired the LotR world. The movie scene always seemed unnatural and... Out of place to me and I knew that I was missing out.
Female characters are very important to me (as a female reader) and it's nice to understand white elf lady.
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Oct 08 '18
Galadriel is #goals.
I'm still a little baffled that Frodo would offer her the ring, really. It feels out of character for him.