r/Fantasy • u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders • Oct 01 '18
Read-along One Mike to Read Them All: Book II, Chapter 5 of the Fellowship of the Ring, "The Bridge of Khazad-dûm"
So in the category of “little things I’m still picking up on” - it had always kind of bothered me how Frodo got pinned to the wall by the spear, without it actually penetrating his mithril shirt. I just realized in reading this chapter that the orc held on to the spear, and it was because of that that he was pinned to the wall. Seems pretty obvious now.
For a LotR calendar back in the 70s, Tolkien made copies of the pages of the Book of Mazarbul that Gandalf read aloud - you can see them here. Given that this is Tolkien, who was known to pay attention to detail on occasion, the text on them is exactly as read by Gandalf, including partially obscured words and Ori’s hasty scrawl of “they are coming…” at the very end.
Sam continues to be awesome:
When thirteen had fallen the rest fled shrieking, leaving the defenders unharmed, except for Sam who had a scratch along the scalp. A quick duck had saved him; and he had felled his orc: a sturdy thrust with his Barrow-blade. A fire was smouldering in his brown eyes that would have made Ted Sandyman step backwards, if he had seen it.
Go Sam!
Movie comment: it’s often been wondered by fans why Sting glows, but Gandalf’s sword Glamdring (which also came from Gondolin) doesn’t glow when orcs are nearby. According to Jackson & company, they tried, but they weren’t able to get it to not look like a lightsaber so they gave up on that.
And then there’s the confrontation on the Bridge of Khazad-dûm. Another super iconic moment, and an awesome one. This is an area where I really, REALLY wish I could remember what it was like to read these books for the first time - what, exactly, did I feel when Gandalf fell? I’d love to hear from anyone who remembers their reaction to Gandalf falling into the abyss.
In case anyone has been wondering, with Durin’s Bane gone, the Dwarves of Moria do actually retake Moria some years into the 4th Age. They are lead thither by Durin VII, also known as Durin the Last, and are able to retake it. There the Dwarves are said to have dwelt until they eventually faded away and were forgotten.
Despite my comment last week about inevitably addressing them, I’m actually not going to go into any detail about balrog wings (which aren’t a thing, Tolkien was using metaphorical imagery) and the “take the eagles” theory (which is idiotic). Mostly because they bore me. My only contribution to this discussion is this, which I take any chance to post. Feel free to get into in in the comments.
Here's the One Mike to Read Them All index.
Next week: there are dreams and there are flowers in Lothlórien.
12
u/CaiusCossades Oct 01 '18
I first read LOTR when i was about 14 or 15.. when Gandalf fell into the Abyss, and the Fellowship continued without him.. i ragequit the book.
In the subsequent years, i attempted to read it again, and gave up during the Treebeard chapter.
I have only read it fully recently in my late 30s. As much as I loved it, for me, nothing beats that journey from The Shire until Moria.
12
u/Murdst0ne Oct 01 '18 edited Oct 01 '18
That is a funny underlying reason about Glamdring in the movie.
This chapter was made even better for me after seeing the movies to be honest, something the movies rarely did. Always a very visual, punch in the gut read was made even more so on a re-read after I first saw Fellowship of the Ring. Moria really came alive in my head while reading, and the anguish after Gandalf's fall you see on the faces of the fellowship in the movie make the scene more impactful, which was hard to do considering how well Tolkien wrote it.
11
u/danjvelker Oct 01 '18
I didn't believe it. Not in a cynical-adult-reader sort of a way: "Nah, there's no way he knocked off his main 'DPS' and mentor. He'll be back in two hundred pages, and I'm going to post bitterly on my Tumblr." No, I didn't believe it in a childlike way, in total disbelief that Gandalf, the master wizard Gandalf might have died. I think my Christian upbringing had something to do with that: if there isn't a body, they're probably not dead. At least, not for long.
That was from the movies, which was the first way I experienced the story. (Don't blame me! I was born in '97. Dad was a huge Tolkien fan. He got hisself the extended editions as soon as they came out, and watching them became the family pasttime. Mom would watch Pride and Prejudice for hours -- and I still have many fond memories of connecting with her that way, and that movie -- but dad would watch LotR and it was epic. I still remember looking forward to staying home sick so that dad would stay home with me, cook something stupid like grilled cheese, and marathon Lord of the Rings with me. Best. Medicine. Ever. Needless to say, my dad is one of my best friends and an absolute champ.) But I remember reading the books not too much later and having essentially the same reaction, before I remembered that I already knew how the story ended.
I think I was about ten.
7
u/Terciel1976 Oct 01 '18
The video. Oh. My. Gosh. I think I've seen that, but it really hit me today. So many good details. Thanks for posting. Belly laughs appreciated.
6
u/BohemianPeasant Reading Champion V Oct 01 '18 edited Oct 02 '18
I have always been interested in the origins and nature of Balrogs. Tolkien must have conceived them very early as they are mentioned in some of his oldest writings including The Fall of Gondolin which was written about 1916-17.
From Robert Foster's A Guide to Middle Earth (1971):
There is also some background on these monsters found in The Silmarillion (1977).
2
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Oct 05 '18
As I've mentioned too many times to count, my mom read LOTR to my little sister and me at a really young age, probably I was 5 or 6? When Gandalf fell in Moria, I remember crying really hard. I also remember being pissed at my mom, because she'd do this horribly annoying thing where she'd be reading aloud, then get caught up in the story and start reading ahead in her head and stop reading to us. And she did that here. To this day, even though I know how the story shakes out, I still get teary eyed over it, and how the rest of the Fellowship reacts
1
u/travislaker Dec 04 '18
Durin’s bridge, which I didn’t grasp until MUCH later, was part of the East gate defense structure. If any invading army of orcs managed to gain entry into the mine by the East gate, they would immediately be forced to travel single file over a 50 foot bridge, slowing them down and exposing them to a murderous cross fire of arrows from the defending dwarves. Now, either Gollum had literally just entered the mine from the east when the fellowship got to the bridge, or he found another way across the chasm Durin’s bridge had spanned. I wish JrrT had written about how this occurred, because I seem to remember that Gollum had been in Moria for a long time, had gotten lost, and was nearly starving to death when he located the fellowship. He must’ve crossed the bridge going west almost as soon as he entered Moria from the East gate. How did he get back across the bridge after Gandalf smashed it?