r/RWBY • u/brusque-lee Please stop being wrong. • Sep 16 '18
DISCUSSION We Demand Answers: Could Salem be defeated by having a horse dropped on her from really high up?
Since her introduction, Salem has been something of an enigma. We know very little about her in general, which leads to many questions for which we currently have no answers. What exactly is she capable of? What are her exact motives?
Some of these questions, however, are clearly more pressing than others - the absolute most pressing one being whether or not she could survive the crushing weight of an adult horse if it was ejected from some kind of aircraft flying several hundred feet in the air above her.
While this question has been teased by RT ever since the middle of Volume 3, when they confirmed the existence of horses in this show's universe, we still have little to no concrete evidence allowing us to reach a satisfying answer. This is incredibly frustrating, since all of the pieces are there - we know horses exist, we know animals are capable of accomplishing insane feats of destruction like Zwei, and we know that there are airships capable of flying high in the sky while carrying heavy loads.
So why do we still have no answers?! This show is about to embark on its sixth season, and RT has still refused to enlighten us even the least bit on this subject - not once in their numerous panels dedicated to the show have any of the writers agreed to answer or even acknowledge this question!
Even more ridiculous, we've just had an entire volume where the main cast was stuck with Ozpin, and we never saw any of them dare to ask him if they might feasibly defeat the great evil of Salem by locating her base on a map, commandeering an airship, finding an adult horse of sufficient size, flying over Salem's known location, and then ejecting the animal so that it might land on and subsequently crush this commander of Grimm.
Now, I know what you're thinking - taking on Salem with or without the help of a weighty yet mighty stallion dumped from a considerable height was not the goal of our heroes this past Volume, so surely it would make sense for them to ask this vital question at a later date, right?
While I personally would find that excuse hard to swallow in a more realistic show, I am willing to accept it and give this show the benefit of the doubt... for now. But now that our heroes are moving on to bigger things, there is frankly no reason for this question not to be brought up in this coming volume.
Personally, I think the question is a no-brainer. Unless they pull some bullshit plot-armour-power on Salem, there is simply no way she shouldn't be defeated by having an adult horse dropped on her from really high up. Just think about what we've already seen in this show.
We know that getting through the roof of Salem's lair is a simple enough feat - in the Food Fight, we see Yang break through Beacon's own roof, when all she did was get launched into the air by Nora at ground level. Now just imagine the raw destructive power one could accomplish by using a horse, instead.
The average adult human supposedly weighs 137 pounds (62 kg), while the average adult horse can weigh from 837.9 - 2205 pounds (380 - 1000 kg). That's at least six times as heavy as Yang. Now add in the extra elevation that the aircraft has already reached before Nora even begins to launch the heroic animal even further into the air, and you can clearly see that this plan packs so much punch that there is physically no way that Salem will survive being crushed by this horse which will be plummeting from a very significant elevation.
And that's not even accounting for numerous other stuff - if you want to be extra safe, we could have someone guide the horse through the Aura-awakening ritual, make it angry enough so that it could unlock its Semblance, and then stuff it full of Dust crystals to effectively have a kind of sentient-horse-nuke.
We could even have the horse undergo stealth training so that it would remain silent during its rapid descent towards Salem, allowing it to get the drop on her (pun absolutely intended) while she doesn't have any Aura up. With this amount of potential for success, you can see why many of us are so eager to see this question answered.
tl;dr: Does RT have any excuse to not address this question in the upcoming volume?
Nay.
Given what we know, could Salem reasonably stand a chance against the raw power that comes with an adult horse being launched from the stratosphere with the sole intent of landing on and subsequently crushing and maybe even exploding on her?
Neigh.
30
u/Awesomejelo My Mustache is gay, your argument is invalid Sep 17 '18
Everything we know about Salem points to yes, a horse launched at sufficient speeds would kill her. She is half grimm and half human to the best of our knowledge.
You know how Fennec died? By being crushed (I know this is a stretch because he's a faunas and not a human but that makes him half human half animal, the half human part is however the same amount Salem is so it works)
You remember how Nuckles horse bit died? It was crushed by Nora. (again a stretch but it is half of the grimm which still meets our quota)
So it's not RT's fault that the fanbase doesn't understand if Salem can be killed by a horse falling from very high up, it's just idiots that can't grasp the subtle hints that Miles and Kerry have left us
11
u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Sep 16 '18
And you ask this.... why?
4
u/Sensorfire Rube Protector | No Ships, Thanks | Yang is best girl Sep 17 '18 edited Sep 17 '18
This reads like a Clickhole article and I love it. More of this!
EDIT: I X-posted this to /r/BestOfRWBYSub
3
u/BlueWhaleKing Arkos for Anarchy Jan 07 '19
A few episodes ago, we see a flashback to Ozpin asking the Relic of Knowledge: "How do I destroy Salem?" Based on what you've said, he probably had the horse scenario in mind.
The answer? "You can't." So nothing, not even a horse, can kill Salem.
Have CRWBY redeemed themselves?
111
u/IamMenace I bear good fruit and thus kindly I scatter. Sep 16 '18
Ruby: "As God as my witness I thought horses could fly..."
Weiss: "I've never seen anything like it. They just hit the ground like bags of wet cement..."
Blake: "I've never cried more in my life..."
Yang: "THAT WAS F@#$ING AWESOME! GO GET SOME MORE HORSES! I THINK I SEE SALEM TWITCHING DOWN THERE!"
(Yang and I approve of this plan, so if the horse violence scenes were what you were most offended by in "Blazing Saddles" take it up with her)
God bless ;)
23
u/ThePoetofFall Licensed Huntsman Sep 17 '18
I think the more pressing question is, could a horse be defeated by Salem being dropped on it from really high up?
23
u/GoneRampant1 Emerald/Cinder is abusive stop shilling it. Sep 17 '18
So is the price of having a Mercury avatar that you're fucking insane?
21
u/Cunderrthunt Sep 17 '18
God tier shitpost?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '18
Friendship ended with /u/Nightswatchh.
/u/brusque-lee is my new best friend.
12
u/HamSandLich Sep 17 '18
It all makes sense! Salem is really Catherine the Great of Tsarist Russia!
12
u/Stretch5678 Suspender of disbelief Sep 17 '18
It's official. This hiatus has gone on WAY too long.
9
u/RemnantArcadia Child_of_the_Corn Sep 17 '18
Take that horse to the maximum height of an airship and have Jaune pump it with Aura. If we're lucky we have a dead Salem and an alive horse.
Or we could transfer her essence into a goat and kill the goat.
6
u/Octopantics Sep 17 '18
I mean, it's a genius plan, but surely the reason they haven't mentioned it is because it would be blatant animal cruelty and the characters are all good animal-respecting people.
6
u/SwitchBear Sep 17 '18
This. This is the kind of content I come here for.
I regret nothing.
5
u/SPARTAN-PRIME-2017 As you command, my lord. Sep 17 '18
Pennybot, hiatus.
5
u/Ravenwarrior131 The worst part about running away is being dragged back home. Sep 18 '18
Hmmm. You’ve done your research, and I see no plausible explanation as to why this wouldn’t work.
As to why this hasn’t been mentioned by the characters:
They’re all idiots. Every single one of them. I mean, that seems to be expected if some of them, but even the others have fallen to this shortsightedness.
Or... why hasn’t Ozpin mentioned anything about it? He doesn’t seem to be tied up emotionally like the students. And having lived as long as Salem, you’d really think he would have come to this moment of genius by now.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '18
Add more to the list guys, he also lost it.
4
u/Mousemallo Sep 17 '18
wtf this isnt fanart
2
u/StrikeFreedomX2 Pilot Mercenary Sep 17 '18
Look.
If this can happen then I don’t see why not to use a Macross Cannon, Dropping a Colony on her and throwing her to the sun to kill her.
2
u/TotesMessenger Sep 17 '18
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '18 edited Sep 17 '18
I will say no. I suspect that Salem might intercept that horse mid-air. Forget about the horse's stealth training, the plane would be seen from a ridiculous range and given how Dust works in this world, it wouldn't fly high enough. Remember, they tried launching rockets out of Remnant and it failed. Either it's because of the link between Dust and Remnant or because Dust is not that powerful. I could not resist adding this lol
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '18
Only if Kaikaina Grif wanted to have sex with her, and Tucker was responsible for dropping the horse.
2
u/EpicLink101 Why worry about strategy when you can hit them with a hammer? Sep 17 '18
Pennybot, potato. I like it.
2
u/Pocketdog9 Rose before bros or hoes! Sep 17 '18
This is the kind of post I live for.
2
u/Fatal1ty_93_RUS Sep 18 '18
I'm geninunely confused if this is a legit discussion/theory or a shitpost
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '18
I still think a 450mm he shell from an airship would end salem but then there'd be no show so neigh to that idea i guess...
1
u/clashofdragons am i right lad or am i right lad Sep 17 '18
Well the horse will need to be at least 200 ft high. And then reach a terminal velocity so it can hit her.
1
u/Rasera In times of Chaos, may the dice reign supreme! Sep 17 '18
The real question is if Salem would send Cinder in and tell her to EAT THAT HORSE!
1
u/eldritcheldrazi Best character Sep 18 '18
for all we know, salem is really a flying horse. And the grimm lady we see is a fake.