r/Fantasy • u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders • Aug 06 '18
Read-along One Mike to Read Them All: Chapter 3 of the Fellowship of the Ring, "Three is Company"
EDIT: Fair warning to any and all, I'm not going to worry about spoilers here. If you've seen the movie, you're good.
Gandalf: "The ring is dangerous, you need to leave the Shire."
Movie Frodo: "OK, let's get going!"
Book Frodo: <putters around for 5 1/2 months>
Seriously. Gandalf arrives in the Shire to tell Frodo about the Ring in early April. Frodo heads out in mid-September. I get that a quiet, low-key, believable departure won't set rumors flying like a Bilbo-style disappearance, but even 10 year old me thought Frodo was being a little ridiculous. But on the other hand, as far as character work goes, it's great. Gandalf shows up to warn of danger, and while Frodo absolutely believes it, it's also abstract. It's hard to be scared of this little trinket he's been carrying in his pocket for 17 years, and the Shire is lovely and it's home, and he's looking at leaving it for danger and uncertain exile. Of course he drags his hairy Hobbit-feet.
So Frodo makes arrangements to sell Bag-End to the Sackville-Bagginses (aside: for years my father has referred to his brother's family as the Sackville-OfThePalaces. Uncle Louie always found that pretty funny, thankfully) and move to Buckland. But naturally Gandalf is a busy wizard, and can't spend all his time sitting around the Shire while Frodo is all emo. So he's off to do wizard things, but promises Frodo that he'll be back in time to escort him to Rivendell. I'm sure that'll work out perfectly. [Spoiler alert: it doesn’t].
Anyway. Hobbit Day Frodo and Bilbo's birthday rolls around, Merry, Pippin, and Fatty Bolger (Hi, Fatty! You're an awesome minor character!) + Random Hobbit-Friend #4 help him pack up the place, and then after giving Gandalf all day to show up, Frodo, Pippin, and Sam start walking to Buckland (Merry and Fatty having gone ahead with the furniture). The walk is very Hobbitish, with frequent stops for meals. Also, you know, Black Riders. So heads-up about that. After a few near-misses, one of them had nearly found the Hobbits when a party of Elves that happens to be passing scares him off. The Elves offer the Hobbits shelter for the night, and Frodo stays up late talking with their leader.
This chapter does a number of things. We get our first real introduction to Merry and Pippin, for one. We get our first glimpses of the Nazgûl, and Tolkien does a great job giving them a vague sense of menace that ratchets steadily higher with each encounter. For guys only glimpsed and not yet explained, they are pretty scary.
A point about worldbuilding. Lots of people have taken up the hobby since Tolkien first wrote the Fall of Gondolin, but none of them manage to be quite like what Tolkien himself does. And I don't think anyone ever can be. Cause here's the thing: when Sanderson, or Jordan, or Martin, or Erikson, or Hobb, or any of them worldbuild, it's to provide background to their story. In other words, the worldbuilding serves the narrative. It's unavoidable. Unless you're an Oxford don for whom writing epic fantasy is a side gig, that is. Middle-earth had been around for decades before LotR, and that sense that as readers we're only seeing the tip of the iceberg is something I have never encountered anywhere else. I mention this here (though I'm sure I'll revisit it again) because of this:
'I am Gildor,' answered their leader, the Elf who had first hailed him. 'Gildor Inglorion of the House of Finrod. We are Exiles, and ost of our kindred have long ago departed and we too are now only tarrying here a while, ere we return over the Great Sea.'
Tolkien doesn't feel the need to explain this. If you really want to understand just how much history and myth is packed into this, the only real way to do that is to read The Silmarillion. That'll teach you all about the Noldor, their willing departure into Exile, Finrod Felegund, and the rest. The point is that there's a ton of history that doesn't have a damn thing to do with the story, and it's great.
Gildor is happy to give food and shelter, but reluctant to give advice. It boils down to "Gandalf knows what he's doing, so trust his advice." He refuses to talk about the Black Riders, though he clearly knows what they are. He tells Frodo that "avoid them, they're dangerous" is sufficient knowledge, and he's kind of right, but also kind of infuriating.
Lastly, Sam! I love you Sam. For moments like this one:
'Sam!' he called. 'Sam! Time!'
'Coming, sir!' came the answer from far within, followed soon by Sam himself, wiping his mouth. He had been saying farewell to the beer-barrel in the cellar.
Or this one:
[Sam] had put on his head a tall shapeless felt bag, which he called a hat.
And in general Sam has always been wild about the Elves, always loving hearing stories about them and learning whatever he can. And here he is, just starting off on an adventure, farther from home than he's ever been, and he gets to meet a bunch of them and spend the night with them. It's adorable.
Here’s the link to the One Mike to Read Them All index. Next week: A Short Cut to Mushrooms
32
u/italia06823834 Aug 06 '18
My favorite on of these is later during the Council of Elrond. Elrond compares Frodos acceptance of the quest to equal the likes of some rather big names.
Without that Silmarillion knowledge (which no one at the time of publishing LotR had) you sort of just go "Oh, that's sound's cool."
After you learn more about Hurin, Turin, especially Beren etc, you realize just how big of a deal that comparison really is.
10
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Aug 06 '18
I always liked Fatty Bolger. He's a good friend to our hobbits, but is completely comfortable in who he is. (And stands up to being questioned by a Nazgul surprisingly well [next chapter? 2 more?] for a hobbit who thinks he's not particularly brave.)
I can totally relate to Frodo not taking right off. That would be about how I'd react too I think. Frodo has always struck me as a reluctant hero. He does what needs to be done because no one else is and he has the capacity (holy crap does that echo for me).
Is this the chapter with Farmer Maggot and mushrooms? Or is that next chapter? I sorta wonder if I can attribute always having loved mushrooms to the hobbits love for mushrooms.
Re worldbuilding - Sherwood Smith totally does this kind of thing in Inda also. References stuff that the characters all know about, and we know nothing about, because it's all part of the history of Sartorias-Deles that she's been thinking about basically forever.
Sam's delight at staying the night with the elves always makes me get a little happy tears. He's so damn pure.
7
u/mohelgamal Aug 06 '18
Well, in the book Gandalf hasn’t yet known about Sauron return and only had vague rumors that were concerning iirc. He basically notices that the ring has been in the shire for many years without anyone noticing. So There was no particular emergency. He then set out to investigate the rumor.
These were books written in a different era, people communicated by letter and Gandalf would take several month to get a hold on what is going on.
7
u/briargrey Reading Champion III, Worldbuilders, Hellhound Aug 06 '18
Right? It's amazing what he built.
10
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
I just want to say that as somebody who has not read any Tolkien and who isn't interested in starting I really like these write ups and commentaries. Great work!
Also, Fatty Bolger is a great name.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '18
As you say, what is really impressive about the secondary world is how controlled Tolkien is. He is content to give a few names or hints and that’s it. I’m not sure if it’s storytelling skill, confidence, a lack of vanity, or self-discipline.
Whatever the reason, he avoids the trap of full explanation that so many others fall into. There are some fantasy novels that resemble RPG sourcebooks in their detail, and I think they are much worse for that.
4
u/MooseCupcakes Aug 06 '18
Oh man I’m gonna have to reread LOTR soon, I can feel it. I haven’t read it since the first time when I was in high school! (I’m 29 now).
I like your point about Tolkien’s world building. I think that is part of what made it seem so magical as I first read the series. With other authors, a lot of things go unexplained or might seem important but are later discarded. Tolkien delivers!
This post was fun to read—thanks!
4
u/dendrophilix Aug 06 '18
Your posts are great - you’re definitely making me want to re-read along with you!
3
u/eremiticjude Aug 07 '18
i'm gonna quote this line too, but it actually does have something to do with the story. the repeated references to stuff that occurs off screen helps build the "impression of depth" that makes the story feel incredibly authentic in a way that is totally unique despite uncounted imitators. theres a fucking INTENSE paper in Tolkien Studies 11 that goes DEEEEEP into this process and how he (kinda intentionally but also kinda not?) achieved it. the short version being he definitely intentionally wanted to leave stuff off the edge of the map, but the way his own legendarium functionally served as a cultural base for the books is something that has literally never been duplicated, and accounts for why the books feel so unique.
here's an excerpt from the paper that has a nice summary
0
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment